SlideShare a Scribd company logo
Will Britain ever
learn to love
philanthropy?
Institute of Fundraising
Major Donor conference
28th January 2013


Dr Beth Breeze, University of Kent
No!
1.   Because of sustained negative/cynical media coverage.
2.   Because philanthropists are aware of that attitude and it’s a real
     barrier to giving.
3.   Because last year’s Budget proposal on capping charity tax relief
     put the debate back by a generation.




                                                     www.shaw-trust.org.uk
What do philanthropists say?
 “I am afraid of the media, it’s always negative… They have great power and there’s
 no right of reply”

 “Journalists decry giving. They enjoy digging the dirt. The press can be very hurtful”

 “Why are the media nasty? They don’t do good news, they are snide and they
 pander to jealousy. The obituaries of philanthropists are nice but during their lifetime
 journalists dig. There’s nothing to be done”

 “Reforming the press is a hopeless cause. We won’t be able to change their
 negative approach. You need to accept from the outset that whatever you do will be
 rubbished in newspapers because that’s what they’re there for. If you are giving
 money away people will think you are doing it for self-aggrandisement”

 [Journalism is] “the enemy of philanthropy”.

            All quotes from ‘Theresa Lloyd (2004) Why Rich Peoplewww.shaw-trust.org.uk
                                                                  Give. ACF/Philanthropy UK
What’s the evidence?

Adjectives preceding the word ‘philanthropist’ in UK media coverage:
Austere                       Status-seeking                Tax-ruse
Self-styled                   Couture-clad                  Saintly (sarcastically)
Disgraced                     Philandering                  Designer-trousered
Dickensian                    High-rolling                  Ruthless




                                                               www.shaw-trust.org.uk
What the papers say…
[Philanthropy] “attracts the bored and under-qualified”                       (The Times 29/3/06)
[Philanthropists are] “hypocrites with more money than sense”          (Independent on Sunday 17/9/06)
“Philanthropy is, if not exactly a dirty word in this country, at any rate nothing to shout about”
                                                                                      (Daily Mail 27/6/06)
[Philanthropists are] “motivated by a desire to be loved by as many as possible”
                                                                               (Sunday Telegraph 19/2/06)




“Bill Gates is giving millions to charity. So? Why not? What else could he possibly do with all
his money except coat himself in treacle and roll in banknotes?”
                                                                                      (Guardian 28/11/06)


“When the world’s second-richest man gives most of his money to the world’s richest man,
we do well to count our spoons”
                                                                                       (Guardian 28/6/06)



                                                                      www.shaw-trust.org.uk
Why don’t we love philanthropists?
Because philanthropists are treated like other celebrities – their existence invites
   intense scrutiny, comment and criticism.
Because of highly charged cultural attitudes towards wealth, success and class:
“Curry King”
“Fake Tan Queen”
“The man to blame for shell suits”
“The woman who gave us peppermint foot balm”

Because of ideas about the ‘undeserving rich’
People who’ve made too much money, too quickly and don’t dispose of it ‘well’
“Getting rich is now like body building. Do it too much or too quickly and you look stupid”
                                                                   www.shaw-trust.org.uk
   (Clive James)
Concluding thought: It’s not just us


“The word philanthropy and the idea it carries with it arouses mixed emotions… We
expect rich men to be generous with their wealth and criticise them when they are not;
but when they make benefaction, we question their motives, deplore the methods by
which they obtained their abundance and wonder whether their gifts will not do more
harm than good”
               Robert Bremner (1960) American Philanthropy. Chicago: Chicago University Press




                                                                  www.shaw-trust.org.uk

More Related Content

Viewers also liked

How to plan for effective growth
How to plan for effective growthHow to plan for effective growth
How to plan for effective growth
Natalie Blackburn
 
Adroit
AdroitAdroit
Looking for the win-win situation for grant makers and charities
Looking for the win-win situation for grant makers and charitiesLooking for the win-win situation for grant makers and charities
Looking for the win-win situation for grant makers and charities
Natalie Blackburn
 
The hallmarks of a model grant-maker
The hallmarks of a model grant-makerThe hallmarks of a model grant-maker
The hallmarks of a model grant-maker
Natalie Blackburn
 
Rnib
RnibRnib
Oxfam
OxfamOxfam
Getting there
Getting there Getting there
Getting there
Natalie Blackburn
 
Building a positive relationship with funders
Building a positive relationship with fundersBuilding a positive relationship with funders
Building a positive relationship with funders
Natalie Blackburn
 
St peters hospice
St peters hospiceSt peters hospice
St peters hospice
Natalie Blackburn
 
In-house face to face fundraising
In-house face to face fundraisingIn-house face to face fundraising
In-house face to face fundraising
Natalie Blackburn
 
Oxfam
OxfamOxfam
World jewish relief
World jewish reliefWorld jewish relief
World jewish relief
Natalie Blackburn
 
Raising the profile of research
Raising the profile of research Raising the profile of research
Raising the profile of research
Natalie Blackburn
 
Telephone fundraising in the arts
Telephone fundraising in the artsTelephone fundraising in the arts
Telephone fundraising in the arts
Natalie Blackburn
 
Gary hancock
Gary hancockGary hancock
Gary hancock
Natalie Blackburn
 
How to really sell your charity
How to really sell your charityHow to really sell your charity
How to really sell your charity
Natalie Blackburn
 
Make data work harder
Make data work harder Make data work harder
Make data work harder
Natalie Blackburn
 
breaking into Europe
breaking into Europebreaking into Europe
breaking into Europe
Natalie Blackburn
 

Viewers also liked (18)

How to plan for effective growth
How to plan for effective growthHow to plan for effective growth
How to plan for effective growth
 
Adroit
AdroitAdroit
Adroit
 
Looking for the win-win situation for grant makers and charities
Looking for the win-win situation for grant makers and charitiesLooking for the win-win situation for grant makers and charities
Looking for the win-win situation for grant makers and charities
 
The hallmarks of a model grant-maker
The hallmarks of a model grant-makerThe hallmarks of a model grant-maker
The hallmarks of a model grant-maker
 
Rnib
RnibRnib
Rnib
 
Oxfam
OxfamOxfam
Oxfam
 
Getting there
Getting there Getting there
Getting there
 
Building a positive relationship with funders
Building a positive relationship with fundersBuilding a positive relationship with funders
Building a positive relationship with funders
 
St peters hospice
St peters hospiceSt peters hospice
St peters hospice
 
In-house face to face fundraising
In-house face to face fundraisingIn-house face to face fundraising
In-house face to face fundraising
 
Oxfam
OxfamOxfam
Oxfam
 
World jewish relief
World jewish reliefWorld jewish relief
World jewish relief
 
Raising the profile of research
Raising the profile of research Raising the profile of research
Raising the profile of research
 
Telephone fundraising in the arts
Telephone fundraising in the artsTelephone fundraising in the arts
Telephone fundraising in the arts
 
Gary hancock
Gary hancockGary hancock
Gary hancock
 
How to really sell your charity
How to really sell your charityHow to really sell your charity
How to really sell your charity
 
Make data work harder
Make data work harder Make data work harder
Make data work harder
 
breaking into Europe
breaking into Europebreaking into Europe
breaking into Europe
 

Similar to Cgap

What's wrong with fundraising. IOF 2015 presentation
What's wrong with fundraising. IOF 2015 presentationWhat's wrong with fundraising. IOF 2015 presentation
What's wrong with fundraising. IOF 2015 presentation
queerideas
 
Philanthropy diversity and inclusion slides (rhodri davies)
Philanthropy diversity and  inclusion slides (rhodri davies)Philanthropy diversity and  inclusion slides (rhodri davies)
Philanthropy diversity and inclusion slides (rhodri davies)
rhoddavies1
 
Computer Mouse Essay
Computer Mouse EssayComputer Mouse Essay
Computer Mouse Essay
Trina Locklear
 
Power and Philanthropy: CP Charterhouse Presentation Sept 2013
Power and Philanthropy: CP Charterhouse Presentation Sept 2013Power and Philanthropy: CP Charterhouse Presentation Sept 2013
Power and Philanthropy: CP Charterhouse Presentation Sept 2013
Giving Centre
 
History of philanthropy in city of london guildhall library event
History of philanthropy in city of london  guildhall library eventHistory of philanthropy in city of london  guildhall library event
History of philanthropy in city of london guildhall library event
rhoddavies1
 
More than money: The meaning and purpose of contemporary UK philanthropy
More than money: The meaning and purpose of contemporary UK philanthropyMore than money: The meaning and purpose of contemporary UK philanthropy
More than money: The meaning and purpose of contemporary UK philanthropy
Giving Centre
 
Philanthropy and Civic Identity
Philanthropy and Civic IdentityPhilanthropy and Civic Identity
Philanthropy and Civic Identity
rhoddavies1
 
Essay Story About Kidnapping. Online assignment writing service.
Essay Story About Kidnapping. Online assignment writing service.Essay Story About Kidnapping. Online assignment writing service.
Essay Story About Kidnapping. Online assignment writing service.
Megan Williams
 
Capitalism in Crisis
Capitalism in CrisisCapitalism in Crisis
Capitalism in Crisis
Asad Zaman
 
Solution Air Pollution Essay
Solution Air Pollution EssaySolution Air Pollution Essay
Solution Air Pollution Essay
Sarah Prabha
 
Example Of An Introduction For A Research Paper How To Make
Example Of An Introduction For A Research Paper  How To MakeExample Of An Introduction For A Research Paper  How To Make
Example Of An Introduction For A Research Paper How To Make
Melissa Dudas
 
008 Film Evaluation Essay Example On Mo. Online assignment writing service.
008 Film Evaluation Essay Example On Mo. Online assignment writing service.008 Film Evaluation Essay Example On Mo. Online assignment writing service.
008 Film Evaluation Essay Example On Mo. Online assignment writing service.
Dustin Pytko
 
Capitalism
CapitalismCapitalism
Capitalism
Kyle Patrick
 
We, the Sheeple Vs. the Banksters
We, the Sheeple Vs. the BankstersWe, the Sheeple Vs. the Banksters
We, the Sheeple Vs. the Banksters
lauren tratar
 
PPT - How To Write A DBQ PowerPoint Presentation, F
PPT - How To Write A DBQ PowerPoint Presentation, FPPT - How To Write A DBQ PowerPoint Presentation, F
PPT - How To Write A DBQ PowerPoint Presentation, F
Wendy Fox
 
Short Essay On Welcome To Mars
Short Essay On Welcome To MarsShort Essay On Welcome To Mars
Short Essay On Welcome To Mars
Melissa Smith
 
3 Analytical Essay Outline Templates Free Premiu
3 Analytical Essay Outline Templates Free Premiu3 Analytical Essay Outline Templates Free Premiu
3 Analytical Essay Outline Templates Free Premiu
Sandra Willey
 

Similar to Cgap (17)

What's wrong with fundraising. IOF 2015 presentation
What's wrong with fundraising. IOF 2015 presentationWhat's wrong with fundraising. IOF 2015 presentation
What's wrong with fundraising. IOF 2015 presentation
 
Philanthropy diversity and inclusion slides (rhodri davies)
Philanthropy diversity and  inclusion slides (rhodri davies)Philanthropy diversity and  inclusion slides (rhodri davies)
Philanthropy diversity and inclusion slides (rhodri davies)
 
Computer Mouse Essay
Computer Mouse EssayComputer Mouse Essay
Computer Mouse Essay
 
Power and Philanthropy: CP Charterhouse Presentation Sept 2013
Power and Philanthropy: CP Charterhouse Presentation Sept 2013Power and Philanthropy: CP Charterhouse Presentation Sept 2013
Power and Philanthropy: CP Charterhouse Presentation Sept 2013
 
History of philanthropy in city of london guildhall library event
History of philanthropy in city of london  guildhall library eventHistory of philanthropy in city of london  guildhall library event
History of philanthropy in city of london guildhall library event
 
More than money: The meaning and purpose of contemporary UK philanthropy
More than money: The meaning and purpose of contemporary UK philanthropyMore than money: The meaning and purpose of contemporary UK philanthropy
More than money: The meaning and purpose of contemporary UK philanthropy
 
Philanthropy and Civic Identity
Philanthropy and Civic IdentityPhilanthropy and Civic Identity
Philanthropy and Civic Identity
 
Essay Story About Kidnapping. Online assignment writing service.
Essay Story About Kidnapping. Online assignment writing service.Essay Story About Kidnapping. Online assignment writing service.
Essay Story About Kidnapping. Online assignment writing service.
 
Capitalism in Crisis
Capitalism in CrisisCapitalism in Crisis
Capitalism in Crisis
 
Solution Air Pollution Essay
Solution Air Pollution EssaySolution Air Pollution Essay
Solution Air Pollution Essay
 
Example Of An Introduction For A Research Paper How To Make
Example Of An Introduction For A Research Paper  How To MakeExample Of An Introduction For A Research Paper  How To Make
Example Of An Introduction For A Research Paper How To Make
 
008 Film Evaluation Essay Example On Mo. Online assignment writing service.
008 Film Evaluation Essay Example On Mo. Online assignment writing service.008 Film Evaluation Essay Example On Mo. Online assignment writing service.
008 Film Evaluation Essay Example On Mo. Online assignment writing service.
 
Capitalism
CapitalismCapitalism
Capitalism
 
We, the Sheeple Vs. the Banksters
We, the Sheeple Vs. the BankstersWe, the Sheeple Vs. the Banksters
We, the Sheeple Vs. the Banksters
 
PPT - How To Write A DBQ PowerPoint Presentation, F
PPT - How To Write A DBQ PowerPoint Presentation, FPPT - How To Write A DBQ PowerPoint Presentation, F
PPT - How To Write A DBQ PowerPoint Presentation, F
 
Short Essay On Welcome To Mars
Short Essay On Welcome To MarsShort Essay On Welcome To Mars
Short Essay On Welcome To Mars
 
3 Analytical Essay Outline Templates Free Premiu
3 Analytical Essay Outline Templates Free Premiu3 Analytical Essay Outline Templates Free Premiu
3 Analytical Essay Outline Templates Free Premiu
 

More from Natalie Blackburn

Getting the most from charity of the year partnerships
Getting the most from charity of the year partnershipsGetting the most from charity of the year partnerships
Getting the most from charity of the year partnerships
Natalie Blackburn
 
Keeping the passion alive: Avon and Breakthrough's 21 year partnership
Keeping the passion alive: Avon and Breakthrough's 21 year partnership Keeping the passion alive: Avon and Breakthrough's 21 year partnership
Keeping the passion alive: Avon and Breakthrough's 21 year partnership
Natalie Blackburn
 
Regional corporate fundraising
Regional corporate fundraisingRegional corporate fundraising
Regional corporate fundraising
Natalie Blackburn
 
Working with corporates as partners and clients
Working with corporates as partners and clientsWorking with corporates as partners and clients
Working with corporates as partners and clients
Natalie Blackburn
 
Thinking big beyond the corporate csr budget
Thinking big   beyond the corporate csr budgetThinking big   beyond the corporate csr budget
Thinking big beyond the corporate csr budget
Natalie Blackburn
 
Money for life with family action case study
Money for life with family action   case studyMoney for life with family action   case study
Money for life with family action case study
Natalie Blackburn
 
Transforming corporate partnerships
Transforming corporate partnershipsTransforming corporate partnerships
Transforming corporate partnerships
Natalie Blackburn
 
The changing face of corporate fundraising
The changing face of corporate fundraisingThe changing face of corporate fundraising
The changing face of corporate fundraising
Natalie Blackburn
 
Branded fundraising pages
Branded fundraising pagesBranded fundraising pages
Branded fundraising pages
Natalie Blackburn
 
Effective event promotion
Effective event promotionEffective event promotion
Effective event promotion
Natalie Blackburn
 
Social media and events
Social media and eventsSocial media and events
Social media and events
Natalie Blackburn
 
Ensuring supporters reach their targets
Ensuring supporters reach their targetsEnsuring supporters reach their targets
Ensuring supporters reach their targets
Natalie Blackburn
 
From ticket buyer to donor
From ticket buyer to donorFrom ticket buyer to donor
From ticket buyer to donor
Natalie Blackburn
 
Flagship events - flash in the pan, slow burners or quick death?
Flagship events - flash in the pan, slow burners or quick death?Flagship events - flash in the pan, slow burners or quick death?
Flagship events - flash in the pan, slow burners or quick death?
Natalie Blackburn
 
19 ideas to improve your supporters' loyalty
19 ideas to improve your supporters' loyalty 19 ideas to improve your supporters' loyalty
19 ideas to improve your supporters' loyalty
Natalie Blackburn
 
Optimising return on investment
Optimising return on investment Optimising return on investment
Optimising return on investment
Natalie Blackburn
 
Great recruitment propositions
Great recruitment propositionsGreat recruitment propositions
Great recruitment propositions
Natalie Blackburn
 
Developing a perfect proposition
Developing a perfect propositionDeveloping a perfect proposition
Developing a perfect proposition
Natalie Blackburn
 
Getting testing right
Getting testing right Getting testing right
Getting testing right
Natalie Blackburn
 
Drtv on a budget
Drtv on a budget Drtv on a budget
Drtv on a budget
Natalie Blackburn
 

More from Natalie Blackburn (20)

Getting the most from charity of the year partnerships
Getting the most from charity of the year partnershipsGetting the most from charity of the year partnerships
Getting the most from charity of the year partnerships
 
Keeping the passion alive: Avon and Breakthrough's 21 year partnership
Keeping the passion alive: Avon and Breakthrough's 21 year partnership Keeping the passion alive: Avon and Breakthrough's 21 year partnership
Keeping the passion alive: Avon and Breakthrough's 21 year partnership
 
Regional corporate fundraising
Regional corporate fundraisingRegional corporate fundraising
Regional corporate fundraising
 
Working with corporates as partners and clients
Working with corporates as partners and clientsWorking with corporates as partners and clients
Working with corporates as partners and clients
 
Thinking big beyond the corporate csr budget
Thinking big   beyond the corporate csr budgetThinking big   beyond the corporate csr budget
Thinking big beyond the corporate csr budget
 
Money for life with family action case study
Money for life with family action   case studyMoney for life with family action   case study
Money for life with family action case study
 
Transforming corporate partnerships
Transforming corporate partnershipsTransforming corporate partnerships
Transforming corporate partnerships
 
The changing face of corporate fundraising
The changing face of corporate fundraisingThe changing face of corporate fundraising
The changing face of corporate fundraising
 
Branded fundraising pages
Branded fundraising pagesBranded fundraising pages
Branded fundraising pages
 
Effective event promotion
Effective event promotionEffective event promotion
Effective event promotion
 
Social media and events
Social media and eventsSocial media and events
Social media and events
 
Ensuring supporters reach their targets
Ensuring supporters reach their targetsEnsuring supporters reach their targets
Ensuring supporters reach their targets
 
From ticket buyer to donor
From ticket buyer to donorFrom ticket buyer to donor
From ticket buyer to donor
 
Flagship events - flash in the pan, slow burners or quick death?
Flagship events - flash in the pan, slow burners or quick death?Flagship events - flash in the pan, slow burners or quick death?
Flagship events - flash in the pan, slow burners or quick death?
 
19 ideas to improve your supporters' loyalty
19 ideas to improve your supporters' loyalty 19 ideas to improve your supporters' loyalty
19 ideas to improve your supporters' loyalty
 
Optimising return on investment
Optimising return on investment Optimising return on investment
Optimising return on investment
 
Great recruitment propositions
Great recruitment propositionsGreat recruitment propositions
Great recruitment propositions
 
Developing a perfect proposition
Developing a perfect propositionDeveloping a perfect proposition
Developing a perfect proposition
 
Getting testing right
Getting testing right Getting testing right
Getting testing right
 
Drtv on a budget
Drtv on a budget Drtv on a budget
Drtv on a budget
 

Cgap

  • 1. Will Britain ever learn to love philanthropy? Institute of Fundraising Major Donor conference 28th January 2013 Dr Beth Breeze, University of Kent
  • 2. No! 1. Because of sustained negative/cynical media coverage. 2. Because philanthropists are aware of that attitude and it’s a real barrier to giving. 3. Because last year’s Budget proposal on capping charity tax relief put the debate back by a generation. www.shaw-trust.org.uk
  • 3. What do philanthropists say? “I am afraid of the media, it’s always negative… They have great power and there’s no right of reply” “Journalists decry giving. They enjoy digging the dirt. The press can be very hurtful” “Why are the media nasty? They don’t do good news, they are snide and they pander to jealousy. The obituaries of philanthropists are nice but during their lifetime journalists dig. There’s nothing to be done” “Reforming the press is a hopeless cause. We won’t be able to change their negative approach. You need to accept from the outset that whatever you do will be rubbished in newspapers because that’s what they’re there for. If you are giving money away people will think you are doing it for self-aggrandisement” [Journalism is] “the enemy of philanthropy”. All quotes from ‘Theresa Lloyd (2004) Why Rich Peoplewww.shaw-trust.org.uk Give. ACF/Philanthropy UK
  • 4. What’s the evidence? Adjectives preceding the word ‘philanthropist’ in UK media coverage: Austere Status-seeking Tax-ruse Self-styled Couture-clad Saintly (sarcastically) Disgraced Philandering Designer-trousered Dickensian High-rolling Ruthless www.shaw-trust.org.uk
  • 5. What the papers say… [Philanthropy] “attracts the bored and under-qualified” (The Times 29/3/06) [Philanthropists are] “hypocrites with more money than sense” (Independent on Sunday 17/9/06) “Philanthropy is, if not exactly a dirty word in this country, at any rate nothing to shout about” (Daily Mail 27/6/06) [Philanthropists are] “motivated by a desire to be loved by as many as possible” (Sunday Telegraph 19/2/06) “Bill Gates is giving millions to charity. So? Why not? What else could he possibly do with all his money except coat himself in treacle and roll in banknotes?” (Guardian 28/11/06) “When the world’s second-richest man gives most of his money to the world’s richest man, we do well to count our spoons” (Guardian 28/6/06) www.shaw-trust.org.uk
  • 6. Why don’t we love philanthropists? Because philanthropists are treated like other celebrities – their existence invites intense scrutiny, comment and criticism. Because of highly charged cultural attitudes towards wealth, success and class: “Curry King” “Fake Tan Queen” “The man to blame for shell suits” “The woman who gave us peppermint foot balm” Because of ideas about the ‘undeserving rich’ People who’ve made too much money, too quickly and don’t dispose of it ‘well’ “Getting rich is now like body building. Do it too much or too quickly and you look stupid” www.shaw-trust.org.uk (Clive James)
  • 7. Concluding thought: It’s not just us “The word philanthropy and the idea it carries with it arouses mixed emotions… We expect rich men to be generous with their wealth and criticise them when they are not; but when they make benefaction, we question their motives, deplore the methods by which they obtained their abundance and wonder whether their gifts will not do more harm than good” Robert Bremner (1960) American Philanthropy. Chicago: Chicago University Press www.shaw-trust.org.uk