SlideShare a Scribd company logo
Promoting social protection in Uganda:
the pros and cons of ‘going with the grain’
Sam Hickey (ESID & GDI, UoM) and
Badru Bukenya (ESID & Makerere University)
DSA Conference, Bath
7-8 September 2015
Current status of social protection in Uganda
• Policy and legislative arrangements are largely in place
– e.g. 1995 Constitutional Commitments
• Multiple (uncoordinated) programmes
• Overall coverage of the sector is very low
– Low levels of spending in the sector – less than 1% of GDP (ILO 2014 says 1.16%)
– Financing for non-contributory social security only US$ 80 million in 2013 (0.33% GDP).
• 2013: towards higher levels of political commitment?
– President extends cash transfer pilot to a 15th District; plans for a national roll-out
– National Social Protection Policy Framework
The politics of development in Uganda
• The shifting political settlement in Uganda
– From a ‘dominant/developmental’ coalition (1990s) to ‘weak
dominant’ (since 2000)
– Pressures from excluded elites & rural base increase under multi-
partyism
• Ideas
– From poverty reduction (back) to structural transformation/economic
nationalism
• New (global) political economy (since mid-2000s)
– Declining reliance on ‘traditional’ donors, oil, China, Russia…
Promoting SP in Uganda
• A donor driven project
– WB and DFID
• Began around 2002
– ‘SP’ literally a foreign concept before this point
• Three phases
– 2002-6: Getting SP onto the policy agenda
– 2007-10: Establishing a pilot & national policy framework
– 2011-date: Roll-out
Phase I (2002-5)
• Donor-led efforts to integrate a focus on SP into the PEAP
– Raise awareness: studies, seminars, brown-bags
– Capacity-building: training for civil servants, wider support for key ministry
• Failed to engage key players (Ministry of Finance)
• Over-reliant on the (weak) Ministry of Gender
• Ideas: linked to poverty discourse
• Limited progress: strategy poorly aligned with dominant
incentives, ideas and actors…but SP now on the policy (if not
political) agenda
Phase II (2006-10)
Clearer strategy:cash transfers and national SP strategy.
Smarter tactics: (informed by PEA)
• Study Tours: key ministers sent to South Africa, Lesotho etc.
• Informal lobbying: e.g. breakfast meetings with Ministers
• Media: promote idea of SP and impacts of the pilot project
• Donors: co-ordination increases (e.g. UNICEF, DFID & IrishAid)
Also luck:
• New Minister of Finance is the ex-Minister of Gender
Progress…
• 2006: Memorandum of Understanding between DFID and
GoU to design and pilot a cash transfer programme signed.
• 2009: Cabinet approval for roll-out of the pilot cash transfer
programme (Social Assistance Grants for Empowerment)
• April 2010: SP is included in the National Development Plan
(2010-15), but with limited budgetary allocations.
• June 2010: Cabinet approves the establishment of the
Expanding Social Protection (ESP) programme within MGLSD
The importance of ideas
• “…back in 2008 when the Ministry of Gender first requested permission
from cabinet to implement the program. They were rejected. The feeling
in cabinet was that SP would lead to dependence, and was not
sustainable, it was seen as welfare hand-outs and government didn’t want
to give such…”
• “So what we did was that we redefined the program around vulnerability
of certain groups of people, old people, orphans and disabled whom
everyone would be comfortable giving money to basing on their
vulnerability rather than their income poverty…so when we re-articulated
the programme that way, cabinet approved it (in 2009). So I think that is
the first political lesson we learnt”.
– ESP source (Interview, March 2014)
My Government aims to
restore the dignity of our
senior citizens…through in
particular the provision of
Senior Citizens Grants…
Launching these grants in
Nebbi today, represents a
clear delivery on our
Manifesto promises.
President M7, Nebbi, International
Women’s Day 2012/Launch of SAGE
Phase III: 2011-
• National Social Protection Framework drafted and promoted
• 2013: formal Presidential support for the Senior Citizens Grant
– The 15th district (Yumbe, in W Nile) and national roll-out requested
• Ministry of Finance: now partially split
– Budgetary support for first time in 2014-5: 2bn UgSch, 7bn in 2015-16
– Senior bureaucrats and (ex)Minister opposed: cost/sustainability, other
priorities, sovereignty
• Political society now offering stronger support
• Political feedback from grassroots
– Cash transfers are now a political fact on the ground
– Understood within the rubric of patron-client relations
President handing over cash to one of the leaders of youth groups of
Busoga region
Concluding thoughts
• SP: a donor-driven agenda, only gains political support when
it reveals potential to support strategy for regime survival in
line with political settlement dynamics
• Increasingly competitive pressures, extend constituency in the North
• But other forms of clientelism preferred (including within MGLSD)
• ‘Going with the grain’ (e.g. ideas, political approach) has costs
– SCTs now on the ground but…
– Evidence-based advocacy?
– How pro-poor? Size of the transfer maintains the social ordering of poverty
• Social contract or mired in the politics of patronage?

More Related Content

What's hot

Long-Term Unemployment
Long-Term UnemploymentLong-Term Unemployment
Long-Term Unemployment
The Rockefeller Foundation
 
Women and Work: Role of Policies and Programmes
Women and Work: Role of Policies and Programmes Women and Work: Role of Policies and Programmes
Women and Work: Role of Policies and Programmes
Paramita Majumdar (Ph.D)
 
CURRENT EXPERIENCES AND TRENDS IN THE REFORM OF
CURRENT EXPERIENCES AND TRENDS IN THE REFORM OFCURRENT EXPERIENCES AND TRENDS IN THE REFORM OF
CURRENT EXPERIENCES AND TRENDS IN THE REFORM OFAnne Van Lancker
 
Minimum income and poverty indicators and targets
Minimum income and poverty indicators and targetsMinimum income and poverty indicators and targets
Minimum income and poverty indicators and targets
European Economic and Social Committee - SOC Section
 
EAPN proposals for an EU framework on Minimum Income and Proposals on Indicators
EAPN proposals for an EU framework on Minimum Income and Proposals on IndicatorsEAPN proposals for an EU framework on Minimum Income and Proposals on Indicators
EAPN proposals for an EU framework on Minimum Income and Proposals on Indicators
European Economic and Social Committee - SOC Section
 
The Governance of Inclusive Growth - OECD
The Governance of Inclusive Growth - OECDThe Governance of Inclusive Growth - OECD
The Governance of Inclusive Growth - OECD
OECD Governance
 
GN-PBO Gender Budgeting Webinar Presentation - Austrian PBO (April 24, 2017)
GN-PBO Gender Budgeting Webinar Presentation - Austrian PBO (April 24, 2017)GN-PBO Gender Budgeting Webinar Presentation - Austrian PBO (April 24, 2017)
GN-PBO Gender Budgeting Webinar Presentation - Austrian PBO (April 24, 2017)
parliaments.cluster
 
Poverty Indicators - supporting the coordination of social policies at EU level
Poverty Indicators - supporting the coordination of social policies at EU levelPoverty Indicators - supporting the coordination of social policies at EU level
Poverty Indicators - supporting the coordination of social policies at EU level
European Economic and Social Committee - SOC Section
 
Digitalisation of finance activities: Challenges and opportunities - Thomas ...
Digitalisation of finance activities:  Challenges and opportunities - Thomas ...Digitalisation of finance activities:  Challenges and opportunities - Thomas ...
Digitalisation of finance activities: Challenges and opportunities - Thomas ...
OECD Governance
 
Gender Budget Analysis Tools
Gender Budget Analysis ToolsGender Budget Analysis Tools
Gender Budget Analysis Toolsbegraj SIWAL
 
Gender budgeting in Austria - Monika Geppl & Eva Festl, Austria
Gender budgeting in Austria - Monika Geppl & Eva Festl, AustriaGender budgeting in Austria - Monika Geppl & Eva Festl, Austria
Gender budgeting in Austria - Monika Geppl & Eva Festl, Austria
OECD Governance
 
GN-PBO Gender Budgeting Webinar Presentation - Armine Yalnizyan (April 24, 2017)
GN-PBO Gender Budgeting Webinar Presentation - Armine Yalnizyan (April 24, 2017)GN-PBO Gender Budgeting Webinar Presentation - Armine Yalnizyan (April 24, 2017)
GN-PBO Gender Budgeting Webinar Presentation - Armine Yalnizyan (April 24, 2017)
parliaments.cluster
 
David Hulme: Can Social Protection Contribute to Growth in Sub-Saharan Africa...
David Hulme: Can Social Protection Contribute to Growth in Sub-Saharan Africa...David Hulme: Can Social Protection Contribute to Growth in Sub-Saharan Africa...
David Hulme: Can Social Protection Contribute to Growth in Sub-Saharan Africa...
Global Development Institute
 
Session Two A: Overview Of Intergovernmental Fiscal Reforms In South Africa, ...
Session Two A: Overview Of Intergovernmental Fiscal Reforms In South Africa, ...Session Two A: Overview Of Intergovernmental Fiscal Reforms In South Africa, ...
Session Two A: Overview Of Intergovernmental Fiscal Reforms In South Africa, ...
OECDtax
 
Benefit take up in the finnish basic income experiment
Benefit take up in the finnish basic income experimentBenefit take up in the finnish basic income experiment
Benefit take up in the finnish basic income experiment
Kelan tutkimus / Research at Kela
 
Understanding the State Budget Making Process
Understanding the State Budget  Making ProcessUnderstanding the State Budget  Making Process
Understanding the State Budget Making Process
Paramita Majumdar (Ph.D)
 
Urban Public Finance / Local Public Finance
Urban Public Finance / Local Public FinanceUrban Public Finance / Local Public Finance
Urban Public Finance / Local Public Finance
Ravikant Joshi
 
D2-PM - Session 6 - Eileen REGAN & Matthew WILSON, UK
D2-PM - Session 6 - Eileen REGAN & Matthew WILSON, UKD2-PM - Session 6 - Eileen REGAN & Matthew WILSON, UK
D2-PM - Session 6 - Eileen REGAN & Matthew WILSON, UK
OECD Governance
 

What's hot (20)

Long-Term Unemployment
Long-Term UnemploymentLong-Term Unemployment
Long-Term Unemployment
 
Women and Work: Role of Policies and Programmes
Women and Work: Role of Policies and Programmes Women and Work: Role of Policies and Programmes
Women and Work: Role of Policies and Programmes
 
CURRENT EXPERIENCES AND TRENDS IN THE REFORM OF
CURRENT EXPERIENCES AND TRENDS IN THE REFORM OFCURRENT EXPERIENCES AND TRENDS IN THE REFORM OF
CURRENT EXPERIENCES AND TRENDS IN THE REFORM OF
 
Minimum income and poverty indicators and targets
Minimum income and poverty indicators and targetsMinimum income and poverty indicators and targets
Minimum income and poverty indicators and targets
 
EAPN proposals for an EU framework on Minimum Income and Proposals on Indicators
EAPN proposals for an EU framework on Minimum Income and Proposals on IndicatorsEAPN proposals for an EU framework on Minimum Income and Proposals on Indicators
EAPN proposals for an EU framework on Minimum Income and Proposals on Indicators
 
The Governance of Inclusive Growth - OECD
The Governance of Inclusive Growth - OECDThe Governance of Inclusive Growth - OECD
The Governance of Inclusive Growth - OECD
 
GN-PBO Gender Budgeting Webinar Presentation - Austrian PBO (April 24, 2017)
GN-PBO Gender Budgeting Webinar Presentation - Austrian PBO (April 24, 2017)GN-PBO Gender Budgeting Webinar Presentation - Austrian PBO (April 24, 2017)
GN-PBO Gender Budgeting Webinar Presentation - Austrian PBO (April 24, 2017)
 
Poverty Indicators - supporting the coordination of social policies at EU level
Poverty Indicators - supporting the coordination of social policies at EU levelPoverty Indicators - supporting the coordination of social policies at EU level
Poverty Indicators - supporting the coordination of social policies at EU level
 
Digitalisation of finance activities: Challenges and opportunities - Thomas ...
Digitalisation of finance activities:  Challenges and opportunities - Thomas ...Digitalisation of finance activities:  Challenges and opportunities - Thomas ...
Digitalisation of finance activities: Challenges and opportunities - Thomas ...
 
Gender Budget Analysis Tools
Gender Budget Analysis ToolsGender Budget Analysis Tools
Gender Budget Analysis Tools
 
Gender budgeting in Austria - Monika Geppl & Eva Festl, Austria
Gender budgeting in Austria - Monika Geppl & Eva Festl, AustriaGender budgeting in Austria - Monika Geppl & Eva Festl, Austria
Gender budgeting in Austria - Monika Geppl & Eva Festl, Austria
 
GN-PBO Gender Budgeting Webinar Presentation - Armine Yalnizyan (April 24, 2017)
GN-PBO Gender Budgeting Webinar Presentation - Armine Yalnizyan (April 24, 2017)GN-PBO Gender Budgeting Webinar Presentation - Armine Yalnizyan (April 24, 2017)
GN-PBO Gender Budgeting Webinar Presentation - Armine Yalnizyan (April 24, 2017)
 
David Hulme: Can Social Protection Contribute to Growth in Sub-Saharan Africa...
David Hulme: Can Social Protection Contribute to Growth in Sub-Saharan Africa...David Hulme: Can Social Protection Contribute to Growth in Sub-Saharan Africa...
David Hulme: Can Social Protection Contribute to Growth in Sub-Saharan Africa...
 
Session Two A: Overview Of Intergovernmental Fiscal Reforms In South Africa, ...
Session Two A: Overview Of Intergovernmental Fiscal Reforms In South Africa, ...Session Two A: Overview Of Intergovernmental Fiscal Reforms In South Africa, ...
Session Two A: Overview Of Intergovernmental Fiscal Reforms In South Africa, ...
 
Benefit take up in the finnish basic income experiment
Benefit take up in the finnish basic income experimentBenefit take up in the finnish basic income experiment
Benefit take up in the finnish basic income experiment
 
COFACE_HU_2015
COFACE_HU_2015COFACE_HU_2015
COFACE_HU_2015
 
Understanding the State Budget Making Process
Understanding the State Budget  Making ProcessUnderstanding the State Budget  Making Process
Understanding the State Budget Making Process
 
Urban Public Finance / Local Public Finance
Urban Public Finance / Local Public FinanceUrban Public Finance / Local Public Finance
Urban Public Finance / Local Public Finance
 
33804110
3380411033804110
33804110
 
D2-PM - Session 6 - Eileen REGAN & Matthew WILSON, UK
D2-PM - Session 6 - Eileen REGAN & Matthew WILSON, UKD2-PM - Session 6 - Eileen REGAN & Matthew WILSON, UK
D2-PM - Session 6 - Eileen REGAN & Matthew WILSON, UK
 

Similar to Promoting Social Protection in Uganda: The Pros and Cons of 'Going with the Grain'

The Politics of Ethiopia's Productive Safety Net Programme
The Politics of Ethiopia's Productive Safety Net ProgrammeThe Politics of Ethiopia's Productive Safety Net Programme
The Politics of Ethiopia's Productive Safety Net Programme
Anna Webster
 
Aligning your funding strategy 2022
Aligning your funding strategy 2022Aligning your funding strategy 2022
Aligning your funding strategy 2022
MzN International
 
Impact of Conflict on Public Investment in Children
Impact of Conflict on Public Investment in ChildrenImpact of Conflict on Public Investment in Children
Impact of Conflict on Public Investment in Children
rmcpu
 
Presentatie-Nicholas-Awortwi.pptx
Presentatie-Nicholas-Awortwi.pptxPresentatie-Nicholas-Awortwi.pptx
Presentatie-Nicholas-Awortwi.pptx
NabiswaboazWangila
 
RPD Bites (September 2020)
RPD Bites (September 2020)RPD Bites (September 2020)
RPD Bites (September 2020)
Yayasan MENDAKI
 
Elsa Alfai presentation english
Elsa Alfai presentation englishElsa Alfai presentation english
Elsa Alfai presentation englishlucifer
 
The Politics of Social Protection in Africa
The Politics of Social Protection in AfricaThe Politics of Social Protection in Africa
The Politics of Social Protection in Africa
The Transfer Project
 
О. Churkina
О. ChurkinaО. Churkina
О. Churkina
Decentralizationgovua
 
Expanding access to social services using remittances
Expanding access to social services using remittancesExpanding access to social services using remittances
Expanding access to social services using remittances
khdiallo
 
Why Policies fail: A study of Nigeria
Why Policies fail: A study of NigeriaWhy Policies fail: A study of Nigeria
Why Policies fail: A study of Nigeria
Solomon Adetokunbo
 
Kenya Mobilizing financial resources needed for health in the SDG era
Kenya  Mobilizing financial resources needed for health in the SDG eraKenya  Mobilizing financial resources needed for health in the SDG era
Kenya Mobilizing financial resources needed for health in the SDG era
Deepak Mattur
 
Ed Strengthening Community Linkages On Poverty Reduction In Ontario E6
Ed Strengthening Community Linkages On Poverty Reduction In Ontario E6Ed Strengthening Community Linkages On Poverty Reduction In Ontario E6
Ed Strengthening Community Linkages On Poverty Reduction In Ontario E6ocasiconference
 
Strengthening Community Linkages On Poverty Reduction In Ontario
Strengthening Community Linkages On Poverty Reduction In OntarioStrengthening Community Linkages On Poverty Reduction In Ontario
Strengthening Community Linkages On Poverty Reduction In Ontariosettlementatwork
 
23634.ppt
23634.ppt23634.ppt
23634.ppt
Gurumurthy B R
 
Social protection and development cooperation
Social protection and development cooperationSocial protection and development cooperation
Social protection and development cooperation
HelpAge International
 
NCVO's analysis of the 2015 election (S3)
NCVO's analysis of the 2015 election (S3)NCVO's analysis of the 2015 election (S3)
NCVO's analysis of the 2015 election (S3)
NCVO - National Council for Voluntary Organisations
 
Evidence of Social Protection in contexts of Fragility and Forced Displacement
Evidence of Social Protection in contexts of Fragility and Forced DisplacementEvidence of Social Protection in contexts of Fragility and Forced Displacement
Evidence of Social Protection in contexts of Fragility and Forced Displacement
UNICEF Office of Research - Innocenti
 
M5.1 Kenya Shaping Actions For Crisis Response
M5.1 Kenya Shaping Actions For Crisis ResponseM5.1 Kenya Shaping Actions For Crisis Response
M5.1 Kenya Shaping Actions For Crisis ResponseSDTI
 
Fiscal policy and eco growth
Fiscal policy and eco growthFiscal policy and eco growth
Fiscal policy and eco growth
Prabha Panth
 

Similar to Promoting Social Protection in Uganda: The Pros and Cons of 'Going with the Grain' (20)

The Politics of Ethiopia's Productive Safety Net Programme
The Politics of Ethiopia's Productive Safety Net ProgrammeThe Politics of Ethiopia's Productive Safety Net Programme
The Politics of Ethiopia's Productive Safety Net Programme
 
Aligning your funding strategy 2022
Aligning your funding strategy 2022Aligning your funding strategy 2022
Aligning your funding strategy 2022
 
Impact of Conflict on Public Investment in Children
Impact of Conflict on Public Investment in ChildrenImpact of Conflict on Public Investment in Children
Impact of Conflict on Public Investment in Children
 
Presentatie-Nicholas-Awortwi.pptx
Presentatie-Nicholas-Awortwi.pptxPresentatie-Nicholas-Awortwi.pptx
Presentatie-Nicholas-Awortwi.pptx
 
RPD Bites (September 2020)
RPD Bites (September 2020)RPD Bites (September 2020)
RPD Bites (September 2020)
 
Elsa Alfai presentation english
Elsa Alfai presentation englishElsa Alfai presentation english
Elsa Alfai presentation english
 
Elsa 2
Elsa 2Elsa 2
Elsa 2
 
The Politics of Social Protection in Africa
The Politics of Social Protection in AfricaThe Politics of Social Protection in Africa
The Politics of Social Protection in Africa
 
О. Churkina
О. ChurkinaО. Churkina
О. Churkina
 
Expanding access to social services using remittances
Expanding access to social services using remittancesExpanding access to social services using remittances
Expanding access to social services using remittances
 
Why Policies fail: A study of Nigeria
Why Policies fail: A study of NigeriaWhy Policies fail: A study of Nigeria
Why Policies fail: A study of Nigeria
 
Kenya Mobilizing financial resources needed for health in the SDG era
Kenya  Mobilizing financial resources needed for health in the SDG eraKenya  Mobilizing financial resources needed for health in the SDG era
Kenya Mobilizing financial resources needed for health in the SDG era
 
Ed Strengthening Community Linkages On Poverty Reduction In Ontario E6
Ed Strengthening Community Linkages On Poverty Reduction In Ontario E6Ed Strengthening Community Linkages On Poverty Reduction In Ontario E6
Ed Strengthening Community Linkages On Poverty Reduction In Ontario E6
 
Strengthening Community Linkages On Poverty Reduction In Ontario
Strengthening Community Linkages On Poverty Reduction In OntarioStrengthening Community Linkages On Poverty Reduction In Ontario
Strengthening Community Linkages On Poverty Reduction In Ontario
 
23634.ppt
23634.ppt23634.ppt
23634.ppt
 
Social protection and development cooperation
Social protection and development cooperationSocial protection and development cooperation
Social protection and development cooperation
 
NCVO's analysis of the 2015 election (S3)
NCVO's analysis of the 2015 election (S3)NCVO's analysis of the 2015 election (S3)
NCVO's analysis of the 2015 election (S3)
 
Evidence of Social Protection in contexts of Fragility and Forced Displacement
Evidence of Social Protection in contexts of Fragility and Forced DisplacementEvidence of Social Protection in contexts of Fragility and Forced Displacement
Evidence of Social Protection in contexts of Fragility and Forced Displacement
 
M5.1 Kenya Shaping Actions For Crisis Response
M5.1 Kenya Shaping Actions For Crisis ResponseM5.1 Kenya Shaping Actions For Crisis Response
M5.1 Kenya Shaping Actions For Crisis Response
 
Fiscal policy and eco growth
Fiscal policy and eco growthFiscal policy and eco growth
Fiscal policy and eco growth
 

More from EffectiveStates

The Regime-Reform Struggle: Elite Politics, Policy Ideas, and Public Sector E...
The Regime-Reform Struggle: Elite Politics, Policy Ideas, and Public Sector E...The Regime-Reform Struggle: Elite Politics, Policy Ideas, and Public Sector E...
The Regime-Reform Struggle: Elite Politics, Policy Ideas, and Public Sector E...
EffectiveStates
 
Social Protection: At the Intersection of Transnational Ideas and Domestic Po...
Social Protection: At the Intersection of Transnational Ideas and Domestic Po...Social Protection: At the Intersection of Transnational Ideas and Domestic Po...
Social Protection: At the Intersection of Transnational Ideas and Domestic Po...
EffectiveStates
 
The Politics of Negotiating Gender Equity in Bangladesh: Coalitions, Gendered...
The Politics of Negotiating Gender Equity in Bangladesh: Coalitions, Gendered...The Politics of Negotiating Gender Equity in Bangladesh: Coalitions, Gendered...
The Politics of Negotiating Gender Equity in Bangladesh: Coalitions, Gendered...
EffectiveStates
 
How Does Politics Shape Development? The Role of Incentives, Ideas and Coalit...
How Does Politics Shape Development? The Role of Incentives, Ideas and Coalit...How Does Politics Shape Development? The Role of Incentives, Ideas and Coalit...
How Does Politics Shape Development? The Role of Incentives, Ideas and Coalit...
EffectiveStates
 
The Banality of Certainty: Organizational, ethical and cognitive pathologies ...
The Banality of Certainty: Organizational, ethical and cognitive pathologies ...The Banality of Certainty: Organizational, ethical and cognitive pathologies ...
The Banality of Certainty: Organizational, ethical and cognitive pathologies ...
EffectiveStates
 
Public Sector Reform: Challenges and Prospects in Ghana and Beyond
Public Sector Reform: Challenges and Prospects in Ghana and BeyondPublic Sector Reform: Challenges and Prospects in Ghana and Beyond
Public Sector Reform: Challenges and Prospects in Ghana and Beyond
EffectiveStates
 
Birmingham governance seminar presentation
Birmingham governance seminar presentationBirmingham governance seminar presentation
Birmingham governance seminar presentation
EffectiveStates
 
Política, resultados y adaptación: Tres posibles futuros para la eficacia y l...
Política, resultados y adaptación: Tres posibles futuros para la eficacia y l...Política, resultados y adaptación: Tres posibles futuros para la eficacia y l...
Política, resultados y adaptación: Tres posibles futuros para la eficacia y l...
EffectiveStates
 
Oriented Towards Action: The Politics of Improving Education Quality in Rwanda
Oriented Towards Action: The Politics of Improving Education Quality in RwandaOriented Towards Action: The Politics of Improving Education Quality in Rwanda
Oriented Towards Action: The Politics of Improving Education Quality in Rwanda
EffectiveStates
 
The politics of improving educational outcomes: From quantity to quality?
The politics of improving educational outcomes: From quantity to quality?The politics of improving educational outcomes: From quantity to quality?
The politics of improving educational outcomes: From quantity to quality?
EffectiveStates
 
The Political Settlement & Basic Education Quality in Bangladesh
The Political Settlement & Basic Education Quality in BangladeshThe Political Settlement & Basic Education Quality in Bangladesh
The Political Settlement & Basic Education Quality in Bangladesh
EffectiveStates
 

More from EffectiveStates (11)

The Regime-Reform Struggle: Elite Politics, Policy Ideas, and Public Sector E...
The Regime-Reform Struggle: Elite Politics, Policy Ideas, and Public Sector E...The Regime-Reform Struggle: Elite Politics, Policy Ideas, and Public Sector E...
The Regime-Reform Struggle: Elite Politics, Policy Ideas, and Public Sector E...
 
Social Protection: At the Intersection of Transnational Ideas and Domestic Po...
Social Protection: At the Intersection of Transnational Ideas and Domestic Po...Social Protection: At the Intersection of Transnational Ideas and Domestic Po...
Social Protection: At the Intersection of Transnational Ideas and Domestic Po...
 
The Politics of Negotiating Gender Equity in Bangladesh: Coalitions, Gendered...
The Politics of Negotiating Gender Equity in Bangladesh: Coalitions, Gendered...The Politics of Negotiating Gender Equity in Bangladesh: Coalitions, Gendered...
The Politics of Negotiating Gender Equity in Bangladesh: Coalitions, Gendered...
 
How Does Politics Shape Development? The Role of Incentives, Ideas and Coalit...
How Does Politics Shape Development? The Role of Incentives, Ideas and Coalit...How Does Politics Shape Development? The Role of Incentives, Ideas and Coalit...
How Does Politics Shape Development? The Role of Incentives, Ideas and Coalit...
 
The Banality of Certainty: Organizational, ethical and cognitive pathologies ...
The Banality of Certainty: Organizational, ethical and cognitive pathologies ...The Banality of Certainty: Organizational, ethical and cognitive pathologies ...
The Banality of Certainty: Organizational, ethical and cognitive pathologies ...
 
Public Sector Reform: Challenges and Prospects in Ghana and Beyond
Public Sector Reform: Challenges and Prospects in Ghana and BeyondPublic Sector Reform: Challenges and Prospects in Ghana and Beyond
Public Sector Reform: Challenges and Prospects in Ghana and Beyond
 
Birmingham governance seminar presentation
Birmingham governance seminar presentationBirmingham governance seminar presentation
Birmingham governance seminar presentation
 
Política, resultados y adaptación: Tres posibles futuros para la eficacia y l...
Política, resultados y adaptación: Tres posibles futuros para la eficacia y l...Política, resultados y adaptación: Tres posibles futuros para la eficacia y l...
Política, resultados y adaptación: Tres posibles futuros para la eficacia y l...
 
Oriented Towards Action: The Politics of Improving Education Quality in Rwanda
Oriented Towards Action: The Politics of Improving Education Quality in RwandaOriented Towards Action: The Politics of Improving Education Quality in Rwanda
Oriented Towards Action: The Politics of Improving Education Quality in Rwanda
 
The politics of improving educational outcomes: From quantity to quality?
The politics of improving educational outcomes: From quantity to quality?The politics of improving educational outcomes: From quantity to quality?
The politics of improving educational outcomes: From quantity to quality?
 
The Political Settlement & Basic Education Quality in Bangladesh
The Political Settlement & Basic Education Quality in BangladeshThe Political Settlement & Basic Education Quality in Bangladesh
The Political Settlement & Basic Education Quality in Bangladesh
 

Recently uploaded

一比一原版(Adelaide毕业证)阿德莱德大学毕业证成绩单
一比一原版(Adelaide毕业证)阿德莱德大学毕业证成绩单一比一原版(Adelaide毕业证)阿德莱德大学毕业证成绩单
一比一原版(Adelaide毕业证)阿德莱德大学毕业证成绩单
ehbuaw
 
Counting Class for Micro Observers 2024.pptx
Counting Class for Micro Observers 2024.pptxCounting Class for Micro Observers 2024.pptx
Counting Class for Micro Observers 2024.pptx
Revenue Department Kerala State
 
2024: The FAR - Federal Acquisition Regulations, Part 37
2024: The FAR - Federal Acquisition Regulations, Part 372024: The FAR - Federal Acquisition Regulations, Part 37
2024: The FAR - Federal Acquisition Regulations, Part 37
JSchaus & Associates
 
Uniform Guidance 3.0 - The New 2 CFR 200
Uniform Guidance 3.0 - The New 2 CFR 200Uniform Guidance 3.0 - The New 2 CFR 200
Uniform Guidance 3.0 - The New 2 CFR 200
GrantManagementInsti
 
一比一原版(WSU毕业证)西悉尼大学毕业证成绩单
一比一原版(WSU毕业证)西悉尼大学毕业证成绩单一比一原版(WSU毕业证)西悉尼大学毕业证成绩单
一比一原版(WSU毕业证)西悉尼大学毕业证成绩单
evkovas
 
What is the point of small housing associations.pptx
What is the point of small housing associations.pptxWhat is the point of small housing associations.pptx
What is the point of small housing associations.pptx
Paul Smith
 
一比一原版(ANU毕业证)澳大利亚国立大学毕业证成绩单
一比一原版(ANU毕业证)澳大利亚国立大学毕业证成绩单一比一原版(ANU毕业证)澳大利亚国立大学毕业证成绩单
一比一原版(ANU毕业证)澳大利亚国立大学毕业证成绩单
ehbuaw
 
2024: The FAR - Federal Acquisition Regulations, Part 36
2024: The FAR - Federal Acquisition Regulations, Part 362024: The FAR - Federal Acquisition Regulations, Part 36
2024: The FAR - Federal Acquisition Regulations, Part 36
JSchaus & Associates
 
PPT Item # 9 - 2024 Street Maintenance Program(SMP) Amendment
PPT Item # 9 - 2024 Street Maintenance Program(SMP) AmendmentPPT Item # 9 - 2024 Street Maintenance Program(SMP) Amendment
PPT Item # 9 - 2024 Street Maintenance Program(SMP) Amendment
ahcitycouncil
 
Many ways to support street children.pptx
Many ways to support street children.pptxMany ways to support street children.pptx
Many ways to support street children.pptx
SERUDS INDIA
 
PACT launching workshop presentation-Final.pdf
PACT launching workshop presentation-Final.pdfPACT launching workshop presentation-Final.pdf
PACT launching workshop presentation-Final.pdf
Mohammed325561
 
如何办理(uoit毕业证书)加拿大安大略理工大学毕业证文凭证书录取通知原版一模一样
如何办理(uoit毕业证书)加拿大安大略理工大学毕业证文凭证书录取通知原版一模一样如何办理(uoit毕业证书)加拿大安大略理工大学毕业证文凭证书录取通知原版一模一样
如何办理(uoit毕业证书)加拿大安大略理工大学毕业证文凭证书录取通知原版一模一样
850fcj96
 
Understanding the Challenges of Street Children
Understanding the Challenges of Street ChildrenUnderstanding the Challenges of Street Children
Understanding the Challenges of Street Children
SERUDS INDIA
 
Russian anarchist and anti-war movement in the third year of full-scale war
Russian anarchist and anti-war movement in the third year of full-scale warRussian anarchist and anti-war movement in the third year of full-scale war
Russian anarchist and anti-war movement in the third year of full-scale war
Antti Rautiainen
 
PNRR MADRID GREENTECH FOR BROWN NETWORKS NETWORKS MUR_MUSA_TEBALDI.pdf
PNRR MADRID GREENTECH FOR BROWN NETWORKS NETWORKS MUR_MUSA_TEBALDI.pdfPNRR MADRID GREENTECH FOR BROWN NETWORKS NETWORKS MUR_MUSA_TEBALDI.pdf
PNRR MADRID GREENTECH FOR BROWN NETWORKS NETWORKS MUR_MUSA_TEBALDI.pdf
ClaudioTebaldi2
 
Get Government Grants and Assistance Program
Get Government Grants and Assistance ProgramGet Government Grants and Assistance Program
Get Government Grants and Assistance Program
Get Government Grants
 
Canadian Immigration Tracker March 2024 - Key Slides
Canadian Immigration Tracker March 2024 - Key SlidesCanadian Immigration Tracker March 2024 - Key Slides
Canadian Immigration Tracker March 2024 - Key Slides
Andrew Griffith
 
MHM Roundtable Slide Deck WHA Side-event May 28 2024.pptx
MHM Roundtable Slide Deck WHA Side-event May 28 2024.pptxMHM Roundtable Slide Deck WHA Side-event May 28 2024.pptx
MHM Roundtable Slide Deck WHA Side-event May 28 2024.pptx
ILC- UK
 
The Role of a Process Server in real estate
The Role of a Process Server in real estateThe Role of a Process Server in real estate
The Role of a Process Server in real estate
oklahomajudicialproc1
 
快速制作(ocad毕业证书)加拿大安大略艺术设计学院毕业证本科学历雅思成绩单原版一模一样
快速制作(ocad毕业证书)加拿大安大略艺术设计学院毕业证本科学历雅思成绩单原版一模一样快速制作(ocad毕业证书)加拿大安大略艺术设计学院毕业证本科学历雅思成绩单原版一模一样
快速制作(ocad毕业证书)加拿大安大略艺术设计学院毕业证本科学历雅思成绩单原版一模一样
850fcj96
 

Recently uploaded (20)

一比一原版(Adelaide毕业证)阿德莱德大学毕业证成绩单
一比一原版(Adelaide毕业证)阿德莱德大学毕业证成绩单一比一原版(Adelaide毕业证)阿德莱德大学毕业证成绩单
一比一原版(Adelaide毕业证)阿德莱德大学毕业证成绩单
 
Counting Class for Micro Observers 2024.pptx
Counting Class for Micro Observers 2024.pptxCounting Class for Micro Observers 2024.pptx
Counting Class for Micro Observers 2024.pptx
 
2024: The FAR - Federal Acquisition Regulations, Part 37
2024: The FAR - Federal Acquisition Regulations, Part 372024: The FAR - Federal Acquisition Regulations, Part 37
2024: The FAR - Federal Acquisition Regulations, Part 37
 
Uniform Guidance 3.0 - The New 2 CFR 200
Uniform Guidance 3.0 - The New 2 CFR 200Uniform Guidance 3.0 - The New 2 CFR 200
Uniform Guidance 3.0 - The New 2 CFR 200
 
一比一原版(WSU毕业证)西悉尼大学毕业证成绩单
一比一原版(WSU毕业证)西悉尼大学毕业证成绩单一比一原版(WSU毕业证)西悉尼大学毕业证成绩单
一比一原版(WSU毕业证)西悉尼大学毕业证成绩单
 
What is the point of small housing associations.pptx
What is the point of small housing associations.pptxWhat is the point of small housing associations.pptx
What is the point of small housing associations.pptx
 
一比一原版(ANU毕业证)澳大利亚国立大学毕业证成绩单
一比一原版(ANU毕业证)澳大利亚国立大学毕业证成绩单一比一原版(ANU毕业证)澳大利亚国立大学毕业证成绩单
一比一原版(ANU毕业证)澳大利亚国立大学毕业证成绩单
 
2024: The FAR - Federal Acquisition Regulations, Part 36
2024: The FAR - Federal Acquisition Regulations, Part 362024: The FAR - Federal Acquisition Regulations, Part 36
2024: The FAR - Federal Acquisition Regulations, Part 36
 
PPT Item # 9 - 2024 Street Maintenance Program(SMP) Amendment
PPT Item # 9 - 2024 Street Maintenance Program(SMP) AmendmentPPT Item # 9 - 2024 Street Maintenance Program(SMP) Amendment
PPT Item # 9 - 2024 Street Maintenance Program(SMP) Amendment
 
Many ways to support street children.pptx
Many ways to support street children.pptxMany ways to support street children.pptx
Many ways to support street children.pptx
 
PACT launching workshop presentation-Final.pdf
PACT launching workshop presentation-Final.pdfPACT launching workshop presentation-Final.pdf
PACT launching workshop presentation-Final.pdf
 
如何办理(uoit毕业证书)加拿大安大略理工大学毕业证文凭证书录取通知原版一模一样
如何办理(uoit毕业证书)加拿大安大略理工大学毕业证文凭证书录取通知原版一模一样如何办理(uoit毕业证书)加拿大安大略理工大学毕业证文凭证书录取通知原版一模一样
如何办理(uoit毕业证书)加拿大安大略理工大学毕业证文凭证书录取通知原版一模一样
 
Understanding the Challenges of Street Children
Understanding the Challenges of Street ChildrenUnderstanding the Challenges of Street Children
Understanding the Challenges of Street Children
 
Russian anarchist and anti-war movement in the third year of full-scale war
Russian anarchist and anti-war movement in the third year of full-scale warRussian anarchist and anti-war movement in the third year of full-scale war
Russian anarchist and anti-war movement in the third year of full-scale war
 
PNRR MADRID GREENTECH FOR BROWN NETWORKS NETWORKS MUR_MUSA_TEBALDI.pdf
PNRR MADRID GREENTECH FOR BROWN NETWORKS NETWORKS MUR_MUSA_TEBALDI.pdfPNRR MADRID GREENTECH FOR BROWN NETWORKS NETWORKS MUR_MUSA_TEBALDI.pdf
PNRR MADRID GREENTECH FOR BROWN NETWORKS NETWORKS MUR_MUSA_TEBALDI.pdf
 
Get Government Grants and Assistance Program
Get Government Grants and Assistance ProgramGet Government Grants and Assistance Program
Get Government Grants and Assistance Program
 
Canadian Immigration Tracker March 2024 - Key Slides
Canadian Immigration Tracker March 2024 - Key SlidesCanadian Immigration Tracker March 2024 - Key Slides
Canadian Immigration Tracker March 2024 - Key Slides
 
MHM Roundtable Slide Deck WHA Side-event May 28 2024.pptx
MHM Roundtable Slide Deck WHA Side-event May 28 2024.pptxMHM Roundtable Slide Deck WHA Side-event May 28 2024.pptx
MHM Roundtable Slide Deck WHA Side-event May 28 2024.pptx
 
The Role of a Process Server in real estate
The Role of a Process Server in real estateThe Role of a Process Server in real estate
The Role of a Process Server in real estate
 
快速制作(ocad毕业证书)加拿大安大略艺术设计学院毕业证本科学历雅思成绩单原版一模一样
快速制作(ocad毕业证书)加拿大安大略艺术设计学院毕业证本科学历雅思成绩单原版一模一样快速制作(ocad毕业证书)加拿大安大略艺术设计学院毕业证本科学历雅思成绩单原版一模一样
快速制作(ocad毕业证书)加拿大安大略艺术设计学院毕业证本科学历雅思成绩单原版一模一样
 

Promoting Social Protection in Uganda: The Pros and Cons of 'Going with the Grain'

  • 1. Promoting social protection in Uganda: the pros and cons of ‘going with the grain’ Sam Hickey (ESID & GDI, UoM) and Badru Bukenya (ESID & Makerere University) DSA Conference, Bath 7-8 September 2015
  • 2. Current status of social protection in Uganda • Policy and legislative arrangements are largely in place – e.g. 1995 Constitutional Commitments • Multiple (uncoordinated) programmes • Overall coverage of the sector is very low – Low levels of spending in the sector – less than 1% of GDP (ILO 2014 says 1.16%) – Financing for non-contributory social security only US$ 80 million in 2013 (0.33% GDP). • 2013: towards higher levels of political commitment? – President extends cash transfer pilot to a 15th District; plans for a national roll-out – National Social Protection Policy Framework
  • 3. The politics of development in Uganda • The shifting political settlement in Uganda – From a ‘dominant/developmental’ coalition (1990s) to ‘weak dominant’ (since 2000) – Pressures from excluded elites & rural base increase under multi- partyism • Ideas – From poverty reduction (back) to structural transformation/economic nationalism • New (global) political economy (since mid-2000s) – Declining reliance on ‘traditional’ donors, oil, China, Russia…
  • 4. Promoting SP in Uganda • A donor driven project – WB and DFID • Began around 2002 – ‘SP’ literally a foreign concept before this point • Three phases – 2002-6: Getting SP onto the policy agenda – 2007-10: Establishing a pilot & national policy framework – 2011-date: Roll-out
  • 5. Phase I (2002-5) • Donor-led efforts to integrate a focus on SP into the PEAP – Raise awareness: studies, seminars, brown-bags – Capacity-building: training for civil servants, wider support for key ministry • Failed to engage key players (Ministry of Finance) • Over-reliant on the (weak) Ministry of Gender • Ideas: linked to poverty discourse • Limited progress: strategy poorly aligned with dominant incentives, ideas and actors…but SP now on the policy (if not political) agenda
  • 6. Phase II (2006-10) Clearer strategy:cash transfers and national SP strategy. Smarter tactics: (informed by PEA) • Study Tours: key ministers sent to South Africa, Lesotho etc. • Informal lobbying: e.g. breakfast meetings with Ministers • Media: promote idea of SP and impacts of the pilot project • Donors: co-ordination increases (e.g. UNICEF, DFID & IrishAid) Also luck: • New Minister of Finance is the ex-Minister of Gender
  • 7. Progress… • 2006: Memorandum of Understanding between DFID and GoU to design and pilot a cash transfer programme signed. • 2009: Cabinet approval for roll-out of the pilot cash transfer programme (Social Assistance Grants for Empowerment) • April 2010: SP is included in the National Development Plan (2010-15), but with limited budgetary allocations. • June 2010: Cabinet approves the establishment of the Expanding Social Protection (ESP) programme within MGLSD
  • 8. The importance of ideas • “…back in 2008 when the Ministry of Gender first requested permission from cabinet to implement the program. They were rejected. The feeling in cabinet was that SP would lead to dependence, and was not sustainable, it was seen as welfare hand-outs and government didn’t want to give such…” • “So what we did was that we redefined the program around vulnerability of certain groups of people, old people, orphans and disabled whom everyone would be comfortable giving money to basing on their vulnerability rather than their income poverty…so when we re-articulated the programme that way, cabinet approved it (in 2009). So I think that is the first political lesson we learnt”. – ESP source (Interview, March 2014)
  • 9. My Government aims to restore the dignity of our senior citizens…through in particular the provision of Senior Citizens Grants… Launching these grants in Nebbi today, represents a clear delivery on our Manifesto promises. President M7, Nebbi, International Women’s Day 2012/Launch of SAGE
  • 10. Phase III: 2011- • National Social Protection Framework drafted and promoted • 2013: formal Presidential support for the Senior Citizens Grant – The 15th district (Yumbe, in W Nile) and national roll-out requested • Ministry of Finance: now partially split – Budgetary support for first time in 2014-5: 2bn UgSch, 7bn in 2015-16 – Senior bureaucrats and (ex)Minister opposed: cost/sustainability, other priorities, sovereignty • Political society now offering stronger support • Political feedback from grassroots – Cash transfers are now a political fact on the ground – Understood within the rubric of patron-client relations
  • 11. President handing over cash to one of the leaders of youth groups of Busoga region
  • 12. Concluding thoughts • SP: a donor-driven agenda, only gains political support when it reveals potential to support strategy for regime survival in line with political settlement dynamics • Increasingly competitive pressures, extend constituency in the North • But other forms of clientelism preferred (including within MGLSD) • ‘Going with the grain’ (e.g. ideas, political approach) has costs – SCTs now on the ground but… – Evidence-based advocacy? – How pro-poor? Size of the transfer maintains the social ordering of poverty • Social contract or mired in the politics of patronage?

Editor's Notes

  1. 1995 Constitution promises social and economic rights of vulnerable groups like women; reasonable provision for the aged protection of children from social or economic exploitation; special protection for orphans and other disadvantaged children; support to PWD
  2. Reflects the politicised promotion of SP