BSRIA
Isolation rooms
Blanca Beato Arribas
26 February 2016
2
Making buildings better…
BSRIA
A test, consultancy, instrument, research
and market research organisation
Specialists in construction and building
services
Member based association
Our values are to be authoritative,
collaborative, independent and innovative
Our Mission is to
• Make Buildings Better
3
Making buildings better…
Turnover breakdown
4
Making buildings better…
Advice
Indoor air quality and thermal comfort
BIM strategy and roadmap to implementation
Life Cycle Costing and environmental assessment
Soft Landings implementation
Mock up testing and design validation
5
Making buildings better…
Investigations
Troubleshooting and failure investigations
Building Performance Evaluation (pre and post construction)
Maintenance audits, strategy and condition surveys
Condition monitoring
Building user guides
6
Making buildings better…
Mock-up testing
7
Making buildings better…
Mock-up testing
BSRIA’s facilities
 White box chambers
– 9 m x 6 m x 4.5 m
– 8 m x 6 m x 4.5 m
 “a box within a box”
– Controlled conditions
– Bigger spaces- i.e. open plan office
8
Making buildings better…
Isolation Rooms
Department of Health of
England
 PPVL and Negative P
 CL4 downflow system
Department of Health, Social
Services and Public Safety
(DHSSPS), Northern Ireland
 Intensive Care Unit (ICU)
9
Making buildings better…
PPVL Concept
 Protection from
airborne infection
 Protection to inmuno
compromised patients
 Protection to staff in
room
Corridor
Isolation room
Backpassage
Ensuite
Lobby
Viewing chamber
S
E
Corridor
0.70
4.24 2.49
1.80
1.12
2.412.0
2.84.5
8.45
6.83
All measurements in m
Internal height=3m excluding floor
Internal height lobby=2.7m excluding floor
Positively Pressurised Ventilated Lobby
10
Making buildings better…
Supply
220 l/s
Pressure
stabiliser
100 l/s
Extract
160 l/s
Door
60 l/s
Door
60 l/s
Door
60 l/s
Grille
100 l/s
+10 Pa0 Pa
0 Pa
-10 Pa
HBN4 Isolation room
LOBBY
ISOLATION
ROOM
EN SUITE
BATHROOM
CORRIDOR
11
Making buildings better…
Intensive Care Unit
CORRIDOR
PLANT ROOM
ISOLATION ROOM
LOBBY
Lobby to Isolation
room door
Lobby to corridor
door
Bed
RPS
LPS
Supply
Supply
High Extract
Low Extract
0 Pa
0 Pa
0 Pa
10 Pa
0 Pa
12
Making buildings better…
Mock-up construction HBN4
13
Making buildings better…
14
Making buildings better…
ICU Mock-up Belfast
15
Making buildings better…
CL4 mock-up Bracknell
16
Making buildings better…
Isolation room
Validated
Smoke tests
Airtightness
Gas tracer
tests Salt tests/
bio-
aerosols*
Design
Mock-up
construction
Room air
movement
Validation process
CFD
*University of Leeds, UK
17
Making buildings better…
Airtightness
 Differential Pressure 
Flows through structure
 These flows need to be
quantified
 Set up the P/S and flow
under doors
 Fan failure
 BSRIA Standard on
airtightness of Isolation
rooms in 2016 ATTMA Technical Standard 1 Issue 2
“Measuring Air Permeability of Building Envelopes”
18
Making buildings better…
Airtightness
Sealed plate for testing
19
Making buildings better…
Smoke tests
20
Making buildings better…
Smoke tests
21
Making buildings better…
Anemometer Surveys
(Room air movement)
22
Making buildings better…
23
Making buildings better…
24
Making buildings better…
25
Making buildings better…
26
Making buildings better…
Gas Tracer Tests
Nitrous Oxide
Release: different points
Room challenges: fan failure,
effect of doors
27
Making buildings better…
Gas Tracer Tests
 Nitrous Oxide
 Release: patient, sink,
nurse, tent
 Room challenges: fan
failure, effect of doors
 N2O-airborne
pathogens-studied at
the university of Leeds,
UK
28
Making buildings better…
Gas tracer tests
29
Making buildings better…
Comparison of PPVL and Neg P
(Normalised Gas tracer concentration)
Model Type Test Extr.ppm 2
Bed
3
LHS
4
LHS
5
RHS
7
under bed
ACR (h-1
)
Measured
1 PPVL 24 152 1.31 0.96 0.99 1.39 1.15 8.5
1 Neg P 30 174 0.95 0.86 0.90 1.14 0.44 11
Model Type Test Extr.ppm Extract Around bed 6
by nurse
2
by sink
7
under bed
ACR (h-1
)
Measured
2 PPVL 5 138 Low 1.00 0.88 0.97 0.88 12.3
2 Neg P 29 152 Low 1.18 1.18 0.98 0.86 18.2
30
Making buildings better…
CFD model
 Model of empty room
 Pressure stabiliser
 Air speed
measurements- Used to
verify the predictions
 Accurate modelling of
blade profile
31
Making buildings better…
Airtightness
 Building Regulations :10 m3/hr/m2 at 50 Pa
 BSRIA 1 m3/hr/m2 at a test pressure of 10 Pa = 2.62
at 50 Pa.
Model Working P Test P ALI ALI (used) Max Test Flow Rate
Max. Test Flow
Rate / unit volume
(Pa) (Pa) m3
/(h.m2
) m3
/(h.m2
) (l.s-1
) (l.s-1
per m3
)
1 10 20 3.16 3 72.5 1.01
15 30 3.87 3.9 94.3 1.31
20 40 4.47 4.5 108.8 1.51
25 50 5 5 120.8 1.68
2 10 20 3.16 3 99.2 0.75
15 30 3.87 3.9 128.9 0.98
20 40 4.47 4.5 148.8 1.13
25 50 5 5 165.3 1.25
n
PkQ 
32
Making buildings better…
Conclusions-Cat 1-3 Isolation
rooms
 Successful validation: Well mixed (80%) single zone
 Good comparison between GTT salt tests and
bioaerosols
 Structural integrity = passive protection
 Pressure differentials = protection to an extent (doors
closed)
 Protection within the room = determined by internal
flows
– 0.5 to 2 of extract concentration
– Dilution strategy provides 10^3 Protection factor
33
Making buildings better…
Acknowledgements
 The Department of Health of England
 The Department of Health, Social Services and
Public Safety (DHSSPS), Northern Ireland
 The University of Leeds, UK
34
Making buildings better…
The patient in the next bed is
highly contagious- thank God
for these curtains!!
Thank you for
your attention
Any questions?

BSRIA Isolation Rooms