SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 36
Serious Games, Serious Play


     An Industry Overview

                              Presented by:
                            Michael Cai
                     VP Research, Games and
                    Technology at Interpret


                            August 22, 2012
Date:
   08/22/12
                 Study Specifications
Presenter:
        M. Cai

                 Key Discussion Points
                  Overall landscape of the serious games industry
                  Growth dynamics in different industry segments
                  Market opportunities and challenges in various
                   sectors
                  Cost for developing serious games
                  How the industry is currently addressing
                   measurement and effectiveness


                 Methodology
Section:          Survey Methods        Telephone interview &
            1
                                         E-mail survey
Page:
                  Timing                July/August 2012
            2
Date:
   08/22/12
                 Study Participants
Presenter:
        M. Cai

                  Interviews with Experts
                     At least 10+ years in industry
                  Hold positions such as:




Section:
            1


Page:
            3
Date:
   08/22/12
                 Sector Composition
Presenter:
        M. Cai

                  The experts’ experience covers all
                   the major categories




Section:
            1


Page:
            4
The Serious Games Landscape



Defining the Market
Date:
   08/22/12
                 Defining ‘Serious Games’
Presenter:
        M. Cai

                  Common Themes:




Section:
            1


Page:
            6                          However…
Date:
   08/22/12
                 Defining ‘Serious Games’
Presenter:
        M. Cai

                               “There’s a
                  tech answer and a marketing answer.”




Section:
            1


Page:
            7
Opportunity Today vs. Three
Date:
   08/22/12


Presenter:       Years Ago
        M. Cai

                  Acceptance outpacing adoption

                                       Serious Games
                                                                 Acceptance




                                                                 Adoption



Section:
            1
                  “I don’t expect an upswing as the industry as a whole is
Page:
                  still pretty much in its growth stage, but there has been
                  much greater improvement in the profile.”
            8
Opportunity Today vs. Three
Date:
   08/22/12


Presenter:       Years Ago
        M. Cai

                  Reasons Acceptance is growing:




                 • Stigma of        • Traditional ways    • More powerful
                   ‘game’ is          of training,          technology
                   vanishing          education not       • More tools
                 • Gamers getting     working               available
                   older            • Games seen as
Section:                              valid substitutes
            1


Page:
            9
Opportunity Today vs. Three
Date:
   08/22/12


Presenter:       Years Ago
        M. Cai

                  Reasons Adoption is falling behind:




                 • The       • Growth is   • Employers
                   economy     niche-        hesitant
                               specific      to spend
Section:
                                             on the
            1                                workplace

Page:
           10
Date:
   08/22/12
                 Size of Industry in Revenue
Presenter:
        M. Cai
                             “The answer to that question is
                                  very elusive, difficult to
                                 pin down. It’s hard to find
                                   research on the subject.”

                 “There are indicators of
                 growth, but it’s difficult
                 to quantify.”


                           “It’s all about definition. Should
Section:
                         Bejeweled count, since it’s known to
            1              reduce stress? Or Wii bowling, for
                          all the benefits in nursing homes.”
Page:
           11
Date:
   08/22/12
                 Revenue Generation
Presenter:
        M. Cai


                            Direct                 Indirect



                   Revenue generated     Revenue not generated
                   by the game itself      by the game itself

                 • Grants                • Games for marketing
                 • B2B contracts          (used as assets to sell something else)

                                         • Sales training
                 • Corporate              (improvement in sales efficacy)

Section:
                   sponsorship           • Process optimization
            1    • Licensing software/    (process efficiencies gained)


                   subscriptions
Page:            • Microtransactions
                  (in virtual worlds)
           12
Date:
   08/22/12
                 Growth Sectors
Presenter:
        M. Cai

                  Agreement that there is:




Section:
            1
                        Growth in         Growth in
                        Healthcare        Military
Page:
           13
Date:
   08/22/12
                 Growth Sectors
Presenter:
        M. Cai

                  Differing opinions for Education
                   and Corporate




                    • Government/institutional      • Game feature usage (leader
                      involvement is growing          boards, etc.) growing
Section:            • More money than ever          • Companies have the budgets
            1


Page:               • Games lack production value   • Economy causing frugality
                    • Designers don’t know how to   • Less likely to spend on
           14
                      make educational games          innovations such as games
Date:
   08/22/12
                 Growth Trajectory
Presenter:
        M. Cai
                  “Much bigger” in the next 5 years
                   due to:

                                         More gamers
                                         More platforms




                  As gaming becomes the norm,
                   barriers to entry get lower
Section:
            1


Page:
           15
The Serious Games Landscape



Costs and Timing
Date:
   08/22/12
                 Average Cost of Game/Sim
Presenter:
        M. Cai

                  HUGE variation depending on
                   sector and sales model


                                     Licenses;
                   Education
                                Per Classroom ~$100

                                  Subscriptions;
                  Healthcare
                                 Bundles $5K-$10K

                                Range $30K-$500K;
                   Corporate
                                   Average $65K
Section:
            2                       Fixed Grants; Phase 1 $90K,
                  Government
                                            Phase 2 $750K
Page:
                           $0                       $500K         $1M
           17
Average Length of
Date:
   08/22/12


Presenter:       Development Time
        M. Cai

                  For all sectors,
                   more complexity = more time


                   Education    3 mos.


                  Healthcare    6 mos.


                   Corporate    3 mos.
Section:
            2     Government                     2-3 yrs.

Page:
           18
Date:
   08/22/12
                 Variables Impacting Cost
Presenter:
        M. Cai



                        Complexity   Assets



                        # of
                        Platforms    Music/Audio
                        Desired



                        Graphics     Labor


Section:
            2
                        3D           Testing
Page:
           19
Date:
   08/22/12
                 Acceleration in Cost?
Presenter:
        M. Cai

                  Some say Yes, some say No

                               Yes, making                   No, making
                                 games is                     games is
                                   more                       getting
                               expensive!                     cheaper.




                 • Level of complexity has   • More off-the-shelf
                   increased                   tools available
Section:         • Trying to make things     • Licenses are cheaper
            2      simple actually costs     • Barriers of entry
                   more                        are lower
Page:
                 • Cost of labor has grown
           20
Date:
   08/22/12
                 Types of Metrics
Presenter:
        M. Cai




Section:
            2


Page:
           21
Marketing, Game Development, Measurement



Industry Challenges
Getting More Industries and
Date:
   08/22/12


Presenter:       Schools to Use Games to Teach
        M. Cai




                 Consider first:




Section:
            2


Page:
           23
Getting More Industries and
Date:
   08/22/12


Presenter:       Schools to Use Games to Teach
        M. Cai

                  Position I: Providing Proof

                        Publishing documentation that
                         serious games do achieve desired
                         training or educational outcomes

                        Offering evidence of cost
                         effectiveness, particularly in
                         comparison to other methods of
Section:
                         training and learning
            2


Page:
           24
Getting More Industries and
Date:
   08/22/12


Presenter:       Schools to Use Games to Teach
        M. Cai

                  Position II: “Stealth Mode”

                    Removing the stigma associated with
                     the word “games” or taking it out of
                     the name entirely

                    Hiding “games” within
                     the words “activity”
Section:
                     or “learning module”
            2


Page:
           25
Date:
   08/22/12
                 Making Games More Effective
Presenter:
        M. Cai

                  Focus on the end user
                    Understand       Appeal to
                     end user      all types of      Educate end
                   requirements      end users          users
                   • Avoid being   • How do people   • The game has
                     “chocolate-     want to play      to make sense
                     covered         (PvP, PvE,        to the user
                     broccoli”       etc.)?



Section:
            2


Page:
           26
Games vs. Sims vs. Virtual
Date:
   08/22/12


Presenter:       Worlds
        M. Cai

                  Analyze the task/information that
                   needs to be taught
                    Don’t be afraid to combine!


                                             “Generally speaking,
                                             though, training games
                                             need to have a very
                                             strong simulation
                                             component while mere
                                             educational titles may
                                             indulge on a more
Section:                                     traditional gaming
            2                                experience.”

Page:
           27
Date:
   08/22/12
                 Making Games More Effective
Presenter:
        M. Cai

                  Inherent to the game must be:
                            Design Mechanics
                             Games need to promote learning through
                             their very mechanics, i.e., the act of
                             playing = learning

                            Point System
                             Must assign points for participation,
                             rewards; giving feedback, motivating,
                             building a relationship


Section:                    Stickiness
            2                Pay attention to the psychological
                             effects, find out what motivates people
                             to play
Page:
           28
Date:
   08/22/12
                 Making Games More Effective
Presenter:
        M. Cai

                  However, the following pose
                   challenges to innovation:
                      Dearth of Talented Designers
                      “Good developers are usually lured to big studios or
                      become indies… dedicated serious games companies might
                      not find it easy to get the right talent.”



                      Costs
                      Complex design and realistic simulations are not
                      cheap. Also, some institutions are dependent on
Section:              government funding.
            2


Page:
           29
Date:
   08/22/12
                 Making Games More Effective
Presenter:
        M. Cai

                  And the biggest criticism:


                     Need for Measurement
                     Aren’t enough tools that are proven to actually
                     measure the effectiveness of a game; progress is slow
                     on that end.




Section:
            2


Page:
           30
Improving Marketing to
Date:
   08/22/12


Presenter:       Increase Buyer Interest
        M. Cai


                             Emphasize Outcomes
                             • Market the outcomes
                               being achieved, make
                               the focus of games
                               secondary


                             Positive Press
                             • Publish more success
Section:                       stories to improve
            2                  category’s image, show
Page:
                               positive side of games
           31
Research Inspires… More Research



Future Opportunities
Date:
   08/22/12
                 The Ideal Trade Group
Presenter:
        M. Cai




Section:
            2


Page:
           33
Date:
   08/22/12
                 Key Questions Raised by Our
Presenter:
                 Experts                                   Wh
                                                             e
                                                      ga mob re
        M. Cai
                                                        me il do
                                                          s
                                                       in f e
                                 the                     ? it
                             are     the
                       What rs of
                           ete      es
                     param ous gam a
                        seri ? Is it
                            et        f
                       mark gment o e?
                          fra ng els
                             thi
                         some
                                           Is o
                                                ne
                                           ahea countr
                                                d of   y
                                              game the
                                                   ?




                          Wh
Section:               oppo ere do                       Doe
                           rt                        termi s
            2           lie unities                       nol
                            b
                        the eyond                      matte ogy
                            u                               r?
                       susp sual
Page:                      ects
                               ?
           34
THANK YOU!
Useful Links:
www.seriousplayconference.com
www.seriousgamesdirectory.com
www.seriousgamesassociation.com

Contact:
sbohle@seriousgamesassociation.com

More Related Content

Viewers also liked

CommsMEA cover
CommsMEA coverCommsMEA cover
CommsMEA cover
whitear
 
SGA Webinar- Designing a Curriculum for Serious Games
SGA Webinar- Designing a Curriculum for Serious GamesSGA Webinar- Designing a Curriculum for Serious Games
SGA Webinar- Designing a Curriculum for Serious Games
SeriousGamesAssoc
 

Viewers also liked (20)

Animating Your Coursebook1
Animating Your Coursebook1Animating Your Coursebook1
Animating Your Coursebook1
 
LANGUAGE DEVELOPMENT FOR TEACHERS (LDT)
LANGUAGE DEVELOPMENT FOR TEACHERS (LDT)LANGUAGE DEVELOPMENT FOR TEACHERS (LDT)
LANGUAGE DEVELOPMENT FOR TEACHERS (LDT)
 
Creative Teaching, Creative Learning
Creative Teaching, Creative Learning Creative Teaching, Creative Learning
Creative Teaching, Creative Learning
 
Charlene Blohm - These Bananas Aren’t Going To Sell Themselves
Charlene Blohm - These Bananas Aren’t Going To Sell ThemselvesCharlene Blohm - These Bananas Aren’t Going To Sell Themselves
Charlene Blohm - These Bananas Aren’t Going To Sell Themselves
 
CommsMEA cover
CommsMEA coverCommsMEA cover
CommsMEA cover
 
SGA Webinar- Designing a Curriculum for Serious Games
SGA Webinar- Designing a Curriculum for Serious GamesSGA Webinar- Designing a Curriculum for Serious Games
SGA Webinar- Designing a Curriculum for Serious Games
 
Ask Agger - Change Through Involvement
Ask Agger - Change Through InvolvementAsk Agger - Change Through Involvement
Ask Agger - Change Through Involvement
 
Damian Brown, Kirk Taylor--Serious Games Interactive
Damian Brown, Kirk Taylor--Serious Games InteractiveDamian Brown, Kirk Taylor--Serious Games Interactive
Damian Brown, Kirk Taylor--Serious Games Interactive
 
Lien Tran - Humanitarian Games for International Social Impact: Guiding Princ...
Lien Tran - Humanitarian Games for International Social Impact: Guiding Princ...Lien Tran - Humanitarian Games for International Social Impact: Guiding Princ...
Lien Tran - Humanitarian Games for International Social Impact: Guiding Princ...
 
Sean O'Neil
Sean O'Neil Sean O'Neil
Sean O'Neil
 
"Serious Communication for Serious Games" By Ross Kukulinski- Serious Play Co...
"Serious Communication for Serious Games" By Ross Kukulinski- Serious Play Co..."Serious Communication for Serious Games" By Ross Kukulinski- Serious Play Co...
"Serious Communication for Serious Games" By Ross Kukulinski- Serious Play Co...
 
Developing  creative thinking skills in english language teaching
Developing  creative thinking skills in english language teachingDeveloping  creative thinking skills in english language teaching
Developing  creative thinking skills in english language teaching
 
Chris Hazard - Measuring and Manipulating Player Biases and Trust Through Cho...
Chris Hazard - Measuring and Manipulating Player Biases and Trust Through Cho...Chris Hazard - Measuring and Manipulating Player Biases and Trust Through Cho...
Chris Hazard - Measuring and Manipulating Player Biases and Trust Through Cho...
 
Ask Agger - Bringing the Board Game to the Board Room
Ask Agger - Bringing the Board Game to the Board RoomAsk Agger - Bringing the Board Game to the Board Room
Ask Agger - Bringing the Board Game to the Board Room
 
Essentials for Teachers New to Online Teaching
Essentials for Teachers New to Online TeachingEssentials for Teachers New to Online Teaching
Essentials for Teachers New to Online Teaching
 
Autonomous professional development begins at home
Autonomous professional development begins at homeAutonomous professional development begins at home
Autonomous professional development begins at home
 
"Silos Support Farmers, Not the Learning Ecosystem" By Susan Meek- Serious Pl...
"Silos Support Farmers, Not the Learning Ecosystem" By Susan Meek- Serious Pl..."Silos Support Farmers, Not the Learning Ecosystem" By Susan Meek- Serious Pl...
"Silos Support Farmers, Not the Learning Ecosystem" By Susan Meek- Serious Pl...
 
Jenn McNamara - Using Games for Assessment: Why? How? And Examples
Jenn McNamara - Using Games for Assessment: Why? How? And ExamplesJenn McNamara - Using Games for Assessment: Why? How? And Examples
Jenn McNamara - Using Games for Assessment: Why? How? And Examples
 
Richard A. Carey - Game Design Canvas
Richard A. Carey - Game Design CanvasRichard A. Carey - Game Design Canvas
Richard A. Carey - Game Design Canvas
 
Nicole Lazzaro - The Science of Fun: 3 Ways Games Make You Happier and Save t...
Nicole Lazzaro - The Science of Fun: 3 Ways Games Make You Happier and Save t...Nicole Lazzaro - The Science of Fun: 3 Ways Games Make You Happier and Save t...
Nicole Lazzaro - The Science of Fun: 3 Ways Games Make You Happier and Save t...
 

Similar to “Serious Games, Serious Play” Research Study: “Where Are the Opportunities?” By Michael Cai - Serious Games Conference 2012

EDR Insight DDD Minneapolis November 2012
EDR Insight DDD Minneapolis November 2012EDR Insight DDD Minneapolis November 2012
EDR Insight DDD Minneapolis November 2012
EDR
 
Insight DDD San Francisco October 2012
Insight DDD San Francisco October 2012Insight DDD San Francisco October 2012
Insight DDD San Francisco October 2012
EDR
 
Pitch book decade_investments_2001_2010
Pitch book decade_investments_2001_2010Pitch book decade_investments_2001_2010
Pitch book decade_investments_2001_2010
MMMTechLaw
 
EDR Insight Market Update: Navigating in an Uncertain Market - Atlanta
EDR Insight Market Update: Navigating in an Uncertain Market - AtlantaEDR Insight Market Update: Navigating in an Uncertain Market - Atlanta
EDR Insight Market Update: Navigating in an Uncertain Market - Atlanta
EDR
 
Ochromeni strachem aneb Jak vydělat na krizi - Jan Mrázek, Adastra Group
Ochromeni strachem aneb Jak vydělat na krizi - Jan Mrázek, Adastra GroupOchromeni strachem aneb Jak vydělat na krizi - Jan Mrázek, Adastra Group
Ochromeni strachem aneb Jak vydělat na krizi - Jan Mrázek, Adastra Group
TUESDAY Business Network
 
SoLoMo Thursday - Social Media for Insurance: Time to Get Personal
SoLoMo Thursday - Social Media for Insurance: Time to Get PersonalSoLoMo Thursday - Social Media for Insurance: Time to Get Personal
SoLoMo Thursday - Social Media for Insurance: Time to Get Personal
SoLoMo Thursday
 
Med Week Final - Arete Leadership Consulting
Med Week Final - Arete Leadership ConsultingMed Week Final - Arete Leadership Consulting
Med Week Final - Arete Leadership Consulting
ALC
 

Similar to “Serious Games, Serious Play” Research Study: “Where Are the Opportunities?” By Michael Cai - Serious Games Conference 2012 (20)

December 2010 - Michigan Energy Forum - Kurt Riegger
December 2010 - Michigan Energy Forum - Kurt RieggerDecember 2010 - Michigan Energy Forum - Kurt Riegger
December 2010 - Michigan Energy Forum - Kurt Riegger
 
M and A Leaders Forum April 2013- S.G.s Presentation
M and A Leaders Forum April 2013- S.G.s PresentationM and A Leaders Forum April 2013- S.G.s Presentation
M and A Leaders Forum April 2013- S.G.s Presentation
 
EDR Insight DDD Minneapolis November 2012
EDR Insight DDD Minneapolis November 2012EDR Insight DDD Minneapolis November 2012
EDR Insight DDD Minneapolis November 2012
 
I game conference investing in educational technology
I game conference   investing in educational technologyI game conference   investing in educational technology
I game conference investing in educational technology
 
Insight DDD San Francisco October 2012
Insight DDD San Francisco October 2012Insight DDD San Francisco October 2012
Insight DDD San Francisco October 2012
 
Pitch book decade_investments_2001_2010
Pitch book decade_investments_2001_2010Pitch book decade_investments_2001_2010
Pitch book decade_investments_2001_2010
 
EDR Insight Market Update: Navigating in an Uncertain Market - Atlanta
EDR Insight Market Update: Navigating in an Uncertain Market - AtlantaEDR Insight Market Update: Navigating in an Uncertain Market - Atlanta
EDR Insight Market Update: Navigating in an Uncertain Market - Atlanta
 
It\'s Not Rocket Science! Tools for Quick Project Feasibility
It\'s Not Rocket Science! Tools for Quick Project FeasibilityIt\'s Not Rocket Science! Tools for Quick Project Feasibility
It\'s Not Rocket Science! Tools for Quick Project Feasibility
 
Savi chapter3
Savi chapter3Savi chapter3
Savi chapter3
 
Ochromeni strachem aneb Jak vydělat na krizi - Jan Mrázek, Adastra Group
Ochromeni strachem aneb Jak vydělat na krizi - Jan Mrázek, Adastra GroupOchromeni strachem aneb Jak vydělat na krizi - Jan Mrázek, Adastra Group
Ochromeni strachem aneb Jak vydělat na krizi - Jan Mrázek, Adastra Group
 
171231 ca2
171231 ca2171231 ca2
171231 ca2
 
SoLoMo Thursday - Social Media for Insurance: Time to Get Personal
SoLoMo Thursday - Social Media for Insurance: Time to Get PersonalSoLoMo Thursday - Social Media for Insurance: Time to Get Personal
SoLoMo Thursday - Social Media for Insurance: Time to Get Personal
 
Harley Davidson, Strategic Analysis
Harley Davidson, Strategic Analysis Harley Davidson, Strategic Analysis
Harley Davidson, Strategic Analysis
 
Am team meeting 5.6.13
Am team meeting 5.6.13Am team meeting 5.6.13
Am team meeting 5.6.13
 
Houston Website Marketing & Lead Generation
Houston Website Marketing & Lead GenerationHouston Website Marketing & Lead Generation
Houston Website Marketing & Lead Generation
 
Industry Analysis: the bigger picture
Industry Analysis: the bigger pictureIndustry Analysis: the bigger picture
Industry Analysis: the bigger picture
 
Med Week Final - Arete Leadership Consulting
Med Week Final - Arete Leadership ConsultingMed Week Final - Arete Leadership Consulting
Med Week Final - Arete Leadership Consulting
 
Dominion Midstream Partners LP.pdf
Dominion Midstream Partners LP.pdfDominion Midstream Partners LP.pdf
Dominion Midstream Partners LP.pdf
 
Nintendo Switch Case 22 Strategic Management
Nintendo Switch Case 22 Strategic ManagementNintendo Switch Case 22 Strategic Management
Nintendo Switch Case 22 Strategic Management
 
Common or conflicting interests: Inputs for a CSO brainstorm on "People Cent...
Common or conflicting interests: Inputs for a CSO brainstorm on  "People Cent...Common or conflicting interests: Inputs for a CSO brainstorm on  "People Cent...
Common or conflicting interests: Inputs for a CSO brainstorm on "People Cent...
 

More from SeriousGamesAssoc

The Value of Robotics for Surgery Training
The Value of Robotics for Surgery Training The Value of Robotics for Surgery Training
The Value of Robotics for Surgery Training
SeriousGamesAssoc
 
Designing Immersive Experiences that Create Empathy, Reveal Biases, Alter Min...
Designing Immersive Experiences that Create Empathy, Reveal Biases, Alter Min...Designing Immersive Experiences that Create Empathy, Reveal Biases, Alter Min...
Designing Immersive Experiences that Create Empathy, Reveal Biases, Alter Min...
SeriousGamesAssoc
 
OODA OODA! How Rapid Iteration Can Help Level Up Your Gaming Business
OODA OODA! How Rapid Iteration Can Help Level Up Your Gaming BusinessOODA OODA! How Rapid Iteration Can Help Level Up Your Gaming Business
OODA OODA! How Rapid Iteration Can Help Level Up Your Gaming Business
SeriousGamesAssoc
 
The ux of serious games how to impact a wider audience
The ux of serious games  how to impact a wider audienceThe ux of serious games  how to impact a wider audience
The ux of serious games how to impact a wider audience
SeriousGamesAssoc
 
Alphabet Soup Cans: Avoiding Bad Tropes of Educational Games
Alphabet Soup Cans: Avoiding Bad Tropes of Educational GamesAlphabet Soup Cans: Avoiding Bad Tropes of Educational Games
Alphabet Soup Cans: Avoiding Bad Tropes of Educational Games
SeriousGamesAssoc
 
Building Heroes: Using Roleplaying Game Design for Classroom Management, Read...
Building Heroes: Using Roleplaying Game Design for Classroom Management, Read...Building Heroes: Using Roleplaying Game Design for Classroom Management, Read...
Building Heroes: Using Roleplaying Game Design for Classroom Management, Read...
SeriousGamesAssoc
 
Augmented Reality: Revolutionary or Disruptor of Training and Assessment
Augmented Reality: Revolutionary or Disruptor of Training and AssessmentAugmented Reality: Revolutionary or Disruptor of Training and Assessment
Augmented Reality: Revolutionary or Disruptor of Training and Assessment
SeriousGamesAssoc
 
Enhancing New Employee Orientation with a Digital Scavenger Hunt
Enhancing New Employee Orientation with a Digital Scavenger HuntEnhancing New Employee Orientation with a Digital Scavenger Hunt
Enhancing New Employee Orientation with a Digital Scavenger Hunt
SeriousGamesAssoc
 

More from SeriousGamesAssoc (20)

The Value of Robotics for Surgery Training
The Value of Robotics for Surgery Training The Value of Robotics for Surgery Training
The Value of Robotics for Surgery Training
 
Developing Low Cost Simulation Immersions
Developing Low Cost Simulation ImmersionsDeveloping Low Cost Simulation Immersions
Developing Low Cost Simulation Immersions
 
Finding Partners in Applied Research – A Case Study on Industry/Academic Coll...
Finding Partners in Applied Research – A Case Study on Industry/Academic Coll...Finding Partners in Applied Research – A Case Study on Industry/Academic Coll...
Finding Partners in Applied Research – A Case Study on Industry/Academic Coll...
 
Designing Immersive Experiences that Create Empathy, Reveal Biases, Alter Min...
Designing Immersive Experiences that Create Empathy, Reveal Biases, Alter Min...Designing Immersive Experiences that Create Empathy, Reveal Biases, Alter Min...
Designing Immersive Experiences that Create Empathy, Reveal Biases, Alter Min...
 
Designing Memorable Games
Designing Memorable GamesDesigning Memorable Games
Designing Memorable Games
 
Preparing Soldiers for the Future: The Army's New Synthetic Training Environment
Preparing Soldiers for the Future: The Army's New Synthetic Training EnvironmentPreparing Soldiers for the Future: The Army's New Synthetic Training Environment
Preparing Soldiers for the Future: The Army's New Synthetic Training Environment
 
Learning Through Play: STEM Games in the Classroom
Learning Through Play: STEM Games in the ClassroomLearning Through Play: STEM Games in the Classroom
Learning Through Play: STEM Games in the Classroom
 
Playable Design
Playable DesignPlayable Design
Playable Design
 
Playful Learning Without Games
Playful Learning Without GamesPlayful Learning Without Games
Playful Learning Without Games
 
Client-Centered Serious Game Design
Client-Centered Serious Game DesignClient-Centered Serious Game Design
Client-Centered Serious Game Design
 
A Promise to Future Generations: Making Learning Fun
A Promise to Future Generations: Making Learning FunA Promise to Future Generations: Making Learning Fun
A Promise to Future Generations: Making Learning Fun
 
Lets make a game workshop ser play orlando 2019
Lets make a game workshop ser play orlando 2019Lets make a game workshop ser play orlando 2019
Lets make a game workshop ser play orlando 2019
 
0 for 3: Edtech Startup Lessons Learned
0 for 3: Edtech Startup Lessons Learned0 for 3: Edtech Startup Lessons Learned
0 for 3: Edtech Startup Lessons Learned
 
OODA OODA! How Rapid Iteration Can Help Level Up Your Gaming Business
OODA OODA! How Rapid Iteration Can Help Level Up Your Gaming BusinessOODA OODA! How Rapid Iteration Can Help Level Up Your Gaming Business
OODA OODA! How Rapid Iteration Can Help Level Up Your Gaming Business
 
The ux of serious games how to impact a wider audience
The ux of serious games  how to impact a wider audienceThe ux of serious games  how to impact a wider audience
The ux of serious games how to impact a wider audience
 
Alphabet Soup Cans: Avoiding Bad Tropes of Educational Games
Alphabet Soup Cans: Avoiding Bad Tropes of Educational GamesAlphabet Soup Cans: Avoiding Bad Tropes of Educational Games
Alphabet Soup Cans: Avoiding Bad Tropes of Educational Games
 
Building Heroes: Using Roleplaying Game Design for Classroom Management, Read...
Building Heroes: Using Roleplaying Game Design for Classroom Management, Read...Building Heroes: Using Roleplaying Game Design for Classroom Management, Read...
Building Heroes: Using Roleplaying Game Design for Classroom Management, Read...
 
Augmented Reality: Revolutionary or Disruptor of Training and Assessment
Augmented Reality: Revolutionary or Disruptor of Training and AssessmentAugmented Reality: Revolutionary or Disruptor of Training and Assessment
Augmented Reality: Revolutionary or Disruptor of Training and Assessment
 
Return on Investment (ROI) for Virtual Environments and Gaming
Return on Investment (ROI) for Virtual Environments and GamingReturn on Investment (ROI) for Virtual Environments and Gaming
Return on Investment (ROI) for Virtual Environments and Gaming
 
Enhancing New Employee Orientation with a Digital Scavenger Hunt
Enhancing New Employee Orientation with a Digital Scavenger HuntEnhancing New Employee Orientation with a Digital Scavenger Hunt
Enhancing New Employee Orientation with a Digital Scavenger Hunt
 

Recently uploaded

Title Unlocking Imagination The Importance of Toca Boca for Kids.pdf
Title Unlocking Imagination The Importance of Toca Boca for Kids.pdfTitle Unlocking Imagination The Importance of Toca Boca for Kids.pdf
Title Unlocking Imagination The Importance of Toca Boca for Kids.pdf
Toca boca
 
在线办理(concordia学位证书)康考迪亚大学毕业证学历学位证书学费发票原版一模一样
在线办理(concordia学位证书)康考迪亚大学毕业证学历学位证书学费发票原版一模一样在线办理(concordia学位证书)康考迪亚大学毕业证学历学位证书学费发票原版一模一样
在线办理(concordia学位证书)康考迪亚大学毕业证学历学位证书学费发票原版一模一样
ahafux
 
Vector Methods.pptxjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjj
Vector Methods.pptxjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjVector Methods.pptxjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjj
Vector Methods.pptxjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjj
joshuaclack73
 
batwheels_01batwheels_01batwheels_01batwheels_01
batwheels_01batwheels_01batwheels_01batwheels_01batwheels_01batwheels_01batwheels_01batwheels_01
batwheels_01batwheels_01batwheels_01batwheels_01
Patricia Pham
 
8th Global Fashion and Design Week Noida 2024 Sets New Standards in Creative ...
8th Global Fashion and Design Week Noida 2024 Sets New Standards in Creative ...8th Global Fashion and Design Week Noida 2024 Sets New Standards in Creative ...
8th Global Fashion and Design Week Noida 2024 Sets New Standards in Creative ...
Marwah Studios
 
week 3 questions and answers.phhhhhhhhhhptx
week 3 questions and answers.phhhhhhhhhhptxweek 3 questions and answers.phhhhhhhhhhptx
week 3 questions and answers.phhhhhhhhhhptx
joshuaclack73
 

Recently uploaded (20)

Vibration Control.pptxjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjj
Vibration Control.pptxjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjVibration Control.pptxjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjj
Vibration Control.pptxjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjj
 
Title Unlocking Imagination The Importance of Toca Boca for Kids.pdf
Title Unlocking Imagination The Importance of Toca Boca for Kids.pdfTitle Unlocking Imagination The Importance of Toca Boca for Kids.pdf
Title Unlocking Imagination The Importance of Toca Boca for Kids.pdf
 
The Ultimate Guide to Choosing the Best HD IPTV Service in 2024.pdf
The Ultimate Guide to Choosing the Best HD IPTV Service in 2024.pdfThe Ultimate Guide to Choosing the Best HD IPTV Service in 2024.pdf
The Ultimate Guide to Choosing the Best HD IPTV Service in 2024.pdf
 
在线办理(concordia学位证书)康考迪亚大学毕业证学历学位证书学费发票原版一模一样
在线办理(concordia学位证书)康考迪亚大学毕业证学历学位证书学费发票原版一模一样在线办理(concordia学位证书)康考迪亚大学毕业证学历学位证书学费发票原版一模一样
在线办理(concordia学位证书)康考迪亚大学毕业证学历学位证书学费发票原版一模一样
 
Khaki-Files-Inside-Stories-of-Police-Missions-Kumar-Neeraj-Z-Library.pdf
Khaki-Files-Inside-Stories-of-Police-Missions-Kumar-Neeraj-Z-Library.pdfKhaki-Files-Inside-Stories-of-Police-Missions-Kumar-Neeraj-Z-Library.pdf
Khaki-Files-Inside-Stories-of-Police-Missions-Kumar-Neeraj-Z-Library.pdf
 
Vector Methods.pptxjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjj
Vector Methods.pptxjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjVector Methods.pptxjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjj
Vector Methods.pptxjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjj
 
C&C Artists' Websites .
C&C Artists' Websites                       .C&C Artists' Websites                       .
C&C Artists' Websites .
 
batwheels_01batwheels_01batwheels_01batwheels_01
batwheels_01batwheels_01batwheels_01batwheels_01batwheels_01batwheels_01batwheels_01batwheels_01
batwheels_01batwheels_01batwheels_01batwheels_01
 
small presentation about Star Wars/.pptx
small presentation about Star Wars/.pptxsmall presentation about Star Wars/.pptx
small presentation about Star Wars/.pptx
 
WHO KILLED ALASKA? #17: Mirror Memoria - "OFFICER" TRANSCRIPT.pdf
WHO KILLED ALASKA? #17: Mirror Memoria - "OFFICER" TRANSCRIPT.pdfWHO KILLED ALASKA? #17: Mirror Memoria - "OFFICER" TRANSCRIPT.pdf
WHO KILLED ALASKA? #17: Mirror Memoria - "OFFICER" TRANSCRIPT.pdf
 
Young & Hot ℂall Girls Visakhapatnam 8250077686 WhatsApp Number Best Rates of...
Young & Hot ℂall Girls Visakhapatnam 8250077686 WhatsApp Number Best Rates of...Young & Hot ℂall Girls Visakhapatnam 8250077686 WhatsApp Number Best Rates of...
Young & Hot ℂall Girls Visakhapatnam 8250077686 WhatsApp Number Best Rates of...
 
NO1 Pakistan kala jadu Specialist Expert in Quetta, Gujranwala, muzaffarabad,...
NO1 Pakistan kala jadu Specialist Expert in Quetta, Gujranwala, muzaffarabad,...NO1 Pakistan kala jadu Specialist Expert in Quetta, Gujranwala, muzaffarabad,...
NO1 Pakistan kala jadu Specialist Expert in Quetta, Gujranwala, muzaffarabad,...
 
WHO KILLED ALASKA? #15: "5½ STORIES Part Two" Transcript .pdf
WHO KILLED ALASKA? #15: "5½ STORIES Part Two" Transcript .pdfWHO KILLED ALASKA? #15: "5½ STORIES Part Two" Transcript .pdf
WHO KILLED ALASKA? #15: "5½ STORIES Part Two" Transcript .pdf
 
Online Winbuzz ID Provider in India | Get Your Sports ID
Online Winbuzz ID Provider in India | Get Your Sports IDOnline Winbuzz ID Provider in India | Get Your Sports ID
Online Winbuzz ID Provider in India | Get Your Sports ID
 
8th Global Fashion and Design Week Noida 2024 Sets New Standards in Creative ...
8th Global Fashion and Design Week Noida 2024 Sets New Standards in Creative ...8th Global Fashion and Design Week Noida 2024 Sets New Standards in Creative ...
8th Global Fashion and Design Week Noida 2024 Sets New Standards in Creative ...
 
The Gaming Quiz - 17th April 2024, Quiz Club NITW
The Gaming Quiz - 17th April 2024,  Quiz Club NITWThe Gaming Quiz - 17th April 2024,  Quiz Club NITW
The Gaming Quiz - 17th April 2024, Quiz Club NITW
 
Young & Hot ℂall Girls Jaipur 8250077686 WhatsApp Number Best Rates of Jaipur...
Young & Hot ℂall Girls Jaipur 8250077686 WhatsApp Number Best Rates of Jaipur...Young & Hot ℂall Girls Jaipur 8250077686 WhatsApp Number Best Rates of Jaipur...
Young & Hot ℂall Girls Jaipur 8250077686 WhatsApp Number Best Rates of Jaipur...
 
week 3 questions and answers.phhhhhhhhhhptx
week 3 questions and answers.phhhhhhhhhhptxweek 3 questions and answers.phhhhhhhhhhptx
week 3 questions and answers.phhhhhhhhhhptx
 
kiff2
kiff2kiff2
kiff2
 
the red riding girl story fkjgoifdjgijogifdoin
the red riding girl story fkjgoifdjgijogifdointhe red riding girl story fkjgoifdjgijogifdoin
the red riding girl story fkjgoifdjgijogifdoin
 

“Serious Games, Serious Play” Research Study: “Where Are the Opportunities?” By Michael Cai - Serious Games Conference 2012

  • 1. Serious Games, Serious Play An Industry Overview Presented by: Michael Cai VP Research, Games and Technology at Interpret August 22, 2012
  • 2. Date: 08/22/12 Study Specifications Presenter: M. Cai Key Discussion Points  Overall landscape of the serious games industry  Growth dynamics in different industry segments  Market opportunities and challenges in various sectors  Cost for developing serious games  How the industry is currently addressing measurement and effectiveness Methodology Section:  Survey Methods Telephone interview & 1 E-mail survey Page:  Timing July/August 2012 2
  • 3. Date: 08/22/12 Study Participants Presenter: M. Cai  Interviews with Experts  At least 10+ years in industry  Hold positions such as: Section: 1 Page: 3
  • 4. Date: 08/22/12 Sector Composition Presenter: M. Cai  The experts’ experience covers all the major categories Section: 1 Page: 4
  • 5. The Serious Games Landscape Defining the Market
  • 6. Date: 08/22/12 Defining ‘Serious Games’ Presenter: M. Cai  Common Themes: Section: 1 Page: 6 However…
  • 7. Date: 08/22/12 Defining ‘Serious Games’ Presenter: M. Cai “There’s a tech answer and a marketing answer.” Section: 1 Page: 7
  • 8. Opportunity Today vs. Three Date: 08/22/12 Presenter: Years Ago M. Cai  Acceptance outpacing adoption Serious Games Acceptance Adoption Section: 1 “I don’t expect an upswing as the industry as a whole is Page: still pretty much in its growth stage, but there has been much greater improvement in the profile.” 8
  • 9. Opportunity Today vs. Three Date: 08/22/12 Presenter: Years Ago M. Cai  Reasons Acceptance is growing: • Stigma of • Traditional ways • More powerful ‘game’ is of training, technology vanishing education not • More tools • Gamers getting working available older • Games seen as Section: valid substitutes 1 Page: 9
  • 10. Opportunity Today vs. Three Date: 08/22/12 Presenter: Years Ago M. Cai  Reasons Adoption is falling behind: • The • Growth is • Employers economy niche- hesitant specific to spend Section: on the 1 workplace Page: 10
  • 11. Date: 08/22/12 Size of Industry in Revenue Presenter: M. Cai “The answer to that question is very elusive, difficult to pin down. It’s hard to find research on the subject.” “There are indicators of growth, but it’s difficult to quantify.” “It’s all about definition. Should Section: Bejeweled count, since it’s known to 1 reduce stress? Or Wii bowling, for all the benefits in nursing homes.” Page: 11
  • 12. Date: 08/22/12 Revenue Generation Presenter: M. Cai Direct Indirect Revenue generated Revenue not generated by the game itself by the game itself • Grants • Games for marketing • B2B contracts (used as assets to sell something else) • Sales training • Corporate (improvement in sales efficacy) Section: sponsorship • Process optimization 1 • Licensing software/ (process efficiencies gained) subscriptions Page: • Microtransactions (in virtual worlds) 12
  • 13. Date: 08/22/12 Growth Sectors Presenter: M. Cai  Agreement that there is: Section: 1 Growth in Growth in Healthcare Military Page: 13
  • 14. Date: 08/22/12 Growth Sectors Presenter: M. Cai  Differing opinions for Education and Corporate • Government/institutional • Game feature usage (leader involvement is growing boards, etc.) growing Section: • More money than ever • Companies have the budgets 1 Page: • Games lack production value • Economy causing frugality • Designers don’t know how to • Less likely to spend on 14 make educational games innovations such as games
  • 15. Date: 08/22/12 Growth Trajectory Presenter: M. Cai  “Much bigger” in the next 5 years due to: More gamers More platforms  As gaming becomes the norm, barriers to entry get lower Section: 1 Page: 15
  • 16. The Serious Games Landscape Costs and Timing
  • 17. Date: 08/22/12 Average Cost of Game/Sim Presenter: M. Cai  HUGE variation depending on sector and sales model Licenses; Education Per Classroom ~$100 Subscriptions; Healthcare Bundles $5K-$10K Range $30K-$500K; Corporate Average $65K Section: 2 Fixed Grants; Phase 1 $90K, Government Phase 2 $750K Page: $0 $500K $1M 17
  • 18. Average Length of Date: 08/22/12 Presenter: Development Time M. Cai  For all sectors, more complexity = more time Education 3 mos. Healthcare 6 mos. Corporate 3 mos. Section: 2 Government 2-3 yrs. Page: 18
  • 19. Date: 08/22/12 Variables Impacting Cost Presenter: M. Cai Complexity Assets # of Platforms Music/Audio Desired Graphics Labor Section: 2 3D Testing Page: 19
  • 20. Date: 08/22/12 Acceleration in Cost? Presenter: M. Cai  Some say Yes, some say No Yes, making No, making games is games is more getting expensive! cheaper. • Level of complexity has • More off-the-shelf increased tools available Section: • Trying to make things • Licenses are cheaper 2 simple actually costs • Barriers of entry more are lower Page: • Cost of labor has grown 20
  • 21. Date: 08/22/12 Types of Metrics Presenter: M. Cai Section: 2 Page: 21
  • 22. Marketing, Game Development, Measurement Industry Challenges
  • 23. Getting More Industries and Date: 08/22/12 Presenter: Schools to Use Games to Teach M. Cai Consider first: Section: 2 Page: 23
  • 24. Getting More Industries and Date: 08/22/12 Presenter: Schools to Use Games to Teach M. Cai  Position I: Providing Proof  Publishing documentation that serious games do achieve desired training or educational outcomes  Offering evidence of cost effectiveness, particularly in comparison to other methods of Section: training and learning 2 Page: 24
  • 25. Getting More Industries and Date: 08/22/12 Presenter: Schools to Use Games to Teach M. Cai  Position II: “Stealth Mode”  Removing the stigma associated with the word “games” or taking it out of the name entirely  Hiding “games” within the words “activity” Section: or “learning module” 2 Page: 25
  • 26. Date: 08/22/12 Making Games More Effective Presenter: M. Cai  Focus on the end user Understand Appeal to end user all types of Educate end requirements end users users • Avoid being • How do people • The game has “chocolate- want to play to make sense covered (PvP, PvE, to the user broccoli” etc.)? Section: 2 Page: 26
  • 27. Games vs. Sims vs. Virtual Date: 08/22/12 Presenter: Worlds M. Cai  Analyze the task/information that needs to be taught  Don’t be afraid to combine! “Generally speaking, though, training games need to have a very strong simulation component while mere educational titles may indulge on a more Section: traditional gaming 2 experience.” Page: 27
  • 28. Date: 08/22/12 Making Games More Effective Presenter: M. Cai  Inherent to the game must be:  Design Mechanics Games need to promote learning through their very mechanics, i.e., the act of playing = learning  Point System Must assign points for participation, rewards; giving feedback, motivating, building a relationship Section:  Stickiness 2 Pay attention to the psychological effects, find out what motivates people to play Page: 28
  • 29. Date: 08/22/12 Making Games More Effective Presenter: M. Cai  However, the following pose challenges to innovation: Dearth of Talented Designers “Good developers are usually lured to big studios or become indies… dedicated serious games companies might not find it easy to get the right talent.” Costs Complex design and realistic simulations are not cheap. Also, some institutions are dependent on Section: government funding. 2 Page: 29
  • 30. Date: 08/22/12 Making Games More Effective Presenter: M. Cai  And the biggest criticism: Need for Measurement Aren’t enough tools that are proven to actually measure the effectiveness of a game; progress is slow on that end. Section: 2 Page: 30
  • 31. Improving Marketing to Date: 08/22/12 Presenter: Increase Buyer Interest M. Cai Emphasize Outcomes • Market the outcomes being achieved, make the focus of games secondary Positive Press • Publish more success Section: stories to improve 2 category’s image, show Page: positive side of games 31
  • 32. Research Inspires… More Research Future Opportunities
  • 33. Date: 08/22/12 The Ideal Trade Group Presenter: M. Cai Section: 2 Page: 33
  • 34. Date: 08/22/12 Key Questions Raised by Our Presenter: Experts Wh e ga mob re M. Cai me il do s in f e the ? it are the What rs of ete es param ous gam a seri ? Is it et f mark gment o e? fra ng els thi some Is o ne ahea countr d of y game the ? Wh Section: oppo ere do Doe rt termi s 2 lie unities nol b the eyond matte ogy u r? susp sual Page: ects ? 34

Editor's Notes

  1. How would you define Serious Games?   Common themes : Designed for a purpose beyond just entertainment Provides a useful outcome or essential service (not just recall back, but critical thinking and learning; raises awareness) Uses game technologies (hardware and software) Employs features commonly found in games – rewards, competition   A number of interviewees cited differences of opinion on the definition among people within the same organization. “There’s a tech answer and a marketing answer.”   Also disagreement about even the idea; “all games have the capacity for learning, a ‘serious’ game just wants to make that learning about a broader concept that can be exported from the game itself.” (paraphrased)
  2. How would you define Serious Games?   Common themes : Designed for a purpose beyond just entertainment Provides a useful outcome or essential service (not just recall back, but critical thinking and learning; raises awareness) Uses game technologies (hardware and software) Employs features commonly found in games – rewards, competition   A number of interviewees cited differences of opinion on the definition among people within the same organization. “There’s a tech answer and a marketing answer.”   Also disagreement about even the idea; “all games have the capacity for learning, a ‘serious’ game just wants to make that learning about a broader concept that can be exported from the game itself.” (paraphrased)
  3. How do you see the market opportunity in the serious games industry today versus 3 years ago?   “ The opportunity is growing, mainly because the stigma of the word ‘game’ is vanishing and gamers are getting older. Also, more serious games success stories mean more interest.”   “ You can say the word ‘gaming’ out loud. We’ve gone through the ‘civil rights’ of gaming. Gamers have gotten older, are coming to work saying, ‘why can’t the interface look more interesting a fun like games.’ The demand is being put there by users.”   “ In general when it comes to learning, whether K-12 or the workforce, people are realizing that the traditional ways of training and education are not working. Test results will say that people are prepared, but they don’t have thought skills or career skills. Games and situated learning allow them to create the connection between the content and the ‘so what.’”   “ Potential clients have stopped comparing serious games to their ‘non-serious’ counterparts (entertainment games) but as valid substitutes for traditional training methods.”   The industries that are using serious games (particularly healthcare) are more accepting today. There is still some resistance, but not much. Technology is now much more powerful; hyper-reality is more engaging. Tools are available (Facebook, etc.) that were not available before. There’s not just a push, but people are seeking games out now. “Doctors are saying, ‘can I play Bones in my few spare minutes on my cell phone.’” As the world becomes more digital, there is more opportunity to overlay games onto work.   “ Serious games are being taken more seriously at a very rapid pace, but truly serious work is being curtailed by the short-sightedness and overwhelming emphasis on profit by corporations” (Same person, different question: “It’s not all about money. Ironically, if more enlightened motives for funding research existed, profits would be amplified prodigiously.”)   Growth “hampered by the difficult, if not critical, macro-economic situation worldwide.”   “ While the market is evolving, the adoption rate is still niche specific. I don’t expect an upswing as the industry as a whole is still pretty much in it growth stage but there has been much greater improvement in the profile.”   A more pessimistic view: Workplace learning seems unchanged – people not willing to spend, relying on PowerPoint and social media Serious games as the future of learning? Results are incredibly inconclusive People are enchanted by games, but they are not always the answer just because they are a hot topic Example: You play the game, then stop the fun and go back to learning. Once initial enthusiasm is over, we need to figure out what makes a good game
  4. How do you see the market opportunity in the serious games industry today versus 3 years ago?   “ The opportunity is growing, mainly because the stigma of the word ‘game’ is vanishing and gamers are getting older. Also, more serious games success stories mean more interest.”   “ You can say the word ‘gaming’ out loud. We’ve gone through the ‘civil rights’ of gaming. Gamers have gotten older, are coming to work saying, ‘why can’t the interface look more interesting a fun like games.’ The demand is being put there by users.”   “ In general when it comes to learning, whether K-12 or the workforce, people are realizing that the traditional ways of training and education are not working. Test results will say that people are prepared, but they don’t have thought skills or career skills. Games and situated learning allow them to create the connection between the content and the ‘so what.’”   “ Potential clients have stopped comparing serious games to their ‘non-serious’ counterparts (entertainment games) but as valid substitutes for traditional training methods.”   The industries that are using serious games (particularly healthcare) are more accepting today. There is still some resistance, but not much. Technology is now much more powerful; hyper-reality is more engaging. Tools are available (Facebook, etc.) that were not available before. There’s not just a push, but people are seeking games out now. “Doctors are saying, ‘can I play Bones in my few spare minutes on my cell phone.’” As the world becomes more digital, there is more opportunity to overlay games onto work.   “ Serious games are being taken more seriously at a very rapid pace, but truly serious work is being curtailed by the short-sightedness and overwhelming emphasis on profit by corporations” (Same person, different question: “It’s not all about money. Ironically, if more enlightened motives for funding research existed, profits would be amplified prodigiously.”)   Growth “hampered by the difficult, if not critical, macro-economic situation worldwide.”   “ While the market is evolving, the adoption rate is still niche specific. I don’t expect an upswing as the industry as a whole is still pretty much in it growth stage but there has been much greater improvement in the profile.”   A more pessimistic view: Workplace learning seems unchanged – people not willing to spend, relying on PowerPoint and social media Serious games as the future of learning? Results are incredibly inconclusive People are enchanted by games, but they are not always the answer just because they are a hot topic Example: You play the game, then stop the fun and go back to learning. Once initial enthusiasm is over, we need to figure out what makes a good game
  5. How do you see the market opportunity in the serious games industry today versus 3 years ago?   “ The opportunity is growing, mainly because the stigma of the word ‘game’ is vanishing and gamers are getting older. Also, more serious games success stories mean more interest.”   “ You can say the word ‘gaming’ out loud. We’ve gone through the ‘civil rights’ of gaming. Gamers have gotten older, are coming to work saying, ‘why can’t the interface look more interesting a fun like games.’ The demand is being put there by users.”   “ In general when it comes to learning, whether K-12 or the workforce, people are realizing that the traditional ways of training and education are not working. Test results will say that people are prepared, but they don’t have thought skills or career skills. Games and situated learning allow them to create the connection between the content and the ‘so what.’”   “ Potential clients have stopped comparing serious games to their ‘non-serious’ counterparts (entertainment games) but as valid substitutes for traditional training methods.”   The industries that are using serious games (particularly healthcare) are more accepting today. There is still some resistance, but not much. Technology is now much more powerful; hyper-reality is more engaging. Tools are available (Facebook, etc.) that were not available before. There’s not just a push, but people are seeking games out now. “Doctors are saying, ‘can I play Bones in my few spare minutes on my cell phone.’” As the world becomes more digital, there is more opportunity to overlay games onto work.   “ Serious games are being taken more seriously at a very rapid pace, but truly serious work is being curtailed by the short-sightedness and overwhelming emphasis on profit by corporations” (Same person, different question: “It’s not all about money. Ironically, if more enlightened motives for funding research existed, profits would be amplified prodigiously.”)   Growth “hampered by the difficult, if not critical, macro-economic situation worldwide.”   “ While the market is evolving, the adoption rate is still niche specific. I don’t expect an upswing as the industry as a whole is still pretty much in it growth stage but there has been much greater improvement in the profile.”   A more pessimistic view: Workplace learning seems unchanged – people not willing to spend, relying on PowerPoint and social media Serious games as the future of learning? Results are incredibly inconclusive People are enchanted by games, but they are not always the answer just because they are a hot topic Example: You play the game, then stop the fun and go back to learning. Once initial enthusiasm is over, we need to figure out what makes a good game
  6. Consensus : “ The answer to that question is very elusive, difficult to pin down. It’s hard to find research on the subject.” “ There are indicators of growth, but it’s difficult to quantify. There are more people making games, but maybe not more money being made.” “ It’s all about definition. Should Bejeweled be counted as a serious game, since it’s known to reduce stress? Or how about Wii Bowling, for all the benefits in nursing homes.”
  7. Direct : Grants, for those who work with the government or in educational institutions Ad sponsorship Licensing software/subscriptions Transactions done within virtual worlds B2B contracts Corporate Support (especially educational institutions)   Indirect (the game itself is not generating the revenue): Games for marketing – used as assets to sell something else Sales training – how well the training works Process optimization – how well you’re optimizing your process
  8. In what sector of the industry do you see the most growth? Education Games/Corporate sector, for training (for internal training?)/Health care games/Medical professional training/Government/Military sims/training/ Activist Games (games for good/games for change)/Any other sectors emerging?   Strong consensus that there is growth in healthcare . “If you don’t call it a game, doctors are receptive to it.” “It’s a lot easier to talk with people about it now than two years ago. Business has picked up.” Mobile technology in particular is reshaping games in healthcare. Also big are health games and sports science (Kinect and Wii, Nike+, etc.)  +2 Growth in military .  +4 Decline in education . “Doesn’t usually have the production value. May not have the budget to pull off a 3D environment.” May be political. Disagreement: Big growth in education : most of the developers I talked to are education focused, and they say that government and institutional involvement is growing; more money than ever in the education sector. More educational games and platforms using gaming technology in schools in the UK. Increasing interest in the corporate sector , as game design features like achievements and leaderboards become widespread in training.  +1 Also, corporations have the budgets to commission these types of projects. Disagreement: corporate sector is lagging behind , despite innovation programs, in tough economic times rather than revolutionize, corporations tend to hunker down. “Anything that is odd, strange, different, etc. will be looked at with disdain, despite the clear advantages.” “ Anything that takes a lot of time is the next candidate for growth.”
  9. In what sector of the industry do you see the most growth? Education Games/Corporate sector, for training (for internal training?)/Health care games/Medical professional training/Government/Military sims/training/ Activist Games (games for good/games for change)/Any other sectors emerging?   Strong consensus that there is growth in healthcare . “If you don’t call it a game, doctors are receptive to it.” “It’s a lot easier to talk with people about it now than two years ago. Business has picked up.” Mobile technology in particular is reshaping games in healthcare. Also big are health games and sports science (Kinect and Wii, Nike+, etc.)  +2 Growth in military .  +4 Decline in education . “Doesn’t usually have the production value. May not have the budget to pull off a 3D environment.” May be political. Disagreement: Big growth in education : most of the developers I talked to are education focused, and they say that government and institutional involvement is growing; more money than ever in the education sector. More educational games and platforms using gaming technology in schools in the UK. Increasing interest in the corporate sector , as game design features like achievements and leaderboards become widespread in training.  +1 Also, corporations have the budgets to commission these types of projects. Disagreement: corporate sector is lagging behind , despite innovation programs, in tough economic times rather than revolutionize, corporations tend to hunker down. “Anything that is odd, strange, different, etc. will be looked at with disdain, despite the clear advantages.” “ Anything that takes a lot of time is the next candidate for growth.”
  10. Growth Trajectory Not willing to project hard estimates (double, triple, etc.), but general agreement that it will be bigger based on: More people game (casual gamers, women, etc) More platforms (mobile, web) People who are familiar with games will become more prominent and numerous leading to: People in decision-making roles being comfortable with using games as tools Users being more willing and receptive to using games as training/learning tools Tools get simpler and cheaper; proliferation of engines and game-making suites make it easier and cheaper to hack together a game to see if it’s effective
  11. What is the average cost of a game/sim for the sectors you work in? (Add: and what length of development time is required?) Education Corporate training Health care Govt/Military Activist Games   There is huge variation in cost and timing depending on sector and sales model (subscription, etc.).   Corporate – cost depends on graphics and number of platforms desired. Anywhere from $30K-$500K, with an average around $65K. Timing about 3 months. For games done within company on own time, 1 full time person for a couple of weeks (~$10K). Healthcare – With the subscription model, sell bundles of $5-10K. But almost always have to sell custom contracts in addition to subscriptions. Timing, about 6 months. Government/military – payment in the form of grants, which are fixed. First phase $90K, second phase $750K, over the course of 2 years. The government is recognizing that things are more complex, are more willing to spend $1-$2M now. Timing is fixed too. Currently set at 2-3 years, but could be done faster, probably 9-18 months. Education – licensing: about $100 per classroom (35-40 kids), about $10-15 per household. 50,000 British pounds over 1 year in Japan. Small games take about a month or so with a small team; larger games/sims can take 3 months with a dedicated core team and auxiliary asset producers; some games (MMOs, etc.) are massive, multi-year projects costing lots of money. $75K - $500K.   Etc. - “Basically, people do the best they can with the budget at their disposal and scope the project accordingly. Projects can take from a few weeks to a couple of years or even more.”
  12. What is the average cost of a game/sim for the sectors you work in? (Add: and what length of development time is required?) Education Corporate training Health care Govt/Military Activist Games   There is huge variation in cost and timing depending on sector and sales model (subscription, etc.).   Corporate – cost depends on graphics and number of platforms desired. Anywhere from $30K-$500K, with an average around $65K. Timing about 3 months. For games done within company on own time, 1 full time person for a couple of weeks (~$10K). Healthcare – With the subscription model, sell bundles of $5-10K. But almost always have to sell custom contracts in addition to subscriptions. Timing, about 6 months. Government/military – payment in the form of grants, which are fixed. First phase $90K, second phase $750K, over the course of 2 years. The government is recognizing that things are more complex, are more willing to spend $1-$2M now. Timing is fixed too. Currently set at 2-3 years, but could be done faster, probably 9-18 months. Education – licensing: about $100 per classroom (35-40 kids), about $10-15 per household. 50,000 British pounds over 1 year in Japan. Small games take about a month or so with a small team; larger games/sims can take 3 months with a dedicated core team and auxiliary asset producers; some games (MMOs, etc.) are massive, multi-year projects costing lots of money. $75K - $500K.   Etc. - “Basically, people do the best they can with the budget at their disposal and scope the project accordingly. Projects can take from a few weeks to a couple of years or even more.”
  13. What are the variables (i.e., what impacts cost structure? Art assets, licensing, labor, etc.)? Graphics 3D Number of platforms desired Complexity – What’s being taught, and how intricate does the programming need to be Assets Music/Audio Testing Labor
  14. Has the cost of making serious games accelerated in recent years? Are there more off the shelf tools for building serious games?   Some say yes, some say no : Yes because there are more tools available – more models, cheaper game engines, cheaper licenses; the barriers of entry are lower. No because the level of complexity has accelerated , trying to make things simple actually costs more. No because of the cost of labor . No because of off-the-shelf tools: “ There is a plethora of game engines, middleware and tools currently available today at little or no cost so it is actually possible to start building research prototypes and proofs of concept fairly cheaply. I'd say the cost of developing effective serious games that are not overly dependent on high end graphical assets or performance, has not increased significantly during the last few years.” “ Yes cost has definitely accelerated but in a good way, it has made the technology more accessible to a wider range of audiences.”
  15. “ Current state is paltry; I don’t think any measurement can be called state of the art presently. Many interesting articles but very few real studies and of the appropriate scale/time.” (The quote is from a professor working with serious games for education; in Education people have been more pessimistic)  Build metrics into the game/sim : In many cases, the metric itself is part of the game/sim (i.e., have to meet the desired outcome in order to pass or move on). Observational/external metrics : An observer watches people playing the game and scores them. Or, the people who will be using the game test it and provide feedback. Sales data and other business revenue metrics : By how much did this increase revenue, what were the cost savings, what is the impact on the bottom line? Biometrics (among the university crowd): changes in heart rate, brain waves, facial expressions Data mining (i.e. games keep track of what you’re doing) “ Psychometrics  is the field of study concerned with the theory and technique of psychologicalmeasurement, which includes the measurement of knowledge, abilities, attitudes, personality traits, and educational measurement. The field is primarily concerned with the construction and validation of measurement instruments such as questionnaires, tests, and personality assessments.” http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Psychometrics Kirkpatrick’s 4 Levels of Learning Evaluation http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Donald_Kirkpatrick#Four_Levels_of_Learning_Evaluation Four Levels of Learning Evaluation Kirkpatrick's four levels are designed as a sequence of ways to evaluate training programs. As you proceed through each of the levels, the evaluation becomes more difficult and requires more time and each level provides more information. Kirkpatrick notes in his book, 'Evaluating Training Programs (Third Edition)' that "none of the levels should be bypassed simply to get to level that the trainer considers the most important."  [1] The four levels of Kirkpatrick's evaluation model essentially measure: Reaction - what participants thought and felt about the training (satisfaction; "smile sheets") Learning - the resulting increase in knowledge and/or skills, and change in attitudes. This evaluation occurs during the training in the form of either a knowledge demonstration or test. Behavior - transfer of knowledge, skills, and/or attitudes from classroom to the job (change in job behavior due to training program). This evaluation occurs 3-6 months post training while the trainee is performing the job. Evaluation usually occurs through observation. Results - the final results that occurred because of attendance and participation in a training program (can be monetary, performance-based, etc.) Several authors have suggested an addition of a fifth level of evaluation. JJ Phillips has argued for the addition of a "Return on Investment (ROI) level which is essentially about comparing the fourth level of the standard model to the overall costs of training. [2]  Roger Kaufmanhas argued that ROI is essentially a level-four type of evaluation since it is still internal to the organization and that a fifth level of evaluation should focus on the impact of the organization on external clients and society. [3]
  16. What is required to get more industries/companies/schools to use games for training/learning? There are two main camps on this – education/validation, and re-naming/“stealth mode” Education/validation: Publish proof/evidence/case studies that serious games work. Convince the people making the decisions/holding the purse strings. A better appreciation of the potent psychological potentials inherent in serious games. “ A more conducive environment will naturally evolve when, in a few more years, more and more people grown up with games will start getting into high responsibility and management positions across all types of companies and agencies.” “ Culture – digital natives vs. immigrants. How comfortable are older professors/professionals with the technology and how they feel personally about utilizing it in their class or workplace.” Evidence of cost-effectiveness. Re-naming/“stealth mode”: Remove the stigma associated with the word games, or take the word “game” out of the name entirely. “Stealth mode” = games hidden inside the words “activity” or “learning module.” Change game publishers’ advertising practices on selling games. Even more than just the educational validation, the idea that measurement can be accurately implemented into games, then games can be designed based on measurement, resulting in a feedback loop that increases the effectiveness rapidly. Mindset: games are not always the answer, may be more hype in certain situations In education, for example: a game may be fun, but what did you learn by playing? Measurement needs to be improved. Educators always talk about measurement, but it’s all lip service   Regarding the games themselves: Need more people who know what they’re doing, who understand games and how to synthesize content, who really understand behavioral motivation. Need good design.   In some cases (Japan), easier access to creative tools is needed. “SL and OpenSim are either too controlled or too difficult. Unity 3D needs to be developed for a flatter learning path.”   Another one (and this may also fit under challenges to making games/sims more effective) is time restraints.
  17. What is required to get more industries/companies/schools to use games for training/learning? There are two main camps on this – education/validation, and re-naming/“stealth mode” Education/validation: Publish proof/evidence/case studies that serious games work. Convince the people making the decisions/holding the purse strings. A better appreciation of the potent psychological potentials inherent in serious games. “ A more conducive environment will naturally evolve when, in a few more years, more and more people grown up with games will start getting into high responsibility and management positions across all types of companies and agencies.” “ Culture – digital natives vs. immigrants. How comfortable are older professors/professionals with the technology and how they feel personally about utilizing it in their class or workplace.” Evidence of cost-effectiveness. Re-naming/“stealth mode”: Remove the stigma associated with the word games, or take the word “game” out of the name entirely. “Stealth mode” = games hidden inside the words “activity” or “learning module.” Change game publishers’ advertising practices on selling games. Even more than just the educational validation, the idea that measurement can be accurately implemented into games, then games can be designed based on measurement, resulting in a feedback loop that increases the effectiveness rapidly. Mindset: games are not always the answer, may be more hype in certain situations In education, for example: a game may be fun, but what did you learn by playing? Measurement needs to be improved. Educators always talk about measurement, but it’s all lip service   Regarding the games themselves: Need more people who know what they’re doing, who understand games and how to synthesize content, who really understand behavioral motivation. Need good design.   In some cases (Japan), easier access to creative tools is needed. “SL and OpenSim are either too controlled or too difficult. Unity 3D needs to be developed for a flatter learning path.”   Another one (and this may also fit under challenges to making games/sims more effective) is time restraints.
  18. What is required to get more industries/companies/schools to use games for training/learning? There are two main camps on this – education/validation, and re-naming/“stealth mode” Education/validation: Publish proof/evidence/case studies that serious games work. Convince the people making the decisions/holding the purse strings. A better appreciation of the potent psychological potentials inherent in serious games. “ A more conducive environment will naturally evolve when, in a few more years, more and more people grown up with games will start getting into high responsibility and management positions across all types of companies and agencies.” “ Culture – digital natives vs. immigrants. How comfortable are older professors/professionals with the technology and how they feel personally about utilizing it in their class or workplace.” Evidence of cost-effectiveness. Re-naming/“stealth mode”: Remove the stigma associated with the word games, or take the word “game” out of the name entirely. “Stealth mode” = games hidden inside the words “activity” or “learning module.” Change game publishers’ advertising practices on selling games. Even more than just the educational validation, the idea that measurement can be accurately implemented into games, then games can be designed based on measurement, resulting in a feedback loop that increases the effectiveness rapidly. Mindset: games are not always the answer, may be more hype in certain situations In education, for example: a game may be fun, but what did you learn by playing? Measurement needs to be improved. Educators always talk about measurement, but it’s all lip service   Regarding the games themselves: Need more people who know what they’re doing, who understand games and how to synthesize content, who really understand behavioral motivation. Need good design.   In some cases (Japan), easier access to creative tools is needed. “SL and OpenSim are either too controlled or too difficult. Unity 3D needs to be developed for a flatter learning path.”   Another one (and this may also fit under challenges to making games/sims more effective) is time restraints.
  19. Several suggestions : Understanding end user requirements – what’s the problem that needs to be solved? A game may not always be the right solution, even if the client initially requests it. Some games are seen as “chocolate-covered broccoli” because they were created along the following lines: we’re trying to teach something, feel the need to make it fun, so we arbitrarily throw it into the game format. Need to think carefully about why what you’re trying to teach is fun, what is the right kind of experience of puzzle that matches learning points. Lots of derision from the people I interviewed for this type of design; games need to promote learning through the very mechanics, not as an afterthought. The act of playing it must teach a skill/knowledge that is translatable to the outside world, rather than just make it a vehicle for unassociated knowledge. “ If the context is not receptive to the game, even brilliant games will fail.” Educating end users – the game has to make sense to the user. Need to help people understand how they can use these tools. Cost – simulations, for example, are not cheap. K-12 institutions dependant on government funds  price pressures against creativity, they must leverage existing resources and do not have enough to devote to truly effective games Appealing to all types of end users – this is particularly important internationally (i.e., in some countries the leaderboard is motivating and in others it is not). How do people want to play – player vs. self, environment, or player? Stickiness – paying attention to the psychological effects, finding out what makes people want to play for the sake of increasing their score, skill or knowledge. Successful games don’t always have to be 3D, FPS, etc. Some of the most popular games, such as Farmville, couldn’t get more simple. Figuring out what the point system is – points for participation, rewards, giving feedback, motivating, building a relationship. Talent with Experience – “ Good developers are usually lured into big studios or become indies to work on their own niche projects. Dedicated companies in the serious games field might not find easy to get the right talent. This is even more true for universities and research labs that may be forced to develop games with staff who had no real industry exposure and experience.” Teaching game design in schools. Measurement kept coming up; there aren’t enough tools that are proven to actually measure the effectiveness of a game, and progress is slow on that end. Some of the developers were confident in their games’ efficacy, but others (and particularly Eva Baker) were of the opinion that massive strides need to be made to really glean useful information about the effectiveness of serious games. Modularity: several developers mentioned the necessity to make games (but perhaps more accurately sims) as platforms, not just discrete products. Making an environment that either the developer can adjust or add to quickly, or maybe even the user can adjust to suit his needs, is a much more cost-effective solution overall.
  20. Obviously depends on the end result desired “ It’s often an AND (i.e., combination of game, sim, mobile, etc.), not an EITHER/OR.” In education, simulations may be better suited for service learning – through sim experiences participants see situations they’ve never encountered before, and are reacting to an environment modeled after a piece of the relevant world
  21. Several suggestions : Understanding end user requirements – what’s the problem that needs to be solved? A game may not always be the right solution, even if the client initially requests it. Some games are seen as “chocolate-covered broccoli” because they were created along the following lines: we’re trying to teach something, feel the need to make it fun, so we arbitrarily throw it into the game format. Need to think carefully about why what you’re trying to teach is fun, what is the right kind of experience of puzzle that matches learning points. Lots of derision from the people I interviewed for this type of design; games need to promote learning through the very mechanics, not as an afterthought. The act of playing it must teach a skill/knowledge that is translatable to the outside world, rather than just make it a vehicle for unassociated knowledge. “ If the context is not receptive to the game, even brilliant games will fail.” Educating end users – the game has to make sense to the user. Need to help people understand how they can use these tools. Cost – simulations, for example, are not cheap. K-12 institutions dependant on government funds  price pressures against creativity, they must leverage existing resources and do not have enough to devote to truly effective games Appealing to all types of end users – this is particularly important internationally (i.e., in some countries the leaderboard is motivating and in others it is not). How do people want to play – player vs. self, environment, or player? Stickiness – paying attention to the psychological effects, finding out what makes people want to play for the sake of increasing their score, skill or knowledge. Successful games don’t always have to be 3D, FPS, etc. Some of the most popular games, such as Farmville, couldn’t get more simple. Figuring out what the point system is – points for participation, rewards, giving feedback, motivating, building a relationship. Talent with Experience – “ Good developers are usually lured into big studios or become indies to work on their own niche projects. Dedicated companies in the serious games field might not find easy to get the right talent. This is even more true for universities and research labs that may be forced to develop games with staff who had no real industry exposure and experience.” Teaching game design in schools. Measurement kept coming up; there aren’t enough tools that are proven to actually measure the effectiveness of a game, and progress is slow on that end. Some of the developers were confident in their games’ efficacy, but others (and particularly Eva Baker) were of the opinion that massive strides need to be made to really glean useful information about the effectiveness of serious games. Modularity: several developers mentioned the necessity to make games (but perhaps more accurately sims) as platforms, not just discrete products. Making an environment that either the developer can adjust or add to quickly, or maybe even the user can adjust to suit his needs, is a much more cost-effective solution overall.
  22. Several suggestions : Understanding end user requirements – what’s the problem that needs to be solved? A game may not always be the right solution, even if the client initially requests it. Some games are seen as “chocolate-covered broccoli” because they were created along the following lines: we’re trying to teach something, feel the need to make it fun, so we arbitrarily throw it into the game format. Need to think carefully about why what you’re trying to teach is fun, what is the right kind of experience of puzzle that matches learning points. Lots of derision from the people I interviewed for this type of design; games need to promote learning through the very mechanics, not as an afterthought. The act of playing it must teach a skill/knowledge that is translatable to the outside world, rather than just make it a vehicle for unassociated knowledge. “ If the context is not receptive to the game, even brilliant games will fail.” Educating end users – the game has to make sense to the user. Need to help people understand how they can use these tools. Cost – simulations, for example, are not cheap. K-12 institutions dependant on government funds  price pressures against creativity, they must leverage existing resources and do not have enough to devote to truly effective games Appealing to all types of end users – this is particularly important internationally (i.e., in some countries the leaderboard is motivating and in others it is not). How do people want to play – player vs. self, environment, or player? Stickiness – paying attention to the psychological effects, finding out what makes people want to play for the sake of increasing their score, skill or knowledge. Successful games don’t always have to be 3D, FPS, etc. Some of the most popular games, such as Farmville, couldn’t get more simple. Figuring out what the point system is – points for participation, rewards, giving feedback, motivating, building a relationship. Talent with Experience – “ Good developers are usually lured into big studios or become indies to work on their own niche projects. Dedicated companies in the serious games field might not find easy to get the right talent. This is even more true for universities and research labs that may be forced to develop games with staff who had no real industry exposure and experience.” Teaching game design in schools. Measurement kept coming up; there aren’t enough tools that are proven to actually measure the effectiveness of a game, and progress is slow on that end. Some of the developers were confident in their games’ efficacy, but others (and particularly Eva Baker) were of the opinion that massive strides need to be made to really glean useful information about the effectiveness of serious games. Modularity: several developers mentioned the necessity to make games (but perhaps more accurately sims) as platforms, not just discrete products. Making an environment that either the developer can adjust or add to quickly, or maybe even the user can adjust to suit his needs, is a much more cost-effective solution overall.
  23. Several suggestions : Understanding end user requirements – what’s the problem that needs to be solved? A game may not always be the right solution, even if the client initially requests it. Some games are seen as “chocolate-covered broccoli” because they were created along the following lines: we’re trying to teach something, feel the need to make it fun, so we arbitrarily throw it into the game format. Need to think carefully about why what you’re trying to teach is fun, what is the right kind of experience of puzzle that matches learning points. Lots of derision from the people I interviewed for this type of design; games need to promote learning through the very mechanics, not as an afterthought. The act of playing it must teach a skill/knowledge that is translatable to the outside world, rather than just make it a vehicle for unassociated knowledge. “ If the context is not receptive to the game, even brilliant games will fail.” Educating end users – the game has to make sense to the user. Need to help people understand how they can use these tools. Cost – simulations, for example, are not cheap. K-12 institutions dependant on government funds  price pressures against creativity, they must leverage existing resources and do not have enough to devote to truly effective games Appealing to all types of end users – this is particularly important internationally (i.e., in some countries the leaderboard is motivating and in others it is not). How do people want to play – player vs. self, environment, or player? Stickiness – paying attention to the psychological effects, finding out what makes people want to play for the sake of increasing their score, skill or knowledge. Successful games don’t always have to be 3D, FPS, etc. Some of the most popular games, such as Farmville, couldn’t get more simple. Figuring out what the point system is – points for participation, rewards, giving feedback, motivating, building a relationship. Talent with Experience – “ Good developers are usually lured into big studios or become indies to work on their own niche projects. Dedicated companies in the serious games field might not find easy to get the right talent. This is even more true for universities and research labs that may be forced to develop games with staff who had no real industry exposure and experience.” Teaching game design in schools. Measurement kept coming up; there aren’t enough tools that are proven to actually measure the effectiveness of a game, and progress is slow on that end. Some of the developers were confident in their games’ efficacy, but others (and particularly Eva Baker) were of the opinion that massive strides need to be made to really glean useful information about the effectiveness of serious games. Modularity: several developers mentioned the necessity to make games (but perhaps more accurately sims) as platforms, not just discrete products. Making an environment that either the developer can adjust or add to quickly, or maybe even the user can adjust to suit his needs, is a much more cost-effective solution overall.
  24. Emphasize outcomes – market the outcomes that are being achieved, make the glitz and glamour of games secondary. An evidence-based approach will win out. “ It’s more an issue of personal biases and unwillingness” Positive press – publish more success stories to improve the category’s image, show that there’s a positive side of games. Put the stories where the people are – social media, blogs, etc.
  25. Help us with the positive press. Promote our category. Come out with statistics, find stories and show that there’s successful adoption. Show us best of class. Find out where the breakthroughs are happening. Help us answer the questions we were asked that we don’t know the answers to – size of market space, size of category in terms of revenue, etc. Help us get into sectors that are tough to crack, or help us expand in sectors that are stuck in one type of tool only. Do research into peripheral devices – Kinect, Google glasses, etc. Develop a serious games locale within a virtual world. “Eat your own dog food.” Facilitate Research-Corporate Partnerships “Help in bringing together academic and industry players for possible partnership. Arrange events dedicated to particular fields within the serious gaming domain to attract clients who could potentially be interested in using serious games within their own organizations for specific purposes.” Set a standard: “I don’t think we need to build any more awareness as there are already in my opinion too many conferences on SG. What is needed is consolidation of the thoughts/findings of these conferences and coming up with a plan to examine assessment in the first instance and then standards in the second.” Research on measurement (Awareness already exists) Publication in good academic journals to spur research and promote high profile “ Be proactive in promoting serious games as means to serious goals, not as goals. ” In the long run, that implies getting rid of the term ‘serious games’.”
  26. What key questions did we miss?   Does terminology matter? Does it matter if it’s called a game? What are the parameters of the serious games market? Does it exist? Is it a fragment of training or traditional games? Or interactive media? Who (besides people who work with the government) is making any money on this? Where are there opportunities beyond the usual suspects (government and healthcare). Or is it just the usual suspects? What tools are you using to build games? What platforms, etc.? Where do mobile games fit in? What is required to get people to use games for training and learning? What stops them from using it? Is America in the lead? If not, how can we become the lead? How are security and privacy being address? Within virtual worlds, how are you going to collect money and transactions? Within the virtual space? Or through a website? How do we establish productivity games as an additional sector within serious games? How can simulations from the private sector and the military inform education? Which journals or resources from the private sector and the military are most informative? (To be asked of consumers with children) Do your children or children in your family learn from games? Side effect learning from playing a particular set of games Specific school games Which do they prefer? Why do you think that is?