The document outlines grading criteria for a two-part portfolio assignment on a scale of 90-100 (exceptional pass) to 20-29 (needs significant revision to pass). Criteria include fulfillment of learning outcomes, use of examples from weekly readings, explanation of the selection process, identification and understanding of key points, justification for the second article choice, writing standards, referencing, and presentation/organization. Higher scores are given for more in-depth coverage of topics, insightful understanding, clear explanation and justification, excellent writing mechanics and few errors. Lower scores involve partial or non-fulfillment of criteria.