Presentation made in the session: Improving Pedagogy and Practice of Undergraduate Engineering Teaching
session at the Higher Education Partnership Models for South Africa: A co-design workshop, CSIR International Convention Centre, 8 June 2015.
The use of ICTs to facilitate work integrated learning in engineering education: introducing the Open Architecture case study
1. The use of ICTs to facilitate work integrated
learning in engineering education:
introducing the Open Architecture case study
Jolanda Morkel
Senior lecturer, Architectural Technology, Faculty of Informatics and Design,
Cape Peninsula University of Technology
CPUT part-time coordinator, OpenArchitecture
Higher Education Partnership Models for South Africa: A co-design workshop
CSIR International Convention Centre, 8 June 2015.
Session: Improving Pedagogy and Practice of Undergraduate Engineering Teaching
2. Hangberg Community Project: video
Emerging themes:
- Blurring of boundaries between Industry/ Practice, Community and
Academia
- Different roles and responsibilities
- Different kinds of practices require different approaches to teaching and
learning
- Learning drawing on students’ indigenous knowledge, sense of care and
contribution
- That it’s all about people
3. Education lies at a peculiar crossroad in
society. On one hand it has the responsibility
of anticipating real-life skills by preparing us
for an increasingly complex world – but
education methodologies can only be
formalized after practices have been
defined. This dichotomy is particularly
aggravated when it comes to technology,
where fast-paced innovation and
perpetual change is the only constant.
http://www.teachthought.com/technology/6-characteristics-of-tomorrows-classroom-technology/
4. challenges facing studio traditionchanging practice & learning landscape
practice specialization, diversification, transformation
changing roles and responsibilities, identity
academy diverse, non-traditional students, growing
numbers, student-lecturer ratio, demographics
technology information & communication
resources limited, unequally spread
time ubiquitous: anytime &
place anywhere: campus, community, office, online
5. What are the relevant knowledges
that will best equip students to
become responsible practitioners in
an ever-changing world?
6.
7. What are the most appropriate
ways to make such learning
happen?
What are the different activity
systems/ communities of practice
where such learning can happen
and how do they work?
9. Work-Integrated Learning (WIL) is a methodology of
curriculum design that integrates academic learning
(including theoretical, problem-based and project-
based learning) at CPUT with industry-based and/or
community-based experiential learning that is
structured, monitored and assessed to meet the
outcomes of a learning programme.
From: INSTITUTIONAL POSITION STATEMENT ON WORK INTEGRATED
LEARNING - DISCUSSION DOCUMENT (1ST DRAFT)
10. But it’s about more than just the content
and more than just the place…
The learning environment is the content
taught, the pedagogical methods
employed, the sequencing of learning
activities, and the sociology of learning.
(Collins et al 1991:1)
12. How might emerging digital
technologies contribute to and
enable relevant and authentic
learning experiences?
How does it promote access and
transformation?
18. Based on Anderson and Krathwohl's Taxonomy 2000 (adapted Bloom’s Taxonomy 1956
remembering
understanding
applying
analyzing
creating
evaluating .
http://www.schrockguide.net
/bloomin-apps.html
19. behaviourist: change in actions
constructivist: construct new ideas based on existing knowledge
situated: authentic context and culture
collaborative: social interaction
informal and lifelong: outside dedicated learning spaces
[Naismith, Lonsdale, Vavoula and Sharples 2004]
different technologies
for different learning paradigms
22. "We will have students in face-to-face
traditional environments when that makes
sense, in the workplace when that makes
sense, and out in the world exploring when
that makes sense, plus…the value and
advantages of online flexible learning...”
Stephen Kossakoski, 2013
CEO of the Virtual Learning Academy Charter School
…as long as it’s appropriate, relevant & makes sense
employing ICTs in blended learning liberate face to face
sessions to becoming truly interactive: no more lectures.
23. ‘The purpose and aim of a blended approach
remains to ‘enhance the learning experiences
for students and teachers by enabling them to
engage in ways that would not normally be
available or effective in their usual
environment...’
Bath & Bourke, 2010
why blended learning
24. Blended learning
“Learning that uses multiple strategies, methods and delivery systems”.
The Node Learning Technologies Network, 2003
“Learning methods that combine e-learning with other forms of flexible learning
and more traditional forms of learning.”
Flexible Learning Advisory Group, 2004
25. on campus off campus
face-to-faceonline
technology
technology
26. taking architectural learning online
the use of digital technologies to facilitate the
formative studio critique (crit)
more than just the tool…
learning is the relationships between people
Smith, M. K. 2003. Communities of practice, the encyclopedia of informal education
www.infed.org/biblio/communities_of_practice.htm. Accessed 10 July 2011
27. “A part time blended architectural learning programme”
OpenArchitecture provides part time Architectural studies through a
blended learning programme whereby an online learning portal supports
office-based mentoring, occasional regional studios and face-to-face block
release sessions on campus.
28. practice-academic collaboration
The first programme to be presented in this way is
the two year part-time
BTech Architectural Technology (Applied Design)
in collaboration with the
Cape Peninsula University of Technology
(CPUT) which started in January 2014.
29. practice-academic collaboration
In response to the shortage of Professional Architects in
South Africa, the need for transformation in the
Architectural Profession and growing numbers of non-
traditional students with work and family commitments,
OpenArchitecture (OA) was conceived as a South African
Institute of Architects (SAIA) initiative.
Collaborating with Architectural Learning Sites (ALS) at
different Higher Education Institutions (HEI) it aims to offer
universally recognised alternatives to main-stream
graduate and post-graduate architecture education.
32. on campus off campus
face-to-faceonline
office-based‘block release’
online
Part time BTech
Architectural
Technology
(Applied Design)
using
technology
f2f
33. OA PROGRAMME
OpenArchitecture provides four different forms of engagement
office based
mentoring
[WIL]
online learning portal
[formal online]
facebook group
[Informal online]
face-to-face block
release [on campus,
community]
34. Announcements are made by
lecturers and visible to students
Calendar entries are regularly
updated to reflect all online
meetings (crits), submissions and
assessment dates, including
portfolio reviews.
Hangout topics are created by
staff and students and discussed
online.
The online learning portal contains the
following virtual spaces for learning:
35. Course work
is shared by educators and organised
per subject and assignment. Learning
material includes: recorded lectures,
short videos, written briefs, document
resources and links to available
online material. All staff and students
have access to the course work
folders.
Student work
is submitted for feedback and
assessment. Work is mostly created
in Word or Powerpoint formats and
then uploaded in pdf format. Only
staff can view and access the
submitted student work, not the
students.
36. Design Journal
(asynchronous)
students are required to keep a
design journal for every design
project. It resembles a blog and
contains drawings and text,
arranged in chronological order, to
reflect on their individual design
process and receive feedback from
tutors and peers.
Online crits (synchronous)
are held weekly through a webinar
where staff and students discuss
projects, using audio and digital on-
screen sketching. Crits are recorded
and uploaded to the learning portal.
37. Facebook group
A closed facebook group provides informal social
interaction, discussions and sharing of resources
38. The OpenArchitecture virtual learning interface
has demonstrated that it is possible to successfully
enable studio-based learning in a virtual
environment through the various face to face
interactions of the blended programme
Since the late 19th Century project-based learning has been central to the pedagogy of architectural education when the primary training for architects shifted from practice where the student would be apprenticed to the architect, to HE establishments (Cuff 1998). This education practice has remained mostly unchanged for the last hundred years.
However, changes in architectural practice, the nature of the student body, demands on resources such as time and space, as well as major developments in how we interact, communicate and function in the 21st Century, demand a critical relook at traditional studio teaching and learning strategies.
The emergence of information and communication technologies presents interesting opportunities for design collaboration that were not available before. They are often referred to as “disruptive” technologies but where disruption is used in a positive sense.
In design education, these technologies have formed new design platforms for interactive and engaged learning as part of a blended programme or where students are situated in remote locations.
I am using a framework formulated by Naismith, Lonsdale, Vavoula and Sharples for understanding mobile learning, to present the main threads in the literature and then illustrate each one with a relevant project or related research. Students learn through various interactions mediated through drawing, speech and gestures, in a process known as the critique or crit (Lymer 2010). So I will look at how ict might support design learning through behaviourist, constructivist, situated, collaborative and informal lifelong learning strategies.
The role of ICT is seen as part of a blended learning offering. There are many definitions for the term “blended learning, also known as “hybrid” or “mixed-mode” learning.
The Node Learning Technologies Network (2003) defines Blended Learning as learning that uses “multiple strategies, methods and delivery systems”.
Good educators have always used a mix of strategies, methods and media to reach their objectives – that’s not new. What is new is that today’s internet-based tools can facilitate communication, interaction, and collaborative learning in ways that were not possible before. It is on this basis that the OpenArchitecture programmes have been conceptualised, as learning happening in the office, online and on campus in block release intensive workshop style sessions.
The course outcomes will be directly aligned with the approved and accredited fulltime programmes at the respective collaborating Architectural Learning Sites, but the learning activities and material will be designed to support learning in a range of learning modes and spaces.