This lesson introduces requirements elicitation and modeling techniques for software engineering projects. Three initial research questions are defined to guide the elicitation process. Requirements elicitation involves discovering what users want through activities like interviews and workshops. Domain modeling adds visual and textual representations to help document decisions. The strengths and weaknesses of system-as-is and requirements engineering are discussed to understand different perspectives.

1. 3#40$)#5#&+*!6&7$&##)$&7!!
8#)921::#7#!;<)$&7!=>?=!
!
;#**$1&!?@!A&+)1%02B1&!
Christoph Johann Stettina (stettina@liacs.nl)
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"#$%#&!'&$(#)*$+,-!./#!0&$(#)*$+,!+1!%$*21(#)-
!

2. C1D:*!
!"#$%&"#'($)*"+,$
$
- E1F!+1!%1!)#40$)#5#&+!#:$2$+DB1&!!
$
- E1F!+1!D&D:,G#!)#40$)#5#&+*!!
$
- E1F!+1!*<#2$H,!D&%!%1205#&+!)#40$)#5#&+*!
!!!!!!!!!!!!!"#$%#&!'&$(#)*$+,-!./#!0&$(#)*$+,!+1!%$*21(#)-!

3. .$5#!.DI:#!=>?=!J!--,-.$/$-0,112$3""4$516$
;#**$1&!?@!A&+)1%02B1&!D&%!K15D$&!'&%#)*+D&%$&7!
7$89:;#<;=$->$?$@*A;"(#BC"*$D$E"4<F*$G"(9'F*H$
$$
;#**$1&!=@!6:$2$+DB1&@!;+D9#/1:%#)*!
7$G<;B&$-$?$IA<)9&"'(9;$J*<'=%F%$D$K%9?B<%9$(F<H;<4%$
$
;#**$1&!L@!6:$2$+DB1&@!3#40$)#5#&+*$
7$G<;B&$-.$/$E<A<$B"''9BC"*,$@*A9;LF9+%$D$K%9;$IA";F9%$
$$
;#**$1&!M@!;<#2$N2DB1&$$
7$G<;B&$6M$?$E"B#49*A<C"*$N94O'<A9%$D$P;"(#BA$Q<B)'"H$
$
;#**$1&!O@!6*B5DB1&$
7$JO;F'$-6$?$P'<**F*H$P")9;$$
$
;#**$1&!P@!Q$&D:!RD*#!;+0%,$
7$JO;F'$6R$?$SO9*T9<;*F*HT<:$
the goal, three initial research questions have been defined.
!!!!!!!!!!!!!"#$%#&!'&$(#)*$+,-!./#!0&$(#)*$+,!+1!%$*21(#)-!

4. C)D%$&7!
=OS!8#)921::#7#!T!UOS!6VD5!
!
• .$J%%FH*49*A%$A"$:9$<**"#*B9($F*$B'<%%$
• .$P"F*A%$9<B&$
• .$E9'FL9;9($<%%FH*49*A%$U$6.$P"F*A%$"*$VW<4$
• J''$<%%FH*49*A%$<**"#*B9($F*$B'<%%$
• I9*($F*$<%$PE8$
• P9;$O9;%"*$
!!!!!!!!!!!!!"#$%#&!'&$(#)*$+,-!./#!0&$(#)*$+,!+1!%$*21(#)-!

5. ;#**$1&!?@!3#40$)#5#&+*!6:$2$+DB1&!
http://www.projectcartoon.com/about/
!!!!!!!!!!!!!"#$%#&!'&$(#)*$+,-!./#!0&$(#)*$+,!+1!%$*21(#)-!

6. ;#**$1&!?@!3#40$)#5#&+*!6:$2$+DB1&!
;1WFD)#@!X#F!Y)1%02+!K#(#:1<5#&+!
- N9<4$*<LFH<A9%$A&;"#H&$#*9WO'";9($+<A9;%$
- X#%A"49;%$("*YA$;9<''=$)*"+$+&<A$A&9=$+<*A$
- EFZB#'C9%$F*$%A<C*H$<''$A&9=$+<*A$<*($)*"+$
- X&<*H9$A&9F;$4F*(%$<%$A&9$O;"(#BA$(9L9'"O%$
- E9A<F'%$"L9;+&9'4F*H'=$B"4O'9W$
- VWA9;*<'$[";B9%$B"4O9CA";%2$*9+$A9B&*"'"H=]$
$
Z!K$[20:+,!$*!+/#!*<#2$N2DB1&!1H!+/#!*,*+#5!!
!!!!!&1+!$+*!%#(#:1<5#&+$Q;"")%2$-MM.]$$
!!!!!!!!!!!!!"#$%#&!'&$(#)*$+,-!./#!0&$(#)*$+,!+1!%$*21(#)-!

7. ;#**$1&!?@!3#40$)#5#&+*!6:$2$+DB1&!
.!6"ARA.@$N"$(;<+$"#A2$A"$(F%B"L9;2$A"$;9L9<'^$
$
A.!A;!X.@$<%)F*H$+&<A$#%9;%$+<*A^$$
$
A.!A;@$;9L9<'F*H$+&<A$#%9;%$+F''$:9$+<*C*H^$$
$
36;'".;@$B"4O'9A92$B"*%F%A9*A2$#*<4:FH#"#%2$
;9<'F%CB2$;9'9L<*A$;9_#F;949*A%^$$
$
Y3R6;;@$9'FBFA$?$<*<'=`9$?$*9H"C<A9^$$
$
EAX.@$(9a*9$I^G^J^3^N$IO9BFaB2$G9<%#;<:'92$
Jb<F*<:'92$39<'F%CB2$NF49'=]$;9_#F;949*A%^ been
defined.
!!!!!!!!!!!!!"#$%#&!'&$(#)*$+,-!./#!0&$(#)*$+,!+1!%$*21(#)-!

8. ;#**$1&!?@!3#40$)#5#&+*!6:$2$+DB1&!
.)D%$B1&D:!3#40$)#5#&+*!6&7$&##)$&7!
• P;9(FBCL9,$I=%A94$(9a*9($:9[";9$F4O'949*A<C"*$
• Q9b9;$<A$B"*A;"''F*H$A&9$<;B&FA9BA#;9$"[$:FH$%=%A94%$
• K*;9<'F%CB$F*$#*B9;A<F*$9*LF;"*49*A%,$$
$$$$$$E9a*92$F4O'949*A$<*($&"O9$B#%A"49;$+F''$'F)9$FA$
]7$:#!3#40$)#5#&+*!6&7$&##)$&7!
• J(<OCL9$;<A&9;$A&9*$O;9(FBCL9,$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$
!"#$B<**"A$O;9(FBA$<''$F%%#9%$A"$<OO9<;$$
• 3V$F*$%&";A$B=B'9%$A&;"#H&"#A$A&9$+&"'9$O;"c9BA$
• K%9;?F*L"'L949*A$9*&<*B9%$B#%A"49;$%<C%[<BC"*$
!
!!!!!!!!!!!!!"#$%#&!'&$(#)*$+,-!./#!0&$(#)*$+,!+1!%$*21(#)-!

9. ;#**$1&!?@!3#40$)#5#&+*!6:$2$+DB1&!
6V+)#&#!Y:D&JK)$(#&!8D+#)HD::! Y0)#!]7$:#!
;+)#&7+/*! ;+)#&7+/*!
&FH&9;$'9L9'%$"[$B"*A;"'$<*($O;9(FBA<:F'FA=$"L9;$ [<%A9;$(9L9'"O49*A$C49%$+FA&$&FH&9;$'9L9'%$"[$
B"%A%$<*($%B&9(#'9%$ O;"(#BCLFA=$
'9%%$(9O9*(9*A$"*$&FH&'=$%)F''9($;9%"#;B9%$ d9WF:F'FA=$A"$<(<OA$A"$#*B9;A<F*$<*($B&<*HF*H$
;9_#F;949*A%$
B"*%F%A9*A$+FA&$4<*=$A=OFB<'$B"4O<*=$ [<%A9;$'9<;*F*H$B#;L9%$A"$F*B";O";<A9$O;"B9%%$
9*LF;"*49*A%$ F4O;"L949*A%$
8#D9&#**#*! 8#D9&#**#*!
"L9;'=$:#;9<#B;<CB$B"*A;"'$<*($("B#49*A<C"*$ (FZB#'A$A"$F4O'949*A$(#9$A"$;9A;<F*F*H$"[$%A<e$
"[$;9_#F;949*A%$
#**9B9%%<;=$"L9;&9<($$ ;9_#F;9%$B&<*H9$4<*<H949*A$
;<F%9%$B"%A%$<*($(9L9'"O49*A$C49%$ *"A$<OO;"O;F<A9$[";$'<;H9$<*($B"4O'9W$O;"c9BA%$
'"+9;$<:F'FA=$A"$;9<BA$A"$949;H9*A$<*($$ F*%#ZBF9*A$'9L9'$"[$;F%)$4<*<H949*A$<*($
B&<*HF*H$;9_#F;949*A%$ B"*A;"'$
F*<(9_#<A9$94O&<%F%$"*$'9<;*F*H$<*($$ '"+9;$O;9(FBA<:F'FA=$"[$(9L9'"O49*A$B"%A%$<*($
B"*C*#"#%$F4O;"L949*A$ %B&9(#'9$
(Cobb, 2011, p. 163)
!!!!!!!!!!!!!"#$%#&!'&$(#)*$+,-!./#!0&$(#)*$+,!+1!%$*21(#)-!

10. ;#**$1&!?@!3#40$)#5#&+*!6:$2$+DB1&!
K15D$&!'&%#)*+D&%$&7!
• K*(9;%A<*($A&9$%=%A94?<%?F%$<*($FA%$B"*A9WA$
• 3""A%$"[$A&9$O;":'94$
• S;H<*F`<C"*$
• IB"O9$
• IA<)9&"'(9;%$
• IA;9*HA&%$<*($+9<)*9%%9%$"[$%=%A94?<%?F%$
!
$
!!!!!!!!!!!!!"#$%#&!'&$(#)*$+,-!./#!0&$(#)*$+,!+1!%$*21(#)-!

11. ;#**$1&!?@!3#40$)#5#&+*!6:$2$+DB1&!
^1%#:$&7!
- J((%$<$LF%#<'$(F49*%F"*$A"$A9WA#<'$(9%B;FOC"*$
- I"49$#*(9;%A<*($OFBA#;9%$:9b9;$A&<*$A9WA$
- G";9$%A;FBA,$&9'O%$A"$("B#49*A$(9BF%F"*%$
- V<%=$A"$(;<+,$f9'O%$F*$B#%A"49;$499C*H%$A"$
<;B&FA9BA$
$
!!!!!!!!!!!!!"#$%#&!'&$(#)*$+,-!./#!0&$(#)*$+,!+1!%$*21(#)-!

12. K15D$&!^1%#:$&7@!]!K#N&$B1&!
gJ$:#%F*9%%h("4<F*$4"(9'$F%$<*$<:%A;<BA$;9O;9%9*A<C"*$"[$
<$%=%A94$";$";H<*F`<C"*^$@A$B<OA#;9%$":c9BA%2$F*[";4<C"*$
B"*A<F*9($:=$":c9BA%2$<*($:#%F*9%%$;#'9%$A&<A$;9'<A9$
":c9BA%^i$
$
$
$
$
$
$
$
$
?j$K%9$FA$A"$(;<k$="#;$F(9<%
!!!!!!!!!!!!!"#$%#&!'&$(#)*$+,-!./#!0&$(#)*$+,!+1!%$*21(#)-!

13. 8/,!2)#DB&7!K15D$&!^1%#:*_!
! J$A9B&*F_#9$A"$<*<'=`9$<*($("B#49*A$
$
:#%F*9%%$("4<F*%$H;<O&FB<''=$$
! @4O;"L9$#*(9;%A<*(F*H$<:"#A$<$("4<F*,$$
" Q#%F*9%%$9*CC9%$<*($A&9F;$;9'<C"*%&FO%$
" @4O";A<*A$:#%F*9%%$;#'9%$$
! P"A9*C<'$[";$(9;FLF*H$<$(<A<$4"(9'$
$
!!!!!!!!!!!!!"#$%#&!'&$(#)*$+,-!./#!0&$(#)*$+,!+1!%$*21(#)-!

14. R:D**!K$D7)D5!H1)!`0*$&#**!^1%#:$&7!
gJ$B'<%%$(F<H;<4$(9%B;F:9%$A&9$A=O9%$"[$":c9BA$F*$
A&9$%=%A94$<*($A&9$L<;F"#%$)F*(%$"[$
;9'<C"*%&FO%$<4"*H$A&94i$$
$8"+'9;2$6115]$
$
$
Student
$
X'<%%$EF<H;<4,$A&9$:<%FB%$$ - ID:String[5] - DoB
$?$P;"O9;C9%$$ + Name: String[1] Date
$?$G#'CO'FBFA=$$ + Address: String[1] 1
$?$QF(F;9BC"*<'$<%%"BF<C"*$$ SetID
$?$SO9;<C"*$$ getID
$?$l9*9;<'F`<C"*$$
$?$E9O9*(9*B=$%9A@E$$
!!!!!!!!!!!!!"#$%#&!'&$(#)*$+,-!./#!0&$(#)*$+,!+1!%$*21(#)-!

15. R:D**!K$D7)D5!H1)!`0*$&#**!^1%#:$&7!
Y)1<#)B#*$?$;9O;9%9*A$%A;#BA#;<'$[9<A#;9%$"[$<$B'<%%$
P;"O9;C9%$B<*$:9$(9OFBA9($F*$A+"$+<=%,$$
$
?-!]a)$I0+#!! Student LF%F:F'FA=$*<49,$A=O9$m4#'CO'FBFA=n$
$ - ID:String[5]
+ Name: String[1]
$
$ + Address: String[1] o"A9$&"+$bK1`b$B<*$:9$;9O;9%9*A9($<%$<*$
- DoB: Date[1] <b;F:#A9$<%$+9''$<%$<*$<%%"BF<C"*p$
$ SetID
$ getID
$
=-!]**12$DB1&!! Student
- ID:String[5] - DoB
+ Name: String[1] Date
+ Address: String[1] 1
SetID
getID
fF*A,$G"(9'$O;"O9;C9%$<%$<%%"BF<C"*%$"*'=$
F[$("F*H$%"$<((%$L<'#9$A"$="#;$(F<H;<4%p$
!!!!!!!!!!!!!"#$%#&!'&$(#)*$+,-!./#!0&$(#)*$+,!+1!%$*21(#)-!

16. R:D**!K$D7)D5!H1)!`0*$&#**!^1%#:$&7!
^0:B<:$2$+,$$
q@*(FB<A9%$&"+$4<*=$":c9BA%$B<*$:9$<%%"BF<A9($+FA&$<$O;"O9;A=q$$
?$-$ $ $ $,$J$%A#(9*A$4#%A$&<L9$9W<BA'=$"*9$%#O9;LF%";$$
?$1^^-$$ $,$J$%A#(9*A$4<=$";$4<=$*"A$&<L9$<$%#O9;LF%";$$
?$r$";$1^^r$ $,$J$%A#(9*A$4<=$&<L9$`9;"$";$4";9$%#O9;LF%";%$$
$
`$%$)#2B1&D:!]**12$DB1&!
! has
Student Grade J$%A#(9*A$":c9BA$4<=$&"'($`9;"$";$4";9$H;<(9$":c9BA%$
! 0..*
!
! Student
0..5 1..5
Course
J$%A#(9*A$":c9BA$4<=$&"'($-$#O$A"$.$B"#;%9$":c9BA%$$
J$B"#;%9$":c9BA$4<=$&"'($1$#O$A"$.$%A#(9*A$":c9BA%$
! Follow >
!
E$&+@!A&!I0*$&#**!51%#:$&7!c21&2#<+0D:!51%#:*de!&D($7DI$:$+,!$*!&1+!D&!$5<1)+D&+!!
$**0#-!f10!2D&!15$+!&D($7DI$:$+,!$&!21&2#<+0D:!51%#:*g!!
!!!!!!!!!!!!!"#$%#&!'&$(#)*$+,-!./#!0&$(#)*$+,!+1!%$*21(#)-!

17. R:D**!K$D7)D5!H1)!`0*$&#**!^1%#:$&7!
<#)DB1&*$$
q8#*BC"*%$A&<A$<;9$O;"LF(9($:=$<$B'<%%q$$
$ Student
$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$LF%F:F'FA=$*<49$O<;<49A9;?'F%A]$,$;9A#;*$A=O9$$
- ID:String[5]
$ + Name: String[1]
+ Address: String[1]
$ - DoB: Date[1]
+ setID(id: String)
$ - getID(id: String):
! String
C#&#)D:$GDB1&$$
qIO9BF<'F`<C"*$"[$<$B'<%%$F*A"$"*9$";$4";9$%O9BFaB$B'<%%9%q$
superclass
User
subclass Borrower Librarian subclass
!!!!!!!!!!!!!"#$%#&!'&$(#)*$+,-!./#!0&$(#)*$+,!+1!%$*21(#)-!

18. R:D**!K$D7)D5!H1)!`0*$&#**!^1%#:$&7!
K#<#&%#&2,!!
qK%9$(9O9*(9*B=$A"$F*(FB<A9$<$%FA#<C"*$+&9;9$B&<*H9%$F*$<$B'<%%$";$"A&9;$
9'949*A%]$4FH&A$<'A9;$"A&9;$B'<%%9%q$$
$ Student
$ StudentControlle
$ User
r
$
$ client supplier Course
$
J%%"BF<C"*$(9OFBA%$!"#$%"&!'"#$(9O9*(9*BF9%$
$
R)#DB&7!D!`0*$&#**!^1%#:!!
qJ$:#%F*9%%$4"(9'$F%$<*$<:%A;<BA$;9O;9%9*A<C"*$"[$<$%=%A94^$@A$B<OA#;9%$":c9BA%2$
F*[";4<C"*$B"*A<F*9($:=$":c9BA%2$<*($:#%F*9%%$;#'9%$A&<A$;9'<A9$":c9BA%q^$$
$
$?$@(9*C[=$9*CA=$B'<%%9%$B'<%%9%$A&<A$<;9$49<*F*H[#'$A"$A&9$:#%F*9%%]$$
$?$@(9*C[=$B'<%%$O;"O9;C9%$F^9^2$<b;F:#A9%$<*($<%%"BF<C"*%]$$
$?$@(9*C[=$4#'CO'FBFA=$$
$?$@(9*C[=$O"A9*C<'$H9*9;<'F`<C"*%$
!!!!!!!!!!!!!"#$%#&!'&$(#)*$+,-!./#!0&$(#)*$+,!+1!%$*21(#)-!

19. R:D**!K$D7)D5!H1)!`^@!6VD5<:#*!
TF:;<;=$I=%A94$@*[";4<C"*$I=%A94]$
!!!!!!!!!!!!!"#$%#&!'&$(#)*$+,-!./#!0&$(#)*$+,!+1!%$*21(#)-!

20. R:D**!K$D7)D5!H1)!`^@!6VD5<:#*!
J#(F"$39B";(9;$V4:9((9($I=%A94]$
!!!!!!!!!!!!!"#$%#&!'&$(#)*$+,-!./#!0&$(#)*$+,!+1!%$*21(#)-!

21. .1<!?>!%15D$&!51%#:$&7!70$%#:$&#*!
-1^$8"B#%$"*$;9<'?+";'($O;":'94$("4<F*]$":c9BA%$$
M^$K%9$H9*9;<'F`<C"*$F%?<]$<*($<HH;9H<C"*$&<%?<]$;9'<C"*%&FO%$A"$
%&"+$&"+$A&9$":c9BA%$;9'<A9$A"$9<B&$"A&9;$$
>^$TF4FA$F*FC<'$("4<F*$4"(9'F*H$9e";A%$A"$<$B"#O'9$"[$&"#;%$$
s^$S;H<*F`9$B'<%%9%$<;"#*($)9=$<:%A;<BC"*%$"[$A&9$O;":'94$
R^$E"*YA$4F%A<)9$="#;$("4<F*$4"(9'$[";$<$(<A<$4"(9'$$
.^$E"*YA$B"*[#%9$<*$":c9BA$+&FB&$;9O;9%9*A%$<$%F*H'9$F*%A<*B9]$+FA&$<$
(<A<:<%9$A<:'9$+&FB&$B"*A<F*%$<$B"''9BC"*$"[$A&F*H%]$$
5^$K%9$A&9$("4<F*$4"(9'$<%$<$O;"c9BA$H'"%%<;=$$
0^$E"$="#;$F*FC<'$("4<F*$4"(9'$:9[";9$="#$+;FA9$="#;$#%9$B<%9%2$A"$
<L"F($*<49$<4:FH#FA=$$
6^$E"*YA$9WO9BA$="#;$a*<'$B'<%%$(F<H;<4%$A"$O;9BF%9'=$4<AB&$="#;$
("4<F*$4"(9'2$:#A$A&9;9$%&"#'($:9$%"49$;9%94:'<*B9$:9A+99*$A&94$$
-^$E"*YA$O#A$%B;99*%$<*($"A&9;$lK@?%O9BFaB$B'<%%9%$"*$="#;$4"(9'$
$
IA9O&9*%2$G^2$N&9$@XSo@t$P;"B9%%$F*$OF9B9%,$E"4<F*$4"(9''F*H2$611s$
&bO,hh+++^A&9;9HF%A9;^B"^#)h611sh--h-0h("4<F*u4"(9''F*Hu9WB9;OAhO<H96^&A4'$
!!!!!!!!!!!!!"#$%#&!'&$(#)*$+,-!./#!0&$(#)*$+,!+1!%$*21(#)-!

22. Y)12#**!
$
-^$@(9*C[=$S:c9BA%$
$$$$$$
6^$@(9*C[=$39'<C"*%$
$$$$$
0^$@(9*C[=$Jb;F:#A9%$<*($SO9;<C"*%$
$$$$$
!!!!!!!!!!!!!"#$%#&!'&$(#)*$+,-!./#!0&$(#)*$+,!+1!%$*21(#)-!

23. K15D$&!^1%#:$&7@!A&J2:D**!D**$7&5#&+!
E9%B;F:9$<$&"#%9$#%F*H$<$("4<F*$4"(9'^$
K%9$A&9$<$2+0)#$A"$%9A$#O$%A;#BA#;9$"[$A&9$("4<F*^$
K%9$A&9$%B9*<;F"$/10*#!5D$&+#&D&2#$A"$<(($:9&<LF";$A"$A&9$4"(9'^$
$
39494:9;,$J$:#%F*9%%$
4"(9'$4#%A$B<OA#;9$<''$
F4O";A<*A$":c9BA%$A&<A$
<;9$49<*F*H[#'$A"$A&9$
:#%F*9%%$p$
$
!!!!!!!!!!!!!"#$%#&!'&$(#)*$+,-!./#!0&$(#)*$+,!+1!%$*21(#)-!

24. `$I:$17)D</,!
• Q;"")%2$8^$-MM.]$G=A&FB<'$4<*?4"*A&,$9%%<=%$"*$%"k+<;9$
9*HF*99;F*H2$61A&$<**FL9;%<;=$9(FC"*^$J((F%"*?v9%'9=$
P;"[9%%F"*<'^$l<#%92$E^2$<*($l^$v9F*:9;H^$-M>M^$VWO'";F*H$
;9_#F;949*A%2$_#<'FA=$:9[";9$(9%FH*^$o9+$!";),$E";%9A$f"#%9$
P#:'F%&F*H^$
• 8"+'9;2$G^$6115]$KGT$EF%C''9(,$J$Q;F9[$l#F(9$A"$A&9$
IA<*(<;($S:c9BA$G"(9'F*H$T<*H#<H9$0;($9(^$9(^]^$J((F%"*?
v9%'9=$
• L<*$T<4%+99;(92$J^$611M]$39_#F;949*A%$V*HF*99;F*H,$8;"4$
I=%A94$l"<'%$A"$KGT$G"(9'%$A"$I"k+<;9$IO9BFaB<C"*%^$
vF'9=2$G<;B&$611M^$
$
!!!!!!!!!!!!!"#$%#&!'&$(#)*$+,-!./#!0&$(#)*$+,!+1!%$*21(#)-!