This SlideShare was uploaded as a assignment for Barry University - HRD 647 - DIGITAL DESIGN FOR E-LEARNING by Tyronella Ferguson The slides compare and contrast two well known instructional design theories, the ADDIE Model vs Dick & Carey Model. The slide deck briefly highlights pros, cons, similarities and differences in these models.

1. INSTRUCTIONALDESIGN
MODELCOMPARISON
ADDIE Model
VS
Dick and Carry Model
Tyronella Ferguson -HRD 647

2. Objective
ADDIE MODEL DICK AND CAREY MODEL COMPARE & CONTRASTS

3. ADDIE MODEL
• 5 Step Model
• Pros
• Systematic and thorough guide
• front-loads as much research and
analysis into the beginning of the
overall design process
• Useful management tool
• Well established ad widely used
• Cons
• Works best with larger projects can be
redunddnt in standard classroom
settngs
• Five stages are self explanatory, but the
model does not provide further
guidelines on how and what to chose
within the steps.
• Can be inflexible for the digital age

4. Dick & Carey
Model
• 10 Step Model
• Pros
• addresses instruction as an
entire system
• once instructional goal has
been established, the ID team
can complete the remaining
phases can be accomplished
iteratively and in any order
• Front-end focus on the learners’
needs and prior knowledge
• Cons
• The process can be
cumbersome
• Can require more time than
other models

5. Compare & Contrast
ADDIE MODEL
◦ Foundation of ID Models
◦ Address evaluation in the final phase of the
design process
◦ User Friendly
DC MODEL
◦ More Detailed Approach
◦ Addresses evaluation throughout the design
process
Similarities
Linear Processes
Phased Development
Both begin with Audience
Analysis and address
Development and Evaluation

6. Conclusion
Emphasis should be place on the value in Instructional Design
. Instructional Designers should choose applicable models
based on training and audience needs.