The Vocabulary of Science

      Dr. John Bradford
Three types of Studies
•  There are 3 different types of studies that
   correspond to 3 different sorts of dependent
   variables (Y), or objects of investigation…
1. Case study (what causes an event or condition)
    –   Often we aren’t interested in Y itself as a fact or
        event, but changes in Y across time (longitudinal study)
        or differences in Y across space (cross-sectional study).
2. Cross-sectional study (comparison across space)
3. Longitudinal study (comparison across time)
Levels of Knowledge
1. Descriptive/factual/observational- report data.
   –   I know it because I saw it or heard it, and if someone else were
       there, they would have heard or seen the same thing.
2. Inferences or Assumptions-
   – Statements made about something we don’t know, on the basis
     of what we do know. Most common form of knowledge.
3. Evaluations/Judgments:
   – An expression of approval or disapproval to assumptions we
     made, whether or not it is based on something we have seen or
     heard.
   – Example: “John is a total jerk!”
   – They do not convey why we feel the way feel. Abstract
     judgment words are more about selves and the hidden feelings
     we want to express.
What’s a Good Explanation?
• “A scientific theory should be as
  simple as possible, but no
  simpler.” - Einstein
• This idea that (all other things
  being equal) the simpler of two
  theories is the better theory, is
  called the principle of parsimony,
  or ‘Occam’s razor’
• Question: Can you think of
  reasons why a simpler explanation
  might be a better explanation?
Three Simple Steps to Social Science
               (easier said than done)

STEP 1: Select some concepts of interest
   (variables)
STEP 2: Posit (suggest) some relationship
   between these concepts (Hypothesis)
STEP 3: Test these suggestions empirically to
   see if they are right.
Concepts and Constructs
• Concept: a label that is applied to things with
  similar characteristics or attributes; a
  generalization, or category.
• Constructs: an abstract concept; words used
  to describe things that exist analytically (in our
  minds) but are not directly observable or
  perceivable.
  – Examples: Racism, love, economic depression,
    loyalty, etc.
What are Variables?
• Variable: something of interest to a social
  researcher.
• Variables have two characteristics:
  1. It is thought to influence or be influenced by
      another thing.
  2. A variable is some attribute of a category of things
      that has more than one possible ‘value’
  – A ‘variable’ is not a constant! Not all observed cases
    are identical with respect to this value.
  – Variables imply differences and hence comparability.
Variable Definitions
• Here are some more ways of defining
  ‘variable’:
  – A variable is a characteristic or value that can
    change or be changed.
  – A category or attribute with more than one
    possible type or value.
  – A category of things with observed differences or
    changes.
  – a quantity that may assume any one of a set of
    values (Merrian-Webster)
Variables: Cause and Effect
• Below are some examples of how two variables may relate
  causally. We usually designate with an ‘X’ the variable we
  think is ‘causing’ (‘influencing’, ‘effecting’ etc.) the other
  variable, which we designate as Y.
• X Y
• Examples:
   – Gender (X) is thought to influence occupation (Y)
   – Religious affiliation (Y) is thought to be influenced by income.
   – Educational attainment (X) is thought to influence income (Y).
   – Age (X) is thought to influence attitudes towards using
     computers (Y)
   – Income (Y) is thought to be influenced by race (X)
Variables:
   Independent (X) vs Dependent (Y)
• Independent variable (X) = the cause.
  Variable that influences.
• Dependent variable (Y) = the effect. Variable
  that is influenced by the cause; it is dependent
  on the cause.
• INCA: the INdependent variable is the CAuse.
Directionality
• Variables that vary in the same
  direction have a positive
  relationship.
• Variables that vary in the opposite
  direction have a negative
  relationship.
  – Example: a decrease in employment
    is associated with a decrease in
    income:
  – Even though both variables go
    down, they vary in the same
    direction. This is a positive
    relationship! (-1 * -1 = + 1)
Operational Definitions
• Creating an operational definition involves
  transforming the variables into things that can
  be observed and measured.
• Operational just means ‘working’: you are
  creating a ‘working’ definition, i.e. one that
  you can use!
Mean, Median, Mode
• Mean is the average: add up the values and
  divide the result by the number of cases.
• Median is the number in the middle so that
  half of the numbers in the set are above this
  number and half are below it.
• Mode is the number that occurs most
  frequently.
Quantitative and Qualitative Research
1. Quantitative Research
  – Gathers data that are easily expressed in numbers
  – Emile Durkheim felt that the goal of sociology was to
    discover the laws that govern social behavior
2. Qualitative Research
  – Focuses not only on objective nature of behavior but
    also on its meaning
  – Max Weber thought that sociology had to be an
    interpretive science- it must take into account the
    social meanings/reasons attached to behaviors.

1 29-13 the vocabulary of science

  • 1.
    The Vocabulary ofScience Dr. John Bradford
  • 2.
    Three types ofStudies • There are 3 different types of studies that correspond to 3 different sorts of dependent variables (Y), or objects of investigation… 1. Case study (what causes an event or condition) – Often we aren’t interested in Y itself as a fact or event, but changes in Y across time (longitudinal study) or differences in Y across space (cross-sectional study). 2. Cross-sectional study (comparison across space) 3. Longitudinal study (comparison across time)
  • 3.
    Levels of Knowledge 1.Descriptive/factual/observational- report data. – I know it because I saw it or heard it, and if someone else were there, they would have heard or seen the same thing. 2. Inferences or Assumptions- – Statements made about something we don’t know, on the basis of what we do know. Most common form of knowledge. 3. Evaluations/Judgments: – An expression of approval or disapproval to assumptions we made, whether or not it is based on something we have seen or heard. – Example: “John is a total jerk!” – They do not convey why we feel the way feel. Abstract judgment words are more about selves and the hidden feelings we want to express.
  • 4.
    What’s a GoodExplanation? • “A scientific theory should be as simple as possible, but no simpler.” - Einstein • This idea that (all other things being equal) the simpler of two theories is the better theory, is called the principle of parsimony, or ‘Occam’s razor’ • Question: Can you think of reasons why a simpler explanation might be a better explanation?
  • 5.
    Three Simple Stepsto Social Science (easier said than done) STEP 1: Select some concepts of interest (variables) STEP 2: Posit (suggest) some relationship between these concepts (Hypothesis) STEP 3: Test these suggestions empirically to see if they are right.
  • 6.
    Concepts and Constructs •Concept: a label that is applied to things with similar characteristics or attributes; a generalization, or category. • Constructs: an abstract concept; words used to describe things that exist analytically (in our minds) but are not directly observable or perceivable. – Examples: Racism, love, economic depression, loyalty, etc.
  • 7.
    What are Variables? •Variable: something of interest to a social researcher. • Variables have two characteristics: 1. It is thought to influence or be influenced by another thing. 2. A variable is some attribute of a category of things that has more than one possible ‘value’ – A ‘variable’ is not a constant! Not all observed cases are identical with respect to this value. – Variables imply differences and hence comparability.
  • 8.
    Variable Definitions • Hereare some more ways of defining ‘variable’: – A variable is a characteristic or value that can change or be changed. – A category or attribute with more than one possible type or value. – A category of things with observed differences or changes. – a quantity that may assume any one of a set of values (Merrian-Webster)
  • 9.
    Variables: Cause andEffect • Below are some examples of how two variables may relate causally. We usually designate with an ‘X’ the variable we think is ‘causing’ (‘influencing’, ‘effecting’ etc.) the other variable, which we designate as Y. • X Y • Examples: – Gender (X) is thought to influence occupation (Y) – Religious affiliation (Y) is thought to be influenced by income. – Educational attainment (X) is thought to influence income (Y). – Age (X) is thought to influence attitudes towards using computers (Y) – Income (Y) is thought to be influenced by race (X)
  • 10.
    Variables: Independent (X) vs Dependent (Y) • Independent variable (X) = the cause. Variable that influences. • Dependent variable (Y) = the effect. Variable that is influenced by the cause; it is dependent on the cause. • INCA: the INdependent variable is the CAuse.
  • 11.
    Directionality • Variables thatvary in the same direction have a positive relationship. • Variables that vary in the opposite direction have a negative relationship. – Example: a decrease in employment is associated with a decrease in income: – Even though both variables go down, they vary in the same direction. This is a positive relationship! (-1 * -1 = + 1)
  • 12.
    Operational Definitions • Creatingan operational definition involves transforming the variables into things that can be observed and measured. • Operational just means ‘working’: you are creating a ‘working’ definition, i.e. one that you can use!
  • 13.
    Mean, Median, Mode •Mean is the average: add up the values and divide the result by the number of cases. • Median is the number in the middle so that half of the numbers in the set are above this number and half are below it. • Mode is the number that occurs most frequently.
  • 14.
    Quantitative and QualitativeResearch 1. Quantitative Research – Gathers data that are easily expressed in numbers – Emile Durkheim felt that the goal of sociology was to discover the laws that govern social behavior 2. Qualitative Research – Focuses not only on objective nature of behavior but also on its meaning – Max Weber thought that sociology had to be an interpretive science- it must take into account the social meanings/reasons attached to behaviors.

Editor's Notes

  • #3 This list is not exhaustive. I excluded, for example, the obvious combination of #2 and #3, which in statistics is sometimes called “panel” data analysis. There is also comparative statics, which is like taking cross-sectional studies taken at two different times (like snapshots) and comparing them. The object of investigation is called the explanandum, more commonly known as the dependent variable (Y).
  • #4 These correspond to the different meaning of the phrase ‘I KNOW’. Observations say as much about the observer as they do that which they observe.