Motivating Performance
Matthew L. Eisenhard, Psy.D.
Week 8: Psychology for Business & Industry
Defining Motivation
• Daniel Pink TED talk
• MOTIVATION = the internal process leading to
behavior to satisfy needs (the REASON you do anything).
▫ Q = Why do people do what they do?
▫ A = To meet their needs & wants.
▫ It is a process – and a continuous one.
 Need > Motive > Behavior > Satisfy/or
Not
• IMPORTANCE = being able to motivate
yourself and others is critical to your career
success (and life over-all).
Performance Formula
Emotions > Behavior > Performance
The Formula:
Performance = Ability X Motivation X
Resources
All 3 factors need to be HIGH.
If any one is weak = performance will suffer.
When people’s needs are not met – generally they
become dissatisfied and low performers.
Theories for Motivation help us understand and
Techniques for Application help us implement them.
Theories of Motivation
• Content
Theories
• Process
Theories
• Reinforcement
Theories
Content Theories of Motivation
Content Theories = focus on identifying
people’s needs in order to understand what
motivates them.
◦ Maslow’s Hierarchy of Needs
◦ ERG Theory (Existence –
Relatedness – Growth)
◦ Two-Factor Theory
◦ Manifest Needs Theory
Maslow’s Hierarchy
Shown in a Pyramid (Exhibit 8.1)
 Needs are in order – from basic to more complex.
 You cannot meet higher needs until basic ones are
attained.
Five Basic Needs
1. PHYSICAL – food, water, shelter, sex.
2. SAFETY – safe working conditions, security.
3. SOCIAL – love, friendship, affection, acceptance.
4. ESTEEM – ego, status, self-respect, recognition
(titles, raises, promotions, etc).
5. SELF-ACTUALIZATION – your full potential.
ERG Theory
Classification of needs is
highly debatable.
Some say only 2 – others
say 7.
ERG is a well-known
simplification.
Alderfer reorganized
Maslow’s into 3 categories
that correlate.
◦ Existence =
physical & safety
needs
◦ Relatedness =
social needs
◦ Growth = esteem &
self-actualization
needs
How to Motivate Using
Hierarchy & ERG Theories
• General rule of thumb: meet lower-level needs
so people can work on upper-levels.
• With ERG ask:
▫ What are this persons needs?
▫ What needs have been met?
▫ What are the lowest ones that haven’t been met?
▫ Have any higher needs been frustrated & how?
▫ Is the person refocusing on lower levels?
▫ How can the unmet needs be attained?
Two-Factor Theory
• Herzberg’s (1950’s) Classification of Needs
Motivators & Hygienes
Self-assessment exercise 8.1.
◦ HYGIENES (lower level needs).
 Physical, Safety, Social
 a.k.a. EXtrinsic - external to job itself.
 Pay, job security, job titles, etc.
 Keep people from being dissatisfied – but do not
motivate them.
◦ MOTIVATORS (higher level needs).
 Esteem, Growth, Self-Actualization.
 a.k.a. INtrinsic – internal to individual.
 Achievement, recognition, challenge, etc.
 To be truly motivated and satisfied you must seek and
attain INTERNAL REWARDS – your job must have
meaning to you beyond $$ and titles.
Manifest Needs Theory
• McClelland’s Classification
Of Needs.
▫ PERSONALITY based
approach to motivation.
• Self-assessment exercise 8.2.
• Three needs.
▫ ACHIEVEMENT.
▫ POWER.
▫ AFFILIATION.
Need for Achievement
• High = problem solvers –
goal-oriented – like
challenges – strive for
excellence – realistic risk
takers – hard workers –
high performers.
• To Motivate = give non-
routine challenging tasks
– lots of feedback and
often – increasing
responsibilities.
Need for Power
• High = want to control –
are competitive – don’t
like loosing – willing to
confront others – low
need for affiliation.
• To Motivate = give lots
of autonomy – include in
decision making – work
alone rather than in teams
– give them the whole
task, not just a part of it.
Need for Affiliation
• High = like close relationships – need to be
liked – enjoy socializing – like to belong to
groups and organizations – tend to be low Power
people – prefer to follow instead of lead.
• To Motive = work as part of a team – give lots
of praise and recognition – let them train new
people on the job – great mentors.
Content Theories
Process Motivation Theories
• Attempt to understand How And
Why people are motivated.
• Focus more on
behavior than
need.
▫ Expectancy
Theory
▫ Equity
Theory
Expectancy Theory
• Vroom’s Formula
▫ Motivation = Expectancy X Valence
 Depends on how much someone wants
something.
• Expectancy
▫ A person’s perception of their own ability &
what they foresee as outcomes.
▫ Higher expectations = higher motivation.
• Valence
▫ The value placed on the outcome or reward.
▫ Higher value = higher motivation.
Expectancy Theory
How To Motivate Using This Theory
◦ Give clear precise goals.
◦ Tie performance to rewards.
◦ Make sure the reward is of value to the
person (remember what one person values
another may not).
◦ Make sure people believe
you will give them the
reward.
Equity Theory
Based on the perception of inputs and outputs.
“Does what I put into this job equal what I get out of it?”
“Am I getting what I deserve for the work I do?”
“Am I getting paid equally in comparison to others doing
the same work I am doing?
People must perceive they are being treated equal to
others.
If they perceive they are not - then trouble comes knocking.
When people think they are being treated with equity they
are more motivated to perform.
Most people tend to inflate their own efforts and
performance over others – and also overestimate what
others earn.
Motivating with Equity Theory
Be aware equity is based on perception.
◦ Perceptions can be right or wrong.
◦ Some managers have favorites – inequity.
Rewards need to be fair.
◦ If people think they are not being treated fairly then
resentment and retaliation can occur.
High performance needs rewarding.
◦ Must have clear understanding of what they need to do
(input) to get reward (output).
How people feel is what counts most.
◦ What people “know” isn’t as important as how they “feel.”
◦ Inequity makes for high emotionality.
Reinforcement Theory
• B.F. Skinner = behavior can be controlled through
the use of positive or negative consequences.
• A.K.A. Behavior Modification or Operant
Conditioning.
• Three Components:
▫ STIMULUS – the event/
something that happens.
▫ RESPONSE – behavior/
performance.
▫ CONSEQUENCES –
reinforcement – positive/
negative.
Types of Reinforcement
POSITIVE
◦ Rewarding desired behavior.
◦ Increases possibility of repeated behavior.
NEGATIVE (Avoidance)
◦ Removal of something unpleasant.
◦ Increases possibility of repeated behavior.
EXTINCTION
◦ When reinforcers are not given.
◦ The desired behaviors disappear.
PUNISHMENT
◦ Least effective method of controlling behaviors.
◦ Lowers morale, productivity.
◦ Encourages acts of sabotage, theft, etc.
Schedules of
Reinforcement
CONTINUOUS = Every Time.
INTERMITTENT:
◦ FIXED INTERVAL
 Reinforcement after set time.
 Weekly pay check.
◦ VARIABLE INTERVAL
 Reinforcement after a unpredictable time lapse.
 Fishing.
◦ FIXED RATIO
 Reinforcement after a set number of events occur.
 Piecework.
◦ VARIABLE RATIO (HIGHEST PREDICTOR )
 Reinforcement after an average or variable or unpredictable
number of events occur.
 Slot machines.
Motivating with Reinforcement
• Make expectations and objectives
clear.
• Use appropriate rewards.
• Use the right reinforcement
schedule.
• Never reward undesired behaviors.
• Focus on positives – reward them.
• Never go a day without praising.
• Do things FOR people not TO them.
Motivation Techniques
• Praise
• Objectives and
Management By
Objectives (MBO)
• Job Enrichment
• Job Design
Praise
• Research since 1940’s show appreciation and
recognition motivate more than anything else
• Even $$$!
Objectives
◦ State what is to be accomplished within
a Certain Time Frame (goals with
deadlines) – should be written.
◦ It Is a Plan for Success.
 Criteria For Objectives (Goals)
 Difficult But Doable.
 Challenging but not impossible.
 Observable And Measurable
 Ability to see and evaluate (keeping score).
 Specific – Target Dates
 Know exactly what and when .
 Participative (When Possible)
 Employee input = better performance.
 Accepted
 Employees must accept and be willing – buy in.
Motivation Techniques
• Management By Objectives
(MBO)
▫ The process where managers and
employees Jointly Set Objectives for the
employee.
▫ Three Steps:
 Set Individual Objectives and Plans.
 Give Feedback and Evaluate
Performance (frequently).
 Reward According to Performance.
Motivation Techniques
JOB ENRICHMENT
◦ Process of building motivators into the job itself by making
it more interesting and challenging.
 Ways To Do That:
 Delegate More Variety And Responsibility.
 Learn new skills – relieves boredom.
 Form Natural Work Groups.
 Allowing teams to work together instead of in separate
offices – tear down the cubicles?
 Make Employees Responsible For Their Own
Identifiable Work.
 Put the worker’s name on the label!
 Give Employees More Autonomy.
 Flexibility to plan and organize your own job.
Motivation Techniques
Job Design
◦ The employee’s system for transforming inputs into outputs.
◦ The more effective the method – the productive the employee.
◦ Job Simplification:
 ELIMINATE
 If something isn’t productive – quit doing it just because
that’s the way it’s always been done.
 COMBINE
 Some tasks can be done at the same time as others – good
time management.
 CHANGE SEQUENCE
 Just changing the order in which things get done sometimes
makes a huge difference in saving time.
 Do the dreaded task first and get it over with!
Self Motivation
• Feeling bored…or trapped?
• Try these techniques
(Model 8.3).
▫ Set Objectives
 Decide what you want – get a destination.
▫ Develop Plans – Willpower Alone Fails
 Make a step-by-step plan – prioritize it.
▫ Measure Results
 Get feedback – compare performance to goal.
▫ Reinforce Results
 Reward yourself for successes – and if you slip
start again!
Motivation Around the Globe
Cross-Cultural Differences in Motivation
◦ Hierarchy Needs
 Countries at risk may place Security high.
 Countries that value relationships over possessions may
place Social Needs higher.
 Obviously higher-level needs are more relevant to wealthy
societies than to poor ones.
◦ Achievement Needs
 High quantity of life countries value high performance.
 High quality of life countries are not as interested in
performance.
 Individualist societies focus on self-accomplishments.
 Collective societies focus on group-accomplishments.
Motivation Around the Globe
Cross-Cultural Differences in Motivation
◦ Individualistic –v- Collective
 Equity is more of a motivator in Individualistic cultures –
with higher producers earning more.
 But even in U.S. (Individualistic) – Worker Unions
(including teachers) tend to prefer equal pay as opposed
to merit pay.
◦ Expectations
 This motivation is flexible and works well within a variety
of countries because it is all relative.
◦ Goal Setting
 Not as important in countries where quality of life is
valued over quantity of life issues.
Chapter Review
• Motivation Process
& Performance
• Motivation Theories
▫ Content Theories
▫ Process Theories
▫ Reinforcement
Theories
• Motivation
Techniques

PSY 126 Week 8: Motivating Performance

  • 1.
    Motivating Performance Matthew L.Eisenhard, Psy.D. Week 8: Psychology for Business & Industry
  • 2.
    Defining Motivation • DanielPink TED talk • MOTIVATION = the internal process leading to behavior to satisfy needs (the REASON you do anything). ▫ Q = Why do people do what they do? ▫ A = To meet their needs & wants. ▫ It is a process – and a continuous one.  Need > Motive > Behavior > Satisfy/or Not • IMPORTANCE = being able to motivate yourself and others is critical to your career success (and life over-all).
  • 3.
    Performance Formula Emotions >Behavior > Performance The Formula: Performance = Ability X Motivation X Resources All 3 factors need to be HIGH. If any one is weak = performance will suffer. When people’s needs are not met – generally they become dissatisfied and low performers. Theories for Motivation help us understand and Techniques for Application help us implement them.
  • 4.
    Theories of Motivation •Content Theories • Process Theories • Reinforcement Theories
  • 5.
    Content Theories ofMotivation Content Theories = focus on identifying people’s needs in order to understand what motivates them. ◦ Maslow’s Hierarchy of Needs ◦ ERG Theory (Existence – Relatedness – Growth) ◦ Two-Factor Theory ◦ Manifest Needs Theory
  • 7.
    Maslow’s Hierarchy Shown ina Pyramid (Exhibit 8.1)  Needs are in order – from basic to more complex.  You cannot meet higher needs until basic ones are attained. Five Basic Needs 1. PHYSICAL – food, water, shelter, sex. 2. SAFETY – safe working conditions, security. 3. SOCIAL – love, friendship, affection, acceptance. 4. ESTEEM – ego, status, self-respect, recognition (titles, raises, promotions, etc). 5. SELF-ACTUALIZATION – your full potential.
  • 9.
    ERG Theory Classification ofneeds is highly debatable. Some say only 2 – others say 7. ERG is a well-known simplification. Alderfer reorganized Maslow’s into 3 categories that correlate. ◦ Existence = physical & safety needs ◦ Relatedness = social needs ◦ Growth = esteem & self-actualization needs
  • 10.
    How to MotivateUsing Hierarchy & ERG Theories • General rule of thumb: meet lower-level needs so people can work on upper-levels. • With ERG ask: ▫ What are this persons needs? ▫ What needs have been met? ▫ What are the lowest ones that haven’t been met? ▫ Have any higher needs been frustrated & how? ▫ Is the person refocusing on lower levels? ▫ How can the unmet needs be attained?
  • 11.
    Two-Factor Theory • Herzberg’s(1950’s) Classification of Needs
  • 12.
    Motivators & Hygienes Self-assessmentexercise 8.1. ◦ HYGIENES (lower level needs).  Physical, Safety, Social  a.k.a. EXtrinsic - external to job itself.  Pay, job security, job titles, etc.  Keep people from being dissatisfied – but do not motivate them. ◦ MOTIVATORS (higher level needs).  Esteem, Growth, Self-Actualization.  a.k.a. INtrinsic – internal to individual.  Achievement, recognition, challenge, etc.  To be truly motivated and satisfied you must seek and attain INTERNAL REWARDS – your job must have meaning to you beyond $$ and titles.
  • 13.
    Manifest Needs Theory •McClelland’s Classification Of Needs. ▫ PERSONALITY based approach to motivation. • Self-assessment exercise 8.2. • Three needs. ▫ ACHIEVEMENT. ▫ POWER. ▫ AFFILIATION.
  • 14.
    Need for Achievement •High = problem solvers – goal-oriented – like challenges – strive for excellence – realistic risk takers – hard workers – high performers. • To Motivate = give non- routine challenging tasks – lots of feedback and often – increasing responsibilities.
  • 15.
    Need for Power •High = want to control – are competitive – don’t like loosing – willing to confront others – low need for affiliation. • To Motivate = give lots of autonomy – include in decision making – work alone rather than in teams – give them the whole task, not just a part of it.
  • 16.
    Need for Affiliation •High = like close relationships – need to be liked – enjoy socializing – like to belong to groups and organizations – tend to be low Power people – prefer to follow instead of lead. • To Motive = work as part of a team – give lots of praise and recognition – let them train new people on the job – great mentors.
  • 17.
  • 19.
    Process Motivation Theories •Attempt to understand How And Why people are motivated. • Focus more on behavior than need. ▫ Expectancy Theory ▫ Equity Theory
  • 20.
    Expectancy Theory • Vroom’sFormula ▫ Motivation = Expectancy X Valence  Depends on how much someone wants something. • Expectancy ▫ A person’s perception of their own ability & what they foresee as outcomes. ▫ Higher expectations = higher motivation. • Valence ▫ The value placed on the outcome or reward. ▫ Higher value = higher motivation.
  • 21.
    Expectancy Theory How ToMotivate Using This Theory ◦ Give clear precise goals. ◦ Tie performance to rewards. ◦ Make sure the reward is of value to the person (remember what one person values another may not). ◦ Make sure people believe you will give them the reward.
  • 22.
    Equity Theory Based onthe perception of inputs and outputs. “Does what I put into this job equal what I get out of it?” “Am I getting what I deserve for the work I do?” “Am I getting paid equally in comparison to others doing the same work I am doing? People must perceive they are being treated equal to others. If they perceive they are not - then trouble comes knocking. When people think they are being treated with equity they are more motivated to perform. Most people tend to inflate their own efforts and performance over others – and also overestimate what others earn.
  • 24.
    Motivating with EquityTheory Be aware equity is based on perception. ◦ Perceptions can be right or wrong. ◦ Some managers have favorites – inequity. Rewards need to be fair. ◦ If people think they are not being treated fairly then resentment and retaliation can occur. High performance needs rewarding. ◦ Must have clear understanding of what they need to do (input) to get reward (output). How people feel is what counts most. ◦ What people “know” isn’t as important as how they “feel.” ◦ Inequity makes for high emotionality.
  • 25.
    Reinforcement Theory • B.F.Skinner = behavior can be controlled through the use of positive or negative consequences. • A.K.A. Behavior Modification or Operant Conditioning. • Three Components: ▫ STIMULUS – the event/ something that happens. ▫ RESPONSE – behavior/ performance. ▫ CONSEQUENCES – reinforcement – positive/ negative.
  • 26.
    Types of Reinforcement POSITIVE ◦Rewarding desired behavior. ◦ Increases possibility of repeated behavior. NEGATIVE (Avoidance) ◦ Removal of something unpleasant. ◦ Increases possibility of repeated behavior. EXTINCTION ◦ When reinforcers are not given. ◦ The desired behaviors disappear. PUNISHMENT ◦ Least effective method of controlling behaviors. ◦ Lowers morale, productivity. ◦ Encourages acts of sabotage, theft, etc.
  • 27.
    Schedules of Reinforcement CONTINUOUS =Every Time. INTERMITTENT: ◦ FIXED INTERVAL  Reinforcement after set time.  Weekly pay check. ◦ VARIABLE INTERVAL  Reinforcement after a unpredictable time lapse.  Fishing. ◦ FIXED RATIO  Reinforcement after a set number of events occur.  Piecework. ◦ VARIABLE RATIO (HIGHEST PREDICTOR )  Reinforcement after an average or variable or unpredictable number of events occur.  Slot machines.
  • 28.
    Motivating with Reinforcement •Make expectations and objectives clear. • Use appropriate rewards. • Use the right reinforcement schedule. • Never reward undesired behaviors. • Focus on positives – reward them. • Never go a day without praising. • Do things FOR people not TO them.
  • 30.
    Motivation Techniques • Praise •Objectives and Management By Objectives (MBO) • Job Enrichment • Job Design
  • 31.
    Praise • Research since1940’s show appreciation and recognition motivate more than anything else • Even $$$!
  • 32.
    Objectives ◦ State whatis to be accomplished within a Certain Time Frame (goals with deadlines) – should be written. ◦ It Is a Plan for Success.  Criteria For Objectives (Goals)  Difficult But Doable.  Challenging but not impossible.  Observable And Measurable  Ability to see and evaluate (keeping score).  Specific – Target Dates  Know exactly what and when .  Participative (When Possible)  Employee input = better performance.  Accepted  Employees must accept and be willing – buy in.
  • 34.
    Motivation Techniques • ManagementBy Objectives (MBO) ▫ The process where managers and employees Jointly Set Objectives for the employee. ▫ Three Steps:  Set Individual Objectives and Plans.  Give Feedback and Evaluate Performance (frequently).  Reward According to Performance.
  • 35.
    Motivation Techniques JOB ENRICHMENT ◦Process of building motivators into the job itself by making it more interesting and challenging.  Ways To Do That:  Delegate More Variety And Responsibility.  Learn new skills – relieves boredom.  Form Natural Work Groups.  Allowing teams to work together instead of in separate offices – tear down the cubicles?  Make Employees Responsible For Their Own Identifiable Work.  Put the worker’s name on the label!  Give Employees More Autonomy.  Flexibility to plan and organize your own job.
  • 36.
    Motivation Techniques Job Design ◦The employee’s system for transforming inputs into outputs. ◦ The more effective the method – the productive the employee. ◦ Job Simplification:  ELIMINATE  If something isn’t productive – quit doing it just because that’s the way it’s always been done.  COMBINE  Some tasks can be done at the same time as others – good time management.  CHANGE SEQUENCE  Just changing the order in which things get done sometimes makes a huge difference in saving time.  Do the dreaded task first and get it over with!
  • 37.
    Self Motivation • Feelingbored…or trapped? • Try these techniques (Model 8.3). ▫ Set Objectives  Decide what you want – get a destination. ▫ Develop Plans – Willpower Alone Fails  Make a step-by-step plan – prioritize it. ▫ Measure Results  Get feedback – compare performance to goal. ▫ Reinforce Results  Reward yourself for successes – and if you slip start again!
  • 38.
    Motivation Around theGlobe Cross-Cultural Differences in Motivation ◦ Hierarchy Needs  Countries at risk may place Security high.  Countries that value relationships over possessions may place Social Needs higher.  Obviously higher-level needs are more relevant to wealthy societies than to poor ones. ◦ Achievement Needs  High quantity of life countries value high performance.  High quality of life countries are not as interested in performance.  Individualist societies focus on self-accomplishments.  Collective societies focus on group-accomplishments.
  • 39.
    Motivation Around theGlobe Cross-Cultural Differences in Motivation ◦ Individualistic –v- Collective  Equity is more of a motivator in Individualistic cultures – with higher producers earning more.  But even in U.S. (Individualistic) – Worker Unions (including teachers) tend to prefer equal pay as opposed to merit pay. ◦ Expectations  This motivation is flexible and works well within a variety of countries because it is all relative. ◦ Goal Setting  Not as important in countries where quality of life is valued over quantity of life issues.
  • 40.
    Chapter Review • MotivationProcess & Performance • Motivation Theories ▫ Content Theories ▫ Process Theories ▫ Reinforcement Theories • Motivation Techniques