CLIMATE CHANGE,
   COASTAL GEOLOGIC HAZARDS
              and
         SEA-LEVEL RISE
         URI Climate Change Symposium
                    18 November 2011
                    Jon C. Boothroyd
               Rhode Island State Geologist,
     Research Professor Emeritus – Quaternary Geology
                            -------------
Rhode Island Geological Survey and Department of Geosciences
         College of the Environment and Life Sciences
                  University of Rhode Island
                     jon_boothroyd@uri.edu
Southern New England, Long Island, Continental Shelf ~ 26,000 yBP




                                                 Map Generated By:
                                             BA Oakley and JC Boothroyd
THE LAST NORTH AMERICAN
           ICE SHEETS




    CORDILLERAN


                               LAURENTIDE




-



                                            You are
                                             here
    After Dyke & Prest, 1987
MALASPINA GLACIER – Northeast Gulf of Alaska




-




                   An Analog “The size of Rhode Island”
Oakley, 2011




               You are
                here




                         Ice margins modified from:
                         Dyke and Prest, 1987
                         Ridge, 2010; Goss, 1993
                         Smith, 2010
Oakley, 2011




               Ice margins modified from:
               Dyke and Prest, 1987
               Ridge, 2010; Goss, 1993
               Smith, 2010
Oakley, 2011
               Charlestown
                 Moraine




                             Ice margins modified from:
                             Dyke and Prest, 1987
                             Ridge, 2010; Goss, 1993
                             Smith, 2010
Ice margins modified from:
Dyke and Prest, 1987
Ridge, 2010; Goss, 1993
Smith, 2010


     Oakley, 2011
Ice margins modified from:
Dyke and Prest, 1987
Ridge, 2010; Goss, 1993
Smith, 2010




      Oakley, 2011
Oakley, 2011




               Ice margins modified from:
               Dyke and Prest, 1987
               Ridge, 2010; Goss, 1993
               Smith, 2010
Eustatic
Sea-Level
  Rise
    +
Isostatic
Rebound                            Laurentide
     at                            Ice Sheet?
                                    Laurentide
                                   2m.100yr-1
                                     Ice Sheet?
Block Island                         2m.100yr-1



                               Antarctic Ice
                              Antarctic Ice
                                   Sheet?
                                 Sheet? -1
                                2-5m.100yr
                              2-5m.100yr-1

                                    Explanation


                   - 390 ft
Oakley and Boothroyd,
   submitted 2011
-165 ft




 Begin Meltwater Pulse 1B




                                Post-Glacial
                                   Lake




                            Atlantic Ocean
-130 ft




 End Meltwater Pulse 1B




                                       Post-Glacial
                                          Lake



                                                      Estuary




                          Atlantic Ocean
When Contemplating Rhode Island
     Coastal Geologic Hazards



One Must Consider:
• Extratropical Cyclones (“Nor’easters”)
• Hurricanes (Tropical Cyclones)
• and ……. Sea Level Rise
When Contemplating Rhode Island
      Coastal Geologic Hazards



Which Give Rise to these Processes:
• Frontal Erosion – from Breaking Waves
  and Swash
• Storm-Surge Overwash
• Elevated MHHW into the Future
When Contemplating Rhode Island
       Coastal Geologic Hazards


The Scale of Processes are:
• Breaking Waves – 3 to 10+ feet at shoreline
• Storm-Surge Overwash – 1 to 10+ feet water
  depth across shore zone
• Sea-Level Rise – 0.14 inches per year at present
The Sea May Be Rising Long Term – But…..
      Instantaneous Storm Surges
         Elevate Sea Level Now
Narragansett Pier Seawall – Patriots Day 2007




                                          WPRI.com
                                          16 apr 2007
Patriots Day Extratropical Storm – April 2007
            Newport Tide Gauge

                    SET UP                              PREDICTED




                http://tidesandcurrents.noaa.gov/
  STORM SURGE   data_menu.shtml?stn=8452660%20Newport,%20RI&type=Tide+Data
Overwash -
Browning Cottages




                    RE Hehre
Frontal Erosion - Browning Cottages




                                      BA Oakley
Frontal Erosion 1939-2006 -
Browning Cottages


                                 2011




                      2006

                          1939
Charlestown Beach




Overwash




                    RE Hehre
Charlestown Beach – Hurricane Bob 1991
Washover Fan Deposition




  Removal is a Bad Idea …….
   Barriers Naturally Retreat
    Landward and Upward          Aug 1991
Watch Hill – Hurricane Carol, 1954




But… Sometimes there is no alternative

                                         Providence Journal, 1954
A General Coastal Barrier Model for Rhode Island
Napatree Barrier – Westerly, RI



                         Little Narragansett Bay




                                                        Watch Hill




                                             Hehre and Boothroyd, 2007
Napatree Barrier – Shoreline Change Maps

                         2004 – Sound Side
     1939 – Sound Side




                     1939 –      2004 – Ocean Side
                   Ocean Side

                                                 Hehre and Boothroyd, 2007
Tidal
   Datums
   Newport                           MHHW = 3.85 ft

                                3


    “Zero” in some                   NAVD 1988 = 2.05 ft
       data sets                2
                                       MSL = 1.74ft          New MSL
     and on maps
                                       NGVD 1929 = 1.18 ft     Old “MSL”
                                1


                                     MLLW = 0.0 ft
                                0


                                -1

         Adapted from:
 www.ngs.noaa.gov/newsys-cgi-
bin/ngs_opsd.prl?PID=LW0493&E
        POCH=1983-2001
How High
 will the
Water Be?                             Boothroyd and
                                       Hehre 2008



              9.46 Feet Above MHHW



  Tidal
 Heights
 Newport


            MHHW = 3.85 ft




            MLLW = 0.0 ft          Adapted from: www.ngs.noaa.gov/newsys-cgi-
                                 bin/ngs_opsd.prl?PID=LW0493&EPOCH=1983-2001
Frequency?
   Next Month or
     Next Year



Tropical Storm
Irene Aug 2011




                   Adapted from
                      NOAA;
                   USACE 1988;
                    Hehre 2007
Lastly,
 Climate Change
     and the
Future Shore Zone
        of
  Rhode Island
Greenland Outlet Glaciers
Change from Polythermal to Warm Based

 A Key to Future Sea-Level Rise
Brathwaite, 2002
HEIGHT NOW




                      Adapted from:
        http://tidesandcurrents.noaa.gov/sltrends/
sltrends_station.shtml?stnid=8452660%20Newport,%20RI
                                                       Boothroyd 2011
Observed Global Sea Level Rise ... Accelerating


                                                                               IPCC
      18 cm rise since 1900                                                    2001
           Current rate:
                                                                             estimate
       3.3 cm per decade




       Rahmstorf, Cazenave, Church, Hansen, Keeling, Parker and Somerville (Science 2007)
Global Sea Level Linked to Global Temperature

Projection of Sea-Level Rise 1990 - 2100
     Using IPCC 2007 Temperature Projections



                                      Extreme
                                     Projection




                                     IPCC 2007




                                         Vermeer and Rahmstorf, 2009,
                                          PNAS, v106, p 21537-21532
Height above NOW


                                   New
                                 Estimate
                                   Low
3.3 ft                            Range     100 cm




1.1 ft            35 cm




                          2050
Height above NOW
                                     New      140 cm
4.6 ft
                                   Estimate
                                     Mid




1.4 ft            42 cm




                            2050
6.2 ft   Height above NOW                             190 cm
                             New Estimate High Range




1.6 ft                           50 cm




                                         2050
Misquamicut Headland – 100 Yr Hurricane Surge
  + 3 feet Sea
  Level Rise

                                    Present
                                   Outdated
                                   Flood Map
Misquamicut – US 1A – Westerly
 1938 Hurricane - Debris Swath
Debris Swath after                        Barrier
 Sea-Level Rise




                                 Providence Journal, 1938
Ninigret – Green Hill Lagoons
2003 – 2004 Orthophoto


  Today
Ninigret – Green Hill Lagoons
1938 Storm Surge + SL Rise after 1938
         11 ft above MHHW

  Today
Ninigret – Green Hill Lagoons
1938 Storm Surge + SL Rise
    11 ft above MHHW

   Today

                                Frosty
                                Drew




            Foster
           Cove Area
Ninigret – Green Hill Lagoons
2003 – 2004 Orthophoto

 Today
Ninigret – Green Hill Lagoons
 2100 Inundation – 5 ft
200 ft Barrier Migration

  Projected
Ninigret – Green Hill Lagoons
 2100 Inundation – 5 ft
200 ft Barrier Migration

  Projected                     Frosty
                                Drew




      Foster
     Cove Area
Wickford Marketplace – In-Place Inundation “The Bathtub Ring”
  Today




 10 Sept 2010                                      Teresa Crean
End of Presentation
THE HOCKEY STICK              The Message
                                     Temp lags
                                       CO2



       Medieval Warm Period       Little Ice
                                     Age




                                        Moberg et al, 2005

Boothroyd climate change-symposium-18nov2011-final

  • 1.
    CLIMATE CHANGE, COASTAL GEOLOGIC HAZARDS and SEA-LEVEL RISE URI Climate Change Symposium 18 November 2011 Jon C. Boothroyd Rhode Island State Geologist, Research Professor Emeritus – Quaternary Geology ------------- Rhode Island Geological Survey and Department of Geosciences College of the Environment and Life Sciences University of Rhode Island jon_boothroyd@uri.edu
  • 2.
    Southern New England,Long Island, Continental Shelf ~ 26,000 yBP Map Generated By: BA Oakley and JC Boothroyd
  • 3.
    THE LAST NORTHAMERICAN ICE SHEETS CORDILLERAN LAURENTIDE - You are here After Dyke & Prest, 1987
  • 4.
    MALASPINA GLACIER –Northeast Gulf of Alaska - An Analog “The size of Rhode Island”
  • 5.
    Oakley, 2011 You are here Ice margins modified from: Dyke and Prest, 1987 Ridge, 2010; Goss, 1993 Smith, 2010
  • 6.
    Oakley, 2011 Ice margins modified from: Dyke and Prest, 1987 Ridge, 2010; Goss, 1993 Smith, 2010
  • 7.
    Oakley, 2011 Charlestown Moraine Ice margins modified from: Dyke and Prest, 1987 Ridge, 2010; Goss, 1993 Smith, 2010
  • 8.
    Ice margins modifiedfrom: Dyke and Prest, 1987 Ridge, 2010; Goss, 1993 Smith, 2010 Oakley, 2011
  • 9.
    Ice margins modifiedfrom: Dyke and Prest, 1987 Ridge, 2010; Goss, 1993 Smith, 2010 Oakley, 2011
  • 10.
    Oakley, 2011 Ice margins modified from: Dyke and Prest, 1987 Ridge, 2010; Goss, 1993 Smith, 2010
  • 11.
    Eustatic Sea-Level Rise + Isostatic Rebound Laurentide at Ice Sheet? Laurentide 2m.100yr-1 Ice Sheet? Block Island 2m.100yr-1 Antarctic Ice Antarctic Ice Sheet? Sheet? -1 2-5m.100yr 2-5m.100yr-1 Explanation - 390 ft Oakley and Boothroyd, submitted 2011
  • 12.
    -165 ft BeginMeltwater Pulse 1B Post-Glacial Lake Atlantic Ocean
  • 13.
    -130 ft EndMeltwater Pulse 1B Post-Glacial Lake Estuary Atlantic Ocean
  • 14.
    When Contemplating RhodeIsland Coastal Geologic Hazards One Must Consider: • Extratropical Cyclones (“Nor’easters”) • Hurricanes (Tropical Cyclones) • and ……. Sea Level Rise
  • 15.
    When Contemplating RhodeIsland Coastal Geologic Hazards Which Give Rise to these Processes: • Frontal Erosion – from Breaking Waves and Swash • Storm-Surge Overwash • Elevated MHHW into the Future
  • 16.
    When Contemplating RhodeIsland Coastal Geologic Hazards The Scale of Processes are: • Breaking Waves – 3 to 10+ feet at shoreline • Storm-Surge Overwash – 1 to 10+ feet water depth across shore zone • Sea-Level Rise – 0.14 inches per year at present
  • 17.
    The Sea MayBe Rising Long Term – But….. Instantaneous Storm Surges Elevate Sea Level Now
  • 18.
    Narragansett Pier Seawall– Patriots Day 2007 WPRI.com 16 apr 2007
  • 19.
    Patriots Day ExtratropicalStorm – April 2007 Newport Tide Gauge SET UP PREDICTED http://tidesandcurrents.noaa.gov/ STORM SURGE data_menu.shtml?stn=8452660%20Newport,%20RI&type=Tide+Data
  • 20.
  • 21.
    Frontal Erosion -Browning Cottages BA Oakley
  • 22.
    Frontal Erosion 1939-2006- Browning Cottages 2011 2006 1939
  • 23.
  • 24.
    Charlestown Beach –Hurricane Bob 1991 Washover Fan Deposition Removal is a Bad Idea ……. Barriers Naturally Retreat Landward and Upward Aug 1991
  • 25.
    Watch Hill –Hurricane Carol, 1954 But… Sometimes there is no alternative Providence Journal, 1954
  • 26.
    A General CoastalBarrier Model for Rhode Island
  • 27.
    Napatree Barrier –Westerly, RI Little Narragansett Bay Watch Hill Hehre and Boothroyd, 2007
  • 28.
    Napatree Barrier –Shoreline Change Maps 2004 – Sound Side 1939 – Sound Side 1939 – 2004 – Ocean Side Ocean Side Hehre and Boothroyd, 2007
  • 29.
    Tidal Datums Newport MHHW = 3.85 ft 3 “Zero” in some NAVD 1988 = 2.05 ft data sets 2 MSL = 1.74ft New MSL and on maps NGVD 1929 = 1.18 ft Old “MSL” 1 MLLW = 0.0 ft 0 -1 Adapted from: www.ngs.noaa.gov/newsys-cgi- bin/ngs_opsd.prl?PID=LW0493&E POCH=1983-2001
  • 30.
    How High willthe Water Be? Boothroyd and Hehre 2008 9.46 Feet Above MHHW Tidal Heights Newport MHHW = 3.85 ft MLLW = 0.0 ft Adapted from: www.ngs.noaa.gov/newsys-cgi- bin/ngs_opsd.prl?PID=LW0493&EPOCH=1983-2001
  • 31.
    Frequency? Next Month or Next Year Tropical Storm Irene Aug 2011 Adapted from NOAA; USACE 1988; Hehre 2007
  • 32.
    Lastly, Climate Change and the Future Shore Zone of Rhode Island
  • 33.
    Greenland Outlet Glaciers Changefrom Polythermal to Warm Based A Key to Future Sea-Level Rise
  • 34.
  • 35.
    HEIGHT NOW Adapted from: http://tidesandcurrents.noaa.gov/sltrends/ sltrends_station.shtml?stnid=8452660%20Newport,%20RI Boothroyd 2011
  • 36.
    Observed Global SeaLevel Rise ... Accelerating IPCC 18 cm rise since 1900 2001 Current rate: estimate 3.3 cm per decade Rahmstorf, Cazenave, Church, Hansen, Keeling, Parker and Somerville (Science 2007)
  • 37.
    Global Sea LevelLinked to Global Temperature Projection of Sea-Level Rise 1990 - 2100 Using IPCC 2007 Temperature Projections Extreme Projection IPCC 2007 Vermeer and Rahmstorf, 2009, PNAS, v106, p 21537-21532
  • 38.
    Height above NOW New Estimate Low 3.3 ft Range 100 cm 1.1 ft 35 cm 2050
  • 39.
    Height above NOW New 140 cm 4.6 ft Estimate Mid 1.4 ft 42 cm 2050
  • 40.
    6.2 ft Height above NOW 190 cm New Estimate High Range 1.6 ft 50 cm 2050
  • 41.
    Misquamicut Headland –100 Yr Hurricane Surge + 3 feet Sea Level Rise Present Outdated Flood Map
  • 42.
    Misquamicut – US1A – Westerly 1938 Hurricane - Debris Swath Debris Swath after Barrier Sea-Level Rise Providence Journal, 1938
  • 43.
    Ninigret – GreenHill Lagoons 2003 – 2004 Orthophoto Today
  • 44.
    Ninigret – GreenHill Lagoons 1938 Storm Surge + SL Rise after 1938 11 ft above MHHW Today
  • 45.
    Ninigret – GreenHill Lagoons 1938 Storm Surge + SL Rise 11 ft above MHHW Today Frosty Drew Foster Cove Area
  • 46.
    Ninigret – GreenHill Lagoons 2003 – 2004 Orthophoto Today
  • 47.
    Ninigret – GreenHill Lagoons 2100 Inundation – 5 ft 200 ft Barrier Migration Projected
  • 48.
    Ninigret – GreenHill Lagoons 2100 Inundation – 5 ft 200 ft Barrier Migration Projected Frosty Drew Foster Cove Area
  • 49.
    Wickford Marketplace –In-Place Inundation “The Bathtub Ring” Today 10 Sept 2010 Teresa Crean
  • 50.
  • 52.
    THE HOCKEY STICK The Message Temp lags CO2 Medieval Warm Period Little Ice Age Moberg et al, 2005