January 13, 2016 NISO Webinar: Ensuring the Scholarly Record: Scholarly Retractions, Scientific Reproducibility, and the Role of Publishers and Libraries

•

1 like•1,202 views

Trust through transparency - why the quality (and quantity) of publishers’ metadata matters Kirsty Meddings, Product Manager, CrossRef

Trust Through Transparency
Kirsty Meddings
@kmeddings
NISO Webinar: Ensuring the scholarly record. January 13th 2016

infrastructure |ˈɪnfrəstrʌktʃə|
noun

the basic physical and organizational
structures and facilities (e.g. buildings,
roads, power supplies) needed for the
operation of a society or enterprise.
the social and economic infrastructure
of a country.
Oxford Dictionary of English

Building trust in your content
• Who contributed to this research?
• (And what other research have they been involved in?)
• Is it original?
• Has it been updated?
• How was it peer-reviewed?
• What can I do with it?

Who contributed to this research?
Author: K. Meddings

http://orcid.org/0000-0001-9205-2956
Who contributed to this?

Crossref funding data (previously FundRef)
Standardisation of funder names using the
Open Funder Registry
Publisher deposit of funding metadata
Large-scale analysis and reporting to
funders

CrossCheck
iThenticate software to analyse
and compare text
Database of relevant content to
compare text against

CrossCheck
700 Crossref member publishers using CrossCheck
Screening against database of 44 million content items
270,000 manuscripts checked each month

Has it been updated?
erratum
corrigendum
correction
withdrawal
retraction
new edition
expression of concern
partial retraction
removal
addendum
clarification

CrossMark metadata
Freely available at api.crossref.org
• 275,000 DOIs with CrossMarks
• 26,000 are correction notices
• 950 are retraction notices

Publication history
Copyright statements
ORCIDs
Aims & Scope
A wealth of additional metadata
Links to datasets
Originality screening
Supplementary materials
And more…

Linked Clinical Trials pilot
• Deposit of registered clinical trial numbers (CTNs)
referenced in articles
• Links to other articles that also reference the same CTN
• Pre-results, results, post-results
• Display and navigation within CrossMark

Linked Clinical Trials pilot
● BMJ

● PLOS

● ISRCTN

● eLife

● F1000

● The Lancet

● Wiley/Cochrane

● BioMed Central

● CMAJ

● Wellcome

● Elsevier

What can I do with it?
Share & adapt for any purpose
with appropriate credit

Call to action!
Publishers already have all of this valuable information
Add it to your metadata and get it out there
Give the reader enough information to make a sound
judgement
Let other people and systems use it to research trends, build
tools and drive traffic

Thank you
kmeddings@crossref.org
@kmeddings

What does success look like when it comes to library discoverability? Index based discovery systems have seen a dramatic rate of adoption since introduction to the research ecosystem in 2009, with more than 9,000 libraries relying on a discovery system to provide users with a comprehensive index to their offerings. Some issues bar the way to providing this comprehensive view, but many challenges have been overcome through collaboration between libraries, content providers and discovery partners. The NISO ODI initiative began to examine these issues in 2011, and released a best practice in June 2014. Speakers will highlight examples of successful collaboration, note continued areas of challenge, and provide insight on how the Open Discovery Initiative Conformance Checklists can be used as a mechanism to evaluate content provider or discovery provider conformance with the best practice.

Research data spring: giving researchers credit for their data

Jisc RDM

This document outlines a 3-phase plan to develop a "helper app" that would streamline the process of publishing data papers by facilitating the deposit of research data into repositories and its connection to published data papers. Phase 1 involved gathering requirements and interest from repositories and publishers. Phase 2 involves developing a prototype app and building community support. Phase 3 focuses on demonstrating use cases, consolidating efforts with related projects, and planning for sustainability and expansion to additional domains. The goal is to incentivize data sharing by making it easier for researchers to get citations and publications from deposited data.

Bosman-Kramer Changing Research Workflows

National Information Standards Organization (NISO)

Manage your online profile: Maximize the visibility of your work and make an ...

Julia Gelfand

This document summarizes a presentation on managing your online profile to maximize the visibility and impact of your work. It discusses using online tools to share research, creating profiles on services like Scopus and Google Scholar to increase citations and discoverability. It also covers measuring impact through bibliometrics and altmetrics, making work open access through institutional or subject repositories, and using identifiers like ORCID to disambiguate authors. The presentation provides resources for authors to promote their work and research online.

A National Approach to Open Data in Ireland: Publishers and Research Data Man...

Rebecca Grant

NIH BD2K bioCADDIE DataMed: Data Discovery Index

Susanna-Assunta Sansone

This document summarizes the work of developing a Data Discovery Index prototype that helps users find and access shared biomedical data from various repositories. It ingests metadata from different standards and sources using ElasticSearch. It was presented at the Alan Turing Institute Symposium in April 2016. The project aims to organize data through an aggregator framework and portal. It involves mapping various metadata standards to have maximum coverage of use cases with minimal data elements. More information can be found at the listed websites.

Birgit Schmidt: RDA for Libraries from an International Perspective

dri_ireland

This session will comprise a talk with a panel of speakers looking at KBART: seven years later (since the publication of the first set of recommendations up to today). The panel will discuss the changes on the e-resources metadata landscape, the benefits of KBART and the challenges of its implementation. Today poor metadata in the electronic resources supply chain is still a problem. The panel will use practical examples to explain how metadata creation, consumption and usage are marked by the constant requirement of finding the balance between available resources (technical and human) and end user discoverability needs. The KBART Standing Committee sees the implementation of KBART recommendations as a community effort from a range of stakeholders (content providers, knowledge bases, link resolvers and librarians).

Broadbent Rozum Creating a Culture of Compliance

National Information Standards Organization (NISO)

Integration - the heart of researcher centric research data management system...

Repository Fringe

NISO's Altmetrics Initiative

National Information Standards Organization (NISO)

Discovering the research data alliance

Jisc RDM

Attribution From Res Lib Perspective - Micah Altman, MIT

National Information Standards Organization (NISO)

NISO Virtual Conference Scientific Data Management: Caring for Your Instituti...

National Information Standards Organization (NISO)

RDAP 16 Lightning: An Open Science Framework for Solving Institutional Challe...

ASIS&T

Natalie Harrower - DRI, RDA and Ireland

dri_ireland

Ingrid Dillo - Trustworthy repositories for open research data

dri_ireland

DANS is an institute of the Royal Netherlands Academy of Arts and Sciences (KNAW) and the Netherlands Organization for Scientific Research (NWO). It has been promoting and providing permanent access to digital research resources since 2005, building on predecessors dating back to 1964. DANS obtains certification for its repositories and services, including the Data Seal of Approval, to build trust with depositors, users, and funders by demonstrating its commitment to digital preservation best practices and transparency. The certification process also improves DANS' internal workflows and documentation.

Repositories for OA, RDM and Beyond - Rory McNicholl

Repository Fringe

This document summarizes the history and services of the University of London Computer Centre (ULCC), including its Digital Archives & Research Technologies (DART) service. DART provides open access repositories, research data repositories, and archival storage using platforms like EPrints, OJS, and Arkivum. It works with the research community to meet open access and research data management requirements. The presentation concludes by discussing potential future directions like preservation as a service and moving back through the full research lifecycle.

KBART-Wilson-ALA Annual 2015 NISO Update

National Information Standards Organization (NISO)

KBART (Knowledge Bases And Related Tools) is a recommended practice for publishers to provide standardized metadata to knowledge bases to improve the accuracy of holdings information. Phase 1 focused on serials while Phase 2 expanded the scope to ebooks, open access resources, and consortial holdings. The KBART standing committee oversees the recommended practice. Knowledge bases aggregate holdings data to support linking, discovery, and electronic resource management. Inaccurate holdings data in knowledge bases can negatively impact these services. KBART provides guidelines for data formatting and delivery, educational materials, and an endorsement program to recognize compliant publisher data feeds. Current priorities include increasing adoption of KBART best practices.

A post doc in the library?

Jisc RDM

Mejias "Making it work globally"

National Information Standards Organization (NISO)

2015 NISO Forum: The Future of Library Resource Discovery

National Information Standards Organization (NISO)

NISO Access & License Indicators - ALA Midwinter 2015

National Information Standards Organization (NISO)

This document summarizes a presentation by Nettie Lagace from NISO about the NISO Access and License Indicators working group. The working group aims to 1) specify a format for bibliographic metadata describing readership rights of scholarly works, 2) recommend mechanisms for publishing and distributing this metadata, 3) report on including downstream reuse rights, and 4) develop use cases for the outputs. The working group has developed <free_to_read> and <license_ref> tags to indicate access rights and point to license terms in a machine-readable way. Successful implementation could help address confusion about rights by transmitting open access information to enable discovery and tracking of scholarly works.

January 13, 2016 NISO Webinar: Ensuring the Scholarly Record: Scholarly Retra...

DeVonne Parks, CEM

January 13, 2016 NISO Webinar: Ensuring the Scholarly Record: Scholarly Retra...

DeVonne Parks, CEM

What's hot

Research data spring: extending the OPD to cover RDM

Jisc RDM

Lightning Talk - Angela Dappart

Jisc RDM

Kate Kelly - Open Research Ireland

dri_ireland

Taylor Delivering faster and more effective research discovery

National Information Standards Organization (NISO)

UKSG Conference 2017 Breakout - KBART recommendations: challenges and achieve...

UKSG: connecting the knowledge community

Broadbent Rozum Creating a Culture of Compliance

National Information Standards Organization (NISO)

Integration - the heart of researcher centric research data management system...

Repository Fringe

NISO's Altmetrics Initiative

National Information Standards Organization (NISO)

Discovering the research data alliance

Jisc RDM

Attribution From Res Lib Perspective - Micah Altman, MIT

National Information Standards Organization (NISO)

NISO Virtual Conference Scientific Data Management: Caring for Your Instituti...

National Information Standards Organization (NISO)

RDAP 16 Lightning: An Open Science Framework for Solving Institutional Challe...

ASIS&T

Natalie Harrower - DRI, RDA and Ireland

dri_ireland

Ingrid Dillo - Trustworthy repositories for open research data

dri_ireland

Repositories for OA, RDM and Beyond - Rory McNicholl

Repository Fringe

KBART-Wilson-ALA Annual 2015 NISO Update

National Information Standards Organization (NISO)

A post doc in the library?

Jisc RDM

Mejias "Making it work globally"

National Information Standards Organization (NISO)

2015 NISO Forum: The Future of Library Resource Discovery

National Information Standards Organization (NISO)

NISO Access & License Indicators - ALA Midwinter 2015

National Information Standards Organization (NISO)

What's hot (20)

Research data spring: extending the OPD to cover RDM

Lightning Talk - Angela Dappart

Kate Kelly - Open Research Ireland

Taylor Delivering faster and more effective research discovery

UKSG Conference 2017 Breakout - KBART recommendations: challenges and achieve...

Broadbent Rozum Creating a Culture of Compliance

Integration - the heart of researcher centric research data management system...

NISO's Altmetrics Initiative

Discovering the research data alliance

Attribution From Res Lib Perspective - Micah Altman, MIT

NISO Virtual Conference Scientific Data Management: Caring for Your Instituti...

RDAP 16 Lightning: An Open Science Framework for Solving Institutional Challe...

Natalie Harrower - DRI, RDA and Ireland

Ingrid Dillo - Trustworthy repositories for open research data

Repositories for OA, RDM and Beyond - Rory McNicholl

KBART-Wilson-ALA Annual 2015 NISO Update

A post doc in the library?

Mejias "Making it work globally"

2015 NISO Forum: The Future of Library Resource Discovery

NISO Access & License Indicators - ALA Midwinter 2015

Viewers also liked

January 13, 2016 NISO Webinar: Ensuring the Scholarly Record: Scholarly Retra...

DeVonne Parks, CEM

January 13, 2016 NISO Webinar: Ensuring the Scholarly Record: Scholarly Retra...

DeVonne Parks, CEM

Kopans Technology-Mediated Content

National Information Standards Organization (NISO)

Maureen C Kelly Managing Access in New World of Scholarly Research

National Information Standards Organization (NISO)

Henderson Balancing Rights and Reuse for Authors, Readers and Publishers

National Information Standards Organization (NISO)

Ratner -Discovering Reuse Rights

National Information Standards Organization (NISO)

Viewers also liked (6)

January 13, 2016 NISO Webinar: Ensuring the Scholarly Record: Scholarly Retra...

Kopans Technology-Mediated Content

Maureen C Kelly Managing Access in New World of Scholarly Research

Henderson Balancing Rights and Reuse for Authors, Readers and Publishers

Ratner -Discovering Reuse Rights

Similar to January 13, 2016 NISO Webinar: Ensuring the Scholarly Record: Scholarly Retractions, Scientific Reproducibility, and the Role of Publishers and Libraries

Collaboration Through Interoperability: FundRef and Other Metadata

Crossref

Carol Anne Meyer's presentation at the Council of Science Editors 2014 annual meeting May 5 2014 Session Description: There are several organizations, such as CrossRef, theNational Library of Medicine, ORCID and Ringgold, which are putting forth ideas tostandardize data and data exchange throughout scholarly publishing. This sessionwill discuss new initiatives that address such challenges as easily identifying fundingsources, managing author disambiguation, managing institution disambiguation, andstandardization of information exchange. Who Should Attend: Managing Editor/Publisher, Copy Editor/Production Editor, Editorin- Chief Standardizing Data and Data Exchange in Scholarly Publishing

Collaboration Through Interoperability

Carol Anne Meyer

Integrating ORCID, Funding, and Institutional Identifiers

Micah Altman

SHARE Update for CNI, Fall 2014

This document summarizes a SHARE membership meeting about the SHARE Notification Service. It discusses how the service will gather research release events from multiple providers, normalize the data, and notify consumers like funders and repositories. The Center for Open Science is helping to build the modular, scalable infrastructure. Challenges include inconsistent metadata across sources and a lack of identifiers. Future phases aim to reconcile records and provide more comprehensive researcher profiles.

ORCID: Connecting Research & Researchers

AIMS (Agricultural Information Management Standards)

Identification of Early Career Researchers: How Universities and Funding Orga...

ORCID, Inc

Funding agencies, universities, and research institutes all face challenges of reliably identifying their researchers and monitoring outcomes over time. All researchers—and especially early career researchers seeking to establish their careers—need to be reliably connected to their research outputs, without the confusion common, changeable names creates. Graduate students and postdoctoral researchers supported by grants also have specific challenges: if they are not the PI, they are not included in grant information; they may not even know which grant(s) they are supported by; and as a result, the existing challenges of reliably tying publications to grant funding are even more problematic. The use of the unique, persistent ORCID identifier can help support outcomes tracking and evaluation. In 2012, the U.S. National Institutes of Health Biomedical Research Workforce Working Group made recommendations that the NIH should take to support a sustainable biomedical research workforce in the U.S. In the course of its study, working group members were “frustrated and sometimes stymied” by the lack of quality, comprehensive data about biomedical researchers. In response, NIH has recommended the development of a simple, comprehensive tracking system for trainees, implemented a shared, voluntary researcher profile system called the Science Experts Network Curriculum Vitae (SciENcv), and encouraged the adoption of unique, persistent ORCID identifiers for researchers. Additionally, NIH has begun collecting data about individuals in graduate and undergraduate student project roles who are supported by NIH grants. Research universities like Texas A&M are also responding by incorporating the ORCID identifier into their systems, enabling the improved identification, data collection, and career outcome tracking of students and postdoctoral researchers--and educating these early career researchers about the benefits they will receive from a unique, persistent research identifier. They are also beginning to link Electronic Theses and Dissertations (ETDs) to early career researchers' ORCID records. ORCID is an independent, non-profit organization that provides an open registry of unique and persistent identifiers for researchers and scholars. ORCID collaborates with the community to integrate ORCID identifiers into research systems and workflows, improving data management and accuracy across systems. ORCID enables interoperability between research systems worldwide, ensuring that researchers are correctly and automatically linked to their contributions. Since its launch in October 2012, ORCID has seen rapid adoption by more than 670,000 researchers and 130+ member organizations. From Webinar 4/23/14, https://orcid.org/content/identification-early-career-researchers-how-universities-and-funding-organizations-are-using

Introduction to CrossRef for Researchers

Crossref

4.16.15 Slides, “Enhancing Early Career Researcher Profiles: VIVO & ORCID Int...

DuraSpace

Hot Topics: The DuraSpace Community Webinar Series Series 11: Integrating ORCID Persistent Identifiers with DSpace, Fedora and VIVO Webinar 3: “Enhancing Early Career Researcher Profiles: VIVO & ORCID Integration” April 16, 2015 Curated by Josh Brown, ORCID Presented by: Simeon Warner, Library Information Systems, Cornell University, Jon Corson-Rikert, Head of Information Technology Services, Cornell University and Kristi Holmes, Director, Galter Health Sciences Library, Northwestern University

Scientific Data overview of Data Descriptors - WT Data-Literature integration...

Susanna-Assunta Sansone

This document introduces Scientific Data, a new peer-reviewed journal for publishing data descriptors from Nature Publishing Group. It will provide structured metadata and narrative articles to describe datasets for reuse. The journal is now open for submissions and will launch in May 2014, featuring an advisory panel and sections for standardized data descriptor articles and experimental metadata. It aims to give proper credit for data sharing and promote open access, reuse and peer review of curated scientific datasets.

Authority files - Jisc Digital Festival 2014

Jisc

This document summarizes a workshop on authority files. It discusses how authority files can transform from library silos to a web of linked data by uniquely identifying entities like people, publications, organizations, and connecting them using identifiers. Four use cases are presented: developing a repository authority file, enhancing a journal authority file to track open access evolution, integrating existing authority files to make cultural data web compliant, and using authority files to enable new analyses and business intelligence from research information systems. The benefits of authority files for discovery, reliability, accountability, and efficiency are outlined. An example of crosswalking different authority files is also provided. The document concludes with an opinion poll on authority file topics.

OpenAthens Conference 2018 - Tim Lull and Chad Smith - Cultivating your onlin...

OpenAthens

The document discusses strategies for improving library discovery and the end user experience. It emphasizes making library resources easy to find through a unified discovery service that allows full-text searching across databases. The discovery service should integrate well with the library website, authenticate users smoothly, and provide an intuitive interface optimized for mobile users. Data on several libraries shows discovery services dramatically increasing usage of online resources. Integrating with OpenAthens single sign-on can streamline authentication across devices for users. The Stacks discovery platform is highlighted as focusing on usability, design, and plug-and-play integrations to create the best digital experience for patrons and librarians.

Who's the Author? Identifier soup - ORCID, ISNI, LC NACO and VIAF

Simeon Warner

Identifiers, including ORCID, ISNI, LC NACO and VIAF, are playing an increasing role in library authority work. Well describe changes to cataloging practices to leverage identifiers. We'll then tell a short story of the how and why of ORCID identifiers for researchers, and relationships with other person identifiers. Finally, we'll discuss the use of identifiers as part of moves toward linked data cataloging being explored in Linked Data for Libraries work (in the LD4L Labs and LD4P projects).

Orcid poster 09092013

Rebecca Bryant, PhD

ORCID provides a unique identifier for researchers and scholars to improve the discoverability and attribution of their work. It connects an individual researcher to all of their publications, datasets, and other research outputs. ORCID identifiers are embedded in many existing research systems to reduce repetitive data entry and ensure proper attribution of work. Over 240,000 identifiers have been issued internationally across disciplines and sectors to better connect the global research community.

بنك المعرفة-المصرى

ghadeermagdy

The document discusses the establishment of a national knowledge bank in Egypt with the following key points: 1. The knowledge bank will have multiple portals for researchers, students, children, and the general public. 2. Registration will require identifying the user's access level and providing basic personal and institutional details. 3. Registered users can access databases of scientific resources, publications, and datasets through their designated portal.

GARNet workshop on Integrating Large Data into Plant Science

David Johnson

Elsevier: Empowering Knowledge Discovery in Research with Graphs

Neo4j

This document summarizes a presentation about enabling knowledge discovery with graphs. It discusses Elsevier's use of Neo4j's graph database to build structured search applications and power recommendations. Some key points include: - Elsevier connects over 4 billion relationships in its graph, including references, grants, works, authors, and more to enable queries like finding all papers by an author. - The graph helps build new product experiences across Elsevier's portfolio like enhanced author profiles and citation counts in search results. - Graphs and embeddings provide a more precise understanding of author expertise and how their fields of study may have changed over time. - The graph supports data science and accelerates analytics like evaluating academic impact with page rank

Jonathan David Crabtree - The Dataverse Community: Supporting Open Science an...

SciELO - Scientific Electronic Library Online

The Odum Institute provides research infrastructure to support the social sciences at UNC. It houses the Lou Harris Data Center and partners on projects to promote open data sharing and reproducible science using the Dataverse platform. Dataverse is an open-source platform developed at Harvard to archive and share research data, assign DOIs, and build a community around data standards and best practices. The Odum Institute is working to improve data reuse by integrating tools like Encapsulator and Code Ocean with Dataverse repositories to facilitate replication.

Kasyanov "Web of Science API Workshop"

National Information Standards Organization (NISO)

FAIR Software (and Data) Citation: Europe, Research Object Systems, Networks ...

Carole Goble

L&P Eric Celeste - SHARE

CASRAI

Similar to January 13, 2016 NISO Webinar: Ensuring the Scholarly Record: Scholarly Retractions, Scientific Reproducibility, and the Role of Publishers and Libraries (20)

Collaboration Through Interoperability: FundRef and Other Metadata

Collaboration Through Interoperability

Integrating ORCID, Funding, and Institutional Identifiers

SHARE Update for CNI, Fall 2014

ORCID: Connecting Research & Researchers

Identification of Early Career Researchers: How Universities and Funding Orga...

Introduction to CrossRef for Researchers

4.16.15 Slides, “Enhancing Early Career Researcher Profiles: VIVO & ORCID Int...

Scientific Data overview of Data Descriptors - WT Data-Literature integration...

Authority files - Jisc Digital Festival 2014

OpenAthens Conference 2018 - Tim Lull and Chad Smith - Cultivating your onlin...

Who's the Author? Identifier soup - ORCID, ISNI, LC NACO and VIAF

Orcid poster 09092013

بنك المعرفة-المصرى

GARNet workshop on Integrating Large Data into Plant Science

Elsevier: Empowering Knowledge Discovery in Research with Graphs

Jonathan David Crabtree - The Dataverse Community: Supporting Open Science an...

Kasyanov "Web of Science API Workshop"

FAIR Software (and Data) Citation: Europe, Research Object Systems, Networks ...

L&P Eric Celeste - SHARE

More from DeVonne Parks, CEM

December 16, 2015 NISO Webinar: Two-Part Webinar: Emerging Resource Types Pa...

DeVonne Parks, CEM

December 16, 2015 NISO Webinar: Two-Part Webinar: Emerging Resource Types Pa...

DeVonne Parks, CEM

December 16, 2015 NISO Two-Part Webinar: Emerging Resource Types - Part 2 Equ...

DeVonne Parks, CEM

December 9, 2015 NISO Webinar: Two-Part Webinar: Emerging Resource Types - Pa...

DeVonne Parks, CEM

This document discusses the challenges of sharing large-scale and sensitive data and outlines approaches to address them. It describes how data sharing needs to continue supporting discovery, citation, access and reuse of data as datasets increase in size from GBs to TBs and PBs. Current collaborations are working on techniques like integrating large datasets with the Dataverse platform, deploying Dataverse on cloud computing resources, and using the DataTags system to enable controlled sharing of sensitive data while preserving privacy.

December 9, 2015 NISO Webinar: Two-Part Webinar: Emerging Resource Types - Pa...

DeVonne Parks, CEM

The National Snow and Ice Data Center (NSIDC) provides data and information about snow and ice to researchers and the public. Originally focused on cryosphere scientists, NSIDC's audience grew when satellite data revealed declining Arctic sea ice trends starting in the 2000s. To meet the needs of different user groups, NSIDC developed multiple data products around sea ice data, including the Sea Ice Index for climate researchers and the Arctic Sea Ice News & Analysis site for general audiences. NSIDC continues refining its data products and education efforts to make big cryosphere data useful and accessible to an expanding designated community with diverse needs.

December 9, 2015 NISO Webinar: Two-Part Webinar: Emerging Resource Types - Pa...

DeVonne Parks, CEM