Prof. M.R.Ezhilkumar
Assistant Professor
Department of Civil Engineering
Sri Krishna College of Engineering and Technology
Coimbatore
ezhilkumar@skcet.ac.in
I only feel angry when I see waste.
When I see people throwing away
things we could use. – Mother
Teresa
1
17CE413
SOLID AND HAZARDOUS
WASTE MANAGEMENT
3.2 – Site selection
SHWM – Module 3 – SANITARY LANDFILL AND HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGEMENT  Mr.M.R.Ezhilkumar 2
Learning Outcomes
☼ Landfill site selection guidelines and criteria's to follow
3.2 – Site selection
SHWM – Module 3 – SANITARY LANDFILL AND HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGEMENT  Mr.M.R.Ezhilkumar 3
Video Session
SHWM – Module 3 – SANITARY LANDFILL AND HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGEMENT  Mr.M.R.Ezhilkumar 4
Landfill site selection
SHWM – Module 3 – SANITARY LANDFILL AND HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGEMENT  Mr.M.R.Ezhilkumar 5
Landfill site selection
LANDFILL COMES LAST IN THE WASTE MANAGEMENT HIERARCHY
• Large Land Required.
• High Capital Costs for Landfill facility
• Valuable Resource is buried.
• Potential for ground water contamination and Air pollution
• Capital, O&M Costs of leachate treatment.
SHWM – Module 3 – SANITARY LANDFILL AND HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGEMENT  Mr.M.R.Ezhilkumar 6
Landfill site selection
Landfill is still the dominant MSW disposal practice,even in the developed
world
SHWM – Module 3 – SANITARY LANDFILL AND HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGEMENT  Mr.M.R.Ezhilkumar 7
Landfill site selection
SHWM – Module 3 – SANITARY LANDFILL AND HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGEMENT  Mr.M.R.Ezhilkumar 8
Landfill site selection
SHWM – Module 3 – SANITARY LANDFILL AND HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGEMENT  Mr.M.R.Ezhilkumar 9
Landfill site selection
LANDFILL COMPONENT REQUIREMENTS VARY
Depend on the characteristics of the waste, method of operation and nature of
the landfill site
• Inert landfills
• Sanitary landfills -MSW
• Secure landfills - HW
• Monofills
• Bioreactor landfills
• Sustainable landfills
• Excavated and filled
• Excavation/Trench method
• Built up from the ground
• Area method
• Fill existing depressions
• Canyon/depression method
• A combination of above
SHWM – Module 3 – SANITARY LANDFILL AND HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGEMENT  Mr.M.R.Ezhilkumar 10
Landfill site selection
Landfill Siting - the first and most important consideration
• Prevention of environmental impacts
• Reducing the cost of:
• Design and Construction
• Operation
• Maintenance
• Mostly controversial
• NIMBY/NIMFY : Not In My Back/Front Yard Syndrome
• Time consuming
SHWM – Module 3 – SANITARY LANDFILL AND HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGEMENT  Mr.M.R.Ezhilkumar 11
Landfill site selection
LANDFILL SITING – SEVERAL CONSIDERATIONS
• Haul Distance
• Close to waste generation from an engineering point of view;
• Location Restrictions
• airports, flood plains, wetlands
• Available Land
• perhaps for 25 years/min. for 15 years
• Site Access/Infrastructure
• capacity of the road network
• minimize passing of residences; proximity to railroad lines for long hauls.
SHWM – Module 3 – SANITARY LANDFILL AND HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGEMENT  Mr.M.R.Ezhilkumar 12
Landfill site selection
LANDFILL SITING – SEVERAL CONSIDERATIONS
• Soil Conditions and Topography
• cover material and excavation
• Climatological
• precipitation/evaporation for drainage and leachate control, prevailing winds for
litter and dust control
SHWM – Module 3 – SANITARY LANDFILL AND HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGEMENT  Mr.M.R.Ezhilkumar 13
Landfill site selection
LANDFILL SITING – SEVERAL CONSIDERATIONS
• Geologic and Hydrogeologic Conditions (Most important environmental
considerations)
• Ground water – Min. 2m above max. GWL
• Surface water – Wetlands, flood plains, water supply catchments
• Flora and Fauna – Avoid critical habitats
• Land ownership
• Community needs
• Ultimate use for completed landfills
• Buffer distances
SHWM – Module 3 – SANITARY LANDFILL AND HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGEMENT  Mr.M.R.Ezhilkumar 14
Landfill site selection
Stages of a Landfill Sitting Process
• Define project and its needs
• Identify major environmental factors
• Identify candidate sites
• Collect and analyze environmental, economic, and socioeconomic data
• Evaluate candidates sites
• Screen candidate sites to a small number
• Collect and assess site-specific engineering and environmental data
• Decision making
Mapping of constraints
Short-listing of
potential sites
investigation on preferred sites
Ranking of sites
Final decision based on EIA and Public
Consultation
SHWM – Module 3 – SANITARY LANDFILL AND HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGEMENT  Mr.M.R.Ezhilkumar 15
Landfill site selection
LANDFILL LOCATION-EXCLUSION CRITERIA
1. Lake or Pond > 200 m
2. River > 100 m
3. Flood Plain – Should not be built
4. Highway > 500 m from SH/ NH
5. Habitation > 500 m – Notified
Habitation
6. Public Parks > 500 m
7. Critical Habitat – Should not be built
– Endangered Species
8. Wetlands – Should not be built
9. Airports – As per Aviation Authority >
10 Kms
10. Water Supply Well > 500 m
11. Coastal Regulation Zone – Should
not be built
12. Groundwater Level > 2m from base
of landfill
SHWM – Module 3 – SANITARY LANDFILL AND HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGEMENT  Mr.M.R.Ezhilkumar 16
Landfill site selection
Ranking of MSW Landfill sites - Attribute Weightage and Sensitivity
Guidelines
SHWM – Module 3 – SANITARY LANDFILL AND HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGEMENT  Mr.M.R.Ezhilkumar 17
Landfill site selection
Ranking of MSW Landfill sites - Attribute Weightage and Sensitivity
Guidelines
SHWM – Module 3 – SANITARY LANDFILL AND HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGEMENT  Mr.M.R.Ezhilkumar 18
Landfill site selection
Ranking of MSW Landfill sites - Attribute Weightage and Sensitivity
Guidelines
SHWM – Module 3 – SANITARY LANDFILL AND HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGEMENT  Mr.M.R.Ezhilkumar 19
Landfill site selection
Ranking of MSW Landfill sites - Attribute Weightage and Sensitivity
Guidelines
SHWM – Module 3 – SANITARY LANDFILL AND HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGEMENT  Mr.M.R.Ezhilkumar 20
Landfill site selection
Ranking of MSW Landfill sites - Attribute Weightage and Sensitivity
Guidelines
SHWM – Module 3 – SANITARY LANDFILL AND HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGEMENT  Mr.M.R.Ezhilkumar 21
Landfill site selection
Ranking of MSW Landfill sites - Attribute Weightage and Sensitivity
Guidelines
SHWM – Module 3 – SANITARY LANDFILL AND HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGEMENT  Mr.M.R.Ezhilkumar 22
Landfill site selection
SITE EVALUATION BASED ON THE AGGREGATE SCORE
Preferred location:
1. Low Population
2. Low Alternate Land use
3. Low Groundwater contamination Potential
4. Low Permeable Soils
5. Proximity to Waste generators
6. Minimum Rainfall
7. Not Sensitive Areas
SHWM – Module 3 – SANITARY LANDFILL AND HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGEMENT  Mr.M.R.Ezhilkumar 23
Landfill site selection
ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT PROCESS
SHWM – Module 3 – SANITARY LANDFILL AND HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGEMENT  Mr.M.R.Ezhilkumar 24
Landfill site selection
Extensive Data to be considered
• Topo Maps
• Soil Maps
• Land Use Plans
• Transportation Maps
• Water Use Plans
• Flood Plain Maps
• Geological Maps
• Aerial Photographs
• Groundwater Maps
• Rainfall Data
• Wind Map
• Seismic Data
SHWM – Module 3 – SANITARY LANDFILL AND HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGEMENT  Mr.M.R.Ezhilkumar 25
Landfill site selection
Extensive Data to be considered
• Subsoil Investigation – Geophysical: Stratification, GW Table and Bedrock, Soil
Properties
• Groundwater/Hydrogeological Investigation
• Depth to GW, GW flow direction, Baseline information
• 3 Boreholes per Hectare of landfill area upto 15m beneath base of landfill
• Topographical Investigation: 0.3 m interval
• Hydrological Investigation: Runoff water planning
• Geological and Seismic Investigation: Bedrock Profile, specially in hilly and rocky
areas
SHWM – Module 3 – SANITARY LANDFILL AND HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGEMENT  Mr.M.R.Ezhilkumar 26
Landfill site selection
SHWM – Module 3 – SANITARY LANDFILL AND HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGEMENT  Mr.M.R.Ezhilkumar 27
Landfill site selection
It is not enough that the best site is chosen
• A buffer zone of No-Development should be declared and enforced
• in the land-use plans, to prevent objections by future neighbours in later years
before the site life is exhausted.
• Landfill facilities should:
• minimise potential environmental impacts;
• minimise health and safety risks for landfill operators and the public and
• make the most efficient use of resources onsite
SHWM – Module 3 – SANITARY LANDFILL AND HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGEMENT  Mr.M.R.Ezhilkumar 28
Landfill site selection
Essential Components of Landfills to focus
1. The liner system at the base and sides of the landfill prevents migration of
leachate or gas to the surrounding environment.
2. The leachate collection and treatment system collects and extracts
leachate from within and from the base of the landfill and treats to meet
regulatory requirements.
3. Landfill Gas management System (Optional)
4. The final cover of the landfill enhances surface drainage, prevents infiltration
of water and supports surface vegetation.
SHWM – Module 3 – SANITARY LANDFILL AND HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGEMENT  Mr.M.R.Ezhilkumar 29
Landfill site selection
Essential Components of Landfills to focus
5. The surface water drainage system collects and removes all surface runoff
from the landfill site.
6. The environmental monitoring system periodically collects and analyses
air, surface water, soil and ground water samples around the landfill site.
SHWM – Module 3 – SANITARY LANDFILL AND HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGEMENT  Mr.M.R.Ezhilkumar 30
Landfill site selection
INCORPORATE OPERATIONAL BEST PRACTICES
• Environmental improvement
• Financial assurance: after care
and remedial action
• Waste minimisation
• Waste acceptance
• Waste pre-treatment
• Waste placement
• Waste cover
• Litter control
• Fire control
• Contingency planning
• Performance monitoring and
reporting
SHWM – Module 3 – SANITARY LANDFILL AND HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGEMENT  Mr.M.R.Ezhilkumar 31
Assessment Time
Review
Question Recommend a suitable landfill location in Coimbatore region
based on the criteria for selection.
SHWM – Module 3 – SANITARY LANDFILL AND HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGEMENT  Mr.M.R.Ezhilkumar 32

Landfill Site selection

  • 1.
    Prof. M.R.Ezhilkumar Assistant Professor Departmentof Civil Engineering Sri Krishna College of Engineering and Technology Coimbatore ezhilkumar@skcet.ac.in I only feel angry when I see waste. When I see people throwing away things we could use. – Mother Teresa 1 17CE413 SOLID AND HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGEMENT 3.2 – Site selection
  • 2.
    SHWM – Module3 – SANITARY LANDFILL AND HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGEMENT  Mr.M.R.Ezhilkumar 2 Learning Outcomes ☼ Landfill site selection guidelines and criteria's to follow 3.2 – Site selection
  • 3.
    SHWM – Module3 – SANITARY LANDFILL AND HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGEMENT  Mr.M.R.Ezhilkumar 3 Video Session
  • 4.
    SHWM – Module3 – SANITARY LANDFILL AND HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGEMENT  Mr.M.R.Ezhilkumar 4 Landfill site selection
  • 5.
    SHWM – Module3 – SANITARY LANDFILL AND HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGEMENT  Mr.M.R.Ezhilkumar 5 Landfill site selection LANDFILL COMES LAST IN THE WASTE MANAGEMENT HIERARCHY • Large Land Required. • High Capital Costs for Landfill facility • Valuable Resource is buried. • Potential for ground water contamination and Air pollution • Capital, O&M Costs of leachate treatment.
  • 6.
    SHWM – Module3 – SANITARY LANDFILL AND HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGEMENT  Mr.M.R.Ezhilkumar 6 Landfill site selection Landfill is still the dominant MSW disposal practice,even in the developed world
  • 7.
    SHWM – Module3 – SANITARY LANDFILL AND HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGEMENT  Mr.M.R.Ezhilkumar 7 Landfill site selection
  • 8.
    SHWM – Module3 – SANITARY LANDFILL AND HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGEMENT  Mr.M.R.Ezhilkumar 8 Landfill site selection
  • 9.
    SHWM – Module3 – SANITARY LANDFILL AND HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGEMENT  Mr.M.R.Ezhilkumar 9 Landfill site selection LANDFILL COMPONENT REQUIREMENTS VARY Depend on the characteristics of the waste, method of operation and nature of the landfill site • Inert landfills • Sanitary landfills -MSW • Secure landfills - HW • Monofills • Bioreactor landfills • Sustainable landfills • Excavated and filled • Excavation/Trench method • Built up from the ground • Area method • Fill existing depressions • Canyon/depression method • A combination of above
  • 10.
    SHWM – Module3 – SANITARY LANDFILL AND HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGEMENT  Mr.M.R.Ezhilkumar 10 Landfill site selection Landfill Siting - the first and most important consideration • Prevention of environmental impacts • Reducing the cost of: • Design and Construction • Operation • Maintenance • Mostly controversial • NIMBY/NIMFY : Not In My Back/Front Yard Syndrome • Time consuming
  • 11.
    SHWM – Module3 – SANITARY LANDFILL AND HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGEMENT  Mr.M.R.Ezhilkumar 11 Landfill site selection LANDFILL SITING – SEVERAL CONSIDERATIONS • Haul Distance • Close to waste generation from an engineering point of view; • Location Restrictions • airports, flood plains, wetlands • Available Land • perhaps for 25 years/min. for 15 years • Site Access/Infrastructure • capacity of the road network • minimize passing of residences; proximity to railroad lines for long hauls.
  • 12.
    SHWM – Module3 – SANITARY LANDFILL AND HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGEMENT  Mr.M.R.Ezhilkumar 12 Landfill site selection LANDFILL SITING – SEVERAL CONSIDERATIONS • Soil Conditions and Topography • cover material and excavation • Climatological • precipitation/evaporation for drainage and leachate control, prevailing winds for litter and dust control
  • 13.
    SHWM – Module3 – SANITARY LANDFILL AND HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGEMENT  Mr.M.R.Ezhilkumar 13 Landfill site selection LANDFILL SITING – SEVERAL CONSIDERATIONS • Geologic and Hydrogeologic Conditions (Most important environmental considerations) • Ground water – Min. 2m above max. GWL • Surface water – Wetlands, flood plains, water supply catchments • Flora and Fauna – Avoid critical habitats • Land ownership • Community needs • Ultimate use for completed landfills • Buffer distances
  • 14.
    SHWM – Module3 – SANITARY LANDFILL AND HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGEMENT  Mr.M.R.Ezhilkumar 14 Landfill site selection Stages of a Landfill Sitting Process • Define project and its needs • Identify major environmental factors • Identify candidate sites • Collect and analyze environmental, economic, and socioeconomic data • Evaluate candidates sites • Screen candidate sites to a small number • Collect and assess site-specific engineering and environmental data • Decision making Mapping of constraints Short-listing of potential sites investigation on preferred sites Ranking of sites Final decision based on EIA and Public Consultation
  • 15.
    SHWM – Module3 – SANITARY LANDFILL AND HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGEMENT  Mr.M.R.Ezhilkumar 15 Landfill site selection LANDFILL LOCATION-EXCLUSION CRITERIA 1. Lake or Pond > 200 m 2. River > 100 m 3. Flood Plain – Should not be built 4. Highway > 500 m from SH/ NH 5. Habitation > 500 m – Notified Habitation 6. Public Parks > 500 m 7. Critical Habitat – Should not be built – Endangered Species 8. Wetlands – Should not be built 9. Airports – As per Aviation Authority > 10 Kms 10. Water Supply Well > 500 m 11. Coastal Regulation Zone – Should not be built 12. Groundwater Level > 2m from base of landfill
  • 16.
    SHWM – Module3 – SANITARY LANDFILL AND HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGEMENT  Mr.M.R.Ezhilkumar 16 Landfill site selection Ranking of MSW Landfill sites - Attribute Weightage and Sensitivity Guidelines
  • 17.
    SHWM – Module3 – SANITARY LANDFILL AND HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGEMENT  Mr.M.R.Ezhilkumar 17 Landfill site selection Ranking of MSW Landfill sites - Attribute Weightage and Sensitivity Guidelines
  • 18.
    SHWM – Module3 – SANITARY LANDFILL AND HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGEMENT  Mr.M.R.Ezhilkumar 18 Landfill site selection Ranking of MSW Landfill sites - Attribute Weightage and Sensitivity Guidelines
  • 19.
    SHWM – Module3 – SANITARY LANDFILL AND HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGEMENT  Mr.M.R.Ezhilkumar 19 Landfill site selection Ranking of MSW Landfill sites - Attribute Weightage and Sensitivity Guidelines
  • 20.
    SHWM – Module3 – SANITARY LANDFILL AND HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGEMENT  Mr.M.R.Ezhilkumar 20 Landfill site selection Ranking of MSW Landfill sites - Attribute Weightage and Sensitivity Guidelines
  • 21.
    SHWM – Module3 – SANITARY LANDFILL AND HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGEMENT  Mr.M.R.Ezhilkumar 21 Landfill site selection Ranking of MSW Landfill sites - Attribute Weightage and Sensitivity Guidelines
  • 22.
    SHWM – Module3 – SANITARY LANDFILL AND HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGEMENT  Mr.M.R.Ezhilkumar 22 Landfill site selection SITE EVALUATION BASED ON THE AGGREGATE SCORE Preferred location: 1. Low Population 2. Low Alternate Land use 3. Low Groundwater contamination Potential 4. Low Permeable Soils 5. Proximity to Waste generators 6. Minimum Rainfall 7. Not Sensitive Areas
  • 23.
    SHWM – Module3 – SANITARY LANDFILL AND HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGEMENT  Mr.M.R.Ezhilkumar 23 Landfill site selection ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT PROCESS
  • 24.
    SHWM – Module3 – SANITARY LANDFILL AND HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGEMENT  Mr.M.R.Ezhilkumar 24 Landfill site selection Extensive Data to be considered • Topo Maps • Soil Maps • Land Use Plans • Transportation Maps • Water Use Plans • Flood Plain Maps • Geological Maps • Aerial Photographs • Groundwater Maps • Rainfall Data • Wind Map • Seismic Data
  • 25.
    SHWM – Module3 – SANITARY LANDFILL AND HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGEMENT  Mr.M.R.Ezhilkumar 25 Landfill site selection Extensive Data to be considered • Subsoil Investigation – Geophysical: Stratification, GW Table and Bedrock, Soil Properties • Groundwater/Hydrogeological Investigation • Depth to GW, GW flow direction, Baseline information • 3 Boreholes per Hectare of landfill area upto 15m beneath base of landfill • Topographical Investigation: 0.3 m interval • Hydrological Investigation: Runoff water planning • Geological and Seismic Investigation: Bedrock Profile, specially in hilly and rocky areas
  • 26.
    SHWM – Module3 – SANITARY LANDFILL AND HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGEMENT  Mr.M.R.Ezhilkumar 26 Landfill site selection
  • 27.
    SHWM – Module3 – SANITARY LANDFILL AND HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGEMENT  Mr.M.R.Ezhilkumar 27 Landfill site selection It is not enough that the best site is chosen • A buffer zone of No-Development should be declared and enforced • in the land-use plans, to prevent objections by future neighbours in later years before the site life is exhausted. • Landfill facilities should: • minimise potential environmental impacts; • minimise health and safety risks for landfill operators and the public and • make the most efficient use of resources onsite
  • 28.
    SHWM – Module3 – SANITARY LANDFILL AND HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGEMENT  Mr.M.R.Ezhilkumar 28 Landfill site selection Essential Components of Landfills to focus 1. The liner system at the base and sides of the landfill prevents migration of leachate or gas to the surrounding environment. 2. The leachate collection and treatment system collects and extracts leachate from within and from the base of the landfill and treats to meet regulatory requirements. 3. Landfill Gas management System (Optional) 4. The final cover of the landfill enhances surface drainage, prevents infiltration of water and supports surface vegetation.
  • 29.
    SHWM – Module3 – SANITARY LANDFILL AND HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGEMENT  Mr.M.R.Ezhilkumar 29 Landfill site selection Essential Components of Landfills to focus 5. The surface water drainage system collects and removes all surface runoff from the landfill site. 6. The environmental monitoring system periodically collects and analyses air, surface water, soil and ground water samples around the landfill site.
  • 30.
    SHWM – Module3 – SANITARY LANDFILL AND HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGEMENT  Mr.M.R.Ezhilkumar 30 Landfill site selection INCORPORATE OPERATIONAL BEST PRACTICES • Environmental improvement • Financial assurance: after care and remedial action • Waste minimisation • Waste acceptance • Waste pre-treatment • Waste placement • Waste cover • Litter control • Fire control • Contingency planning • Performance monitoring and reporting
  • 31.
    SHWM – Module3 – SANITARY LANDFILL AND HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGEMENT  Mr.M.R.Ezhilkumar 31 Assessment Time Review Question Recommend a suitable landfill location in Coimbatore region based on the criteria for selection.
  • 32.
    SHWM – Module3 – SANITARY LANDFILL AND HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGEMENT  Mr.M.R.Ezhilkumar 32