The Evolution of Blogging
How Dark Skies, Lucas from Venmo,
and Batkid changed the way we communicate
Roger Wu
Co-Founder, Cooperatize
@rogerwu99
In the Beginning
What is a Blog?
• Blogging (a web log) was a simple way to
publish one’s thoughts on the Internet
• It was typically a semi-private diary.
• Traffic was attained by sending links to
friends.
• There was no way to monetize these blogs;
there were no ad networks back then.
The Very Beginning
• The only sites that got real traffic were
those that had real estate value.
• Real estate value could be from a name
brand URL, news.com (CNET), or the New
York Times (nytimes.com)
• A directory site like Yahoo could also drive
meaningful traffic to sites.
• Blogs were not indexed in directory sites
and thus were virtually invisible.
• Blogging had advantages over traditional
journalism with what they could cover
• Blogs had opinions that traditional
publications didn’t want to have
• Blogs could publish much faster (although
there were occasional errors).
• Early names like Drudge Report,
Mashable, TechCrunch
Early Adopters
Search Engines
• Search engines were the sole source of
majority traffic besides email subscribers
• RSS, now deprecated, was another way to
subscribe to a blog’s posts
• Only big names showed up in search due
to page rank algorithm.
• Blogs still had little visibility..
• 2005 – Platforms
aggregating user
generated content
exploded.
• The Year of You
according to Time.
Social Media
• Thousands of social sites showed up,
these ranked well on search but also
became platforms in themselves
• Millions of blogs now could be found
through “social media”
• Content is now truly democratized
The Golden Age
Social Media: Changing the Guard
37%
2%
38%
23%
9%
26%
26%
39%
$1.9b $1.7b
More Blogs
Blogs as a Marketing Tool
We’ve become better searchers
The Dark Ages
And then the bubble bursts
The Bubble Bursts: Why?
Too much contentContent creation is growing - FAST
Lots of Inventory, RTB, Rising Spends
Too many ads
Our day is still finite, so who
consumes this content?
Robots account for a lot
of web traffic and thus
look at a lot of ads …
While humans are blocking them
The Comeback
Who are we?
• Cooperatize, the best of PR,
influencer, and advertising:
• Influencer: influencer creates long
form content and promotes it
• Advertising: Cost per read model up
to a capped amount
• PR: Excess beyond cap is earned
media
Do what you are good at
We let publishers do what they are
best at, creating content, not selling
advertising
Long Form Content is Alive!
There’s been a huge emphasis on
social media, but it all ties back
to long form content. There is
only so much that can be
conveyed in 140.
• Smartphones like the iPhone let us
Google anything anytime
• Amazon let’s us buy anything we
want, whenever we want it
• It is not about seeing an ad and
converting, it is all about being top
of mind.
Getting into the Consideration Set
Dark Sky
An app that tells you when it will rain and for
how long? Too good to be true!
Then why aren’t you
downloading it now?
Because it’s not raining, but when it does, as
long as I remember the story (and not the
name), its only a Google search away!
A Future of Better Stories
Story Elements that work – Numbers or Narrative
Patients were given the choice between a 50%
effective drug and a 90% effective drug:
When the 90% drug was coupled with a:
Positive story: patients chose it 88% of the time.
Neutral story, patients chose it 81% of the time.
Negative story, patients chose it 39% of the time.
ONE data point trumps many when it is personal
“I was moving to NYC from LA after I broke up with
my boyfriend. My flight was inevitably delayed at
O’Hare. While at the bar, a guy struck up a
conversation: he was going to Fargo, ND to run the
marathon, had an extra bib, and asked if I’d like to
join. I realized that I didn’t have anything waiting
for me in New York so I said Yes. I’m glad I did, the
Fargo marathon was amazing ….”
**Turns out this was fiction but
regardless but Fargo into my head
Story Elements that work – What vs Why
• Steve Jobs, a masterful storyteller, illustrates
the difference between why and what
• What is the new iPhone? 5MB camera, 64GB
storage, A8 processor, retina display etc
• Why the new iPhone? Front facing camera lets
the hearing impaired make a phone call
• Newcastle, England wanted to publicize the new
non-stop United flight from EWR to NCL.
• Some wrote about the what: the new flight
• The memorable powerful stories focused on the
why: without a stopover, weekend trips are
possible, bachelor/ette parties, Birthday parties,
sporting events, special events, etc. are all
possible because of the saved time
Story Elements that work – Context
• Display advertising will not likely go away in
the short term. However, “targeting” does
not work. With new products, the lack of
context asks more questions than it answers.
• What is the story behind say, “Lucas uses
Venmo” versus “two cavemen with a broken
car behind them.” We know that story cold,
since we’ve been told it so many times,
without the story we are confused
• We provided context for a country in
Southeast Asia who was running cryptic
display advertising.
• Readers of the stories were retargeted with
display ads which changed their entire
meaning in the context of the story.
• Display advertising works, if the right story is
behind it.
Thank You!
Roger Wu
roger@cooperatize.com
@rogerwu99
1-917-549-0188

How Blogging has Evolved in the World of Content Marketing

  • 1.
    The Evolution ofBlogging How Dark Skies, Lucas from Venmo, and Batkid changed the way we communicate Roger Wu Co-Founder, Cooperatize @rogerwu99
  • 2.
  • 3.
    What is aBlog? • Blogging (a web log) was a simple way to publish one’s thoughts on the Internet • It was typically a semi-private diary. • Traffic was attained by sending links to friends. • There was no way to monetize these blogs; there were no ad networks back then.
  • 4.
    The Very Beginning •The only sites that got real traffic were those that had real estate value. • Real estate value could be from a name brand URL, news.com (CNET), or the New York Times (nytimes.com) • A directory site like Yahoo could also drive meaningful traffic to sites. • Blogs were not indexed in directory sites and thus were virtually invisible.
  • 5.
    • Blogging hadadvantages over traditional journalism with what they could cover • Blogs had opinions that traditional publications didn’t want to have • Blogs could publish much faster (although there were occasional errors). • Early names like Drudge Report, Mashable, TechCrunch Early Adopters
  • 6.
    Search Engines • Searchengines were the sole source of majority traffic besides email subscribers • RSS, now deprecated, was another way to subscribe to a blog’s posts • Only big names showed up in search due to page rank algorithm. • Blogs still had little visibility..
  • 7.
    • 2005 –Platforms aggregating user generated content exploded. • The Year of You according to Time.
  • 8.
    Social Media • Thousandsof social sites showed up, these ranked well on search but also became platforms in themselves • Millions of blogs now could be found through “social media” • Content is now truly democratized
  • 9.
  • 10.
    Social Media: Changingthe Guard 37% 2% 38% 23% 9% 26% 26% 39% $1.9b $1.7b
  • 11.
  • 12.
    Blogs as aMarketing Tool
  • 13.
  • 14.
  • 15.
    And then thebubble bursts The Bubble Bursts: Why?
  • 16.
    Too much contentContentcreation is growing - FAST
  • 17.
    Lots of Inventory,RTB, Rising Spends
  • 18.
  • 19.
    Our day isstill finite, so who consumes this content?
  • 20.
    Robots account fora lot of web traffic and thus look at a lot of ads …
  • 21.
    While humans areblocking them
  • 22.
  • 23.
    Who are we? •Cooperatize, the best of PR, influencer, and advertising: • Influencer: influencer creates long form content and promotes it • Advertising: Cost per read model up to a capped amount • PR: Excess beyond cap is earned media
  • 24.
    Do what youare good at We let publishers do what they are best at, creating content, not selling advertising
  • 25.
    Long Form Contentis Alive! There’s been a huge emphasis on social media, but it all ties back to long form content. There is only so much that can be conveyed in 140.
  • 28.
    • Smartphones likethe iPhone let us Google anything anytime • Amazon let’s us buy anything we want, whenever we want it • It is not about seeing an ad and converting, it is all about being top of mind. Getting into the Consideration Set
  • 29.
    Dark Sky An appthat tells you when it will rain and for how long? Too good to be true! Then why aren’t you downloading it now? Because it’s not raining, but when it does, as long as I remember the story (and not the name), its only a Google search away!
  • 30.
    A Future ofBetter Stories
  • 31.
    Story Elements thatwork – Numbers or Narrative Patients were given the choice between a 50% effective drug and a 90% effective drug: When the 90% drug was coupled with a: Positive story: patients chose it 88% of the time. Neutral story, patients chose it 81% of the time. Negative story, patients chose it 39% of the time. ONE data point trumps many when it is personal
  • 32.
    “I was movingto NYC from LA after I broke up with my boyfriend. My flight was inevitably delayed at O’Hare. While at the bar, a guy struck up a conversation: he was going to Fargo, ND to run the marathon, had an extra bib, and asked if I’d like to join. I realized that I didn’t have anything waiting for me in New York so I said Yes. I’m glad I did, the Fargo marathon was amazing ….” **Turns out this was fiction but regardless but Fargo into my head
  • 33.
    Story Elements thatwork – What vs Why • Steve Jobs, a masterful storyteller, illustrates the difference between why and what • What is the new iPhone? 5MB camera, 64GB storage, A8 processor, retina display etc • Why the new iPhone? Front facing camera lets the hearing impaired make a phone call
  • 34.
    • Newcastle, Englandwanted to publicize the new non-stop United flight from EWR to NCL. • Some wrote about the what: the new flight • The memorable powerful stories focused on the why: without a stopover, weekend trips are possible, bachelor/ette parties, Birthday parties, sporting events, special events, etc. are all possible because of the saved time
  • 35.
    Story Elements thatwork – Context • Display advertising will not likely go away in the short term. However, “targeting” does not work. With new products, the lack of context asks more questions than it answers. • What is the story behind say, “Lucas uses Venmo” versus “two cavemen with a broken car behind them.” We know that story cold, since we’ve been told it so many times, without the story we are confused
  • 36.
    • We providedcontext for a country in Southeast Asia who was running cryptic display advertising. • Readers of the stories were retargeted with display ads which changed their entire meaning in the context of the story. • Display advertising works, if the right story is behind it.
  • 37.

Editor's Notes

  • #4 Geocities The first blog You still needed complex software
  • #5 There wasn’t much. HTML was basic and anything interactive required programming. In fact Yahoo was a directory. There were a handful of webpages. And thus display ads were somewhat useful.
  • #6 Geeks and Techies and Quake Mashable / Techcrunch Talk about stuff no one else wants to report about, Lewinsky, Trent Lott
  • #7 Page Rank --- hard to get new readers RSS google reader (now dead) Bloggers were still bloggers, they weren’t press
  • #8 10 years ago the person of the year was YOU
  • #9 New way to get fans Viral spread. Not foresaken by search Small blogs could get through
  • #11 Pure real estate play, but we’re putting a lot of power into the hands of Facebook. Brands valuable but social traffic equalizes New york times worth $1.98b Buzzfeed 1.7b Their traffic: Facebook: 37% Other Social 38% Google 2% Direct 23%
  • #12 That leads to more sites. Upworthy, Buzzefeed on the high end, NYT, businessweek (newsweek) WSJ, Conde, Hearst mags everything is now a blog But bloggers are now equal to these sites And as people become better Googlers niches pop out and they are found on Google So now, lot of blogs, lots of influencers, lots of content means that … 2006 You is the Time person of the year
  • #13 That leads to more sites. Upworthy, Buzzefeed on the high end, NYT, businessweek (newsweek) WSJ, Conde, Hearst mags everything is now a blog But bloggers are now equal to these sites And as people become better Googlers niches pop out and they are found on Google So now, lot of blogs, lots of influencers, lots of content means that … 2006 You is the Time person of the year
  • #14 People figured out how to use search leading to more detailed queries leading to better sites Niche content People figured out how to write click bait headlines like Upworthy Companies are getting into it with their own content marketing strategies Things couldn’t be better. A lot of people are still here.
  • #17 More than 50% of YouTube videos are seen by less than 500 people The average number of video views is 2 Facebook organic reach decline due to glut of content Status updating is much more common than it once was No one is reading my stuff 
  • #18 That leads to more sites. Upworthy, Buzzefeed on the high end, NYT, businessweek (newsweek) WSJ, Conde, Hearst mags everything is now a blog But bloggers are now equal to these sites And as people become better Googlers niches pop out and they are found on Google So now, lot of blogs, lots of influencers, lots of content means that … 2006 You is the Time person of the year
  • #19 25-34 y.o’s see 2094 Banners/month 445 advertisers delivered 1b banners in ‘12 Desktop internet CPMs 3.50 Mobile internet CPMs .75 --- 50% of clicks on mobile banner are accidental 8% of internet users account for 85% of clicks (and some are not human) 31% of impressions cannot be seen The 468x60 is clicked on 0.04% 5.3T display ads were served in 2010 The typical user is served 1707 banners per month Users are shown nearly 2,000 banners per month 5.3T display ads served in 2010 (5 years ago!) and this is growing The 468x60 has a 0.04% CTR 50% of clicks on mobile are by accident AdBlock is on the rise, you might get charged now for ads that don’t even show
  • #21 25-34 y.o’s see 2094 Banners/month 445 advertisers delivered 1b banners in ‘12 Desktop internet CPMs 3.50 Mobile internet CPMs .75 --- 50% of clicks on mobile banner are accidental 8% of internet users account for 85% of clicks (and some are not human) 31% of impressions cannot be seen The 468x60 is clicked on 0.04% 5.3T display ads were served in 2010 The typical user is served 1707 banners per month
  • #24 Content marketing Sponsored storytelling venn diagram of advertising, influencer and PR Brands have made a comeback because of fake stories
  • #25 Publishers should do what they do best Brands do what they do best Why do we have brands telling stories and publishers trying to sell things?
  • #26 Cecil the Lion, Ahmed the Clock Maker, Rachel Dolezal, Kim Davis, Blogging has huge influence over “mass” media (testing ground) (book deals from twitter) etc Things that make you feel good, but also things that make you angry BatKid We know what kind of content works, we have a huge testing ground to figure out what stories resonate best, memorable, SEO friendly, etc. LONG FORM CONTENT
  • #27 STEPPS Social Currency Trigger Emotion Public Practical Stories
  • #29 But the world has changed yet again with Amazon and Apple. What’s in your pocket? You know you can get anything you want within 2 days via Prime. But you don’t know what you don’t know. Story is making a comeback Physical real estate to mental real estate
  • #31 Better stories Stronger integration More niche Big data v narrative What v why Retargeting Provides context for other forms of advertising where a whole story cannot be told (radio, print, display)
  • #32  Number vs Narrative (emotions vs rationality) What vs Why Manage expectations start high, end high
  • #33 1 Tess’s north dakota story
  • #34  Number vs Narrative (emotions vs rationality) What vs Why Manage expectations start high, end high
  • #36 Lucas uses Venmo Geico Display is not dead yet.
  • #37 Lucas uses Venmo Geico Display is not dead yet.