Practice
Management
Quality Control
Quality Control
 Due skill and Care
Quality Control
 Due skill and Care
              Technical Competence
Quality Control
Quality Control

     Incorrect
   Audit Opinion
       Risk
Quality Control
Quality Control

     Sued for
    Negligence
       Risk
Quality Control
Quality Control
Quality Control
Quality Control


Individual Audit
Quality Control


Individual Audit
Quality Control


Individual Audit   Audit Firm
Quality Control


 Individual Audit   Audit Firm


ISA 220
Isa 220the engagement
key quality control matters on
               partner
Isa 220the engagement
key quality control matters on
                    partner


   • ethical standards are complied with
Isa 220the engagement
key quality control matters on
                    partner


   • ethical standards are complied with
   • independence requirements are met
Isa 220the engagement
key quality control matters on
                    partner


   • ethical standards are complied with
   • independence requirements are met
   • procedures for new engagements
Isa 220the engagement
key quality control matters on
                    partner


   • ethical standards are complied with
   • independence requirements are met
   • procedures for new engagements
   • appropriate audit team
Isa 220the engagement
key quality control matters on
                    partner


   • ethical standards are complied with
   • independence requirements are met
   • procedures for new engagements
   • appropriate audit team
   • appropriate management of team
Isa 220the engagement
key quality control matters on
                    partner


   • ethical standards are complied with
   • independence requirements are met
   • procedures for new engagements
   • appropriate audit team
   • appropriate management of team
   • adequate consultation on difficult matters
Isalisted company
     If audit of
                 220
engagement quality control reviewer
Isalisted company
       If audit of
                   220
engagement quality control reviewer


• objective evaluation of the significant
  judgements
Isalisted company
       If audit of
                   220
engagement quality control reviewer


• objective evaluation of the significant
  judgements
• evaluation of the firm’s independence
Isalisted company
       If audit of
                   220
engagement quality control reviewer


• objective evaluation of the significant
  judgements
• evaluation of the firm’s independence
• audit documentation selected for review
  reflects the work performed
Isalisted company
       If audit of
                   220
engagement quality control reviewer


• objective evaluation of the significant
  judgements
• evaluation of the firm’s independence
• audit documentation selected for review
  reflects the work performed
• Has adequate consultation on difficult
  matters occurred?
Quality Control
Quality Control
Quality Control


Individual Audit
Quality Control


Individual Audit
Quality Control


Individual Audit   Audit Firm
Quality Control


 Individual Audit   Audit Firm


ISA 220
Quality Control


 Individual Audit   Audit Firm


ISA 220             ISQC 1
Quality Control


 Individual Audit                    Audit Firm


ISA 220                             ISQC 1
                     Quality control for firms that perform audits
                    and reviews of financial statements, and other
                     assurance and related services engagements
ISQC 1 each of the
a system in place which addresses
             following :
ISQC 1 each of the
a system in place which addresses
                    following :
   •   Leadership responsibilities for quality
ISQC 1 each of the
a system in place which addresses
                  following :
   • Leadership responsibilities for quality
   • Ethical requirements
ISQC 1 each of the
a system in place which addresses
                  following :
   • Leadership responsibilities for quality
   • Ethical requirements
   • Acceptance and continuance of engagements
ISQC 1 each of the
a system in place which addresses
                  following :
   • Leadership responsibilities for quality
   • Ethical requirements
   • Acceptance and continuance of engagements
   • Human resources
ISQC 1 each of the
a system in place which addresses
                  following :
   • Leadership responsibilities for quality
   • Ethical requirements
   • Acceptance and continuance of engagements
   • Human resources
   • Engagement performance
ISQC 1 each of the
a system in place which addresses
                  following :
   • Leadership responsibilities for quality
   • Ethical requirements
   • Acceptance and continuance of engagements
   • Human resources
   • Engagement performance
   • Monitoring
ISQC 1 each of the
a system in place which addresses
                  following :
   • Leadership responsibilities for quality
   • Ethical requirements
   • Acceptance and continuance of engagements
   • Human resources
   • Engagement performance
   • Monitoring
   • Documentation
ISQC 1 each of the
a system in place which addresses
                  following :
   • Leadership responsibilities for quality
   • Ethical requirements
   • Acceptance and continuance of engagements
   • Human resources
   • Engagement performance
   • Monitoring
   • Documentation
Leadership
Responsibilities
Leadership
   Responsibilities

• Culture of Quality
Leadership
   Responsibilities

• Culture of Quality
• Appropriate experience and authority
Ethical
Requirements
Ethical
     Requirements
• comply with relevant ethical requirements
Ethical
     Requirements
• comply with relevant ethical requirements
• maintain independence & communicate to
  staff (identify threats and safeguards)
Ethical
     Requirements
• comply with relevant ethical requirements
• maintain independence & communicate to
  staff (identify threats and safeguards)
• annual written confirmation from staff of
  compliance policies on independence.
Acceptance and
continuance of
 engagements
Acceptance and
   continuance of
    engagements
• Competent to perform
Acceptance and
   continuance of
    engagements
• Competent to perform
• Capable to do so
Acceptance and
   continuance of
    engagements
• Competent to perform
• Capable to do so
• Considered integrity of client
Acceptance and
   continuance of
    engagements
• Competent to perform
• Capable to do so
• Considered integrity of client
• Consider conflicts of interest
Acceptance and
   continuance of
    engagements
• Competent to perform
• Capable to do so
• Considered integrity of client
• Consider conflicts of interest
• Professional clearance from old auditors
Acceptance and
   continuance of
    engagements
• Competent to perform
• Capable to do so
• Considered integrity of client
• Consider conflicts of interest
• Professional clearance from old auditors
• Anti money laundering procedures
Human
Resources
Human
          Resources
• Sufficient personnel with the competence,
  capabilities and commitment to ethical
  principles
Human
          Resources
• Sufficient personnel with the competence,
  capabilities and commitment to ethical
  principles
• An appropriate engagement partner and
  team are assigned
Human
          Resources
• Sufficient personnel with the competence,
  capabilities and commitment to ethical
  principles
• An appropriate engagement partner and
  team are assigned
• Auditing procedures in a manual
  (reinforced by training)
Engagememt
 Performance
Engagememt
       Performance
• Promote consistent quality engagement
  performance
Engagememt
        Performance
• Promote consistent quality engagement
  performance
• Supervision responsibilities
Engagememt
        Performance
• Promote consistent quality engagement
  performance
• Supervision responsibilities
• Review responsibilities (on the basis that
  more experienced team members
  review the work of less experienced team
  members)
Engagememt
        Performance
• Promote consistent quality engagement
  performance
• Supervision responsibilities
• Review responsibilities (on the basis that
  more experienced team members
  review the work of less experienced team
  members)
Monitoring of
quality control
 procedures
Monitoring of
     quality control
      procedures
• Evaluate if any deficiencies found indicate a
  failing in the firm’s quality control system
Monitoring of
     quality control
      procedures
• Evaluate if any deficiencies found indicate a
  failing in the firm’s quality control system
• Communicate deficiencies to relevant
  personnel, together with appropriate
  remedial action
Direction of Audit
       Staff
Direction of Audit
        Staff
• Their responsibilities
• Nature of the business of the client
  company
• Risk-related issues
• Problems that may arise with the audit and
  how these problems should be dealt with if
  they do occur
Review of Audit
     Work
Review of Audit
     Work
Review of Audit
     Work
Audit
Review of Audit
      Work
  Audit

Hot Review
Review of Audit
      Work
  Audit

Hot Review
Review of Audit
      Work
  Audit      Audit Report

Hot Review
Review of Audit
      Work
  Audit              Audit Report

Hot Review   Post Audit Review
Review of Audit
      Work
  Audit              Audit Report

Hot Review   Post Audit Review
              Audit Manager
              Audit Partner
Review of Audit
      Work
  Audit              Audit Report

Hot Review   Post Audit Review
              Audit Manager
              Audit Partner
Review of Audit
      Work
  Audit              Audit Report

Hot Review   Post Audit Review
              Audit Manager
              Audit Partner

                    Modified Opinion?
Review of Audit
      Work
  Audit              Audit Report

Hot Review   Post Audit Review
              Audit Manager
              Audit Partner

                    Modified Opinion?
             Second Partner Review
Review of Audit
       Work
    Audit             Audit Report

 Hot Review   Post Audit Review
Peer review    Audit Manager
               Audit Partner

                     Modified Opinion?
              Second Partner Review
Review of Audit
       Work
    Audit             Audit Report

 Hot Review   Post Audit Review
Peer review    Audit Manager
               Audit Partner

                     Modified Opinion?
              Second Partner Review
Review of Audit
             Work
         Audit                   Audit Report

      Hot Review         Post Audit Review
     Peer review          Audit Manager
                          Audit Partner
Review by a specialist
    ‘Audit review
                                Modified Opinion?
     department’
                         Second Partner Review
Audit Practice management p7

Audit Practice management p7

  • 1.
  • 2.
  • 3.
    Quality Control Dueskill and Care
  • 4.
    Quality Control Dueskill and Care Technical Competence
  • 5.
  • 6.
    Quality Control Incorrect Audit Opinion Risk
  • 7.
  • 8.
    Quality Control Sued for Negligence Risk
  • 9.
  • 10.
  • 11.
  • 12.
  • 13.
  • 14.
  • 15.
    Quality Control IndividualAudit Audit Firm ISA 220
  • 16.
    Isa 220the engagement keyquality control matters on partner
  • 17.
    Isa 220the engagement keyquality control matters on partner • ethical standards are complied with
  • 18.
    Isa 220the engagement keyquality control matters on partner • ethical standards are complied with • independence requirements are met
  • 19.
    Isa 220the engagement keyquality control matters on partner • ethical standards are complied with • independence requirements are met • procedures for new engagements
  • 20.
    Isa 220the engagement keyquality control matters on partner • ethical standards are complied with • independence requirements are met • procedures for new engagements • appropriate audit team
  • 21.
    Isa 220the engagement keyquality control matters on partner • ethical standards are complied with • independence requirements are met • procedures for new engagements • appropriate audit team • appropriate management of team
  • 22.
    Isa 220the engagement keyquality control matters on partner • ethical standards are complied with • independence requirements are met • procedures for new engagements • appropriate audit team • appropriate management of team • adequate consultation on difficult matters
  • 23.
    Isalisted company If audit of 220 engagement quality control reviewer
  • 24.
    Isalisted company If audit of 220 engagement quality control reviewer • objective evaluation of the significant judgements
  • 25.
    Isalisted company If audit of 220 engagement quality control reviewer • objective evaluation of the significant judgements • evaluation of the firm’s independence
  • 26.
    Isalisted company If audit of 220 engagement quality control reviewer • objective evaluation of the significant judgements • evaluation of the firm’s independence • audit documentation selected for review reflects the work performed
  • 27.
    Isalisted company If audit of 220 engagement quality control reviewer • objective evaluation of the significant judgements • evaluation of the firm’s independence • audit documentation selected for review reflects the work performed • Has adequate consultation on difficult matters occurred?
  • 28.
  • 29.
  • 30.
  • 31.
  • 32.
  • 33.
    Quality Control IndividualAudit Audit Firm ISA 220
  • 34.
    Quality Control IndividualAudit Audit Firm ISA 220 ISQC 1
  • 35.
    Quality Control IndividualAudit Audit Firm ISA 220 ISQC 1 Quality control for firms that perform audits and reviews of financial statements, and other assurance and related services engagements
  • 36.
    ISQC 1 eachof the a system in place which addresses following :
  • 37.
    ISQC 1 eachof the a system in place which addresses following : • Leadership responsibilities for quality
  • 38.
    ISQC 1 eachof the a system in place which addresses following : • Leadership responsibilities for quality • Ethical requirements
  • 39.
    ISQC 1 eachof the a system in place which addresses following : • Leadership responsibilities for quality • Ethical requirements • Acceptance and continuance of engagements
  • 40.
    ISQC 1 eachof the a system in place which addresses following : • Leadership responsibilities for quality • Ethical requirements • Acceptance and continuance of engagements • Human resources
  • 41.
    ISQC 1 eachof the a system in place which addresses following : • Leadership responsibilities for quality • Ethical requirements • Acceptance and continuance of engagements • Human resources • Engagement performance
  • 42.
    ISQC 1 eachof the a system in place which addresses following : • Leadership responsibilities for quality • Ethical requirements • Acceptance and continuance of engagements • Human resources • Engagement performance • Monitoring
  • 43.
    ISQC 1 eachof the a system in place which addresses following : • Leadership responsibilities for quality • Ethical requirements • Acceptance and continuance of engagements • Human resources • Engagement performance • Monitoring • Documentation
  • 44.
    ISQC 1 eachof the a system in place which addresses following : • Leadership responsibilities for quality • Ethical requirements • Acceptance and continuance of engagements • Human resources • Engagement performance • Monitoring • Documentation
  • 45.
  • 46.
    Leadership Responsibilities • Culture of Quality
  • 47.
    Leadership Responsibilities • Culture of Quality • Appropriate experience and authority
  • 48.
  • 49.
    Ethical Requirements • comply with relevant ethical requirements
  • 50.
    Ethical Requirements • comply with relevant ethical requirements • maintain independence & communicate to staff (identify threats and safeguards)
  • 51.
    Ethical Requirements • comply with relevant ethical requirements • maintain independence & communicate to staff (identify threats and safeguards) • annual written confirmation from staff of compliance policies on independence.
  • 52.
  • 53.
    Acceptance and continuance of engagements • Competent to perform
  • 54.
    Acceptance and continuance of engagements • Competent to perform • Capable to do so
  • 55.
    Acceptance and continuance of engagements • Competent to perform • Capable to do so • Considered integrity of client
  • 56.
    Acceptance and continuance of engagements • Competent to perform • Capable to do so • Considered integrity of client • Consider conflicts of interest
  • 57.
    Acceptance and continuance of engagements • Competent to perform • Capable to do so • Considered integrity of client • Consider conflicts of interest • Professional clearance from old auditors
  • 58.
    Acceptance and continuance of engagements • Competent to perform • Capable to do so • Considered integrity of client • Consider conflicts of interest • Professional clearance from old auditors • Anti money laundering procedures
  • 59.
  • 60.
    Human Resources • Sufficient personnel with the competence, capabilities and commitment to ethical principles
  • 61.
    Human Resources • Sufficient personnel with the competence, capabilities and commitment to ethical principles • An appropriate engagement partner and team are assigned
  • 62.
    Human Resources • Sufficient personnel with the competence, capabilities and commitment to ethical principles • An appropriate engagement partner and team are assigned • Auditing procedures in a manual (reinforced by training)
  • 63.
  • 64.
    Engagememt Performance • Promote consistent quality engagement performance
  • 65.
    Engagememt Performance • Promote consistent quality engagement performance • Supervision responsibilities
  • 66.
    Engagememt Performance • Promote consistent quality engagement performance • Supervision responsibilities • Review responsibilities (on the basis that more experienced team members review the work of less experienced team members)
  • 67.
    Engagememt Performance • Promote consistent quality engagement performance • Supervision responsibilities • Review responsibilities (on the basis that more experienced team members review the work of less experienced team members)
  • 68.
  • 69.
    Monitoring of quality control procedures • Evaluate if any deficiencies found indicate a failing in the firm’s quality control system
  • 70.
    Monitoring of quality control procedures • Evaluate if any deficiencies found indicate a failing in the firm’s quality control system • Communicate deficiencies to relevant personnel, together with appropriate remedial action
  • 71.
  • 72.
    Direction of Audit Staff • Their responsibilities • Nature of the business of the client company • Risk-related issues • Problems that may arise with the audit and how these problems should be dealt with if they do occur
  • 73.
  • 74.
  • 75.
    Review of Audit Work Audit
  • 76.
    Review of Audit Work Audit Hot Review
  • 77.
    Review of Audit Work Audit Hot Review
  • 78.
    Review of Audit Work Audit Audit Report Hot Review
  • 79.
    Review of Audit Work Audit Audit Report Hot Review Post Audit Review
  • 80.
    Review of Audit Work Audit Audit Report Hot Review Post Audit Review Audit Manager Audit Partner
  • 81.
    Review of Audit Work Audit Audit Report Hot Review Post Audit Review Audit Manager Audit Partner
  • 82.
    Review of Audit Work Audit Audit Report Hot Review Post Audit Review Audit Manager Audit Partner Modified Opinion?
  • 83.
    Review of Audit Work Audit Audit Report Hot Review Post Audit Review Audit Manager Audit Partner Modified Opinion? Second Partner Review
  • 84.
    Review of Audit Work Audit Audit Report Hot Review Post Audit Review Peer review Audit Manager Audit Partner Modified Opinion? Second Partner Review
  • 85.
    Review of Audit Work Audit Audit Report Hot Review Post Audit Review Peer review Audit Manager   Audit Partner Modified Opinion? Second Partner Review
  • 86.
    Review of Audit Work Audit Audit Report Hot Review Post Audit Review Peer review Audit Manager   Audit Partner Review by a specialist ‘Audit review Modified Opinion? department’ Second Partner Review