Decompression Illness: Bubble Trouble
James R. Holm, MD, FACP, FACEP, FUHM
Medical Director, Center for Hyperbaric Medicine
Virginia Mason Medical Center, Seattle, WA
Resident Noon Lecture Series
Virginia Mason Medical Center
October 1st, 2018
Background
 Education
 Georgetown University
Medical School, 1985
 Northwestern University
Residency in EM/IM, 1989
 Board Certified
 Internal Medicine
 Emergency Medicine
 Undersea & Hyperbaric
Medicine
 Medical Practice
 Emergency Medicine since 1989
 Hyperbaric Medicine since 1997
 VMMC since June 2009
 Diving Experience
 1969 NAUI SCUBA Certified
 1978 NAUI/PADI Instructor
Outline
 Case
 Diving Injuries Related to Pressure
 Definition of DCI = DCS and AGE
 Mechanism of Bubble Related Injury
 Diagnosis of DCI
 Emergency Treatment for DCI
 Recompression Treatment for DCI
 Chambers, Treatment Tables, Protocols
Case
 48 yo male geoduck diving on surface
supplied air in the Puget Sound
 >20 years of diving without history of DCS
 PMH: HTN, depression, hx of substance
abuse
 Meds: Suboxone, Lexapro, Lisinopril
 Diving Profile
 86 fsw for 21 minutes Bottom Time
 35 minute Surface Interval
 90 fsw for 84 minutes Bottom Time
 Surface supplied air without rapid ascent
 Computer set on 44% nitrox (44% O2 54% N2)
 Used one computer for each dive
 After surfacing
 10 minutes later had numbness from umbilicus down and
paraplegia and unable to walk
 Rash (cutis marmorata)
 Given surface O2 and helicoptered to HMC
 Hypotensive and given IV fluid boluses
 Transferred to VMMC
 Numbness and weakness resolved with O2
 Hct 63 WBC 25.4
 Given IV fluids (7 L in 8 hours) HBO2 (Table 6) and pressers and
admitted to ICU
 Treated in ICU with supportive care for ARF and hypotension
86 fsw for 21 minutes Bottom Time (BT)
35 minute Surface Interval (SI)
90 fsw for 84 minutes Bottom Time (BT)
86 fsw for 21 minutes Bottom Time (BT)
35 minute Surface Interval (SI)
90 fsw for 84 minutes Bottom Time (BT)
86 fsw for 21 minutes Bottom Time (BT)
35 minute Surface Interval (SI)
90 fsw for 84 minutes Bottom Time (BT)
Diving Injuries Related to Pressure
 Common barotrauma (squeeze)
 Middle ear
 Sinus/tooth/mask
 Uncommon barotrauma
 Inner ear
 Pneumothorax
 Subcutaneous/mediastinal emphysema
 Arterial gas embolism (AGE)
 Decompression sickness (DCS or bends)
 Incidence is estimated at 2-5 cases per 10,000 dives
 VMMC CHM treats about 40 cases a year
 Most cases are mild to moderate severity
 Most are treated through the ED and not admitted
Bubble Trouble
 Decompression Sickness (DCS)
 SCUBA divers, pilots, and astronauts
 Staff in multiplace chambers
 Arterial Gas Embolism (AGE)
 SCUBA divers: breath holding upon
ascent
 Iatrogenic: with some medical
procedures
Decompression Illness (DCI)
 DCI (Decompression Illness) includes:
 AGE (Arterial Gas Embolism… “Air Embolism”)
 DCS (Decompression Sickness)
 Type I : Pain Only
 Type II: Neurologic or Severe
 Sport divers tend to have more type II
 May have multiple symptoms
 Treatment is essentially the same
Bubble Disease
Dissolved gas Pulmonary barotrauma
Venous blood Arterial bloodTissues
DCS AGE
Type I and Type II
Mechanism of Bubble Related Injury
Muth CM. N Engl J Med, 2000
Massive AGE for Positive Pressure Ventilation
Weaver LK. Chest 1998
Cylindrical, blood occluding gas emboli in the middle meningeal artery
at postmortem exam
Mechanism of Bubble Related Injury
Gas bubbles and hemorrhagic infarcts in spinal tissue of animals with
severe decompression sickness at postmortem exam
Helps SC. Stroke 1990
Mechanisms of Injury in Gas Embolism
Courtesy of Steve Helps and Des Gorman from the University of Adelaide
Video
Helps SC. Stroke 1990
Non-mechanical Effects of Bubbles
 Endothelial damage leads to:
 WBC adherence/activation
 Microvascular leak
 Edema
 Hemorrhage
 Infarction
 Neutrophil mediated process
Levin LL. J Appl Physiol 1981
Non-mechanical Effects of Bubbles
Arterial Gas Embolism
 Divers holding their breath upon ascent
or with obstructive airway disease
 Gas moves from the alveoli and into the
left sided circulation to the brain and
heart
 This can occur:
 In as little as 10 ft of water
 Independent of the nitrogen load a
diver has
 Symptoms are severe and immediate
Vann RD. Lancet 2011
Causes of Gas Embolism
 Barotrauma
 Scuba diver holding their breath upon ascent
 Patient on positive pressure ventilation
 Surgery or medical procedures
 Faulty contrast injector
 Lung biopsy
 Laparoscopy
 Multiple other procedures
Pulmonary Anatomy & Blood-Gas Barrier
West JB. Lancet 1992
“The surprising thing is not that the [pulmonary] capillaries fail,
but that they don’t do so more often”
Arterial Gas Embolism in a Diver
 A 24 year old healthy marine in the Royal
Netherlands Navy
 Free ascent training in pool
 He held his breath during from 30 fsw to 15 fsw
 Developed right sided hemiplegia and loss of eyesight
 Course and treatment
 Administration of 100% oxygen led to improvement
 Complete resolution after a USN table 6
 Work up failed to reveal any other risk factors
Courtesy of Lieutenant T.T. (Thijs) Wingelaar, MD
Courtesy of Lieutenant T.T. (Thijs) Wingelaar, MD
Video
Diagnosis of AGE
 Clinical Diagnosis
 Symptoms occur within seconds or minutes
 Altered LOC
 Seizure
 Neurologic findings
 Cardiovascular collapse
 Lab and X-Ray Findings are Often Negative
 It is rare to see arterial gas on CT
Decompression Sickness (DCS)
Eads Bridge, MO, 1871
Brooklyn Bridge, NY, 1872 Hudson River Tunnel, NY/NJ, 1902
Brooklyn Bridge
 Dr. Andrew Smith
 Coined the term “caisson’s disease” & “bends”
 110 severe cases requiring treatment
 Treatments included:
 Atropine
 Mercury chloride
 Ergot
 Whiskey
 Ginger
 He considered recompression “heroic” but never used it
 Washington Roebling: permanently paralyzed
Hudson River Tunnel
 E.W. Moir
 British engineer brought in for the project
 Was the first to use recompression as a treatment
 Reduced the death rate from 25% of the work force per
year to 1.7% of the work force per year
 Moir tables
 Recompress to ½ the working pressure
 Later recompress to ¾ of the working pressure
Decompression Sickness
 Inert gas is absorbed/eliminated from different body
“compartments” at different rates (time & depth)
 Even with computers and tables… divers can get
decompression sickness even if “within their limits”!
 Most computers and tables do not account for:
 Dehydration
 Poor fitness
 Advanced age
 Amount of work the diver did
 Other medical problems
Assessment of the DCS Patient
 History
 Exam
 Diagnostic tests
 Differential diagnosis
 Tips:
 Presentation may be delayed and vague
 Response to treatment may assist in diagnosis
 Have a low threshold for treatment
History and Physical
 History
 Past medical history including medications
 Past diving history including past history of DCI
 Detailed dive history as well as pre- and post-dive history
 Exact onset of each symptoms (especially the first one)
 Physical Examination
 Signs of otic or pulmonary barotrauma
 A quick but careful neurologic exam
 Check for gait, bowel, bladder function
 Check for balance and brain function
 Get them out of the gurney or off the ground if possible
 Findings may be subtle and variable (not “one lesion”)
Vann RD, et al. Lancet 2011
By Frequency (Initial & All Symptoms)
Cutis Marmorata
Diagnostic Tests
 Not too helpful in management
 Chest x-ray changes due to near- drowning,
barotrauma, etc.
 CT and MRI may be negative early but may find
other causes of symptoms
 Blood testing may reveal
 Hemoconcentration
 Elevated CPK (* for AGE)
 Intoxications
*Smith RM. N Engl J Med, 1994
AGE or DCS?
Factors AGE DCS
Diving profile rapid ascent time/depth profile
Symptom onset seconds to minutes
(after surfacing)
minutes to hours
(after surfacing)
Type of symptoms cerebral
seizure/LOC
hemiplegia
spinal /peripheral
paraplegia/weakness
numbness/tingling
joint pain
Treatment of DCI
Treatment of DCI
 Airway
 Breathing
 Circulation
 Body position: “Supine is Fine”
 Oxygen administration (100%)
 Don’t attempt in-water recompression
 Call DAN: 919-684-9111 (emergencies only)
 Usually transport to the closest ED
 Recompress in hyperbaric chamber
Recompression
Goals of Recompression
 Shrink and dissolve bubbles
 By pressure and counter diffusion mechanisms
 Do not create new bubbles on decompression
 Expedite inert gas elimination
 Oxygenate ischemic tissue
 Reduce “injury/reperfusion” damage
 Don’t hurt your patient or inside attendant
 Pressure
 Shrink bubbles (Boyle’s Law)
 Gas Gradient
 Diffuse inert gas out of bubbles
P1V1=P2V2
pN2
100%
O2 100%
HBO2 Effect on Gas Bubbles
pN2 0%
HBO2 Effect on Neutrophil Adhesion
Thom SR. Am J Physiol Cell Physiol 1997
Hyperbaric Chambers and Treatment Tables
US Navy Oxygen Treatment Tables
US Navy Table 6 Management
Repeat Treatments
 Serious DCI
 Retreat with USN TT6 immediately
 Moderate DCI
 Retreat with USN TT6 4-12 hours
 Mild DCI residuals
 Retreat with USN TT5
 Retreat with USN TT9 (qd or BID)
 Give NSAIDs (1 less HBO2 with tenoxicam *)
 Do nothing, will get better regardless
 Treat until complete resolution or no change on 2
successive treatments
Bennett MB. Undersea Hyperb Med, 2003
Questions?
James R. Holm, MD
james.holm@vmmc.org
hbodoctor@yahoo.com

Decompression illness

  • 1.
    Decompression Illness: BubbleTrouble James R. Holm, MD, FACP, FACEP, FUHM Medical Director, Center for Hyperbaric Medicine Virginia Mason Medical Center, Seattle, WA Resident Noon Lecture Series Virginia Mason Medical Center October 1st, 2018
  • 3.
    Background  Education  GeorgetownUniversity Medical School, 1985  Northwestern University Residency in EM/IM, 1989  Board Certified  Internal Medicine  Emergency Medicine  Undersea & Hyperbaric Medicine  Medical Practice  Emergency Medicine since 1989  Hyperbaric Medicine since 1997  VMMC since June 2009  Diving Experience  1969 NAUI SCUBA Certified  1978 NAUI/PADI Instructor
  • 5.
    Outline  Case  DivingInjuries Related to Pressure  Definition of DCI = DCS and AGE  Mechanism of Bubble Related Injury  Diagnosis of DCI  Emergency Treatment for DCI  Recompression Treatment for DCI  Chambers, Treatment Tables, Protocols
  • 6.
    Case  48 yomale geoduck diving on surface supplied air in the Puget Sound  >20 years of diving without history of DCS  PMH: HTN, depression, hx of substance abuse  Meds: Suboxone, Lexapro, Lisinopril  Diving Profile  86 fsw for 21 minutes Bottom Time  35 minute Surface Interval  90 fsw for 84 minutes Bottom Time
  • 7.
     Surface suppliedair without rapid ascent  Computer set on 44% nitrox (44% O2 54% N2)  Used one computer for each dive  After surfacing  10 minutes later had numbness from umbilicus down and paraplegia and unable to walk  Rash (cutis marmorata)  Given surface O2 and helicoptered to HMC  Hypotensive and given IV fluid boluses  Transferred to VMMC  Numbness and weakness resolved with O2  Hct 63 WBC 25.4  Given IV fluids (7 L in 8 hours) HBO2 (Table 6) and pressers and admitted to ICU  Treated in ICU with supportive care for ARF and hypotension
  • 8.
    86 fsw for21 minutes Bottom Time (BT) 35 minute Surface Interval (SI) 90 fsw for 84 minutes Bottom Time (BT)
  • 9.
    86 fsw for21 minutes Bottom Time (BT) 35 minute Surface Interval (SI) 90 fsw for 84 minutes Bottom Time (BT)
  • 10.
    86 fsw for21 minutes Bottom Time (BT) 35 minute Surface Interval (SI) 90 fsw for 84 minutes Bottom Time (BT)
  • 11.
    Diving Injuries Relatedto Pressure  Common barotrauma (squeeze)  Middle ear  Sinus/tooth/mask  Uncommon barotrauma  Inner ear  Pneumothorax  Subcutaneous/mediastinal emphysema  Arterial gas embolism (AGE)  Decompression sickness (DCS or bends)  Incidence is estimated at 2-5 cases per 10,000 dives  VMMC CHM treats about 40 cases a year  Most cases are mild to moderate severity  Most are treated through the ED and not admitted
  • 12.
    Bubble Trouble  DecompressionSickness (DCS)  SCUBA divers, pilots, and astronauts  Staff in multiplace chambers  Arterial Gas Embolism (AGE)  SCUBA divers: breath holding upon ascent  Iatrogenic: with some medical procedures
  • 14.
    Decompression Illness (DCI) DCI (Decompression Illness) includes:  AGE (Arterial Gas Embolism… “Air Embolism”)  DCS (Decompression Sickness)  Type I : Pain Only  Type II: Neurologic or Severe  Sport divers tend to have more type II  May have multiple symptoms  Treatment is essentially the same
  • 15.
    Bubble Disease Dissolved gasPulmonary barotrauma Venous blood Arterial bloodTissues DCS AGE Type I and Type II
  • 16.
    Mechanism of BubbleRelated Injury Muth CM. N Engl J Med, 2000
  • 17.
    Massive AGE forPositive Pressure Ventilation Weaver LK. Chest 1998 Cylindrical, blood occluding gas emboli in the middle meningeal artery at postmortem exam
  • 18.
    Mechanism of BubbleRelated Injury Gas bubbles and hemorrhagic infarcts in spinal tissue of animals with severe decompression sickness at postmortem exam
  • 19.
    Helps SC. Stroke1990 Mechanisms of Injury in Gas Embolism
  • 20.
    Courtesy of SteveHelps and Des Gorman from the University of Adelaide Video
  • 21.
  • 22.
  • 23.
     Endothelial damageleads to:  WBC adherence/activation  Microvascular leak  Edema  Hemorrhage  Infarction  Neutrophil mediated process Levin LL. J Appl Physiol 1981 Non-mechanical Effects of Bubbles
  • 25.
    Arterial Gas Embolism Divers holding their breath upon ascent or with obstructive airway disease  Gas moves from the alveoli and into the left sided circulation to the brain and heart  This can occur:  In as little as 10 ft of water  Independent of the nitrogen load a diver has  Symptoms are severe and immediate Vann RD. Lancet 2011
  • 26.
    Causes of GasEmbolism  Barotrauma  Scuba diver holding their breath upon ascent  Patient on positive pressure ventilation  Surgery or medical procedures  Faulty contrast injector  Lung biopsy  Laparoscopy  Multiple other procedures
  • 27.
    Pulmonary Anatomy &Blood-Gas Barrier West JB. Lancet 1992 “The surprising thing is not that the [pulmonary] capillaries fail, but that they don’t do so more often”
  • 28.
    Arterial Gas Embolismin a Diver  A 24 year old healthy marine in the Royal Netherlands Navy  Free ascent training in pool  He held his breath during from 30 fsw to 15 fsw  Developed right sided hemiplegia and loss of eyesight  Course and treatment  Administration of 100% oxygen led to improvement  Complete resolution after a USN table 6  Work up failed to reveal any other risk factors Courtesy of Lieutenant T.T. (Thijs) Wingelaar, MD
  • 29.
    Courtesy of LieutenantT.T. (Thijs) Wingelaar, MD Video
  • 30.
    Diagnosis of AGE Clinical Diagnosis  Symptoms occur within seconds or minutes  Altered LOC  Seizure  Neurologic findings  Cardiovascular collapse  Lab and X-Ray Findings are Often Negative  It is rare to see arterial gas on CT
  • 31.
  • 32.
    Eads Bridge, MO,1871 Brooklyn Bridge, NY, 1872 Hudson River Tunnel, NY/NJ, 1902
  • 33.
    Brooklyn Bridge  Dr.Andrew Smith  Coined the term “caisson’s disease” & “bends”  110 severe cases requiring treatment  Treatments included:  Atropine  Mercury chloride  Ergot  Whiskey  Ginger  He considered recompression “heroic” but never used it  Washington Roebling: permanently paralyzed
  • 34.
    Hudson River Tunnel E.W. Moir  British engineer brought in for the project  Was the first to use recompression as a treatment  Reduced the death rate from 25% of the work force per year to 1.7% of the work force per year  Moir tables  Recompress to ½ the working pressure  Later recompress to ¾ of the working pressure
  • 35.
    Decompression Sickness  Inertgas is absorbed/eliminated from different body “compartments” at different rates (time & depth)  Even with computers and tables… divers can get decompression sickness even if “within their limits”!  Most computers and tables do not account for:  Dehydration  Poor fitness  Advanced age  Amount of work the diver did  Other medical problems
  • 36.
    Assessment of theDCS Patient  History  Exam  Diagnostic tests  Differential diagnosis  Tips:  Presentation may be delayed and vague  Response to treatment may assist in diagnosis  Have a low threshold for treatment
  • 37.
    History and Physical History  Past medical history including medications  Past diving history including past history of DCI  Detailed dive history as well as pre- and post-dive history  Exact onset of each symptoms (especially the first one)  Physical Examination  Signs of otic or pulmonary barotrauma  A quick but careful neurologic exam  Check for gait, bowel, bladder function  Check for balance and brain function  Get them out of the gurney or off the ground if possible  Findings may be subtle and variable (not “one lesion”)
  • 38.
    Vann RD, etal. Lancet 2011 By Frequency (Initial & All Symptoms)
  • 40.
  • 41.
    Diagnostic Tests  Nottoo helpful in management  Chest x-ray changes due to near- drowning, barotrauma, etc.  CT and MRI may be negative early but may find other causes of symptoms  Blood testing may reveal  Hemoconcentration  Elevated CPK (* for AGE)  Intoxications *Smith RM. N Engl J Med, 1994
  • 42.
    AGE or DCS? FactorsAGE DCS Diving profile rapid ascent time/depth profile Symptom onset seconds to minutes (after surfacing) minutes to hours (after surfacing) Type of symptoms cerebral seizure/LOC hemiplegia spinal /peripheral paraplegia/weakness numbness/tingling joint pain
  • 43.
  • 44.
    Treatment of DCI Airway  Breathing  Circulation  Body position: “Supine is Fine”  Oxygen administration (100%)  Don’t attempt in-water recompression  Call DAN: 919-684-9111 (emergencies only)  Usually transport to the closest ED  Recompress in hyperbaric chamber
  • 45.
  • 46.
    Goals of Recompression Shrink and dissolve bubbles  By pressure and counter diffusion mechanisms  Do not create new bubbles on decompression  Expedite inert gas elimination  Oxygenate ischemic tissue  Reduce “injury/reperfusion” damage  Don’t hurt your patient or inside attendant
  • 47.
     Pressure  Shrinkbubbles (Boyle’s Law)  Gas Gradient  Diffuse inert gas out of bubbles P1V1=P2V2 pN2 100% O2 100% HBO2 Effect on Gas Bubbles pN2 0%
  • 49.
    HBO2 Effect onNeutrophil Adhesion Thom SR. Am J Physiol Cell Physiol 1997
  • 50.
    Hyperbaric Chambers andTreatment Tables
  • 51.
    US Navy OxygenTreatment Tables
  • 52.
    US Navy Table6 Management
  • 53.
    Repeat Treatments  SeriousDCI  Retreat with USN TT6 immediately  Moderate DCI  Retreat with USN TT6 4-12 hours  Mild DCI residuals  Retreat with USN TT5  Retreat with USN TT9 (qd or BID)  Give NSAIDs (1 less HBO2 with tenoxicam *)  Do nothing, will get better regardless  Treat until complete resolution or no change on 2 successive treatments Bennett MB. Undersea Hyperb Med, 2003
  • 54.
    Questions? James R. Holm,MD james.holm@vmmc.org hbodoctor@yahoo.com