SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 28
Download to read offline
NATO CAPSTONE CONCEPT: MILITARY CONTRIBUTION TO COUNTERING HYBRID THREATS
1. SURVEILLANCE, DETECTION, RECOGNITION,
IDENTIFICATION AND ANALYSIS OF CHALLENGES, RISKS
AND THREATS TO NATIONAL SECURITY
1.1. EXISTENCE OF INSTITUTIONAL BODIES FOR
RECOGNITION AND MONITORING NATIONAL
SECURITY CHALLENGES, RISKS AND THREATS
№ NATIONAL SECURITY SYSTEM’S BASIC FUNCTIONS INSTITUTIONAL ROLE
1.
1. SURVEILLANCE, DETECTION, RECOGNITION,
IDENTIFICATION AND ANALYSIS OF CHALLENGES, RISKS AND
THREATS TO NATIONAL SECURITY
PRIMARY SECONDARY INSIGNIFICANT
I DON’T
KNOW
COMPLETELY BUILT
CAPABILITIES:
FULL
CAPABILITIES BUILT
TO A LARGE EXTENT:
RATHER FULL
CAPABILITIES BUILT
TO A MIDDLE STAGE:
MIDDLE
MARGINALLY BUILT
CAPABILITIES:
INSIGNIFICANT
LACK OF
CAPABILITIES:
MISSING
I CAN’T DECIDE
5 4 3 2 1 0
ASSESSMENT OF THE AVAILABLE CAPABILITIES TO EXECUTE
THIS FUNCTION
FULL
RATHER
FULL
MIDDLE
INSIGNIFI
CANT
MISSING
I DON’T
KNOW
1.1
AVAILABILITY OF INSTITUTIONAL BODIES FOR MONITORING
AND DISCLOSURE NATIONAL SECURITY CHALLENGES, RISKS
AND THREATS
5 4 3 2 1 0
1
2
3
EXTREMELY HIGH
INFLUENCE OR NEED
HIGH INFLUENCE OR
NEED
MIDDLE INFLUENCE
OR NEED
INSUFFICIENT
INFLUENCE OR NEED
LACK OF INFLUENCE
OR NEED
I DON’T KNOW
5 4 3 2 1 0
ASSESSMENT OF THE CAPABILITIES AVAILABILITY FOR THE FUNCTION
EXECUTION
EXTREMELY
HIGH
HIGH MIDDLE INSUFFICIENT MISSING
I DON’T
KNOW
1.4
ANALYSES AND ASSESSMENTS INFLUENCE ON THE
DECISION MAKING
5 4 3 2 1 0
ASSESSMENT OF THE CAPABILITY DEVELOPMENT NEED
EXTREMELY
HIGH
HIGH MIDDLE INSUFFICIENT MISSING
I DON’T
KNOW
1.6
NEED FOR INSTITUTIONAL CAPABILITIES
DEVELOPMENT AND MODERNIZATION
5 4 3 2 1 0
4
5
6
1 LAWS, REGULATIONS, STRATEGIES, DOCTRINES, CONCEPTS, PROGRAMS AND PLANS 5 4 3 2 1 0
7
STATISTICAL
ANALYSIS
METHODS:
1. ANALYSIS OF AVERAGES - TO PRESENT THE VALUE ESTIMATE OF THE AVERAGE LEVEL OF RESEARCH FUNCTION
2. ANALYSIS OF THE STANDARD DEVIATION - TO ACCOMMODATE THE CONVERGENCE OR DIVERSITY OF THE RESULTS
3. NONPARAMETRIC METHODS MANN-WHITNEY AND KRUSKAL-WALLIS - TO PROVE OR DISPROVE THE STATISTICAL SIGNIFICANCE
8
2 STRUCTURES, ORGANIZATIONS, SYSTEMS 5 4 3 2 1 0
3 EDUCATION, TRAINING, EXERCISES 5 4 3 2 1 0
4 EQUIPMENT AND MATERIALS 5 4 3 2 1 0
5 MANAGEMENT, COMMAND AND CONTROL 5 4 3 2 1 0
6 PERSONNEL 5 4 3 2 1 0
7 INFRASTRUCTURE, CRITICAL INFRASTRUCTURE 5 4 3 2 1 0
8 COOPERATION AND INTEROPERABILITY 5 4 3 2 1 0
DISCUSSION AREAS MAIN TOPICS
1
1
DEFINING POTENTIAL HYBRID THREATS WHOSE OCCURRENCE
COULD THREATEN THE NATIONAL INTERESTS OF THE
REPUBLIC OF BULGARIA
ENERGY SECURITY, TERRORISM, DEMOGRAPHY, MIGRATION,
INFORMATION SECURITY, CORRUPTION, STATE INSTITUTIONS
FUNCTIONING, ETHNIC MARGINALIZATION AND ALIENATION ……
2
DEFINING INSTITUTIONAL CAPABILITIES TO COUNTERING
HYBRID THREATS
CRITICAL INFRASTRUCTURE PROTECTION, INSTITUTIONS
RESILIENCE, EDUCATION & TRAINING, STRATEGIC ENERGY
BALANCE, BORDER PROTECTION, SOCIAL SECURITY MEASURES…….
3
DEFINING AND ANALYSIS OF AVAILABLE INSTITUTIONAL
CAPABILITIES TO COUNTERING HYBRID THREATS
CYBER SECURITY/DEFENSE, SURVEILLANCE SYSTEMS, BORDER
SECURITY, MIGRATION POLICY AND MEASURES, FINANCIAL
SECURITY, INTERNAL SECURITY AND CRIME, LAW ENFORCEMENT....
4
DEFICIT OF INSTITUTIONAL/NATIONAL CAPABILITIES TO
COUNTERING HYBRID THREATS
NATIONAL LEGAL BASE, PREVENTION CAPABILITIES, CYBER
SECURITY, CRITICAL INFRASTRUCTURE AND BORDER PROTECTION,
INFORMATION SECURITY, ENERGY SECURITY, INTEROPERABILITY…..
5
FORMS AND METHODS FOR INTERINSTITUTIONAL
COOPERATION IN CAPABILITIES DEVELOPMENT AND USE
SECURITY STANDING OPERATIONAL PROCEDURES, EDUCATION,
TRAINING AND EXERCISING, SURVEILLANCE AND SITUATION
CENTERS, INFORMATION DISTRIBUTION AND SHARING…………….
FINDINGS
1. NEED OF DEVELOPMENT MODERNIZATION OF NATIONAL LEGAL BASE AND INSTITUTIONAL STRATEGIC DOCUMENTS
2. ENLARGING INSTITUTIONAL AWARENESS AND INTEROPERABILITY IN CAPABILITY DEVELOPMENT AND USE AREAS
3. INGROWING INTERINSTITUTIONAL AND INTERNATIONAL COOPERATION TO COUNTERING HYBRID THREATS
2
1. MONITORING, DETECTION, IDENTIFICATION AND ANALYSIS OF CHALLENGES,
RISKS AND THREATS TO NATIONAL SECURITY
MOD&AF (60)
SECONDARY
55%
LEAD INST (7)
PRIMARY
67%
CIVILIAN INST
(11)
SECONDARY
73%
11.1
Availability of institutional capabilities for detecting and monitoring
national security challenges, risks and threats
3,30 ,96 3,43 ,79 2,60 1,43
11.2
Availability of institutional capabilities for analysis and assessment
national security challenges, risks and threats development
3,37 ,90 3,29 ,76 2,50 1,08
11.3
Availability of institutional capabilities for receiving/sharing information of
national security challenges, risks and threats development
3,39 ,95 3,57 ,98 3,00 ,82
11.4
Influence of analysis and assessment of the development challenges, risks
and threats on the decision making processes
3,43 ,95 3,57 1,13 2,90 1,10
11.5
Influence of analysis and assessment of the development challenges, risks
and threats on the development of institutional/national legal base
3,27 ,95 3,57 1,13 2,70 1,34
11.6
Need of development and modernization of institutional capabilities for
detecting and monitoring national security challenges, risks and threats
3,78 ,89 3,71 ,49 3,40 ,97
1. MONITORING, DETECTION, IDENTIFICATION AND ANALYSIS OF CHALLENGES,
RISKS AND THREATS TO NATIONAL SECURITY
MOD&AF (60)
SECONDARY
55%
LEAD INST (7)
PRIMARY
67%
CIVILIAN INST
(11)
SECONDARY
73%
11.1
Availability of institutional capabilities for detecting and monitoring
national security challenges, risks and threats
3,30 ,96 3,43 ,79 2,60 1,43
11.2
Availability of institutional capabilities for analysis and assessment
national security challenges, risks and threats development
3,37 ,90 3,29 ,76 2,50 1,08
11.3
Availability of institutional capabilities for receiving/sharing information
of national security challenges, risks and threats development
3,39 ,95 3,57 ,98 3,00 ,82
11.4
Influence of analysis and assessment of the development challenges,
risks and threats on the decision making processes
3,43 ,95 3,57 1,13 2,90 1,10
11.5
Influence of analysis and assessment of the development challenges,
risks and threats on the development of institutional/national legal base
3,27 ,95 3,57 1,13 2,70 1,34
11.6
Need of development and modernization of institutional capabilities for
detecting and monitoring national security challenges, risks and threats
3,78 ,89 3,71 ,49 3,40 ,97
1. MONITORING, DETECTION, IDENTIFICATION AND ANALYSIS OF CHALLENGES,
RISKS AND THREATS TO NATIONAL SECURITY
MOD&AF (60)
SECONDARY
55%
LEAD INST (7)
PRIMARY
67%
CIVILIAN INST
(11)
SECONDARY
73%
11.1
Availability of institutional capabilities for detecting and monitoring
national security challenges, risks and threats
3,30 ,96 3,43 ,79 2,60 1,43
11.2
Availability of institutional capabilities for analysis and assessment
national security challenges, risks and threats development
3,37 ,90 3,29 ,76 2,50 1,08
11.3
Availability of institutional capabilities for receiving/sharing information
of national security challenges, risks and threats development
3,39 ,95 3,57 ,98 3,00 ,82
11.4
Influence of analysis and assessment of the development challenges,
risks and threats on the decision making processes
3,43 ,95 3,57 1,13 2,90 1,10
11.5
Influence of analysis and assessment of the development challenges,
risks and threats on the development of institutional/national legal base
3,27 ,95 3,57 1,13 2,70 1,34
11.6
Need of development and modernization of institutional capabilities for
detecting and monitoring national security challenges, risks and threats
3,78 ,89 3,71 ,49 3,40 ,97
1. MONITORING, DETECTION, IDENTIFICATION AND ANALYSIS OF CHALLENGES,
RISKS AND THREATS TO NATIONAL SECURITY
MOD&AF (60)
SECONDARY
55%
LEAD INST (7)
PRIMARY
67%
CIVILIAN INST
(11)
SECONDARY
73%
11.1
Availability of institutional capabilities for detecting and monitoring
national security challenges, risks and threats
3,30 ,96 3,43 ,79 2,60 1,43
11.2
Availability of institutional capabilities for analysis and assessment
national security challenges, risks and threats development
3,37 ,90 3,29 ,76 2,50 1,08
11.3
Availability of institutional capabilities for receiving/sharing information
of national security challenges, risks and threats development
3,39 ,95 3,57 ,98 3,00 ,82
11.4
Influence of analysis and assessment of the development challenges,
risks and threats on the decision making processes
3,43 ,95 3,57 1,13 2,90 1,10
11.5
Influence of analysis and assessment of the development challenges,
risks and threats on the development of institutional/national legal base
3,27 ,95 3,57 1,13 2,70 1,34
11.6
Need of development and modernization of institutional capabilities for
detecting and monitoring national security challenges, risks and threats
3,78 ,89 3,71 ,49 3,40 ,97
1. MONITORING, DETECTION, IDENTIFICATION AND ANALYSIS OF CHALLENGES,
RISKS AND THREATS TO NATIONAL SECURITY
MOD&AF (60)
SECONDARY
55%
LEAD INST (7)
PRIMARY
67%
CIVILIAN INST
(11)
SECONDARY
73%
11.1
Availability of institutional capabilities for detecting and monitoring
national security challenges, risks and threats
3,30 ,96 3,43 ,79 2,60 1,43
11.2
Availability of institutional capabilities for analysis and assessment
national security challenges, risks and threats development
3,37 ,90 3,29 ,76 2,50 1,08
11.3
Availability of institutional capabilities for receiving/sharing information
of national security challenges, risks and threats development
3,39 ,95 3,57 ,98 3,00 ,82
11.4
Influence of analysis and assessment of the development challenges,
risks and threats on the decision making processes
3,43 ,95 3,57 1,13 2,90 1,10
11.5
Influence of analysis and assessment of the development challenges,
risks and threats on the development of institutional/national legal base
3,27 ,95 3,57 1,13 2,70 1,34
11.6
Need of development and modernization of institutional capabilities for
detecting and monitoring national security challenges, risks and threats
3,78 ,89 3,71 ,49 3,40 ,97
1. MONITORING, DETECTION, IDENTIFICATION AND ANALYSIS OF CHALLENGES,
RISKS AND THREATS TO NATIONAL SECURITY
MOD&AF (60)
SECONDARY
55%
LEAD INST (7)
PRIMARY
67%
CIVILIAN INST
(11)
SECONDARY
73%
11.1
Availability of institutional capabilities for detecting and monitoring
national security challenges, risks and threats
3,30 ,96 3,43 ,79 2,60 1,43
11.2
Availability of institutional capabilities for analysis and assessment
national security challenges, risks and threats development
3,37 ,90 3,29 ,76 2,50 1,08
11.3
Availability of institutional capabilities for receiving/sharing information
of national security challenges, risks and threats development
3,39 ,95 3,57 ,98 3,00 ,82
11.4
Influence of analysis and assessment of the development challenges,
risks and threats on the decision making processes
3,43 ,95 3,57 1,13 2,90 1,10
11.5
Influence of analysis and assessment of the development challenges,
risks and threats on the development of institutional/national legal base
3,27 ,95 3,57 1,13 2,70 1,34
11.6
Need of development and modernization of institutional capabilities for
detecting and monitoring national security challenges, risks and threats
3,78 ,89 3,71 ,49 3,40 ,97
1. MONITORING, DETECTION, IDENTIFICATION AND ANALYSIS OF CHALLENGES,
RISKS AND THREATS TO NATIONAL SECURITY
MOD&AF (60)
SECONDARY
55%
LEAD INST (7)
PRIMARY
67%
CIVILIAN INST
(11)
SECONDARY
73%
11.1
Availability of institutional capabilities for detecting and monitoring
national security challenges, risks and threats
3,30 ,96 3,43 ,79 2,60 1,43
11.2
Availability of institutional capabilities for analysis and assessment
national security challenges, risks and threats development
3,37 ,90 3,29 ,76 2,50 1,08
11.3
Availability of institutional capabilities for receiving/sharing information
of national security challenges, risks and threats development
3,39 ,95 3,57 ,98 3,00 ,82
11.4
Influence of analysis and assessment of the development challenges,
risks and threats on the decision making processes
3,43 ,95 3,57 1,13 2,90 1,10
11.5
Influence of analysis and assessment of the development challenges,
risks and threats on the development of institutional/national legal base
3,27 ,95 3,57 1,13 2,70 1,34
11.6
Need of development and modernization of institutional capabilities for
detecting and monitoring national security challenges, risks and threats
3,78 ,89 3,71 ,49 3,40 ,97
1. MONITORING, DETECTION, IDENTIFICATION AND ANALYSIS OF CHALLENGES,
RISKS AND THREATS TO NATIONAL SECURITY
MOD&AF (60)
SECONDARY
55%
LEAD INST (7)
PRIMARY
67%
CIVILIAN INST
(11)
SECONDARY
73%
11.1
Availability of institutional capabilities for detecting and monitoring
national security challenges, risks and threats
3,30 ,96 3,43 ,79 2,60 1,43
11.2
Availability of institutional capabilities for analysis and assessment
national security challenges, risks and threats development
3,37 ,90 3,29 ,76 2,50 1,08
11.3
Availability of institutional capabilities for receiving/sharing information
of national security challenges, risks and threats development
3,39 ,95 3,57 ,98 3,00 ,82
11.4
Influence of analysis and assessment of the development challenges,
risks and threats on the decision making processes
3,43 ,95 3,57 1,13 2,90 1,10
11.5
Influence of analysis and assessment of the development challenges,
risks and threats on the development of institutional/national legal base
3,27 ,95 3,57 1,13 2,70 1,34
11.6
Need of development and modernization of institutional capabilities for
detecting and monitoring national security challenges, risks and threats
3,78 ,89 3,71 ,49 3,40 ,97
1. MONITORING, DETECTION, IDENTIFICATION AND ANALYSIS OF CHALLENGES,
RISKS AND THREATS TO NATIONAL SECURITY
MOD&AF (60)
SECONDARY
55%
LEAD INST (7)
PRIMARY
67%
CIVILIAN INST
(11)
SECONDARY
73%
11.1
Availability of institutional capabilities for detecting and monitoring
national security challenges, risks and threats
3,30 ,96 3,43 ,79 2,60 1,43
11.2
Availability of institutional capabilities for analysis and assessment
national security challenges, risks and threats development
3,37 ,90 3,29 ,76 2,50 1,08
11.3
Availability of institutional capabilities for receiving/sharing information
of national security challenges, risks and threats development
3,39 ,95 3,57 ,98 3,00 ,82
11.4
Influence of analysis and assessment of the development challenges,
risks and threats on the decision making processes
3,43 ,95 3,57 1,13 2,90 1,10
11.5
Influence of analysis and assessment of the development challenges,
risks and threats on the development of institutional/national legal base
3,27 ,95 3,57 1,13 2,70 1,34
11.6
Need of development and modernization of institutional capabilities for
detecting and monitoring national security challenges, risks and threats
3,78 ,89 3,71 ,49 3,40 ,97
1. MONITORING, DETECTION, IDENTIFICATION AND ANALYSIS OF CHALLENGES,
RISKS AND THREATS TO NATIONAL SECURITY
MOD&AF (60)
SECONDARY
55%
LEAD INST (7)
PRIMARY
67%
CIVILIAN INST
(11)
SECONDARY
73%
11.1
Availability of institutional capabilities for detecting and monitoring
national security challenges, risks and threats
3,30 ,96 3,43 ,79 2,60 1,43
11.2
Availability of institutional capabilities for analysis and assessment
national security challenges, risks and threats development
3,37 ,90 3,29 ,76 2,50 1,08
11.3
Availability of institutional capabilities for receiving/sharing information
of national security challenges, risks and threats development
3,39 ,95 3,57 ,98 3,00 ,82
11.4
Influence of analysis and assessment of the development challenges,
risks and threats on the decision making processes
3,43 ,95 3,57 1,13 2,90 1,10
11.5
Influence of analysis and assessment of the development challenges,
risks and threats on the development of institutional/national legal base
3,27 ,95 3,57 1,13 2,70 1,34
11.6
Need of development and modernization of institutional capabilities for
detecting and monitoring national security challenges, risks and threats
3,78 ,89 3,71 ,49 3,40 ,97
1. MONITORING, DETECTION, IDENTIFICATION AND ANALYSIS OF CHALLENGES,
RISKS AND THREATS TO NATIONAL SECURITY
MOD&AF (60)
SECONDARY
55%
LEAD INST (7)
PRIMARY
67%
CIVILIAN INST
(11)
SECONDARY
73%
11.1
Availability of institutional capabilities for detecting and monitoring
national security challenges, risks and threats
3,30 ,96 3,43 ,79 2,60 1,43
11.2
Availability of institutional capabilities for analysis and assessment
national security challenges, risks and threats development
3,37 ,90 3,29 ,76 2,50 1,08
11.3
Availability of institutional capabilities for receiving/sharing information
of national security challenges, risks and threats development
3,39 ,95 3,57 ,98 3,00 ,82
11.4
Influence of analysis and assessment of the development challenges,
risks and threats on the decision making processes
3,43 ,95 3,57 1,13 2,90 1,10
11.5
Influence of analysis and assessment of the development challenges,
risks and threats on the development of institutional/national legal base
3,27 ,95 3,57 1,13 2,70 1,34
11.6
Need of development and modernization of institutional capabilities for
detecting and monitoring national security challenges, risks and threats
3,78 ,89 3,71 ,49 3,40 ,97
1. MONITORING, DETECTION, IDENTIFICATION AND ANALYSIS OF CHALLENGES,
RISKS AND THREATS TO THE NATIONAL SECURITY
MOD&AF (60)
SECONDARY
55%
LEAD INST (7)
PRIMARY
67%
CIVILIAN INST
(11)
SECONDARY
73%
11.1
Availability of institutional capabilities for detecting and monitoring
national security challenges, risks and threats
3,30 ,96 3,43 ,79 2,60 1,43
11.2
Availability of institutional capabilities for analysis and assessment
national security challenges, risks and threats development
3,37 ,90 3,29 ,76 2,50 1,08
11.3
Availability of institutional capabilities for receiving/sharing information
of national security challenges, risks and threats development
3,39 ,95 3,57 ,98 3,00 ,82
11.4
Influence of analysis and assessment of the development challenges,
risks and threats on the decision making processes
3,43 ,95 3,57 1,13 2,90 1,10
11.5
Influence of analysis and assessment of the development challenges,
risks and threats on the development of institutional/national legal base
3,27 ,95 3,57 1,13 2,70 1,34
11.6
Need of development and modernization of institutional capabilities for
detecting and monitoring national security challenges, risks and threats
3,78 ,89 3,71 ,49 3,40 ,97
THE NEED IS LITTLE HIGHER THAN THE AVAILABLE CAPABILITIES, BUT AS A WHOLE AVAILABLE INSTITUTIONAL
CAPABILITIES ALLOW TO EXECUTE THEIR CURRENT ROLE
NATIONAL SECURITY SYSTEM LEGAL FRAMEWORK – LAW ON NSS, DEFENCE LAW, LAW ON INTERNAL MINISTRY, CRISIS
MANAGEMENT LAW, DISASTER MANAGEMENT LAW
INSTITUTIONAL AND NATIONAL CONCEPTUAL AND STRATEGIC DOCUMENTS RELATED TO THE AREAS OF COUNTERING
HYBRID THREATS
NATIONAL AND INSTITUTIONAL CAPABILITY DEVELOPMENT RELATED STRATEGIC DOCUMENTS AND PLANS VS ALLIED
(NATO AND EU) CAPSTONE AND STRATEGIC DOCUMENTS
NSS MANAGEMENT: POLICY AND SYSTEM RESILIENCE, DECISION MAKING AND OPERATIONAL PROCEDURES, FOREIGN
FACTORS OF INSTABILITY, POOR OR INEFFECTIVE MANAGEMENT PRACTICES AND VIOLATED PUBLIC TRUST
CRITICAL ECONOMY SECTORS - ENERGETICS, DIVERSIFICATION OF RESOURCE MANAGEMENT, TRANSPORTATION,
BANKING AND FINANCE, CRITICAL INFRASTRUCTURES
INFORMATION POLICY, INFORMATION SECURITY AND PROTECTION, MEDIA, NETWORKS AND INFORMATION
INFLUENCE, DISRUPTED STRATEGIC COMMUNICATION
POSSIBLE AREAS OF ARISING OF HYBRID THREATS:
THE MOST SIGNIFICANT POTENTIAL MIGHT HAVE A MANIFESTATION OF COMPLEMENTARITY, OVERLAY OR COMBINED
AND HIGH NEGATIVE IMPACTS ON SECURITY WITH INTERNAL AND EXTERNAL NATURE, HARD TO PREDICT WITH LONG-
TERM EFFECTS AND CONSEQUENCES. THEIR IDENTIFICATION AND MANAGEMENT REQUIRE SPECIALIZED INSTITUTIONAL
BODIES FOR RECOGNITION, TRACKING, ANALYSIS AND COUNTERMEASURES
THE ESTIMATION OF THE ARISING POSSIBILITY OF SUCH THREATS RANGE FROM MODERATELY HIGH UP TO HIGH, AND
CALL FOR IMMEDIATE INSTITUTIONAL MEASURES TO ENHANCE THE PRELIMINARY INSTITUTIONAL READINESS AND
STANDING PLANS, PROCEDURES AND MEASURES TO REACT ON THEIR UNEXPECTED DEVELOPMENT AND INFLUENCE
A STRONG EMPHASIS ON THE NEED OF INSTITUTIONAL REFORMS TO ABSORB INSTITUTIONAL AND NATIONAL POTENTIAL
WITH INTERNAL AND EXTERNAL POLITICAL DIALOGUE, OUTREACH, PUBLIC DIPLOMACY, COMBINATION OF ECONOMIC,
INFORMATION AND SOCIAL MEASURES FOR ENHANCING PUBLIC TRUST AND SOCIETY RESILIENCE
THE DISCUSSION IDENTIFIED THE NEED OF A PROACTIVE STRATEGY TO EXPAND INTERINSTITUTIONAL AND
INTERNATIONAL COOPERATION AND COLLABORATION FOR A SHARED DEVELOPMENT AND USAGE OF NEW AND
MODERNIZED INSTITUTIONAL/NATIONAL CAPABILITIES TO COUNTERING THREATS HYBRID
IT WAS ACKNOWLEDGED THE INCREASING ROLE OF MODERN EDUCATION, TRAINING AND EXERCISING, AS WELL AS THE
NEED OF MORE INSTITUTIONAL AND NATIONAL SCIENTIFIC RESEARCHES IN THIS AREA IN ORDER TO CONTINUOUSLY
DEVELOP AND UPDATE SPECIALIZED SUBJECT MATTER EXPERTISE FOR NATIONAL SECURITY AND DEFENSE
DELIBERATELY USE OF WEAKNESSES AND VULNERABILITIES:
WEAKNESSES IN NATIONAL INSTITUTIONS AND GOVERNMENT FUNCTIONING, CORRUPTION
LACK OF PUBLIC TRUST AND SUPPORT FOR INTERNAL SECURITY AND DEFENCE INSTITUTIONS’ EFFORT
ETHNIC SEPARATION AND NEGLECTED THE INTERESTS OF LARGE ETHNIC GROUPS – POLITICAL, ECONOMIC AND
SOCIAL MARGINALIZATION
CRITICAL DEPENDENCE ON RESOURCES IMPORTS, ECONOMIC AND ENERGY DEPENDENCE, LACK OF DIVERSITY AND
VULNERABILITY OF CRITICAL INFRASTRUCTURE - FINANCE, ENERGY, COMMUNICATIONS AND TRANSPORTATION AND CYBER
THE REALIZATION OF A SMALL PART OF THE NATIONAL SECURITY FUNCTIONS (20% OR FOUR OF TWENTY) IS PERFORMED
WITH AVAILABLE INSTITUTIONAL CAPABILITIES AT ABOVE THE MIDDLE TO HIGH LEVEL OF MEASUREMENT SCALE
THE MAIN PART OF THE NSS FUNCTIONS IS PERFORMED UPON AVAILABLE CAPABILITIES AT ABOUT MIDDLE LEVEL, AND A
SIGNIFICANT PART OF THESE ARE RATED EVEN LOWER THAN MIDDLE ON THE MEASUREMENT SCALE
THE COMPARATIVE ASSESSMENT BETWEEN THE MOD NEEDS AND AVAILABLE CAPABILITIES REVEALED MULTIPLE GROUPS
OF CAPABILITIES THAT NEED DEVELOPMENT, AS THE NEEDS ARE CONSIDERABLY HIGHER THAN ACTUAL AVAILABILITY
THE INSUFFICIENT EXPERT INSTITUTIONAL REPRESENTATION (EXCEPT MOD), AND THEREFORE A BROADER EXPERT-
PROFILE GROUPING, THE RESULTS OF ASSESSMENT THE INSTITUTIONAL ROLE OF MINISTRIES AND STATE AGENCIES
COULD NOT BE CONSTRUED SUITABLE FOR EACH GROUP OF INSTITUTIONS
THE RESULTS REVEAL A RELATIVELY NARROW INSTITUTIONAL AND SECTORAL SPECIALIZATION OF PARTICIPATING
EXPERTS, AND IT COULD BE ASSUMED THAT INSTITUTIONAL ROLE IN SOME BASIC FUNCTIONS HAS NOT BEEN EVALUATED
IN FULL COMPLIANCE WITH PRESCRIBED IN THE ENTIRE NSS LEGAL BASE INSTITUTIONAL RESPONSIBILITIES AND TASKS
THE RESULTS REVEAL A CLEAR TREND OF AN EXPERT FOLLOWING THE ACTUAL POLITICAL TRENDS AND A PRIORITY
EMPHASIS ON THE TOPICAL POLITICAL DECISIONS ON CAPABILITY DEVELOPMENT TO BOOST THE NSS FUNCTIONALITY
A GOOD EXPERT SPECIALIZATION ALLOWS A SUFFICIENTLY FULL COMPLIANCE OF THE ASSESSMENT’S HIGHLIGHTS WITH
REQUIREMENTS OF DEFENSE LEGISLATION, OFFICIAL POLICY AND INSTITUTIONAL STRATEGIC DOCUMENTS, AIMED TO
INCREASE THE EFFECTIVENESS OF MOD CONTRIBUTION TO THE ALLIED CAPABILITY DEVELOPMENT AND USE
DUE TO THE RESPONSE TO THE INSTITUTIONAL PRIORITIZATION AND COMMITMENT TO THE DEVELOPMENT OF SPECIFIC
GROUPS OF CAPABILITIES, IT SEEMS UNDERESTIMATED THE NEED OF UPDATING CAPABILITIES TO DEFENSE THE
TERRITORIAL INTEGRITY, STATE INDEPENDENCE AND TO COMBAT TERRORISM
DESPITE INSTITUTIONAL EFFORT, THE UNDERESTIMATION OF THE NEED OF COMMAND AND CONTROL CAPABILITIES (TO
IDENTIFY AND ANALYZE ARISING SECURITY CHALLENGES AND THREATS), IT STILL EXIST A PROBABILITY OF HYBRID
THREATS DEVELOPMENT IN THE EXECUTION OF INTER-INSTITUTIONAL AND MULTI-INSTITUTIONAL NSS FUNCTIONS
THE ANALYSIS OF THE RESEARCH’S RESULTS AND FINDINGS REVEALS - IN ORDER TO OVERCOME THE CAPABILITY
SHORTAGE AND TO ENHANCE NSS READINESS IT IS NEEDED:
COMPREHENSIVE REVIEW AND UPDATE NSS LEGAL AND REGULATORY FRAMEWORK, DEVELOPMENT A
DETAILED CLASSIFICATION OF INSTITUTIONAL ROLES AND RESPONSIBILITIES FOR IMPLEMENTATION OF ITS
BASIC FUNCTIONS
PRIORITIZATION OF THE DEVELOPMENT AND ACTUALIZATION THE INSTITUTIONAL CAPABILITIES, NECESSARY
FOR THE EXECUTION THE LEADING INSTITUTIONAL ROLES IN MAIN NATIONAL SECURITY AND DEFENSE
FUNCTIONS
INTER-INSTITUTIONAL PRIORITIZATION OF CAPABILITY COMMITMENT FOR THE IMPLEMENTATION OF
LEGALLY PRESCRIBED INSTITUTIONAL ROLES, ENLARGING THE INSTITUTIONAL CONTRIBUTION TO THE
SHARED NATIONAL AND ALLIANCE CAPABILITY DEVELOPMENT
DEVELOPMENT EFFECTIVE MECHANISMS TO IMPROVE THE QUALITY OF INSTITUTIONAL EXPERTISE WITH
EDUCATION, TRAINING AND EXERCISING, IN ORDER TO ENHANCE INTER-INSTITUTIONAL AND
INTERNATIONAL COOPERATION AND COLLABORATION IN COUNTERING HYBRID THREATS
Capabilities Expert Assessment

More Related Content

Viewers also liked

Lokesh C B_Resume
Lokesh C B_ResumeLokesh C B_Resume
Lokesh C B_ResumeLokesh cb
 
Casa Olympia Park Campo Grande
Casa Olympia Park Campo GrandeCasa Olympia Park Campo Grande
Casa Olympia Park Campo GrandeApartamentosRIO
 
PI Preparation Kit 2014 by IIM Rohtak for Admissions-2014
PI Preparation Kit 2014 by IIM Rohtak for Admissions-2014PI Preparation Kit 2014 by IIM Rohtak for Admissions-2014
PI Preparation Kit 2014 by IIM Rohtak for Admissions-2014PR Cell, IIM Rohtak
 
Remanufacturing tecnitude retour expérience actena
Remanufacturing tecnitude retour expérience actenaRemanufacturing tecnitude retour expérience actena
Remanufacturing tecnitude retour expérience actenaCCI Alsace Eurométropole
 
Olga Duran
Olga DuranOlga Duran
Olga Duranolcs13
 
From Bootstrapping to Venture Rounds: A Startup Case Study
From Bootstrapping to Venture Rounds: A Startup Case StudyFrom Bootstrapping to Venture Rounds: A Startup Case Study
From Bootstrapping to Venture Rounds: A Startup Case StudyRoger Ehrenberg
 
DMRC Feeder Bus Branding - Delhi Metro Bus Branding
DMRC Feeder Bus Branding - Delhi Metro Bus BrandingDMRC Feeder Bus Branding - Delhi Metro Bus Branding
DMRC Feeder Bus Branding - Delhi Metro Bus BrandingOrganized Outdoor
 
Cranial nerves xi and xii
Cranial nerves xi and xiiCranial nerves xi and xii
Cranial nerves xi and xiiNeurologyKota
 

Viewers also liked (15)

Feito1
Feito1Feito1
Feito1
 
19 feb2015
19 feb201519 feb2015
19 feb2015
 
Lokesh C B_Resume
Lokesh C B_ResumeLokesh C B_Resume
Lokesh C B_Resume
 
Battle Ships
Battle ShipsBattle Ships
Battle Ships
 
Casa Olympia Park Campo Grande
Casa Olympia Park Campo GrandeCasa Olympia Park Campo Grande
Casa Olympia Park Campo Grande
 
Pablo valdiviezo
Pablo valdiviezoPablo valdiviezo
Pablo valdiviezo
 
PI Preparation Kit 2014 by IIM Rohtak for Admissions-2014
PI Preparation Kit 2014 by IIM Rohtak for Admissions-2014PI Preparation Kit 2014 by IIM Rohtak for Admissions-2014
PI Preparation Kit 2014 by IIM Rohtak for Admissions-2014
 
Dublin
DublinDublin
Dublin
 
Remanufacturing tecnitude retour expérience actena
Remanufacturing tecnitude retour expérience actenaRemanufacturing tecnitude retour expérience actena
Remanufacturing tecnitude retour expérience actena
 
Olga Duran
Olga DuranOlga Duran
Olga Duran
 
From Bootstrapping to Venture Rounds: A Startup Case Study
From Bootstrapping to Venture Rounds: A Startup Case StudyFrom Bootstrapping to Venture Rounds: A Startup Case Study
From Bootstrapping to Venture Rounds: A Startup Case Study
 
DMRC Feeder Bus Branding - Delhi Metro Bus Branding
DMRC Feeder Bus Branding - Delhi Metro Bus BrandingDMRC Feeder Bus Branding - Delhi Metro Bus Branding
DMRC Feeder Bus Branding - Delhi Metro Bus Branding
 
Migraine guidelines
Migraine guidelinesMigraine guidelines
Migraine guidelines
 
Cranial nerves xi and xii
Cranial nerves xi and xiiCranial nerves xi and xii
Cranial nerves xi and xii
 
Teenu's cv
Teenu's cvTeenu's cv
Teenu's cv
 

Similar to Capabilities Expert Assessment

Applied intelligence analysis
Applied intelligence analysisApplied intelligence analysis
Applied intelligence analysisUnimasteressays
 
FEMARisk Management SeriesRisk AssessmentA How-To Gu.docx
FEMARisk Management SeriesRisk AssessmentA How-To Gu.docxFEMARisk Management SeriesRisk AssessmentA How-To Gu.docx
FEMARisk Management SeriesRisk AssessmentA How-To Gu.docxmydrynan
 
2012 Reenergize the Americas 3B: Charles Hamilton
2012 Reenergize the Americas 3B: Charles Hamilton2012 Reenergize the Americas 3B: Charles Hamilton
2012 Reenergize the Americas 3B: Charles HamiltonReenergize
 
(U fouo) committee on national security systems supply chain risk management ...
(U fouo) committee on national security systems supply chain risk management ...(U fouo) committee on national security systems supply chain risk management ...
(U fouo) committee on national security systems supply chain risk management ...PublicLeaker
 
(U fouo) committee on national security systems supply chain risk management ...
(U fouo) committee on national security systems supply chain risk management ...(U fouo) committee on national security systems supply chain risk management ...
(U fouo) committee on national security systems supply chain risk management ...PublicLeaks
 
Asymmetric threat 5_paper
Asymmetric threat 5_paperAsymmetric threat 5_paper
Asymmetric threat 5_paperMarioEliseo3
 
ITACG_Guide_for_First_Responders_2011
ITACG_Guide_for_First_Responders_2011ITACG_Guide_for_First_Responders_2011
ITACG_Guide_for_First_Responders_2011Robert J. Breitenbach
 
How do you predict the threat landscape?
How do you predict the threat landscape?How do you predict the threat landscape?
How do you predict the threat landscape?F-Secure Corporation
 
2019 11 terp_mansonbulletproof_master copy
2019 11 terp_mansonbulletproof_master copy2019 11 terp_mansonbulletproof_master copy
2019 11 terp_mansonbulletproof_master copySara-Jayne Terp
 
Cybersecurity Risk Management Tools and Techniques (1).pptx
Cybersecurity Risk Management Tools and Techniques (1).pptxCybersecurity Risk Management Tools and Techniques (1).pptx
Cybersecurity Risk Management Tools and Techniques (1).pptxClintonKelvin
 
Michael DeMark Federal Resume
Michael DeMark Federal ResumeMichael DeMark Federal Resume
Michael DeMark Federal ResumeMichael DeMark
 
Emerging Threats: Creation of a Regional Foresight Matrix by Mathew Maavak
Emerging Threats: Creation of a Regional Foresight Matrix by Mathew MaavakEmerging Threats: Creation of a Regional Foresight Matrix by Mathew Maavak
Emerging Threats: Creation of a Regional Foresight Matrix by Mathew MaavakMathew Maavak
 
The Evolving Landscape on Information Security
The Evolving Landscape on Information SecurityThe Evolving Landscape on Information Security
The Evolving Landscape on Information SecuritySimoun Ung
 
Justin BennettTerrorism is one of the six strategic risk that is.docx
Justin BennettTerrorism is one of the six strategic risk that is.docxJustin BennettTerrorism is one of the six strategic risk that is.docx
Justin BennettTerrorism is one of the six strategic risk that is.docxtawnyataylor528
 
TestimonyBefore the Subcommittee on National Security,Ve.docx
TestimonyBefore the Subcommittee on National Security,Ve.docxTestimonyBefore the Subcommittee on National Security,Ve.docx
TestimonyBefore the Subcommittee on National Security,Ve.docxmattinsonjanel
 
Free dhs ied search procedures workshop in washington
Free dhs ied search procedures workshop in washingtonFree dhs ied search procedures workshop in washington
Free dhs ied search procedures workshop in washingtonDavid Jimenez
 
A theoretical superworm
A theoretical superwormA theoretical superworm
A theoretical superwormUltraUploader
 
AQA Geography New natural disaster ppt
AQA Geography New natural disaster pptAQA Geography New natural disaster ppt
AQA Geography New natural disaster pptWill Williams
 

Similar to Capabilities Expert Assessment (20)

Applied intelligence analysis
Applied intelligence analysisApplied intelligence analysis
Applied intelligence analysis
 
FEMARisk Management SeriesRisk AssessmentA How-To Gu.docx
FEMARisk Management SeriesRisk AssessmentA How-To Gu.docxFEMARisk Management SeriesRisk AssessmentA How-To Gu.docx
FEMARisk Management SeriesRisk AssessmentA How-To Gu.docx
 
2012 Reenergize the Americas 3B: Charles Hamilton
2012 Reenergize the Americas 3B: Charles Hamilton2012 Reenergize the Americas 3B: Charles Hamilton
2012 Reenergize the Americas 3B: Charles Hamilton
 
(U fouo) committee on national security systems supply chain risk management ...
(U fouo) committee on national security systems supply chain risk management ...(U fouo) committee on national security systems supply chain risk management ...
(U fouo) committee on national security systems supply chain risk management ...
 
(U fouo) committee on national security systems supply chain risk management ...
(U fouo) committee on national security systems supply chain risk management ...(U fouo) committee on national security systems supply chain risk management ...
(U fouo) committee on national security systems supply chain risk management ...
 
Homeland Security Bill
Homeland Security BillHomeland Security Bill
Homeland Security Bill
 
Asymmetric threat 5_paper
Asymmetric threat 5_paperAsymmetric threat 5_paper
Asymmetric threat 5_paper
 
ITACG_Guide_for_First_Responders_2011
ITACG_Guide_for_First_Responders_2011ITACG_Guide_for_First_Responders_2011
ITACG_Guide_for_First_Responders_2011
 
How do you predict the threat landscape?
How do you predict the threat landscape?How do you predict the threat landscape?
How do you predict the threat landscape?
 
ATT00080
ATT00080ATT00080
ATT00080
 
2019 11 terp_mansonbulletproof_master copy
2019 11 terp_mansonbulletproof_master copy2019 11 terp_mansonbulletproof_master copy
2019 11 terp_mansonbulletproof_master copy
 
Cybersecurity Risk Management Tools and Techniques (1).pptx
Cybersecurity Risk Management Tools and Techniques (1).pptxCybersecurity Risk Management Tools and Techniques (1).pptx
Cybersecurity Risk Management Tools and Techniques (1).pptx
 
Michael DeMark Federal Resume
Michael DeMark Federal ResumeMichael DeMark Federal Resume
Michael DeMark Federal Resume
 
Emerging Threats: Creation of a Regional Foresight Matrix by Mathew Maavak
Emerging Threats: Creation of a Regional Foresight Matrix by Mathew MaavakEmerging Threats: Creation of a Regional Foresight Matrix by Mathew Maavak
Emerging Threats: Creation of a Regional Foresight Matrix by Mathew Maavak
 
The Evolving Landscape on Information Security
The Evolving Landscape on Information SecurityThe Evolving Landscape on Information Security
The Evolving Landscape on Information Security
 
Justin BennettTerrorism is one of the six strategic risk that is.docx
Justin BennettTerrorism is one of the six strategic risk that is.docxJustin BennettTerrorism is one of the six strategic risk that is.docx
Justin BennettTerrorism is one of the six strategic risk that is.docx
 
TestimonyBefore the Subcommittee on National Security,Ve.docx
TestimonyBefore the Subcommittee on National Security,Ve.docxTestimonyBefore the Subcommittee on National Security,Ve.docx
TestimonyBefore the Subcommittee on National Security,Ve.docx
 
Free dhs ied search procedures workshop in washington
Free dhs ied search procedures workshop in washingtonFree dhs ied search procedures workshop in washington
Free dhs ied search procedures workshop in washington
 
A theoretical superworm
A theoretical superwormA theoretical superworm
A theoretical superworm
 
AQA Geography New natural disaster ppt
AQA Geography New natural disaster pptAQA Geography New natural disaster ppt
AQA Geography New natural disaster ppt
 

Recently uploaded

LIGHT-PHENOMENA-BY-CABUALDIONALDOPANOGANCADIENTE-CONDEZA (1).pptx
LIGHT-PHENOMENA-BY-CABUALDIONALDOPANOGANCADIENTE-CONDEZA (1).pptxLIGHT-PHENOMENA-BY-CABUALDIONALDOPANOGANCADIENTE-CONDEZA (1).pptx
LIGHT-PHENOMENA-BY-CABUALDIONALDOPANOGANCADIENTE-CONDEZA (1).pptxmalonesandreagweneth
 
Pests of safflower_Binomics_Identification_Dr.UPR.pdf
Pests of safflower_Binomics_Identification_Dr.UPR.pdfPests of safflower_Binomics_Identification_Dr.UPR.pdf
Pests of safflower_Binomics_Identification_Dr.UPR.pdfPirithiRaju
 
TOPIC 8 Temperature and Heat.pdf physics
TOPIC 8 Temperature and Heat.pdf physicsTOPIC 8 Temperature and Heat.pdf physics
TOPIC 8 Temperature and Heat.pdf physicsssuserddc89b
 
Grafana in space: Monitoring Japan's SLIM moon lander in real time
Grafana in space: Monitoring Japan's SLIM moon lander  in real timeGrafana in space: Monitoring Japan's SLIM moon lander  in real time
Grafana in space: Monitoring Japan's SLIM moon lander in real timeSatoshi NAKAHIRA
 
Microphone- characteristics,carbon microphone, dynamic microphone.pptx
Microphone- characteristics,carbon microphone, dynamic microphone.pptxMicrophone- characteristics,carbon microphone, dynamic microphone.pptx
Microphone- characteristics,carbon microphone, dynamic microphone.pptxpriyankatabhane
 
THE ROLE OF PHARMACOGNOSY IN TRADITIONAL AND MODERN SYSTEM OF MEDICINE.pptx
THE ROLE OF PHARMACOGNOSY IN TRADITIONAL AND MODERN SYSTEM OF MEDICINE.pptxTHE ROLE OF PHARMACOGNOSY IN TRADITIONAL AND MODERN SYSTEM OF MEDICINE.pptx
THE ROLE OF PHARMACOGNOSY IN TRADITIONAL AND MODERN SYSTEM OF MEDICINE.pptxNandakishor Bhaurao Deshmukh
 
Davis plaque method.pptx recombinant DNA technology
Davis plaque method.pptx recombinant DNA technologyDavis plaque method.pptx recombinant DNA technology
Davis plaque method.pptx recombinant DNA technologycaarthichand2003
 
Pests of soyabean_Binomics_IdentificationDr.UPR.pdf
Pests of soyabean_Binomics_IdentificationDr.UPR.pdfPests of soyabean_Binomics_IdentificationDr.UPR.pdf
Pests of soyabean_Binomics_IdentificationDr.UPR.pdfPirithiRaju
 
Harmful and Useful Microorganisms Presentation
Harmful and Useful Microorganisms PresentationHarmful and Useful Microorganisms Presentation
Harmful and Useful Microorganisms Presentationtahreemzahra82
 
STOPPED FLOW METHOD & APPLICATION MURUGAVENI B.pptx
STOPPED FLOW METHOD & APPLICATION MURUGAVENI B.pptxSTOPPED FLOW METHOD & APPLICATION MURUGAVENI B.pptx
STOPPED FLOW METHOD & APPLICATION MURUGAVENI B.pptxMurugaveni B
 
Vision and reflection on Mining Software Repositories research in 2024
Vision and reflection on Mining Software Repositories research in 2024Vision and reflection on Mining Software Repositories research in 2024
Vision and reflection on Mining Software Repositories research in 2024AyushiRastogi48
 
Call Girls In Nihal Vihar Delhi ❤️8860477959 Looking Escorts In 24/7 Delhi NCR
Call Girls In Nihal Vihar Delhi ❤️8860477959 Looking Escorts In 24/7 Delhi NCRCall Girls In Nihal Vihar Delhi ❤️8860477959 Looking Escorts In 24/7 Delhi NCR
Call Girls In Nihal Vihar Delhi ❤️8860477959 Looking Escorts In 24/7 Delhi NCRlizamodels9
 
Microteaching on terms used in filtration .Pharmaceutical Engineering
Microteaching on terms used in filtration .Pharmaceutical EngineeringMicroteaching on terms used in filtration .Pharmaceutical Engineering
Microteaching on terms used in filtration .Pharmaceutical EngineeringPrajakta Shinde
 
Best Call Girls In Sector 29 Gurgaon❤️8860477959 EscorTs Service In 24/7 Delh...
Best Call Girls In Sector 29 Gurgaon❤️8860477959 EscorTs Service In 24/7 Delh...Best Call Girls In Sector 29 Gurgaon❤️8860477959 EscorTs Service In 24/7 Delh...
Best Call Girls In Sector 29 Gurgaon❤️8860477959 EscorTs Service In 24/7 Delh...lizamodels9
 
Topic 9- General Principles of International Law.pptx
Topic 9- General Principles of International Law.pptxTopic 9- General Principles of International Law.pptx
Topic 9- General Principles of International Law.pptxJorenAcuavera1
 
Base editing, prime editing, Cas13 & RNA editing and organelle base editing
Base editing, prime editing, Cas13 & RNA editing and organelle base editingBase editing, prime editing, Cas13 & RNA editing and organelle base editing
Base editing, prime editing, Cas13 & RNA editing and organelle base editingNetHelix
 
Analytical Profile of Coleus Forskohlii | Forskolin .pptx
Analytical Profile of Coleus Forskohlii | Forskolin .pptxAnalytical Profile of Coleus Forskohlii | Forskolin .pptx
Analytical Profile of Coleus Forskohlii | Forskolin .pptxSwapnil Therkar
 
Scheme-of-Work-Science-Stage-4 cambridge science.docx
Scheme-of-Work-Science-Stage-4 cambridge science.docxScheme-of-Work-Science-Stage-4 cambridge science.docx
Scheme-of-Work-Science-Stage-4 cambridge science.docxyaramohamed343013
 
RESPIRATORY ADAPTATIONS TO HYPOXIA IN HUMNAS.pptx
RESPIRATORY ADAPTATIONS TO HYPOXIA IN HUMNAS.pptxRESPIRATORY ADAPTATIONS TO HYPOXIA IN HUMNAS.pptx
RESPIRATORY ADAPTATIONS TO HYPOXIA IN HUMNAS.pptxFarihaAbdulRasheed
 
Neurodevelopmental disorders according to the dsm 5 tr
Neurodevelopmental disorders according to the dsm 5 trNeurodevelopmental disorders according to the dsm 5 tr
Neurodevelopmental disorders according to the dsm 5 trssuser06f238
 

Recently uploaded (20)

LIGHT-PHENOMENA-BY-CABUALDIONALDOPANOGANCADIENTE-CONDEZA (1).pptx
LIGHT-PHENOMENA-BY-CABUALDIONALDOPANOGANCADIENTE-CONDEZA (1).pptxLIGHT-PHENOMENA-BY-CABUALDIONALDOPANOGANCADIENTE-CONDEZA (1).pptx
LIGHT-PHENOMENA-BY-CABUALDIONALDOPANOGANCADIENTE-CONDEZA (1).pptx
 
Pests of safflower_Binomics_Identification_Dr.UPR.pdf
Pests of safflower_Binomics_Identification_Dr.UPR.pdfPests of safflower_Binomics_Identification_Dr.UPR.pdf
Pests of safflower_Binomics_Identification_Dr.UPR.pdf
 
TOPIC 8 Temperature and Heat.pdf physics
TOPIC 8 Temperature and Heat.pdf physicsTOPIC 8 Temperature and Heat.pdf physics
TOPIC 8 Temperature and Heat.pdf physics
 
Grafana in space: Monitoring Japan's SLIM moon lander in real time
Grafana in space: Monitoring Japan's SLIM moon lander  in real timeGrafana in space: Monitoring Japan's SLIM moon lander  in real time
Grafana in space: Monitoring Japan's SLIM moon lander in real time
 
Microphone- characteristics,carbon microphone, dynamic microphone.pptx
Microphone- characteristics,carbon microphone, dynamic microphone.pptxMicrophone- characteristics,carbon microphone, dynamic microphone.pptx
Microphone- characteristics,carbon microphone, dynamic microphone.pptx
 
THE ROLE OF PHARMACOGNOSY IN TRADITIONAL AND MODERN SYSTEM OF MEDICINE.pptx
THE ROLE OF PHARMACOGNOSY IN TRADITIONAL AND MODERN SYSTEM OF MEDICINE.pptxTHE ROLE OF PHARMACOGNOSY IN TRADITIONAL AND MODERN SYSTEM OF MEDICINE.pptx
THE ROLE OF PHARMACOGNOSY IN TRADITIONAL AND MODERN SYSTEM OF MEDICINE.pptx
 
Davis plaque method.pptx recombinant DNA technology
Davis plaque method.pptx recombinant DNA technologyDavis plaque method.pptx recombinant DNA technology
Davis plaque method.pptx recombinant DNA technology
 
Pests of soyabean_Binomics_IdentificationDr.UPR.pdf
Pests of soyabean_Binomics_IdentificationDr.UPR.pdfPests of soyabean_Binomics_IdentificationDr.UPR.pdf
Pests of soyabean_Binomics_IdentificationDr.UPR.pdf
 
Harmful and Useful Microorganisms Presentation
Harmful and Useful Microorganisms PresentationHarmful and Useful Microorganisms Presentation
Harmful and Useful Microorganisms Presentation
 
STOPPED FLOW METHOD & APPLICATION MURUGAVENI B.pptx
STOPPED FLOW METHOD & APPLICATION MURUGAVENI B.pptxSTOPPED FLOW METHOD & APPLICATION MURUGAVENI B.pptx
STOPPED FLOW METHOD & APPLICATION MURUGAVENI B.pptx
 
Vision and reflection on Mining Software Repositories research in 2024
Vision and reflection on Mining Software Repositories research in 2024Vision and reflection on Mining Software Repositories research in 2024
Vision and reflection on Mining Software Repositories research in 2024
 
Call Girls In Nihal Vihar Delhi ❤️8860477959 Looking Escorts In 24/7 Delhi NCR
Call Girls In Nihal Vihar Delhi ❤️8860477959 Looking Escorts In 24/7 Delhi NCRCall Girls In Nihal Vihar Delhi ❤️8860477959 Looking Escorts In 24/7 Delhi NCR
Call Girls In Nihal Vihar Delhi ❤️8860477959 Looking Escorts In 24/7 Delhi NCR
 
Microteaching on terms used in filtration .Pharmaceutical Engineering
Microteaching on terms used in filtration .Pharmaceutical EngineeringMicroteaching on terms used in filtration .Pharmaceutical Engineering
Microteaching on terms used in filtration .Pharmaceutical Engineering
 
Best Call Girls In Sector 29 Gurgaon❤️8860477959 EscorTs Service In 24/7 Delh...
Best Call Girls In Sector 29 Gurgaon❤️8860477959 EscorTs Service In 24/7 Delh...Best Call Girls In Sector 29 Gurgaon❤️8860477959 EscorTs Service In 24/7 Delh...
Best Call Girls In Sector 29 Gurgaon❤️8860477959 EscorTs Service In 24/7 Delh...
 
Topic 9- General Principles of International Law.pptx
Topic 9- General Principles of International Law.pptxTopic 9- General Principles of International Law.pptx
Topic 9- General Principles of International Law.pptx
 
Base editing, prime editing, Cas13 & RNA editing and organelle base editing
Base editing, prime editing, Cas13 & RNA editing and organelle base editingBase editing, prime editing, Cas13 & RNA editing and organelle base editing
Base editing, prime editing, Cas13 & RNA editing and organelle base editing
 
Analytical Profile of Coleus Forskohlii | Forskolin .pptx
Analytical Profile of Coleus Forskohlii | Forskolin .pptxAnalytical Profile of Coleus Forskohlii | Forskolin .pptx
Analytical Profile of Coleus Forskohlii | Forskolin .pptx
 
Scheme-of-Work-Science-Stage-4 cambridge science.docx
Scheme-of-Work-Science-Stage-4 cambridge science.docxScheme-of-Work-Science-Stage-4 cambridge science.docx
Scheme-of-Work-Science-Stage-4 cambridge science.docx
 
RESPIRATORY ADAPTATIONS TO HYPOXIA IN HUMNAS.pptx
RESPIRATORY ADAPTATIONS TO HYPOXIA IN HUMNAS.pptxRESPIRATORY ADAPTATIONS TO HYPOXIA IN HUMNAS.pptx
RESPIRATORY ADAPTATIONS TO HYPOXIA IN HUMNAS.pptx
 
Neurodevelopmental disorders according to the dsm 5 tr
Neurodevelopmental disorders according to the dsm 5 trNeurodevelopmental disorders according to the dsm 5 tr
Neurodevelopmental disorders according to the dsm 5 tr
 

Capabilities Expert Assessment

  • 1.
  • 2.
  • 3.
  • 4.
  • 5. NATO CAPSTONE CONCEPT: MILITARY CONTRIBUTION TO COUNTERING HYBRID THREATS
  • 6.
  • 7.
  • 8.
  • 9.
  • 10.
  • 11. 1. SURVEILLANCE, DETECTION, RECOGNITION, IDENTIFICATION AND ANALYSIS OF CHALLENGES, RISKS AND THREATS TO NATIONAL SECURITY 1.1. EXISTENCE OF INSTITUTIONAL BODIES FOR RECOGNITION AND MONITORING NATIONAL SECURITY CHALLENGES, RISKS AND THREATS
  • 12. № NATIONAL SECURITY SYSTEM’S BASIC FUNCTIONS INSTITUTIONAL ROLE 1. 1. SURVEILLANCE, DETECTION, RECOGNITION, IDENTIFICATION AND ANALYSIS OF CHALLENGES, RISKS AND THREATS TO NATIONAL SECURITY PRIMARY SECONDARY INSIGNIFICANT I DON’T KNOW COMPLETELY BUILT CAPABILITIES: FULL CAPABILITIES BUILT TO A LARGE EXTENT: RATHER FULL CAPABILITIES BUILT TO A MIDDLE STAGE: MIDDLE MARGINALLY BUILT CAPABILITIES: INSIGNIFICANT LACK OF CAPABILITIES: MISSING I CAN’T DECIDE 5 4 3 2 1 0 ASSESSMENT OF THE AVAILABLE CAPABILITIES TO EXECUTE THIS FUNCTION FULL RATHER FULL MIDDLE INSIGNIFI CANT MISSING I DON’T KNOW 1.1 AVAILABILITY OF INSTITUTIONAL BODIES FOR MONITORING AND DISCLOSURE NATIONAL SECURITY CHALLENGES, RISKS AND THREATS 5 4 3 2 1 0 1 2 3
  • 13. EXTREMELY HIGH INFLUENCE OR NEED HIGH INFLUENCE OR NEED MIDDLE INFLUENCE OR NEED INSUFFICIENT INFLUENCE OR NEED LACK OF INFLUENCE OR NEED I DON’T KNOW 5 4 3 2 1 0 ASSESSMENT OF THE CAPABILITIES AVAILABILITY FOR THE FUNCTION EXECUTION EXTREMELY HIGH HIGH MIDDLE INSUFFICIENT MISSING I DON’T KNOW 1.4 ANALYSES AND ASSESSMENTS INFLUENCE ON THE DECISION MAKING 5 4 3 2 1 0 ASSESSMENT OF THE CAPABILITY DEVELOPMENT NEED EXTREMELY HIGH HIGH MIDDLE INSUFFICIENT MISSING I DON’T KNOW 1.6 NEED FOR INSTITUTIONAL CAPABILITIES DEVELOPMENT AND MODERNIZATION 5 4 3 2 1 0 4 5 6
  • 14. 1 LAWS, REGULATIONS, STRATEGIES, DOCTRINES, CONCEPTS, PROGRAMS AND PLANS 5 4 3 2 1 0 7 STATISTICAL ANALYSIS METHODS: 1. ANALYSIS OF AVERAGES - TO PRESENT THE VALUE ESTIMATE OF THE AVERAGE LEVEL OF RESEARCH FUNCTION 2. ANALYSIS OF THE STANDARD DEVIATION - TO ACCOMMODATE THE CONVERGENCE OR DIVERSITY OF THE RESULTS 3. NONPARAMETRIC METHODS MANN-WHITNEY AND KRUSKAL-WALLIS - TO PROVE OR DISPROVE THE STATISTICAL SIGNIFICANCE 8 2 STRUCTURES, ORGANIZATIONS, SYSTEMS 5 4 3 2 1 0 3 EDUCATION, TRAINING, EXERCISES 5 4 3 2 1 0 4 EQUIPMENT AND MATERIALS 5 4 3 2 1 0 5 MANAGEMENT, COMMAND AND CONTROL 5 4 3 2 1 0 6 PERSONNEL 5 4 3 2 1 0 7 INFRASTRUCTURE, CRITICAL INFRASTRUCTURE 5 4 3 2 1 0 8 COOPERATION AND INTEROPERABILITY 5 4 3 2 1 0
  • 15. DISCUSSION AREAS MAIN TOPICS 1 1 DEFINING POTENTIAL HYBRID THREATS WHOSE OCCURRENCE COULD THREATEN THE NATIONAL INTERESTS OF THE REPUBLIC OF BULGARIA ENERGY SECURITY, TERRORISM, DEMOGRAPHY, MIGRATION, INFORMATION SECURITY, CORRUPTION, STATE INSTITUTIONS FUNCTIONING, ETHNIC MARGINALIZATION AND ALIENATION …… 2 DEFINING INSTITUTIONAL CAPABILITIES TO COUNTERING HYBRID THREATS CRITICAL INFRASTRUCTURE PROTECTION, INSTITUTIONS RESILIENCE, EDUCATION & TRAINING, STRATEGIC ENERGY BALANCE, BORDER PROTECTION, SOCIAL SECURITY MEASURES……. 3 DEFINING AND ANALYSIS OF AVAILABLE INSTITUTIONAL CAPABILITIES TO COUNTERING HYBRID THREATS CYBER SECURITY/DEFENSE, SURVEILLANCE SYSTEMS, BORDER SECURITY, MIGRATION POLICY AND MEASURES, FINANCIAL SECURITY, INTERNAL SECURITY AND CRIME, LAW ENFORCEMENT.... 4 DEFICIT OF INSTITUTIONAL/NATIONAL CAPABILITIES TO COUNTERING HYBRID THREATS NATIONAL LEGAL BASE, PREVENTION CAPABILITIES, CYBER SECURITY, CRITICAL INFRASTRUCTURE AND BORDER PROTECTION, INFORMATION SECURITY, ENERGY SECURITY, INTEROPERABILITY….. 5 FORMS AND METHODS FOR INTERINSTITUTIONAL COOPERATION IN CAPABILITIES DEVELOPMENT AND USE SECURITY STANDING OPERATIONAL PROCEDURES, EDUCATION, TRAINING AND EXERCISING, SURVEILLANCE AND SITUATION CENTERS, INFORMATION DISTRIBUTION AND SHARING……………. FINDINGS 1. NEED OF DEVELOPMENT MODERNIZATION OF NATIONAL LEGAL BASE AND INSTITUTIONAL STRATEGIC DOCUMENTS 2. ENLARGING INSTITUTIONAL AWARENESS AND INTEROPERABILITY IN CAPABILITY DEVELOPMENT AND USE AREAS 3. INGROWING INTERINSTITUTIONAL AND INTERNATIONAL COOPERATION TO COUNTERING HYBRID THREATS 2
  • 16. 1. MONITORING, DETECTION, IDENTIFICATION AND ANALYSIS OF CHALLENGES, RISKS AND THREATS TO NATIONAL SECURITY MOD&AF (60) SECONDARY 55% LEAD INST (7) PRIMARY 67% CIVILIAN INST (11) SECONDARY 73% 11.1 Availability of institutional capabilities for detecting and monitoring national security challenges, risks and threats 3,30 ,96 3,43 ,79 2,60 1,43 11.2 Availability of institutional capabilities for analysis and assessment national security challenges, risks and threats development 3,37 ,90 3,29 ,76 2,50 1,08 11.3 Availability of institutional capabilities for receiving/sharing information of national security challenges, risks and threats development 3,39 ,95 3,57 ,98 3,00 ,82 11.4 Influence of analysis and assessment of the development challenges, risks and threats on the decision making processes 3,43 ,95 3,57 1,13 2,90 1,10 11.5 Influence of analysis and assessment of the development challenges, risks and threats on the development of institutional/national legal base 3,27 ,95 3,57 1,13 2,70 1,34 11.6 Need of development and modernization of institutional capabilities for detecting and monitoring national security challenges, risks and threats 3,78 ,89 3,71 ,49 3,40 ,97 1. MONITORING, DETECTION, IDENTIFICATION AND ANALYSIS OF CHALLENGES, RISKS AND THREATS TO NATIONAL SECURITY MOD&AF (60) SECONDARY 55% LEAD INST (7) PRIMARY 67% CIVILIAN INST (11) SECONDARY 73% 11.1 Availability of institutional capabilities for detecting and monitoring national security challenges, risks and threats 3,30 ,96 3,43 ,79 2,60 1,43 11.2 Availability of institutional capabilities for analysis and assessment national security challenges, risks and threats development 3,37 ,90 3,29 ,76 2,50 1,08 11.3 Availability of institutional capabilities for receiving/sharing information of national security challenges, risks and threats development 3,39 ,95 3,57 ,98 3,00 ,82 11.4 Influence of analysis and assessment of the development challenges, risks and threats on the decision making processes 3,43 ,95 3,57 1,13 2,90 1,10 11.5 Influence of analysis and assessment of the development challenges, risks and threats on the development of institutional/national legal base 3,27 ,95 3,57 1,13 2,70 1,34 11.6 Need of development and modernization of institutional capabilities for detecting and monitoring national security challenges, risks and threats 3,78 ,89 3,71 ,49 3,40 ,97 1. MONITORING, DETECTION, IDENTIFICATION AND ANALYSIS OF CHALLENGES, RISKS AND THREATS TO NATIONAL SECURITY MOD&AF (60) SECONDARY 55% LEAD INST (7) PRIMARY 67% CIVILIAN INST (11) SECONDARY 73% 11.1 Availability of institutional capabilities for detecting and monitoring national security challenges, risks and threats 3,30 ,96 3,43 ,79 2,60 1,43 11.2 Availability of institutional capabilities for analysis and assessment national security challenges, risks and threats development 3,37 ,90 3,29 ,76 2,50 1,08 11.3 Availability of institutional capabilities for receiving/sharing information of national security challenges, risks and threats development 3,39 ,95 3,57 ,98 3,00 ,82 11.4 Influence of analysis and assessment of the development challenges, risks and threats on the decision making processes 3,43 ,95 3,57 1,13 2,90 1,10 11.5 Influence of analysis and assessment of the development challenges, risks and threats on the development of institutional/national legal base 3,27 ,95 3,57 1,13 2,70 1,34 11.6 Need of development and modernization of institutional capabilities for detecting and monitoring national security challenges, risks and threats 3,78 ,89 3,71 ,49 3,40 ,97 1. MONITORING, DETECTION, IDENTIFICATION AND ANALYSIS OF CHALLENGES, RISKS AND THREATS TO NATIONAL SECURITY MOD&AF (60) SECONDARY 55% LEAD INST (7) PRIMARY 67% CIVILIAN INST (11) SECONDARY 73% 11.1 Availability of institutional capabilities for detecting and monitoring national security challenges, risks and threats 3,30 ,96 3,43 ,79 2,60 1,43 11.2 Availability of institutional capabilities for analysis and assessment national security challenges, risks and threats development 3,37 ,90 3,29 ,76 2,50 1,08 11.3 Availability of institutional capabilities for receiving/sharing information of national security challenges, risks and threats development 3,39 ,95 3,57 ,98 3,00 ,82 11.4 Influence of analysis and assessment of the development challenges, risks and threats on the decision making processes 3,43 ,95 3,57 1,13 2,90 1,10 11.5 Influence of analysis and assessment of the development challenges, risks and threats on the development of institutional/national legal base 3,27 ,95 3,57 1,13 2,70 1,34 11.6 Need of development and modernization of institutional capabilities for detecting and monitoring national security challenges, risks and threats 3,78 ,89 3,71 ,49 3,40 ,97 1. MONITORING, DETECTION, IDENTIFICATION AND ANALYSIS OF CHALLENGES, RISKS AND THREATS TO NATIONAL SECURITY MOD&AF (60) SECONDARY 55% LEAD INST (7) PRIMARY 67% CIVILIAN INST (11) SECONDARY 73% 11.1 Availability of institutional capabilities for detecting and monitoring national security challenges, risks and threats 3,30 ,96 3,43 ,79 2,60 1,43 11.2 Availability of institutional capabilities for analysis and assessment national security challenges, risks and threats development 3,37 ,90 3,29 ,76 2,50 1,08 11.3 Availability of institutional capabilities for receiving/sharing information of national security challenges, risks and threats development 3,39 ,95 3,57 ,98 3,00 ,82 11.4 Influence of analysis and assessment of the development challenges, risks and threats on the decision making processes 3,43 ,95 3,57 1,13 2,90 1,10 11.5 Influence of analysis and assessment of the development challenges, risks and threats on the development of institutional/national legal base 3,27 ,95 3,57 1,13 2,70 1,34 11.6 Need of development and modernization of institutional capabilities for detecting and monitoring national security challenges, risks and threats 3,78 ,89 3,71 ,49 3,40 ,97 1. MONITORING, DETECTION, IDENTIFICATION AND ANALYSIS OF CHALLENGES, RISKS AND THREATS TO NATIONAL SECURITY MOD&AF (60) SECONDARY 55% LEAD INST (7) PRIMARY 67% CIVILIAN INST (11) SECONDARY 73% 11.1 Availability of institutional capabilities for detecting and monitoring national security challenges, risks and threats 3,30 ,96 3,43 ,79 2,60 1,43 11.2 Availability of institutional capabilities for analysis and assessment national security challenges, risks and threats development 3,37 ,90 3,29 ,76 2,50 1,08 11.3 Availability of institutional capabilities for receiving/sharing information of national security challenges, risks and threats development 3,39 ,95 3,57 ,98 3,00 ,82 11.4 Influence of analysis and assessment of the development challenges, risks and threats on the decision making processes 3,43 ,95 3,57 1,13 2,90 1,10 11.5 Influence of analysis and assessment of the development challenges, risks and threats on the development of institutional/national legal base 3,27 ,95 3,57 1,13 2,70 1,34 11.6 Need of development and modernization of institutional capabilities for detecting and monitoring national security challenges, risks and threats 3,78 ,89 3,71 ,49 3,40 ,97 1. MONITORING, DETECTION, IDENTIFICATION AND ANALYSIS OF CHALLENGES, RISKS AND THREATS TO NATIONAL SECURITY MOD&AF (60) SECONDARY 55% LEAD INST (7) PRIMARY 67% CIVILIAN INST (11) SECONDARY 73% 11.1 Availability of institutional capabilities for detecting and monitoring national security challenges, risks and threats 3,30 ,96 3,43 ,79 2,60 1,43 11.2 Availability of institutional capabilities for analysis and assessment national security challenges, risks and threats development 3,37 ,90 3,29 ,76 2,50 1,08 11.3 Availability of institutional capabilities for receiving/sharing information of national security challenges, risks and threats development 3,39 ,95 3,57 ,98 3,00 ,82 11.4 Influence of analysis and assessment of the development challenges, risks and threats on the decision making processes 3,43 ,95 3,57 1,13 2,90 1,10 11.5 Influence of analysis and assessment of the development challenges, risks and threats on the development of institutional/national legal base 3,27 ,95 3,57 1,13 2,70 1,34 11.6 Need of development and modernization of institutional capabilities for detecting and monitoring national security challenges, risks and threats 3,78 ,89 3,71 ,49 3,40 ,97 1. MONITORING, DETECTION, IDENTIFICATION AND ANALYSIS OF CHALLENGES, RISKS AND THREATS TO NATIONAL SECURITY MOD&AF (60) SECONDARY 55% LEAD INST (7) PRIMARY 67% CIVILIAN INST (11) SECONDARY 73% 11.1 Availability of institutional capabilities for detecting and monitoring national security challenges, risks and threats 3,30 ,96 3,43 ,79 2,60 1,43 11.2 Availability of institutional capabilities for analysis and assessment national security challenges, risks and threats development 3,37 ,90 3,29 ,76 2,50 1,08 11.3 Availability of institutional capabilities for receiving/sharing information of national security challenges, risks and threats development 3,39 ,95 3,57 ,98 3,00 ,82 11.4 Influence of analysis and assessment of the development challenges, risks and threats on the decision making processes 3,43 ,95 3,57 1,13 2,90 1,10 11.5 Influence of analysis and assessment of the development challenges, risks and threats on the development of institutional/national legal base 3,27 ,95 3,57 1,13 2,70 1,34 11.6 Need of development and modernization of institutional capabilities for detecting and monitoring national security challenges, risks and threats 3,78 ,89 3,71 ,49 3,40 ,97 1. MONITORING, DETECTION, IDENTIFICATION AND ANALYSIS OF CHALLENGES, RISKS AND THREATS TO NATIONAL SECURITY MOD&AF (60) SECONDARY 55% LEAD INST (7) PRIMARY 67% CIVILIAN INST (11) SECONDARY 73% 11.1 Availability of institutional capabilities for detecting and monitoring national security challenges, risks and threats 3,30 ,96 3,43 ,79 2,60 1,43 11.2 Availability of institutional capabilities for analysis and assessment national security challenges, risks and threats development 3,37 ,90 3,29 ,76 2,50 1,08 11.3 Availability of institutional capabilities for receiving/sharing information of national security challenges, risks and threats development 3,39 ,95 3,57 ,98 3,00 ,82 11.4 Influence of analysis and assessment of the development challenges, risks and threats on the decision making processes 3,43 ,95 3,57 1,13 2,90 1,10 11.5 Influence of analysis and assessment of the development challenges, risks and threats on the development of institutional/national legal base 3,27 ,95 3,57 1,13 2,70 1,34 11.6 Need of development and modernization of institutional capabilities for detecting and monitoring national security challenges, risks and threats 3,78 ,89 3,71 ,49 3,40 ,97 1. MONITORING, DETECTION, IDENTIFICATION AND ANALYSIS OF CHALLENGES, RISKS AND THREATS TO NATIONAL SECURITY MOD&AF (60) SECONDARY 55% LEAD INST (7) PRIMARY 67% CIVILIAN INST (11) SECONDARY 73% 11.1 Availability of institutional capabilities for detecting and monitoring national security challenges, risks and threats 3,30 ,96 3,43 ,79 2,60 1,43 11.2 Availability of institutional capabilities for analysis and assessment national security challenges, risks and threats development 3,37 ,90 3,29 ,76 2,50 1,08 11.3 Availability of institutional capabilities for receiving/sharing information of national security challenges, risks and threats development 3,39 ,95 3,57 ,98 3,00 ,82 11.4 Influence of analysis and assessment of the development challenges, risks and threats on the decision making processes 3,43 ,95 3,57 1,13 2,90 1,10 11.5 Influence of analysis and assessment of the development challenges, risks and threats on the development of institutional/national legal base 3,27 ,95 3,57 1,13 2,70 1,34 11.6 Need of development and modernization of institutional capabilities for detecting and monitoring national security challenges, risks and threats 3,78 ,89 3,71 ,49 3,40 ,97 1. MONITORING, DETECTION, IDENTIFICATION AND ANALYSIS OF CHALLENGES, RISKS AND THREATS TO NATIONAL SECURITY MOD&AF (60) SECONDARY 55% LEAD INST (7) PRIMARY 67% CIVILIAN INST (11) SECONDARY 73% 11.1 Availability of institutional capabilities for detecting and monitoring national security challenges, risks and threats 3,30 ,96 3,43 ,79 2,60 1,43 11.2 Availability of institutional capabilities for analysis and assessment national security challenges, risks and threats development 3,37 ,90 3,29 ,76 2,50 1,08 11.3 Availability of institutional capabilities for receiving/sharing information of national security challenges, risks and threats development 3,39 ,95 3,57 ,98 3,00 ,82 11.4 Influence of analysis and assessment of the development challenges, risks and threats on the decision making processes 3,43 ,95 3,57 1,13 2,90 1,10 11.5 Influence of analysis and assessment of the development challenges, risks and threats on the development of institutional/national legal base 3,27 ,95 3,57 1,13 2,70 1,34 11.6 Need of development and modernization of institutional capabilities for detecting and monitoring national security challenges, risks and threats 3,78 ,89 3,71 ,49 3,40 ,97 1. MONITORING, DETECTION, IDENTIFICATION AND ANALYSIS OF CHALLENGES, RISKS AND THREATS TO THE NATIONAL SECURITY MOD&AF (60) SECONDARY 55% LEAD INST (7) PRIMARY 67% CIVILIAN INST (11) SECONDARY 73% 11.1 Availability of institutional capabilities for detecting and monitoring national security challenges, risks and threats 3,30 ,96 3,43 ,79 2,60 1,43 11.2 Availability of institutional capabilities for analysis and assessment national security challenges, risks and threats development 3,37 ,90 3,29 ,76 2,50 1,08 11.3 Availability of institutional capabilities for receiving/sharing information of national security challenges, risks and threats development 3,39 ,95 3,57 ,98 3,00 ,82 11.4 Influence of analysis and assessment of the development challenges, risks and threats on the decision making processes 3,43 ,95 3,57 1,13 2,90 1,10 11.5 Influence of analysis and assessment of the development challenges, risks and threats on the development of institutional/national legal base 3,27 ,95 3,57 1,13 2,70 1,34 11.6 Need of development and modernization of institutional capabilities for detecting and monitoring national security challenges, risks and threats 3,78 ,89 3,71 ,49 3,40 ,97
  • 17.
  • 18.
  • 19.
  • 20. THE NEED IS LITTLE HIGHER THAN THE AVAILABLE CAPABILITIES, BUT AS A WHOLE AVAILABLE INSTITUTIONAL CAPABILITIES ALLOW TO EXECUTE THEIR CURRENT ROLE
  • 21. NATIONAL SECURITY SYSTEM LEGAL FRAMEWORK – LAW ON NSS, DEFENCE LAW, LAW ON INTERNAL MINISTRY, CRISIS MANAGEMENT LAW, DISASTER MANAGEMENT LAW INSTITUTIONAL AND NATIONAL CONCEPTUAL AND STRATEGIC DOCUMENTS RELATED TO THE AREAS OF COUNTERING HYBRID THREATS NATIONAL AND INSTITUTIONAL CAPABILITY DEVELOPMENT RELATED STRATEGIC DOCUMENTS AND PLANS VS ALLIED (NATO AND EU) CAPSTONE AND STRATEGIC DOCUMENTS NSS MANAGEMENT: POLICY AND SYSTEM RESILIENCE, DECISION MAKING AND OPERATIONAL PROCEDURES, FOREIGN FACTORS OF INSTABILITY, POOR OR INEFFECTIVE MANAGEMENT PRACTICES AND VIOLATED PUBLIC TRUST CRITICAL ECONOMY SECTORS - ENERGETICS, DIVERSIFICATION OF RESOURCE MANAGEMENT, TRANSPORTATION, BANKING AND FINANCE, CRITICAL INFRASTRUCTURES INFORMATION POLICY, INFORMATION SECURITY AND PROTECTION, MEDIA, NETWORKS AND INFORMATION INFLUENCE, DISRUPTED STRATEGIC COMMUNICATION POSSIBLE AREAS OF ARISING OF HYBRID THREATS:
  • 22. THE MOST SIGNIFICANT POTENTIAL MIGHT HAVE A MANIFESTATION OF COMPLEMENTARITY, OVERLAY OR COMBINED AND HIGH NEGATIVE IMPACTS ON SECURITY WITH INTERNAL AND EXTERNAL NATURE, HARD TO PREDICT WITH LONG- TERM EFFECTS AND CONSEQUENCES. THEIR IDENTIFICATION AND MANAGEMENT REQUIRE SPECIALIZED INSTITUTIONAL BODIES FOR RECOGNITION, TRACKING, ANALYSIS AND COUNTERMEASURES THE ESTIMATION OF THE ARISING POSSIBILITY OF SUCH THREATS RANGE FROM MODERATELY HIGH UP TO HIGH, AND CALL FOR IMMEDIATE INSTITUTIONAL MEASURES TO ENHANCE THE PRELIMINARY INSTITUTIONAL READINESS AND STANDING PLANS, PROCEDURES AND MEASURES TO REACT ON THEIR UNEXPECTED DEVELOPMENT AND INFLUENCE A STRONG EMPHASIS ON THE NEED OF INSTITUTIONAL REFORMS TO ABSORB INSTITUTIONAL AND NATIONAL POTENTIAL WITH INTERNAL AND EXTERNAL POLITICAL DIALOGUE, OUTREACH, PUBLIC DIPLOMACY, COMBINATION OF ECONOMIC, INFORMATION AND SOCIAL MEASURES FOR ENHANCING PUBLIC TRUST AND SOCIETY RESILIENCE THE DISCUSSION IDENTIFIED THE NEED OF A PROACTIVE STRATEGY TO EXPAND INTERINSTITUTIONAL AND INTERNATIONAL COOPERATION AND COLLABORATION FOR A SHARED DEVELOPMENT AND USAGE OF NEW AND MODERNIZED INSTITUTIONAL/NATIONAL CAPABILITIES TO COUNTERING THREATS HYBRID IT WAS ACKNOWLEDGED THE INCREASING ROLE OF MODERN EDUCATION, TRAINING AND EXERCISING, AS WELL AS THE NEED OF MORE INSTITUTIONAL AND NATIONAL SCIENTIFIC RESEARCHES IN THIS AREA IN ORDER TO CONTINUOUSLY DEVELOP AND UPDATE SPECIALIZED SUBJECT MATTER EXPERTISE FOR NATIONAL SECURITY AND DEFENSE
  • 23. DELIBERATELY USE OF WEAKNESSES AND VULNERABILITIES: WEAKNESSES IN NATIONAL INSTITUTIONS AND GOVERNMENT FUNCTIONING, CORRUPTION LACK OF PUBLIC TRUST AND SUPPORT FOR INTERNAL SECURITY AND DEFENCE INSTITUTIONS’ EFFORT ETHNIC SEPARATION AND NEGLECTED THE INTERESTS OF LARGE ETHNIC GROUPS – POLITICAL, ECONOMIC AND SOCIAL MARGINALIZATION CRITICAL DEPENDENCE ON RESOURCES IMPORTS, ECONOMIC AND ENERGY DEPENDENCE, LACK OF DIVERSITY AND VULNERABILITY OF CRITICAL INFRASTRUCTURE - FINANCE, ENERGY, COMMUNICATIONS AND TRANSPORTATION AND CYBER
  • 24.
  • 25. THE REALIZATION OF A SMALL PART OF THE NATIONAL SECURITY FUNCTIONS (20% OR FOUR OF TWENTY) IS PERFORMED WITH AVAILABLE INSTITUTIONAL CAPABILITIES AT ABOVE THE MIDDLE TO HIGH LEVEL OF MEASUREMENT SCALE THE MAIN PART OF THE NSS FUNCTIONS IS PERFORMED UPON AVAILABLE CAPABILITIES AT ABOUT MIDDLE LEVEL, AND A SIGNIFICANT PART OF THESE ARE RATED EVEN LOWER THAN MIDDLE ON THE MEASUREMENT SCALE THE COMPARATIVE ASSESSMENT BETWEEN THE MOD NEEDS AND AVAILABLE CAPABILITIES REVEALED MULTIPLE GROUPS OF CAPABILITIES THAT NEED DEVELOPMENT, AS THE NEEDS ARE CONSIDERABLY HIGHER THAN ACTUAL AVAILABILITY THE INSUFFICIENT EXPERT INSTITUTIONAL REPRESENTATION (EXCEPT MOD), AND THEREFORE A BROADER EXPERT- PROFILE GROUPING, THE RESULTS OF ASSESSMENT THE INSTITUTIONAL ROLE OF MINISTRIES AND STATE AGENCIES COULD NOT BE CONSTRUED SUITABLE FOR EACH GROUP OF INSTITUTIONS THE RESULTS REVEAL A RELATIVELY NARROW INSTITUTIONAL AND SECTORAL SPECIALIZATION OF PARTICIPATING EXPERTS, AND IT COULD BE ASSUMED THAT INSTITUTIONAL ROLE IN SOME BASIC FUNCTIONS HAS NOT BEEN EVALUATED IN FULL COMPLIANCE WITH PRESCRIBED IN THE ENTIRE NSS LEGAL BASE INSTITUTIONAL RESPONSIBILITIES AND TASKS
  • 26. THE RESULTS REVEAL A CLEAR TREND OF AN EXPERT FOLLOWING THE ACTUAL POLITICAL TRENDS AND A PRIORITY EMPHASIS ON THE TOPICAL POLITICAL DECISIONS ON CAPABILITY DEVELOPMENT TO BOOST THE NSS FUNCTIONALITY A GOOD EXPERT SPECIALIZATION ALLOWS A SUFFICIENTLY FULL COMPLIANCE OF THE ASSESSMENT’S HIGHLIGHTS WITH REQUIREMENTS OF DEFENSE LEGISLATION, OFFICIAL POLICY AND INSTITUTIONAL STRATEGIC DOCUMENTS, AIMED TO INCREASE THE EFFECTIVENESS OF MOD CONTRIBUTION TO THE ALLIED CAPABILITY DEVELOPMENT AND USE DUE TO THE RESPONSE TO THE INSTITUTIONAL PRIORITIZATION AND COMMITMENT TO THE DEVELOPMENT OF SPECIFIC GROUPS OF CAPABILITIES, IT SEEMS UNDERESTIMATED THE NEED OF UPDATING CAPABILITIES TO DEFENSE THE TERRITORIAL INTEGRITY, STATE INDEPENDENCE AND TO COMBAT TERRORISM DESPITE INSTITUTIONAL EFFORT, THE UNDERESTIMATION OF THE NEED OF COMMAND AND CONTROL CAPABILITIES (TO IDENTIFY AND ANALYZE ARISING SECURITY CHALLENGES AND THREATS), IT STILL EXIST A PROBABILITY OF HYBRID THREATS DEVELOPMENT IN THE EXECUTION OF INTER-INSTITUTIONAL AND MULTI-INSTITUTIONAL NSS FUNCTIONS THE ANALYSIS OF THE RESEARCH’S RESULTS AND FINDINGS REVEALS - IN ORDER TO OVERCOME THE CAPABILITY SHORTAGE AND TO ENHANCE NSS READINESS IT IS NEEDED:
  • 27. COMPREHENSIVE REVIEW AND UPDATE NSS LEGAL AND REGULATORY FRAMEWORK, DEVELOPMENT A DETAILED CLASSIFICATION OF INSTITUTIONAL ROLES AND RESPONSIBILITIES FOR IMPLEMENTATION OF ITS BASIC FUNCTIONS PRIORITIZATION OF THE DEVELOPMENT AND ACTUALIZATION THE INSTITUTIONAL CAPABILITIES, NECESSARY FOR THE EXECUTION THE LEADING INSTITUTIONAL ROLES IN MAIN NATIONAL SECURITY AND DEFENSE FUNCTIONS INTER-INSTITUTIONAL PRIORITIZATION OF CAPABILITY COMMITMENT FOR THE IMPLEMENTATION OF LEGALLY PRESCRIBED INSTITUTIONAL ROLES, ENLARGING THE INSTITUTIONAL CONTRIBUTION TO THE SHARED NATIONAL AND ALLIANCE CAPABILITY DEVELOPMENT DEVELOPMENT EFFECTIVE MECHANISMS TO IMPROVE THE QUALITY OF INSTITUTIONAL EXPERTISE WITH EDUCATION, TRAINING AND EXERCISING, IN ORDER TO ENHANCE INTER-INSTITUTIONAL AND INTERNATIONAL COOPERATION AND COLLABORATION IN COUNTERING HYBRID THREATS