In this presentation we introduce the game balance type 'sustained uncertainty'. Uncertainty is usually understood as related to randomness and difficulty. It is essential to keep the game interesting to the user.
These slides were prepared by Dr. Marc Miquel. All the materials used in them are referenced to their authors.
In this presentation we introduce the concept game balance, its different types, and the most useful methods to study it.
These slides were prepared by Dr. Marc Miquel. All the materials used in them are referenced to their authors.
In this presentation we introduce the game balance "interesting strategies". It is especially important as games with a single dominant strategy are boring. No strategy must be much better than others and without drawbacks.
These slides were prepared by Dr. Marc Miquel. All the materials used in them are referenced to their authors.
Game Balance 3: Player Equality and FairnessMarc Miquel
In this presentation we introduce the game balance type "player equality and fairness". It is essential so the players do not feel the game is unworthy of playing. All the players must feel they are given the chances to win.
These slides were prepared by Dr. Marc Miquel. All the materials used in them are referenced to their authors.
In this course concepts and requirements of the video game development will be taught. Students will get familiar to the fundamentals of the game industry and finally put all the learned stuff together to work on a small game project.
In this presentation we introduce the concept game balance, its different types, and the most useful methods to study it.
These slides were prepared by Dr. Marc Miquel. All the materials used in them are referenced to their authors.
In this presentation we introduce the game balance "interesting strategies". It is especially important as games with a single dominant strategy are boring. No strategy must be much better than others and without drawbacks.
These slides were prepared by Dr. Marc Miquel. All the materials used in them are referenced to their authors.
Game Balance 3: Player Equality and FairnessMarc Miquel
In this presentation we introduce the game balance type "player equality and fairness". It is essential so the players do not feel the game is unworthy of playing. All the players must feel they are given the chances to win.
These slides were prepared by Dr. Marc Miquel. All the materials used in them are referenced to their authors.
In this course concepts and requirements of the video game development will be taught. Students will get familiar to the fundamentals of the game industry and finally put all the learned stuff together to work on a small game project.
Killer Design Patterns for F2P Mobile/Tablet GamesHenric Suuronen
Presentation on Design Patterns for Mobile and Tablet games presented in July 2013 at ChinaJoy in Shanghai by Henric Suuronen, President & Co-Founder at Nonstop Games
Breaking the Rules of Idle Game Design in Trailer Park Boys: Greasy MoneyDave Rohrl
Trailer Park Boys: Greasy Money is a highly successful mobile idle game that leverages a niche brand. Learn how and why we broke the rules and doubled the genre's typical revenue.
Personalisation as the key to optimising your game's revenue & LTV.GameCamp
What are good and bad approach towards personalisation based on the data? How to use personalisation to improve LTV in mobile games. Good examples of personalisation in mobile games.
2018.03.19 판도라큐브 세미나
제작자: 기획 파트 한서현
코멘트: 없음
비고: 없음
판도라큐브는 세종대학교 소프트웨어융합대학 소속의 게임 제작 동아리입니다.
매주 회의마다 게임 제작과 관련된 주제로 세미나를 개최합니다.
모든 자료는 세미나 자료 제작자의 동의 하에 업로드됩니다.
세미나의 소유 및 책임은 제작자가 지닙니다.
This is a version of the presentation by Stone Librande at GDC 2010, converted for people who don't have powerpoint. Please visit Stone's site at http://stonetronix.com/
Game Design - Monetization
The Deck covers some of the basic aspects and mechanisms of social game design. This is the 1st out of 4 decks, covering the aspects needed for amplifying MONETIZATION among players and users
The series includes 4 chapters: Engagement, Virality, Retention, Monetization
Lecture 1 of 4 in the Game Design Class, Fall 2012 - Structure of Games: introduction to formal, dramatic, spatial elements, and a definition of games.
Killer Design Patterns for F2P Mobile/Tablet GamesHenric Suuronen
Presentation on Design Patterns for Mobile and Tablet games presented in July 2013 at ChinaJoy in Shanghai by Henric Suuronen, President & Co-Founder at Nonstop Games
Breaking the Rules of Idle Game Design in Trailer Park Boys: Greasy MoneyDave Rohrl
Trailer Park Boys: Greasy Money is a highly successful mobile idle game that leverages a niche brand. Learn how and why we broke the rules and doubled the genre's typical revenue.
Personalisation as the key to optimising your game's revenue & LTV.GameCamp
What are good and bad approach towards personalisation based on the data? How to use personalisation to improve LTV in mobile games. Good examples of personalisation in mobile games.
2018.03.19 판도라큐브 세미나
제작자: 기획 파트 한서현
코멘트: 없음
비고: 없음
판도라큐브는 세종대학교 소프트웨어융합대학 소속의 게임 제작 동아리입니다.
매주 회의마다 게임 제작과 관련된 주제로 세미나를 개최합니다.
모든 자료는 세미나 자료 제작자의 동의 하에 업로드됩니다.
세미나의 소유 및 책임은 제작자가 지닙니다.
This is a version of the presentation by Stone Librande at GDC 2010, converted for people who don't have powerpoint. Please visit Stone's site at http://stonetronix.com/
Game Design - Monetization
The Deck covers some of the basic aspects and mechanisms of social game design. This is the 1st out of 4 decks, covering the aspects needed for amplifying MONETIZATION among players and users
The series includes 4 chapters: Engagement, Virality, Retention, Monetization
Lecture 1 of 4 in the Game Design Class, Fall 2012 - Structure of Games: introduction to formal, dramatic, spatial elements, and a definition of games.
What does a game designer really do. And, more importantly, how do they make the products better. How does a designer contribute and what how do you work with them to solve your problem.
What is a Game Designer (And Why Do You Need One)? - Douglas WhatleySeriousGamesAssoc
What does a game designer really do. And, more importantly, how do they make the products better. How does a designer contribute and what how do you work with them to solve your problem.
In games we are always chasing our better selves. We are natural learners. But to unfold this skill we need to consider a few conditions. This is about Gamification in education.
Primer on Play: Case Study for Knowledge GuruMarlo Gorelick
As shared in #GE4L, great structure of how and why to create game based learning. Prime case study to use when discussing possibilities of gamification for business
User Experience 8: Business, Ethics and MoreMarc Miquel
This presentation introduces the topic of ethics in video games from the user experience perspective. The implications of a f2p monetizations are enumerated. Dark User experience is defined in relation to the company and the user. Its main examples (Dark Patterns) are ellaborated for both websites and video games. Finally, a clear case study of Dark UX in video gambling is developed.
These slides were prepared by Dr. Marc Miquel. All the materials used in them are referenced to their authors.
User Experience 7: Quantitative Methods, Questionnaires, Biometrics and Data ...Marc Miquel
This presentation introduces the most important quantitative research methods: questionnaires, biometrics and data analysis. It discusses several case studies in which these methods are employed.
These slides were prepared by Dr. Marc Miquel. All the materials used in them are referenced to their authors.
User Experience 6: Qualitative Methods, Playtesting and InterviewsMarc Miquel
This presentation introduces the most fundamental qualitative methods: the playtesting and the interview. It discusses when to use it and the possible bias the researcher may incur.
These slides were prepared by Dr. Marc Miquel. All the materials used in them are referenced to their authors.
User Experience 5: User Centered Design and User ResearchMarc Miquel
This presentation introduces the user-centered design paradigm and the field of game user research. It includes some hypothetical case studies which are later discussed in the following presentations.
These slides were prepared by Dr. Marc Miquel. All the materials used in them are referenced to their authors.
User Experience 4: Usable User InterfaceMarc Miquel
This presentation introduces several interfaces and discusses what their usability and user experience depend on.
These slides were prepared by Dr. Marc Miquel. All the materials used in them are referenced to their authors.
User Experience 3: User Experience, Usability and AccessibilityMarc Miquel
This presentation introduces the most important usability models among other concepts (affordances, heuristics, etc.).
These slides were prepared by Dr. Marc Miquel. All the materials used in them are referenced to their authors.
This is an introduction to the most important psychology concepts from the perspective of UX and their application to video games and software.
These slides were prepared by Dr. Marc Miquel. All the materials used in them are referenced to their authors.
User Experience 1: What is User Experience?Marc Miquel
This is an introduction to this course on User Experience in video games and web.
These slides were prepared by Dr. Marc Miquel. All the materials used in them are referenced to their authors.
Quality Assurance 2: Searching for BugsMarc Miquel
In this presentation we introduce the most useful testing techniques in order to find bugs (ad hoc testing, combinatorial testing, test flow diagram, cleanroom testing and testing trees).
These slides were prepared by Dr. Marc Miquel. All the materials used in them are referenced to their authors.
In this presentation we introduce the concept quality assurance in video games along with the most important concepts, team members and testing phases.
These slides were prepared by Dr. Marc Miquel. All the materials used in them are referenced to their authors.
public presentation of "Calçotada Wars" the card gameMarc Miquel
This is a presentation I gave in FNAC Plaça Catalunya in order to explain and show "Calçotada Wars" (the card game) for promotional purposes.
For more info about the project, check out marcmiquel.com
public presentation of "La Puta i la Ramoneta" the card gameMarc Miquel
This is a presentation I gave in Ateneu Igualadí in order to explain and show "La Puta i la Ramoneta" (the card game) for promotional purposes.
For more info about the project, check out marcmiquel.com
Towards a User-Centered Wikipedia - Viquitrobada, 26 de novembre 2016, ValènciaMarc Miquel
En aquesta presentació faig dues observacions; la primera sobre com s'ha construït Viquipèdia, quins són els seus valors relacionats amb la cultura hacker i com poden obstruïr el disseny centrat en l'usuari; la segona sobre com pel viquipedista és fonamental desenvolupar una identitat de comunitat i com s'ha d'ajudar als nouvinguts a crear-la. Per altra banda i vinculat amb les observacions, faig dues propostes per centrar el disseny i la cultura de Viquipèdia en els editors per tal de millorar l'engagement (participació).
Cultural Identities in Wikipedia (Wikimania 2016)Marc Miquel
Unlike in most social network platforms, in Wikipedia editors are not encouraged to disclose personal traits, hobbies or affiliations. In fact, I think the identity issue has not been discussed enough. Since the project is dedicated to promote a common good, there is no content ownership, and the personal aspects become uncomfortable, or partly taboo. However, I defend that identity matters, in terms of building a Wikipedian reputation, and that editors' identities are tightly related to the content. As a Wikipedian, would you contribute equally if you couldn't choose the topics?
In this presentation I want to address the creation process and composition of Wikipedia language editions as a matter of identity. Our research on the issue has shown us that an identity-based motivation allows editors to conciliate the Wikipedian identity in the community along with their other identities. Therefore, in order to act congruently with each of such identities, they contribute with content related to them. To assess the influence of this motivation type, we developed a method and identified articles related to each Wikipedia language edition's Cultural Identities. The results on 40 Wikipedias show that this kind of content represents almost a quarter of each language edition. We analyze the content in terms of topical coverage and find that different specific topics emerge as important for each of them, although the most important topics are generally Geography, People and Culture. Inspecting how articles related to each language edition's cultural identities are exported to other languages, we show relationships between Wikipedias.
The selection of articles reflecting each Wikipedia language based cultural identities is a rich source for research, but can be also a useful base to establish an intercultural exchange between Wikipedia language editions. We propose the diversity of content across languages to be seen as an asset, and the spread of content specific to a language edition to be facilitated by automatic tools. The main point is to recognize the power of identity as a motivator for action and as a driver for change. Finally, we present a project called Wikiidentities in which we will disseminate the results of the research, make the datasets available, and provide some ideas and debate on how identities can be key to bridge the culture gap in any Wikipedia.
Happiness Has To Do With Clarity - World Information Architecture Day '15Marc Miquel
Most of the times we hear design for engagement or for better user experiences. Why don’t we design for happiness? Who is interested in happy users? I will give various examples of games and websites whose success depends on many things but joy and pleasure. Probably the key is in their information architecture and consequently in their interaction design. We as designers have an enormous responsibility for users’ behaviours. How much aware are we of our designs implications? And how much are the users?
To me, happiness in UX is the absence of frustration. Let's fight 'dark patterns' to make a more free Internet.
If you want to learn about Dark Patterns: www.darkpatterns.org
The Elements of Videogambling ExperienceMarc Miquel
For more information: http://uxmag.com/articles/dark-ux-the-elements-of-the-video-gambling-experience
This is a presentation I gave in La-Salle University (Barcelona) on April 12th about Videogambling Design and deceptive user experience. I include some of the most used dark patterns in the business and the tricks companies use to keep gamblers playing for longer sessions.
Its material is complementary to the deceptive UI designs in www.darkpatterns.org.
From the Editor's Desk: 115th Father's day Celebration - When we see Father's day in Hindu context, Nanda Baba is the most vivid figure which comes to the mind. Nanda Baba who was the foster father of Lord Krishna is known to provide love, care and affection to Lord Krishna and Balarama along with his wife Yashoda; Letter’s to the Editor: Mother's Day - Mother is a precious life for their children. Mother is life breath for her children. Mother's lap is the world happiness whose debt can never be paid.
From Slave to Scourge: The Existential Choice of Django Unchained. The Philos...Rodney Thomas Jr
#SSAPhilosophy #DjangoUnchained #DjangoFreeman #ExistentialPhilosophy #Freedom #Identity #Justice #Courage #Rebellion #Transformation
Welcome to SSA Philosophy, your ultimate destination for diving deep into the profound philosophies of iconic characters from video games, movies, and TV shows. In this episode, we explore the powerful journey and existential philosophy of Django Freeman from Quentin Tarantino’s masterful film, "Django Unchained," in our video titled, "From Slave to Scourge: The Existential Choice of Django Unchained. The Philosophy of Django Freeman!"
From Slave to Scourge: The Existential Choice of Django Unchained – The Philosophy of Django Freeman!
Join me as we delve into the existential philosophy of Django Freeman, uncovering the profound lessons and timeless wisdom his character offers. Through his story, we find inspiration in the power of choice, the quest for justice, and the courage to defy oppression. Django Freeman’s philosophy is a testament to the human spirit’s unyielding drive for freedom and justice.
Don’t forget to like, comment, and subscribe to SSA Philosophy for more in-depth explorations of the philosophies behind your favorite characters. Hit the notification bell to stay updated on our latest videos. Let’s discover the principles that shape these icons and the profound lessons they offer.
Django Freeman’s story is one of the most compelling narratives of transformation and empowerment in cinema. A former slave turned relentless bounty hunter, Django’s journey is not just a physical liberation but an existential quest for identity, justice, and retribution. This video delves into the core philosophical elements that define Django’s character and the profound choices he makes throughout his journey.
Link to video: https://youtu.be/GszqrXk38qk
Experience the thrill of Progressive Puzzle Adventures, like Scavenger Hunt Games and Escape Room Activities combined Solve Treasure Hunt Puzzles online.
Young Tom Selleck: A Journey Through His Early Years and Rise to Stardomgreendigital
Introduction
When one thinks of Hollywood legends, Tom Selleck is a name that comes to mind. Known for his charming smile, rugged good looks. and the iconic mustache that has become synonymous with his persona. Tom Selleck has had a prolific career spanning decades. But, the journey of young Tom Selleck, from his early years to becoming a household name. is a story filled with determination, talent, and a touch of luck. This article delves into young Tom Selleck's life, background, early struggles. and pivotal moments that led to his rise in Hollywood.
Follow us on: Pinterest
Early Life and Background
Family Roots and Childhood
Thomas William Selleck was born in Detroit, Michigan, on January 29, 1945. He was the second of four children in a close-knit family. His father, Robert Dean Selleck, was a real estate investor and executive. while his mother, Martha Selleck, was a homemaker. The Selleck family relocated to Sherman Oaks, California. when Tom was a child, setting the stage for his future in the entertainment industry.
Education and Early Interests
Growing up, young Tom Selleck was an active and athletic child. He attended Grant High School in Van Nuys, California. where he excelled in sports, particularly basketball. His tall and athletic build made him a standout player, and he earned a basketball scholarship to the University of Southern California (U.S.C.). While at U.S.C., Selleck studied business administration. but his interests shifted toward acting.
Discovery of Acting Passion
Tom Selleck's journey into acting was serendipitous. During his time at U.S.C., a drama coach encouraged him to try acting. This nudge led him to join the Hills Playhouse, where he began honing his craft. Transitioning from an aspiring athlete to an actor took time. but young Tom Selleck became drawn to the performance world.
Early Career Struggles
Breaking Into the Industry
The path to stardom was a challenging one for young Tom Selleck. Like many aspiring actors, he faced many rejections and struggled to find steady work. A series of minor roles and guest appearances on television shows marked his early career. In 1965, he debuted on the syndicated show "The Dating Game." which gave him some exposure but did not lead to immediate success.
The Commercial Breakthrough
During the late 1960s and early 1970s, Selleck began appearing in television commercials. His rugged good looks and charismatic presence made him a popular brand choice. He starred in advertisements for Pepsi-Cola, Revlon, and Close-Up toothpaste. These commercials provided financial stability and helped him gain visibility in the industry.
Struggling Actor in Hollywood
Despite his success in commercials. breaking into large acting roles remained a challenge for young Tom Selleck. He auditioned and took on small parts in T.V. shows and movies. Some of his early television appearances included roles in popular series like Lancer, The F.B.I., and Bracken's World. But, it would take a
Scandal! Teasers June 2024 on etv Forum.co.zaIsaac More
Monday, 3 June 2024
Episode 47
A friend is compelled to expose a manipulative scheme to prevent another from making a grave mistake. In a frantic bid to save Jojo, Phakamile agrees to a meeting that unbeknownst to her, will seal her fate.
Tuesday, 4 June 2024
Episode 48
A mother, with her son's best interests at heart, finds him unready to heed her advice. Motshabi finds herself in an unmanageable situation, sinking fast like in quicksand.
Wednesday, 5 June 2024
Episode 49
A woman fabricates a diabolical lie to cover up an indiscretion. Overwhelmed by guilt, she makes a spontaneous confession that could be devastating to another heart.
Thursday, 6 June 2024
Episode 50
Linda unwittingly discloses damning information. Nhlamulo and Vuvu try to guide their friend towards the right decision.
Friday, 7 June 2024
Episode 51
Jojo's life continues to spiral out of control. Dintle weaves a web of lies to conceal that she is not as successful as everyone believes.
Monday, 10 June 2024
Episode 52
A heated confrontation between lovers leads to a devastating admission of guilt. Dintle's desperation takes a new turn, leaving her with dwindling options.
Tuesday, 11 June 2024
Episode 53
Unable to resort to violence, Taps issues a verbal threat, leaving Mdala unsettled. A sister must explain her life choices to regain her brother's trust.
Wednesday, 12 June 2024
Episode 54
Winnie makes a very troubling discovery. Taps follows through on his threat, leaving a woman reeling. Layla, oblivious to the truth, offers an incentive.
Thursday, 13 June 2024
Episode 55
A nosy relative arrives just in time to thwart a man's fatal decision. Dintle manipulates Khanyi to tug at Mo's heartstrings and get what she wants.
Friday, 14 June 2024
Episode 56
Tlhogi is shocked by Mdala's reaction following the revelation of their indiscretion. Jojo is in disbelief when the punishment for his crime is revealed.
Monday, 17 June 2024
Episode 57
A woman reprimands another to stay in her lane, leading to a damning revelation. A man decides to leave his broken life behind.
Tuesday, 18 June 2024
Episode 58
Nhlamulo learns that due to his actions, his worst fears have come true. Caiphus' extravagant promises to suppliers get him into trouble with Ndu.
Wednesday, 19 June 2024
Episode 59
A woman manages to kill two birds with one stone. Business doom looms over Chillax. A sobering incident makes a woman realize how far she's fallen.
Thursday, 20 June 2024
Episode 60
Taps' offer to help Nhlamulo comes with hidden motives. Caiphus' new ideas for Chillax have MaHilda excited. A blast from the past recognizes Dintle, not for her newfound fame.
Friday, 21 June 2024
Episode 61
Taps is hungry for revenge and finds a rope to hang Mdala with. Chillax's new job opportunity elicits mixed reactions from the public. Roommates' initial meeting starts off on the wrong foot.
Monday, 24 June 2024
Episode 62
Taps seizes new information and recruits someone on the inside. Mary's new job
Tom Selleck Net Worth: A Comprehensive Analysisgreendigital
Over several decades, Tom Selleck, a name synonymous with charisma. From his iconic role as Thomas Magnum in the television series "Magnum, P.I." to his enduring presence in "Blue Bloods," Selleck has captivated audiences with his versatility and charm. As a result, "Tom Selleck net worth" has become a topic of great interest among fans. and financial enthusiasts alike. This article delves deep into Tom Selleck's wealth, exploring his career, assets, endorsements. and business ventures that contribute to his impressive economic standing.
Follow us on: Pinterest
Early Life and Career Beginnings
The Foundation of Tom Selleck's Wealth
Born on January 29, 1945, in Detroit, Michigan, Tom Selleck grew up in Sherman Oaks, California. His journey towards building a large net worth began with humble origins. , Selleck pursued a business administration degree at the University of Southern California (USC) on a basketball scholarship. But, his interest shifted towards acting. leading him to study at the Hills Playhouse under Milton Katselas.
Minor roles in television and films marked Selleck's early career. He appeared in commercials and took on small parts in T.V. series such as "The Dating Game" and "Lancer." These initial steps, although modest. laid the groundwork for his future success and the growth of Tom Selleck net worth. Breakthrough with "Magnum, P.I."
The Role that Defined Tom Selleck's Career
Tom Selleck's breakthrough came with the role of Thomas Magnum in the CBS television series "Magnum, P.I." (1980-1988). This role made him a household name and boosted his net worth. The series' popularity resulted in Selleck earning large salaries. leading to financial stability and increased recognition in Hollywood.
"Magnum P.I." garnered high ratings and critical acclaim during its run. Selleck's portrayal of the charming and resourceful private investigator resonated with audiences. making him one of the most beloved television actors of the 1980s. The success of "Magnum P.I." played a pivotal role in shaping Tom Selleck net worth, establishing him as a major star.
Film Career and Diversification
Expanding Tom Selleck's Financial Portfolio
While "Magnum, P.I." was a cornerstone of Selleck's career, he did not limit himself to television. He ventured into films, further enhancing Tom Selleck net worth. His filmography includes notable movies such as "Three Men and a Baby" (1987). which became the highest-grossing film of the year, and its sequel, "Three Men and a Little Lady" (1990). These box office successes contributed to his wealth.
Selleck's versatility allowed him to transition between genres. from comedies like "Mr. Baseball" (1992) to westerns such as "Quigley Down Under" (1990). This diversification showcased his acting range. and provided many income streams, reinforcing Tom Selleck net worth.
Television Resurgence with "Blue Bloods"
Sustaining Wealth through Consistent Success
In 2010, Tom Selleck began starring as Frank Reagan i
In the vast landscape of cinema, stories have been told, retold, and reimagined in countless ways. At the heart of this narrative evolution lies the concept of a "remake". A successful remake allows us to revisit cherished tales through a fresh lens, often reflecting a different era's perspective or harnessing the power of advanced technology. Yet, the question remains, what makes a remake successful? Today, we will delve deeper into this subject, identifying the key ingredients that contribute to the success of a remake.
Meet Dinah Mattingly – Larry Bird’s Partner in Life and Loveget joys
Get an intimate look at Dinah Mattingly’s life alongside NBA icon Larry Bird. From their humble beginnings to their life today, discover the love and partnership that have defined their relationship.
Skeem Saam in June 2024 available on ForumIsaac More
Monday, June 3, 2024 - Episode 241: Sergeant Rathebe nabs a top scammer in Turfloop. Meikie is furious at her uncle's reaction to the truth about Ntswaki.
Tuesday, June 4, 2024 - Episode 242: Babeile uncovers the truth behind Rathebe’s latest actions. Leeto's announcement shocks his employees, and Ntswaki’s ordeal haunts her family.
Wednesday, June 5, 2024 - Episode 243: Rathebe blocks Babeile from investigating further. Melita warns Eunice to stay clear of Mr. Kgomo.
Thursday, June 6, 2024 - Episode 244: Tbose surrenders to the police while an intruder meddles in his affairs. Rathebe's secret mission faces a setback.
Friday, June 7, 2024 - Episode 245: Rathebe’s antics reach Kganyago. Tbose dodges a bullet, but a nightmare looms. Mr. Kgomo accuses Melita of witchcraft.
Monday, June 10, 2024 - Episode 246: Ntswaki struggles on her first day back at school. Babeile is stunned by Rathebe’s romance with Bullet Mabuza.
Tuesday, June 11, 2024 - Episode 247: An unexpected turn halts Rathebe’s investigation. The press discovers Mr. Kgomo’s affair with a young employee.
Wednesday, June 12, 2024 - Episode 248: Rathebe chases a criminal, resorting to gunfire. Turf High is rife with tension and transfer threats.
Thursday, June 13, 2024 - Episode 249: Rathebe traps Kganyago. John warns Toby to stop harassing Ntswaki.
Friday, June 14, 2024 - Episode 250: Babeile is cleared to investigate Rathebe. Melita gains Mr. Kgomo’s trust, and Jacobeth devises a financial solution.
Monday, June 17, 2024 - Episode 251: Rathebe feels the pressure as Babeile closes in. Mr. Kgomo and Eunice clash. Jacobeth risks her safety in pursuit of Kganyago.
Tuesday, June 18, 2024 - Episode 252: Bullet Mabuza retaliates against Jacobeth. Pitsi inadvertently reveals his parents’ plans. Nkosi is shocked by Khwezi’s decision on LJ’s future.
Wednesday, June 19, 2024 - Episode 253: Jacobeth is ensnared in deceit. Evelyn is stressed over Toby’s case, and Letetswe reveals shocking academic results.
Thursday, June 20, 2024 - Episode 254: Elizabeth learns Jacobeth is in Mpumalanga. Kganyago's past is exposed, and Lehasa discovers his son is in KZN.
Friday, June 21, 2024 - Episode 255: Elizabeth confirms Jacobeth’s dubious activities in Mpumalanga. Rathebe lies about her relationship with Bullet, and Jacobeth faces theft accusations.
Monday, June 24, 2024 - Episode 256: Rathebe spies on Kganyago. Lehasa plans to retrieve his son from KZN, fearing what awaits.
Tuesday, June 25, 2024 - Episode 257: MaNtuli fears for Kwaito’s safety in Mpumalanga. Mr. Kgomo and Melita reconcile.
Wednesday, June 26, 2024 - Episode 258: Kganyago makes a bold escape. Elizabeth receives a shocking message from Kwaito. Mrs. Khoza defends her husband against scam accusations.
Thursday, June 27, 2024 - Episode 259: Babeile's skillful arrest changes the game. Tbose and Kwaito face a hostage crisis.
Friday, June 28, 2024 - Episode 260: Two women face the reality of being scammed. Turf is rocked by breaking
As a film director, I have always been awestruck by the magic of animation. Animation, a medium once considered solely for the amusement of children, has undergone a significant transformation over the years. Its evolution from a rudimentary form of entertainment to a sophisticated form of storytelling has stirred my creativity and expanded my vision, offering limitless possibilities in the realm of cinematic storytelling.
Hollywood Actress - The 250 hottest galleryZsolt Nemeth
Hollywood Actress amazon album eminent worldwide media, female-singer, actresses, alhletina-woman, 250 collection.
Highest and photoreal-print exclusive testament PC collage.
Focused television virtuality crime, novel.
The sheer afterlife of the work is activism-like hollywood-actresses point com.
173 Illustrate, 250 gallery, 154 blog, 120 TV serie logo, 17 TV president logo, 183 active hyperlink.
HD AI face enhancement 384 page plus Bowker ISBN, Congress LLCL or US Copyright.
Meet Crazyjamjam - A TikTok Sensation | Blog EternalBlog Eternal
Crazyjamjam, the TikTok star everyone's talking about! Uncover her secrets to success, viral trends, and more in this exclusive feature on Blog Eternal.
Source: https://blogeternal.com/celebrity/crazyjamjam-leaks/
Create a Seamless Viewing Experience with Your Own Custom OTT Player.pdfGenny Knight
As the popularity of online streaming continues to rise, the significance of providing outstanding viewing experiences cannot be emphasized enough. Tailored OTT players present a robust solution for service providers aiming to enhance their offerings and engage audiences in a competitive market. Through embracing customization, companies can craft immersive, individualized experiences that effectively hold viewers' attention, entertain them, and encourage repeat usage.
Maximizing Your Streaming Experience with XCIPTV- Tips for 2024.pdfXtreame HDTV
In today’s digital age, streaming services have become an integral part of our entertainment lives. Among the myriad of options available, XCIPTV stands out as a premier choice for those seeking seamless, high-quality streaming. This comprehensive guide will delve into the features, benefits, and user experience of XCIPTV, illustrating why it is a top contender in the IPTV industry.
Panchayat Season 3 - Official Trailer.pdfSuleman Rana
The dearest series "Panchayat" is set to make a victorious return with its third season, and the fervor is discernible. The authority trailer, delivered on May 28, guarantees one more enamoring venture through the country heartland of India.
Jitendra Kumar keeps on sparkling as Abhishek Tripathi, the city-reared engineer who ends up functioning as the secretary of the Panchayat office in the curious town of Phulera. His nuanced depiction of a young fellow exploring the difficulties of country life while endeavoring to adjust to his new environmental factors has earned far and wide recognition.
Neena Gupta and Raghubir Yadav return as Manju Devi and Brij Bhushan Dubey, separately. Their dynamic science and immaculate acting rejuvenate the hardships of town administration. Gupta's depiction of the town Pradhan with an ever-evolving outlook, matched with Yadav's carefully prepared exhibition, adds profundity and credibility to the story.
New Difficulties and Experiences
The trailer indicates new difficulties anticipating the characters, as Abhishek keeps on wrestling with his part in the town and his yearnings for a superior future. The series has reliably offset humor with social editorial, and Season 3 looks ready to dig much more profound into the intricacies of rustic organization and self-awareness.
Watchers can hope to see a greater amount of the enchanting and particular residents who have become fan top picks. Their connections and the one of a kind cut of-life situations give a reviving and interesting portrayal of provincial India, featuring the two its appeal and its difficulties.
A Mix of Humor and Heart
One of the signs of "Panchayat" is its capacity to mix humor with sincere narrating. The trailer features minutes that guarantee to convey giggles, as well as scenes that pull at the heartstrings. This equilibrium has been a critical calculate the show's prosperity, resounding with crowds across different socioeconomics.
Creation Greatness
The creation quality remaining parts first rate, with the beautiful setting of Phulera town filling in as a scenery that upgrades the narrating. The meticulousness in portraying provincial life, joined with sharp composition and solid exhibitions, guarantees that "Panchayat" keeps on hanging out in the packed web series scene.
Expectation and Delivery
As the delivery date draws near, expectation for "Panchayat" Season 3 is at a record-breaking high. The authority trailer has previously created critical buzz, with fans enthusiastically anticipating the continuation of Abhishek Tripathi's excursion and the new undertakings that lie ahead in Phulera.
All in all, the authority trailer for "Panchayat" Season 3 recommends that watchers are in for another drawing in and engaging ride. Yet again with its charming characters, convincing story, and ideal mix of humor and show, the new season is set to enamor crowds. Write in your schedules and prepare to get back to the endearing universe of "Panchayat."
240529_Teleprotection Global Market Report 2024.pdfMadhura TBRC
The teleprotection market size has grown
exponentially in recent years. It will grow from
$21.92 billion in 2023 to $28.11 billion in 2024 at a
compound annual growth rate (CAGR) of 28.2%. The
teleprotection market size is expected to see
exponential growth in the next few years. It will grow
to $70.77 billion in 2028 at a compound annual
growth rate (CAGR) of 26.0%.
240529_Teleprotection Global Market Report 2024.pdf
Game Balance 2: Sustained Uncertainty
1. Lesson 2: Sustained Uncertainty (i)
Third year course in Quality Assurance and Game Balance
Bachelor Degree in Video Game Design and Production
Third term, April 2019 Dr. Marc Miquel Ribé
3. • Uncertainty: Information Not Available
Balance is to maintain uncertainty until the end of the game.
In a game we go from uncertainty to more certainty. What is uncertainty?
Uncertainty is a situation which involves imperfect and/or unknown information.
When the game reaches a ‘final state’, in that situation, there is certainty about some
information, and the player feels there is something ‘complete’.
Situations often arise wherein a decision must be made
when the results of each possible choice are uncertain.
Challenges and randomness introduce uncertainty to the system
4. How can we put the system into the ‘final state’?
By using skills: mental skills to foresee what we have to do, and physical skills to do it.
Once we have the personal certainty that we can do it, we do it and the game is
complete, the uncertainty is gone.
• What is the challenge?
The elements of the system introducing uncertainty but which are “solvable”.
Challenges are possible to pick and solve with skill. Solving the challenge is giving the
system the right information, and the game is done.
• What is randomness?
The elements of the system that we do not know how they work but which also give
uncertainty. There is not a visible order in the same way we can detect in challenge.
Science (as a game) has the only mechanic of taking reality’s apparent randomness
and create models to explain it. They separate challenge from randomness.
• Uncertainty in the game is composed by challenge (the part we can solve by
using skills) and randomness (the part we do not know how it works).
5. a) Challenge (and Skill)
You tackle challenge by skill. You try to make order out the system and reach the final
state. Challenge can look in very different ways.
a. Some games like this equation are easily solvable (perfect information),
others like chess are solvable but difficult to compute by mental skills.
b. Blackjack (like all card games) has hidden information.
Some people calculate better than others.
c. Even seducing a girl is seen as a ‘challenge’.
d. Riddles are also solvable challenges: “It’s been around for millions of years, but it’s
no more than a month old. What is it?” The moon
A game is uncertainty, because when we solve it we say “I know this one”.
Uncertainty keeps us playing.
* In this lesson, I use difficulty and challenge interchangeably
6. The big question is: What is the challenge in this game that needs X skills?
There are many types of skills.
Actually, Howard Gardner called
them intelligences to sound
“more cool”. His theory has not
been proved yet, but we are
certain there are different skills.
Think of games that require
their skills.
• Spatial (Strategy games)
• Intrapersonal (Social Networks)
• Linguistic (Scrabble)
• Logical-mathematical (Big Brain
Academy)
• Bodily-kinesthetic (Shooters,
Platformers, etc.)
• …
There are very different sort of challenges that require ‘info inputs’ generated by very
different skills. Do you want to innovate? Create games that require different skills.
7. Physical coordination challenges: speed and reaction time, accuracy and precision,
intuitive understanding of physics, timing and rhythm, combination moves…
Cognitive challenges: formal logic puzzles, mathematical challenges, factual
Knowledge Challenges, Memory challenges, Pattern recognition challenges,…
Exploration challenges: spatial awareness challenges, locked doors, traps, mazes and
illogical spaces, teleporters, hidden objects,..
Conflict challenges: strategy, tactics, logistics, survival, stealth…
Economic challenges: accumulating resources, achieving balance, caring for living
things,…
Conceptual reasoning and lateral thinking challenges: conceptual reasoning, lateral
thinking, etc.
There is a fascinating anatomy of challenges in games in Chapter 9 from “Fundamentals of
Game Design” (Ernest Adams, 2012)
8. The challenge is connected to
the core mechanic of the
game, which also defines
what a genre is.
Fig. Dormans (2012; p.12)
Please, someone tell me the
main core and the type of
difficulty of the game they
are building right now.
9. b) Randomness (and Chance)
You tackle randomness by “giving it a chance”. Chance is interacting with an element
we do not know its outcome. So we try.
• Randomness in the game: when you do not know how the system computes the
“changes”, you call it random.
Casual players enjoy randomness in the game because it adds uncertainty (they can
always win), but randomness also kills the need for skills. For this same reason,
competitive players do not like randomness. Think of games with high randomness.
Introducing randomness has positive and negative effects. I see it like using spices!
The base of the game is ‘challenge’, then you add up randomness so it keeps
uncertainty.
What happens with too much spice in food? No food taste.
What happens with too much randomness in a game?
No possible challenge and skills use.
10. Dealing with randomness
• Estimating chance is a skill. In many games, what separates the skilled players
from the unskilled is their ability to predict what is going to happen next, often
through calculating probabilities.
• Estimating an opponent’s skill is a skill. A big part of a player’s ability to
determine the chances of success for a particular action rests on their ability to
estimate their opponent’s skill.
• Predicting pure chance is an imagined skill. Humans look for patterns, consciously
and subconsciously, to help predict what is going to happen next. Our mania for
patterns often leads us to look for and find patterns where none exist.
• Skills have a probability of success. Naively, one might think that completely skill
based games, such as chess or baseball, have no aspects of randomness or risk in
them. E.g. in a shooter, we can do some headshots ‘by mistake’.
Based on Schell (2008; p. 197)
12. Overview of the Lesson
In this lesson we will see the next topics:
1. Initial challenge level
2. Increasing challenge level
3. Dynamic challenge adjustment
4. Emergence and open worlds
5. Countering positive feedback loops
6. Non-skill based actions in multiplayer games
In games, it is necessary to sustain uncertainty, otherwise there is no game.
These are six usual ways to do it.
13. 1. Choosing the initial challenge level (PvE)
When somebody starts playing a game for the first time, he might say:
“This game is imbalanced, I cannot play it”; or sometimes he goes with “it’s too
difficult, it is not for me”.
PROBLEM:
If the game is too easy or too difficult, there is no way to sustain uncertainty.
The player will probably drop the game soon.
SOLUTION:
To chose the right amount of initial uncertainty (difficulty and randomness) for the
target player.
How? Well, the only way to adjust the initial challenge is to study the target player
level of skill, in other words, to do user research.
14. The perceived difficulty of a
challenge—the difficulty that the
player actually senses, and the
type we are most concerned
with—consists of the relative
difficulty minus the player’s
experience at meeting such
challenges Adams (2013; p. 343).
Remembering that relative
difficulty is absolute difficulty
minus power provided, we can
put all these factors together into
a single equation such that:
perceived difficulty = absolute difficulty - power provided - in-game experience/skills
How does this apply to the game you are building right now?
15. PROBLEM:
“It’s nearly impossible to make a skill-driven game that’s balanced for players of all
skill levels. A designer must target which skill level he wishes to balance for.” Sylvester
(2012; p. 164)
A game that is balanced for players at one skill level may be imbalanced for players at
another because there players at different skill levels with experience in previous
games. This is how it works and we cannot change it. What can we do?
SOLUTIONS:
There are three possible solutions in order to adjust initial challenge:
a) Decrease general challenge (provide different modes: easy, normal, hard).
Offering difficulty modes (Adams, 2013; p. 340). Do the user research (playtesting)
and be sure that ‘easy mode’ means easy!
16. b) Decrease localized challenge (automatic pilots, auto-aim, automatic gear change,
etc.). So the player does not need the skills at specific moments.
c) Allow introducing cheats codes (so players can keep the normal mode, and its
their decision to switch).
17. 2. Increasing the challenge level (PvE, PvP)
PROBLEM: People get tired of repeating the same challenges as their skills get better.
SOLUTION: Increasing the challenge level will sustain the uncertainty.
The challenge level can be designed in PvE (by a game designer). The challenge level
can also consist in assigning players with similar skill levels in a PvP.
Again, let’s examine the relationship between Challenge and Skill. This time
according to Psychology.
With higher levels of challenge players will not solve the game straight-ahead and will
require to develop their skills.
QUESTION: What sort of cognitive resources are required in order to achieve higher
level challenges?
18. Attention.
This is the main idea of Csikszentmihalyi’s Flow Theory, who studied what he called
the mental state of “flow” (we sometimes call it being “in the flow” or “in the zone”).
This is a state of extreme focus of attention, where you tune out everything except
the task you’re concentrating on, you become highly productive, and your brain gives
you a shot of neurochemicals that is pleasurable – being in a flow state is literally a
natural high.
Csikszentmihalyi identified three requirements for a flow state to exist:
• You must be performing a challenging activity that requires skill.
• The activity must provide clear goals and feedback.
• The outcome is uncertain but can be influenced by your actions.
Csikszentmihalyi calls this the “paradox of control”: you are in control of your actions
which gives you indirect control over the outcome, but you do not have direct control
over the outcome.
19. Flow theory (Csikszentmihalyi) explains the relationship between challenge and
skill, attention, motivation and positive emotions.
20. Csikszentmihalyi also gave five effects of being in a flow state:
• A merging of action and awareness: spontaneous, automatic action/reaction. In
other words, you go on autopilot, doing things without thinking about them. (In
fact, your brain is moving faster than the speed of thought)
• Concentration on immediate tasks: complete focus, without any mind-wandering.
You are not thinking about long-term trade-offs or other tasks; your mind is in the
here-and-now, because it has to be.
• Loss of awareness of self, loss of ego. When you are in a flow state, you become
one with your surroundings (in a Zen way, I suppose).
• There is a distorted sense of time. Strangely, this can go both ways. In some cases,
such as Tetris example, time can seem to slow down and things seem to happen in
slow motion. (Actually, what is happening is that your brain is acting so efficiently
that it is working faster; everything else is still going at the same speed, but you
are seeing things from your own point of reference.) Other times, time can seem
to speed up; a common example is sitting down to play a game for “just five
minutes”... and then six hours later, suddenly becoming aware that you burned
away your whole evening.
• The experience of the activity is an end in itself; it is done for its own sake and
not for an external reward. Again, this feeds into the whole “here-and-now” thing,
as you are not in a mental state where you can think that far ahead.
21. Well, now we know that there are deep reasons rooted on psychology in order to
sustain uncertainty by increasing challenge.
At the same time, not only we need to increase challenge level, but we need to
make it clear that the player understands it.
We need to avoid “stagnation”. Stagnation occurs in a PvE game when the game
leaves the player in a position in which he simply does not know what to do next; he
believes that he is stuck. This breaks the flow.
However, you can still give the players information as they progress:
• Tackle stagnation passively by giving plain sight clues about how to proceed.
• Tackle stagnation actively by having the game detect when the player wanders
around aimlessly; make the game provide a few gentle nudges to guide her in the
right direction.
More on stagnation (Adams, 2013; p. 353).
22. How to increase the challenge level
Do you remember the perceived challenge depended on power and in-game skills?
Then:
• We can increase it by calculating the challenge as a relationship of power.
• We can increase it by calculating the challenge as a relationship with in-game skills.
This is based on the idea of “positive linear relationship” between challenges and
power or skills achieved.
y = mx + b
Where: “m” is the slope of the line,
“x” is any point (an input or x-value) on the line,
and “b” is where the line crosses the y-axis.
In games with internal economies it is very clear (e.g. RPG or even the first Super
Marios). These game revolve around the central relationship with the elements which
grantees power and allows to keep playing.
23. Schreiber (gamebalanceconcepts.wordpress.com)
EXAMPLE: Dragon Warrior from NES (1986).
In the game’s combat system, you have four main stats:
Hit Points (HP), Magic Points (MP), Attack and Defense.
This is a game of attrition; you are exploring game areas,
and every few steps you get attacked by an enemy. You
lose if your HP is ever reduced to zero.
How are all of these numbers related? Random
encounters are related to HP: each encounter reduces
HP (you can also say it the other way: by walking around
getting into fights, you can essentially convert HP into
encounters). This is an inverse relationship, as more
encounters means less HP.
There’s a direct relationship between HP and Defense:
the more defense you have, the less damage you take,
which means your HP lasts longer. Effectively, increasing
your Defense is equivalent to giving yourself a pile of
extra HP.
24. Ironically, we see the same linear relationship between HP and Attack. The higher
your attack stat, the faster you can defeat an enemy. If you defeat an enemy faster,
that means it has less opportunity to damage you, so you take less damage. Thus, you
can survive more fights with higher Attack.
MP (mana points) is an interesting case, because you can use it for a lot of things.
Even though MP is versatile, virtually all of the uses for it involve converting it (directly
or indirectly) into HP.
If you draw this all out on paper, you’ll see that everything — Attack, Defense, MP,
Monster Encounters — is linked directly to HP.
Let’s examine the leveling system first. Collect enough XP and you’ll level up, which
increases all of your stats (HP, MP, Attack and Defense). As you can see, this creates a
feedback loop: defeating enemies causes you to gain a level, which increases your
stats, which lets you defeat more enemies
Examining the economic system, Gold is used for a few things. Its primary use is to
buy equipment which permanently increases the player’s Attack or Defense, thus
effectively converting Gold into extra permanent HP.
25. • Another loop that is linked to the economic system, is that of progression itself.
Many areas in the game are behind locked doors, and in order to open them you
need to use your Gold to purchase magic keys. You defeat monsters, get Gold, use
it to purchase Keys, and use those keys to open new areas which have stronger
monsters (which then let you get even more Gold/XP). Of course, this loop is itself
limited by the player’s stats; unlocking a new area with monsters that are too
strong to handle does not help the player much.
How would a designer balance things within all these systems?
By relating everything back to the central value of HP, and then comparing the
current sum of power and the current sum of challenge.
We need to be sure there is an increase of challenge higher than the current power.
26. • Coins: there is a 100-to-1 relationship between Coins and Lives, since collecting 100
coins awards an extra life. There is a 1-to-200 relationship between Coins and Score,
since collecting a coin gives 200 points. There is a relationship between Coin Blocks
and Coins, in that each block gives you some number of coins.
• Time: there is a 100-to-1 relationship between Time and Score, since you get a time
bonus at the end of each level. There is also an inverse relationship between Time
and Lives, since running out of time costs you a life.
• Enemies: there is a relationship between Enemies and Score, since killing enemies
gives you from 100 to 1000 points (depending on the enemy). There is an inverse
relationship between Enemies and Lives, since sometimes an enemy will cost you a
life (in a few select levels there is potentially a positive relationship between
Enemies and Lives, as stomping enough enemies in a combo will give extra lives, but
that is a special case.)
EXAMPLE: Even manual skills-based games
such as Super Mario Bros contained an
economy which should be balanced to
guarantee a positive linear relationship.
What is the central element of the Super
Mario Bros. game economy?
27. Lives: there is this strange relationship between Lives and everything else, because
losing a life resets the Coins, Time and Enemies on a level. Note that since Coins give
you extra Lives, and losing a Life resets Coins, any level with more than 100 Coins
would provide a positive feedback loop where you could die intentionally, get more
than 100 Coins, and repeat to gain infinite lives. The original Super Mario Bros. did not
have any levels like this, but Super Mario 3 did.
If you have no lives, you cannot continue the game, therefore, it’s the end of the game.
Relationship between Lives and Score: There is no direct link between Lives and Score.
However, losing a Life resets a bunch of things that give scoring opportunities, so
indirectly you can convert a Life to Score. Interestingly, this does not happen the other
way around; unlike other arcade games of the time, you cannot earn extra Lives by
getting a sufficiently high Score.
Looking at these relationships, we see that Score is actually the central resource in
Super Mario Bros. since everything is tied to Score. This makes sense in the context of
early arcade games, since the win condition is not “beat the game,” but rather, “get the
highest score.”
28. How can we balance Super Mario Bros. in order to make a difficulty increase with a
positive relationship to score?
Ideally, we need higher challenge for when the player has higher power/skills. At the
same time, we need to give a higher score when there is a higher challenge.
From the power/skills perspective:
• You can check the number of coins that you get in initial levels and further levels, to
see the number of lives they give.
• You can check the number of power-ups that you get in levels.
• …
From the difficulty perspective:
• You can check how difficult enemies are (how hard to kill and how easy is they get
you) and assign a proper score.
• You can make the level longer or provide less time.
• …
29. Where is challenge?
Where is ‘higher’ challenge?
What is a different sort of challenge?
How are challenges tied together?
A partial skill tree for Super Mario Bros.
(Dormans and Adams, 2012; p. 240)
30. One way to be sure that the game increases challenge is to detect which are the most
difficult actions and purposely design each level to include them more often. Even
you can use Excel to have a clear map of the challenge.
Level 1 Level 2 Level 3
Action required: Ch. 1 20 15 10
Action required: Ch. 2 15 13 10
Action required: Ch. 3 13 20 12
Action required: Ch. 4 1 5 10
Action required: Ch. 5 0 1 10
Remember increasing challenge
in relation to previous levels and
to the same level.
Remember starting lower than
the last part of the previous level,
so it allows the player to gain lost
skills again (in case of not having
played for a while).
31. How does challenge evolves in games? Let’s put three more examples.
1. Space Invaders (PvE)
This game presents the same skill-based challenge to you, wave after wave, and
increasing the skill by making the aliens move and shoot faster and start lower. The
player has absolutely no way to gain power in the game; you start with three lives
and that’s all you get, and there are no power-ups. On the other hand, you also don’t
really lose power in the game, in a sense: whether you have one life remaining or all
three, your offensive and defensive capabilities are the same. The player’s goal is not
to win, but to survive as long as possible before the increasing challenge curve
overwhelms them.
Schreiber (gamebalanceconcepts.wordpress.com)
32. 2. Settlers of Catan (PvP)
Here is a game where progression is gaining power, so it is positive-sum. There are
only very limited cases where players can actually lose their progress; mostly, when
you build something, that gain is permanent. Catan contains a pretty powerful
positive feedback loop, in that building more settlements and cities gives you more
resources which lets you build even more, and building is the primary victory
condition.
Where is the challenge? Other players get ahead and have more power than you, so
they are closer to the victory condition. What counterbalances this? Players can
trade freely with other player, so they can refuse to help ’the leader’.
In a PvP challenge depends on how difficult is to obtain power,
according to how power other players have and what they
do to block you from doing it.
33. 4. The Sims (PvE)
The Sims is a time-management game in which the player must use the limited time
available to perform all the activities necessary to keep them happy and healthy. By
taking good care of his sims, they will find jobs. If they make it to work on time and in
good health and good spirits, they will advance their careers. Better jobs means they
will bring home more money that the player can spend on items to entertain the sims
and to make their daily routine run more efficiently. Although the game does not
state that the goal is to guide the sims toward material and professional success, it is
implicit in the mechanics, and many players play it that way.
In such PvE, the challenge is not
directed towards the player as a
requirement; instead, they are
presented as voluntary goals, but
also need to be balanced in order
to create a linear relationship.
34. Increasing challenge until the end? Finding the Elder Game
In most cases, the end of the game happens after the progression is over. Why would
you continue playing if there is no challenge, right? No challenge, no attention (Flow).
In a few specialized cases, the game has no end (MMOs, Sims, tabletop RPGs, or
progression-based Facebook games), so progression is used as a reward structure and
a training simulator in the early game rather than a way to move towards the end the
game. This has an obvious problem which can be seen with just about all of these
games: at some point, more progression just isn’t meaningful.
The player has seen all the content in the game that they need to, they’ve reached
the level cap, they’ve unlocked all of their special abilities in their skill tree, they’ve
maxed their stats, or whatever.
In just about all cases, when the player reaches this point, they have to find
something else to do, and there is a sharp transition into what’s sometimes called the
“elder game” where the objective changes from progression to something else.
Perhaps ‘mentoring’ newbes?
35. FarmVille
These are positive-sum games where you basically click to progress, it’s nearly
impossible to lose any progress at all, and you’re always gaining something. More
player skill simply means you progress at a faster rate. After a certain point you don’t
really get any interesting rewards for doing so. But after awhile, the reward loop
starts rewarding you less and less frequently, you finish earning all the ribbons or
trophies or achievements or whatever, so it’s not that you can’t progress any further,
but that the game doesn’t really reward you for progression as much (you are in the
Elder Game), so at some point the player decides that further progression just isn’t
worth it to them, and they either stop playing or they start playing in a different way.
36. 3. Using dynamic challenge adjustment (PvE)
PROBLEMS:
- We do not know when people are going to improve their skills... Players are not
equal. What if the challenge curve is too slope or just the opposite?
- We do not want to redesign the game for difficulty modes, as people may not like
them, as this implies deleting things, adjusting the parameters, etcetera.
SOLUTION:
Create a new game mode which solves this: dynamic game difficulty balancing (or
dynamic challenge adjustment, or dynamic difficulty adjustment DDA).
With Dynamic Difficulty Adjustment, the game makes itself easier or harder based on
how the player is doing in order to preserve a proper level of challenge
The challenge level becomes more difficult to understand, but its changes are
effective in order to sustain “perceived difficulty”.
37. • Crash Bandicoot, an action game, offers the player extra shields against attack if he
fails to get through a certain section too many times in a row. Players find this
mechanism rather obvious. Furthermore, rather than being a global system in the
entire game, it had to be implemented separately for each region of the game where
it offered extra shields.
• The first-person shooter game Max Payne automatically adjusts the strength of
enemies and the amount of aiming assistance provided to the player based on his
performance. These changes work to keep the player’s experience at an appropriate
level of difficulty, but they are invisible to the user.
• Half-Life 2 checks the state of the avatar’s health and ammunition when he breaks
open a crate in the game world, and adjusts the contents of the crate accordingly. If
he is healthy and well supplied, he might find little or nothing, but if he is short of
one of these resources, he might find medical kits or spare ammunition.
• Madden NFL 09 gives the player a series of explicit tests in its “Virtual Training
Center”, then adjusts the difficulty of the gameplay in the real game based on his
performance in the tests.
Examples from Adams (2013; p. 347)
38. Some of the problems with DDA:
• Some players hate it. This is the number one reason to think twice about
implementing DDA, especially if it can't be switched off. Many players feel
patronized when they discover that a game is going easy on them when get into
trouble, and they don't want the difficulty level to change at all.
• Players can learn to exploit DDA by pretending to be worse than they are. It's a bit
like hustling pool; you sucker your opponent into thinking you're a novice, then wipe
the floor with him when his money's on the table.
• DDA doesn't work for all kinds of challenges. If the challenges in a game are based
on numeric entities -- health points, money, speed and so on -- then it's fairly easy to
dynamically adjust these values to change the difficulty of a challenge. What about
symbolic entities? Words, puzzles, etc.?
• DDA can create absurdities. In some car racing games, if you crash your car, the
game slows down the other drivers so as to give you a chance to catch up. Then
there's the notorious rubber-band effect: if you get too far ahead your opponents
always catch up, and if you get too far behind, they always slow down. It feels as if
your car and theirs are connected by rubber bands.
[http://www.gamasutra.com/view/feature/132061/the_designers_notebook_.php?print=1]
39. If you're definitely going to use DDA, consider the following suggestions:
• Make the game harder by beefing up the opposition, not by weakening the
player. Players rightly feel that any power they have, they earned. Never arbitrarily
take something away from a player; if they lose something they've gained, there has
to be a reason for it. It's OK to make the AI more lucky, but not OK to make the
player less lucky. If he's doing well and then suddenly finds that his sniper rifle no
longer shoots straight, he's going to hate you.
• Make it optional, as in Lego Star Wars II. That way the players who don't like it can
turn it off. Lego Star Wars II actually offered both DDA and settable difficulty levels,
but not everyone can afford to put in that much development work.
• Make it subtle. I can't emphasize this enough. The same monsters that were easy to
beat in level one should not suddenly be tough as nails in level two -- or vice versa.
Big changes spoil the player's immersion and create inappropriate spikes or troughs
in the perceived-difficulty curve. If at all possible, adjust the difficulty of the game
through frequent small changes rather than one large one, so the player doesn't
notice it happening.
• Keep the details secret. Don't let your players find out exactly what performance-
evaluation mechanism you're using, nor what the game will do to become easier.
40. 4. Emergence and open worlds (PvE)
You can increase uncertainty by providing non-linearity.
There is a game distinction based on mechanics: Emergence and Progression
Dormans (2012; p. 38).
• Emergence describes a game with simple mechanics but complex dynamics.
“Emergent complexity” can be used to describe any system of this nature, even
things that are not games. Let’s take Chess. The rules of this game are pretty
simple, with only six different piece types and a handful of special-case moves, but
a set of common opening moves has emerged from repeated play.
• Progression describes a game that requires a particular path. It implies a linearity
and specific rules for each specific moment.
For our purpose, emergence
and progression can both
sustain uncertainty.
There may be challenge in
each game structure.
41. Back in 2002, from the perspective of Jesper Juul, emergence is more interesting than
progression, since it takes the game from simplicity into complexity.
• Starcraft is an excellent example of a game of emergence, while Starcraft 2
introduced more progression elements.
The emergent part of the games have evolved and many things have been invented,
but progression has been more difficult to evolve, they are very similar to twenty
years ago (probably because of the difficulty in designing multilinear progression).
PROBLEM:
Progression is not much interesting, since society (and life) are bigger than that. In
other words, I know that “after this, comes that”. Multilinear progression is difficult.
SOLUTION:
Open worlds and a better integration of emergence and progression (a more dynamic
progression): this is the solution to multilinear progression. Another way of
sustaining uncertainty is giving more paths i.e. more open worlds.
[https://www.jesperjuul.net/text/openandtheclosed.html]
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=45PdtGDGhac The Illusion of Choice - How Games Balance Freedom and Scope
42. The evolution of progression into open worlds has been gradual. Crash Bandicoot
creators thought “people will not know what to do” when they played Mario 64 for
the first time.
Grand Theft Auto games provide good example in integration of both emergence and
progression. In those games, players may achieve victory in a mission by a wide
variety of means, but their gameplay choices don’t really affect the story
PROBLEM:
In open worlds we do sustain uncertainty by letting explore, but we do not know
how to manage difficulty increase. What can we do?
43. SOLUTION:
Huge possibilities + Dynamic difficulty adjustment
This is what Zelda: Breath of the Wild is doing: a bigger map, more things, less
explanation, less linearity and… DDA (the more enemies you kill they stronger they get).
Twilight Princess linearity.
44. 5. Dealing with positive feedback loops (PvP, PvE)
Understanding positive feedback loops
A positive feedback loop can be thought of as a reinforcing relationship. Something
happens that causes the same thing to happen again, which causes it to happen yet
again, getting stronger in each iteration – like a snowball that starts out small at the
top of the hill and gets larger and faster as it rolls and collects more snow.
Air Conditioning:
Closed Loop Control System with a controller.
“Is there an ideal number of feedback loops in a game? We have found that
somewhere between two and four major feedback loops seems to be sufficient for
most types of games.” (Dormans and Adams, 2012; p. 118)
45. Positive feedback loops are everywhere (for better or worse)
They can be even ‘outside’ the rules, in the meta-game.
• Show biz. Win competitions > Earn money > Get better players > Win
competitions > Advertising > Earn money > Get better players,…
Games are played at very different levels of society, then, it is difficult to ’cut’ loops…
In football, you may remember that many years ago only five foreigners could play for
a team. This prevented teams from buying good brazilians and not making any effort,
at the same time it made it possible for poorer teams to compete.
• Psychology. Playing better than the competitor > Self-rewards and growing
confidence > Paying more attention > Playing better,…
46. Two benefits of Positive Feedback (Adams, 2013; p. 349; p. 352)
• Positive feedback discourages stalemate. A well-balanced PvP game should only
rarely result in a stalemate, and PvE games should never end in stalemate.
• Positive feedback rewards success and provides that reward in a useful form rather
than a purely cosmetic form, such as a higher score. Even though the perceived
difficulty of challenges may increase, thus requiring the player to work harder
nearer the end of the game, she still feels rewarded by a sense of power and
growth at being able to do things she could not do at the beginning of the game.
PROBLEM: One player gets ahead and it becomes obvious so soon that the others will
have no chance to catch up. It becomes boring,… in othe words, it does not sustain
the uncertainty for other players. We might want to ‘cut’ the loops in a game in order
to balance it and sustain uncertainty.
EXERCISE:
“Monopoly contains one game-balance weakness: The point at which one player
becomes invincible due to the action of positive feedback is typically about an hour
before the last player goes bankrupt and the game actually ends.
Proposing changes to the rules that would speed up the action of positive feedback in
the later stages of the game without giving the first player who gets into the lead too
much of an advantage in the early stages.” Adams (2013; p.356)
47. Some possibilities I came up with:
1. To get more money when you pass the ‘Go’ when you already have houses on
your streets. This will allow you to build more houses,…
2. To get more money when you pass the ‘Go’ when you have streets from different
colors. This will allow you to buy more streets,…
3. To be able to modify the number of a dice roll by buying extra values to add or
subtract. Then, the richer could avoid or consolidate certain options.
48. SOLUTIONS:
1. To increase the positive feedback loop, so the game finishes faster.
2. To introduce a negative feedback loop. Negative feedback stabilizes the game by
disadvantaging the winners and providing extra help to the losers e.g. in some
sports, the team being scored can start from the middle controlling the ball (this
is a small negative feedback loop).
What is Mario Kart solution to sustain uncertainty?
49. “Games like Mario Kart take this a step further, offering pickups that are weighted so
that if you’re behind, you’re likely to get something that lets you catch up, while if
you’re ahead you’ll get something less valuable, making it harder for you to fight for
first. On the one hand, this provides an interesting tension: players in the lead know
that they just have to keep the lead for a little bit longer.” Schreiber
(gamebalanceconcepts.wordpress.org)
Picture from Mario Kart Double Dash
50. “Notice that Mario Kart has actually the same progression pattern as Catan: both
games have negative feedback to stop the positive feedback loop. And yet, it feels
very different as a player. I think this is mostly because in Catan, the negative
feedback is under player control, while in Mario Kart a lot of it is under computer
control.
In autoracing, there’s also a natural negative feedback loop, but it feels a lot more
fair: the person in the lead is running into a bunch of air resistance so they’re burning
extra fuel to maintain their high speed, which means they need more pit stops;
meanwhile, the people drafting behind them are much more fuel-efficient and can
take over the lead later.”
Instead in a sailing regatta, the wind creates a positive feedback loop. The sailing
boat in second position does not get as much wind as the one in the first…
51. Three more solutions in order to mitigate the effects of a positive feedback loop:
• Allow collusion against the leader. In games with three or more players, you can
write the rules in such a way that the other players can collaborate against the
player in the lead.
• Define victory in terms unrelated to the feedback cycle. If you define the victory
condition of your game explicitly in terms of player rewards, power, or success at
achievements that make up parts of the positive feedback cycle, then positive
feedback will hasten victory. But you can also define victory in other terms.
• Use the effects of chance to reduce the size of the player’s rewards. Role-playing
games do this to some degree by randomly varying the amount of loot that
enemies yield to the player when they are defeated. By occasionally giving players
a lower reward for their achievements, you slow down positive feedback.
There are several ways to counterbalance positive feedback loops so we can sustain
uncertainty for all players.
52. 6. Introducing non-skill actions in multiplayer games (PvP)
In a multiplayer, we have a core with high skills and we have a periphery with low skills.
PROBLEM: Core deserves to win, as they have higher skills, but noobs have no chance at
all, so they leave (no uncertainty).
53. SOLUTION: Decrease the required skills for a certain situation, in other words, create
some situations in which everybody can win.
• Example 1: Call of Duty 4 “noobtube”. Experienced players maybe put together
with inexperienced players. The only way to make the game both engaging for
both kind of players is to grant players with a lot of power for the low skill
required. This is the grenade launcher employed by n00bs of the highest calibre.
Veterans don’t use it as there are more powerful tactics available, but some new
players may take veterans out with this launcher. Even though people complain, it
plays an important rule in sustaining uncertainty.
• Example 2: headshots in many FPS. The idea here is that if you shoot someone in
the head rather than the rest of the body, it’s an instant kill, or something like
that. Now, you might be thinking... wait, isn’t that a skill thing? Yes, in some cases
that is true, depending on the game, but in a lot of games (especially older ones)
that kind of accuracy just really isn’t possible in most situations; you’re moving,
they’re moving,… but it may also happen “by accident”. Therefore, with
headshots, the weaker player will occasionally just get an automatic kill, so it
makes it more likely that the weaker player see some more success with general
lower skills.
54. Concluding remarks
1. Uncertainty is what attracts players into a game. Challenge
provides uncertainty, and randomness can also increase it.
2. Challenge and skill are two sides of the same coin. Its
relationship is even backed by psychology theory of Flow. We
need to increase the challenge to maintain attention.
3. There exist several ways to ‘sustain uncertainty’. As designers,
we first need to guarantee the right amount of initial challenge
for the target player; then we either increase this challenge level
manually or use dynamic challenge adjustment;
complementarily, we can design open worlds. In PvP, to sustain
uncertainty, we need to deal with positive feedback loops and
introduce non-skill based actions.
The next lesson will be dedicated to Player Equality.
55. The golden rule of player/gameplay balance
“The game should be fun to learn as well as to play, and it
should be more fun the more you master it."
Rollings and Morris (2003, p. 139)
56. Game Balance Course Selected References
• Adams, E. (2014). Fundamentals of game design. Pearson Education. Chapter 11.
• Adams, E., & Dormans, J. (2012). Game mechanics: advanced game design. Chapter 8.
• Costikyan, G. (2013). Uncertainty in games. Mit Press.
• Fields, T. (2014). Mobile & social game design: Monetization methods and mechanics. CRC
Press. Chapter 9.
• Fullerton, T. (2014). Game design workshop: a playcentric approach to creating innovative
games. CRC press. Chapter 10.
• Oxland, K. (2004). Gameplay and design. Pearson Education. Chapter 16.
• Schell, J. (2014). The Art of Game Design: A book of lenses. CRC Press. Chapters 10-11.
• Sylvester, T. (2013). Designing games: A guide to engineering experiences. " O'Reilly Media,
Inc.". Chapter 6.
• Rollings, A., & Morris, D. (2003). Game architecture and design: a new edition. Chapter 5.
• Selinker, M. (Ed.). (2011). The Kobold Guide to Board Game Design. Part 4.
• Schreiber, I. Game Design Concepts [https://gamedesignconcepts.wordpress.com] (Level 16).
• Schreiber, I. Game Balance Concepts [https://gamebalanceconcepts.wordpress.com].