Formalised Sales & Operations Planning (S&OP)
– KFC Case Study
Elizbe Rohde
Implementation Project Manager
KFC Supply Chain Manager (South Africa)
Agenda
• About KFC
• Complexity in QSR
• The Project
• Lessons Learnt
Did you know the following about KFC?
Sell 400+ tons of chicken per day which
to give a visual representation, is equal
to the weight of 57 fully grown elephants
(1.3m birds/ week)
57x
Total Weight of KFC Mash sold per year
equivalent to 2 Boeing 747’s (total
dressings will fill up an Olympic sized
swimming pool)
2x
Add Hope feeds 100k children per day,
enough to fill Ellis park stadium
Yum! is the parent company of the
brands KFC, Pizza Hut and Taco Bell
which is the largest restaurant company
in the world with ~41k restaurants in 125
countries
KFC’s Original Recipe® chicken is still
prepared to Colonel Sanders’ exact
standards, using the secret blend of 11
herbs and spices he perfected back in
1940
Proud heritage in South Africa for the
past 40 years with ~800 restaurants
(~120 in the rest of Africa). Voted the
most loved fast food brand in South
Africa for the last 16 years
Agenda
• About KFC
• Complexity in QSR
• The Project
• Lessons Learnt
QSR Store Dynamics differ to other industries and the
way in which we need to forecast
Clear Menu Item Trends
• 800 Stores with similar menu items and trends (not multiple brands) sold directly to consumers
• Products sold directly to consumer with immediate consumption vs. buying for future use results in
clear POS sales data and trends
• Significant growth from new stores (40 opened in 2014), forecasting needs to consider volume and
store growth - forecast on Weekly Per Store Average (WPSA)
• Different store types i.e. breakfast stores
• Different menu types which include Permanent Items and Limited Time Offers (LTO’s) which adds
additional complexity
• Need to consider abnormal activities in the past that affects forecasts such as strikes impacting
supply
Easter Christmas
Large component of Limited Time Offers (LTO’s) or
Promotions that have a high level of uncertainty
• LTO = Promotion running for 7 – 15 weeks
• Combination of unique and existing
ingredients
• Unique lifecycle: Need to balance out-of-
stock vs. write-off’s through planning
• Challenge: All ingredients on time in stores
with high level of sales uncertainty which is
greatest within start-up and growth phases
• Consideration to impact on permanent
items (cannibalisation on other items)
LTO: Menu Item LTO: Ingredients
New Menu
Item
Unique Ingredient
(significant impact)
Existing Ingredient
(limited impact)
Menu Items are converted via a BOM to Ingredients
1 Bun
15g Sauce
6 Doritos
10g Lettuce
1 Fillet
BOM Menu ItemIngredients
• Menu Items are assembled from ingredients based on the Bill of Materials (BOM) or recipe
• Forecasting is based on menu item store sales
• Menu item sales are converted through the BOM to ingredients and gives a view of ingredient sales out of
the store
• Ingredient sales out of the store is compared to ingredients sales into the store from the 3PL supplier
• Ingredients to Menu items have a one-to-many relationship
Agenda
• About KFC
• Complexity in QSR
• The Project
• Lessons Learnt
Why the need for a formalised Sales & Operations
Planning (S&OP) process and system that balances
supply and demand
The importance of Planning to bridge the gap between
Strategy and Execution
TACTICAL SUPPLY CHAIN PLANNING
Plan supply Match demand and supply Plan demand
Return
OPERATIONAL EXECUTION
STRATEGIC PLANNINGSTRATEGIC PLANNING
Plan Source Make Deliver Sell
KFC South Africa S&OP journey and the way forward
20142013
Sustain the achievement and prepare for
the next step to be a best in class
organisation
Complete/ In Progress
Next focus areas
No S&OP
Processes and
ad-hoc LTO
Planning
Bi-Monthly Demand
Planning (with
Excel based LTO’s)
2015 2016 Time
Value
S&OP for all items with
supplier sharing and 3PL
replenishment (LTO’s &
permanent)
Integrated Business
Planning
Extend to New
Africa Markets
We are here
Select & Implement
Planning System
S&OP for current &
upcoming LTOs (with
Planning System)
A formal S&OP process and system allowing KFC to be
more pro-active and flexible with 3 main objectives
Planning
Forecast
-ing
Finance &
Marketing
Maintain good stock
availability (involving less
effort) especially with
increased marketing
complexity
Improved Supply Chain
control and pro-active
forward visibility
Increased visibility on
permanent items (not only
focused on LTO’s)
1
2
3
Main Objectives
Supply Chain,
Suppliers & 3PL
Re-align supply
with changing
demand
Stock
Availability &
Write-Offs
Actual vs.
Forecasted
Demand
We set detailed sub-objectives to guide our journey
and the implementation of the project
Good stock availability
Reduced effort to plan
(increased automation and
fewer resources required)
Improved Supply Chain control
Pro-Active visibility of supply
issues (LTO & permanent)
Supplier & 3PL plans
Forecasts and plans for
permanent items (not current)
Actual vs. Forecasted Demand
Improved storage capacity
planning visibility
Better write-off management
Integrated BOM management
Current Future
Planning for the KFC South Africa Supply Chain
3PL 5 DC’s 800 KFC’s100 Suppliers
Supply Planning Demand Planning
What the next level in the maturity curve required given
the multi-layered Supply Chain
Store Supply Chain
Source: Deliver: Make
Store Supply Chain
Source: Deliver: Make
3PL
Source: Deliver
3PL
Source: Deliver
Supplier Supply Chain
Source: Make: Deliver
Supplier Supply Chain
Source: Make: Deliver
Plan 1 week ahead
Forecast LTO’s Nationally
New Process
Old Process
Forecast all menu items at
regional level (some by store)
Forecast and plan all
ingredients by DC & Supplier
Menu Items
Converted
through BOM
to Ingredients
… with a tailored system
Interface
Master Data
Forecasting Tool
Demand Planning
Open PO’s &
Planning
Parameters (lead
time, minimum
order quantities)
> 3PL System
Stock on Hand
(SOH) from
> 3PL System
Ingredients/ DC
Sales
> 3PL System
BOM (recipe info)
> KFC System
Menu Item/ Store
Sales
> KFC System
(POS)
Reports and data
extraction
Statistical and
consensus
forecast by week
for menu items
and ingredients
Suggested
purchase orders
for ingredients by
DC and supplier
within constraints
Sales History (weekly)
SOH, PO’s, Planning Parameters (daily)
Planning Tool
Supply Planning
In Summary
Planning (Supply Plan)Forecasting (Demand Plan)
Store Sales
Sales
INTERFACE
Menu Item Forecasting (by Region, LTO
by Store)
Ingredients Forecasting (by DC)
DC and Supplier Planning for
Ingredients
BOM CONVERSION
S&OP Process
1
2
3
4
Agenda
• About KFC
• Complexity in QSR
• The Project
• Lessons Learnt
Choose the right service provider in accordance with
your requirements
Sample of Key Clients Barnton Competitive Edge
• Significant advanced forecasting & planning
experience
• Blue chip SA (incl. international) clients
• Only planning systems vendor with local QSR
experience (i.e. Famous Brands)
• Highly recommended by SA Supply Chain
practitioners
• Flexible, configurable systems
• “Simple” advanced planning system (not “overkill”)
Strong project management and a rigorous approach
with strong governance is a critical success factor
20
Project Charter
Governance & Stakeholder Management
Approach & Timeline
Project Plan
What worked well and what didn’t
What Worked Well Areas for Improvement
• Interface effort and complexity underestimated
• Data cleansing effort underestimated
• Clearly defined scope i.e. BOM module
development
• Availability of key stakeholders
• Implement consensus S&OP (Demand Planning)
process prior to systems implementation
• Project leadership very involved in understanding
and guiding solution design
• Strong project manager with good methodology &
governance
• Good buy-in through Cross Functional Team and
stakeholder involvement and communication
• Choose the right demand & supply planning
solution with flexibility to tailor for KFC specific
functional needs
• Defined new roles and responsibilities in line with
S&OP process (one new role)
• Hands-on training with KFC’s real data and on-the-
job coaching
Since formalising the S&OP process, write-off spend
has reduced by ~60% whilst doubling the number of
promotions
7
10
14
0
2
4
6
8
10
12
14
16
0
100
200
300
400
500
600
700
2012 2013 2014
Thousands
Promo Performance: Execution vs Write Off (ZAR)
Write Offs Promos
Effective write off cost per promo has been improving
0
2 000
4 000
6 000
8 000
10 000
12 000
14 000
16 000
2013 2014
Out of Stock Occurance at Order Line Level
… and Out of Stocks at DC’s have reduced by 48%
(despite 6% volume growth in the last year)
48%
Our journey has already yielded benefits, but at
substantial effort (permanent items on auto-
pilot)
Q&A and Contact Details for more information
For more
information please
contact:
Thinus Hermann
Implementation Partner
Barnton Consulting
Mobile: +27 (0) 79 502 7515
Email: thinus@barnton-consulting.co.za
Elizbe Rohde
Implementation Project Manager
KFC Supply Chain Manager (South
Africa)
Landline: +27 (0) 11 790 9149
Mobile: +27 (0) 82 416 7029
Email: elizbe.rohde@yum.com

Formalized sales and operations planning (S&OP)

  • 1.
    Formalised Sales &Operations Planning (S&OP) – KFC Case Study Elizbe Rohde Implementation Project Manager KFC Supply Chain Manager (South Africa)
  • 2.
    Agenda • About KFC •Complexity in QSR • The Project • Lessons Learnt
  • 3.
    Did you knowthe following about KFC? Sell 400+ tons of chicken per day which to give a visual representation, is equal to the weight of 57 fully grown elephants (1.3m birds/ week) 57x Total Weight of KFC Mash sold per year equivalent to 2 Boeing 747’s (total dressings will fill up an Olympic sized swimming pool) 2x Add Hope feeds 100k children per day, enough to fill Ellis park stadium Yum! is the parent company of the brands KFC, Pizza Hut and Taco Bell which is the largest restaurant company in the world with ~41k restaurants in 125 countries KFC’s Original Recipe® chicken is still prepared to Colonel Sanders’ exact standards, using the secret blend of 11 herbs and spices he perfected back in 1940 Proud heritage in South Africa for the past 40 years with ~800 restaurants (~120 in the rest of Africa). Voted the most loved fast food brand in South Africa for the last 16 years
  • 4.
    Agenda • About KFC •Complexity in QSR • The Project • Lessons Learnt
  • 5.
    QSR Store Dynamicsdiffer to other industries and the way in which we need to forecast Clear Menu Item Trends • 800 Stores with similar menu items and trends (not multiple brands) sold directly to consumers • Products sold directly to consumer with immediate consumption vs. buying for future use results in clear POS sales data and trends • Significant growth from new stores (40 opened in 2014), forecasting needs to consider volume and store growth - forecast on Weekly Per Store Average (WPSA) • Different store types i.e. breakfast stores • Different menu types which include Permanent Items and Limited Time Offers (LTO’s) which adds additional complexity • Need to consider abnormal activities in the past that affects forecasts such as strikes impacting supply Easter Christmas
  • 6.
    Large component ofLimited Time Offers (LTO’s) or Promotions that have a high level of uncertainty • LTO = Promotion running for 7 – 15 weeks • Combination of unique and existing ingredients • Unique lifecycle: Need to balance out-of- stock vs. write-off’s through planning • Challenge: All ingredients on time in stores with high level of sales uncertainty which is greatest within start-up and growth phases • Consideration to impact on permanent items (cannibalisation on other items) LTO: Menu Item LTO: Ingredients New Menu Item Unique Ingredient (significant impact) Existing Ingredient (limited impact)
  • 7.
    Menu Items areconverted via a BOM to Ingredients 1 Bun 15g Sauce 6 Doritos 10g Lettuce 1 Fillet BOM Menu ItemIngredients • Menu Items are assembled from ingredients based on the Bill of Materials (BOM) or recipe • Forecasting is based on menu item store sales • Menu item sales are converted through the BOM to ingredients and gives a view of ingredient sales out of the store • Ingredient sales out of the store is compared to ingredients sales into the store from the 3PL supplier • Ingredients to Menu items have a one-to-many relationship
  • 8.
    Agenda • About KFC •Complexity in QSR • The Project • Lessons Learnt
  • 9.
    Why the needfor a formalised Sales & Operations Planning (S&OP) process and system that balances supply and demand
  • 10.
    The importance ofPlanning to bridge the gap between Strategy and Execution TACTICAL SUPPLY CHAIN PLANNING Plan supply Match demand and supply Plan demand Return OPERATIONAL EXECUTION STRATEGIC PLANNINGSTRATEGIC PLANNING Plan Source Make Deliver Sell
  • 11.
    KFC South AfricaS&OP journey and the way forward 20142013 Sustain the achievement and prepare for the next step to be a best in class organisation Complete/ In Progress Next focus areas No S&OP Processes and ad-hoc LTO Planning Bi-Monthly Demand Planning (with Excel based LTO’s) 2015 2016 Time Value S&OP for all items with supplier sharing and 3PL replenishment (LTO’s & permanent) Integrated Business Planning Extend to New Africa Markets We are here Select & Implement Planning System S&OP for current & upcoming LTOs (with Planning System)
  • 12.
    A formal S&OPprocess and system allowing KFC to be more pro-active and flexible with 3 main objectives Planning Forecast -ing Finance & Marketing Maintain good stock availability (involving less effort) especially with increased marketing complexity Improved Supply Chain control and pro-active forward visibility Increased visibility on permanent items (not only focused on LTO’s) 1 2 3 Main Objectives Supply Chain, Suppliers & 3PL Re-align supply with changing demand Stock Availability & Write-Offs Actual vs. Forecasted Demand
  • 13.
    We set detailedsub-objectives to guide our journey and the implementation of the project Good stock availability Reduced effort to plan (increased automation and fewer resources required) Improved Supply Chain control Pro-Active visibility of supply issues (LTO & permanent) Supplier & 3PL plans Forecasts and plans for permanent items (not current) Actual vs. Forecasted Demand Improved storage capacity planning visibility Better write-off management Integrated BOM management Current Future
  • 14.
    Planning for theKFC South Africa Supply Chain 3PL 5 DC’s 800 KFC’s100 Suppliers Supply Planning Demand Planning
  • 15.
    What the nextlevel in the maturity curve required given the multi-layered Supply Chain Store Supply Chain Source: Deliver: Make Store Supply Chain Source: Deliver: Make 3PL Source: Deliver 3PL Source: Deliver Supplier Supply Chain Source: Make: Deliver Supplier Supply Chain Source: Make: Deliver Plan 1 week ahead Forecast LTO’s Nationally New Process Old Process Forecast all menu items at regional level (some by store) Forecast and plan all ingredients by DC & Supplier Menu Items Converted through BOM to Ingredients
  • 16.
    … with atailored system Interface Master Data Forecasting Tool Demand Planning Open PO’s & Planning Parameters (lead time, minimum order quantities) > 3PL System Stock on Hand (SOH) from > 3PL System Ingredients/ DC Sales > 3PL System BOM (recipe info) > KFC System Menu Item/ Store Sales > KFC System (POS) Reports and data extraction Statistical and consensus forecast by week for menu items and ingredients Suggested purchase orders for ingredients by DC and supplier within constraints Sales History (weekly) SOH, PO’s, Planning Parameters (daily) Planning Tool Supply Planning
  • 17.
    In Summary Planning (SupplyPlan)Forecasting (Demand Plan) Store Sales Sales INTERFACE Menu Item Forecasting (by Region, LTO by Store) Ingredients Forecasting (by DC) DC and Supplier Planning for Ingredients BOM CONVERSION S&OP Process 1 2 3 4
  • 18.
    Agenda • About KFC •Complexity in QSR • The Project • Lessons Learnt
  • 19.
    Choose the rightservice provider in accordance with your requirements Sample of Key Clients Barnton Competitive Edge • Significant advanced forecasting & planning experience • Blue chip SA (incl. international) clients • Only planning systems vendor with local QSR experience (i.e. Famous Brands) • Highly recommended by SA Supply Chain practitioners • Flexible, configurable systems • “Simple” advanced planning system (not “overkill”)
  • 20.
    Strong project managementand a rigorous approach with strong governance is a critical success factor 20 Project Charter Governance & Stakeholder Management Approach & Timeline Project Plan
  • 21.
    What worked welland what didn’t What Worked Well Areas for Improvement • Interface effort and complexity underestimated • Data cleansing effort underestimated • Clearly defined scope i.e. BOM module development • Availability of key stakeholders • Implement consensus S&OP (Demand Planning) process prior to systems implementation • Project leadership very involved in understanding and guiding solution design • Strong project manager with good methodology & governance • Good buy-in through Cross Functional Team and stakeholder involvement and communication • Choose the right demand & supply planning solution with flexibility to tailor for KFC specific functional needs • Defined new roles and responsibilities in line with S&OP process (one new role) • Hands-on training with KFC’s real data and on-the- job coaching
  • 22.
    Since formalising theS&OP process, write-off spend has reduced by ~60% whilst doubling the number of promotions 7 10 14 0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16 0 100 200 300 400 500 600 700 2012 2013 2014 Thousands Promo Performance: Execution vs Write Off (ZAR) Write Offs Promos Effective write off cost per promo has been improving
  • 23.
    0 2 000 4 000 6000 8 000 10 000 12 000 14 000 16 000 2013 2014 Out of Stock Occurance at Order Line Level … and Out of Stocks at DC’s have reduced by 48% (despite 6% volume growth in the last year) 48% Our journey has already yielded benefits, but at substantial effort (permanent items on auto- pilot)
  • 24.
    Q&A and ContactDetails for more information For more information please contact: Thinus Hermann Implementation Partner Barnton Consulting Mobile: +27 (0) 79 502 7515 Email: thinus@barnton-consulting.co.za Elizbe Rohde Implementation Project Manager KFC Supply Chain Manager (South Africa) Landline: +27 (0) 11 790 9149 Mobile: +27 (0) 82 416 7029 Email: elizbe.rohde@yum.com