Improving clinical reasoning skills by electronic voting Dr. Peter de Jong Leiden University Medical Center The Netherlands Nynke Bos Roel Sijstermans Dr. Mario Maas Academic Medical Center The Netherlands
Electronic voting? Audience Polling System Vote with clicker, laptop or PDA Real-time results
Where are you from? Africa North America South America Asia Europe Oceania 10
Why electronic voting? Activates & stimulates learning Gains insight in level of students’ knowledge  Tutor adapts to lack of knowlegde Discussion Data for evaluation and research
Different ways to use… Pre- and Post testing Entrance level determination Evaluation Competition Clinical reasoning
Current situation 350 medical students each year Divided into 30 groups Each group his own professor 10 times a year Prepare medical case on paper Discussion
Pilot situation Implementing clinical reasoning skills in the lecture hall 350 students with clickers 1 professor Each lecture can be a clinical reasoning lecture
How does it work? Clinical case with multi media Branching slides Students determine clinical reasoning path Majority of votes counts
Clinical Case: Debby A 17 year old girl is brought into the ER after a scooter accident. She was shortly unconscious  at the scene. She complaints of headache and a painful right knee
 
Prioritize Head Knee 10
X- right knee
In the meantime… While waiting for the X- ray of the right knee patient starts to vomit. She also complaints of enormous headache. What will you do now?
Head X- ray CT 10
X - head
CT head
Team Scores Europe 100 Asia 100 South America 100 Oceania 133.33 North America 200
Advantages Presenting cases with multi media More times a year Less professors needed Mistakes in clinical reasoning can be corrected on the spot Insight in level of clinical reasoning skills of large group of students Reduces the costs and logistics More interactive lectures
Disadvantages Professor needs more time to prepare one case Majority feedback instead of individual Inactive students less involvement
Conclusions Clinical reasoning with clickers is a good supplement to the current small group situation Clickers offer change to practice more cases of clinical reasoning
Questions ?
The use of clickers in large groups is a good method for training students in clinical reasoning Strongly agree Agree Neutral Disagree Strongly disagree 10
I’m using or thinking about using clickers in my classroom or faculty  Strongly Agree Agree Neutral Disagree Strongly Disagree 10
 
PLEASE RETURN THE CLICKERS
Pilot results Compare midterm exams with last year students on clinical reasoning exam Level = results exam of this year must be improved Exam date June 5 th Current data: opinions of students (n=270) and professors (n=7)
Costs Free software:  www.turningtechnologies.com RF-receiver: € 400,- Clicker: € 50,- 1RF-receiver for 1000 clickers
The project Collaboration AMC and LUMC Financed by SURF Foundation AMC: clickers and RF receiver LUMC: laptops and WiFi Stimulate and train tutors to use electronic voting as a tool for improving their lectures and increase interaction during lectures

Improving clinical reasoning skills by electronic voting

  • 1.
    Improving clinical reasoningskills by electronic voting Dr. Peter de Jong Leiden University Medical Center The Netherlands Nynke Bos Roel Sijstermans Dr. Mario Maas Academic Medical Center The Netherlands
  • 2.
    Electronic voting? AudiencePolling System Vote with clicker, laptop or PDA Real-time results
  • 3.
    Where are youfrom? Africa North America South America Asia Europe Oceania 10
  • 4.
    Why electronic voting?Activates & stimulates learning Gains insight in level of students’ knowledge Tutor adapts to lack of knowlegde Discussion Data for evaluation and research
  • 5.
    Different ways touse… Pre- and Post testing Entrance level determination Evaluation Competition Clinical reasoning
  • 6.
    Current situation 350medical students each year Divided into 30 groups Each group his own professor 10 times a year Prepare medical case on paper Discussion
  • 7.
    Pilot situation Implementingclinical reasoning skills in the lecture hall 350 students with clickers 1 professor Each lecture can be a clinical reasoning lecture
  • 8.
    How does itwork? Clinical case with multi media Branching slides Students determine clinical reasoning path Majority of votes counts
  • 9.
    Clinical Case: DebbyA 17 year old girl is brought into the ER after a scooter accident. She was shortly unconscious at the scene. She complaints of headache and a painful right knee
  • 10.
  • 11.
  • 12.
  • 13.
    In the meantime…While waiting for the X- ray of the right knee patient starts to vomit. She also complaints of enormous headache. What will you do now?
  • 14.
  • 15.
  • 16.
  • 17.
    Team Scores Europe100 Asia 100 South America 100 Oceania 133.33 North America 200
  • 18.
    Advantages Presenting caseswith multi media More times a year Less professors needed Mistakes in clinical reasoning can be corrected on the spot Insight in level of clinical reasoning skills of large group of students Reduces the costs and logistics More interactive lectures
  • 19.
    Disadvantages Professor needsmore time to prepare one case Majority feedback instead of individual Inactive students less involvement
  • 20.
    Conclusions Clinical reasoningwith clickers is a good supplement to the current small group situation Clickers offer change to practice more cases of clinical reasoning
  • 21.
  • 22.
    The use ofclickers in large groups is a good method for training students in clinical reasoning Strongly agree Agree Neutral Disagree Strongly disagree 10
  • 23.
    I’m using orthinking about using clickers in my classroom or faculty Strongly Agree Agree Neutral Disagree Strongly Disagree 10
  • 24.
  • 25.
  • 26.
    Pilot results Comparemidterm exams with last year students on clinical reasoning exam Level = results exam of this year must be improved Exam date June 5 th Current data: opinions of students (n=270) and professors (n=7)
  • 27.
    Costs Free software: www.turningtechnologies.com RF-receiver: € 400,- Clicker: € 50,- 1RF-receiver for 1000 clickers
  • 28.
    The project CollaborationAMC and LUMC Financed by SURF Foundation AMC: clickers and RF receiver LUMC: laptops and WiFi Stimulate and train tutors to use electronic voting as a tool for improving their lectures and increase interaction during lectures