2. INTRODUCTION
Will examine:Will examine:
Explanations for gender inequality
Gender inequality in the home, the
labour force, and politics
Recommendations for reducing
gender inequality*
3.
4. GENDER INEQUALITY
Social roles: Behaviours expected of people
occupying particular social positions
In 20th
century, enormous change in
attitudes, expectations, behaviours, and
social roles of men and women in Canada
But persistence of gender inequalities:
Hierarchical asymmetries between women
and men in terms of distribution of power,
material wellbeing, and prestige*
5.
6. GENDER STEREOTYPES
Gender inequality is reinforced by gender
stereotypes:
Set of prejudicial biologically-based
generalizations about men and women in
terms of personality traits and behaviour
Persistence of polarized gender stereotypes is
supported by research
Yet , gender-related identities and behaviours
largely socially constructed and continually
altered through social interaction*
7.
8. GENDER STEREOTYPES
Socially constructed nature of gender
identities means gender identities:
Are not stable or fixed
Need not be congruent with sex assigned
at birth
Are not polar opposites (despite notion of
“opposite sex”), but can operate on a
continuum of masculinity and femininity*
9.
10. DIMENSIONS OF INEQUALITY:
POWER, MATERIAL WELLBEING,
AND PRESTIGE
1. Power: Capacity to impose your will on others,
regardless of any resistance
2. Material wellbeing: Involves access to economic
resources required to pay for necessities of life
and other possessions and advantages
3. Prestige: Average evaluation of occupational
activities and positions arranged in a hierarchy*
11. EXPLAINING GENDER
INEQUALITY
Feminism: Body of knowledge about causes
and nature of women’s subordination to
men in society, and various agendas - often
involving political action - for removing that
subordination
Feminist theories:
1. Liberal feminism
2. Marxist feminism
3. Socialist feminism…*
14. 1. LIBERAL FEMINIST
THEORIES
Gender inequalities caused and
perpetuated by gender stereotyping and
gendered division of labour
Achieve gender equality through:
Removing gender stereotyping and
discrimination in workplace and education,
and
Changing laws to allow for equal
opportunities in labour force and politics*
15. 2. MARXIST FEMINIST
THEORIES
Women’s unpaid domestic work maintains and
reproduces labour force
Capitalists benefit by women (wives/mothers):
Ensuring workers (males) ready to work each
day
Raising children to become future labourers
Acting as own reserve army of labour
Achieve gender equality through socialism*
16.
17. 3. SOCIALIST FEMINIST
THEORIES
Agree with Marxist feminist theories but include
additional component:
Recognize classes constitute only one set of social
relations that oppress women
Second set of oppressive social relations:
Patriarchy System of male domination over
women
Decrease gender inequality through:
State-subsidies for maternal benefits and child care
Equal pay for equal work*
18. Male power and control over women
characterize all social relations, routine
behaviours, and commonly accepted
practices
Workplace sexual harassment: Result of
general belief that men are superior to
women and may impose their will upon
them
Is example of power as a system of
dominance and exploitation
Is system because capacity of men
and incapacity of women to control
and influence has become routine*
19. SEPARATE SPHERES
Separation of public sphere for men and
private sphere for women
Consequences of separation for women:
Association of domestic labour as women’s
work
Devaluation of unpaid domestic labour
Tendency to view nurturing and care-giving
as biologically-determined traits
Financial dependence on men
Reduced access to power, prestige, and
material wellbeing*
20.
21. DOMESTIC LABOUR
Despite rise in female labour force
participation, women still more likely than
men to do unpaid work involving home
maintenance and child-care
While men have begun to do housework
and child-care, women still spend more
hours than men on domestic activities
Consequences of “double day” for women:
Less time available for recreational activities
More likely to report feeling stressed*
22. OCCUPATIONAL SEGREGATION
AND SEX TYPING
Women in paid labour force typically do jobs
that involve care-giving, nurturing, and
household-type management
Has given rise to:
i. Sex typing (or sex labelling) of occupations:
Designating an occupation as appropriate for
one sex
ii. Sex segregation of occupations:
Concentration of women and men in different
occupations*
In the 1950s, women’s roles were those of wives and mothers
In contrast, men were expected to have paying jobs, and be the “provider” for family as well as “head of the household”
Social scientists usually refer to inequalities between men and women as “gender inequalities” rather than “sex inequalities” because gender refers to the social meanings associated with being a man or a woman, whereas sex refers to the biological characteristics of men and women
Gender is found in social roles in daily interactions, and in institutions
Definition of gender inequalities does not imply men as individuals always have greater prestige, wealth, and power but that, on average, compared with women, men have more wealth, greater power, and positions that are accorded higher prestige
Gives rise to notions of “masculinity” or “femininity”: Cultural prescriptions for behaviour based on biological sex
A fixation of the alleged opposed characteristics of men and women is evident in such phrases as the “opposite sex”
Power involves the capacity to influence, manipulate, and control others, and is exercised at the individual, group, and organizational levels
Important sources of material wellbeing: Work-related income and accumulated wealth
Prestige reflects the degree of respect, honour, or deference generally accorded to a person occupying a given position
Commonly, two or more differently evaluated positions are described as having higher or lower prestige
These three dimensions (power, material wellbeing, prestige) are found in discussions of social stratification as well
Of the many feminist theories that exist, liberal, Marxist, and socialist feminism are three popular explanations for gender inequalities in Canada’s economy and polity.
Liberal feminism is rooted in the liberalism of the 1700s.
It assumes that human beings are rational and will correct inequalities when they know about them.
Liberalism assumes that a good society is one in which men and women enjoy equal rights and opportunities.
According to liberal feminism, gender inequalities are caused and perpetuated by gender stereotyping and the division of work into “women’s” and “men’s” jobs.
Accordingly, the two main ways to achieve gender equality are by (1) removing gender stereotyping and discrimination in education and paid work and (2) changing laws so that men and women have equal opportunities in the labour force and in politics (Lorber, 1998).
A different perspective on gender inequality derives from the writings of Karl Marx.
According to Marxist feminists, women’s unpaid work in the home maintains and reproduces the labour force.
Capitalists benefit because they obtain refreshed workers at the beginning of each day and mothers raise children who will become future labourers.
They also benefit from women’s paid work because women in the paid labour force, like men, help capitalists earn profit and because they act as a “reserve army of labour” that can be hired and fired as labour demands change.
Marxist feminists believe that gender equality is possible once socialism replaces capitalism.
Socialist feminists build on Marxist feminism; they agree that gender inequality is caused by the gendered division of labour and its exploitation by capitalism.
However, they argue that classes constitute only one set of social relations that oppress women.
The second set of social relations that performs this function is that of patriarchy, the system of male domination over women.
Patriarchy predates capitalism; the forms it takes vary across time and within societies.
But generally, childbearing and the sexual activities of women are the foundation of gender inequality.
Moreover, because domestic and public spheres intersect, inequalities in one sphere can create disadvantages for women in the other sphere (the “public sphere” refers to government and the world of paid work).
For socialist feminists, the steps required to decrease gender inequality include government-subsidized maternal benefits and child care, and the payment of equal wages and salaries to people who do equally valued work.
Removing inequality altogether requires the eradication of male dominance as expressed in the legal system, the educational system, the family, and the economy (Chafetz, 1999; Jaggar, 1983; Lorber, 1998).
Male influence and control over women does not simply mean the predominance of men rather than women in politics and the military
Other examples include women being denied the right to vote, and workplace regulations that encourage or compel women to quit work upon marriage (one such regulation existed in the federal civil service until 1955)
Gender inequalities in power also combine with racial inequalities
As a result, minority women experience the most harassment because they are both women and members of a minority group
Male domination and female subordination are evident in all social relations: political, economic, familial, and sexual
Gender inequality derives from the historical fact that women have been allocated the private sphere, and men the public sphere: This has created differential opportunities for acquiring wealth, power, and prestige
The demands on women to provide unpaid care likely will increase, because the number of senior Canadians in need of care will increase substantially
Past care-giving patterns suggest future providers of care are most likely to be women
This situation is exacerbated for the “sandwich” generation: Women caught between demands of caring for children and caring for older relatives
Stereotypical association of women with care giving is also found in paid work
Men tend to be managers, doctors, construction workers, etc.
Sex labelling of occupations usually accompanies occupational segregation