EARTH HISTORY 2
Changes in Atmosphere
ppt. by Robin D. Seamon
CLIMATE VARIABLES
VIDEO: Ian Stewart ‘Atmosphere’ (50 min)
It’s all connected! Changes in one affects the other:
CLIMATE CHANGES
Atmosphere: gas layer of the earth; it’s where
weather happens
Climate: weather patterns shown over time
** if the atmosphere changes so does the climate**
QUESTION: What creates change
in climate?
ANSWER: Changes in atmosphere
1. Biotic processes (life) **
• Respiration: breathing in/out O and CO
• Transpiration: release of H 0 and CO
• Waste products
• Recycling of gases after death
2 2
2 2
• Life affects gas cycles:
• Carbon Cycle
• Water Cycle
• Cloud formation
• Weathering
EXAMPLE:
2.4 bya The Great Oxidation Event (put oxygen into
atmosphere)
http://guardianlv.com/2014/02/australian-crystal-found-is-4-4-billion-years-old/
2. Variations in solar radiation
• amount affects photosynthesis, precipitation,
wind patterns, temperature (AFFECTS LIFE)
• Sun has cycles of solar
storms (flares) & sun
spots which could
affect earth & it’s life
EXAMPLE: 1550-1850
Little Ice Age
Thames River: HENDRICK AVERCAMP'S LITTLE ICE AGE VIDEO: CC 4- Climate change, chaos & little Ice Age (10 min)
3. Plate tectonics
• shape of the
continents determine
ocean & wind
currents
• How heat is
transferred
• How much moisture
http://www.bgs.ac.uk/discoveringGeology/climateChange/general/causes.html?src=topNav
EXAMPLES:
• Mountains vs. plains
• Large continent vs. several smaller ones
• Connection of two continents block off
ocean currents- Isthmus of Panama
• IN PAST- tectonic movement caused big storage
of Carbon- fossil fuels
TODAY: Coal mines
Carboniferous Era
VIDEO: Formation of Fossil Fuels (2:30)
4. Volcanic eruptions & LIPs
• spew gases into the atmosphere-
changes chemistry (LIFE)
http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-asia-29399306
Mt Ontake
9/27/2014
• LIP- large igneous provinces
Places where igneous large rock beds indicate a
flow of lava from cracks in the crust
• Can block out sunlight, preventing
photosynthesis
(LIFE)
• Meteor induced
http://news.nationalgeographic.com/news/2013/13/130212--chicxulub-asteroid-dinosaurs-volcano-mass-extinction-
environment-science/
VIDEO: Large Igneous Province formation (2:00)
MODERN EXAMPLES:
1815 Mt. Tambora: Year without a Summer
1991: Mt. Pinatubo: global temp down 0.9˚F for 3
yrs
5. Cryosphere: ice layer
http://www.toppforskningsinitiativet.org/en/programmer-1/program-2
http://rramu0153.wordpress.com/
• During ice ages, sea levels are lower
• water/run-off is trapped in ice
• not in water cycle = DRIER
VIDEO NASA Sea Ice 2008 (3:00)
• Albedo: amount of ice affects temperature:
• more ice: more sunlight is reflected back
off Earth
• less ice: Earth absorbs more solar Energy
• Carbon sink: ice keeps dead organisms from
decomposing (more carbon) is absorbed than
released
http://www.earthgauge.net/2011/system-dynamics
6. Milankovitch Cycle variation in intensity of
sunlight due to slight variation in Earth’s orbit
• Pace setter for cycles of warming & cooling
http://www.bgs.ac.uk/discoveringGeology/climateChange/ge
neral/causes.html?src=topNav
http://www.southwestclimatechan
ge.org/figures/milankovitch
Orbital shape:
(eccentricity)
Earth’s orbit changes
from it’s elliptical
shape; 100,000 yrs
Orbital axis
wobble:
Changes in tilt
causes strength of
seasons
20,000- 40,000 yrs
VIDEO: Orbital Forcing (1 min)
7. Greenhouse Gases
• More greenhouse gases = thicker blanket,
holding in solar radiation (warmer)
• Fewer greenhouse gases = thinner blanket,
trapping less solar radiation= (cooler)
http://www.ib.bioninja.com.au/standard-level/topic-5-ecology-and-
evoluti/52-the-greenhouse-effect.html
• Natural Causes
• Cold oceans absorb CO
• Warm oceans release CO
• CH (methane) from decay
2
2
4
• Human contributions
• Release of carbon into the air through
burning of fossil fuels & cement manufacture
increases the greenhouse layer
• Aerosol increase (tiny particles in
atmosphere)
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Climate_change#mediaviewer/Fil
e:NSFmonsoonsandclimatesince200AD.jpg
Human civilizations affected by
climate changes:
VIDEO 2: 300 yrs of fossil fuels in 300 sec (5:30)
VIDEO 1: Climate 101 with Bill Nye (4:30)
CO2 carbon dioxide
CH4 methane
H2O water
C O
1 2
C H
1 4
H O
2 1
1 carbon
atom, 2
oxygen atoms
1 carbon
atom, 4
hydrogen
atoms
2 hydrogen
atoms, 1
oxygen atom
PALEOCLIMATOLOGY
-study of ancient climate
How do scientists measure atmosphere from earlier in
Earth’s history?
Radiometric Dating in:
Rocks & sediment
• Sea floor cores
composition &
past temperature
• Loess composition
& past temperature
Ice core data
• Layer size, pattern, &
• Composition
VIDEO : Drilling back to the Future (6:20)
Ancient Fossils
foraminifera in ancient
sea beds
Glaciers –
moraine sediments
Evidence left of past sea levels
• On shore
• In ancient
coral beds
HISTORY OF
PALEOCLIMATOLOGY
Pleistoscene Epoch: most recent Epoch in Earth’s
history- glacier cycles
• Before that: long eras of warm climate
Late 19th Century:
• Patterns were seen, but tools not there to date
stuff
• Palynology: study of pollen
• Each species distinctive &
durable
• Show patterns of where
plants lived in the past
• (hot-cold range)
SO SCIENTISTS STUDIED:
• Saw fossil hoards of nuts showed hazel trees
farther N 5,000 yrs ago
• Sea level change:
• (ice locks up ice from water cycle, lowering
ocean levels during Ice Ages)
• Coastal crust showed sea level changes
with a long time between Ice Ages
??? How were Ice Ages triggered???
• Traditional View: Earth only had 4 big
glaciations, based on surface strata
• Moraines: rocks & sediments carried &
deposited by a glacier at its farthest edges
http://www.mediahex.com/Moraine
• Astronomy 1920’s & 1930’s
• Milutin Milankovitch’s Theory (Serbian)
Saw patterns in Earth’s orbit that he thought
coincided with Ice Ages in Earth’s past
• 20,000 yr cycle (inclination)
• 100,000 yr cycle (eccentricity)
• Conflicted with traditional view so most
scientists dismissed
Reliable Dates & Temperatures 1955-1971
• Absolute dating- new tool: radiometric dating
• Cesare Emiliani (Italian) 1955 recorded temp
variations from the amount of oxygen in ancient
sea shells
• Said patterns matched Ice Age cycle
predicted by Milankovitch
• Didn’t match the Big 4 glaciations
• Needed to dig farther for pattern?
• Wallace Broecker (US) 1968 studied ancient
coral reef beds
• Different elevations showed that
the sea levels went up and down
with Ice Sheets
• Used radiometric dating Uranium
• Matched Milankovitch cycles
• George Kukla (Czech Republic) 1977 studied
loess to confirm existence of dozens of Ice Ages
• Loess wind-blown dust accumulations
that were found in clay quarry on land
1. Sea level changes
2. Temperature of deep sea cores
SO: Orbital variations verified in:
??? How could something as small as angle of
sunlight cause ice Ages???
• Global Cooling: 1970’s Emiliani predicts start of
a new Ice Age soon
• warned that greenhouse warming caused
by humans could overwhelm orbital shifts
• Magnetic Reversals: new dating technique
verified age of rocks & core samples being
studied
Ice Core Samples
• Samples of ancient air!
• Show past atmosphere composition
• Show aerosols (small particles in air)
• Scientists can count layers yearly
• Can be checked with major known
eruptions (like Pompeii in 79CE)
VIDEO 1: Drilling for Ice (3:20)
• Ratio of oxygen in ice can measure temperature
inside cloud it was formed
• (warmer air= heavier isotope of O)
• 1950’s US Camp Century created in Greenland
(Cold War)
• 1966 -1 mile down
• Ice core showed last 100,000 yrs
THEORIES CONFIRMED 1971-1980:
VIDEO: Camp Century Truthloader (4:30)
• 1968 US Byrd Station created in W. Antarctica
• Confirmed Ice Age happened at same time in
N & S (GLOBAL GLACIATION)
• Showed same saw-tooth curve pattern seen in
deep sea cores:
Brief warmth
Longer cold
http://www.skepticalscience.com/trend_and_variation.html
Nicholas Shackleton 1973 used magnetic reversal
dates & deep core samples
• Confirmed sea levels coincides
with Ice Sheets
• matched Milankovitch cycles
• deep sea drilling
• loess
SO: 100,000 yr cycle verified in:
• Earth’s climate system has evolved in the past so
change is possible
• Feedback mechanisms: natural responses that
add to the system
??? How was Milankovitch Cycle
a pace maker to trigger Ice
Ages???
??? What were the feedback
mechanisms that amplified the
Mil. Cycle???
• 1980’s scientists noticed CO levels went up or
down with the temperature in the past
• Russiann Vostok Station (1957 +) cores
• CO & CH during Ice Age
• CO & CH in warm periods
??? GAS KEY ???
2
2 4
42
• 1980’s global warming becomes a political issue
??? Could swing in greenhouse GASES
amplify orbital shifts ???
• Greenhouse warming & other human influences
strong enough to change the natural trend
• Could launch Earth into a wholly new climate
trend (new pattern)
• Climate Sensitivity CO levels in past 750,000
yrs at 180-280 parts per million
• In 2012: levels were at 400 ppm and rising
(methane too)
2
FACTS:
Scientists Warn:
http://www.science20.com/virtual_worlds/blog/is_global_warming_real
ly_a_recovery_from_regional_cooling-121820
http://www.forbes.com/sites/alexknapp/2013/09/10/the-daily-mail-is-wrong-the-
earth-keeps-warming/
SEA ICE
SEA LEVEL
Changes in Feedback?
• In past glaciations it appears that:
• Sunlight
• Temperature
• CO & CH from oceans
Making a warming
loop until Mil. Cycle
turns the cycle
towards cooling
2 4
CO & CH
increase
2 4Ice melts-
albedo
decreases
Temperature
increases
Temperature
CO & CH2 4
CO & CH2 4
Temperature
FASTER
SLOWER
THEN orbital shift:
• Sunlight
• Temperature
• CO & CH from oceans
Making a cooling loop
until Mil. Cycle turns
the cycle towards
warming
2 4
CO & CH
decrease
2 4Ice forms-
albedo
increases
Temperature
decreases
decreased
IN THE PAST:
• Temp increased b/c of sun angle shift
• Sun angle shift started the loop, increasing the
greenhouse gases & warmth
NEW:
• Orbital shift isn’t triggering the warming trend
• extra greenhouse gases are starting the process
• NOW- CO levels are increasing the
temperature first
2
NEW:
• Gas levels rising faster than anything seen for
millions of years & natural feedbacks are
kicking in
• Drying forests
• Warmer seas
• Methane from Arctic melt
CONCLUSION
• Geological record verifies with independent
methods & data the process computer models
are predicting:
• Disruption of climate from its recent
patterns
??? What will the changes be???
This is where the
ARGUMENTS BEGIN…
VIDEO: Crash Course-Climate
Change (10:00)
***********************
VIDEO: Ian Stewart: Cryosphere (50 min)
RESOURCES
http://www.aip.org/history/climate/cycles.htm
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Climate_change
http://www.bgs.ac.uk/discoveringGeology/climateC
hange/general/causes.html?src=topNav

Earth history 2

  • 1.
    EARTH HISTORY 2 Changesin Atmosphere ppt. by Robin D. Seamon
  • 2.
    CLIMATE VARIABLES VIDEO: IanStewart ‘Atmosphere’ (50 min)
  • 3.
    It’s all connected!Changes in one affects the other:
  • 5.
    CLIMATE CHANGES Atmosphere: gaslayer of the earth; it’s where weather happens Climate: weather patterns shown over time ** if the atmosphere changes so does the climate** QUESTION: What creates change in climate? ANSWER: Changes in atmosphere
  • 6.
    1. Biotic processes(life) ** • Respiration: breathing in/out O and CO • Transpiration: release of H 0 and CO • Waste products • Recycling of gases after death 2 2 2 2
  • 7.
    • Life affectsgas cycles: • Carbon Cycle • Water Cycle • Cloud formation • Weathering EXAMPLE: 2.4 bya The Great Oxidation Event (put oxygen into atmosphere) http://guardianlv.com/2014/02/australian-crystal-found-is-4-4-billion-years-old/
  • 8.
    2. Variations insolar radiation • amount affects photosynthesis, precipitation, wind patterns, temperature (AFFECTS LIFE) • Sun has cycles of solar storms (flares) & sun spots which could affect earth & it’s life EXAMPLE: 1550-1850 Little Ice Age Thames River: HENDRICK AVERCAMP'S LITTLE ICE AGE VIDEO: CC 4- Climate change, chaos & little Ice Age (10 min)
  • 9.
    3. Plate tectonics •shape of the continents determine ocean & wind currents • How heat is transferred • How much moisture http://www.bgs.ac.uk/discoveringGeology/climateChange/general/causes.html?src=topNav
  • 10.
    EXAMPLES: • Mountains vs.plains • Large continent vs. several smaller ones • Connection of two continents block off ocean currents- Isthmus of Panama
  • 11.
    • IN PAST-tectonic movement caused big storage of Carbon- fossil fuels TODAY: Coal mines Carboniferous Era VIDEO: Formation of Fossil Fuels (2:30)
  • 12.
    4. Volcanic eruptions& LIPs • spew gases into the atmosphere- changes chemistry (LIFE) http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-asia-29399306 Mt Ontake 9/27/2014
  • 13.
    • LIP- largeigneous provinces Places where igneous large rock beds indicate a flow of lava from cracks in the crust
  • 14.
    • Can blockout sunlight, preventing photosynthesis (LIFE) • Meteor induced http://news.nationalgeographic.com/news/2013/13/130212--chicxulub-asteroid-dinosaurs-volcano-mass-extinction- environment-science/ VIDEO: Large Igneous Province formation (2:00)
  • 15.
    MODERN EXAMPLES: 1815 Mt.Tambora: Year without a Summer 1991: Mt. Pinatubo: global temp down 0.9˚F for 3 yrs
  • 16.
    5. Cryosphere: icelayer http://www.toppforskningsinitiativet.org/en/programmer-1/program-2 http://rramu0153.wordpress.com/
  • 17.
    • During iceages, sea levels are lower • water/run-off is trapped in ice • not in water cycle = DRIER VIDEO NASA Sea Ice 2008 (3:00)
  • 18.
    • Albedo: amountof ice affects temperature: • more ice: more sunlight is reflected back off Earth • less ice: Earth absorbs more solar Energy • Carbon sink: ice keeps dead organisms from decomposing (more carbon) is absorbed than released http://www.earthgauge.net/2011/system-dynamics
  • 19.
    6. Milankovitch Cyclevariation in intensity of sunlight due to slight variation in Earth’s orbit • Pace setter for cycles of warming & cooling
  • 20.
    http://www.bgs.ac.uk/discoveringGeology/climateChange/ge neral/causes.html?src=topNav http://www.southwestclimatechan ge.org/figures/milankovitch Orbital shape: (eccentricity) Earth’s orbitchanges from it’s elliptical shape; 100,000 yrs Orbital axis wobble: Changes in tilt causes strength of seasons 20,000- 40,000 yrs VIDEO: Orbital Forcing (1 min)
  • 21.
    7. Greenhouse Gases •More greenhouse gases = thicker blanket, holding in solar radiation (warmer) • Fewer greenhouse gases = thinner blanket, trapping less solar radiation= (cooler) http://www.ib.bioninja.com.au/standard-level/topic-5-ecology-and- evoluti/52-the-greenhouse-effect.html
  • 22.
    • Natural Causes •Cold oceans absorb CO • Warm oceans release CO • CH (methane) from decay 2 2 4
  • 23.
    • Human contributions •Release of carbon into the air through burning of fossil fuels & cement manufacture increases the greenhouse layer • Aerosol increase (tiny particles in atmosphere)
  • 24.
    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Climate_change#mediaviewer/Fil e:NSFmonsoonsandclimatesince200AD.jpg Human civilizations affectedby climate changes: VIDEO 2: 300 yrs of fossil fuels in 300 sec (5:30) VIDEO 1: Climate 101 with Bill Nye (4:30)
  • 25.
    CO2 carbon dioxide CH4methane H2O water C O 1 2 C H 1 4 H O 2 1 1 carbon atom, 2 oxygen atoms 1 carbon atom, 4 hydrogen atoms 2 hydrogen atoms, 1 oxygen atom
  • 26.
  • 27.
    How do scientistsmeasure atmosphere from earlier in Earth’s history? Radiometric Dating in: Rocks & sediment • Sea floor cores composition & past temperature • Loess composition & past temperature
  • 28.
    Ice core data •Layer size, pattern, & • Composition VIDEO : Drilling back to the Future (6:20)
  • 29.
  • 30.
    Glaciers – moraine sediments Evidenceleft of past sea levels • On shore • In ancient coral beds
  • 31.
  • 32.
    Pleistoscene Epoch: mostrecent Epoch in Earth’s history- glacier cycles • Before that: long eras of warm climate
  • 33.
    Late 19th Century: •Patterns were seen, but tools not there to date stuff • Palynology: study of pollen • Each species distinctive & durable • Show patterns of where plants lived in the past • (hot-cold range) SO SCIENTISTS STUDIED:
  • 34.
    • Saw fossilhoards of nuts showed hazel trees farther N 5,000 yrs ago • Sea level change: • (ice locks up ice from water cycle, lowering ocean levels during Ice Ages) • Coastal crust showed sea level changes with a long time between Ice Ages ??? How were Ice Ages triggered???
  • 35.
    • Traditional View:Earth only had 4 big glaciations, based on surface strata • Moraines: rocks & sediments carried & deposited by a glacier at its farthest edges http://www.mediahex.com/Moraine
  • 36.
    • Astronomy 1920’s& 1930’s • Milutin Milankovitch’s Theory (Serbian) Saw patterns in Earth’s orbit that he thought coincided with Ice Ages in Earth’s past • 20,000 yr cycle (inclination) • 100,000 yr cycle (eccentricity) • Conflicted with traditional view so most scientists dismissed
  • 37.
    Reliable Dates &Temperatures 1955-1971 • Absolute dating- new tool: radiometric dating • Cesare Emiliani (Italian) 1955 recorded temp variations from the amount of oxygen in ancient sea shells
  • 38.
    • Said patternsmatched Ice Age cycle predicted by Milankovitch • Didn’t match the Big 4 glaciations • Needed to dig farther for pattern?
  • 39.
    • Wallace Broecker(US) 1968 studied ancient coral reef beds • Different elevations showed that the sea levels went up and down with Ice Sheets • Used radiometric dating Uranium • Matched Milankovitch cycles
  • 40.
    • George Kukla(Czech Republic) 1977 studied loess to confirm existence of dozens of Ice Ages • Loess wind-blown dust accumulations that were found in clay quarry on land
  • 41.
    1. Sea levelchanges 2. Temperature of deep sea cores SO: Orbital variations verified in: ??? How could something as small as angle of sunlight cause ice Ages???
  • 42.
    • Global Cooling:1970’s Emiliani predicts start of a new Ice Age soon • warned that greenhouse warming caused by humans could overwhelm orbital shifts • Magnetic Reversals: new dating technique verified age of rocks & core samples being studied
  • 43.
    Ice Core Samples •Samples of ancient air! • Show past atmosphere composition • Show aerosols (small particles in air) • Scientists can count layers yearly • Can be checked with major known eruptions (like Pompeii in 79CE) VIDEO 1: Drilling for Ice (3:20)
  • 44.
    • Ratio ofoxygen in ice can measure temperature inside cloud it was formed • (warmer air= heavier isotope of O)
  • 45.
    • 1950’s USCamp Century created in Greenland (Cold War) • 1966 -1 mile down • Ice core showed last 100,000 yrs THEORIES CONFIRMED 1971-1980: VIDEO: Camp Century Truthloader (4:30)
  • 46.
    • 1968 USByrd Station created in W. Antarctica • Confirmed Ice Age happened at same time in N & S (GLOBAL GLACIATION)
  • 47.
    • Showed samesaw-tooth curve pattern seen in deep sea cores: Brief warmth Longer cold http://www.skepticalscience.com/trend_and_variation.html
  • 48.
    Nicholas Shackleton 1973used magnetic reversal dates & deep core samples • Confirmed sea levels coincides with Ice Sheets • matched Milankovitch cycles • deep sea drilling • loess SO: 100,000 yr cycle verified in:
  • 49.
    • Earth’s climatesystem has evolved in the past so change is possible • Feedback mechanisms: natural responses that add to the system ??? How was Milankovitch Cycle a pace maker to trigger Ice Ages??? ??? What were the feedback mechanisms that amplified the Mil. Cycle???
  • 50.
    • 1980’s scientistsnoticed CO levels went up or down with the temperature in the past • Russiann Vostok Station (1957 +) cores • CO & CH during Ice Age • CO & CH in warm periods ??? GAS KEY ??? 2 2 4 42
  • 51.
    • 1980’s globalwarming becomes a political issue ??? Could swing in greenhouse GASES amplify orbital shifts ???
  • 52.
    • Greenhouse warming& other human influences strong enough to change the natural trend • Could launch Earth into a wholly new climate trend (new pattern) • Climate Sensitivity CO levels in past 750,000 yrs at 180-280 parts per million • In 2012: levels were at 400 ppm and rising (methane too) 2 FACTS: Scientists Warn:
  • 54.
  • 55.
    Changes in Feedback? •In past glaciations it appears that: • Sunlight • Temperature • CO & CH from oceans Making a warming loop until Mil. Cycle turns the cycle towards cooling 2 4 CO & CH increase 2 4Ice melts- albedo decreases Temperature increases
  • 56.
    Temperature CO & CH24 CO & CH2 4 Temperature FASTER SLOWER
  • 57.
    THEN orbital shift: •Sunlight • Temperature • CO & CH from oceans Making a cooling loop until Mil. Cycle turns the cycle towards warming 2 4 CO & CH decrease 2 4Ice forms- albedo increases Temperature decreases decreased
  • 58.
    IN THE PAST: •Temp increased b/c of sun angle shift • Sun angle shift started the loop, increasing the greenhouse gases & warmth NEW: • Orbital shift isn’t triggering the warming trend • extra greenhouse gases are starting the process • NOW- CO levels are increasing the temperature first 2
  • 59.
    NEW: • Gas levelsrising faster than anything seen for millions of years & natural feedbacks are kicking in • Drying forests • Warmer seas • Methane from Arctic melt
  • 60.
    CONCLUSION • Geological recordverifies with independent methods & data the process computer models are predicting: • Disruption of climate from its recent patterns ??? What will the changes be??? This is where the ARGUMENTS BEGIN… VIDEO: Crash Course-Climate Change (10:00)
  • 61.
  • 62.