SlideShare a Scribd company logo
Chapter 1
Thinking
Critically with
Psychological
Science
Topics and Questions
 The history and
growth of
psychology
 The big question:
Nature vs. Nurture
 Biopsychosocial
levels of analysis
 Psychology’s
subfields
 Avoiding three
“common sense”
thinking errors
How do I explain
dreams? Anxiety? The
abilities and funny
behavior of babies?
 The Scientific Attitude:
Curiosity, Skepticism,
Humility
 The Scientific Method
 Description, Correlation,
and Experimentation
 Frequently Asked Questions
about Psychology
 Applying psychology to
learning the text: SQ3R
From speculation to science:
The Birth of Modern Psychology
Aristotle (4th century BCE) had ideas
about how the body and mind work.
His method: making guesses.
Wilhelm Wundt (1832-1920) added
two key elements to help make
psychology a science:
1. carefully measured observations
2. experiments
Push a button when a ball
dropped (based on when they
heard the ball hit a platform):
1/10th of a second.
Push a button when
consciously aware of hearing
the ball hit the platform:
2/10ths of a second.
Wilhelm Wundt’s 1879 experiment
measured the time it took for people to:
Why were the
times different?
Structuralism
 Edward Titchener, like his teacher Wundt, used data from
introspection, reporting on sensations and other elements of
experience.
 Structuralism: Using these introspective reports to build a
view of the mind’s structure
Functionalism: The school of thought that
Psychological processes have a function: helping us survive
as individuals, adapt as a species
 The developer of
functionalism, William
James (1842-1910),
asked: How did the
human style of thinking
and behavior enable our
ancestors to live long
enough to reproduce?
 James mentored another
pioneer
William
James
 Mary Whiton Calkins
(1863-1930) became a
memory researcher and
the first female president
of the APA.
 She studied with William
James but was denied a
Harvard PhD. Why?
Because of her gender.
Psychology Pioneers
Mary
Whiton
Calkins
Psychology Pioneers
Margaret Floy
Washburn,
PhD
Margaret Floy Washburn
(1871-1939):
 The first female to earn a
Psychology PhD
 The second female APA
president
 Author of The Animal
Mind.
Shifting definitions of “psychology”
Wilhelm
Wundt and
Edward
Titchener,
around 1900:
“The science
of mental life.”
John B.
Watson and
B.F. Skinner,
behaviorists,
1920’s: “The
scientific
study of
observable
behavior.”
Cognitive
psychologists,
1960’s,
studied
internal mental
processes,
helped by
neuroscience.
Now we combine
these definitions:
“The science of
behavior and
mental
processes.”
Behaviorists study and
experiment with
observable behavior.
Watson experimented
with conditioned
responses.
Skinner studied the way
consequences shape
behavior.
Like other behaviorists,
he saw little value in
introspection.
Trends in Psychological Science:
Behaviorism
John B. Watson
B. F. Skinner
Sigmund Freud, founder of
psychoanalysis:
 He studied and helped people with a
variety of mental disorders.
 More about Freud when we study
personality and therapy
Sigmund Freud
Trends in Psychology:
Freudian/Psychoanalytic Psychology
Humanists: Abraham Maslow and Carl
Rogers (1960s):
 studied people who were thriving rather
than those who had psychological
problems.
 developed theories and treatments to
help people to feel accepted and to reach
their full potential.
Carl Rogers
Abraham Maslow
Trends in Psychology:
Humanism
The Growth of
Psychology
 Psychology’s pioneers have come
from many fields: physiology,
philosophy, medicine, and biology.
 Advances in psychology also have
been made in many countries
 Psychology has spread rapidly;
there are 71 member nations in
the IUPS.
The subjects studied in
psychology have
multiplied too… as we
shall see in this course.
The Big Issue in Psychology: N-N
To what extent are
our traits already set
in place at birth (our
“Nature”)?
And to what extent
do our traits
develop in
response to our
environment/
experience (our
“Nurture”)?
The Nature-
Nurture
Question:
vs.
Nature Nurture
Plato:
Ideas such
as “the
good” and
“beauty”
are inborn.
Descartes:
Some ideas
are innate.
Charles Darwin: Some
traits become part of
our nature through
natural selection: they
help us survive long
enough to pass the traits
to the next generation.
Aristotle:
All knowledge
comes through
the senses.
John Locke:
The mind is a
blank slate (blank
chalkboard or
screen) “written
on” by experience.
Nature Nurture
We have
differences
that are
shaped by our
environment.
We share a
common
origin that
gives us an
inborn human
nature in
common.
+
“Nurture works on what Nature endows.”
The Roles of
Nature and
Nurture:
Biology Plus Environment..
are part of
psychology’s three
“biopsychosocial”
levels of analysis.
The deep level,
Biology:
genes, brain,
neuro-
transmitters,
survival,
reflexes,
sensation
The outer level,
Environment:
social Influences,
culture,
education,
relationships
In the middle,
Psychology:
thoughts,
emotions,
moods, choices,
behaviors, traits,
motivations,
knowledge,
perceptions
The three levels as influences on
some psychological phenomenon
Example: Depression
Example: Intelligence
Example: Enjoying Soccer
Example: Shyness
Cognitive
perspective
Social-cultural
Behavioral
genetics
Neuroscience
Psychodynamic
Behaviorist
Evolutionary
There are many
perspectives for
describing
psychological
phenomena: From different angles, you ask different questions:
How reliable is memory? How can we improve our
thinking?
Could our behavior, skills, and attitudes be
“downloads” from our culture?
Could our behavior, skills, and attitudes be
genetically programmed instincts?
What role do our bodies and brains play in
emotions? How is pain inhibited? Can we trust our
senses?
Do inner childhood conflicts still plague me and
affect my behavior?
How are our problematic behaviors reinforced?
How do our fears become conditioned? What can
we do to change these fears and behaviors?
Why are humans prone to panic, anger, and
making irrational judgments?
Different perspectives on a single issue:
Six Blind Men and an Elephant
Let’s play: “What’s my perspective?”
“Obsessive-
compulsive
disorder is a
problem in the
orbital cortex.”
“No, it’s a sign
of unresolved
childhood
issues.”
“No, OCD is
an
inherited
condition.”
“Compulsions start as habits
and are rewarded by the
anxiety relief they bring.”
“OCD comes
from our
natural instinct
to control our
environment.”
“OCD thinking
and behavior is a
reaction to our
fast-paced, out-
of-control
lifestyles.”
“No, OCD is a matter
of mental habits and
errors that can be
corrected.”
Psychology’s Subfields
Applied
Clinical Psychology
Counseling Psychology
Educational Psychology
Industrial-Organizational
Community Psychology
Clinical Psychology
Basic research
Biological
Developmental
Cognitive
Personality
Social
Positive Psychology
Psychology’s Subfields
Research Examples
Type of research
Biological
Developmental
Cognitive
Personality
Social
Positive Psychology
Study how the stages of
cognitive and emotional
development vary in autism
Explore the structural problems
in the brain that may be part of
autism
Clarify the difficulties autistic
children have with
understanding sarcasm
Decide whether traits like
neuroticism need to be
measured differently in autism
Find how autistic children can
learn social skills as procedures
if not by intuition
Explore what motivates people
and contributes to life
satisfaction
Applied
Clinical Psychology
Counseling Psychology
Educational Psychology
Industrial-Organizational
Community Psychology
Clinical Psychology
Psychology’s Subfields
Applied
Help someone achieve career
goals despite family conflict and
self-doubt
Use exposure therapy to
decrease phobic reactions in a
traumatized client
Evaluate aptitudes and
achievement to plan for a
student with learning problems
Figure out how a factory can
improve coordination of tasks,
roles, and personalities
Help coordinate a city’s efforts
to understand and prevent
elder abuse
Use exposure therapy to
decrease phobic reactions in a
traumatized client
Psychology in context with
other professions
Psychiatrists are
physicians, M.D.s or
D.O.s. They can prescribe
medication.
In addition to
psychologists,
professionals in social
work, counseling, and
marriage and family
therapy may be trained
to do psychotherapy.
The Need for Psychological Science:
Overview
 Typical errors in hindsight, overconfidence, and
coincidence
 The scientific attitude and critical thinking
 The scientific method: theories and hypotheses
 Gathering psychological data: description,
correlation, and experimentation/causation
 Describing data: significant differences
 Issues in psychology: laboratory vs. life, culture
and gender, values and ethics
When our natural thinking style fails:
Hindsight bias:
“I knew it all
along.”
Overconfidence
error:
“I am sure I am
correct.”
The coincidence
error, or
mistakenly
perceiving order
in random events:
“The dice must be
fixed because you
rolled three sixes
in a row.”
Hindsight
bias is like a
crystal ball
that we use
to predict…
the past.
I knew this would
happen…
You were accepted
into this
college/university
Classic example:
after watching a
competition (sports,
cooking), if you don’t
make a prediction
ahead of time, you
might make a
“postdiction”: “I
figured that
team/person would
win because…”
When you see most
results of
psychological
research, you might
say, “that was
obvious…”
Hindsight Bias
These sayings all
seem to make sense,
in hindsight, after we
read them.
Out of sight, out of mind
S/He who hesitates is lost
No [wo]man is an island
Actions speak louder than words
You’re never too old to learn
Curiosity killed the cat
Opposites attract
There’s no place like home
Absence makes the heart grow fonder
Look before you leap
Good fences make good neighbors
The pen is mightier than the sword
You can’t teach an old dog new tricks
The grass is always greener on the other side of the fence
Seek and ye shall find
Birds of a feather flock together
But then why do
these other
phrases also seem
to make sense?
Hindsight “Bias”
The mind builds its
current wisdom around
what we have already
been told. We are
“biased” in favor of old
information.
For example, we may
stay in a bad relationship
because it has lasted this
far and thus was “meant
to be.”
Why call it “bias”?
Overconfidence
Error:
Predicting performance
 We overestimate our
performance, our rate of work,
our skills, and our degree of
self-control.
Overconfidence
Error:
Judging our accuracy
 When stating that we
“know” something, our
level of confidence is
usually much higher than
our level of accuracy.
 Overconfidence is a
problem in preparing for
tests. Familiarity is not
understanding
 If you feel confident
that you know a concept,
try explaining it to
someone else.
Test for this: “how long do
you think it takes you to…”
(e.g. “just finish this one thing I’m
doing on the computer before I get
to work”)?
How fast can you unscramble
words? Guess, then try these:
ERSEGA
HEGOUN
Result of this
error:
reacting to
coincidence
as if it has
meaning
Perceiving order in random events:
Example: The
coin tosses
that “look
wrong” if
there are five
heads in a
row.
Danger: thinking you can make a
prediction from a random series.
If there have been five heads in a
row, you can not predict that “it’s
time for tails” on the next flip
Why this error happens: because
we have the wrong idea about
what randomness looks like.
If one poker player
at a table got pocket
aces twice in a row,
is the game rigged?
Making our ideas more accurate by
being scientific
What did “Amazing Randi” do
about the claim of seeing
auras? He developed a
testable prediction, which
would support the theory if it
succeeded.
Which it did not.
The aura-readers were
unable to locate the aura
around Randi’s body without
seeing Randi’s body itself, so
their claim was not
supported.
Scientific Attitude Part 1: Curiosity
Hypothesis:
Curiosity, if not
guided by caution,
can lead to the
death of felines
and perhaps
humans.
Definition:
always asking new
questions
“That behavior I’m noticing in that guy… is that
common to all people? Or is it more common when
under stress? Or only common for males?”
Scientific Attitude Part 2: Skepticism
Definition:
not accepting a ‘fact’ as true without
challenging it; seeing if ‘facts’ can
withstand attempts to disprove them
Skepticism, like curiosity, generates
questions: “Is there another
explanation for the behavior I am
seeing? Is there a problem with how I
measured it, or how I set up my
experiment? Do I need to change my
theory to fit the evidence?”
Scientific Attitude Part 3: Humility
Humility refers to
seeking the truth
rather than trying to
be right; a scientist
needs to be able to
accept being
wrong.
“What matters is
not my opinion or
yours, but the
truth nature
reveals in
response to our
questioning.”
David Myers
Critical thinking refers to a
more careful style of forming
and evaluating knowledge
than simply using intuition.
Along with the scientific method,
critical thinking will help us develop
more effective and accurate ways to
figure out what makes people do,
think, and feel the things they do.
“Think critically” with psychological science…
does this mean “criticize”?
Why do I need to
work on my thinking?
Can’t you just tell me
facts about
psychology?
• The brain is
designed for
surviving and
reproducing, but it
is not the best tool
for seeing ‘reality’
clearly.
Critical thinking:
analyzing
information,
arguments, and
conclusions, to
decide if they make
sense, rather than
simply accepting it.
Look for
hidden
assumptions
and decide if
you agree.
Look for
hidden bias,
politics,
values, or
personal
connections.
Put aside
your own
assumptions
and biases,
and look at
the
evidence.
See if there
was a flaw in
how the
information
was
collected.
Consider if
there are
other
possible
explanations
for the facts
or results.
How Psychologists Ask and Answer Questions:
The Scientific Method
The scientific method is the process of
testing our ideas about the world by:
Turning our theories
into testable
predictions.
Gather information
related to our
predictions.
analyzing whether
the data fits with
our ideas.
If the data doesn’t fit our ideas, then we modify our
hypotheses, set up a study or experiment, and try
again to see if the world fits our predictions.
Scientific Method:
Tools and Goals
Some research findings revealed by
the scientific method:
 The brain can recover from
massive early childhood
brain damage.
 Sleepwalkers are not acting
out dreams.
 Our brains do not have
accurate memories locked
inside like video files.
 There is no “hidden and
unused 90 percent” of our
brain.
 People often change their
opinions to fit their actions.
The basics:
 Theory
 Hypothesis
 Operational
Definitions
 Replication
Research goals/types:
 Description
 Correlation
 Prediction
 Causation
 Experiments
Theory: the big picture
Example of a theory:
“All ADHD symptoms
are a reaction to
eating sugar.”
A theory, in the
language of
science, is a set of
principles, built on
observations and
other verifiable
facts, that explains
some phenomenon
and predicts its
future behavior.
Hypotheses: informed predictions
“Testable” means that the
hypothesis is stated in a way
that we could make
observations to find out if it
is true.
A hypothesis is
a testable
prediction
consistent with
our theory.
What would be a
prediction from the “All
ADHD is about sugar”
theory?
One hypothesis: “If a kid gets sugar, the kid will act more
distracted, impulsive, and hyper.”
To test the “All” part of the theory: “ADHD symptoms
will continue for some kids even after sugar is removed
from the diet.”
Danger when testing hypotheses:
theories can bias our observations
We might select only the
data, or the interpretations
of the data, that support
what we already believe.
There are safeguards
against this:
 Hypotheses designed to
disconfirm
 Operational definitions
Guide for making useful
observations:
 How can we measure
“ADHD symptoms” in
the previous example in
observable terms?
 Impulsivity = # of
times/hour calling
out without raising
hand.
 Hyperactivity = # of
times/hour out of
seat
 Inattention = #
minutes
continuously on task
before becoming
distracted
The next/final step in the
scientific method:
Replication
You could introduce a small change in the study, e.g.
trying the ADHD/sugar test on college students instead
of elementary students.
Replicating research
means trying the methods
of a study again, but with
different participants or
situations, to see if the
same results happen.
Research Process: an example
Scientific Method:
Tools and Goals
The basics:
 Theory
 Hypothesis
 Operational Definitions
 Replication
Research goals/types:
 Description
 Correlation
 Prediction
 Causation
 Experiments
Now that we’ve covered this
We can move on to this
Research goal and strategy:
Description
Strategies for gathering this
information:
 Case Study: observing
and gathering information
to compile an in-depth
study of one individual
 Naturalistic Observation:
gathering data about
behavior; watching but
not intervening
 Surveys and Interviews:
having other people
report on their own
attitudes and behavior
Descriptive
research is a
systematic,
objective
observation of
people.
The goal is to
provide a
clear, accurate
picture of
people’s
behaviors,
thoughts, and
attributes.
Case Study
Examining one individual in
depth
 Benefit: can be a source
of ideas about human
nature in general
 Example: cases of brain
damage have suggested
the function of different
parts of the brain (e.g.
Phineas Gage seen here)
 Danger:
overgeneralization from
one example; “Joe got
better after tapping his
foot, so tapping must be
the key to health!”
 Observing “natural”
behavior means just
watching (and taking
notes), and not trying
to change anything.
 This method can be
used to study more
than one individual,
and to find truths
that apply to a
broader population.
Naturalistic Observation
The Survey
 Definition: A method of
gathering information
about many people’s
thoughts or behaviors
through self-report rather
than observation.
 Keys to getting useful
information:
 Be careful about the
wording of questions
 Only question randomly
sampled people
Wording effects
the results you get
from a survey can be
changed by your
word selection.
Example:
Q: Do you have
motivation to study
hard for this course?
Q: Do you feel a
desire to study hard
for this course?
What psychology
science mistake was
made here?
Hint #1: Harry Truman won.
Hint #2: The
Chicago
Tribune
interviewed
people about
whom they
would vote
for.
Hint #3:
in 1948.
Hint #4:
by
phone.
Random Sampling
• If you want to find out
something about men, you
can’t interview every single
man on earth.
• Sampling saves time. You
can find the ratio of colors in
this jar by making sure they
are well mixed (randomized)
and then taking a sample. population sample
Random sampling is a
technique for making
sure that every individual
in a population has an
equal chance of being in
your sample.
“Random” means
that your
selection of
participants is
driven only by
chance, not by
any characteristic.
Correlation
General Definition: an
observation that two
traits or attributes are
related to each other
(thus, they are “co”-
related)
Scientific definition: a
measure of how closely
two factors vary
together, or how well
you can predict a change
in one from observing a
change in the other
In a case study: The
fewer hours the boy
was allowed to sleep,
the more episodes of
aggression he
displayed.
A possible result of
many descriptive
studies:
discovering a correlation
In a naturalistic
observation:
Children in a
classroom who were
dressed in heavier
clothes were more
likely to fall asleep
than those wearing
lighter clothes.
In a survey: The
greater the number
of Facebook friends,
the less time was
spent studying.
Correlation Coefficient
• The correlation coefficient is a number representing how closely
and in what way two variables correlate (change together).
• The direction of the correlation can be positive (direct relationship;
both variables increase together) or negative (inverse relationship:
as one increases, the other decreases).
• The strength of the relationship, how tightly, predictably they vary
together, is measured in a number that varies from 0.00 to +/- 1.00.
Close to
+1.0
(strong negative
correlation)
(no relationship,
no correlation)
Guess the Correlation Coefficients
(strong positive
correlation)
Height vs. shoe
size
Years in school
vs. years in jail
Height vs.
intelligence
Close to
0.0
Close to
-1.0
If we find a correlation,
what conclusions can we
draw from it?
Let’s say we find the following
result:
there is a positive correlation
between two variables,
 ice cream sales, and
 rates of violent crime
How do we explain this?
Correlation is not Causation!
“People who floss
more regularly have
less risk of heart
disease.”
“People with bigger
feet tend to be taller.”
If this data is from a
survey, can we
conclude that
flossing might
prevent heart
disease? Or that
people with heart-
healthy habits also
floss regularly?
Does that mean
having bigger feet
causes height?
If self-esteem correlates with depression,
there are still numerous possible causal links:
So how do we find out about
causation? By experimentation
 Testing the theory
that ADHD = sugar:
removing sugar from
the diet of children
with ADHD to see if it
makes a difference
 The depression/self-
esteem example:
trying interventions
that improve self-
esteem to see if they
cause a reduction in
depression
Experimentation:
manipulating one
factor in a
situation to
determine its
effect
The Control Group
• If we manipulate a variable in an experimental group
of people, and then we see an effect, how do we
know the change wouldn’t have happened anyway?
• We solve this problem by comparing this group to a
control group, a group that is the same in every way
except the one variable we are changing.
Example: two groups of children have ADHD, but
only one group stops eating refined sugar.
By using random
assignment:
randomly selecting
some study
participants to be
assigned to the
control group or the
experimental group.
How do make
sure the control
group is really
identical in every
way to the
experimental
group?
To clarify two similar-sounding
terms…
First you sample,
then you sort
(assign)
Random
assignment of
participants to
control or
experimental
groups is how
you control all
variables except
the one you’re
manipulating.
Random
sampling is how
you get a pool of
research
participants that
represents the
population
you’re trying to
learn about.
Placebo effect
Placebo effect:
experimental effects
that are caused by
expectations about
the intervention
 How do we make sure that the
experimental group doesn’t
experience an effect because they
expect to experience it?
 How can we make sure both
groups expect to get better, but
only one gets the real
intervention being studied?
Working with the
placebo effect:
Control groups may be
given a placebo – an
inactive substance or
other fake treatment in
place of the experimental
treatment.
 The control group is
ideally “blind” to
whether they are
getting real or fake
treatment.
 Many studies are
double-blind – neither
participants nor
research staff knows
which participants are
in the experimental or
control groups.
The variable we are able to manipulate
independently of what the other variables are
doing is called the independent variable (IV).
• If we test the ADHD/sugar hypothesis:
• Sugar = Cause = Independent Variable
• ADHD = Effect = Dependent Variable
The variable we expect to experience a change
which depends on the manipulation we’re doing is
called the dependent variable (DV).
• Did more hyper kids get to choose to be in the sugar group?
Then their preference for sugar would be a confounding
variable. (preventing this problem: random assignment).
The other variables that might have an effect on the
dependent variable are confounding variables.
Naming the variables
An experiment is a type of
research in which the
researcher carefully
manipulates a limited number
of factors (IVs) and measures
the impact on other factors
(DVs).
*in psychology, you
would be looking at
the effect of the
experimental change
(IV) on a behavior or
mental process (DV).
Filling in our definition of
experimentation
Correlation vs. causation:
the breastfeeding/intelligence question
• Studies have found that
children who were breastfed
score higher on intelligence
tests, on average, than those
who were bottle-fed.
• Can we conclude that breast
feeding CAUSES higher
intelligence?
• Not necessarily. There is at
least one confounding
variable: genes. The
intelligence test scores of the
mothers might be higher in
those who choose
breastfeeding.
• So how do we deal with this
confounding variable? Hint:
experiment.
Ruling out confounding variables:
experiment with random assignment
An actual study in the text: women were randomly selected to
be in a group in which breastfeeding was promoted
+6 points
Comparing Research Methods
Research
Method
Basic Purpose How
Conducted
What is
Manipula
ted
Weaknesses
Summary of the types of Research
Descriptive To observe and
record behavior
Perform case
studies,
surveys, or
naturalistic
observations
Nothing No control of
variables; single
cases may be
misleading
Correlational To detect naturally
occurring
relationships; to
assess how well
one variable
predicts another
Compute
statistical
association,
sometimes
among survey
responses
Nothing Does not specify
cause-effect; one
variable predicts
another but this
does not mean
one causes the
other
Experimental To explore cause-
effect
Manipulate
one or more
factors;
randomly
assign some
to control
group
The
independent
variable(s)
Sometimes not
possible for
practical or ethical
reasons; results
may not
generalize to
other contexts
Drawing conclusions from data:
are the results useful?
After finding a pattern
in our data that shows a
difference between one
group and another, we
can ask more questions.
 Is the difference
reliable: can we use
this result to
generalize or to
predict the future
behavior of the
broader population?
 Is the difference
significant: could the
result have been
caused by random/
chance variation
between the groups?
How to achieve reliability:
 Nonbiased sampling: Make sure the
sample that you studied is a good
representation of the population you are
trying to learn about.
 Consistency: Check that the data
(responses, observations) is not too
widely varied to show a clear pattern.
 Many data points: Don’t try to generalize
from just a few cases, instances, or
responses.
When have you found statistically
significant difference (e.g. between
experimental and control groups)?
 When your data is reliable AND
 When the difference between the groups
is large (e.g. the data’s distribution curves
do not overlap too much).
Question: How can a result from an experiment,
possibly simplified and performed in a laboratory,
give us any insight into real life?
FAQ about Psychology
Laboratory vs.
Life
Diversity
Answer: By isolating variables and studying them
carefully, we can discover general principles that
might apply to all people.
Question: Do the insights from research really
apply to all people, or do the factors of culture
and gender override these “general” principles of
behavior?
Answer: Research can discover human universals
AND study how culture and gender influence
behavior. However, we must be careful not to
generalize too much from studies done with
subjects who do not represent the general
population.
Question: Why study animals? Is it possible to
protect the safety and dignity of animal research
subjects?
FAQ about Psychology
Ethics
Ethics
Answer: Sometimes, biologically related
creatures are less complex than humans and thus
easier to study. In some cases, harm to animals
generates important insights to help all creatures.
The value of animal research remains extremely
controversial.
Question: How do we protect the safety and
dignity of human subjects?
Answer: People in experiments may experience
discomfort; deceiving people sometimes yields
insights into human behavior. Human research
subjects are supposedly protected by guidelines
for non-harmful treatment, confidentiality,
informed consent, and debriefing (explaining the
purpose of the study).
Question: How do the values of psychologists
affect their work? Is it possible to perform value-
free research?
FAQ about Psychology
The impact of
Values
Answer: Researchers’ values affect their choices
of topics, their interpretations, their labels for
what they see, and the advice they generate from
their results. Value-free research remains an
impossible ideal.
An Application of Psychology:
Improving your test performance
Scientific studies show us that:
• The retrieval practice effect/testing effect
Testing yourself boosts retention of material.
• Put it in your own words, make connections
Actively processing material helps master it.
• Spread studying over multiple days
Spaced rehearsal, interspaced with other
subjects, is more efficient than cramming.
• If the concept looks familiar… not good enough
People tend to overestimate their mastery.
Applying this knowledge:
Use SQ3R to master a textbook
Survey
Scan/Skim what you are about to
read, especially chapter outlines
and section heads.
Question Ask questions that the text
might answer; write guesses.
Read
Look for the answer to your
questions, reading a
manageable amount at a time.
Rehearse
Recall what you’ve read in
your own words. Test
yourself with quizzes.
Review
Look over text and
notes and quickly
review the main ideas
of the whole chapter.

More Related Content

Similar to 01 Thinking Critically with Psychological Science.ppt

Chapter1 understanding modernpsychology
Chapter1 understanding modernpsychologyChapter1 understanding modernpsychology
Chapter1 understanding modernpsychologyayeshakhan1000
 
What is Psychology?
What is Psychology?What is Psychology?
What is Psychology?Don Thompson
 
history of psychology.ppt
history of psychology.ppthistory of psychology.ppt
history of psychology.pptAdriiEithan
 
Unit 1 history_and_approaches
Unit 1 history_and_approachesUnit 1 history_and_approaches
Unit 1 history_and_approachesJason Gayheart
 
Introduction to Psych - History
Introduction to Psych - HistoryIntroduction to Psych - History
Introduction to Psych - HistorySam Georgi
 
Introduction to educational psychology by dr.sudhir sahu
Introduction to educational psychology by dr.sudhir sahuIntroduction to educational psychology by dr.sudhir sahu
Introduction to educational psychology by dr.sudhir sahuSudhir INDIA
 
Introduction to Psychology: History
Introduction to Psychology: HistoryIntroduction to Psychology: History
Introduction to Psychology: HistoryBrian Piper
 
Psychology 101: Chapter1
Psychology 101: Chapter1Psychology 101: Chapter1
Psychology 101: Chapter1dborcoman
 
What Lies Beneath: Personality theories simplified
What Lies Beneath: Personality theories simplifiedWhat Lies Beneath: Personality theories simplified
What Lies Beneath: Personality theories simplifiedPreethi Anand
 
Psy150 chpt1revised
Psy150 chpt1revisedPsy150 chpt1revised
Psy150 chpt1revisedwallacecc
 
General Psychology.pptx
General Psychology.pptxGeneral Psychology.pptx
General Psychology.pptxissackmohamed3
 
Izaleo Presentation : Dark Color Version
Izaleo Presentation : Dark Color VersionIzaleo Presentation : Dark Color Version
Izaleo Presentation : Dark Color VersionMadlis
 
Izaleo Presentation : Light Color Version
Izaleo Presentation : Light Color VersionIzaleo Presentation : Light Color Version
Izaleo Presentation : Light Color VersionMadlis
 
Chapter 1. Introducing PsychologyPsychology is the scientific st
Chapter 1. Introducing PsychologyPsychology is the scientific stChapter 1. Introducing PsychologyPsychology is the scientific st
Chapter 1. Introducing PsychologyPsychology is the scientific stEstelaJeffery653
 
What is psychology 2011 version
What is psychology 2011 versionWhat is psychology 2011 version
What is psychology 2011 versionpworth01
 

Similar to 01 Thinking Critically with Psychological Science.ppt (19)

1 R
1 R1 R
1 R
 
Psychology As A Science Essay
Psychology As A Science EssayPsychology As A Science Essay
Psychology As A Science Essay
 
Chapter1 understanding modernpsychology
Chapter1 understanding modernpsychologyChapter1 understanding modernpsychology
Chapter1 understanding modernpsychology
 
What is Psychology?
What is Psychology?What is Psychology?
What is Psychology?
 
history of psychology.ppt
history of psychology.ppthistory of psychology.ppt
history of psychology.ppt
 
Unit 1 history_and_approaches
Unit 1 history_and_approachesUnit 1 history_and_approaches
Unit 1 history_and_approaches
 
History of psych unit 1
History of psych unit 1History of psych unit 1
History of psych unit 1
 
Introduction to Psych - History
Introduction to Psych - HistoryIntroduction to Psych - History
Introduction to Psych - History
 
Introduction to educational psychology by dr.sudhir sahu
Introduction to educational psychology by dr.sudhir sahuIntroduction to educational psychology by dr.sudhir sahu
Introduction to educational psychology by dr.sudhir sahu
 
Introduction to Psychology: History
Introduction to Psychology: HistoryIntroduction to Psychology: History
Introduction to Psychology: History
 
Psychology 101: Chapter1
Psychology 101: Chapter1Psychology 101: Chapter1
Psychology 101: Chapter1
 
What Lies Beneath: Personality theories simplified
What Lies Beneath: Personality theories simplifiedWhat Lies Beneath: Personality theories simplified
What Lies Beneath: Personality theories simplified
 
Psy150 chpt1revised
Psy150 chpt1revisedPsy150 chpt1revised
Psy150 chpt1revised
 
General Psychology.pptx
General Psychology.pptxGeneral Psychology.pptx
General Psychology.pptx
 
Izaleo Presentation : Dark Color Version
Izaleo Presentation : Dark Color VersionIzaleo Presentation : Dark Color Version
Izaleo Presentation : Dark Color Version
 
Izaleo Presentation : Light Color Version
Izaleo Presentation : Light Color VersionIzaleo Presentation : Light Color Version
Izaleo Presentation : Light Color Version
 
Psychology
PsychologyPsychology
Psychology
 
Chapter 1. Introducing PsychologyPsychology is the scientific st
Chapter 1. Introducing PsychologyPsychology is the scientific stChapter 1. Introducing PsychologyPsychology is the scientific st
Chapter 1. Introducing PsychologyPsychology is the scientific st
 
What is psychology 2011 version
What is psychology 2011 versionWhat is psychology 2011 version
What is psychology 2011 version
 

Recently uploaded

An Overview of the Odoo 17 Discuss App.pptx
An Overview of the Odoo 17 Discuss App.pptxAn Overview of the Odoo 17 Discuss App.pptx
An Overview of the Odoo 17 Discuss App.pptxCeline George
 
Gyanartha SciBizTech Quiz slideshare.pptx
Gyanartha SciBizTech Quiz slideshare.pptxGyanartha SciBizTech Quiz slideshare.pptx
Gyanartha SciBizTech Quiz slideshare.pptxShibin Azad
 
Telling Your Story_ Simple Steps to Build Your Nonprofit's Brand Webinar.pdf
Telling Your Story_ Simple Steps to Build Your Nonprofit's Brand Webinar.pdfTelling Your Story_ Simple Steps to Build Your Nonprofit's Brand Webinar.pdf
Telling Your Story_ Simple Steps to Build Your Nonprofit's Brand Webinar.pdfTechSoup
 
Salient features of Environment protection Act 1986.pptx
Salient features of Environment protection Act 1986.pptxSalient features of Environment protection Act 1986.pptx
Salient features of Environment protection Act 1986.pptxakshayaramakrishnan21
 
slides CapTechTalks Webinar May 2024 Alexander Perry.pptx
slides CapTechTalks Webinar May 2024 Alexander Perry.pptxslides CapTechTalks Webinar May 2024 Alexander Perry.pptx
slides CapTechTalks Webinar May 2024 Alexander Perry.pptxCapitolTechU
 
Matatag-Curriculum and the 21st Century Skills Presentation.pptx
Matatag-Curriculum and the 21st Century Skills Presentation.pptxMatatag-Curriculum and the 21st Century Skills Presentation.pptx
Matatag-Curriculum and the 21st Century Skills Presentation.pptxJenilouCasareno
 
Morse OER Some Benefits and Challenges.pptx
Morse OER Some Benefits and Challenges.pptxMorse OER Some Benefits and Challenges.pptx
Morse OER Some Benefits and Challenges.pptxjmorse8
 
Benefits and Challenges of Using Open Educational Resources
Benefits and Challenges of Using Open Educational ResourcesBenefits and Challenges of Using Open Educational Resources
Benefits and Challenges of Using Open Educational Resourcesdimpy50
 
The Benefits and Challenges of Open Educational Resources
The Benefits and Challenges of Open Educational ResourcesThe Benefits and Challenges of Open Educational Resources
The Benefits and Challenges of Open Educational Resourcesaileywriter
 
How to the fix Attribute Error in odoo 17
How to the fix Attribute Error in odoo 17How to the fix Attribute Error in odoo 17
How to the fix Attribute Error in odoo 17Celine George
 
Application of Matrices in real life. Presentation on application of matrices
Application of Matrices in real life. Presentation on application of matricesApplication of Matrices in real life. Presentation on application of matrices
Application of Matrices in real life. Presentation on application of matricesRased Khan
 
Basic Civil Engg Notes_Chapter-6_Environment Pollution & Engineering
Basic Civil Engg Notes_Chapter-6_Environment Pollution & EngineeringBasic Civil Engg Notes_Chapter-6_Environment Pollution & Engineering
Basic Civil Engg Notes_Chapter-6_Environment Pollution & EngineeringDenish Jangid
 
Basic phrases for greeting and assisting costumers
Basic phrases for greeting and assisting costumersBasic phrases for greeting and assisting costumers
Basic phrases for greeting and assisting costumersPedroFerreira53928
 
ppt your views.ppt your views of your college in your eyes
ppt your views.ppt your views of your college in your eyesppt your views.ppt your views of your college in your eyes
ppt your views.ppt your views of your college in your eyesashishpaul799
 
Sectors of the Indian Economy - Class 10 Study Notes pdf
Sectors of the Indian Economy - Class 10 Study Notes pdfSectors of the Indian Economy - Class 10 Study Notes pdf
Sectors of the Indian Economy - Class 10 Study Notes pdfVivekanand Anglo Vedic Academy
 
How to Manage Notification Preferences in the Odoo 17
How to Manage Notification Preferences in the Odoo 17How to Manage Notification Preferences in the Odoo 17
How to Manage Notification Preferences in the Odoo 17Celine George
 
GIÁO ÁN DẠY THÊM (KẾ HOẠCH BÀI BUỔI 2) - TIẾNG ANH 8 GLOBAL SUCCESS (2 CỘT) N...
GIÁO ÁN DẠY THÊM (KẾ HOẠCH BÀI BUỔI 2) - TIẾNG ANH 8 GLOBAL SUCCESS (2 CỘT) N...GIÁO ÁN DẠY THÊM (KẾ HOẠCH BÀI BUỔI 2) - TIẾNG ANH 8 GLOBAL SUCCESS (2 CỘT) N...
GIÁO ÁN DẠY THÊM (KẾ HOẠCH BÀI BUỔI 2) - TIẾNG ANH 8 GLOBAL SUCCESS (2 CỘT) N...Nguyen Thanh Tu Collection
 
The Art Pastor's Guide to Sabbath | Steve Thomason
The Art Pastor's Guide to Sabbath | Steve ThomasonThe Art Pastor's Guide to Sabbath | Steve Thomason
The Art Pastor's Guide to Sabbath | Steve ThomasonSteve Thomason
 
IATP How-to Foreign Travel May 2024.pdff
IATP How-to Foreign Travel May 2024.pdffIATP How-to Foreign Travel May 2024.pdff
IATP How-to Foreign Travel May 2024.pdff17thcssbs2
 

Recently uploaded (20)

An Overview of the Odoo 17 Discuss App.pptx
An Overview of the Odoo 17 Discuss App.pptxAn Overview of the Odoo 17 Discuss App.pptx
An Overview of the Odoo 17 Discuss App.pptx
 
Gyanartha SciBizTech Quiz slideshare.pptx
Gyanartha SciBizTech Quiz slideshare.pptxGyanartha SciBizTech Quiz slideshare.pptx
Gyanartha SciBizTech Quiz slideshare.pptx
 
B.ed spl. HI pdusu exam paper-2023-24.pdf
B.ed spl. HI pdusu exam paper-2023-24.pdfB.ed spl. HI pdusu exam paper-2023-24.pdf
B.ed spl. HI pdusu exam paper-2023-24.pdf
 
Telling Your Story_ Simple Steps to Build Your Nonprofit's Brand Webinar.pdf
Telling Your Story_ Simple Steps to Build Your Nonprofit's Brand Webinar.pdfTelling Your Story_ Simple Steps to Build Your Nonprofit's Brand Webinar.pdf
Telling Your Story_ Simple Steps to Build Your Nonprofit's Brand Webinar.pdf
 
Salient features of Environment protection Act 1986.pptx
Salient features of Environment protection Act 1986.pptxSalient features of Environment protection Act 1986.pptx
Salient features of Environment protection Act 1986.pptx
 
slides CapTechTalks Webinar May 2024 Alexander Perry.pptx
slides CapTechTalks Webinar May 2024 Alexander Perry.pptxslides CapTechTalks Webinar May 2024 Alexander Perry.pptx
slides CapTechTalks Webinar May 2024 Alexander Perry.pptx
 
Matatag-Curriculum and the 21st Century Skills Presentation.pptx
Matatag-Curriculum and the 21st Century Skills Presentation.pptxMatatag-Curriculum and the 21st Century Skills Presentation.pptx
Matatag-Curriculum and the 21st Century Skills Presentation.pptx
 
Morse OER Some Benefits and Challenges.pptx
Morse OER Some Benefits and Challenges.pptxMorse OER Some Benefits and Challenges.pptx
Morse OER Some Benefits and Challenges.pptx
 
Benefits and Challenges of Using Open Educational Resources
Benefits and Challenges of Using Open Educational ResourcesBenefits and Challenges of Using Open Educational Resources
Benefits and Challenges of Using Open Educational Resources
 
The Benefits and Challenges of Open Educational Resources
The Benefits and Challenges of Open Educational ResourcesThe Benefits and Challenges of Open Educational Resources
The Benefits and Challenges of Open Educational Resources
 
How to the fix Attribute Error in odoo 17
How to the fix Attribute Error in odoo 17How to the fix Attribute Error in odoo 17
How to the fix Attribute Error in odoo 17
 
Application of Matrices in real life. Presentation on application of matrices
Application of Matrices in real life. Presentation on application of matricesApplication of Matrices in real life. Presentation on application of matrices
Application of Matrices in real life. Presentation on application of matrices
 
Basic Civil Engg Notes_Chapter-6_Environment Pollution & Engineering
Basic Civil Engg Notes_Chapter-6_Environment Pollution & EngineeringBasic Civil Engg Notes_Chapter-6_Environment Pollution & Engineering
Basic Civil Engg Notes_Chapter-6_Environment Pollution & Engineering
 
Basic phrases for greeting and assisting costumers
Basic phrases for greeting and assisting costumersBasic phrases for greeting and assisting costumers
Basic phrases for greeting and assisting costumers
 
ppt your views.ppt your views of your college in your eyes
ppt your views.ppt your views of your college in your eyesppt your views.ppt your views of your college in your eyes
ppt your views.ppt your views of your college in your eyes
 
Sectors of the Indian Economy - Class 10 Study Notes pdf
Sectors of the Indian Economy - Class 10 Study Notes pdfSectors of the Indian Economy - Class 10 Study Notes pdf
Sectors of the Indian Economy - Class 10 Study Notes pdf
 
How to Manage Notification Preferences in the Odoo 17
How to Manage Notification Preferences in the Odoo 17How to Manage Notification Preferences in the Odoo 17
How to Manage Notification Preferences in the Odoo 17
 
GIÁO ÁN DẠY THÊM (KẾ HOẠCH BÀI BUỔI 2) - TIẾNG ANH 8 GLOBAL SUCCESS (2 CỘT) N...
GIÁO ÁN DẠY THÊM (KẾ HOẠCH BÀI BUỔI 2) - TIẾNG ANH 8 GLOBAL SUCCESS (2 CỘT) N...GIÁO ÁN DẠY THÊM (KẾ HOẠCH BÀI BUỔI 2) - TIẾNG ANH 8 GLOBAL SUCCESS (2 CỘT) N...
GIÁO ÁN DẠY THÊM (KẾ HOẠCH BÀI BUỔI 2) - TIẾNG ANH 8 GLOBAL SUCCESS (2 CỘT) N...
 
The Art Pastor's Guide to Sabbath | Steve Thomason
The Art Pastor's Guide to Sabbath | Steve ThomasonThe Art Pastor's Guide to Sabbath | Steve Thomason
The Art Pastor's Guide to Sabbath | Steve Thomason
 
IATP How-to Foreign Travel May 2024.pdff
IATP How-to Foreign Travel May 2024.pdffIATP How-to Foreign Travel May 2024.pdff
IATP How-to Foreign Travel May 2024.pdff
 

01 Thinking Critically with Psychological Science.ppt

  • 2. Topics and Questions  The history and growth of psychology  The big question: Nature vs. Nurture  Biopsychosocial levels of analysis  Psychology’s subfields  Avoiding three “common sense” thinking errors How do I explain dreams? Anxiety? The abilities and funny behavior of babies?  The Scientific Attitude: Curiosity, Skepticism, Humility  The Scientific Method  Description, Correlation, and Experimentation  Frequently Asked Questions about Psychology  Applying psychology to learning the text: SQ3R
  • 3. From speculation to science: The Birth of Modern Psychology Aristotle (4th century BCE) had ideas about how the body and mind work. His method: making guesses. Wilhelm Wundt (1832-1920) added two key elements to help make psychology a science: 1. carefully measured observations 2. experiments
  • 4. Push a button when a ball dropped (based on when they heard the ball hit a platform): 1/10th of a second. Push a button when consciously aware of hearing the ball hit the platform: 2/10ths of a second. Wilhelm Wundt’s 1879 experiment measured the time it took for people to: Why were the times different?
  • 5. Structuralism  Edward Titchener, like his teacher Wundt, used data from introspection, reporting on sensations and other elements of experience.  Structuralism: Using these introspective reports to build a view of the mind’s structure
  • 6. Functionalism: The school of thought that Psychological processes have a function: helping us survive as individuals, adapt as a species  The developer of functionalism, William James (1842-1910), asked: How did the human style of thinking and behavior enable our ancestors to live long enough to reproduce?  James mentored another pioneer William James
  • 7.  Mary Whiton Calkins (1863-1930) became a memory researcher and the first female president of the APA.  She studied with William James but was denied a Harvard PhD. Why? Because of her gender. Psychology Pioneers Mary Whiton Calkins
  • 8. Psychology Pioneers Margaret Floy Washburn, PhD Margaret Floy Washburn (1871-1939):  The first female to earn a Psychology PhD  The second female APA president  Author of The Animal Mind.
  • 9. Shifting definitions of “psychology” Wilhelm Wundt and Edward Titchener, around 1900: “The science of mental life.” John B. Watson and B.F. Skinner, behaviorists, 1920’s: “The scientific study of observable behavior.” Cognitive psychologists, 1960’s, studied internal mental processes, helped by neuroscience. Now we combine these definitions: “The science of behavior and mental processes.”
  • 10. Behaviorists study and experiment with observable behavior. Watson experimented with conditioned responses. Skinner studied the way consequences shape behavior. Like other behaviorists, he saw little value in introspection. Trends in Psychological Science: Behaviorism John B. Watson B. F. Skinner
  • 11. Sigmund Freud, founder of psychoanalysis:  He studied and helped people with a variety of mental disorders.  More about Freud when we study personality and therapy Sigmund Freud Trends in Psychology: Freudian/Psychoanalytic Psychology
  • 12. Humanists: Abraham Maslow and Carl Rogers (1960s):  studied people who were thriving rather than those who had psychological problems.  developed theories and treatments to help people to feel accepted and to reach their full potential. Carl Rogers Abraham Maslow Trends in Psychology: Humanism
  • 13. The Growth of Psychology  Psychology’s pioneers have come from many fields: physiology, philosophy, medicine, and biology.  Advances in psychology also have been made in many countries  Psychology has spread rapidly; there are 71 member nations in the IUPS. The subjects studied in psychology have multiplied too… as we shall see in this course.
  • 14. The Big Issue in Psychology: N-N To what extent are our traits already set in place at birth (our “Nature”)? And to what extent do our traits develop in response to our environment/ experience (our “Nurture”)? The Nature- Nurture Question:
  • 15. vs. Nature Nurture Plato: Ideas such as “the good” and “beauty” are inborn. Descartes: Some ideas are innate. Charles Darwin: Some traits become part of our nature through natural selection: they help us survive long enough to pass the traits to the next generation. Aristotle: All knowledge comes through the senses. John Locke: The mind is a blank slate (blank chalkboard or screen) “written on” by experience.
  • 16. Nature Nurture We have differences that are shaped by our environment. We share a common origin that gives us an inborn human nature in common. +
  • 17. “Nurture works on what Nature endows.” The Roles of Nature and Nurture:
  • 18. Biology Plus Environment.. are part of psychology’s three “biopsychosocial” levels of analysis. The deep level, Biology: genes, brain, neuro- transmitters, survival, reflexes, sensation The outer level, Environment: social Influences, culture, education, relationships In the middle, Psychology: thoughts, emotions, moods, choices, behaviors, traits, motivations, knowledge, perceptions
  • 19. The three levels as influences on some psychological phenomenon Example: Depression Example: Intelligence Example: Enjoying Soccer Example: Shyness
  • 20. Cognitive perspective Social-cultural Behavioral genetics Neuroscience Psychodynamic Behaviorist Evolutionary There are many perspectives for describing psychological phenomena: From different angles, you ask different questions: How reliable is memory? How can we improve our thinking? Could our behavior, skills, and attitudes be “downloads” from our culture? Could our behavior, skills, and attitudes be genetically programmed instincts? What role do our bodies and brains play in emotions? How is pain inhibited? Can we trust our senses? Do inner childhood conflicts still plague me and affect my behavior? How are our problematic behaviors reinforced? How do our fears become conditioned? What can we do to change these fears and behaviors? Why are humans prone to panic, anger, and making irrational judgments?
  • 21. Different perspectives on a single issue: Six Blind Men and an Elephant
  • 22. Let’s play: “What’s my perspective?” “Obsessive- compulsive disorder is a problem in the orbital cortex.” “No, it’s a sign of unresolved childhood issues.” “No, OCD is an inherited condition.” “Compulsions start as habits and are rewarded by the anxiety relief they bring.” “OCD comes from our natural instinct to control our environment.” “OCD thinking and behavior is a reaction to our fast-paced, out- of-control lifestyles.” “No, OCD is a matter of mental habits and errors that can be corrected.”
  • 23. Psychology’s Subfields Applied Clinical Psychology Counseling Psychology Educational Psychology Industrial-Organizational Community Psychology Clinical Psychology Basic research Biological Developmental Cognitive Personality Social Positive Psychology
  • 24. Psychology’s Subfields Research Examples Type of research Biological Developmental Cognitive Personality Social Positive Psychology Study how the stages of cognitive and emotional development vary in autism Explore the structural problems in the brain that may be part of autism Clarify the difficulties autistic children have with understanding sarcasm Decide whether traits like neuroticism need to be measured differently in autism Find how autistic children can learn social skills as procedures if not by intuition Explore what motivates people and contributes to life satisfaction
  • 25. Applied Clinical Psychology Counseling Psychology Educational Psychology Industrial-Organizational Community Psychology Clinical Psychology Psychology’s Subfields Applied Help someone achieve career goals despite family conflict and self-doubt Use exposure therapy to decrease phobic reactions in a traumatized client Evaluate aptitudes and achievement to plan for a student with learning problems Figure out how a factory can improve coordination of tasks, roles, and personalities Help coordinate a city’s efforts to understand and prevent elder abuse Use exposure therapy to decrease phobic reactions in a traumatized client
  • 26. Psychology in context with other professions Psychiatrists are physicians, M.D.s or D.O.s. They can prescribe medication. In addition to psychologists, professionals in social work, counseling, and marriage and family therapy may be trained to do psychotherapy.
  • 27. The Need for Psychological Science: Overview  Typical errors in hindsight, overconfidence, and coincidence  The scientific attitude and critical thinking  The scientific method: theories and hypotheses  Gathering psychological data: description, correlation, and experimentation/causation  Describing data: significant differences  Issues in psychology: laboratory vs. life, culture and gender, values and ethics
  • 28. When our natural thinking style fails: Hindsight bias: “I knew it all along.” Overconfidence error: “I am sure I am correct.” The coincidence error, or mistakenly perceiving order in random events: “The dice must be fixed because you rolled three sixes in a row.”
  • 29. Hindsight bias is like a crystal ball that we use to predict… the past. I knew this would happen… You were accepted into this college/university Classic example: after watching a competition (sports, cooking), if you don’t make a prediction ahead of time, you might make a “postdiction”: “I figured that team/person would win because…” When you see most results of psychological research, you might say, “that was obvious…” Hindsight Bias
  • 30. These sayings all seem to make sense, in hindsight, after we read them. Out of sight, out of mind S/He who hesitates is lost No [wo]man is an island Actions speak louder than words You’re never too old to learn Curiosity killed the cat Opposites attract There’s no place like home Absence makes the heart grow fonder Look before you leap Good fences make good neighbors The pen is mightier than the sword You can’t teach an old dog new tricks The grass is always greener on the other side of the fence Seek and ye shall find Birds of a feather flock together But then why do these other phrases also seem to make sense?
  • 31. Hindsight “Bias” The mind builds its current wisdom around what we have already been told. We are “biased” in favor of old information. For example, we may stay in a bad relationship because it has lasted this far and thus was “meant to be.” Why call it “bias”?
  • 32. Overconfidence Error: Predicting performance  We overestimate our performance, our rate of work, our skills, and our degree of self-control. Overconfidence Error: Judging our accuracy  When stating that we “know” something, our level of confidence is usually much higher than our level of accuracy.  Overconfidence is a problem in preparing for tests. Familiarity is not understanding  If you feel confident that you know a concept, try explaining it to someone else. Test for this: “how long do you think it takes you to…” (e.g. “just finish this one thing I’m doing on the computer before I get to work”)? How fast can you unscramble words? Guess, then try these: ERSEGA HEGOUN
  • 33. Result of this error: reacting to coincidence as if it has meaning Perceiving order in random events: Example: The coin tosses that “look wrong” if there are five heads in a row. Danger: thinking you can make a prediction from a random series. If there have been five heads in a row, you can not predict that “it’s time for tails” on the next flip Why this error happens: because we have the wrong idea about what randomness looks like. If one poker player at a table got pocket aces twice in a row, is the game rigged?
  • 34. Making our ideas more accurate by being scientific What did “Amazing Randi” do about the claim of seeing auras? He developed a testable prediction, which would support the theory if it succeeded. Which it did not. The aura-readers were unable to locate the aura around Randi’s body without seeing Randi’s body itself, so their claim was not supported.
  • 35. Scientific Attitude Part 1: Curiosity Hypothesis: Curiosity, if not guided by caution, can lead to the death of felines and perhaps humans. Definition: always asking new questions “That behavior I’m noticing in that guy… is that common to all people? Or is it more common when under stress? Or only common for males?”
  • 36. Scientific Attitude Part 2: Skepticism Definition: not accepting a ‘fact’ as true without challenging it; seeing if ‘facts’ can withstand attempts to disprove them Skepticism, like curiosity, generates questions: “Is there another explanation for the behavior I am seeing? Is there a problem with how I measured it, or how I set up my experiment? Do I need to change my theory to fit the evidence?”
  • 37. Scientific Attitude Part 3: Humility Humility refers to seeking the truth rather than trying to be right; a scientist needs to be able to accept being wrong. “What matters is not my opinion or yours, but the truth nature reveals in response to our questioning.” David Myers
  • 38. Critical thinking refers to a more careful style of forming and evaluating knowledge than simply using intuition. Along with the scientific method, critical thinking will help us develop more effective and accurate ways to figure out what makes people do, think, and feel the things they do. “Think critically” with psychological science… does this mean “criticize”? Why do I need to work on my thinking? Can’t you just tell me facts about psychology? • The brain is designed for surviving and reproducing, but it is not the best tool for seeing ‘reality’ clearly.
  • 39. Critical thinking: analyzing information, arguments, and conclusions, to decide if they make sense, rather than simply accepting it. Look for hidden assumptions and decide if you agree. Look for hidden bias, politics, values, or personal connections. Put aside your own assumptions and biases, and look at the evidence. See if there was a flaw in how the information was collected. Consider if there are other possible explanations for the facts or results.
  • 40. How Psychologists Ask and Answer Questions: The Scientific Method The scientific method is the process of testing our ideas about the world by: Turning our theories into testable predictions. Gather information related to our predictions. analyzing whether the data fits with our ideas. If the data doesn’t fit our ideas, then we modify our hypotheses, set up a study or experiment, and try again to see if the world fits our predictions.
  • 41. Scientific Method: Tools and Goals Some research findings revealed by the scientific method:  The brain can recover from massive early childhood brain damage.  Sleepwalkers are not acting out dreams.  Our brains do not have accurate memories locked inside like video files.  There is no “hidden and unused 90 percent” of our brain.  People often change their opinions to fit their actions. The basics:  Theory  Hypothesis  Operational Definitions  Replication Research goals/types:  Description  Correlation  Prediction  Causation  Experiments
  • 42. Theory: the big picture Example of a theory: “All ADHD symptoms are a reaction to eating sugar.” A theory, in the language of science, is a set of principles, built on observations and other verifiable facts, that explains some phenomenon and predicts its future behavior.
  • 43. Hypotheses: informed predictions “Testable” means that the hypothesis is stated in a way that we could make observations to find out if it is true. A hypothesis is a testable prediction consistent with our theory. What would be a prediction from the “All ADHD is about sugar” theory? One hypothesis: “If a kid gets sugar, the kid will act more distracted, impulsive, and hyper.” To test the “All” part of the theory: “ADHD symptoms will continue for some kids even after sugar is removed from the diet.”
  • 44. Danger when testing hypotheses: theories can bias our observations We might select only the data, or the interpretations of the data, that support what we already believe. There are safeguards against this:  Hypotheses designed to disconfirm  Operational definitions Guide for making useful observations:  How can we measure “ADHD symptoms” in the previous example in observable terms?  Impulsivity = # of times/hour calling out without raising hand.  Hyperactivity = # of times/hour out of seat  Inattention = # minutes continuously on task before becoming distracted
  • 45. The next/final step in the scientific method: Replication You could introduce a small change in the study, e.g. trying the ADHD/sugar test on college students instead of elementary students. Replicating research means trying the methods of a study again, but with different participants or situations, to see if the same results happen.
  • 47. Scientific Method: Tools and Goals The basics:  Theory  Hypothesis  Operational Definitions  Replication Research goals/types:  Description  Correlation  Prediction  Causation  Experiments Now that we’ve covered this We can move on to this
  • 48. Research goal and strategy: Description Strategies for gathering this information:  Case Study: observing and gathering information to compile an in-depth study of one individual  Naturalistic Observation: gathering data about behavior; watching but not intervening  Surveys and Interviews: having other people report on their own attitudes and behavior Descriptive research is a systematic, objective observation of people. The goal is to provide a clear, accurate picture of people’s behaviors, thoughts, and attributes.
  • 49. Case Study Examining one individual in depth  Benefit: can be a source of ideas about human nature in general  Example: cases of brain damage have suggested the function of different parts of the brain (e.g. Phineas Gage seen here)  Danger: overgeneralization from one example; “Joe got better after tapping his foot, so tapping must be the key to health!”
  • 50.  Observing “natural” behavior means just watching (and taking notes), and not trying to change anything.  This method can be used to study more than one individual, and to find truths that apply to a broader population. Naturalistic Observation
  • 51. The Survey  Definition: A method of gathering information about many people’s thoughts or behaviors through self-report rather than observation.  Keys to getting useful information:  Be careful about the wording of questions  Only question randomly sampled people Wording effects the results you get from a survey can be changed by your word selection. Example: Q: Do you have motivation to study hard for this course? Q: Do you feel a desire to study hard for this course?
  • 52. What psychology science mistake was made here? Hint #1: Harry Truman won. Hint #2: The Chicago Tribune interviewed people about whom they would vote for. Hint #3: in 1948. Hint #4: by phone.
  • 53. Random Sampling • If you want to find out something about men, you can’t interview every single man on earth. • Sampling saves time. You can find the ratio of colors in this jar by making sure they are well mixed (randomized) and then taking a sample. population sample Random sampling is a technique for making sure that every individual in a population has an equal chance of being in your sample. “Random” means that your selection of participants is driven only by chance, not by any characteristic.
  • 54. Correlation General Definition: an observation that two traits or attributes are related to each other (thus, they are “co”- related) Scientific definition: a measure of how closely two factors vary together, or how well you can predict a change in one from observing a change in the other In a case study: The fewer hours the boy was allowed to sleep, the more episodes of aggression he displayed. A possible result of many descriptive studies: discovering a correlation In a naturalistic observation: Children in a classroom who were dressed in heavier clothes were more likely to fall asleep than those wearing lighter clothes. In a survey: The greater the number of Facebook friends, the less time was spent studying.
  • 55. Correlation Coefficient • The correlation coefficient is a number representing how closely and in what way two variables correlate (change together). • The direction of the correlation can be positive (direct relationship; both variables increase together) or negative (inverse relationship: as one increases, the other decreases). • The strength of the relationship, how tightly, predictably they vary together, is measured in a number that varies from 0.00 to +/- 1.00. Close to +1.0 (strong negative correlation) (no relationship, no correlation) Guess the Correlation Coefficients (strong positive correlation) Height vs. shoe size Years in school vs. years in jail Height vs. intelligence Close to 0.0 Close to -1.0
  • 56. If we find a correlation, what conclusions can we draw from it? Let’s say we find the following result: there is a positive correlation between two variables,  ice cream sales, and  rates of violent crime How do we explain this?
  • 57. Correlation is not Causation! “People who floss more regularly have less risk of heart disease.” “People with bigger feet tend to be taller.” If this data is from a survey, can we conclude that flossing might prevent heart disease? Or that people with heart- healthy habits also floss regularly? Does that mean having bigger feet causes height?
  • 58. If self-esteem correlates with depression, there are still numerous possible causal links:
  • 59. So how do we find out about causation? By experimentation  Testing the theory that ADHD = sugar: removing sugar from the diet of children with ADHD to see if it makes a difference  The depression/self- esteem example: trying interventions that improve self- esteem to see if they cause a reduction in depression Experimentation: manipulating one factor in a situation to determine its effect
  • 60. The Control Group • If we manipulate a variable in an experimental group of people, and then we see an effect, how do we know the change wouldn’t have happened anyway? • We solve this problem by comparing this group to a control group, a group that is the same in every way except the one variable we are changing. Example: two groups of children have ADHD, but only one group stops eating refined sugar. By using random assignment: randomly selecting some study participants to be assigned to the control group or the experimental group. How do make sure the control group is really identical in every way to the experimental group?
  • 61. To clarify two similar-sounding terms… First you sample, then you sort (assign) Random assignment of participants to control or experimental groups is how you control all variables except the one you’re manipulating. Random sampling is how you get a pool of research participants that represents the population you’re trying to learn about.
  • 62. Placebo effect Placebo effect: experimental effects that are caused by expectations about the intervention  How do we make sure that the experimental group doesn’t experience an effect because they expect to experience it?  How can we make sure both groups expect to get better, but only one gets the real intervention being studied? Working with the placebo effect: Control groups may be given a placebo – an inactive substance or other fake treatment in place of the experimental treatment.  The control group is ideally “blind” to whether they are getting real or fake treatment.  Many studies are double-blind – neither participants nor research staff knows which participants are in the experimental or control groups.
  • 63. The variable we are able to manipulate independently of what the other variables are doing is called the independent variable (IV). • If we test the ADHD/sugar hypothesis: • Sugar = Cause = Independent Variable • ADHD = Effect = Dependent Variable The variable we expect to experience a change which depends on the manipulation we’re doing is called the dependent variable (DV). • Did more hyper kids get to choose to be in the sugar group? Then their preference for sugar would be a confounding variable. (preventing this problem: random assignment). The other variables that might have an effect on the dependent variable are confounding variables. Naming the variables
  • 64. An experiment is a type of research in which the researcher carefully manipulates a limited number of factors (IVs) and measures the impact on other factors (DVs). *in psychology, you would be looking at the effect of the experimental change (IV) on a behavior or mental process (DV). Filling in our definition of experimentation
  • 65. Correlation vs. causation: the breastfeeding/intelligence question • Studies have found that children who were breastfed score higher on intelligence tests, on average, than those who were bottle-fed. • Can we conclude that breast feeding CAUSES higher intelligence? • Not necessarily. There is at least one confounding variable: genes. The intelligence test scores of the mothers might be higher in those who choose breastfeeding. • So how do we deal with this confounding variable? Hint: experiment.
  • 66. Ruling out confounding variables: experiment with random assignment An actual study in the text: women were randomly selected to be in a group in which breastfeeding was promoted +6 points
  • 67. Comparing Research Methods Research Method Basic Purpose How Conducted What is Manipula ted Weaknesses Summary of the types of Research Descriptive To observe and record behavior Perform case studies, surveys, or naturalistic observations Nothing No control of variables; single cases may be misleading Correlational To detect naturally occurring relationships; to assess how well one variable predicts another Compute statistical association, sometimes among survey responses Nothing Does not specify cause-effect; one variable predicts another but this does not mean one causes the other Experimental To explore cause- effect Manipulate one or more factors; randomly assign some to control group The independent variable(s) Sometimes not possible for practical or ethical reasons; results may not generalize to other contexts
  • 68. Drawing conclusions from data: are the results useful? After finding a pattern in our data that shows a difference between one group and another, we can ask more questions.  Is the difference reliable: can we use this result to generalize or to predict the future behavior of the broader population?  Is the difference significant: could the result have been caused by random/ chance variation between the groups? How to achieve reliability:  Nonbiased sampling: Make sure the sample that you studied is a good representation of the population you are trying to learn about.  Consistency: Check that the data (responses, observations) is not too widely varied to show a clear pattern.  Many data points: Don’t try to generalize from just a few cases, instances, or responses. When have you found statistically significant difference (e.g. between experimental and control groups)?  When your data is reliable AND  When the difference between the groups is large (e.g. the data’s distribution curves do not overlap too much).
  • 69. Question: How can a result from an experiment, possibly simplified and performed in a laboratory, give us any insight into real life? FAQ about Psychology Laboratory vs. Life Diversity Answer: By isolating variables and studying them carefully, we can discover general principles that might apply to all people. Question: Do the insights from research really apply to all people, or do the factors of culture and gender override these “general” principles of behavior? Answer: Research can discover human universals AND study how culture and gender influence behavior. However, we must be careful not to generalize too much from studies done with subjects who do not represent the general population.
  • 70. Question: Why study animals? Is it possible to protect the safety and dignity of animal research subjects? FAQ about Psychology Ethics Ethics Answer: Sometimes, biologically related creatures are less complex than humans and thus easier to study. In some cases, harm to animals generates important insights to help all creatures. The value of animal research remains extremely controversial. Question: How do we protect the safety and dignity of human subjects? Answer: People in experiments may experience discomfort; deceiving people sometimes yields insights into human behavior. Human research subjects are supposedly protected by guidelines for non-harmful treatment, confidentiality, informed consent, and debriefing (explaining the purpose of the study).
  • 71. Question: How do the values of psychologists affect their work? Is it possible to perform value- free research? FAQ about Psychology The impact of Values Answer: Researchers’ values affect their choices of topics, their interpretations, their labels for what they see, and the advice they generate from their results. Value-free research remains an impossible ideal.
  • 72. An Application of Psychology: Improving your test performance Scientific studies show us that: • The retrieval practice effect/testing effect Testing yourself boosts retention of material. • Put it in your own words, make connections Actively processing material helps master it. • Spread studying over multiple days Spaced rehearsal, interspaced with other subjects, is more efficient than cramming. • If the concept looks familiar… not good enough People tend to overestimate their mastery.
  • 73. Applying this knowledge: Use SQ3R to master a textbook Survey Scan/Skim what you are about to read, especially chapter outlines and section heads. Question Ask questions that the text might answer; write guesses. Read Look for the answer to your questions, reading a manageable amount at a time. Rehearse Recall what you’ve read in your own words. Test yourself with quizzes. Review Look over text and notes and quickly review the main ideas of the whole chapter.