The coronavirus pandemic led to a dramatic increase in the use of online learning tools and techniques across the globe as higher education providers moved to maintain teaching provision through lockdowns and social distancing requirements. Emergency Remote Teaching (ERT) required teaching staff to engage with new skills as online learning designers and tutors with unprecedented speed, whilst students were expected to equally quickly develop the skills to engage as fully online learners.
As the sector moved out of the remote phase of the pandemic, there has been a lively debate about what the lasting impact of this ‘crash course’ ERT experience might be on learning supported through the use of technologies. Up to now, however, much of the research attempting to take stock of the post-pandemic impact has been anecdotal and theoretical. There has been little empirical research and questions remain over how pandemic experiences might inform future practice and a sustainable use of learning technology.
This presentation reports on research undertaken at the University of York, exploring how experiences of ERT were carried forward into the academic years 2021-22 and 2022-23. Our study focused on the Departments of Psychology and Biology which took contrasting approaches to the development and delivery of post-pandemic provision. Through structured interviews with teaching leaders in each department, we explored the factors shaping decisions and we compared staff experiences of ERT and its legacy with the perceptions of students and their expectations for how learning technology should be used in the future.
In this presentation we provide an overview of the staff and student focus group findings which suggest that the impact of the pandemic itself was shaped as much by factors which were already in play when it emerged. To differing degrees and at different times, it served to both interrupt and accelerate progress in the integration of learning technologies within departmental learning, teaching and assessment approaches by:
• Changing attitudes and approaches to standardisation, and the management and organisation of teaching and use of learning technologies;
• Re-focusing attention on the importance of academic community building;
• Influencing the ways in which departments perceive student needs, preferences, and engagement patterns;
• Changing how they conceive of and deliver student support and inclusive learning and assessment practices in a flexible way, and the place of blended learning in these endeavours.
Transition Pedagogy and the PostGraduate Student ExperienceSally Kift
Presentation at National Postgraduate Student Experience Symposium https://postgraduatestudentexperience.com/
Kift, S. (2016). The First Year Postgraduate Experience. In National Postgraduate Student Experience Symposium, Bond University, Gold Coast. 7-8 April 2016.
How to engage students as individuals as they experience a personal intellectual journey, while systematically understanding and enhancing the quality of the learning environment at the level of the course, faculty and whole institution.
Transition Pedagogy and the PostGraduate Student ExperienceSally Kift
Presentation at National Postgraduate Student Experience Symposium https://postgraduatestudentexperience.com/
Kift, S. (2016). The First Year Postgraduate Experience. In National Postgraduate Student Experience Symposium, Bond University, Gold Coast. 7-8 April 2016.
How to engage students as individuals as they experience a personal intellectual journey, while systematically understanding and enhancing the quality of the learning environment at the level of the course, faculty and whole institution.
Research Informed Teaching Conference.Researching Teaching Practice to enhanc...Rajesh Dhimar
Research Informed Teaching Conference Presentation. Researching Teaching Practice to enhance the Student Experience – a Criminology Subject Perspective.
ABLE - the NTU Student Dashboard - University of DerbyEd Foster
implementing a university wide learning analytics system.
Presentation Overview:
- Introduction
- Developing the NTU Student Dashboard
- Transitioning from pilot phase to whole institution roll-out
- Embedding the resource into working practices
- Future development
Best Practices in Higher Education - Role of Commerce & Management Teachersgpsudhakaar
Workshop on Best Practices in Higher Education - Role of Commerce & Management Teachers for the Commerce and Teachers Association of the Women's University Vijayapura
QAA Modelling and Managing Student Satisfaction: Use of student feedback to ...Bart Rienties
To what extent are institutions using insights from NSS and institutional surveys to transform their students’ experience?
What are the key enablers and barriers for integrating student satisfaction data with QA and QE
How are student experiences influencing quality enhancements
What influences students’ perceptions of overall satisfaction the most? Are student characteristics or module/presentation related factors more predictive than satisfaction with other aspects of their learning experience?
Is the student cohort homogenous when considering satisfaction key drivers? For example are there systematic differences depending on the level or programme of study?
Developing sustainable staff development for online teachers: What works and ...RichardM_Walker
The Covid-19 pandemic has underlined the importance of online teaching within higher education and provided further encouragement to institutions to develop their fully online course provision - a trend which has been gathering pace over recent years. It has challenged universities and colleges to think about how they support their faculty in developing the competencies and strategies to teach effectively online.
Looking to the future, how do we support the continuous professional learning and development (CPLD) of online instructors, addressing the needs of both new and more experienced online practitioners, with equal attention to their pedagogical knowledge and technical skills development? What works and why within an online teaching context? In this presentation we will present a CPLD model that provides an overview of the different sources of learning development that are available to online instructors - both within and outside the teaching institution – and how they are interrelated and interconnected as part of a wider ecology of CPLD support to staff. We explain how these different sources of support may be combined to support personalised learning development pathways in online teaching practice, drawing on illustrations of evidence-based CPLD practices from staff developers and academics from across the world (Forbes & Walker, 2022).
Encouraging academic skills development through social reading: A critical re...RichardM_Walker
How can we encourage student engagement with their academic reading? What role can technology play for campus-based and online students in supporting their academic skills development? What solutions are available and how effective are they in supporting students?
These are some of the questions that are addressed in this cross-institutional study of social reading software, looking at the current market options (e.g. Talis Elevate, Leganto ‘Read and Respond’ and Hypothes.is) and the affordances of the supported technology.
Informed by pilot studies with Talis Elevate conducted over the autumn and spring terms (2021-22 academic year) at the University of Leicester, and market research by the University of York, we use this evidence-base to appraise the current state of the market - reporting on technical integration issues with reading lists and VLE platforms, as well as desired functionality to empower students to create and manage critical discussions around target resources, ranging from key texts to images, with scope to annotate key texts and resources online. We then go on to discuss the results of pilot studies with Talis Elevate, focusing on academic engagement strategies to help students make best use of the software to develop their academic reading skills, as well as practical issues related to copyright controls and permissions.
More Related Content
Similar to Evaluating the impact of the Pandemic on departmental uses of learning technology: A catalyst for change?
Research Informed Teaching Conference.Researching Teaching Practice to enhanc...Rajesh Dhimar
Research Informed Teaching Conference Presentation. Researching Teaching Practice to enhance the Student Experience – a Criminology Subject Perspective.
ABLE - the NTU Student Dashboard - University of DerbyEd Foster
implementing a university wide learning analytics system.
Presentation Overview:
- Introduction
- Developing the NTU Student Dashboard
- Transitioning from pilot phase to whole institution roll-out
- Embedding the resource into working practices
- Future development
Best Practices in Higher Education - Role of Commerce & Management Teachersgpsudhakaar
Workshop on Best Practices in Higher Education - Role of Commerce & Management Teachers for the Commerce and Teachers Association of the Women's University Vijayapura
QAA Modelling and Managing Student Satisfaction: Use of student feedback to ...Bart Rienties
To what extent are institutions using insights from NSS and institutional surveys to transform their students’ experience?
What are the key enablers and barriers for integrating student satisfaction data with QA and QE
How are student experiences influencing quality enhancements
What influences students’ perceptions of overall satisfaction the most? Are student characteristics or module/presentation related factors more predictive than satisfaction with other aspects of their learning experience?
Is the student cohort homogenous when considering satisfaction key drivers? For example are there systematic differences depending on the level or programme of study?
Developing sustainable staff development for online teachers: What works and ...RichardM_Walker
The Covid-19 pandemic has underlined the importance of online teaching within higher education and provided further encouragement to institutions to develop their fully online course provision - a trend which has been gathering pace over recent years. It has challenged universities and colleges to think about how they support their faculty in developing the competencies and strategies to teach effectively online.
Looking to the future, how do we support the continuous professional learning and development (CPLD) of online instructors, addressing the needs of both new and more experienced online practitioners, with equal attention to their pedagogical knowledge and technical skills development? What works and why within an online teaching context? In this presentation we will present a CPLD model that provides an overview of the different sources of learning development that are available to online instructors - both within and outside the teaching institution – and how they are interrelated and interconnected as part of a wider ecology of CPLD support to staff. We explain how these different sources of support may be combined to support personalised learning development pathways in online teaching practice, drawing on illustrations of evidence-based CPLD practices from staff developers and academics from across the world (Forbes & Walker, 2022).
Encouraging academic skills development through social reading: A critical re...RichardM_Walker
How can we encourage student engagement with their academic reading? What role can technology play for campus-based and online students in supporting their academic skills development? What solutions are available and how effective are they in supporting students?
These are some of the questions that are addressed in this cross-institutional study of social reading software, looking at the current market options (e.g. Talis Elevate, Leganto ‘Read and Respond’ and Hypothes.is) and the affordances of the supported technology.
Informed by pilot studies with Talis Elevate conducted over the autumn and spring terms (2021-22 academic year) at the University of Leicester, and market research by the University of York, we use this evidence-base to appraise the current state of the market - reporting on technical integration issues with reading lists and VLE platforms, as well as desired functionality to empower students to create and manage critical discussions around target resources, ranging from key texts to images, with scope to annotate key texts and resources online. We then go on to discuss the results of pilot studies with Talis Elevate, focusing on academic engagement strategies to help students make best use of the software to develop their academic reading skills, as well as practical issues related to copyright controls and permissions.
Building community through Slack: a student-owned digital space for connectiv...RichardM_Walker
This presentation discusses an institutional approach to the development of a digital learning community for students participating on our fully online study programmes at the University of York. Our approach was based on the use of a team-based environment Slack as a ‘third space’ for interaction - i.e. an institutionally owned platform which students were invited to control and manage as their own space to support their own networking and community activities.
Inclusive learning design for Online LearnersRichardM_Walker
This talk reflects on the key lessons learned from the University of York’s teaching experience during the pandemic, addressing flexible design and delivery of teaching to support the needs of a fragmented student, located on campus and off site / overseas across different time zones.
It recounts how we have refreshed our inclusive learning strategies in the light of the pivot to online learning delivery.
Nurturing curiosity and inquiry within the curriculum through the use of tech...RichardM_Walker
How may we engage students in inquiry-led and problem-based learning through the use of technology? In this presentation we will consider how active learning principles can be applied to the design of blended learning courses, with digital tools employed to support active learning opportunities for our students. Through a presentation of case examples from the University of York (United Kingdom), we will consider how blended activities can encourage participants to engage in creative learning and problem-solving. An engagement model for active learning, derived from the case examples, is presented as a stimulus for a broader discussion on effective design approaches to support student-led inquiry and problem-solving activities.
Peer-led group learning as a variation of collaborative learning has become widely adopted in science, technology, engineering and mathematics disciplines as a way of supporting research tasks and the development of problem-solving skills. This learning approach is based on ‘small groups of students meeting regularly with a peer – one who has additional expertise in the subject matter – to work on problems collaboratively’ (Pazos, Micari & Light, 2009).
This presentation explores how peer-led group learning was introduced to a third-year undergraduate module for Biology students (international, mixed gender) undertaking extended project work in microbial annotation.
Although the students were engaged in individual projects, meeting on a regular weekly cycle to discuss progress with their facilitator, they were encouraged to work collaboratively in the performance of their research using a centrally- supported virtual collaborative environment – Slack – for the duration of the module, drawing on the expertise of the peer expert as required. Slack was presented to students as a hub to share ideas / findings and to raise questions for the attention of the peer expert and the wider project group.
Bridging the digital divide: academic skills and digital literacies to suppor...RichardM_Walker
This presentation reflects on recent developments in the adoption of technology enhanced learning (TEL) tools within the UK higher education sector - in particular the rise of student-controlled and creative technologies to promote information, knowledge-sharing and networking in learning and teaching activities. Current generations of students are now arriving on campus with the expectation that their technologies will seamlessly interconnect with university services and support a flexible and personalised learning experience - engaging them in collaborative knowledge creation activities and developing their learning as producers of ‘content’ (Generation ‘C’). Drawing on the most recent sector-wide research (Jisc, 2017; UCISA 2018), this paper discusses the impact of these technological developments on academic practice – specifically the scope that learning technologies now present for innovation in the delivery of the taught curriculum.
How are students engaging with lecture recordings as a study resource?RichardM_Walker
This presentation reports on a 4-year study of lecture capture at the University of York (UK), focusing on the student learning experience of accessing and using recordings of lectures to support out-of- class learning. The presentation summarises the headline findings and discusses what this all means for institutional support to students and academic staff in teaching and learning activities.
Facilitating student-led teaching and content creation through technology: Us...RichardM_Walker
User-led design reflects a paradigm shift in pedagogic practice, re-envisioning the role of students as producers rather than consumers of learning. Implicit in this design approach is an acknowledgement that students have the skills and capability to engage in collaborative knowledge creation activities and to develop their learning as producers of content.
Through a presentation of case examples, we report on how user-led principles have been applied to the design of blended learning courses at the University of York (United Kingdom), with learning technology employed to support active learning opportunities for our students. The blended courses each incorporated activities encouraging participants to develop their own learning and teaching resources, engaging them in the mastery of key skills and concepts. We present an engagement model for active learning derived from the case examples, and use this as a stimulus for a broader discussion on effective design approaches to support student-led teaching and content creation activities.
We then go on to discuss the instructional responsibilities associated with the successful delivery of student-led activities within blended courses. Research tells us that instructional support for online learning requires differing strategies to facilitate effective group learning and participant-led activities and can lead to instructors assuming different roles in their online interactions with students. Reflecting on the case studies, we discuss common challenges that instructors may face in the design of student-led activities and present strategies for the effective delivery of student-led teaching and content creation activities, based on a five-stage blended delivery model that has been used to guide academic staff at the University of York.
Facilitating staff to design in active learning opportunities for students th...RichardM_Walker
This presentation reflects on the approach that we are taking at the University of York to help teaching staff consider how the affordances of learning technologies may be applied to support active learning opportunities for students within programme design. We consider how learning technologies may support student work across various modes of engagement, ranging from interleaved practice (formative assessment) to student-led teaching and content creation.
Open and flexible learning opportunities for all? Findings from the 2016 UCIS...RichardM_Walker
This presentation summarises the headline findings from the UCISA 2016 Survey of Technology Enhanced Learning, which tracks developments in the use of learning technologies across the UK higher education sector. In this year's Survey, special attention was directed to open learning activities, ranging from open course provision to badges and open accreditation methods for staff development. The Survey question-set also addressed learner analytics in greater depth than in past Surveys, with a focus on the different types of tool-sets which institutions are using and their deployment across courses. Respondents were invited to comment on how their institution is making use of analytics to evaluate the impact of TEL tools on the student learning experience and what this means for academic practice.
Developing tutoring craft through cross-institutional peer exchange: reflecti...RichardM_Walker
This paper reports on outcomes from a cross-institutional peer observation programme for distance learning tutors - a joint initiative between the Universities of York (UK) and Waikato (New Zealand) - launched for the first time in 2015. The programme was conducted fully online and offered an opportunity for tutors from different institutions and national teaching contexts to address challenges in their practice and share innovations in online tutoring techniques. Participants were paired up and encouraged to collaborate through use of synchronous discussion tools and the mutual sharing of course sites within their institutional LMS platforms.
Evaluation of the participant experience revealed that the cultural and institutional differences between York and Waikato tutors were not insurmountable obstacles to effective peer exchange online and could be minimised through adequate preparation up front in defining respective programme cultures and ways of working. Partners who mastered this ‘norming’ phase in their relationship were able to move beyond agreed objectives for the observations to address deeper pedagogic discussions, challenging their views on institutional norms to assessment design and online support for student learning. Emergent themes for discussion between partners ranged from the merits of actively managing student learning online to the formality and tone of the tutor’s voice, focusing on language and modes of interactions with students. The study highlights the potential of cross-institutional peer observation to shine a light on institutional and personal ‘blind spots’ in tutoring techniques, stimulating deeper personal reflection on tutor identity and related strategies in managing student learning online.
This paper summarises recent findings from UCISA case study and survey research on the pace of change in the institutional adoption of technology enhanced learning tools across the UK higher education sector, and will address the rise of student-controlled and creative technologies to promote information, knowledge-sharing and networking in learning and teaching activities. Current generations of students are now arriving on campus with the expectation that their technologies will seamlessly interconnect with university services and support their learning experience. The paper discusses the impact these technological developments are having on the delivery of campus-based courses – specifically the scope that learning technologies now present for innovation in the delivery of the taught curriculum. Through a presentation of case examples from the University of York we consider how the affordances of mobile and online learning technologies are being applied to support active learning opportunities for students.
Engaging learners in computer-based summative exams: Reflections on a partici...RichardM_Walker
This presentation discusses a participant-informed design approach to high stakes computer-based testing for postgraduate students in a research methods module at the University of York. The combined feedback from students has informed the development of an engagement framework to guide instructors in preparing students to perform successfully in computer-based exams, addressing the organisational and cognitive strategies that they need to master.
Enhancing the assessment experience through closer integration between the SR...RichardM_Walker
Presentation on the customisation of the University of York's institutional virtual learning environment to support an anonymous e-marking workflow, based on closer integration with the student records system.
Achieving flexibility? The rhetoric and reality of the role of learning techn...RichardM_Walker
ascilite 2014 presentation on findings from the UCISA 2014 Technology Enhanced Learning Survey. The presentation explores the role of learning technologies in supporting flexibility in higher education learning and teaching.
Synthetic Fiber Construction in lab .pptxPavel ( NSTU)
Synthetic fiber production is a fascinating and complex field that blends chemistry, engineering, and environmental science. By understanding these aspects, students can gain a comprehensive view of synthetic fiber production, its impact on society and the environment, and the potential for future innovations. Synthetic fibers play a crucial role in modern society, impacting various aspects of daily life, industry, and the environment. ynthetic fibers are integral to modern life, offering a range of benefits from cost-effectiveness and versatility to innovative applications and performance characteristics. While they pose environmental challenges, ongoing research and development aim to create more sustainable and eco-friendly alternatives. Understanding the importance of synthetic fibers helps in appreciating their role in the economy, industry, and daily life, while also emphasizing the need for sustainable practices and innovation.
Instructions for Submissions thorugh G- Classroom.pptxJheel Barad
This presentation provides a briefing on how to upload submissions and documents in Google Classroom. It was prepared as part of an orientation for new Sainik School in-service teacher trainees. As a training officer, my goal is to ensure that you are comfortable and proficient with this essential tool for managing assignments and fostering student engagement.
The Art Pastor's Guide to Sabbath | Steve ThomasonSteve Thomason
What is the purpose of the Sabbath Law in the Torah. It is interesting to compare how the context of the law shifts from Exodus to Deuteronomy. Who gets to rest, and why?
How to Create Map Views in the Odoo 17 ERPCeline George
The map views are useful for providing a geographical representation of data. They allow users to visualize and analyze the data in a more intuitive manner.
How to Make a Field invisible in Odoo 17Celine George
It is possible to hide or invisible some fields in odoo. Commonly using “invisible” attribute in the field definition to invisible the fields. This slide will show how to make a field invisible in odoo 17.
Read| The latest issue of The Challenger is here! We are thrilled to announce that our school paper has qualified for the NATIONAL SCHOOLS PRESS CONFERENCE (NSPC) 2024. Thank you for your unwavering support and trust. Dive into the stories that made us stand out!
Palestine last event orientationfvgnh .pptxRaedMohamed3
An EFL lesson about the current events in Palestine. It is intended to be for intermediate students who wish to increase their listening skills through a short lesson in power point.
The Roman Empire A Historical Colossus.pdfkaushalkr1407
The Roman Empire, a vast and enduring power, stands as one of history's most remarkable civilizations, leaving an indelible imprint on the world. It emerged from the Roman Republic, transitioning into an imperial powerhouse under the leadership of Augustus Caesar in 27 BCE. This transformation marked the beginning of an era defined by unprecedented territorial expansion, architectural marvels, and profound cultural influence.
The empire's roots lie in the city of Rome, founded, according to legend, by Romulus in 753 BCE. Over centuries, Rome evolved from a small settlement to a formidable republic, characterized by a complex political system with elected officials and checks on power. However, internal strife, class conflicts, and military ambitions paved the way for the end of the Republic. Julius Caesar’s dictatorship and subsequent assassination in 44 BCE created a power vacuum, leading to a civil war. Octavian, later Augustus, emerged victorious, heralding the Roman Empire’s birth.
Under Augustus, the empire experienced the Pax Romana, a 200-year period of relative peace and stability. Augustus reformed the military, established efficient administrative systems, and initiated grand construction projects. The empire's borders expanded, encompassing territories from Britain to Egypt and from Spain to the Euphrates. Roman legions, renowned for their discipline and engineering prowess, secured and maintained these vast territories, building roads, fortifications, and cities that facilitated control and integration.
The Roman Empire’s society was hierarchical, with a rigid class system. At the top were the patricians, wealthy elites who held significant political power. Below them were the plebeians, free citizens with limited political influence, and the vast numbers of slaves who formed the backbone of the economy. The family unit was central, governed by the paterfamilias, the male head who held absolute authority.
Culturally, the Romans were eclectic, absorbing and adapting elements from the civilizations they encountered, particularly the Greeks. Roman art, literature, and philosophy reflected this synthesis, creating a rich cultural tapestry. Latin, the Roman language, became the lingua franca of the Western world, influencing numerous modern languages.
Roman architecture and engineering achievements were monumental. They perfected the arch, vault, and dome, constructing enduring structures like the Colosseum, Pantheon, and aqueducts. These engineering marvels not only showcased Roman ingenuity but also served practical purposes, from public entertainment to water supply.
This is a presentation by Dada Robert in a Your Skill Boost masterclass organised by the Excellence Foundation for South Sudan (EFSS) on Saturday, the 25th and Sunday, the 26th of May 2024.
He discussed the concept of quality improvement, emphasizing its applicability to various aspects of life, including personal, project, and program improvements. He defined quality as doing the right thing at the right time in the right way to achieve the best possible results and discussed the concept of the "gap" between what we know and what we do, and how this gap represents the areas we need to improve. He explained the scientific approach to quality improvement, which involves systematic performance analysis, testing and learning, and implementing change ideas. He also highlighted the importance of client focus and a team approach to quality improvement.
Overview on Edible Vaccine: Pros & Cons with Mechanism
Evaluating the impact of the Pandemic on departmental uses of learning technology: A catalyst for change?
1. ALT Conference 2023
Presentation 55: Wednesday 6th September
Evaluating the impact of the
Pandemic on departmental
uses of learning technology:
A catalyst for change?
Rob Shaw and Richard Walker
Digital Education Team, University of York
2. Contents
● The research questions and focus
of the study
● Research approach and methods
○ Staff
○ Students
○ Analysis
● Headline results
○ Department approaches
○ Ongoing impacts
○ Students
● Conclusions
● Implications
3. The research questions
● How did experiences of Emergency Remote Teaching
impact on approaches to learning, teaching and
assessment in two departments at the University of
York?
● What sustainable practices have been carried forward
and incorporated into programme delivery?
4. Focus of the study
● Comparative analysis of two departments (Sciences Faculty):
Biology and Psychology. Focus on UG level.
● Both have large UG cohorts with BSc and Integrated Masters
programmes (Bio n = approx. 1400; Psy = 700)
● Biology greater range of programmes and pathways
● Both have a record of T&L excellence (NSS; Subject TEF)
6. Research approach
● Exploratory case study
● Insights into decision making processes, experiences and perceptions
● Staff and students
● Comparative approach built on detailed insights from a small sample
● Qualitative case study approach prioritising ‘intensiveness’ over
‘extensiveness’ (Thomas, 2011)
7. The methods - staff
● Semi-structured interviews and focus groups with teaching leaders:
○ How did you design and deliver teaching and assessment in the 2021-22 and 2022-23
academic years?
○ How was this influenced by experiences during the remote teaching phases of the
pandemic?
○ What has worked well? / What has been challenging?
○ What are your views on student experiences, attitudes and preferences?
● 5 staff members
● Biology: 1 x professor; 2 x Senior lecturers
● Psychology: 1 x professor; 1 x Senior lecturer
● 4.5 hrs of discussion; 42,030 words
8. The methods - students
● Semi-structured interviews or focus groups with UG students
● On-campus or via Zoom depending on preference, but the same
interview/focus group structure was used:
○ Experiences of learning, teaching and assessment during the pandemic
○ Experiences since the pandemic (positive and less positive elements, on-campus and
online elements of studies, assessment methods)
○ Recommendations for the future
● ~6.5 hrs of discussion; ~57,000 words
10. ● Interview/focus group data transcribed and initial thematic analysis
completed separately
● Core themes and sub-themes identified and agreed
● NVIVO used to carry out coding and support final thematic analysis
Staff
○ Governance / teaching organisation: 31.2%
○ Influences on teaching practice: 18.4%
○ T&L during the pandemic: 15.6%
○ Flexible teaching delivery: 12.5%
○ Student support strategies: 12.1%
○ Assessment strategies: 7.6%
○ Others 2.6%
Students
○ Attitudes to/experiences of course design
and delivery: 57.2%
○ Assessment: 17.3%
○ Study skills / Approaches to learning and
assessment: 17%
○ Attitudes to/experiences of students
support strategies: 8.4%
The methods - Analysis
11. The pandemic impacted on approaches within the departments differently, arriving at
a moment in which they were on contrasting trajectories in terms of organisation of
teaching and learning, standardisation and blended learning.
Headline results: Dept. approaches
Psychology
I think our understanding of students and kind of
what they want is maybe more forward thinking
than it used to be. Yeah. But I think the teaching
and the assessment is quite traditional in its
design. Yeah. But it works for us and we've not
had any major issues with it. So yeah. Why would
you change it?
Biology
I think everybody's learnt that consistency is a really
good thing for lots of different reasons. So the students
appreciate it, but staff also appreciate it
I don’t think we had ever done that thing where we were
looking at what students were doing, not just on the
timetable but off the timetable… And then you think,
well, actually, you can plan all of this
12. For both departments, the pandemic acted as a catalyst for greater use of learning
technologies, particularly in support of increased interactivity in on-campus sessions
and more consistent, organised and explicit use of VLE sites. It also led to lasting
changes in assessment methods in both departments (though more extensive for Bio),
and increased flexibility in approaches to supervision meetings
Headline results: Ongoing impacts
I think assessments have been transformed for
sure. We’ve got less of them. We've got more
support towards the specific type of assessment
that students are going to get in different modules.
… they're all online open book, (which) stresses
the comprehension, understanding and
application. So definitely from the assessment
perspective, I think we're in a very different place
and we're not going back. (Biology SL)
We do seem to have that flexibility. For some sessions
where it might be a lot easier for students just to jump on
to Zoom or whatever. For those quick sort of hour
meetings where it's just touching base with them,
offering them a Q&A session or feedback on something.
(Psychology SL)
13. ● Even in a small sample, experiences and preferences are complex and varied, with different
approaches to study and engagement, and different thoughts on learning.
● Despite some variety in personal assessment preferences, students were typically positive about
open assessment and its suitability for HE as a more authentic and applied form of assessment.
● The increased flexibility of online recordings acted as ‘both a blessing and a curse’ allowing for
engagement to suit preferences but leading to excessive time spent reviewing content. Study
skills impacted by experiences as well as confidence levels and perceptions of support needs.
Headline results: Students
I think definitely the quality of my exams is far
better than what it would have been had we not
had the pandemic ... I personally learnt a lot of
skills and felt that I was being examined more
appropriately for what the uni degree is, but also
moving forward into the world of work and how
things would be there.
It's given me an opportunity to experiment a bit more
because what works for me kind of GCSE to A-levels
doesn't always work for me here. Sometimes it does and
it's great and I can use that. Yeah, but it's having an
adaptability that, okay, if I can't use this set of note
taking, I'll use this instead and having those options to
flick and change. So yeah, that's been quite handy to be
able to develop those skills.
14. ● Attitudes to lectures & small-group sessions, and the relationships between
them are complex and mixed.
● In both lectures and workshops, students value interaction and learning
designs that make the most of connections between them.
● Flexibility is valued (e.g. in flipped learning design) but guidance and
scaffolding are seen as essential. Without this, flexibility can rapidly become
problematic and lead to students falling behind and either not attending
workshops, or attending but struggling.
● Students felt a need for more structured feedback opportunities both from a
‘formative assessment’ perspective, but also in terms of ongoing support and
feedback as they progress through modules.
Headline results: Students
15. ● The pandemic has brought longer–term change but shaped by pre-
pandemic trajectories, e.g.
○ Technology uptake and usage;
○ Standardisation and organisation;
○ Focus and delivery of assessment.
● Students experience tensions between flexibility and structure which are
visible in both departments in terms of:
○ Study skills and workload issues;
○ Perceptions of interaction and feedback (scaffolding v independence);
○ Confidence in study methods and requirements for support.
Conclusions
16. ● Whether returning to ‘normal’ with large lectures or pressing on with increased use
of blended/flipped approaches, learning design is crucial in establishing an
appropriate balance between flexibility and structure/scaffolding.
● To realise the potential benefits of increased flexibility, teaching and
communication approaches that look to develop and sustain positive learning
attitudes (e.g. autonomy, confidence and relatedness) appear to be important.
● There are clear implications for staff support and resources (e.g.
to sustain an increased commitment to learning design, feedback loops, support
and structure).
● Skills support may also need greater attention to assist students in effectively
moving between study modes and making the most of the potential of flexibility
while minimising challenges.
Implications
17. “For digital learning - whether in a blended, hybrid, or online form - a number of
institutional, organisational and administrative factors condition the more proximal
influences on the teacher and student level, which then shape the effectiveness
of teaching and learning… Institutional, teacher and learner expectations must be
aligned in a way that allows time and effort to be dedicated to careful course design, if
results of design are to be meaningful.” (Rapanta et al., 2021)
“While there is no one-size-fits-all solution to meet the needs of all students, there is a
clear imperative for faculty to listen sensitively to students to ascertain their needs via
clear and regular communication. When students feel overwhelmed, they may not
necessarily proactively seek support. Beneficial teaching approaches are important as
they provide clear direction for faculty to support students’ autonomy, competence,
and relatedness needs.” (Hartnett et al., 2023)
Final thoughts
19. ● Hartnett, M. et al. (2023) ‘Enhanced or diminished attitudes: University
students’ agency’, Computers & Education, 198.
● Rapanta, C. et al. (2021) ‘Balancing Technology, Pedagogy and the New
Normal: Post-pandemic Challenges for Higher Education’, Postdigital
Science and Education, 3(3), pp. 715–742.
● Thomas, G. (2011) A typology for the case study in social science following
a review of definition, discourse and structure. Qualitative enquiry, 17(6).
References