4/11/2013




                                                                                                  Critical Path Method (CPM)
                                                                                       • Critical Path Method was developed by Du Pont
                                                                                       • In Critical Path Method (CPM) the emphasis is on the
                     Critical Path Methods                                               trade-off between
                                                                                               – the cost of the project and
                                                                                               – its overall completion time
                                     Presented by:                                     • e.g.
                                                 Anupam Kumar                                  – For certain activities it may be possible to decrease their
                                                                                                 completion times by spending more money
                                                        Reader
                                                                                               – How does this affect the overall completion time of the
                                                   SMS Varanasi                                  project?




                      Critical Path Method                                                                       Illustration 1
       • In Critical Path Method (CPM) activities are shown as                         •   A leading company has decided to bring about certain changes in its
                                                                                           product design for which the time estimates are as follows.
          – a network of precedence relationships using                                •   Estimate the time it would take to get the new design implemented.
          – activity-on-node network construction.                                     •   The activity precedence detail is:    Activity number    Activity number
       • CPM is used in Production management                                                                                   must finish before       can start
                                                                                                                                         1                         3
          – for the jobs of repetitive in nature where the activity time
                                                                                                                                         2                         4
            estimates can be predicted with considerable certainty due
                                                                                                                                         3                         5
            to the existence of past experience.
                                                                                                                                         4                         6
       • CPM has                                                                                                                        5,6                        7
          – Single estimate of activity time                                                                                             7                         8

          – Deterministic activity times                                                                                                 8                         9
                                                                                                                                         8                         10
                                                                                                                                       9,10                        11




                      Illustration 1 (Contd.)                                                                    Illustration 2
          Activity   Activity                                                Time
          No.                                                             (in Weeks)
                                                                                       • The time estimates for completing the plant
             1       Redesign Product                                         6
             2       Redesign Packaging                                       2
                                                                                         construction project is as shown.
             3       Order & receive component for redesigned product         3                – Determine the critical path.
             4       Order & receive component for redesigned packaging       2                – How much slack time is available in the non critical path?
             5       Assemble Product                                         4
             6       Make up packaging                                        1
             7       Package redesign product                                 1                                  3
             8       Test Market redesigned product                           6
                                                                                                                                 5
             9       Revise redesigned product                                3
             10      Revise redesigned packaging                              1                   12       4                                         6
                                                                                           1           2         4                              7              8
             11      Present result to Board                                  1

                                                                                                                                 6




© Copyright 2013 Anupam Kumar                                                                                                                                                  1
4/11/2013




                 Crashing CPM Networks                                                                    Illustration 3
                                                                         Activity Time in Weeks           Cost (Rs.)
       • Project Timelines are crashed for due to                                                                         • The network details for
                                                                                    Normal Crash Normal Crash
         urgent or contingent conditions.                                                                                   a small project is as
                                                                           1-2         6            4    10,000 14,000
                                                                                                                            given.
       • Crashing of CPM Networks is                                       1-3         4            3     5,000   8,000
                                                                                                                             – Draw a network diagram
                                                                           2-4         3            2     4,000   5,000
          – The process to reduce the normal project duration              3-5         8            6     9,000 12,000         with the normal times.
          – to the desired shorter duration                                4-5         7            4     7,000   8,000      – What would be the cost
                                                                                 Total Cost:             35,000 47,000         of the project if the non-
          – activities on the critical path are crashed                                                                        critical path is to be
          – by the use of additional resources / expenses.                                                                     converted to the critical
       Time-cost ratio = Increase in cost / Decrease in time                                                                   path through project
             = (crash cost – normal cost) / (normal time – crash time)                                                         time crashing?




                           Illustration 4                                                               Illustration 4 (Contd.)
                                                                         Activity    Normal Time           Normal Cost Crash time   Crash cost   Immediate
       • A company received an order from a reputed                                                                                              Predecessor
         customer.                                                           A                 4                  1000       3             1300 None
          – As per the contract, from the day 15th the company will          B                 7                  1400       4             2000 None
            have to pay a penalty of Rs. 10 per day until job is             C                 5                  2000       4             2700 None
            completed.                                                       D                 6                  1200       5             1400 A
          – Indirect project costs per day is Rs. 200.                       E                 3                   900       2             1100 B
                                                                             F                 11                 2500       6             4000 C
          – The data on direct cost and activities are as follows.
                                                                             G                 4                   800       3             1500 D, E
       • Draw project network diagram.                                       H                 3                   300       1              500 F, G
       • What completion date would you recommend?
       • Compute project cost after crashing.




© Copyright 2013 Anupam Kumar                                                                                                                                     2

Critical path method

  • 1.
    4/11/2013 Critical Path Method (CPM) • Critical Path Method was developed by Du Pont • In Critical Path Method (CPM) the emphasis is on the Critical Path Methods trade-off between – the cost of the project and – its overall completion time Presented by: • e.g. Anupam Kumar – For certain activities it may be possible to decrease their completion times by spending more money Reader – How does this affect the overall completion time of the SMS Varanasi project? Critical Path Method Illustration 1 • In Critical Path Method (CPM) activities are shown as • A leading company has decided to bring about certain changes in its product design for which the time estimates are as follows. – a network of precedence relationships using • Estimate the time it would take to get the new design implemented. – activity-on-node network construction. • The activity precedence detail is: Activity number Activity number • CPM is used in Production management must finish before can start 1 3 – for the jobs of repetitive in nature where the activity time 2 4 estimates can be predicted with considerable certainty due 3 5 to the existence of past experience. 4 6 • CPM has 5,6 7 – Single estimate of activity time 7 8 – Deterministic activity times 8 9 8 10 9,10 11 Illustration 1 (Contd.) Illustration 2 Activity Activity Time No. (in Weeks) • The time estimates for completing the plant 1 Redesign Product 6 2 Redesign Packaging 2 construction project is as shown. 3 Order & receive component for redesigned product 3 – Determine the critical path. 4 Order & receive component for redesigned packaging 2 – How much slack time is available in the non critical path? 5 Assemble Product 4 6 Make up packaging 1 7 Package redesign product 1 3 8 Test Market redesigned product 6 5 9 Revise redesigned product 3 10 Revise redesigned packaging 1 12 4 6 1 2 4 7 8 11 Present result to Board 1 6 © Copyright 2013 Anupam Kumar 1
  • 2.
    4/11/2013 Crashing CPM Networks Illustration 3 Activity Time in Weeks Cost (Rs.) • Project Timelines are crashed for due to • The network details for Normal Crash Normal Crash urgent or contingent conditions. a small project is as 1-2 6 4 10,000 14,000 given. • Crashing of CPM Networks is 1-3 4 3 5,000 8,000 – Draw a network diagram 2-4 3 2 4,000 5,000 – The process to reduce the normal project duration 3-5 8 6 9,000 12,000 with the normal times. – to the desired shorter duration 4-5 7 4 7,000 8,000 – What would be the cost Total Cost: 35,000 47,000 of the project if the non- – activities on the critical path are crashed critical path is to be – by the use of additional resources / expenses. converted to the critical Time-cost ratio = Increase in cost / Decrease in time path through project = (crash cost – normal cost) / (normal time – crash time) time crashing? Illustration 4 Illustration 4 (Contd.) Activity Normal Time Normal Cost Crash time Crash cost Immediate • A company received an order from a reputed Predecessor customer. A 4 1000 3 1300 None – As per the contract, from the day 15th the company will B 7 1400 4 2000 None have to pay a penalty of Rs. 10 per day until job is C 5 2000 4 2700 None completed. D 6 1200 5 1400 A – Indirect project costs per day is Rs. 200. E 3 900 2 1100 B F 11 2500 6 4000 C – The data on direct cost and activities are as follows. G 4 800 3 1500 D, E • Draw project network diagram. H 3 300 1 500 F, G • What completion date would you recommend? • Compute project cost after crashing. © Copyright 2013 Anupam Kumar 2