Why estimating?

As long there is the currency money in the
world of supply and demand, at least as
long the question will be asked:




  ‘  How much does it cost?

                 www.costengineering.eu
                                          ’
What is estimating?




                      www.costengineering.eu
Current Project Life Cycle

                                                                                                                                       Operational     Abandon
Identification phase                     Definition phase                                      Execution phase
                                                                                                                                         phase          phase


 Project     Feasibility   Development                                                                                   Commission.
                                             Basis for     Project             Detailed       Materials
initiation     study          plan                                                                        Construction     start-up
                                              design     specification         design       procurement
  note                                                                                                                    handover
  ± 40%        ± 25%          ± 25%
               Study          Budget
Screening                                                     ± 10%
 estimate     estimate       estimate
                                                              Control                                                                       Step 6       Step 7
                                                             estimate                             Commit. &
Economics    Economics      Economics                                                                                    Operations
                                                             commit.
                                                                                                  cost control           reference
                              Step 3
 Step 1        Step 2                                          plan
                                                                                                     ± 5%                   plan           Identical    Identical
                                                                                  Change
                              Initial                                             control           Counter                                   to           to
                                                            Economics
                             commit.                                                                estimate                               Execution    Execution
                               plan                           Step 4                                                                        phase        phase
                                                                                                     Step 5
                                                                                                                          Close out
 Approval     Approval                                       Project
                               initial                      execution
                            execution                         plan
                               plan                                                                                                                      Abandon
                                                                                                                                                          project
                                                            Operations                              Contract
                                                            reference                                control               Project
                                                               plan                                                        debrief
                                                                                                   Purchase
                             Review                                                               order control

                                                             Review                                Reporting

                             Approval


                                                             Approval




                                                                         www.costengineering.eu
Estimating cycle

              INITIATION UP TO CLOSE-OUT PHASE




SCREENING               STUDY                   BUDGET                CONTROL
 ESTIMATE              ESTIMATE                ESTIMATE               ESTIMATE




                         DATABASE
     CLOSE-OUT PHASE                                      EXECUTION PHASE



       'CLOSE-OUT'                                   COST               COUNTER
         REPORT
          (DETAILED
                                                    CONTROL             ESTIMATE
        INFORMATION)




                           www.costengineering.eu
How much time is spent?

AACE Cost Estimate Classification System - Process Industries
              Primary                                  Secondary Characteristic
            Characteristic

 ESTIMATE     LEVEL OF            END            METHODOLOGY              EXPECTED         PREPARATION
  CLASS       PROJECT            USAGE                                    ACCURACY           EFFORT
             DEFINITION                                                    RANGE

    5         0% to 2%           concept         capacity factored,    L: -20% to -50%          1
                                screening           parametric
                                                 models, judgment,     H: +30% to + 100%
                                                    or analogy

    4        1% to 15%            study or           equipment         L: -15% to -30%        2 to 4
                                 feasibility         factored or
                                                 parametric models     H: +20% to + 50%

    3        10% to 40%           budget,        semi-detailed unit    L: -10% to -20%        3 to 10
                              authorization or       cost with
                                  control        assembly level line   H: +10% to + 30%
                                                      items

    2        30% to 70%       control or bid /    detailed unit cost   L: -5% to -15%         4 to 20
                                  tender             with forced
                                                  detailed take-off    H: +5% to + 20%

    1       50% to 100%      check estimate or   detailed unit cost    L: -3% to -10%        5 to 100
                                bid / tender     with detailed take-
                                                         off           H: +3% to + 15%



                                       www.costengineering.eu
What information is needed?




www.costengineering.eu
Accuracy
           Level 1
          Screening
  90/10

          40 %         Level 2
                        Study
                                       Level 3
                                       Budget             Level 4
                      25 %
                                                          Control
                                     15 %                           90/10

 50/50
                                                          10 %
                                                                    50/50

                                                         5%
          20 %                        10 %                          Base
                      15 %                            -10 %
                                     -15 %                          10/90

Base
                      -25 %           Level 1              Level 2           Level 3     Level 4
                                     Screening              Study            Budget      Control
          -40 %              Base    € 80,000             € 85,000          € 90,000    € 95,000
10/90                        50/50   € 100,000            € 100,000         € 100,000   € 100,000
                             90/10   € 140,000            € 125,000         € 115,000   € 110,000
                             10/90   € 60,000             € 63,750          € 85,000    € 90,000

                                 www.costengineering.eu

Cost Engineering Principles Of Cost Estimating

  • 1.
    Why estimating? As longthere is the currency money in the world of supply and demand, at least as long the question will be asked: ‘ How much does it cost? www.costengineering.eu ’
  • 2.
    What is estimating? www.costengineering.eu
  • 3.
    Current Project LifeCycle Operational Abandon Identification phase Definition phase Execution phase phase phase Project Feasibility Development Commission. Basis for Project Detailed Materials initiation study plan Construction start-up design specification design procurement note handover ± 40% ± 25% ± 25% Study Budget Screening ± 10% estimate estimate estimate Control Step 6 Step 7 estimate Commit. & Economics Economics Economics Operations commit. cost control reference Step 3 Step 1 Step 2 plan ± 5% plan Identical Identical Change Initial control Counter to to Economics commit. estimate Execution Execution plan Step 4 phase phase Step 5 Close out Approval Approval Project initial execution execution plan plan Abandon project Operations Contract reference control Project plan debrief Purchase Review order control Review Reporting Approval Approval www.costengineering.eu
  • 4.
    Estimating cycle INITIATION UP TO CLOSE-OUT PHASE SCREENING STUDY BUDGET CONTROL ESTIMATE ESTIMATE ESTIMATE ESTIMATE DATABASE CLOSE-OUT PHASE EXECUTION PHASE 'CLOSE-OUT' COST COUNTER REPORT (DETAILED CONTROL ESTIMATE INFORMATION) www.costengineering.eu
  • 5.
    How much timeis spent? AACE Cost Estimate Classification System - Process Industries Primary Secondary Characteristic Characteristic ESTIMATE LEVEL OF END METHODOLOGY EXPECTED PREPARATION CLASS PROJECT USAGE ACCURACY EFFORT DEFINITION RANGE 5 0% to 2% concept capacity factored, L: -20% to -50% 1 screening parametric models, judgment, H: +30% to + 100% or analogy 4 1% to 15% study or equipment L: -15% to -30% 2 to 4 feasibility factored or parametric models H: +20% to + 50% 3 10% to 40% budget, semi-detailed unit L: -10% to -20% 3 to 10 authorization or cost with control assembly level line H: +10% to + 30% items 2 30% to 70% control or bid / detailed unit cost L: -5% to -15% 4 to 20 tender with forced detailed take-off H: +5% to + 20% 1 50% to 100% check estimate or detailed unit cost L: -3% to -10% 5 to 100 bid / tender with detailed take- off H: +3% to + 15% www.costengineering.eu
  • 6.
    What information isneeded? www.costengineering.eu
  • 7.
    Accuracy Level 1 Screening 90/10 40 % Level 2 Study Level 3 Budget Level 4 25 % Control 15 % 90/10 50/50 10 % 50/50 5% 20 % 10 % Base 15 % -10 % -15 % 10/90 Base -25 % Level 1 Level 2 Level 3 Level 4 Screening Study Budget Control -40 % Base € 80,000 € 85,000 € 90,000 € 95,000 10/90 50/50 € 100,000 € 100,000 € 100,000 € 100,000 90/10 € 140,000 € 125,000 € 115,000 € 110,000 10/90 € 60,000 € 63,750 € 85,000 € 90,000 www.costengineering.eu