SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 17
Download to read offline
Doctoral Student Workshop: Contributions vs. Significance
Source: Miles, D.A. and Scott, L. (2017) Workshop: Confessions of a Dissertation Chair Part 1: The Six Mistakes Doctoral Students
Make With the Dissertation. Presented at the 5th Annual 2017 Black Doctoral Network Conference in Atlanta, GA on October 26-29
2017.
1
Let’s Stop the Madness Part 3:
Understanding the Difference Between
Contributions of the Study vs.
Significance of the Study
D. Anthony Miles
ABSTRACT
The purpose of this article is to provide some clear distinctions and insight on the differences
between the contributions of the study and the significance of the study. This is a common
confusion between the two terms and is even more confusing explaining them in the study. There
is a tendency to use the terms synonymously. I see this confusion at a prevalent level with both
novice and experienced researchers. Thus, this article tries to provide some clear understanding
of the two terms and provides some clear definitions and examples of them both.
This article provides some practical importance to researchers in social sciences. This article
provides some valuable knowledge and give the researcher guidance using the correct use of
these two terms. The objective of this article is threefold. First, the article provides some clear
definitions on contributions of the study and significance of the study. Second, this article
provides clear examples of the differences and characteristics between the two terms. Last, this
article provides examples from articles and studies using of the two terms. This article will
provide much needed clarity to many researchers that are confused by the two terms and how to
use them in the proper context.
Doctoral Student Workshop: Contributions vs. Significance
Source: Miles, D.A. and Scott, L. (2017) Workshop: Confessions of a Dissertation Chair Part 1: The Six Mistakes Doctoral Students
Make With the Dissertation. Presented at the 5th Annual 2017 Black Doctoral Network Conference in Atlanta, GA on October 26-29
2017.
2
Introduction
In my many years of working with doctoral students, I have found there is still another
prevailing confusion among them. There is substantial confusion between the terms,
contributions of the study and significance of the study. This is so common that I have seen this
be the case with both experienced researchers and novice researchers. This is most common
with doctoral students. Again, as professors we need to do a better job with assisting students
on understanding the differences between these two terms.
One of prevailing issues is they did not properly understand these concepts in their research
methods courses. They either have never learned the differences between the two terms or they
assume they are the same. It shows when they write their dissertations. However, help is on the
way. I think we have found a useful definition and examples to help doctoral students and
novice researchers understand the differences between the two terms.
The outline of the article will provide information on the differences between the two terms.
First, the article will provide clear definitions of the contributions of the study and significance
of the study. This article discusses the differences and definitions between the terms, the
contributions of the study and the significance of the study. Second, the article will provide
some examples of how to use them in a sentence and paragraph. This article discusses the three
significance types of the study. Last, the article discusses the three types of research
significance. The article will provide examples of them from journal articles and studies.
Doctoral Student Workshop: Contributions vs. Significance
Source: Miles, D.A. and Scott, L. (2017) Workshop: Confessions of a Dissertation Chair Part 1: The Six Mistakes Doctoral Students
Make With the Dissertation. Presented at the 5th Annual 2017 Black Doctoral Network Conference in Atlanta, GA on October 26-29
2017.
3
What is the Definition of Contributions of a Study?
The contributions of a study describe how the study will contribute to the body of
knowledge. There are three types of contributions of the study: (a) Conceptual/Theoretical,
(b) Empirical, and (c) Methodological. These three contributions define most research
contributions in a study (see Figure 1).
Figure 1 The Three Types of Research Contributions of Study
RESEARCH
CONTRIBUTIONS
Conceptual/
Theoretical
Methodological
Empirical
Doctoral Student Workshop: Contributions vs. Significance
Source: Miles, D.A. and Scott, L. (2017) Workshop: Confessions of a Dissertation Chair Part 1: The Six Mistakes Doctoral Students
Make With the Dissertation. Presented at the 5th Annual 2017 Black Doctoral Network Conference in Atlanta, GA on October 26-29
2017.
4
Conceptual/Theoretical Contributions
The conceptual (theoretical) contribution of a study involve contributions such as: (a)
improved conceptual definitions of the original constructs; (b) the identification and
conceptual definition of additional constructs to be added to the conceptual framework (e.g.,
additional dependent, independent, mediating, and/or moderator variables); (c) the
development of additional theoretical linkages (e.g., research hypotheses) with their
accompanying rationale; and (d) the development of improved theoretical rationale for
existing linkages (Summers, 2006; Asgari, 2015; Miles, 2019).
Empirical Contributions
The empirical contribution of a study involve contributions such as: (a) testing a theoretical
linkage between two constructs that has not previously been tested; (b) examining the
effects of a potential moderator variable on the nature of the relationship between two
constructs; (c) determining the degree to which a variable mediates the relationship between
two constructs; and (d) investigating the psychometric properties of an important scale
(Summers, 2006; Asgari, 2015; Miles, 2019).
Methodological Contributions
The methodological contribution of a study involve contributions such as: (a) reduce the
potential problems with shared method variance through the insightful use of multiple
methods of measurement; (b) increase the generalizability of the research through more
appropriate sampling procedures; (c) allow the investigation of the plausibility of "third-
variable explanations" for the results of past studies; and (d) enhance the construct validity
of key measures through the use of refined multiple-item measures and/or the use of
measurement approaches that do not rely on self-reports (Summers, 2006; Asgari, 2015;
Miles, 2019).
Other Research Contributions
These are rare contributions and rarely used except for special situations. Applied
Contribution refers to when a theoretical model applies in a different industry which hasn't
been empirically tested earlier. Survey Contributions are attempts to review and synthesize
work done in a research field with the goal of exposing trends, themes, and gaps in the
literature (Asgari, 2015). See The Statement Grid (Tables 1 and 2 on p. 5) on the examples of
writing the contributions of the study.
Doctoral Student Workshop: Contributions vs. Significance
Source: Miles, D.A. and Scott, L. (2017) Workshop: Confessions of a Dissertation Chair Part 1: The Six Mistakes Doctoral Students
Make With the Dissertation. Presented at the 5th Annual 2017 Black Doctoral Network Conference in Atlanta, GA on October 26-29
2017.
5
Table 1. Introducing: The Statement Grid – for Contributions of the Study
Overall Statement:
“The researcher identified a key contribution of this study. This study makes two key
________________ contributions.”
Contribution 1:
First, this study makes a contribution by
offering a _______________________ that is
lacking in the prior research that primarily
focused on________________________.
Contribution 2:
Second, this study offers
a__________________________ line of
inquiry that was not addressed in the prior
research. This study attempts to address the
potential problems in the prior studies with a
____________ through the insightful use of
________________________.
Table 2. The Statement Grid – Example for Contributions of the Study
Overall Statement:
“The researcher identified a key contribution of this study. This study makes a methodological
contribution. This study makes two key methodological contributions.”
Contribution 1:
First, this study makes a contribution by
offering a qualitative inquiry that is lacking in
the prior research that primarily focused on
empirical research.
Contribution 2:
Second, this study offers a divergent line of
inquiry that was not addressed in the prior
research. This study attempts to address the
potential problems in the prior studies with
shared method variance through the insightful
use of multiple methods of inquiry.
See the actual examples (see Examples 1 to 3) beginning on page 6. These provide some
examples of writing the contribution of the study.
Doctoral Student Workshop: Contributions vs. Significance
Source: Miles, D.A. and Scott, L. (2017) Workshop: Confessions of a Dissertation Chair Part 1: The Six Mistakes Doctoral Students
Make With the Dissertation. Presented at the 5th Annual 2017 Black Doctoral Network Conference in Atlanta, GA on October 26-29
2017.
6
[Example 1]
The researcher identified two contributions of this study. First, this study will make a conceptual
contribution to the field of leadership and management studies. This study hopes to contribute to
the theory of leadership and body of knowledge. Many researchers have explored the impact of
leaders ‘behavior on their employees. Many of these studies deal with leadership styles and how
employees respond to their managers ’actions. The results of such studies indicated that
“employees would respond to the manager’s actions with attitudes reflecting their perception of a
supervisor’s leadership style” (Mulki, Caemmerer & Heggde, 2015, p.6). Kim (2014) suggested
that leaders set the tone and atmosphere in the organization, therefore defining the organization
culture. This study will contribute to the development of additional theoretical linkages (e.g.,
research hypotheses) with their accompanying rationale.
The second contribution will be methodological. This study makes contribution by providing a
divergent research method variance through the insightful use of multiple methods of
measurement. A qualitative line of inquiry is lacking in the prior research. Some of these
unexplored research methods appear to be important and worthy of investigation in the context
of management and job performance. Yoonk Jik & Poister (2014) also asserted that by engaging
employees in building a team work environment, this could be a leading factor towards
increasing organization performance and sustainability. An investigation of these issues is
important because there is a dearth in prior research that approaches this topic from a qualitative
line of inquiry. Furthermore, the previous empirical research has focused primarily on
quantitative methodology and assessment. Very little research has contributed from a qualitative
line of inquiry [Platt, 2019].
Doctoral Student Workshop: Contributions vs. Significance
Source: Miles, D.A. and Scott, L. (2017) Workshop: Confessions of a Dissertation Chair Part 1: The Six Mistakes Doctoral Students
Make With the Dissertation. Presented at the 5th Annual 2017 Black Doctoral Network Conference in Atlanta, GA on October 26-29
2017.
7
[Example 2]
The researcher identified a major contribution of this study. First, this study will offer a much-
needed empirical contribution. This study makes two important empirical contributions. First, the
research uses archival data maintained by the state for public access to make connections. This
information is stored specifically for research purposes as shown in the Appendix F. This
facilitates the use of larger amounts of data and greater populations.
Second, this study will contribute to the empirical evidence for the requirement of a student’s
socio-intellectual development in the high school setting. This research maybe appropriate for
understanding the impact that precise character and behavioral skills have on student interactions
with peers, adults and their studies. Additionally, the need for a specific, codified character
education curriculum may be indicated from the results of the study. Further evidence may be
provided that character education may positively impact student success outside the classroom
[Zeig, 2019].
Doctoral Student Workshop: Contributions vs. Significance
Source: Miles, D.A. and Scott, L. (2017) Workshop: Confessions of a Dissertation Chair Part 1: The Six Mistakes Doctoral Students
Make With the Dissertation. Presented at the 5th Annual 2017 Black Doctoral Network Conference in Atlanta, GA on October 26-29
2017.
8
[Example 3]
The researcher identified a key contribution of this study. This study makes a methodological
contribution. This study makes two key methodological contributions. First, this study makes a
contribution by offering a qualitative inquiry that is lacking in the prior research that primarily
focused on empirical research. Second, this study offers a divergent line of inquiry that was not
addressed in the prior research. This study attempts to address the potential problems in the prior
studies with shared method variance through the insightful use of multiple methods of inquiry.
In addition, this study encompasses on several unexplored dimensions that lately have attracted
research attention and calls for another research method (Harris, 2013; Steele, 2018). Some of
these unexplored research methods appear to be important and worthy of investigation in the
context of technostress and job performance. An investigation of these issues is important
because there is a dearth in prior research that approaches this topic from a qualitative line of
inquiry. Furthermore, the previous empirical research has focused primarily on quantitative
methodology and assessment. Very little research has made a contribution from a qualitative line
of inquiry [Beltran, 2019].
Doctoral Student Workshop: Contributions vs. Significance
Source: Miles, D.A. and Scott, L. (2017) Workshop: Confessions of a Dissertation Chair Part 1: The Six Mistakes Doctoral Students
Make With the Dissertation. Presented at the 5th Annual 2017 Black Doctoral Network Conference in Atlanta, GA on October 26-29
2017.
9
What is the Definition of Significance of a Study?
A second problem that doctoral students have is with the meaning of significance. Many doctoral
students have considerable trouble writing and supporting the significance statement in the
dissertation proposal. The reasons stem from a poor research objective. The significance
statement gives plausible rationale as to why the study matters.
This is a very important section of the proposal. The significance is an explanation why the
proposed study is important why it represents potential contribution the field. Its emphasis
should be on why the study is worthwhile (Webster, 1998). The significance of the study is your
argument that the study makes a significant and original contribution to profession, the scholarly
literature and your discipline. The significance of the study answers questions related to why the
topic is worth studying (Calabrese, 2006). You offer reasons and arguments pertaining to why
your study is important. The reasons may be confined to the potential that your study will add
new knowledge to existing information about your area of interest. These reasons relate to how
practioners behave in carrying out their work (Bryant, 2004).
With significance, the researcher describes how the study: (a) contributes to existing research,
(b) benefits participants, (c) contributes to practice, and (d) generates new theory. If the
significance of the study is presented in the dissertation proposal, the researcher is speculative,
theorizing his or her contributions in these four areas (Calabrese, 2009)
It provides answers as to why your study is important and how it will add something to the body
of knowledge. There are three key points of the significance statement: (a) So, why is this
research important; (b) How does this research contribute to the body of knowledge; and (c)
How does this research contribute to the practice and field?
The significance of a study describes why this study is important. There are three types of
contributions of the study: (a) Theoretical Significance, (b) Practical Significance, and (c)
Research Significance. These three types of significance in a study (see Figure 2).
Doctoral Student Workshop: Contributions vs. Significance
Source: Miles, D.A. and Scott, L. (2017) Workshop: Confessions of a Dissertation Chair Part 1: The Six Mistakes Doctoral Students
Make With the Dissertation. Presented at the 5th Annual 2017 Black Doctoral Network Conference in Atlanta, GA on October 26-29
2017.
10
Figure 2 The Three Types of Significance in a Study
Theoretical Significance
This type of significance is important because it focuses on adding new knowledge or theory to
the body of knowledge into the field. The significance of the study is your argument that the
study makes a significant and original contribution to the scholarly literature and your discipline.
The significance of the study is your argument that the study makes a significant and original
contribution to the scholarly literature and your discipline. (Calabrese, 2009; Miles, 2019;
Webster, 1998).
Practical Significance
This type of significance is important because it focuses on the impact of your results on the
profession or on the solution of practical problems (Madsen, 1990). These reasons relate to how
practioners behave in carrying out their work (Bryant, 2004). The significance of the study is
your argument that the study makes a significant contribution to profession. The key factor here
is how your research contributes in terms of to the practice (Calabrese, 2009).
SIGNIFICANCE
Practical
Significance
Theoretical
Significance
Research
Significance
Doctoral Student Workshop: Contributions vs. Significance
Source: Miles, D.A. and Scott, L. (2017) Workshop: Confessions of a Dissertation Chair Part 1: The Six Mistakes Doctoral Students
Make With the Dissertation. Presented at the 5th Annual 2017 Black Doctoral Network Conference in Atlanta, GA on October 26-29
2017.
11
Research Significance
This type of significance is important because it focuses on the importance of your study and
how it is important from a research perspective. Research significance is usually one of three
types below. There are three components of research significance: (a) continuation; (b)
extension; and (c) new inquiry (Miles, 2017).
(a) Continuation. A continuation is the type of research significance that continues the prior
research with the same or similar population. This would be also be called a replication
study (Miles, 2016a).
(b) Extension. An extension is the type of significance that used is when you are extending
the prior research or theory to a new, underserved or under researched population.
Normally you are applying to prior established theory or conceptual framework or
research methodology to a new population (Miles, 2016a).
(c) New Inquiry. A new inquiry is the type of significance that is used when you are
conducting a new study (brand new), it is with a new theory and/or new population; or
new research method and design. you are doing something new (ibid).
This significance is the selling point of why your study is important You should craft your
significance carefully and conservatively. See The Statement Grid (Table 3 on p. 12) on the
examples of writing significance.
Doctoral Student Workshop: Contributions vs. Significance
Source: Miles, D.A. and Scott, L. (2017) Workshop: Confessions of a Dissertation Chair Part 1: The Six Mistakes Doctoral Students
Make With the Dissertation. Presented at the 5th Annual 2017 Black Doctoral Network Conference in Atlanta, GA on October 26-29
2017.
12
Table 3. The Statement Grid – The Significance of the Study
Overall Statement: “As a basis for this study, the researcher identified three major reasons
why this study is significant.”
Significance 1: First, this
study is important because
provides a theoretical
significance. This study
breaks some new ground in
management and human
resources theory. Many
nursing program deans and
administrators of how nursing
faculty experience job
satisfaction in order to
facilitate a workplace
conducive of job satisfaction
(theoretical significance).
Significance 2: Second, this
study is important because it
also provides a practical
significance. This research
attempts to provide insight to
practicing nurses considering
a transition to a role in
nursing education by
elucidating experiences of job
satisfaction by nursing faculty
(practical significance).
Significance 3: Last, this
study is important because it
also provides research
significance. This study is
important because it is a
replication study or a
continuation. This study is a
continuation of the prior
research on the nursing
shortage. This study will
replicate a prior study by
Shaw and Cruz (2014). This
study will provide additional
insight on the shortage and
inform the nursing
professorate of the current
lived experiences of job
satisfaction by nursing faculty
teaching classroom and
clinical education of
baccalaureate nursing
students (Cook, 2017).
(research significance).
See the actual examples (see Examples 4 to 6) beginning on page 13. These provide some
examples of writing the significance of the study.
Doctoral Student Workshop: Contributions vs. Significance
Source: Miles, D.A. and Scott, L. (2017) Workshop: Confessions of a Dissertation Chair Part 1: The Six Mistakes Doctoral Students
Make With the Dissertation. Presented at the 5th Annual 2017 Black Doctoral Network Conference in Atlanta, GA on October 26-29
2017.
13
[Example 4]
Based on the literature, there are two main reasons why this study is significant, research and
practical. First, this study provides research significance. This study is an extension of the prior
research on technostress among academics working in universities in India (Jena & Mahanti,
2014). This study is extending the prior research to a new population, (U.S. higher education
employees). This study is important because the study’s results will show differences in the
extent of technostress experienced based on the technology awareness, demographic factors, and
job characteristics of higher education workers.
In addition, the proposed study is an extension of the prior research on demographic differences
in technostress conducted by Jena and Mahanti (2014). The researchers utilized the technostress-
demographic model for investigating the effects of technology awareness, gender, age, tenure,
and marital status on technostress of academics working in universities in India (Jena & Mahanti,
2014). Jena and Mahanti (2014) called for future research to include a more diverse sample
within higher education, as well as investigate relationships between technostress and additional
demographic factors. This study, therefore, includes both academic and non-academic roles for
investigation and extends the technostress-demographic model by including additional
demographic factors and job characteristics.
In prior technostress research, technostress has been found to negatively affect job satisfaction
and job performance (Kumar, Singh, & Bhuchar, 2017; Tagurum, Okonoda, Miner, Bello, &
Tagurum, 2017). This study, therefore, may achieve research significance because it can provide
new information germane to some factors potentially affecting or contributing related to
technostress of in this population, and based on past technostress research, can be used as
justification for developing programs for mitigating the effects of technostress among U.S.
higher education workers.. Conducting this study may also open up new inquiries into further
technostress research within the higher education realm such as how technostress affects
technology acceptance and organizational effectiveness among this population.
Second, this study provides practical significance. This study is essential because if results reveal
statistically significant differences in the extent of technostress based on technology awareness,
demographic factors, and job characteristics, these results can become helpful for designing
programs for lessening the effects or preventing technostress in U.S. higher education
employees. In other populations, technostress has been linked to absenteeism, lower productivity
and job satisfaction, and costly mistakes (Chiappetta, 2017). This study offers practical
significance to those in the field who may experience technology related stress to the extent that
it negatively affects work-related progress. These examples demonstrate how addressing the
problem of to what extent technology-related stress differs based on technology awareness,
demographic factors, employment status, and department in the U.S. higher education population
can add value to this population by making their institutions more aware of the problem
potentially prompting the creation of better-coping programs, as well as reducing the costs
associated with lost revenue due to technostress (Galluch et al., 2015). [Cornish, 2019].
Doctoral Student Workshop: Contributions vs. Significance
Source: Miles, D.A. and Scott, L. (2017) Workshop: Confessions of a Dissertation Chair Part 1: The Six Mistakes Doctoral Students
Make With the Dissertation. Presented at the 5th Annual 2017 Black Doctoral Network Conference in Atlanta, GA on October 26-29
2017.
14
[Example 5]
The researcher found two major reasons why this study is significant. First, this study offers a
theoretical significance. This study breaks new ground by introducing the parental perception of
parental involvement with schools into the existing framework of the phenomenon. This study is
important because through identification of the parental perspective on their involvement in
school to support the education of their children, school systems may be able to use the
information to address the issue of parental involvement more effectively.
Lastly, the study offers a research significance by extending research to the under researched
parent population through an investigation into their perceptions of parental involvement in
school. This study is an extension of the prior research on the topic. The study is significant
because it will extend the prior research to the new and under-researched population of parents
[Forbes, 2019].
Doctoral Student Workshop: Contributions vs. Significance
Source: Miles, D.A. and Scott, L. (2017) Workshop: Confessions of a Dissertation Chair Part 1: The Six Mistakes Doctoral Students
Make With the Dissertation. Presented at the 5th Annual 2017 Black Doctoral Network Conference in Atlanta, GA on October 26-29
2017.
15
[Example 6]
As a foundation for this investigation, there are three major reasons why this study is significant.
First, this study provides a theoretical significance. The contribution of this study will add to the
field of management in theory and practice. This study will test the linkage between two
constructs; the air transportation organization, and the geographical location of Puerto Rico not
previously been tested. The foundation theories in this study are the Douglas McGregor’s Theory
X and Theory Y. Miner (2002) stated that this theory has a lack of investigation and need to be
tested. Douglas McGregor's Theory X and Theory Y of management remain virtually untested
(Schein, 2011). Due to the lack of published studies related to the theories, a study testing
McGregor's Theory X and Y with field data would be an important theoretical contribution to the
body of knowledge (Sahin, 2012). This study will allow the researcher to examine and compare
the results of the data from air transportation organizations in Puerto Rico.
Second, this study also offers a practical significance. It is significant to the field of management
practices and the relation with employees. This study will identify if there is a relationship
between leaders’ openness to new business strategies, customer and market focus, and
employee’s empowerment with the organizational performance of air transportation companies
located in Puerto Rico. There are studies that demonstrate the relationship of the variables;
however, none of these studies are related to air transportation companies located in the
geographical area of Puerto Rico. Although there are studies in other industry sectors such as
health care (Lin, Liao, Chen, & Fan, 2014) and the bank industry (Abbasi, Khan, & Rashid,
2011), it cannot be assumed the behavior of the variables will be the same in the air
transportation sector located in Puerto Rico.
Last, this study also offers a research significance as it is an extension of the prior research. This
study will extend prior research to a new population and new industry sector. This study will
contribute to the field of knowledge by extending and enhancing research related to the air
transportation organizations’ performance. The new population on which this study will be
conducted is employees in Puerto Rico. The new industry sector to which this study will extend
is the air transportation organization. This study will fill the gaps presented by conducting
research in air transportation organizations, by conducting research in the geographical location
of Puerto Rico, extending current studies about the correlation between customer and market
focus, employee empowerment, leaders’ openness to new business strategies, and organizational
performance. The investigation will demonstrate the behavior of the variables in study regarding
correlation as similar studies shown in previous researches in other geographical locations
[Morales, 2019].
Doctoral Student Workshop: Contributions vs. Significance
Source: Miles, D.A. and Scott, L. (2017) Workshop: Confessions of a Dissertation Chair Part 1: The Six Mistakes Doctoral Students
Make With the Dissertation. Presented at the 5th Annual 2017 Black Doctoral Network Conference in Atlanta, GA on October 26-29
2017.
16
Conclusions and Summary
This article discussed the differences and definitions between the terms, the contributions of the
study and the significance of the study. This article addressed the two key differences between
the contributions of the study and the significance of the study. First, this article addressed three
key contributions of the study: (a) conceptual/theoretical, (b) empirical, and (c) methodological.
The definition and examples of the three types of contributions of were illustrated.
Last, this article addressed three significance types of the study: (a) theoretical significance, (b)
practical significance, and (c) research significance. The definition and examples of the three
types of significance of were illustrated. In addition, the article discussed the three types of
research significance: (a) continuation, (b) extension, and (c) new inquiry.
We hope this article will act as a guide for helping novice and experienced researchers learn and
understand the district differences between the contributions of the study and the significance of
the study. The researchers hope to build a strong foundation for enlightening both experienced
and novice researchers on the two terms and lessen the confusion.
Doctoral Student Workshop: Contributions vs. Significance
Source: Miles, D.A. and Scott, L. (2017) Workshop: Confessions of a Dissertation Chair Part 1: The Six Mistakes Doctoral Students
Make With the Dissertation. Presented at the 5th Annual 2017 Black Doctoral Network Conference in Atlanta, GA on October 26-29
2017.
17
References
Beltran, V. (2019). A Phenomenological Study of Central Texas Urban School Principals’
Experience of Influences Contributing to Job Stress from ProQuest Dissertations and
Theses database. (UMI No.-To be announced).
Bryant, M.T. (2004). The Portable Dissertation Advisor (1st
Ed). Thousand Oaks, CA: Corwin
Press.
Calabrese, R. (2006). The Elements of An Effective Dissertation & Thesis: A Step-by-Step Guide
to Getting it Right the First Time. Process (1st
Ed). Lanham, MA: Rowman & Littlefield
Education.
Calabrese, R. (2009). The Dissertation Desk Reference: The Doctoral Student’s Manual to
Writing the Dissertation (1st
Ed). Lanham, MA: Rowman & Littlefield Education.
Cook, L. (2017). The Current Issues Affecting Job Satisfaction by Nursing Faculty as a
Lived Experience. from ProQuest Dissertations and Theses database. (UMI No.: To
be announced).
Cornish, D. (2019). An Empirical Study of Technostress Within the US Higher Education
Sector from ProQuest Dissertations and Theses database. (UMI No.: To be
announced).
Forbes, S. (2019). Parental Involvement in Education: The Lived Experience from ProQuest
Dissertations and Theses database. (UMI No. 87569869).
Madsen, D. (1990). Successful Dissertations and Theses: A Guide To Graduate Student
Research From Proposal To Completion. San Francisco, CA: Jossey-Bass Publishers.
Miles, D.A. & Scott, L. (2017). Workshop: Confessions of a Dissertation Chair Part 1: The
Six Mistakes Doctoral Students Make With the Dissertation. Presented at the 5th
Annual 2017 Black Doctoral Network Conference in Atlanta, GA on October 26-29
2017.
Morales, L. (2019). A Baldrige Assessment of an Organization: An Empirical Study of
Baldrige Criteria and Organizational Performance in Air Transportation
Organizations. from ProQuest Dissertations and Theses database. (UMI No.
6529858).
Platt, P. (2019). An Investigation of Leadership Styles and Managerial Practices within the
Federal Government: A Qualitative Study of the Transportation Security
Administration (TSA) from ProQuest Dissertations and Theses database. (UMI No:
To be announced).
Webster, W. (1998). 21 Models for Developing and Writing Theses, Dissertations and Projects:
A Manual of Sound Advice About Conceptualizing, Organizing, Developing and
Finalizing Your Terminal Graduate Research. Surviving Your Dissertation: A
Comprehensive Guide To Content and Process (1st
Ed). San Ramon, CA: Academic
Scholarwrite.
Zeig, M. (2019). Effects of a Character Education Course on Standardized Testing in Texas
High Schools from ProQuest Dissertations and Theses database. (UMI No.
unknown).
.

More Related Content

Similar to ARTICLE Quot Let S Stop The Madness Part 3 Understanding The Difference Between Contributions Of The Study Vs. Significance Of The Study

Discussion 3 Evaluating Research Questions, Hypotheses, and Qua.docx
Discussion 3 Evaluating Research Questions, Hypotheses, and Qua.docxDiscussion 3 Evaluating Research Questions, Hypotheses, and Qua.docx
Discussion 3 Evaluating Research Questions, Hypotheses, and Qua.docxelinoraudley582231
 
Chao Wrote Some trends that influence human resource are, Leade.docx
Chao Wrote Some trends that influence human resource are, Leade.docxChao Wrote Some trends that influence human resource are, Leade.docx
Chao Wrote Some trends that influence human resource are, Leade.docxsleeperharwell
 
Chao Wrote Some trends that influence human resource are, Leade.docx
Chao Wrote Some trends that influence human resource are, Leade.docxChao Wrote Some trends that influence human resource are, Leade.docx
Chao Wrote Some trends that influence human resource are, Leade.docxketurahhazelhurst
 
ENG333 Week 8 writing the method and results
ENG333 Week 8 writing the method and resultsENG333 Week 8 writing the method and results
ENG333 Week 8 writing the method and resultsDr. Russell Rodrigo
 
Assignment 2 RA Annotated BibliographyThe foundation of a rese.docx
Assignment 2 RA Annotated BibliographyThe foundation of a rese.docxAssignment 2 RA Annotated BibliographyThe foundation of a rese.docx
Assignment 2 RA Annotated BibliographyThe foundation of a rese.docxrock73
 
Essent of Nursing homework help.docx
Essent of Nursing homework help.docxEssent of Nursing homework help.docx
Essent of Nursing homework help.docx4934bk
 
1 quantitative research study critiquestudent namewalden
1 quantitative research study critiquestudent namewalden 1 quantitative research study critiquestudent namewalden
1 quantitative research study critiquestudent namewalden abhi353063
 
Researchers consider validity and reliability with each new study th.docx
Researchers consider validity and reliability with each new study th.docxResearchers consider validity and reliability with each new study th.docx
Researchers consider validity and reliability with each new study th.docxbrittneyj3
 
EDUC 8102-6: Applied Research and Adult Learn
EDUC 8102-6: Applied Research and Adult LearnEDUC 8102-6: Applied Research and Adult Learn
EDUC 8102-6: Applied Research and Adult Learneckchela
 
PAGE 52What is Action ResearchViaA review of the Literat.docx
PAGE  52What is Action ResearchViaA review of the Literat.docxPAGE  52What is Action ResearchViaA review of the Literat.docx
PAGE 52What is Action ResearchViaA review of the Literat.docxgerardkortney
 
Lestremau Session 2: Evaluating Info and Intro to Annotated Bibliographies
Lestremau Session 2: Evaluating Info and Intro to Annotated BibliographiesLestremau Session 2: Evaluating Info and Intro to Annotated Bibliographies
Lestremau Session 2: Evaluating Info and Intro to Annotated BibliographiesElizabeth Johns
 
ARTICLE REVIEW INSTRUCTIONSYou will write an article review-relevant t.docx
ARTICLE REVIEW INSTRUCTIONSYou will write an article review-relevant t.docxARTICLE REVIEW INSTRUCTIONSYou will write an article review-relevant t.docx
ARTICLE REVIEW INSTRUCTIONSYou will write an article review-relevant t.docxnoel23456789
 
CHAPTER 10 MIXED METHODS PROCEDURESHow would you write a mixed m
CHAPTER 10 MIXED METHODS PROCEDURESHow would you write a mixed mCHAPTER 10 MIXED METHODS PROCEDURESHow would you write a mixed m
CHAPTER 10 MIXED METHODS PROCEDURESHow would you write a mixed mEstelaJeffery653
 
College of Doctoral StudiesRES-811 Topic 7 S.docx
College of Doctoral StudiesRES-811 Topic 7 S.docxCollege of Doctoral StudiesRES-811 Topic 7 S.docx
College of Doctoral StudiesRES-811 Topic 7 S.docxmadlynplamondon
 
1_Q2-PRACTICAL-RESEARCH.pptx
1_Q2-PRACTICAL-RESEARCH.pptx1_Q2-PRACTICAL-RESEARCH.pptx
1_Q2-PRACTICAL-RESEARCH.pptxGeraldRefil3
 
STDEV . I3.pdf
STDEV . I3.pdfSTDEV . I3.pdf
STDEV . I3.pdfmaxinesfiles2
 
For this Assignment you articulate how you will use research to .docx
For this Assignment you articulate how you will use research to .docxFor this Assignment you articulate how you will use research to .docx
For this Assignment you articulate how you will use research to .docxtemplestewart19
 
Week 9 Data Analysis Resources Readings 
Week 9 Data Analysis Resources Readings Week 9 Data Analysis Resources Readings 
Week 9 Data Analysis Resources Readings lorileemcclatchie
 
Running Head ANNOTATED BIBLIOGRAPHY 1ANNOTATED BIBLIOGRAP.docx
Running Head ANNOTATED BIBLIOGRAPHY 1ANNOTATED BIBLIOGRAP.docxRunning Head ANNOTATED BIBLIOGRAPHY 1ANNOTATED BIBLIOGRAP.docx
Running Head ANNOTATED BIBLIOGRAPHY 1ANNOTATED BIBLIOGRAP.docxtoddr4
 
Forums  Week One Discussions  Discussion Question #1Articl.docx
Forums  Week One Discussions  Discussion Question #1Articl.docxForums  Week One Discussions  Discussion Question #1Articl.docx
Forums  Week One Discussions  Discussion Question #1Articl.docxbudbarber38650
 

Similar to ARTICLE Quot Let S Stop The Madness Part 3 Understanding The Difference Between Contributions Of The Study Vs. Significance Of The Study (20)

Discussion 3 Evaluating Research Questions, Hypotheses, and Qua.docx
Discussion 3 Evaluating Research Questions, Hypotheses, and Qua.docxDiscussion 3 Evaluating Research Questions, Hypotheses, and Qua.docx
Discussion 3 Evaluating Research Questions, Hypotheses, and Qua.docx
 
Chao Wrote Some trends that influence human resource are, Leade.docx
Chao Wrote Some trends that influence human resource are, Leade.docxChao Wrote Some trends that influence human resource are, Leade.docx
Chao Wrote Some trends that influence human resource are, Leade.docx
 
Chao Wrote Some trends that influence human resource are, Leade.docx
Chao Wrote Some trends that influence human resource are, Leade.docxChao Wrote Some trends that influence human resource are, Leade.docx
Chao Wrote Some trends that influence human resource are, Leade.docx
 
ENG333 Week 8 writing the method and results
ENG333 Week 8 writing the method and resultsENG333 Week 8 writing the method and results
ENG333 Week 8 writing the method and results
 
Assignment 2 RA Annotated BibliographyThe foundation of a rese.docx
Assignment 2 RA Annotated BibliographyThe foundation of a rese.docxAssignment 2 RA Annotated BibliographyThe foundation of a rese.docx
Assignment 2 RA Annotated BibliographyThe foundation of a rese.docx
 
Essent of Nursing homework help.docx
Essent of Nursing homework help.docxEssent of Nursing homework help.docx
Essent of Nursing homework help.docx
 
1 quantitative research study critiquestudent namewalden
1 quantitative research study critiquestudent namewalden 1 quantitative research study critiquestudent namewalden
1 quantitative research study critiquestudent namewalden
 
Researchers consider validity and reliability with each new study th.docx
Researchers consider validity and reliability with each new study th.docxResearchers consider validity and reliability with each new study th.docx
Researchers consider validity and reliability with each new study th.docx
 
EDUC 8102-6: Applied Research and Adult Learn
EDUC 8102-6: Applied Research and Adult LearnEDUC 8102-6: Applied Research and Adult Learn
EDUC 8102-6: Applied Research and Adult Learn
 
PAGE 52What is Action ResearchViaA review of the Literat.docx
PAGE  52What is Action ResearchViaA review of the Literat.docxPAGE  52What is Action ResearchViaA review of the Literat.docx
PAGE 52What is Action ResearchViaA review of the Literat.docx
 
Lestremau Session 2: Evaluating Info and Intro to Annotated Bibliographies
Lestremau Session 2: Evaluating Info and Intro to Annotated BibliographiesLestremau Session 2: Evaluating Info and Intro to Annotated Bibliographies
Lestremau Session 2: Evaluating Info and Intro to Annotated Bibliographies
 
ARTICLE REVIEW INSTRUCTIONSYou will write an article review-relevant t.docx
ARTICLE REVIEW INSTRUCTIONSYou will write an article review-relevant t.docxARTICLE REVIEW INSTRUCTIONSYou will write an article review-relevant t.docx
ARTICLE REVIEW INSTRUCTIONSYou will write an article review-relevant t.docx
 
CHAPTER 10 MIXED METHODS PROCEDURESHow would you write a mixed m
CHAPTER 10 MIXED METHODS PROCEDURESHow would you write a mixed mCHAPTER 10 MIXED METHODS PROCEDURESHow would you write a mixed m
CHAPTER 10 MIXED METHODS PROCEDURESHow would you write a mixed m
 
College of Doctoral StudiesRES-811 Topic 7 S.docx
College of Doctoral StudiesRES-811 Topic 7 S.docxCollege of Doctoral StudiesRES-811 Topic 7 S.docx
College of Doctoral StudiesRES-811 Topic 7 S.docx
 
1_Q2-PRACTICAL-RESEARCH.pptx
1_Q2-PRACTICAL-RESEARCH.pptx1_Q2-PRACTICAL-RESEARCH.pptx
1_Q2-PRACTICAL-RESEARCH.pptx
 
STDEV . I3.pdf
STDEV . I3.pdfSTDEV . I3.pdf
STDEV . I3.pdf
 
For this Assignment you articulate how you will use research to .docx
For this Assignment you articulate how you will use research to .docxFor this Assignment you articulate how you will use research to .docx
For this Assignment you articulate how you will use research to .docx
 
Week 9 Data Analysis Resources Readings 
Week 9 Data Analysis Resources Readings Week 9 Data Analysis Resources Readings 
Week 9 Data Analysis Resources Readings 
 
Running Head ANNOTATED BIBLIOGRAPHY 1ANNOTATED BIBLIOGRAP.docx
Running Head ANNOTATED BIBLIOGRAPHY 1ANNOTATED BIBLIOGRAP.docxRunning Head ANNOTATED BIBLIOGRAPHY 1ANNOTATED BIBLIOGRAP.docx
Running Head ANNOTATED BIBLIOGRAPHY 1ANNOTATED BIBLIOGRAP.docx
 
Forums  Week One Discussions  Discussion Question #1Articl.docx
Forums  Week One Discussions  Discussion Question #1Articl.docxForums  Week One Discussions  Discussion Question #1Articl.docx
Forums  Week One Discussions  Discussion Question #1Articl.docx
 

More from Anita Miller

TIME Transitions Words List In English - English Gram
TIME Transitions Words List In English - English GramTIME Transitions Words List In English - English Gram
TIME Transitions Words List In English - English GramAnita Miller
 
Free Santa Letter Notepaper - KiddyCharts Free Resources
Free Santa Letter Notepaper - KiddyCharts Free ResourcesFree Santa Letter Notepaper - KiddyCharts Free Resources
Free Santa Letter Notepaper - KiddyCharts Free ResourcesAnita Miller
 
The Importance Of An Honest Essay Writing Company Revi
The Importance Of An Honest Essay Writing Company ReviThe Importance Of An Honest Essay Writing Company Revi
The Importance Of An Honest Essay Writing Company ReviAnita Miller
 
How To Avoid WriterS Block. Online assignment writing service.
How To Avoid WriterS Block. Online assignment writing service.How To Avoid WriterS Block. Online assignment writing service.
How To Avoid WriterS Block. Online assignment writing service.Anita Miller
 
Essay Websites Best Research Paper. Online assignment writing service.
Essay Websites Best Research Paper. Online assignment writing service.Essay Websites Best Research Paper. Online assignment writing service.
Essay Websites Best Research Paper. Online assignment writing service.Anita Miller
 
Everything You Need To Know About Writing A Diag
Everything You Need To Know About Writing A DiagEverything You Need To Know About Writing A Diag
Everything You Need To Know About Writing A DiagAnita Miller
 
Tutorial 2 - Example Essay - TUTORIAL 2 EXAMPLE E
Tutorial 2 - Example Essay - TUTORIAL 2 EXAMPLE ETutorial 2 - Example Essay - TUTORIAL 2 EXAMPLE E
Tutorial 2 - Example Essay - TUTORIAL 2 EXAMPLE EAnita Miller
 
ANALYTIC CHECKLIST FOR ESSAYS - ESL Works
ANALYTIC CHECKLIST FOR ESSAYS - ESL WorksANALYTIC CHECKLIST FOR ESSAYS - ESL Works
ANALYTIC CHECKLIST FOR ESSAYS - ESL WorksAnita Miller
 
Seminar Paper Writing Guidelines. Online assignment writing service.
Seminar Paper Writing Guidelines. Online assignment writing service.Seminar Paper Writing Guidelines. Online assignment writing service.
Seminar Paper Writing Guidelines. Online assignment writing service.Anita Miller
 
Old Writing On Grunge Black Paper Texture With Water Stains (Paper
Old Writing On Grunge Black Paper Texture With Water Stains (PaperOld Writing On Grunge Black Paper Texture With Water Stains (Paper
Old Writing On Grunge Black Paper Texture With Water Stains (PaperAnita Miller
 
Opinion Editorial Essay Example. Online assignment writing service.
Opinion Editorial Essay Example. Online assignment writing service.Opinion Editorial Essay Example. Online assignment writing service.
Opinion Editorial Essay Example. Online assignment writing service.Anita Miller
 
Writing Paper Printable Kids Learning Activity Writing
Writing Paper Printable  Kids Learning Activity  WritingWriting Paper Printable  Kids Learning Activity  Writing
Writing Paper Printable Kids Learning Activity WritingAnita Miller
 
Thank You Writing Template By Giraffe And Zebra Creat
Thank You Writing Template By Giraffe And Zebra CreatThank You Writing Template By Giraffe And Zebra Creat
Thank You Writing Template By Giraffe And Zebra CreatAnita Miller
 
Write Esse Free Editing Websites For Writing
Write Esse Free Editing Websites For WritingWrite Esse Free Editing Websites For Writing
Write Esse Free Editing Websites For WritingAnita Miller
 
Conclusion - How To Write An Essay - LibGuides At University
Conclusion - How To Write An Essay - LibGuides At UniversityConclusion - How To Write An Essay - LibGuides At University
Conclusion - How To Write An Essay - LibGuides At UniversityAnita Miller
 
Motivation Essay Example - PHDessay.Com. Online assignment writing service.
Motivation Essay Example - PHDessay.Com. Online assignment writing service.Motivation Essay Example - PHDessay.Com. Online assignment writing service.
Motivation Essay Example - PHDessay.Com. Online assignment writing service.Anita Miller
 
How To Write A Summary Step-By-Step Guide With E
How To Write A Summary Step-By-Step Guide With EHow To Write A Summary Step-By-Step Guide With E
How To Write A Summary Step-By-Step Guide With EAnita Miller
 
MLA Handbook For Writers Of Research Papers MLA 97
MLA Handbook For Writers Of Research Papers MLA 97MLA Handbook For Writers Of Research Papers MLA 97
MLA Handbook For Writers Of Research Papers MLA 97Anita Miller
 
Writing An Evaluation Essay. How Do You Write A Evaluation Essay
Writing An Evaluation Essay. How Do You Write A Evaluation EssayWriting An Evaluation Essay. How Do You Write A Evaluation Essay
Writing An Evaluation Essay. How Do You Write A Evaluation EssayAnita Miller
 
17 Best Images About Printable Lined Writing Pa
17 Best Images About Printable Lined Writing Pa17 Best Images About Printable Lined Writing Pa
17 Best Images About Printable Lined Writing PaAnita Miller
 

More from Anita Miller (20)

TIME Transitions Words List In English - English Gram
TIME Transitions Words List In English - English GramTIME Transitions Words List In English - English Gram
TIME Transitions Words List In English - English Gram
 
Free Santa Letter Notepaper - KiddyCharts Free Resources
Free Santa Letter Notepaper - KiddyCharts Free ResourcesFree Santa Letter Notepaper - KiddyCharts Free Resources
Free Santa Letter Notepaper - KiddyCharts Free Resources
 
The Importance Of An Honest Essay Writing Company Revi
The Importance Of An Honest Essay Writing Company ReviThe Importance Of An Honest Essay Writing Company Revi
The Importance Of An Honest Essay Writing Company Revi
 
How To Avoid WriterS Block. Online assignment writing service.
How To Avoid WriterS Block. Online assignment writing service.How To Avoid WriterS Block. Online assignment writing service.
How To Avoid WriterS Block. Online assignment writing service.
 
Essay Websites Best Research Paper. Online assignment writing service.
Essay Websites Best Research Paper. Online assignment writing service.Essay Websites Best Research Paper. Online assignment writing service.
Essay Websites Best Research Paper. Online assignment writing service.
 
Everything You Need To Know About Writing A Diag
Everything You Need To Know About Writing A DiagEverything You Need To Know About Writing A Diag
Everything You Need To Know About Writing A Diag
 
Tutorial 2 - Example Essay - TUTORIAL 2 EXAMPLE E
Tutorial 2 - Example Essay - TUTORIAL 2 EXAMPLE ETutorial 2 - Example Essay - TUTORIAL 2 EXAMPLE E
Tutorial 2 - Example Essay - TUTORIAL 2 EXAMPLE E
 
ANALYTIC CHECKLIST FOR ESSAYS - ESL Works
ANALYTIC CHECKLIST FOR ESSAYS - ESL WorksANALYTIC CHECKLIST FOR ESSAYS - ESL Works
ANALYTIC CHECKLIST FOR ESSAYS - ESL Works
 
Seminar Paper Writing Guidelines. Online assignment writing service.
Seminar Paper Writing Guidelines. Online assignment writing service.Seminar Paper Writing Guidelines. Online assignment writing service.
Seminar Paper Writing Guidelines. Online assignment writing service.
 
Old Writing On Grunge Black Paper Texture With Water Stains (Paper
Old Writing On Grunge Black Paper Texture With Water Stains (PaperOld Writing On Grunge Black Paper Texture With Water Stains (Paper
Old Writing On Grunge Black Paper Texture With Water Stains (Paper
 
Opinion Editorial Essay Example. Online assignment writing service.
Opinion Editorial Essay Example. Online assignment writing service.Opinion Editorial Essay Example. Online assignment writing service.
Opinion Editorial Essay Example. Online assignment writing service.
 
Writing Paper Printable Kids Learning Activity Writing
Writing Paper Printable  Kids Learning Activity  WritingWriting Paper Printable  Kids Learning Activity  Writing
Writing Paper Printable Kids Learning Activity Writing
 
Thank You Writing Template By Giraffe And Zebra Creat
Thank You Writing Template By Giraffe And Zebra CreatThank You Writing Template By Giraffe And Zebra Creat
Thank You Writing Template By Giraffe And Zebra Creat
 
Write Esse Free Editing Websites For Writing
Write Esse Free Editing Websites For WritingWrite Esse Free Editing Websites For Writing
Write Esse Free Editing Websites For Writing
 
Conclusion - How To Write An Essay - LibGuides At University
Conclusion - How To Write An Essay - LibGuides At UniversityConclusion - How To Write An Essay - LibGuides At University
Conclusion - How To Write An Essay - LibGuides At University
 
Motivation Essay Example - PHDessay.Com. Online assignment writing service.
Motivation Essay Example - PHDessay.Com. Online assignment writing service.Motivation Essay Example - PHDessay.Com. Online assignment writing service.
Motivation Essay Example - PHDessay.Com. Online assignment writing service.
 
How To Write A Summary Step-By-Step Guide With E
How To Write A Summary Step-By-Step Guide With EHow To Write A Summary Step-By-Step Guide With E
How To Write A Summary Step-By-Step Guide With E
 
MLA Handbook For Writers Of Research Papers MLA 97
MLA Handbook For Writers Of Research Papers MLA 97MLA Handbook For Writers Of Research Papers MLA 97
MLA Handbook For Writers Of Research Papers MLA 97
 
Writing An Evaluation Essay. How Do You Write A Evaluation Essay
Writing An Evaluation Essay. How Do You Write A Evaluation EssayWriting An Evaluation Essay. How Do You Write A Evaluation Essay
Writing An Evaluation Essay. How Do You Write A Evaluation Essay
 
17 Best Images About Printable Lined Writing Pa
17 Best Images About Printable Lined Writing Pa17 Best Images About Printable Lined Writing Pa
17 Best Images About Printable Lined Writing Pa
 

Recently uploaded

MENTAL STATUS EXAMINATION format.docx
MENTAL     STATUS EXAMINATION format.docxMENTAL     STATUS EXAMINATION format.docx
MENTAL STATUS EXAMINATION format.docxPoojaSen20
 
Sanyam Choudhary Chemistry practical.pdf
Sanyam Choudhary Chemistry practical.pdfSanyam Choudhary Chemistry practical.pdf
Sanyam Choudhary Chemistry practical.pdfsanyamsingh5019
 
KSHARA STURA .pptx---KSHARA KARMA THERAPY (CAUSTIC THERAPY)————IMP.OF KSHARA ...
KSHARA STURA .pptx---KSHARA KARMA THERAPY (CAUSTIC THERAPY)————IMP.OF KSHARA ...KSHARA STURA .pptx---KSHARA KARMA THERAPY (CAUSTIC THERAPY)————IMP.OF KSHARA ...
KSHARA STURA .pptx---KSHARA KARMA THERAPY (CAUSTIC THERAPY)————IMP.OF KSHARA ...M56BOOKSTORE PRODUCT/SERVICE
 
microwave assisted reaction. General introduction
microwave assisted reaction. General introductionmicrowave assisted reaction. General introduction
microwave assisted reaction. General introductionMaksud Ahmed
 
Enzyme, Pharmaceutical Aids, Miscellaneous Last Part of Chapter no 5th.pdf
Enzyme, Pharmaceutical Aids, Miscellaneous Last Part of Chapter no 5th.pdfEnzyme, Pharmaceutical Aids, Miscellaneous Last Part of Chapter no 5th.pdf
Enzyme, Pharmaceutical Aids, Miscellaneous Last Part of Chapter no 5th.pdfSumit Tiwari
 
mini mental status format.docx
mini    mental       status     format.docxmini    mental       status     format.docx
mini mental status format.docxPoojaSen20
 
POINT- BIOCHEMISTRY SEM 2 ENZYMES UNIT 5.pptx
POINT- BIOCHEMISTRY SEM 2 ENZYMES UNIT 5.pptxPOINT- BIOCHEMISTRY SEM 2 ENZYMES UNIT 5.pptx
POINT- BIOCHEMISTRY SEM 2 ENZYMES UNIT 5.pptxSayali Powar
 
Paris 2024 Olympic Geographies - an activity
Paris 2024 Olympic Geographies - an activityParis 2024 Olympic Geographies - an activity
Paris 2024 Olympic Geographies - an activityGeoBlogs
 
The Most Excellent Way | 1 Corinthians 13
The Most Excellent Way | 1 Corinthians 13The Most Excellent Way | 1 Corinthians 13
The Most Excellent Way | 1 Corinthians 13Steve Thomason
 
Solving Puzzles Benefits Everyone (English).pptx
Solving Puzzles Benefits Everyone (English).pptxSolving Puzzles Benefits Everyone (English).pptx
Solving Puzzles Benefits Everyone (English).pptxOH TEIK BIN
 
SOCIAL AND HISTORICAL CONTEXT - LFTVD.pptx
SOCIAL AND HISTORICAL CONTEXT - LFTVD.pptxSOCIAL AND HISTORICAL CONTEXT - LFTVD.pptx
SOCIAL AND HISTORICAL CONTEXT - LFTVD.pptxiammrhaywood
 
Call Girls in Dwarka Mor Delhi Contact Us 9654467111
Call Girls in Dwarka Mor Delhi Contact Us 9654467111Call Girls in Dwarka Mor Delhi Contact Us 9654467111
Call Girls in Dwarka Mor Delhi Contact Us 9654467111Sapana Sha
 
Introduction to ArtificiaI Intelligence in Higher Education
Introduction to ArtificiaI Intelligence in Higher EducationIntroduction to ArtificiaI Intelligence in Higher Education
Introduction to ArtificiaI Intelligence in Higher Educationpboyjonauth
 
BASLIQ CURRENT LOOKBOOK LOOKBOOK(1) (1).pdf
BASLIQ CURRENT LOOKBOOK  LOOKBOOK(1) (1).pdfBASLIQ CURRENT LOOKBOOK  LOOKBOOK(1) (1).pdf
BASLIQ CURRENT LOOKBOOK LOOKBOOK(1) (1).pdfSoniaTolstoy
 
Separation of Lanthanides/ Lanthanides and Actinides
Separation of Lanthanides/ Lanthanides and ActinidesSeparation of Lanthanides/ Lanthanides and Actinides
Separation of Lanthanides/ Lanthanides and ActinidesFatimaKhan178732
 
How to Configure Email Server in Odoo 17
How to Configure Email Server in Odoo 17How to Configure Email Server in Odoo 17
How to Configure Email Server in Odoo 17Celine George
 

Recently uploaded (20)

MENTAL STATUS EXAMINATION format.docx
MENTAL     STATUS EXAMINATION format.docxMENTAL     STATUS EXAMINATION format.docx
MENTAL STATUS EXAMINATION format.docx
 
Sanyam Choudhary Chemistry practical.pdf
Sanyam Choudhary Chemistry practical.pdfSanyam Choudhary Chemistry practical.pdf
Sanyam Choudhary Chemistry practical.pdf
 
Staff of Color (SOC) Retention Efforts DDSD
Staff of Color (SOC) Retention Efforts DDSDStaff of Color (SOC) Retention Efforts DDSD
Staff of Color (SOC) Retention Efforts DDSD
 
KSHARA STURA .pptx---KSHARA KARMA THERAPY (CAUSTIC THERAPY)————IMP.OF KSHARA ...
KSHARA STURA .pptx---KSHARA KARMA THERAPY (CAUSTIC THERAPY)————IMP.OF KSHARA ...KSHARA STURA .pptx---KSHARA KARMA THERAPY (CAUSTIC THERAPY)————IMP.OF KSHARA ...
KSHARA STURA .pptx---KSHARA KARMA THERAPY (CAUSTIC THERAPY)————IMP.OF KSHARA ...
 
Model Call Girl in Tilak Nagar Delhi reach out to us at 🔝9953056974🔝
Model Call Girl in Tilak Nagar Delhi reach out to us at 🔝9953056974🔝Model Call Girl in Tilak Nagar Delhi reach out to us at 🔝9953056974🔝
Model Call Girl in Tilak Nagar Delhi reach out to us at 🔝9953056974🔝
 
microwave assisted reaction. General introduction
microwave assisted reaction. General introductionmicrowave assisted reaction. General introduction
microwave assisted reaction. General introduction
 
Enzyme, Pharmaceutical Aids, Miscellaneous Last Part of Chapter no 5th.pdf
Enzyme, Pharmaceutical Aids, Miscellaneous Last Part of Chapter no 5th.pdfEnzyme, Pharmaceutical Aids, Miscellaneous Last Part of Chapter no 5th.pdf
Enzyme, Pharmaceutical Aids, Miscellaneous Last Part of Chapter no 5th.pdf
 
mini mental status format.docx
mini    mental       status     format.docxmini    mental       status     format.docx
mini mental status format.docx
 
POINT- BIOCHEMISTRY SEM 2 ENZYMES UNIT 5.pptx
POINT- BIOCHEMISTRY SEM 2 ENZYMES UNIT 5.pptxPOINT- BIOCHEMISTRY SEM 2 ENZYMES UNIT 5.pptx
POINT- BIOCHEMISTRY SEM 2 ENZYMES UNIT 5.pptx
 
Paris 2024 Olympic Geographies - an activity
Paris 2024 Olympic Geographies - an activityParis 2024 Olympic Geographies - an activity
Paris 2024 Olympic Geographies - an activity
 
The Most Excellent Way | 1 Corinthians 13
The Most Excellent Way | 1 Corinthians 13The Most Excellent Way | 1 Corinthians 13
The Most Excellent Way | 1 Corinthians 13
 
Solving Puzzles Benefits Everyone (English).pptx
Solving Puzzles Benefits Everyone (English).pptxSolving Puzzles Benefits Everyone (English).pptx
Solving Puzzles Benefits Everyone (English).pptx
 
SOCIAL AND HISTORICAL CONTEXT - LFTVD.pptx
SOCIAL AND HISTORICAL CONTEXT - LFTVD.pptxSOCIAL AND HISTORICAL CONTEXT - LFTVD.pptx
SOCIAL AND HISTORICAL CONTEXT - LFTVD.pptx
 
Call Girls in Dwarka Mor Delhi Contact Us 9654467111
Call Girls in Dwarka Mor Delhi Contact Us 9654467111Call Girls in Dwarka Mor Delhi Contact Us 9654467111
Call Girls in Dwarka Mor Delhi Contact Us 9654467111
 
Introduction to ArtificiaI Intelligence in Higher Education
Introduction to ArtificiaI Intelligence in Higher EducationIntroduction to ArtificiaI Intelligence in Higher Education
Introduction to ArtificiaI Intelligence in Higher Education
 
BASLIQ CURRENT LOOKBOOK LOOKBOOK(1) (1).pdf
BASLIQ CURRENT LOOKBOOK  LOOKBOOK(1) (1).pdfBASLIQ CURRENT LOOKBOOK  LOOKBOOK(1) (1).pdf
BASLIQ CURRENT LOOKBOOK LOOKBOOK(1) (1).pdf
 
Separation of Lanthanides/ Lanthanides and Actinides
Separation of Lanthanides/ Lanthanides and ActinidesSeparation of Lanthanides/ Lanthanides and Actinides
Separation of Lanthanides/ Lanthanides and Actinides
 
9953330565 Low Rate Call Girls In Rohini Delhi NCR
9953330565 Low Rate Call Girls In Rohini  Delhi NCR9953330565 Low Rate Call Girls In Rohini  Delhi NCR
9953330565 Low Rate Call Girls In Rohini Delhi NCR
 
Model Call Girl in Bikash Puri Delhi reach out to us at 🔝9953056974🔝
Model Call Girl in Bikash Puri  Delhi reach out to us at 🔝9953056974🔝Model Call Girl in Bikash Puri  Delhi reach out to us at 🔝9953056974🔝
Model Call Girl in Bikash Puri Delhi reach out to us at 🔝9953056974🔝
 
How to Configure Email Server in Odoo 17
How to Configure Email Server in Odoo 17How to Configure Email Server in Odoo 17
How to Configure Email Server in Odoo 17
 

ARTICLE Quot Let S Stop The Madness Part 3 Understanding The Difference Between Contributions Of The Study Vs. Significance Of The Study

  • 1. Doctoral Student Workshop: Contributions vs. Significance Source: Miles, D.A. and Scott, L. (2017) Workshop: Confessions of a Dissertation Chair Part 1: The Six Mistakes Doctoral Students Make With the Dissertation. Presented at the 5th Annual 2017 Black Doctoral Network Conference in Atlanta, GA on October 26-29 2017. 1 Let’s Stop the Madness Part 3: Understanding the Difference Between Contributions of the Study vs. Significance of the Study D. Anthony Miles ABSTRACT The purpose of this article is to provide some clear distinctions and insight on the differences between the contributions of the study and the significance of the study. This is a common confusion between the two terms and is even more confusing explaining them in the study. There is a tendency to use the terms synonymously. I see this confusion at a prevalent level with both novice and experienced researchers. Thus, this article tries to provide some clear understanding of the two terms and provides some clear definitions and examples of them both. This article provides some practical importance to researchers in social sciences. This article provides some valuable knowledge and give the researcher guidance using the correct use of these two terms. The objective of this article is threefold. First, the article provides some clear definitions on contributions of the study and significance of the study. Second, this article provides clear examples of the differences and characteristics between the two terms. Last, this article provides examples from articles and studies using of the two terms. This article will provide much needed clarity to many researchers that are confused by the two terms and how to use them in the proper context.
  • 2. Doctoral Student Workshop: Contributions vs. Significance Source: Miles, D.A. and Scott, L. (2017) Workshop: Confessions of a Dissertation Chair Part 1: The Six Mistakes Doctoral Students Make With the Dissertation. Presented at the 5th Annual 2017 Black Doctoral Network Conference in Atlanta, GA on October 26-29 2017. 2 Introduction In my many years of working with doctoral students, I have found there is still another prevailing confusion among them. There is substantial confusion between the terms, contributions of the study and significance of the study. This is so common that I have seen this be the case with both experienced researchers and novice researchers. This is most common with doctoral students. Again, as professors we need to do a better job with assisting students on understanding the differences between these two terms. One of prevailing issues is they did not properly understand these concepts in their research methods courses. They either have never learned the differences between the two terms or they assume they are the same. It shows when they write their dissertations. However, help is on the way. I think we have found a useful definition and examples to help doctoral students and novice researchers understand the differences between the two terms. The outline of the article will provide information on the differences between the two terms. First, the article will provide clear definitions of the contributions of the study and significance of the study. This article discusses the differences and definitions between the terms, the contributions of the study and the significance of the study. Second, the article will provide some examples of how to use them in a sentence and paragraph. This article discusses the three significance types of the study. Last, the article discusses the three types of research significance. The article will provide examples of them from journal articles and studies.
  • 3. Doctoral Student Workshop: Contributions vs. Significance Source: Miles, D.A. and Scott, L. (2017) Workshop: Confessions of a Dissertation Chair Part 1: The Six Mistakes Doctoral Students Make With the Dissertation. Presented at the 5th Annual 2017 Black Doctoral Network Conference in Atlanta, GA on October 26-29 2017. 3 What is the Definition of Contributions of a Study? The contributions of a study describe how the study will contribute to the body of knowledge. There are three types of contributions of the study: (a) Conceptual/Theoretical, (b) Empirical, and (c) Methodological. These three contributions define most research contributions in a study (see Figure 1). Figure 1 The Three Types of Research Contributions of Study RESEARCH CONTRIBUTIONS Conceptual/ Theoretical Methodological Empirical
  • 4. Doctoral Student Workshop: Contributions vs. Significance Source: Miles, D.A. and Scott, L. (2017) Workshop: Confessions of a Dissertation Chair Part 1: The Six Mistakes Doctoral Students Make With the Dissertation. Presented at the 5th Annual 2017 Black Doctoral Network Conference in Atlanta, GA on October 26-29 2017. 4 Conceptual/Theoretical Contributions The conceptual (theoretical) contribution of a study involve contributions such as: (a) improved conceptual definitions of the original constructs; (b) the identification and conceptual definition of additional constructs to be added to the conceptual framework (e.g., additional dependent, independent, mediating, and/or moderator variables); (c) the development of additional theoretical linkages (e.g., research hypotheses) with their accompanying rationale; and (d) the development of improved theoretical rationale for existing linkages (Summers, 2006; Asgari, 2015; Miles, 2019). Empirical Contributions The empirical contribution of a study involve contributions such as: (a) testing a theoretical linkage between two constructs that has not previously been tested; (b) examining the effects of a potential moderator variable on the nature of the relationship between two constructs; (c) determining the degree to which a variable mediates the relationship between two constructs; and (d) investigating the psychometric properties of an important scale (Summers, 2006; Asgari, 2015; Miles, 2019). Methodological Contributions The methodological contribution of a study involve contributions such as: (a) reduce the potential problems with shared method variance through the insightful use of multiple methods of measurement; (b) increase the generalizability of the research through more appropriate sampling procedures; (c) allow the investigation of the plausibility of "third- variable explanations" for the results of past studies; and (d) enhance the construct validity of key measures through the use of refined multiple-item measures and/or the use of measurement approaches that do not rely on self-reports (Summers, 2006; Asgari, 2015; Miles, 2019). Other Research Contributions These are rare contributions and rarely used except for special situations. Applied Contribution refers to when a theoretical model applies in a different industry which hasn't been empirically tested earlier. Survey Contributions are attempts to review and synthesize work done in a research field with the goal of exposing trends, themes, and gaps in the literature (Asgari, 2015). See The Statement Grid (Tables 1 and 2 on p. 5) on the examples of writing the contributions of the study.
  • 5. Doctoral Student Workshop: Contributions vs. Significance Source: Miles, D.A. and Scott, L. (2017) Workshop: Confessions of a Dissertation Chair Part 1: The Six Mistakes Doctoral Students Make With the Dissertation. Presented at the 5th Annual 2017 Black Doctoral Network Conference in Atlanta, GA on October 26-29 2017. 5 Table 1. Introducing: The Statement Grid – for Contributions of the Study Overall Statement: “The researcher identified a key contribution of this study. This study makes two key ________________ contributions.” Contribution 1: First, this study makes a contribution by offering a _______________________ that is lacking in the prior research that primarily focused on________________________. Contribution 2: Second, this study offers a__________________________ line of inquiry that was not addressed in the prior research. This study attempts to address the potential problems in the prior studies with a ____________ through the insightful use of ________________________. Table 2. The Statement Grid – Example for Contributions of the Study Overall Statement: “The researcher identified a key contribution of this study. This study makes a methodological contribution. This study makes two key methodological contributions.” Contribution 1: First, this study makes a contribution by offering a qualitative inquiry that is lacking in the prior research that primarily focused on empirical research. Contribution 2: Second, this study offers a divergent line of inquiry that was not addressed in the prior research. This study attempts to address the potential problems in the prior studies with shared method variance through the insightful use of multiple methods of inquiry. See the actual examples (see Examples 1 to 3) beginning on page 6. These provide some examples of writing the contribution of the study.
  • 6. Doctoral Student Workshop: Contributions vs. Significance Source: Miles, D.A. and Scott, L. (2017) Workshop: Confessions of a Dissertation Chair Part 1: The Six Mistakes Doctoral Students Make With the Dissertation. Presented at the 5th Annual 2017 Black Doctoral Network Conference in Atlanta, GA on October 26-29 2017. 6 [Example 1] The researcher identified two contributions of this study. First, this study will make a conceptual contribution to the field of leadership and management studies. This study hopes to contribute to the theory of leadership and body of knowledge. Many researchers have explored the impact of leaders ‘behavior on their employees. Many of these studies deal with leadership styles and how employees respond to their managers ’actions. The results of such studies indicated that “employees would respond to the manager’s actions with attitudes reflecting their perception of a supervisor’s leadership style” (Mulki, Caemmerer & Heggde, 2015, p.6). Kim (2014) suggested that leaders set the tone and atmosphere in the organization, therefore defining the organization culture. This study will contribute to the development of additional theoretical linkages (e.g., research hypotheses) with their accompanying rationale. The second contribution will be methodological. This study makes contribution by providing a divergent research method variance through the insightful use of multiple methods of measurement. A qualitative line of inquiry is lacking in the prior research. Some of these unexplored research methods appear to be important and worthy of investigation in the context of management and job performance. Yoonk Jik & Poister (2014) also asserted that by engaging employees in building a team work environment, this could be a leading factor towards increasing organization performance and sustainability. An investigation of these issues is important because there is a dearth in prior research that approaches this topic from a qualitative line of inquiry. Furthermore, the previous empirical research has focused primarily on quantitative methodology and assessment. Very little research has contributed from a qualitative line of inquiry [Platt, 2019].
  • 7. Doctoral Student Workshop: Contributions vs. Significance Source: Miles, D.A. and Scott, L. (2017) Workshop: Confessions of a Dissertation Chair Part 1: The Six Mistakes Doctoral Students Make With the Dissertation. Presented at the 5th Annual 2017 Black Doctoral Network Conference in Atlanta, GA on October 26-29 2017. 7 [Example 2] The researcher identified a major contribution of this study. First, this study will offer a much- needed empirical contribution. This study makes two important empirical contributions. First, the research uses archival data maintained by the state for public access to make connections. This information is stored specifically for research purposes as shown in the Appendix F. This facilitates the use of larger amounts of data and greater populations. Second, this study will contribute to the empirical evidence for the requirement of a student’s socio-intellectual development in the high school setting. This research maybe appropriate for understanding the impact that precise character and behavioral skills have on student interactions with peers, adults and their studies. Additionally, the need for a specific, codified character education curriculum may be indicated from the results of the study. Further evidence may be provided that character education may positively impact student success outside the classroom [Zeig, 2019].
  • 8. Doctoral Student Workshop: Contributions vs. Significance Source: Miles, D.A. and Scott, L. (2017) Workshop: Confessions of a Dissertation Chair Part 1: The Six Mistakes Doctoral Students Make With the Dissertation. Presented at the 5th Annual 2017 Black Doctoral Network Conference in Atlanta, GA on October 26-29 2017. 8 [Example 3] The researcher identified a key contribution of this study. This study makes a methodological contribution. This study makes two key methodological contributions. First, this study makes a contribution by offering a qualitative inquiry that is lacking in the prior research that primarily focused on empirical research. Second, this study offers a divergent line of inquiry that was not addressed in the prior research. This study attempts to address the potential problems in the prior studies with shared method variance through the insightful use of multiple methods of inquiry. In addition, this study encompasses on several unexplored dimensions that lately have attracted research attention and calls for another research method (Harris, 2013; Steele, 2018). Some of these unexplored research methods appear to be important and worthy of investigation in the context of technostress and job performance. An investigation of these issues is important because there is a dearth in prior research that approaches this topic from a qualitative line of inquiry. Furthermore, the previous empirical research has focused primarily on quantitative methodology and assessment. Very little research has made a contribution from a qualitative line of inquiry [Beltran, 2019].
  • 9. Doctoral Student Workshop: Contributions vs. Significance Source: Miles, D.A. and Scott, L. (2017) Workshop: Confessions of a Dissertation Chair Part 1: The Six Mistakes Doctoral Students Make With the Dissertation. Presented at the 5th Annual 2017 Black Doctoral Network Conference in Atlanta, GA on October 26-29 2017. 9 What is the Definition of Significance of a Study? A second problem that doctoral students have is with the meaning of significance. Many doctoral students have considerable trouble writing and supporting the significance statement in the dissertation proposal. The reasons stem from a poor research objective. The significance statement gives plausible rationale as to why the study matters. This is a very important section of the proposal. The significance is an explanation why the proposed study is important why it represents potential contribution the field. Its emphasis should be on why the study is worthwhile (Webster, 1998). The significance of the study is your argument that the study makes a significant and original contribution to profession, the scholarly literature and your discipline. The significance of the study answers questions related to why the topic is worth studying (Calabrese, 2006). You offer reasons and arguments pertaining to why your study is important. The reasons may be confined to the potential that your study will add new knowledge to existing information about your area of interest. These reasons relate to how practioners behave in carrying out their work (Bryant, 2004). With significance, the researcher describes how the study: (a) contributes to existing research, (b) benefits participants, (c) contributes to practice, and (d) generates new theory. If the significance of the study is presented in the dissertation proposal, the researcher is speculative, theorizing his or her contributions in these four areas (Calabrese, 2009) It provides answers as to why your study is important and how it will add something to the body of knowledge. There are three key points of the significance statement: (a) So, why is this research important; (b) How does this research contribute to the body of knowledge; and (c) How does this research contribute to the practice and field? The significance of a study describes why this study is important. There are three types of contributions of the study: (a) Theoretical Significance, (b) Practical Significance, and (c) Research Significance. These three types of significance in a study (see Figure 2).
  • 10. Doctoral Student Workshop: Contributions vs. Significance Source: Miles, D.A. and Scott, L. (2017) Workshop: Confessions of a Dissertation Chair Part 1: The Six Mistakes Doctoral Students Make With the Dissertation. Presented at the 5th Annual 2017 Black Doctoral Network Conference in Atlanta, GA on October 26-29 2017. 10 Figure 2 The Three Types of Significance in a Study Theoretical Significance This type of significance is important because it focuses on adding new knowledge or theory to the body of knowledge into the field. The significance of the study is your argument that the study makes a significant and original contribution to the scholarly literature and your discipline. The significance of the study is your argument that the study makes a significant and original contribution to the scholarly literature and your discipline. (Calabrese, 2009; Miles, 2019; Webster, 1998). Practical Significance This type of significance is important because it focuses on the impact of your results on the profession or on the solution of practical problems (Madsen, 1990). These reasons relate to how practioners behave in carrying out their work (Bryant, 2004). The significance of the study is your argument that the study makes a significant contribution to profession. The key factor here is how your research contributes in terms of to the practice (Calabrese, 2009). SIGNIFICANCE Practical Significance Theoretical Significance Research Significance
  • 11. Doctoral Student Workshop: Contributions vs. Significance Source: Miles, D.A. and Scott, L. (2017) Workshop: Confessions of a Dissertation Chair Part 1: The Six Mistakes Doctoral Students Make With the Dissertation. Presented at the 5th Annual 2017 Black Doctoral Network Conference in Atlanta, GA on October 26-29 2017. 11 Research Significance This type of significance is important because it focuses on the importance of your study and how it is important from a research perspective. Research significance is usually one of three types below. There are three components of research significance: (a) continuation; (b) extension; and (c) new inquiry (Miles, 2017). (a) Continuation. A continuation is the type of research significance that continues the prior research with the same or similar population. This would be also be called a replication study (Miles, 2016a). (b) Extension. An extension is the type of significance that used is when you are extending the prior research or theory to a new, underserved or under researched population. Normally you are applying to prior established theory or conceptual framework or research methodology to a new population (Miles, 2016a). (c) New Inquiry. A new inquiry is the type of significance that is used when you are conducting a new study (brand new), it is with a new theory and/or new population; or new research method and design. you are doing something new (ibid). This significance is the selling point of why your study is important You should craft your significance carefully and conservatively. See The Statement Grid (Table 3 on p. 12) on the examples of writing significance.
  • 12. Doctoral Student Workshop: Contributions vs. Significance Source: Miles, D.A. and Scott, L. (2017) Workshop: Confessions of a Dissertation Chair Part 1: The Six Mistakes Doctoral Students Make With the Dissertation. Presented at the 5th Annual 2017 Black Doctoral Network Conference in Atlanta, GA on October 26-29 2017. 12 Table 3. The Statement Grid – The Significance of the Study Overall Statement: “As a basis for this study, the researcher identified three major reasons why this study is significant.” Significance 1: First, this study is important because provides a theoretical significance. This study breaks some new ground in management and human resources theory. Many nursing program deans and administrators of how nursing faculty experience job satisfaction in order to facilitate a workplace conducive of job satisfaction (theoretical significance). Significance 2: Second, this study is important because it also provides a practical significance. This research attempts to provide insight to practicing nurses considering a transition to a role in nursing education by elucidating experiences of job satisfaction by nursing faculty (practical significance). Significance 3: Last, this study is important because it also provides research significance. This study is important because it is a replication study or a continuation. This study is a continuation of the prior research on the nursing shortage. This study will replicate a prior study by Shaw and Cruz (2014). This study will provide additional insight on the shortage and inform the nursing professorate of the current lived experiences of job satisfaction by nursing faculty teaching classroom and clinical education of baccalaureate nursing students (Cook, 2017). (research significance). See the actual examples (see Examples 4 to 6) beginning on page 13. These provide some examples of writing the significance of the study.
  • 13. Doctoral Student Workshop: Contributions vs. Significance Source: Miles, D.A. and Scott, L. (2017) Workshop: Confessions of a Dissertation Chair Part 1: The Six Mistakes Doctoral Students Make With the Dissertation. Presented at the 5th Annual 2017 Black Doctoral Network Conference in Atlanta, GA on October 26-29 2017. 13 [Example 4] Based on the literature, there are two main reasons why this study is significant, research and practical. First, this study provides research significance. This study is an extension of the prior research on technostress among academics working in universities in India (Jena & Mahanti, 2014). This study is extending the prior research to a new population, (U.S. higher education employees). This study is important because the study’s results will show differences in the extent of technostress experienced based on the technology awareness, demographic factors, and job characteristics of higher education workers. In addition, the proposed study is an extension of the prior research on demographic differences in technostress conducted by Jena and Mahanti (2014). The researchers utilized the technostress- demographic model for investigating the effects of technology awareness, gender, age, tenure, and marital status on technostress of academics working in universities in India (Jena & Mahanti, 2014). Jena and Mahanti (2014) called for future research to include a more diverse sample within higher education, as well as investigate relationships between technostress and additional demographic factors. This study, therefore, includes both academic and non-academic roles for investigation and extends the technostress-demographic model by including additional demographic factors and job characteristics. In prior technostress research, technostress has been found to negatively affect job satisfaction and job performance (Kumar, Singh, & Bhuchar, 2017; Tagurum, Okonoda, Miner, Bello, & Tagurum, 2017). This study, therefore, may achieve research significance because it can provide new information germane to some factors potentially affecting or contributing related to technostress of in this population, and based on past technostress research, can be used as justification for developing programs for mitigating the effects of technostress among U.S. higher education workers.. Conducting this study may also open up new inquiries into further technostress research within the higher education realm such as how technostress affects technology acceptance and organizational effectiveness among this population. Second, this study provides practical significance. This study is essential because if results reveal statistically significant differences in the extent of technostress based on technology awareness, demographic factors, and job characteristics, these results can become helpful for designing programs for lessening the effects or preventing technostress in U.S. higher education employees. In other populations, technostress has been linked to absenteeism, lower productivity and job satisfaction, and costly mistakes (Chiappetta, 2017). This study offers practical significance to those in the field who may experience technology related stress to the extent that it negatively affects work-related progress. These examples demonstrate how addressing the problem of to what extent technology-related stress differs based on technology awareness, demographic factors, employment status, and department in the U.S. higher education population can add value to this population by making their institutions more aware of the problem potentially prompting the creation of better-coping programs, as well as reducing the costs associated with lost revenue due to technostress (Galluch et al., 2015). [Cornish, 2019].
  • 14. Doctoral Student Workshop: Contributions vs. Significance Source: Miles, D.A. and Scott, L. (2017) Workshop: Confessions of a Dissertation Chair Part 1: The Six Mistakes Doctoral Students Make With the Dissertation. Presented at the 5th Annual 2017 Black Doctoral Network Conference in Atlanta, GA on October 26-29 2017. 14 [Example 5] The researcher found two major reasons why this study is significant. First, this study offers a theoretical significance. This study breaks new ground by introducing the parental perception of parental involvement with schools into the existing framework of the phenomenon. This study is important because through identification of the parental perspective on their involvement in school to support the education of their children, school systems may be able to use the information to address the issue of parental involvement more effectively. Lastly, the study offers a research significance by extending research to the under researched parent population through an investigation into their perceptions of parental involvement in school. This study is an extension of the prior research on the topic. The study is significant because it will extend the prior research to the new and under-researched population of parents [Forbes, 2019].
  • 15. Doctoral Student Workshop: Contributions vs. Significance Source: Miles, D.A. and Scott, L. (2017) Workshop: Confessions of a Dissertation Chair Part 1: The Six Mistakes Doctoral Students Make With the Dissertation. Presented at the 5th Annual 2017 Black Doctoral Network Conference in Atlanta, GA on October 26-29 2017. 15 [Example 6] As a foundation for this investigation, there are three major reasons why this study is significant. First, this study provides a theoretical significance. The contribution of this study will add to the field of management in theory and practice. This study will test the linkage between two constructs; the air transportation organization, and the geographical location of Puerto Rico not previously been tested. The foundation theories in this study are the Douglas McGregor’s Theory X and Theory Y. Miner (2002) stated that this theory has a lack of investigation and need to be tested. Douglas McGregor's Theory X and Theory Y of management remain virtually untested (Schein, 2011). Due to the lack of published studies related to the theories, a study testing McGregor's Theory X and Y with field data would be an important theoretical contribution to the body of knowledge (Sahin, 2012). This study will allow the researcher to examine and compare the results of the data from air transportation organizations in Puerto Rico. Second, this study also offers a practical significance. It is significant to the field of management practices and the relation with employees. This study will identify if there is a relationship between leaders’ openness to new business strategies, customer and market focus, and employee’s empowerment with the organizational performance of air transportation companies located in Puerto Rico. There are studies that demonstrate the relationship of the variables; however, none of these studies are related to air transportation companies located in the geographical area of Puerto Rico. Although there are studies in other industry sectors such as health care (Lin, Liao, Chen, & Fan, 2014) and the bank industry (Abbasi, Khan, & Rashid, 2011), it cannot be assumed the behavior of the variables will be the same in the air transportation sector located in Puerto Rico. Last, this study also offers a research significance as it is an extension of the prior research. This study will extend prior research to a new population and new industry sector. This study will contribute to the field of knowledge by extending and enhancing research related to the air transportation organizations’ performance. The new population on which this study will be conducted is employees in Puerto Rico. The new industry sector to which this study will extend is the air transportation organization. This study will fill the gaps presented by conducting research in air transportation organizations, by conducting research in the geographical location of Puerto Rico, extending current studies about the correlation between customer and market focus, employee empowerment, leaders’ openness to new business strategies, and organizational performance. The investigation will demonstrate the behavior of the variables in study regarding correlation as similar studies shown in previous researches in other geographical locations [Morales, 2019].
  • 16. Doctoral Student Workshop: Contributions vs. Significance Source: Miles, D.A. and Scott, L. (2017) Workshop: Confessions of a Dissertation Chair Part 1: The Six Mistakes Doctoral Students Make With the Dissertation. Presented at the 5th Annual 2017 Black Doctoral Network Conference in Atlanta, GA on October 26-29 2017. 16 Conclusions and Summary This article discussed the differences and definitions between the terms, the contributions of the study and the significance of the study. This article addressed the two key differences between the contributions of the study and the significance of the study. First, this article addressed three key contributions of the study: (a) conceptual/theoretical, (b) empirical, and (c) methodological. The definition and examples of the three types of contributions of were illustrated. Last, this article addressed three significance types of the study: (a) theoretical significance, (b) practical significance, and (c) research significance. The definition and examples of the three types of significance of were illustrated. In addition, the article discussed the three types of research significance: (a) continuation, (b) extension, and (c) new inquiry. We hope this article will act as a guide for helping novice and experienced researchers learn and understand the district differences between the contributions of the study and the significance of the study. The researchers hope to build a strong foundation for enlightening both experienced and novice researchers on the two terms and lessen the confusion.
  • 17. Doctoral Student Workshop: Contributions vs. Significance Source: Miles, D.A. and Scott, L. (2017) Workshop: Confessions of a Dissertation Chair Part 1: The Six Mistakes Doctoral Students Make With the Dissertation. Presented at the 5th Annual 2017 Black Doctoral Network Conference in Atlanta, GA on October 26-29 2017. 17 References Beltran, V. (2019). A Phenomenological Study of Central Texas Urban School Principals’ Experience of Influences Contributing to Job Stress from ProQuest Dissertations and Theses database. (UMI No.-To be announced). Bryant, M.T. (2004). The Portable Dissertation Advisor (1st Ed). Thousand Oaks, CA: Corwin Press. Calabrese, R. (2006). The Elements of An Effective Dissertation & Thesis: A Step-by-Step Guide to Getting it Right the First Time. Process (1st Ed). Lanham, MA: Rowman & Littlefield Education. Calabrese, R. (2009). The Dissertation Desk Reference: The Doctoral Student’s Manual to Writing the Dissertation (1st Ed). Lanham, MA: Rowman & Littlefield Education. Cook, L. (2017). The Current Issues Affecting Job Satisfaction by Nursing Faculty as a Lived Experience. from ProQuest Dissertations and Theses database. (UMI No.: To be announced). Cornish, D. (2019). An Empirical Study of Technostress Within the US Higher Education Sector from ProQuest Dissertations and Theses database. (UMI No.: To be announced). Forbes, S. (2019). Parental Involvement in Education: The Lived Experience from ProQuest Dissertations and Theses database. (UMI No. 87569869). Madsen, D. (1990). Successful Dissertations and Theses: A Guide To Graduate Student Research From Proposal To Completion. San Francisco, CA: Jossey-Bass Publishers. Miles, D.A. & Scott, L. (2017). Workshop: Confessions of a Dissertation Chair Part 1: The Six Mistakes Doctoral Students Make With the Dissertation. Presented at the 5th Annual 2017 Black Doctoral Network Conference in Atlanta, GA on October 26-29 2017. Morales, L. (2019). A Baldrige Assessment of an Organization: An Empirical Study of Baldrige Criteria and Organizational Performance in Air Transportation Organizations. from ProQuest Dissertations and Theses database. (UMI No. 6529858). Platt, P. (2019). An Investigation of Leadership Styles and Managerial Practices within the Federal Government: A Qualitative Study of the Transportation Security Administration (TSA) from ProQuest Dissertations and Theses database. (UMI No: To be announced). Webster, W. (1998). 21 Models for Developing and Writing Theses, Dissertations and Projects: A Manual of Sound Advice About Conceptualizing, Organizing, Developing and Finalizing Your Terminal Graduate Research. Surviving Your Dissertation: A Comprehensive Guide To Content and Process (1st Ed). San Ramon, CA: Academic Scholarwrite. Zeig, M. (2019). Effects of a Character Education Course on Standardized Testing in Texas High Schools from ProQuest Dissertations and Theses database. (UMI No. unknown). .