An overview type of presentation on energy efficiency of telecommunication networks indicating which approaches are more effective than the others. Also pointed out that different actors in the system optimize different optimization problems of energy consumption.

1. Click to edit Master subtitle style
8th
JIEEEC
Amman,
Jordan
17 April 2013
Pavel Loskot
p.loskot@swan.ac.uk

2. 2/32
•
April 2008 workshops defined 2 targets:
•
identify cross-layer techniques to obtain 100x energy reduction
•
identify green network architecture including backhaul
Green Radio project (Jan. 2009 – June 2012)

3. 3/32
Why and How of Green Communications
1. Initial considerations
2. Statistics and observations
3. Metrics and measurements
4. Approaches and solutions
5. Future trends

4. 4/32
Why and how of Green communications
1. Initial considerations
2. Statistics and observations
3. Metrics and measurements
4. Approaches and solutions
5. Future trends

5. 5/32
Green comms – first look
•
energy together with information is one of the most complex and
fundamental subjects
1) Primary contributors to CO2
emissions:
•
electric power generation, transport, manufacturing
•
ICT accounts for only 3% (electronics in household 5%)
2) Rising fuel cost:
•
Base Stations in Radio Access Network (RAN) consumes 80% of
total energy of cellular systems
•
total energy bill to operate RAN represents only 7% of total cost
Why to bother with energy efficiency then?

6. 6/32
Green comms – main motivations
•
Growth of wireless access:
•
from 3.3mil BS in 2007 to 11.2mil BS in 2020
with energy consumption from 49TWh to 98TWh
with average data rate from 60kbit/s to 18Mbit/s
•
i.e., energy cost from 28 J/kbits to mere 0.2 J/kbits
Future wireless access has to
be a lot more energy efficient!

7. 7/32
Green comms – resource management
Spectrum
•
shared resource
•
strictly limited
•
one-off cost
•
generate income
Energy
•
shared resource
•
unlimited (almost)
•
recurring cost
•
eat profits

8. 8/32
Energy consumption – first look

9. 9/32
Why and how of Green communications
1. Initial considerations
2. Statistics and observations
3. Metrics and measurements
4. Approaches and solutions
5. Future trends

10. 10/32
RAN – operational energy
life time: 10-15 yrs 1-1.5 yrs

11. 11/32
Base station – money matters
•
Return-on-Investment (ROI)
•
Take-up rate

12. 12/32
Base station – power budget
•
overall efficiency < 10%
•
total power 600-800W (GSM), 300-500W (WCDMA)
with typical 10W per channel/sector

13. 13/32
Cellular networks – traffic trends
•
majority of traffic indoors
•
strong spatial and temporal variations
(e.g. urban areas, hotspots, time of day)
•
mobile broadband rapidly growing

14. 14/32
Green comms – market drivers
•
Developed countries:
•
good infrastructure
•
almost saturated
•
bottleneck is QoS and
inbuilding coverage
•
key to improve profits
•
Emerging countries:
•
less infrastructure
•
good growth opportunities
•
large geographical areas
•
bottleneck is power supply
•
key is energy efficiency

15. 15/32
Why and how of Green communications
1. Initial considerations
2. Statistics and observations
3. Metrics and measurements
4. Approaches and solutions
5. Future trends

16. 16/32
Energy consumption – modeling

17. 17/32
Energy consumption – modeling
•
Power states: power consumption when
• transmitting Ptx
• receiving Prx
• iddle Piddle
• sleep Psleep
Rule of thumb:
•
the smaller the node, the smaller differences between
power state values
• for marcrocell base station, may consider only Ptx

18. 18/32
Energy – measurements
•
1. Energy metrics
•
what quantities to report (peak, average, effective values)
•
equipment or whole sub-systems
•
2. Measurement procedures
•
methodology, conditions, vendor-neutral
•
Standardization efforts:
•
European Telecommunications Standards Institute (ETSI)
•
Alliance for Telecommunications Industry Solutions (ATIS)
•
International Telecommunication Union (ITU)
•
Energy Consumption Rating (ECR) Initiative

19. 19/32
Energy – metrics
•
Energy Consumption Rating
•
Energy Efficiency Rate
•
Telecommunications Energy Efficiency Ratio (ATIS)
•
ITU metrics

20. 20/32
Energy metrics – Radio Access Networks
•
Energy Consumption Rate
•
Energy Reduction Gain
•
Energy Consumption Gain

21. 21/32
Why and how of Green communications
1. Initial considerations
2. Statistics and observations
3. Metrics and measurements
4. Approaches and solutions
5. Future trends

22. 22/32
Energy efficiency – improvements
1) Reduce transmission distances
•
small cells (pico, femto …) with macrocell overlays
•
distributed antennas, mesh architectures
•
relays and other cooperative transmissions
•
•
2) Use spectrum more efficiently
•
reduce interference (e.g. coordinated mutipoint)
3) Sleep modes
•
turn off components or whole nodes
•
modify protocols (e.g. MAC)

23. 23/32
Energy efficiency – improvements
4) Shape traffic
•
incentives for energy efficient behavior
5) Improve hardware
•
BS design (Power Amp, Cooling, Remote Radio Heads)
•
lower switching times (for sleep modes)
6) Concentrate traffic
•
to smaller sub-networks (e.g. shared base stations)
•
to smaller time epochs (e.g. delay agile traffic)
Transmit as fast as possible!

24. 24/32
Green comms – green baseband
•
Integrated circuits (IC):
•
power proportional to silicon area
•
area proportional to throughput
•
throughput proportional to bandwidth
•
Making IC greener:
•
functions reuse (reduce area)
•
turn more SW into hardware
(sacrifice flexibility)
•
Ultimately:
•
replace semiconductors

25. 25/32
Telecom equipment – powering
•
Alternative energy sources
•
need to be used continuously
•
lack of integration
•
lack of remote monitoring
•
onerous deployment

26. 26/32
Battery lifetime – drivers
•
Wireless sensor networks:
•
driving Internet of Things and initially
also techniques for Green Comms
•
improving battery lifetime is key
•
energy harvesting
•
Mobile handsets:
•
battery lifetime less important
•
transceivers may be very
energy inefficient
•
New technologies

27. 27/32
Why and how of Green communications
1. Initial considerations
2. Statistics and observations
3. Metrics and measurements
4. Approaches and solutions
5. Future trends

28. 28/32
Green comms – main players
Overall energy
strategic priorities
Spectrum and
max RF powers,
total energy
Max embodied energy,
max operational energy
Coverage and QoS,
energy per bit
Coverage and QoS,
battery lifetime
Operational energy
RF power

29. 29/32
Green comms – conflicts of interest
max RF
powers
min operational
energy
limit RF
powers
max battery life max QoS
min overall
energy
limit RF powers
min embodied
energy
min operational
energy
min RF
powers
min RF powers

30. 30/32
Green comms – future
•
Policies and regulations
•
trade energy in transport for energy in ICT
•
cooperation among network operators
•
define how much ICT services
•
ICT as utility
•
new business models
•
incentives for energy efficiency
•
highly flexible (adaptive)
•
selective availability, beyond best effort
•
Hardware to lead signal processing
•
batteries, power amplifiers, plastic electronics
•

31. 31/32
Green comms – concluding remarks
•
Energy minimization
•
holistic approach is mandatory
•
how to align aims of all players is still unclear
•
Publications
•
energy issues is more art than science, papers written by
industrial practitioners more impressive than by academics
•
Standards
•
energy consumption strongly related to implementation, yet
all standards abstract from implementation
For now, it is profits not energy what drives telecom industry!

32. 32/32
Thank you!
Questions?