SlideShare a Scribd company logo
Multilingualism as Cultural Capital?
Study of Studies
Donna L. Confere
Objectives
• To determine if there is a
correlation between multilingualism
and cognitive ability.
• To determine if multilingualism
translates into higher grades and
greater academic achievement.
• To determine if the number of
languages in which a person has
achieved proficiency impacts their
economic advancement, stability,
and status.
Cultural Capital
• Pierre Bourdieu (1986) The Forms of Capital:
• Cultural capital can exist in three forms: in the embodied state, i.e., in the form of long-
lasting dispositions of the mind and body; in the objectified state, in the form of cultural
goods (pictures, books, dictionaries, instruments, machines, etc.), which are the trace or
realization of theories or critiques of these theories, problematics, etc.; and in
the institutionalized state, a form of objectification which must be set apart because, as
will be seen in the case of educational qualifications, it confers entirely original properties
on the cultural capital which it is presumed to guarantee (241-258).
Multilingualism and Cognition
Shift in research in the 1960s to 1980s:
Multilingual strengths in childhood:
• Flexibility
• Good at substitution
• Use of semantic cues
• Metalinguistic awareness
• Making corrections
Multilingual strengths in adulthood:
• Comparison of language rules
• Cognitive reserve
• Memory
• Abstract thinking
• Greater attention
Multilingualism and Education
Outcomes
Schooling
• Contradictory studies
related to grade point
average (GPA).
• Interpersonal
communication
• Conflict resolution
• Educational attainment
questions
• Word choice
• Code switching
• Memory, abstract thinking,
& attention
Multilingualism and Economic
Status
Globalisation
Advantages
• Multilingualism accepted
• Job market
• Promotes self-efficacy
Disadvantages
• Minority and tribal languages
• Impact on elderly, poor and
immigrants
• Dialect and “high” form of a
language
Multilingualism as Cultural Capital
Possibilities
• Language immersion programs
• Focus on literacy
• Multilingualism and multicultural
values
Impediments
• Political power of particular
languages
• Immigration and prejudice
• Lack of focused curriculum on
formal language
Works Cited
Alshenqeeti, Hamz and Naif Alsaedi. (2012). Is Multilingualism a Problem? The Effects of Multilingualism at the Societal
Level. Annual Review of Education, Communication and Language Sciences October 2012 Accessed at
http://connection.ebscohost.com/c/articles/88924968/multilingualism-problem-effects-multilingualism-societal-
level
Accessed at http://www.bu.edu/bucld/supplementvol37/
Bourdieu, Pierre. (1986). Forms of Capital. Numerous sources. Marxists.org
Budria, Santiago. (2014). The Impact of Multilingualism on Spanish Language Acquisition among Immigrants in Spain.
Accessed at http://www.iza.org/en/webcontent/publications/papers/viewAbstract?dp_id=8748
Doshi, Dev etal. (2012). Effects of Multilingualism on Cognition. Carnegie Mellon University. Accessed at
www.andrew.cmu.edu/.../ddoshi/.../ddoshi-la
Engel de Abrou, Pascale. (2011). Working Memory in Multilingual Children: Is There a Bilingual Effect? Memory. Accessed
at http://www.academia.edu/2047410/Working_memory_in_multilingual_children_Is_there_a_bilingual_effect
Gazzola, Michele. (2014). Language Policy and Linguistic Justice in the European Union: The Socio-Economic Effects of
Multilingualism. Economic Langues Formation. Humboldt-Universitat zu Berlin, Germany. Accessed at
www.elf.unige.ch
Grin, Francois et al. (2014). Mobility and Inclusion in Multilingual Europe: A Position Paper on the MIME Project. MIME
Kick-Off Conference, University of Geneva. Accessed at http://www.mime-
project.org/news/index.php?categories=Events
Hakuta, Kenji & Rafael M. Diaz. (1985). The Relationship Between Degree of Bilingualism and Cognitive Ability: A Critical
Discussion and Some New Longitudinal Data. In Children’s Languages, Vol. 5. Hillsdale, NJ: L. Erlbaum.
Kave, Gitit et al. (2008). Multilingualism and Cognitive State in the Oldest Old. Psychology and Aging, Vol. 23, No. 1,
70-78.
Kormos, Judit and Thom Kiddle. (2013). The Role of Socio-economic Factors in Motivation to Learn English as a Foreign
Language: The Case of Chile. Science Direct Accessed at http://www.academia.edu/4418185/The_role_of_socio-
economic_factors_in_learning_English_as_a_foreign_language
Kovalik, Alexandra. (2012). The Impact of Multilingualism on Grade Point Average among College Undergraduates.
Perspectives. Accessed at http://connection.ebscohost.com/c/articles/80029530/impact-multilingualism-grade-
point-average-among-college-undergraduates
Lindberg, Inger. (2007). Multilingual Education: a Swedish Perspective. Accessed at www.srii.org/content/.../66f9f6e9-
c2d7-47ab-8b37-c37c6fb1471a.pdf
Linck, Jared et al. (2014). Moving Beyond Two Languages: The Effects of Multilingualism on Language Processing and Language
Learning. Technical Details. University of Maryland Center for Advanced Study of Language.
Mallinson, Christine. (2007). Social Class, Social Sttus and Stratification: Revisiting Familiar Concepts in Sociolinguistics.
Selected Papers from NWAV 35 Volume 13 Issue 2.
Mohanty, Ajit K. (2006). Multilingualism of the Unequals and Predicaments of Education in India: Mother Tongue or Other
Tongue? Imagining Multilingual Schools Ofelia Garcia.
Palma, Helena Lopez. (2008). Aspects of Multilingualism in the Deocratic Republic of the Congo. In Conversarii: Dynamics
of Language Contact in the Twenty-first Century. Ed. Carla Vergaro. Perugia. 93-110.
Prediger, Susanne. (2013). Family Background or Language Disadvantages? Factors for Underachievement in High Stakes Tests. In
Proceeding of the 37th Conference of the International Group for the Psychology of Mathematics
Education, Vol. 4. 49-56. Kiel, Germany.
Schnelten, Eva-Maria. (2003). Multilingualism: Obligatory at First, Fun at Last. University of Gronigen. Accessed at
talen.wewi.eldoc.ub.rug.nl/.../multilingualism-ev.

More Related Content

What's hot

Societal multilingualism
Societal multilingualismSocietal multilingualism
Societal multilingualism
Winda Widia
 
Multilingual education
Multilingual educationMultilingual education
Multilingual education
Tugba Boz
 
Language policy in education.pptx
Language policy in education.pptxLanguage policy in education.pptx
Language policy in education.pptx
MonojitGope
 
Issues in first language acquisition
Issues in first language acquisitionIssues in first language acquisition
Issues in first language acquisition
shayma Saleem
 
Language Planning and Language Policy
Language Planning and Language PolicyLanguage Planning and Language Policy
Language Planning and Language Policy
bobcharley
 
Chomsky LAD and UG
Chomsky LAD and UGChomsky LAD and UG
Chomsky LAD and UG
Safna KV
 
Language Acquisition Device; Noam Chomsky
Language Acquisition Device; Noam ChomskyLanguage Acquisition Device; Noam Chomsky
Language Acquisition Device; Noam Chomsky
Google, Facebook, Twitter, Hotmail
 
Language Policy
Language PolicyLanguage Policy
Language Policy
Aiden Yeh
 
Factors that influence second language acquisition and learning
Factors that influence second language acquisition and learningFactors that influence second language acquisition and learning
Factors that influence second language acquisition and learning
lislieroyo1
 
Code switching-reason
Code switching-reasonCode switching-reason
Code switching-reason
STATE UNIVERSITY OF BANGLADESH
 
Sapir Whorf hypothesis
Sapir Whorf hypothesisSapir Whorf hypothesis
Sapir Whorf hypothesisAhmet Ateş
 
Codeswitching by KRISHNAKSHI THAKURIA
Codeswitching by KRISHNAKSHI THAKURIACodeswitching by KRISHNAKSHI THAKURIA
Codeswitching by KRISHNAKSHI THAKURIAKrishnakshi Thakuria
 
Critical period hypothesis
Critical period hypothesisCritical period hypothesis
Critical period hypothesis
Narottam Sharma
 
DISCOURSE AND POWER
DISCOURSE AND POWERDISCOURSE AND POWER
DISCOURSE AND POWER
CDAGCUF
 
Theories of Language Learning
Theories of Language LearningTheories of Language Learning
Theories of Language Learning
Gaby LLaneza
 
Nativist theory
Nativist theoryNativist theory
Nativist theory
Maizatul Malik
 
Language and society
Language and societyLanguage and society
Language and society
ShainiVarghese
 
Language policy and planning
Language policy and planningLanguage policy and planning
Language policy and planning
Carlos Mayora
 
Multilingual
MultilingualMultilingual
Multilingual
sgur1212
 
Gardner’s socio educational model.
Gardner’s socio educational model.Gardner’s socio educational model.
Gardner’s socio educational model.Nabeela Taimur Ali
 

What's hot (20)

Societal multilingualism
Societal multilingualismSocietal multilingualism
Societal multilingualism
 
Multilingual education
Multilingual educationMultilingual education
Multilingual education
 
Language policy in education.pptx
Language policy in education.pptxLanguage policy in education.pptx
Language policy in education.pptx
 
Issues in first language acquisition
Issues in first language acquisitionIssues in first language acquisition
Issues in first language acquisition
 
Language Planning and Language Policy
Language Planning and Language PolicyLanguage Planning and Language Policy
Language Planning and Language Policy
 
Chomsky LAD and UG
Chomsky LAD and UGChomsky LAD and UG
Chomsky LAD and UG
 
Language Acquisition Device; Noam Chomsky
Language Acquisition Device; Noam ChomskyLanguage Acquisition Device; Noam Chomsky
Language Acquisition Device; Noam Chomsky
 
Language Policy
Language PolicyLanguage Policy
Language Policy
 
Factors that influence second language acquisition and learning
Factors that influence second language acquisition and learningFactors that influence second language acquisition and learning
Factors that influence second language acquisition and learning
 
Code switching-reason
Code switching-reasonCode switching-reason
Code switching-reason
 
Sapir Whorf hypothesis
Sapir Whorf hypothesisSapir Whorf hypothesis
Sapir Whorf hypothesis
 
Codeswitching by KRISHNAKSHI THAKURIA
Codeswitching by KRISHNAKSHI THAKURIACodeswitching by KRISHNAKSHI THAKURIA
Codeswitching by KRISHNAKSHI THAKURIA
 
Critical period hypothesis
Critical period hypothesisCritical period hypothesis
Critical period hypothesis
 
DISCOURSE AND POWER
DISCOURSE AND POWERDISCOURSE AND POWER
DISCOURSE AND POWER
 
Theories of Language Learning
Theories of Language LearningTheories of Language Learning
Theories of Language Learning
 
Nativist theory
Nativist theoryNativist theory
Nativist theory
 
Language and society
Language and societyLanguage and society
Language and society
 
Language policy and planning
Language policy and planningLanguage policy and planning
Language policy and planning
 
Multilingual
MultilingualMultilingual
Multilingual
 
Gardner’s socio educational model.
Gardner’s socio educational model.Gardner’s socio educational model.
Gardner’s socio educational model.
 

Similar to Multilingualism, Education, and Economy (1)

Educ 6 lesson 2.pptx
Educ 6 lesson 2.pptxEduc 6 lesson 2.pptx
Educ 6 lesson 2.pptx
rodeldbriones
 
ICYGH 2014 (Uploaded)
ICYGH 2014 (Uploaded)ICYGH 2014 (Uploaded)
ICYGH 2014 (Uploaded)Oxana Rosca
 
The Intercultural Being: Fostering Cross-Cultural Interactions in a Globalize...
The Intercultural Being: Fostering Cross-Cultural Interactions in a Globalize...The Intercultural Being: Fostering Cross-Cultural Interactions in a Globalize...
The Intercultural Being: Fostering Cross-Cultural Interactions in a Globalize...
Amanda M. Bent
 
Developing intercultural competence
Developing intercultural competenceDeveloping intercultural competence
Developing intercultural competence
Yamith José Fandiño Parra
 
New-Literacies-Globalization_Cultural_and_Multicultural.pdf
New-Literacies-Globalization_Cultural_and_Multicultural.pdfNew-Literacies-Globalization_Cultural_and_Multicultural.pdf
New-Literacies-Globalization_Cultural_and_Multicultural.pdf
onaagonoy
 
Re-imagining Culture in TESOL
Re-imagining Culture in TESOLRe-imagining Culture in TESOL
Re-imagining Culture in TESOL
William Eggington
 
Language or languages ?
Language or languages ?Language or languages ?
Language or languages ?
Dr. Seyed Hossein Fazeli
 
Silvana baroni powerpoint 1
Silvana baroni powerpoint 1Silvana baroni powerpoint 1
Silvana baroni powerpoint 1aurelia garcia
 
Teramo 2016
Teramo 2016Teramo 2016
Teramo 2016
cincol
 
Linguistic Landscape and its Implications for Language Teaching
Linguistic Landscape and its Implications for Language TeachingLinguistic Landscape and its Implications for Language Teaching
Linguistic Landscape and its Implications for Language Teaching
Dave Malinowski
 
Integrating global issues in genre based approach
Integrating global issues in genre based approachIntegrating global issues in genre based approach
Integrating global issues in genre based approachTitik Winarti
 
Critical Issue: Diversity in Education
Critical Issue: Diversity in EducationCritical Issue: Diversity in Education
Critical Issue: Diversity in Educationlinaazzam
 
Geert Driessen (2001) IRE Ethnicity, forms of capital, and educational achiev...
Geert Driessen (2001) IRE Ethnicity, forms of capital, and educational achiev...Geert Driessen (2001) IRE Ethnicity, forms of capital, and educational achiev...
Geert Driessen (2001) IRE Ethnicity, forms of capital, and educational achiev...
Driessen Research
 
Hani shakir - Internationalization
Hani shakir - Internationalization Hani shakir - Internationalization
Hani shakir - Internationalization
Hani Shakir
 
E-learning and intercultural dimensions of learning theories and teaching models
E-learning and intercultural dimensions of learning theories and teaching modelsE-learning and intercultural dimensions of learning theories and teaching models
E-learning and intercultural dimensions of learning theories and teaching models
eLearning Papers
 
Teramo 2016
Teramo 2016Teramo 2016
Teramo 2016
cincol
 
Multilingualism as Cultural Capital
Multilingualism as Cultural CapitalMultilingualism as Cultural Capital
Multilingualism as Cultural CapitalDonna Confere
 
Slide 5
Slide 5Slide 5
iceri2021-gc-bilingual
iceri2021-gc-bilingualiceri2021-gc-bilingual
iceri2021-gc-bilingual
Vitor Gonçalves
 

Similar to Multilingualism, Education, and Economy (1) (20)

Educ 6 lesson 2.pptx
Educ 6 lesson 2.pptxEduc 6 lesson 2.pptx
Educ 6 lesson 2.pptx
 
ICYGH 2014 (Uploaded)
ICYGH 2014 (Uploaded)ICYGH 2014 (Uploaded)
ICYGH 2014 (Uploaded)
 
The Intercultural Being: Fostering Cross-Cultural Interactions in a Globalize...
The Intercultural Being: Fostering Cross-Cultural Interactions in a Globalize...The Intercultural Being: Fostering Cross-Cultural Interactions in a Globalize...
The Intercultural Being: Fostering Cross-Cultural Interactions in a Globalize...
 
Developing intercultural competence
Developing intercultural competenceDeveloping intercultural competence
Developing intercultural competence
 
New-Literacies-Globalization_Cultural_and_Multicultural.pdf
New-Literacies-Globalization_Cultural_and_Multicultural.pdfNew-Literacies-Globalization_Cultural_and_Multicultural.pdf
New-Literacies-Globalization_Cultural_and_Multicultural.pdf
 
Re-imagining Culture in TESOL
Re-imagining Culture in TESOLRe-imagining Culture in TESOL
Re-imagining Culture in TESOL
 
Language or languages ?
Language or languages ?Language or languages ?
Language or languages ?
 
Silvana baroni powerpoint 1
Silvana baroni powerpoint 1Silvana baroni powerpoint 1
Silvana baroni powerpoint 1
 
Teramo 2016
Teramo 2016Teramo 2016
Teramo 2016
 
Linguistic Landscape and its Implications for Language Teaching
Linguistic Landscape and its Implications for Language TeachingLinguistic Landscape and its Implications for Language Teaching
Linguistic Landscape and its Implications for Language Teaching
 
Integrating global issues in genre based approach
Integrating global issues in genre based approachIntegrating global issues in genre based approach
Integrating global issues in genre based approach
 
343 week 3
343 week 3 343 week 3
343 week 3
 
Critical Issue: Diversity in Education
Critical Issue: Diversity in EducationCritical Issue: Diversity in Education
Critical Issue: Diversity in Education
 
Geert Driessen (2001) IRE Ethnicity, forms of capital, and educational achiev...
Geert Driessen (2001) IRE Ethnicity, forms of capital, and educational achiev...Geert Driessen (2001) IRE Ethnicity, forms of capital, and educational achiev...
Geert Driessen (2001) IRE Ethnicity, forms of capital, and educational achiev...
 
Hani shakir - Internationalization
Hani shakir - Internationalization Hani shakir - Internationalization
Hani shakir - Internationalization
 
E-learning and intercultural dimensions of learning theories and teaching models
E-learning and intercultural dimensions of learning theories and teaching modelsE-learning and intercultural dimensions of learning theories and teaching models
E-learning and intercultural dimensions of learning theories and teaching models
 
Teramo 2016
Teramo 2016Teramo 2016
Teramo 2016
 
Multilingualism as Cultural Capital
Multilingualism as Cultural CapitalMultilingualism as Cultural Capital
Multilingualism as Cultural Capital
 
Slide 5
Slide 5Slide 5
Slide 5
 
iceri2021-gc-bilingual
iceri2021-gc-bilingualiceri2021-gc-bilingual
iceri2021-gc-bilingual
 

Multilingualism, Education, and Economy (1)

  • 1. Multilingualism as Cultural Capital? Study of Studies Donna L. Confere
  • 2. Objectives • To determine if there is a correlation between multilingualism and cognitive ability. • To determine if multilingualism translates into higher grades and greater academic achievement. • To determine if the number of languages in which a person has achieved proficiency impacts their economic advancement, stability, and status.
  • 3. Cultural Capital • Pierre Bourdieu (1986) The Forms of Capital: • Cultural capital can exist in three forms: in the embodied state, i.e., in the form of long- lasting dispositions of the mind and body; in the objectified state, in the form of cultural goods (pictures, books, dictionaries, instruments, machines, etc.), which are the trace or realization of theories or critiques of these theories, problematics, etc.; and in the institutionalized state, a form of objectification which must be set apart because, as will be seen in the case of educational qualifications, it confers entirely original properties on the cultural capital which it is presumed to guarantee (241-258).
  • 5. Shift in research in the 1960s to 1980s: Multilingual strengths in childhood: • Flexibility • Good at substitution • Use of semantic cues • Metalinguistic awareness • Making corrections Multilingual strengths in adulthood: • Comparison of language rules • Cognitive reserve • Memory • Abstract thinking • Greater attention
  • 7. Schooling • Contradictory studies related to grade point average (GPA). • Interpersonal communication • Conflict resolution • Educational attainment questions • Word choice • Code switching • Memory, abstract thinking, & attention
  • 9. Globalisation Advantages • Multilingualism accepted • Job market • Promotes self-efficacy Disadvantages • Minority and tribal languages • Impact on elderly, poor and immigrants • Dialect and “high” form of a language
  • 10. Multilingualism as Cultural Capital Possibilities • Language immersion programs • Focus on literacy • Multilingualism and multicultural values Impediments • Political power of particular languages • Immigration and prejudice • Lack of focused curriculum on formal language
  • 11. Works Cited Alshenqeeti, Hamz and Naif Alsaedi. (2012). Is Multilingualism a Problem? The Effects of Multilingualism at the Societal Level. Annual Review of Education, Communication and Language Sciences October 2012 Accessed at http://connection.ebscohost.com/c/articles/88924968/multilingualism-problem-effects-multilingualism-societal- level Accessed at http://www.bu.edu/bucld/supplementvol37/ Bourdieu, Pierre. (1986). Forms of Capital. Numerous sources. Marxists.org Budria, Santiago. (2014). The Impact of Multilingualism on Spanish Language Acquisition among Immigrants in Spain. Accessed at http://www.iza.org/en/webcontent/publications/papers/viewAbstract?dp_id=8748 Doshi, Dev etal. (2012). Effects of Multilingualism on Cognition. Carnegie Mellon University. Accessed at www.andrew.cmu.edu/.../ddoshi/.../ddoshi-la Engel de Abrou, Pascale. (2011). Working Memory in Multilingual Children: Is There a Bilingual Effect? Memory. Accessed at http://www.academia.edu/2047410/Working_memory_in_multilingual_children_Is_there_a_bilingual_effect Gazzola, Michele. (2014). Language Policy and Linguistic Justice in the European Union: The Socio-Economic Effects of Multilingualism. Economic Langues Formation. Humboldt-Universitat zu Berlin, Germany. Accessed at www.elf.unige.ch Grin, Francois et al. (2014). Mobility and Inclusion in Multilingual Europe: A Position Paper on the MIME Project. MIME Kick-Off Conference, University of Geneva. Accessed at http://www.mime- project.org/news/index.php?categories=Events
  • 12. Hakuta, Kenji & Rafael M. Diaz. (1985). The Relationship Between Degree of Bilingualism and Cognitive Ability: A Critical Discussion and Some New Longitudinal Data. In Children’s Languages, Vol. 5. Hillsdale, NJ: L. Erlbaum. Kave, Gitit et al. (2008). Multilingualism and Cognitive State in the Oldest Old. Psychology and Aging, Vol. 23, No. 1, 70-78. Kormos, Judit and Thom Kiddle. (2013). The Role of Socio-economic Factors in Motivation to Learn English as a Foreign Language: The Case of Chile. Science Direct Accessed at http://www.academia.edu/4418185/The_role_of_socio- economic_factors_in_learning_English_as_a_foreign_language Kovalik, Alexandra. (2012). The Impact of Multilingualism on Grade Point Average among College Undergraduates. Perspectives. Accessed at http://connection.ebscohost.com/c/articles/80029530/impact-multilingualism-grade- point-average-among-college-undergraduates Lindberg, Inger. (2007). Multilingual Education: a Swedish Perspective. Accessed at www.srii.org/content/.../66f9f6e9- c2d7-47ab-8b37-c37c6fb1471a.pdf Linck, Jared et al. (2014). Moving Beyond Two Languages: The Effects of Multilingualism on Language Processing and Language Learning. Technical Details. University of Maryland Center for Advanced Study of Language.
  • 13. Mallinson, Christine. (2007). Social Class, Social Sttus and Stratification: Revisiting Familiar Concepts in Sociolinguistics. Selected Papers from NWAV 35 Volume 13 Issue 2. Mohanty, Ajit K. (2006). Multilingualism of the Unequals and Predicaments of Education in India: Mother Tongue or Other Tongue? Imagining Multilingual Schools Ofelia Garcia. Palma, Helena Lopez. (2008). Aspects of Multilingualism in the Deocratic Republic of the Congo. In Conversarii: Dynamics of Language Contact in the Twenty-first Century. Ed. Carla Vergaro. Perugia. 93-110. Prediger, Susanne. (2013). Family Background or Language Disadvantages? Factors for Underachievement in High Stakes Tests. In Proceeding of the 37th Conference of the International Group for the Psychology of Mathematics Education, Vol. 4. 49-56. Kiel, Germany. Schnelten, Eva-Maria. (2003). Multilingualism: Obligatory at First, Fun at Last. University of Gronigen. Accessed at talen.wewi.eldoc.ub.rug.nl/.../multilingualism-ev.