Presentation from a flipped summer classroom workshop held during May and June 2014 for Arts & Science Faculty at CU Boulder.
Workshop was presented by ASSETT - Arts & Science Support of Education Through Technology.
3. The biggest barrier to [a] blended
learning [approach] is the
pathological fear that your students’
performance will worsen if you do not
lecture to them.
http://edinnovation.wisc.edu/content/uploads/2013/02/06a_flipping_courses.pdf
5. Agenda
9:15 - 11:00 am :: Nuts & Bolts of the Flipped
Classroom
11:00 am - 12:00 pm :: Lunch
12:00 - 1:30 pm :: Camtasia
1:45 pm - 4:00 pm :: Active Learning &
Assessment
6. After attending this workshop, the
participant will be able to:
1. design a lesson/module using tenets of the flipped
classroom;
2. produce a short lecture video for concept mastery;
3. plan in-class activities that provide opportunities
for critical thinking;
4. evaluate student learning using a combination of
assessment types.
9. Flipped Learning is …
a pedagogical approach in which direct instruction
moves from the group learning space to the individual
learning space, and the resulting group space is
transformed into a dynamic, interactive learning
environment where the educator guides students
as they apply concepts and engage creatively in the
subject matter.
Flipped Learning Network
10. Flipped Learning is ...
➔a student-centered learning approach.
➔maximizing in-class time, providing students
with an opportunity to apply concepts, with
personalized attention.
➔changing the way students engage with
content, peers, lectures and YOU.
➔not a new trend or contemporary way of
teaching.
11. Seven Principles for Good Practice in
Undergraduate Education
1. Encourages contact between students and faculty.
2. Develops reciprocity and cooperation among students.
3. Encourages active learning.
4. Gives prompt feedback.
5. Emphasizes time on task.
6. Communicates high expectations.
7. Respects diverse talents and ways of learning.
Chickering and Gamson, 1987
12. Research on Flipped Learning
“Quantitative and rigorous qualitative research
on flipped learning is limited, but there is a
great deal of research that supports the key
elements of the model with respect to
instructional strategies for engaging students
in their learning.”
Flipped Learning Network, 2013
13. Active learning research tells us ….
that active involvement in the learning
process is vitally important in two areas: (a)
for the mastery of skills, such as critical
thinking and problem-solving and (b) for
contributing to the student’s likelihood of
persisting to program completion
(Braxton, Jones, Hirschy, & Hartkey, 2008; Prince, 2004).
14.
15. Growing practice that shows
promise and potential, AND
presents opportunities for
research.
16. Student Engagement
F
Flexible
learning
environment
L
Shift in
Learning
culture
I
Intentional
Content
P
Professional
Educators
Pillars of Flipped Learning
Adapted from A White Paper based on the Literature review titled A Review of Flipped Learning
17. Who is flipping their classrooms
➔Mostly K-12
➔Higher Ed is slowly gaining traction
➔CU
◆ Andrew Martin, EBIO
◆ Shaw Ketels, Psychology
◆ Phoebe Young, History
◆ Olivia Conner, IEC
◆ probably many more!
18. Possible outcomes of the classroom
● Improved critical thinking and problem
solving skills
● Increased engagement with students
● Increased student engagement with content
● Ability to offer personalized learning
● Ability to facilitate mastery learning
● MORE Data
19. Clintondale High School
http://www.pbs.org/newshour/bb/american-graduate-july-dec13-flipped_12-11/
20. Byron High School
Image Credit: http://stemwire.org/files/flipped-1.jpg
21. Higher Ed
● US (UW - Seattle)
o Intro to Biology Pre Flip: 17% failure
o Post Flip: 4% failure rate & # of A increased from 14 to 24%
● Canada (U of BC - Vancouver)
o Large Lecture Physics course (250+/section)
o Flipped only last week of instruction
o Post Flip: Attendance - 20%, engagement 40%, and scored
more than 2x as well as students in lecture section on MC
comp exam.
http://www.flippedlearning.org/cms/lib07/VA01923112/Centricity/Domain/41/HigherEdWhitePaper%20FINAL.pdf
22. Flipped classroom model improves graduate student performance in cardiovascular, respiratory, and renal
physiology (J. D. Tune , M. Sturek , D. P. Basile (2013) Advances in Physiology Education 2013 Vol. 37no. 316-320)
Students in the flipped course scored significantly higher (P ≤ 0.05) on the cardiovascular, respiratory, and weighted cumulative
sections by an average of >12 percentage point. Exam averages for students in the flipped course also tended to be higher on the
renal section by ∼11 percentage points (P = 0.06).
23. From the Educational Technologist lens
...
Pedagogical and
technical support
IT Infrastructure (D2L,
Kaltura, WiFi,
Computer labs)
Availability of
software
28. Criticism of the Flipped Classroom
➔It’s just another higher ed trend, buzz word,
or gimmick.
➔Undervalues the power of good, face to face,
socratic teaching methods.
➔Students say their instructor is just ‘coasting’
and not really teaching them.
29. Considerations
➔One size does not fit all
◆ Humanities, Socratic method, Seminar
◆ Teaching Styles
◆ Learning Styles
➔Physical classroom constraint
◆ Stadium Seating
◆ Lack of outlets or Internet connection
30. Flipping Courses: Transitioning From Traditional Courses to a Blended‐Learning Approach
http://edinnovation.wisc.edu/content/uploads/2013/02/06a_flipping_courses.pdf
32. How do I flip my class?
1. Record lectures
2. Assign lectures as homework
3. Facilitate engaging learning activities during
class time
4. Create assessments that frequently check
for understanding.
5. Create opportunities for student feedback.
36. Flipping Large Classes
The idea and process are the same
BUT....
Classroom management may need more attention than
in a smaller class.
37. Flipping Large Classes
● Can you make stadium seating work?
● Do you have enough TAs?
● Will the TAs’ roles need to shift?
● What technologies can help with classroom
management?
o clickers or other response systems
o auto-graded quizzes
o group tools
● Could you incorporate alternate meeting times?
39. Get Ready to Screencast!
Do you:
● have a lesson/concept that you’d like to
record?
● have the Camtasia software installed?
o If not, go to http://bit.ly/dl_cam
● have your software key?
o Please see a facilitator
40.
41. Creating ADA Compliant Screencasts
● Accessible Delivery of Audio & Video
● Accessible Delivery of Images
● Accessible Delivery of Text
42. “Brain research tells us that the novelty of any stimulus
tends to wear off after about 10 minutes, and as a
result, learners tend to check out after 10 minutes of
exposure to new content” (Medina, 2008.)
“One benefit, then, of placing lectures online may be
that they can break down direct instruction into more
engaging, 10-minute bites of learning.”
Educational Leadership, 2013
43. Recommendations
● <10 minutes
● Adequate lighting and neutral background
● Sound: find a quiet space
o use mic to isolate voice and decrease ambient
sounds
● Clean up your (computer) desktop
● Develop & publish a script to increase
accessibility!
48. What is Active Learning?
Active learning is "anything that involves students
in doing things and thinking about the things they
are doing."
Bonwell, C. C., & Eison, J. A. (1991). Active learning: Creating excitement in the classroom (ASHE–ERIC Higher Education Rep. No. 1). Washington, DC:
The George Washington University, School of Education and Human Development.
51. Structuring Group Activities
How to Implement the Elements of Cooperative Learning
● Lessons are structured
● Learners work together to achieve shared goals.
● Work in small groups.
● Groups are heterogeneous.
● Joint success is celebrated.
● Evaluated by matching performance with clear criteria
52. Structuring Group Activities
Positive Interdependence
Individual Accountability
Face-to-Face (Promotive) Interaction
Interpersonal and Small Group Social Skills
Group Processing
53. Structuring Group Activities
Positive Interdependence Goal Interdependence, Resource Interdependence
Role Interdependence
Individual Accountability Individual Grades, Peer Assessment
Promotive Interaction Student Roles
Interpersonal Skills Discussion, Time to Practice
Group Processing Individual Reflections
62. “In a flipped classroom, a professor is able to teach
both content and process. The kinds of problems
that people with degrees in mathematics get hired to
work on are amorphous and poorly defined. A lot
of the problems my students will face don't even
exist yet. We can't just focus on
content coverage. We have to
teach the ability to adapt and
evolve along with the problems.”
Quote from Robert Talbert in 6 Expert Tips for Flipping the Classroom, 2013
65. Criticism of Higher Ed
“Apathetic students, illiterate graduates,
incompetent teaching, impersonal
campuses …”
Chickering and Gamson, 1987
66. The Transmittal Model
“Assumes that the student's brain is like an empty container
into which the professor pours knowledge. In this view of
teaching and learning, students are passive learners rather
than active ones. Such a view is outdated and will not be
effective for the twenty-first century, when individuals will
be expected to think for themselves, pose and solve
complex problems, and generally produce knowledge
rather than reproduce it.”
College Teaching, 1993
67. Challenges Large Classes
● Instructors have reduced interactions with students
● Students feel isolated and anonymous
● Leads to feeling less responsible and motivated
● Reduced level of active involvement
● How to implement student centered approaches
with so many students
(Kerr, 2011)
68. What we know ….
In one survey of 453 teachers who flipped their
classrooms, 67 percent reported increased test
scores, with particular benefits for students in
advanced placement classes and students with special
needs; 80 percent reported improved student attitudes;
and 99 percent said they would flip their classrooms
again next year (Flipped Learning Network, 2012).
69. Flipped classroom model improves graduate student performance in cardiovascular, respiratory, and renal
physiology (J. D. Tune , M. Sturek , D. P. Basile (2013) Advances in Physiology Education 2013 Vol. 37no. 316-320)
Students in the flipped course scored significantly higher (P ≤ 0.05) on the cardiovascular, respiratory, and weighted cumulative
sections by an average of >12 percentage point. Exam averages for students in the flipped course also tended to be higher on the
renal section by ∼11 percentage points (P = 0.06).
Editor's Notes
Participants introduce themselves and include what department they’re from, class they’d like to flip, size, why they’re here, and expectations of the workshop.
There are different perceptions of what the flipped classroom is - what are some of your definitions?
This is especially important as Dean Leigh mentioned during the A&S meeting on May 22 that we don’t have the capacity to grow so our priority is retention -
The Flipped Learning Network identified 4 common elements that all flipped classrooms have in common. They are Flexibility, Shift in learning culture, having intentional content, and being a professional educator (this is not meant to say that you’re unprofessional - it’s emphasizing that you as a professional cannot be replaced by a video lecture)
Flexible environments: Teachers must expect that class time will be "somewhat chaotic and noisy" and that timelines and expectations for learning assessments will have to be flexible as well. Flexible learning also means that students can learn on their timelines and given various tools to
Culture shift: The classroom becomes student-centered. According to the guide: "Students move from being the product of teaching to the center of learning, where they are actively involved in knowledge formation through opportunities to participate in and evaluate their learning in a manner that is personally meaningful."
Intentional content: Teachers are required to evaluate what they need to teach directly so that classroom time can be used for other methods of teaching, such as "active learning strategies, peer instruction, problem-based learning, or mastery or Socratic methods, depending on grade level and subject matter."
Professional educators: The instructional videos used for flipped classrooms cannot replace trained, professional teachers. Professional
Educators are reflective in their practice, connect with each other to improve their instruction, accept constructive criticism, and tolerate
controlled chaos in their classrooms.
Read more at http://thejournal.com/articles/2013/06/18/report-the-4-pillars-of-the-flipped-classroom.aspx#IlCmX2lokX4jBeKL.99
Note: average # of days in a school year is 180 - average # of disciplinary actions per day - 4
Pre Flip
¾ of students come from low income families.
One of lowest performing schools in MI.
Almost 50% of 9th graders were failing Math, Science, and English
736 disciplinary cases
Post Flip
Failure rates dropped 33%
Disciplinary cases dropped 74% over 2 years
ACT score increase over double of national average
Graduation rate - 90%
College acceptance - ~80%
Jacie -- these is the only positive example I found for highered. Please add wherever it makes sense to add -- I was not sure.
1. Students performed the same whether they enrolled in the flipped classroom or the traditional lecture.
2. Students did not feel the lectures replaced the faculty
** 3. More students in the flipped version enrolled in the subsequent chemistry course than the traditional lecture (so students were engaged)
Instructors have reduced interactions with students
Students feel isolated and anonymous
Leads to feeling less responsible and motivated
Reduced level of active involvement
How to implement student centered approaches with so many students
Some instructors allow students to find spaces outside of the class to work
activities and group work need to be consistent. This means, same groups, same day, in class schedule is same
again -- just some facts found in some article about Flipped learning. Feel free to delete.
Read the case study, think about it, then in groups come up solutions - 15 min.
What really makes a flipped classroom work is how the time spent in class changes. What is done inside the classroom must be uniquely different from what they have learned outside of class as well as require them to apply those concepts.
How will you make that time meaningful for students?
LIttle discussion, what did you notice?
Bonwell and Eison coined the phrase in 1991, quite literally it is talking, listening, reading, writing, reflecting. But it becomes our jobs to provide the prompts that get students to really take part in these activities.
give them the 2 sided handout
moving from instructor oriented to student centered, time
Have you used any of these?
What successes have you had?
What challenges have you had?
Assessment is a great big topic, so focusing on what is important for flipped classroom
There’s all the assessments of student’s learning - diagnostic, formative, summative
And then we also need to determine if we had anything to do with the student learning that occurred or didn’t occur
here I’m talking about course evaluations
Just learned how to make all these cool videos, students are going to be clammering to watch right?!
How will you ensure that students come to class prepared?
self tests/self checks
with possible incentives
JiTT
Short survey responses on thoughts, or questions they may have
When you first start flipping, you may want to regularly collect feedback on how it’s going
so you can make adjustments and clear up any misconceptions early on
Accountability assignments help give you feedback about how students are doing on learning mastery content
But may want to get more informative feedback about the knowledge connections students are making or aren’t making
BUT you do have to be willing to be flexible and make changes
Students will be more willing to give you good responses if they see you’re listening to them
In summative assessment, Alignment becomes key
Probably have seen it a million times, but let’s make life easier and simple again.
Reiterate! It’s practical and makes the development of assessments much easier
Best way to develop an assignment/project is to make sure you know what you’re looking for in the end
&
Best way to align is to make sure your learning objectives/outcomes are written in Bloom’s language and then choose activities and assessments with these words.
Example of learning objective is to understand xyz…., then develop an short activity that asks them to demonstrate, discuss, summarize, etc.
that activity then prepares them for a larger assessment that asks them to evaluate an example of xyz that exists in the real world
Give poor example – most teachers start out with an LO that I want students to understand or know how to do xyz…, but then the assessment may be much more involved, or at least that we’re looking for these nuanced and elaborate analyses of the concepts we introduced
I want students to analyze messages in the media about climate change, and then you asked them to organize examples with explanations in a blog post
Now think what are all the ways I could find out if my students now have more nuanced methods of analyzing the media messages
Distribute objectives evenly and distribute assessments evenly
To reach one objective, you need to balance activities across the various levels
formative along the way to make changes but then it’s a good idea to do an
evaluation about the flipped method - whether after individual unit, or at end of class
Good idea to use some of your own course evaluations that address the specific changes you’ve made.
did the mini lecture videos help you learn concepts
Did the class activities help you learn concepts
did class discussions help you
rate the group project portion
think about data you would want to collect to help round out picture of student perceptions
grades
attendance
number of times videos were accessed
clicker scores, data
???
Anything you would change about the solutions you originally came up with
Then groups 2nd column of worksheet for module
2nd column of worksheet
planning in class activities
Robert Talbert
Department of Mathematics
Grand Valley State University
From Sage on the Stage to Guide on the Side, Alison King
Jacie -- these is the only positive example I found for highered. Please add wherever it makes sense to add -- I was not sure.