The document discusses issues around initiating and maintaining student participation in online learning platforms and social software. It notes that requiring participation through external controls like grading can increase activity but may not foster deeper learning or collaboration. Simply providing tools and expecting voluntary participation often results in low levels of engagement. Instead, participation is more successful when it serves student interests and needs, allows a sense of ownership, and supports different types of learning like expanding opportunities rather than just completing tasks. Overall, the question is raised whether true participation, autonomy and collaboration can be achieved through compulsory controls or if new pedagogical models are needed.