Mike Slater
Threshold Limit Values ® (TLVs)
for heat stress are included in
the American Conference of
Governmental Industrial
Hygienists (ACGIH) TLV booklet
TLVs® are guidelines designed
for use by occupational
hygienists in making decisions
regarding safe levels of
exposure to various chemical
substances and physical agents
found in the workplace.
This flowchart summarises how
to apply the TLV’s. However. It’s
quite complex. We’ll go through
          it step by step
General approach


             Detailed   Heat Strain
 Screening
             Analysis   Monitoring
General approach


             Detailed   Heat Strain
 Screening
             Analysis   Monitoring
Heat Stress   NO
                   STOP
expected?




        YES



SCREENING
Screening
  NO        Clothing
       adjustment factors
           available?

                   YES
TLV Clothing Corrections
Clothing Type                          WBGT Correction

Work clothes (long sleeve and pants)          0
Cloth (woven material) coveralls              0

Double layer woven clothing                   3
SMS polypropylene coveralls                  0.5
Polyolefin overalls                           1
Limited use vapour-barrier overalls          11
Screening
  NO         Clothing
        adjustment factors
            available?

                    YES



 If no clothing adjustment factors are
 available, go straight to heat strain
 (physiological) monitoring
Screening
  NO        Clothing
       adjustment factors
           available?

                   YES



 This may be necessary, for
 example, where chemical
 protective suits are being worn
TLV Clothing Corrections
Clothing Type                          WBGT Correction

Work clothes (long sleeve and pants)          0
Cloth (woven material) coveralls              0

Double layer woven clothing                   3
SMS polypropylene coveralls                  0.5
Polyolefin overalls                           1
Limited use vapour-barrier overalls          11
Screening
  NO        Clothing
       adjustment factors
           available?

                    YES

         Are screening       NO
       criteria for Action
        Limit exceeded?

                   YES
Work out the WBGT from the
results of environmental
measurements and apply the
clothing corrections
WBGT Index
  No direct exposure to sunlight

  WBGT = 0.7 tnwb + 0.3 tg

  With direct exposure to sunlight

  WBGT = 0.7 tnwb + 0.2 tg + 0.1 ta
Compare the corrected WBGT
with the Action Limit Values
ACGIH TLVs – Action Limit

Allocation of               Workload
work in work Light   Moderate   Heavy   V ery
cycle                                   heavy
75% to 100% 28.0     25.0       -       -
50% to 75%   28.5    26.0       24.0    -
25% to 50%   29.5    27.0       25.5    24.5
0 to 25%     30.0    29.0       28.0    27.0
To use this table you have to know
• the time spent working and resting
• the metabolic rate
Metabolic rate categories
Category     Metabolic   Examples
             Rate (W)
                         Sitting
Rest             115
                         Sitting or standing
Light            180     Light hand / arm work
                         Walking
Moderate         300     Moderate lifting
                         Heavy materials handling
Heavy            415
                         Pick and shovel work
Very Heavy       520
ACGIH TLVs – Action Limit

Allocation of               Workload
work in work Light   Moderate   Heavy   V ery
cycle                                   heavy
75% to 100% 28.0     25.0       -       -
50% to 75%   28.5    26.0       24.0    -
25% to 50%   29.5    27.0       25.5    24.5
0 to 25%     30.0    29.0       28.0    27.0
So, for a job involving moderate
work where 75% of the time is spent
working and 25% resting
ACGIH TLVs – Action Limit

Allocation of               Workload
work in work Light   Moderate   Heavy   V ery
cycle                                   heavy
75% to 100% 28.0     25.0       -       -
50% to 75%   28.5    26.0       24.0    -
25% to 50%   29.5    27.0       25.5    24.5
0 to 25%     30.0    29.0       28.0    27.0
ACGIH TLVs – Action Limit

Allocation of               Workload
work in work Light   Moderate   Heavy   V ery
cycle                                   heavy
75% to 100% 28.0     25.0       -       -
50% to 75%   28.5    26.0       24.0    -
25% to 50%   29.5    27.0       25.5    24.5
0 to 25%     30.0    29.0       28.0    27.0
ACGIH TLVs – Action Limit

Allocation of               Workload
work in work Light   Moderate   Heavy   V ery
cycle                                   heavy
75% to 100% 28.0     25.0       -       -
50% to 75%   28.5    26.0       24.0    -
25% to 50%   29.5    27.0       25.5    24.5
0 to 25%     30.0    29.0       28.0    27.0
ACGIH TLVs – Action Limit

Allocation of               Workload
work in work Light   Moderate   Heavy   V ery
cycle                                   heavy
75% to 100% 28.0     25.0       -       -
50% to 75%   28.5    26.0       24.0    -
25% to 50%   29.5    27.0       25.5    24.5
0 to 25%     30.0    29.0       28.0    27.0
ACGIH TLVs – Action Limit

Allocation of                          Workload
work in work Light            Moderate       Heavy          V ery
cycle                                                       heavy
75% to 100% 28.0              25.0           -              -
50% to 75%       28.5         26.0           24.0           -
25% to 50%       29.5         27.0           25.5           24.5
0 to 25%         30.0         29.0           28.0           27.0

If the adjusted WBGT is below this value the Action Limit is not exceeded
Screening
  NO        Clothing
       adjustment factors
           available?

                    YES

         Are screening       NO
       criteria for Action        Low Risk
        Limit exceeded?

                   YES
Screening
  NO        Clothing
       adjustment factors
           available?

                    YES

         Are screening       NO
                                             Continue work
       criteria for Action        Low Risk
                                               Monitor
        Limit exceeded?

                   YES
Screening
  NO        Clothing
       adjustment factors
           available?

                    YES

         Are screening       NO
                                                   Continue work
       criteria for Action        Low Risk
                                                     Monitor
        Limit exceeded?

                   YES

                             NO
                                    If the Action Limit is
         Are screening
                                    exceeded then the WBGT
        criteria for TLV
           exceeded?                value is compared with the
                                    TLV criteria
                   YES
ACGIH TLVs – Screening TLV

Allocation of               Workload
work in work Light   Moderate   Heavy   V ery
cycle                                   heavy
75% to 100% 31.0     28.0       -       -
50% to 75%   31.0    29.0       27.5    -
25% to 50%   32.0    30.0       29.0    28.0
0 to 25%     32.5    31.5       30.5    30.0
Screening
  NO        Clothing
       adjustment factors
           available?

                    YES

         Are screening       NO
                                              Continue work
       criteria for Action        Low Risk
                                                Monitor
        Limit exceeded?

                   YES

         Are screening       NO   Implement
        criteria for TLV            general
           exceeded?               controls

                   YES
General    Information, instruction & training



controls        Regular drinks of water


                     Self regulation

           Health screening and surveillance
            Encourage reporting symptoms

               Encourage healthy lifestyles


                       Monitoring
Screening
  NO        Clothing
       adjustment factors
           available?

                    YES

         Are screening       NO
                                                Continue work
       criteria for Action        Low Risk
                                                  Monitor
        Limit exceeded?

                   YES

         Are screening       NO   Implement    Continue work
        criteria for TLV            general   Maintain controls
           exceeded?               controls       Monitor

                   YES
Screening
  NO        Clothing
       adjustment factors
           available?

                    YES

         Are screening       NO
                                                Continue work
       criteria for Action        Low Risk
                                                  Monitor
        Limit exceeded?

                   YES

         Are screening       NO   Implement    Continue work
        criteria for TLV            general   Maintain controls
           exceeded?               controls       Monitor

                   YES
Detailed analysis
  NO   Are data available
          for detailed
           analysis?

                   YES
                            If the TLV is exceeded,
                            consider carrying out a
                            more detailed analysis
                            using a more sophisticated
                            method, such as the
                            Predicted Heat Strain
                            (PHS) index
Detailed analysis
  NO   Are data available
          for detailed
           analysis?

                   YES

                            NO
         Action Limit
          exceeded?


                   YES
The Action Limit referred to
here is that associated with the
index being used NOT the
ACGIH Action Limit
Detailed analysis
  NO   Are data available
          for detailed
           analysis?

                   YES

                            NO
         Action Limit
          exceeded?


                   YES
Detailed analysis
  NO   Are data available
          for detailed
           analysis?

                   YES

                            NO
         Action Limit
                                 Low Risk
          exceeded?


                   YES
Detailed analysis
  NO   Are data available
          for detailed
           analysis?

                   YES

                            NO
         Action Limit                       Continue work
                                 Low Risk
          exceeded?                           Monitor


                   YES
Detailed analysis
  NO   Are data available
          for detailed
           analysis?

                   YES

                            NO
         Action Limit                       Continue work
                                 Low Risk
          exceeded?                           Monitor


                   YES

                            NO
        TLV exceeded?


                   YES
The TLV referred to here is the
limit value associated with the
index being used NOT the
ACGIH Screening TLVs
Detailed analysis
  NO   Are data available
          for detailed
           analysis?

                   YES

                            NO
         Action Limit                       Continue work
                                 Low Risk
          exceeded?                           Monitor


                   YES

                            NO
        TLV exceeded?


                   YES
Detailed analysis
  NO   Are data available
          for detailed
           analysis?

                   YES

                            NO
         Action Limit                        Continue work
                                 Low Risk
          exceeded?                            Monitor


                   YES

                            NO   Implement
        TLV exceeded?              general
                                  controls

                   YES
Detailed analysis
  NO   Are data available
          for detailed
           analysis?

                   YES

                            NO
         Action Limit                          Continue work
                                 Low Risk
          exceeded?                              Monitor


                   YES

                            NO   Implement    Continue work
        TLV exceeded?              general   Maintain controls
                                  controls       Monitor

                   YES
Heat strain monitoring
                     NO     Implement    Continue work
     TLV exceeded?            general   Maintain controls
                             controls       Monitor

            YES




                          What if the TLV is exceeded?
Heat strain monitoring
                          NO   Implement    Continue work
      TLV exceeded?              general   Maintain controls
                                controls       Monitor

               YES

    Perform heat strain
      (physiological)
        monitoring
Physiological assessment




 Core Temperature   Heart rate
Personal Monitor
Miner’s Core Temperature & Heart Rate




 Source: OHTA.
Heat strain monitoring
                          NO   Implement    Continue work
      TLV exceeded?              general   Maintain controls
                                controls       Monitor

               YES

    Perform heat strain
      (physiological)
        monitoring



       Excessive heat     NO
      strain based on
        monitoring?
               YES
Guidelines for limiting Heat Strain
Factor                          Work should be discontinued if:

Heart rate (beats per minute)   Greater than 180 minus age in years

Core temperature                Greater than 38.5 0C (acclimatised)
                                Greater than 38.0 0C (unacclimatised)

Recovery heart rate             120
(beats per minute)              (at one minute after peak work)

Other                           Symptoms of sudden and severe
                                fatigue, nausea, dizziness or
                                lightheadedness
Heat strain monitoring
                          NO   Implement    Continue work
      TLV exceeded?              general   Maintain controls
                                controls       Monitor

               YES

    Perform heat strain
      (physiological)
        monitoring



       Excessive heat     NO
      strain based on
        monitoring?
               YES
Heat strain monitoring
                          NO   Implement    Continue work
      TLV exceeded?              general   Maintain controls
                                controls       Monitor

               YES

    Perform heat strain
      (physiological)
        monitoring



       Excessive heat     NO
      strain based on
        monitoring?
                YES

     Implement Job-
     specific controls
Job-specific controls

         Engineering controls


        Administrative controls

          Personal protective
              equipment
Heat strain monitoring
                          NO   Implement    Continue work
      TLV exceeded?              general   Maintain controls
                                controls       Monitor

               YES

    Perform heat strain
      (physiological)
        monitoring



       Excessive heat     NO
      strain based on
        monitoring?
                YES

     Implement Job-
     specific controls
Heat strain monitoring
                          NO   Implement    Continue work
      TLV exceeded?              general   Maintain controls
                                controls       Monitor

               YES

    Perform heat strain
      (physiological)
        monitoring



       Excessive heat     NO
      strain based on
        monitoring?
                YES

     Implement Job-
     specific controls
 At workstation
        Ta = 24 0C
        Tw = 22 0C
        Tg = 28 0C
        V = 0.4 m/s

Work involves monitoring process
Minimal manual effort required

Standard overalls worn
WBGT Index
  No direct exposure to sunlight

  WBGT = 0.7 tnwb + 0.3 tg

  With direct exposure to sunlight

  WBGT = 0.7 tnwb + 0.2 tg + 0.1 ta
 At workstation
   Ta = 24 0C
   Tw = 22 0C
   Tg = 28 0C
   V = 0.4 m/s


WBGT = 23.8 0C
Screening
  NO        Clothing
       adjustment factors
           available?

                   YES
TLV Clothing Corrections
Clothing Type                          WBGT Correction

Work clothes (long sleeve and pants)          0
Cloth (woven material) coveralls              0

Double layer woven clothing                   3
SMS polypropylene coveralls                  0.5
Polyolefin overalls                           1
Limited use vapour-barrier overalls          11
Screening
  NO        Clothing
       adjustment factors
           available?

                    YES

         Are screening       NO
       criteria for Action
        Limit exceeded?

                   YES
Metabolic rate categories
Category      Metabolic Rate (W)

Rest                 115
Light                180
Moderate             300
Heavy                415
Very Heavy           520
ACGIH TLVs – Action Limit

Allocation of               Workload
work in work Light   Moderate   Heavy   V ery
cycle                                   heavy
75% to 100% 28.0     25.0       -       -
50% to 75%   28.5    26.0       24.0    -
25% to 50%   29.5    27.0       25.5    24.5
0 to 25%     30.0    29.0       28.0    27.0
ACGIH TLVs – Action Limit

Allocation of               Workload
work in work Light   Moderate   Heavy   V ery
cycle                                   heavy
75% to 100% 28.0     25.0       -       -
50% to 75%   28.5    26.0       24.0    -
25% to 50%   29.5    27.0       25.5    24.5
0 to 25%     30.0    29.0       28.0    27.0


        WBGT = 23.8 0C
Screening
  NO        Clothing
       adjustment factors
           available?

                    YES

         Are screening       NO
       criteria for Action        Low Risk
        Limit exceeded?

                   YES
Screening
  NO        Clothing
       adjustment factors
           available?

                    YES

         Are screening       NO
                                             Continue work
       criteria for Action        Low Risk
                                               Monitor
        Limit exceeded?

                   YES
Boiler Cleaning


                             Air     Wet     Globe   Air
                             temp.   bulb    temp.   velocity
                             (0C)    temp.   (0C)    (m/s)
                                     (0C)
             Start of work   34      19      51      0.2
             After 5 hours   32.5    18.5    51.5    0.2

              Heavy manual effort required

              Standard overalls worn
Boiler Cleaning


                             Air     Wet     Globe   Air
                             temp.   bulb    temp.   velocity
                             (0C)    temp.   (0C)    (m/s)
                                     (0C)
             Start of work   34      19      51      0.2
             After 5 hours   32.5    18.5    51.5    0.2




                     WBGT = 28.6 0C
Screening
  NO        Clothing
       adjustment factors
           available?

                   YES
TLV Clothing Corrections
Clothing Type                          WBGT Correction

Work clothes (long sleeve and pants)          0
Cloth (woven material) coveralls              0

Double layer woven clothing                   3
SMS polypropylene coveralls                  0.5
Polyolefin overalls                           1
Limited use vapour-barrier overalls          11
Screening
  NO        Clothing
       adjustment factors
           available?

                    YES

         Are screening       NO
       criteria for Action
        Limit exceeded?

                   YES
Metabolic rate categories
Category      Metabolic Rate (W)

Rest                 115
Light                180
Moderate             300
Heavy                415
Very Heavy           520
ACGIH TLVs – Action Limit

Allocation of               Workload
work in work Light   Moderate   Heavy   V ery
cycle                                   heavy
75% to 100% 28.0     25.0       -       -
50% to 75%   28.5    26.0       24.0    -
25% to 50%   29.5    27.0       25.5    24.5
0 to 25%     30.0    29.0       28.0    27.0
ACGIH TLVs – Action Limit

Allocation of               Workload
work in work Light   Moderate   Heavy   V ery
cycle                                   heavy
75% to 100% 28.0     25.0       -       -
50% to 75%   28.5    26.0       24.0    -
25% to 50%   29.5    27.0       25.5    24.5
0 to 25%     30.0    29.0       28.0    27.0
ACGIH TLVs – Action Limit

Allocation of               Workload
work in work Light   Moderate   Heavy   V ery
cycle                                   heavy
75% to 100% 28.0     25.0       -       -
50% to 75%   28.5    26.0       24.0    -
25% to 50%   29.5    27.0       25.5    24.5
0 to 25%     30.0    29.0       28.0    27.0

          WBGT = 28.6 0C
          So Action Limit is exceeded
Screening
  NO        Clothing
       adjustment factors
           available?

                    YES

         Are screening
       criteria for Action
        Limit exceeded?

                   YES

         Are screening       NO
        criteria for TLV
           exceeded?

                   YES
ACGIH TLVs – Screening TLV

Allocation of               Workload
work in work Light   Moderate   Heavy   V ery
cycle                                   heavy
75% to 100% 31.0     28.0       -       -
50% to 75%   31.0    29.0       27.5    -
25% to 50%   32.0    30.0       29.0    28.0
0 to 25%     32.5    31.5       30.5    30.0
ACGIH TLVs – Screening TLV

Allocation of               Workload
work in work Light   Moderate   Heavy     V ery
cycle                                     heavy
75% to 100% 31.0     28.0       -         -
50% to 75%   31.0    29.0       27.5      -
25% to 50%   32.0    30.0       29.0      28.0
0 to 25%     32.5    31.5       30.5      30.0

          WBGT = 28.6 0C
          So TLV is NOT exceeded provided
          work is restricted to 50% of shift
Screening
  NO        Clothing
       adjustment factors
           available?

                    YES

         Are screening       NO
                                              Continue work
       criteria for Action        Low Risk
                                                Monitor
        Limit exceeded?

                   YES

         Are screening       NO   Implement
        criteria for TLV            general
           exceeded?               controls

                   YES
Reduce risk
 Allow boiler to cool down before starting
 work
Working methods
 Mechanical aids
 Self pacing
Manage exposure time
 Implement work:rest regime
 Work restricted to 25% to 50% of
 work cycle
Provide information, instruction
and training
 Risks
 Good working practice
 Symptoms to look out for
Provide water
 Drink at regular intervals
Health surveillance
 Pre-placement medical
  screening
 Regular health checks
 Encourage reporting of
  symptoms
Encourage healthy lifestyle
 Diet
 Exercise
 Moderate alcohol
 consumption
Screening
  NO        Clothing
       adjustment factors
           available?

                    YES

         Are screening       NO
                                                Continue work
       criteria for Action        Low Risk
                                                  Monitor
        Limit exceeded?

                   YES

         Are screening       NO   Implement    Continue work
        criteria for TLV            general   Maintain controls
           exceeded?               controls       Monitor

                   YES
Furnace Repair

            Air       Wet bulb Globe      Air
            temp.     temp.    temp.      velocity
            (0C)      (0C)     (0C)       (m/s)
            98        45        150       1



           Heavy manual effort required

           Thick, woollen clothing worn
Furnace Repair

            Air       Wet bulb Globe   Air
            temp.     temp.    temp.   velocity
            (0C)      (0C)     (0C)    (m/s)
            98        45      150      1



                    WBGT = 76.5 0C
TLV Clothing Corrections
Clothing Type                          WBGT Correction

Work clothes (long sleeve and pants)          0
Cloth (woven material) coveralls              0

Double layer woven clothing                   3
SMS polypropylene coveralls                  0.5
Polyolefin overalls                           1
Limited use vapour-barrier overalls          11
TLV Clothing Corrections
Clothing Type                          WBGT Correction

Work clothes (long sleeve and pants)          0
Cloth (woven material) coveralls              0

Double layer woven clothing                   3
SMS polypropylene coveralls                  0.5
Polyolefin overalls                           1
Limited use vapour-barrier overalls          11
Furnace Repair

            Air     Wet bulb Globe   Air
            temp.   temp.    temp.   velocity
            (0C)    (0C)     (0C)    (m/s)
            98      45      150      1



           Corrected WBGT = 79.5 0C
Screening
  NO        Clothing
       adjustment factors
           available?

                    YES

         Are screening       NO
       criteria for Action
        Limit exceeded?

                   YES
Metabolic rate categories
Category      Metabolic Rate (W)

Rest                 115
Light                180
Moderate             300
Heavy                415
Very Heavy           520
ACGIH TLVs – Action Limit

Allocation of               Workload
work in work Light   Moderate   Heavy   V ery
cycle                                   heavy
75% to 100% 28.0     25.0       -       -
50% to 75%   28.5    26.0       24.0    -
25% to 50%   29.5    27.0       25.5    24.5
0 to 25%     30.0    29.0       28.0    27.0
ACGIH TLVs – Action Limit

Allocation of               Workload
work in work Light   Moderate   Heavy   V ery
cycle                                   heavy
75% to 100% 28.0     25.0       -       -
50% to 75%   28.5    26.0       24.0    -
25% to 50%   29.5    27.0       25.5    24.5
0 to 25%     30.0    29.0       28.0    27.0


                     Corrected WBGT = 79.5 0C
                     So Action Limit is exceeded
Screening
  NO        Clothing
       adjustment factors
           available?

                    YES

         Are screening
       criteria for Action
        Limit exceeded?

                   YES

         Are screening       NO
        criteria for TLV
           exceeded?

                   YES
ACGIH TLVs – Screening TLV

Allocation of               Workload
work in work Light   Moderate   Heavy   V ery
cycle                                   heavy
75% to 100% 31.0     28.0       -       -
50% to 75%   31.0    29.0       27.5    -
25% to 50%   32.0    30.0       29.0    28.0
0 to 25%     32.5    31.5       30.5    30.0
ACGIH TLVs – Screening TLV

Allocation of               Workload
work in work Light   Moderate   Heavy   V ery
cycle                                   heavy
75% to 100% 31.0     28.0       -       -
50% to 75%   31.0    29.0       27.5    -
25% to 50%   32.0    30.0       29.0    28.0
0 to 25%     32.5    31.5       30.5    30.0


                     Corrected WBGT = 79.5 0C
                     So TLV is exceeded
Are screening
                            criteria for TLV
                               exceeded?

                                       YES

                      NO   Are data available
                              for detailed
                               analysis?

                                        YES

Perform heat strain
  (physiological)          Detailed analysis
    monitoring
http://www.slideshare.net/mikeslater

mike@diamondenv.co.uk

http://diamondenv.wordpress.com

Twitter: @diamondenv


Mike Slater
Mike Slater, Diamond Environmental Ltd. (mike@diamondenv.co.uk)




     This presentation is distributed under the Creative Commons
                Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike
                        UK:International Licence

TLVs for heat stress

  • 1.
  • 2.
    Threshold Limit Values® (TLVs) for heat stress are included in the American Conference of Governmental Industrial Hygienists (ACGIH) TLV booklet
  • 3.
    TLVs® are guidelinesdesigned for use by occupational hygienists in making decisions regarding safe levels of exposure to various chemical substances and physical agents found in the workplace.
  • 4.
    This flowchart summariseshow to apply the TLV’s. However. It’s quite complex. We’ll go through it step by step
  • 5.
    General approach Detailed Heat Strain Screening Analysis Monitoring
  • 6.
    General approach Detailed Heat Strain Screening Analysis Monitoring
  • 7.
    Heat Stress NO STOP expected? YES SCREENING
  • 8.
    Screening NO Clothing adjustment factors available? YES
  • 9.
    TLV Clothing Corrections ClothingType WBGT Correction Work clothes (long sleeve and pants) 0 Cloth (woven material) coveralls 0 Double layer woven clothing 3 SMS polypropylene coveralls 0.5 Polyolefin overalls 1 Limited use vapour-barrier overalls 11
  • 10.
    Screening NO Clothing adjustment factors available? YES If no clothing adjustment factors are available, go straight to heat strain (physiological) monitoring
  • 11.
    Screening NO Clothing adjustment factors available? YES This may be necessary, for example, where chemical protective suits are being worn
  • 12.
    TLV Clothing Corrections ClothingType WBGT Correction Work clothes (long sleeve and pants) 0 Cloth (woven material) coveralls 0 Double layer woven clothing 3 SMS polypropylene coveralls 0.5 Polyolefin overalls 1 Limited use vapour-barrier overalls 11
  • 13.
    Screening NO Clothing adjustment factors available? YES Are screening NO criteria for Action Limit exceeded? YES
  • 14.
    Work out theWBGT from the results of environmental measurements and apply the clothing corrections
  • 15.
    WBGT Index No direct exposure to sunlight WBGT = 0.7 tnwb + 0.3 tg With direct exposure to sunlight WBGT = 0.7 tnwb + 0.2 tg + 0.1 ta
  • 16.
    Compare the correctedWBGT with the Action Limit Values
  • 17.
    ACGIH TLVs –Action Limit Allocation of Workload work in work Light Moderate Heavy V ery cycle heavy 75% to 100% 28.0 25.0 - - 50% to 75% 28.5 26.0 24.0 - 25% to 50% 29.5 27.0 25.5 24.5 0 to 25% 30.0 29.0 28.0 27.0
  • 18.
    To use thistable you have to know • the time spent working and resting • the metabolic rate
  • 19.
    Metabolic rate categories Category Metabolic Examples Rate (W) Sitting Rest 115 Sitting or standing Light 180 Light hand / arm work Walking Moderate 300 Moderate lifting Heavy materials handling Heavy 415 Pick and shovel work Very Heavy 520
  • 20.
    ACGIH TLVs –Action Limit Allocation of Workload work in work Light Moderate Heavy V ery cycle heavy 75% to 100% 28.0 25.0 - - 50% to 75% 28.5 26.0 24.0 - 25% to 50% 29.5 27.0 25.5 24.5 0 to 25% 30.0 29.0 28.0 27.0
  • 21.
    So, for ajob involving moderate work where 75% of the time is spent working and 25% resting
  • 22.
    ACGIH TLVs –Action Limit Allocation of Workload work in work Light Moderate Heavy V ery cycle heavy 75% to 100% 28.0 25.0 - - 50% to 75% 28.5 26.0 24.0 - 25% to 50% 29.5 27.0 25.5 24.5 0 to 25% 30.0 29.0 28.0 27.0
  • 23.
    ACGIH TLVs –Action Limit Allocation of Workload work in work Light Moderate Heavy V ery cycle heavy 75% to 100% 28.0 25.0 - - 50% to 75% 28.5 26.0 24.0 - 25% to 50% 29.5 27.0 25.5 24.5 0 to 25% 30.0 29.0 28.0 27.0
  • 24.
    ACGIH TLVs –Action Limit Allocation of Workload work in work Light Moderate Heavy V ery cycle heavy 75% to 100% 28.0 25.0 - - 50% to 75% 28.5 26.0 24.0 - 25% to 50% 29.5 27.0 25.5 24.5 0 to 25% 30.0 29.0 28.0 27.0
  • 25.
    ACGIH TLVs –Action Limit Allocation of Workload work in work Light Moderate Heavy V ery cycle heavy 75% to 100% 28.0 25.0 - - 50% to 75% 28.5 26.0 24.0 - 25% to 50% 29.5 27.0 25.5 24.5 0 to 25% 30.0 29.0 28.0 27.0
  • 26.
    ACGIH TLVs –Action Limit Allocation of Workload work in work Light Moderate Heavy V ery cycle heavy 75% to 100% 28.0 25.0 - - 50% to 75% 28.5 26.0 24.0 - 25% to 50% 29.5 27.0 25.5 24.5 0 to 25% 30.0 29.0 28.0 27.0 If the adjusted WBGT is below this value the Action Limit is not exceeded
  • 27.
    Screening NO Clothing adjustment factors available? YES Are screening NO criteria for Action Low Risk Limit exceeded? YES
  • 28.
    Screening NO Clothing adjustment factors available? YES Are screening NO Continue work criteria for Action Low Risk Monitor Limit exceeded? YES
  • 29.
    Screening NO Clothing adjustment factors available? YES Are screening NO Continue work criteria for Action Low Risk Monitor Limit exceeded? YES NO If the Action Limit is Are screening exceeded then the WBGT criteria for TLV exceeded? value is compared with the TLV criteria YES
  • 30.
    ACGIH TLVs –Screening TLV Allocation of Workload work in work Light Moderate Heavy V ery cycle heavy 75% to 100% 31.0 28.0 - - 50% to 75% 31.0 29.0 27.5 - 25% to 50% 32.0 30.0 29.0 28.0 0 to 25% 32.5 31.5 30.5 30.0
  • 31.
    Screening NO Clothing adjustment factors available? YES Are screening NO Continue work criteria for Action Low Risk Monitor Limit exceeded? YES Are screening NO Implement criteria for TLV general exceeded? controls YES
  • 32.
    General Information, instruction & training controls Regular drinks of water Self regulation Health screening and surveillance Encourage reporting symptoms Encourage healthy lifestyles Monitoring
  • 33.
    Screening NO Clothing adjustment factors available? YES Are screening NO Continue work criteria for Action Low Risk Monitor Limit exceeded? YES Are screening NO Implement Continue work criteria for TLV general Maintain controls exceeded? controls Monitor YES
  • 34.
    Screening NO Clothing adjustment factors available? YES Are screening NO Continue work criteria for Action Low Risk Monitor Limit exceeded? YES Are screening NO Implement Continue work criteria for TLV general Maintain controls exceeded? controls Monitor YES
  • 35.
    Detailed analysis NO Are data available for detailed analysis? YES If the TLV is exceeded, consider carrying out a more detailed analysis using a more sophisticated method, such as the Predicted Heat Strain (PHS) index
  • 36.
    Detailed analysis NO Are data available for detailed analysis? YES NO Action Limit exceeded? YES
  • 37.
    The Action Limitreferred to here is that associated with the index being used NOT the ACGIH Action Limit
  • 38.
    Detailed analysis NO Are data available for detailed analysis? YES NO Action Limit exceeded? YES
  • 39.
    Detailed analysis NO Are data available for detailed analysis? YES NO Action Limit Low Risk exceeded? YES
  • 40.
    Detailed analysis NO Are data available for detailed analysis? YES NO Action Limit Continue work Low Risk exceeded? Monitor YES
  • 41.
    Detailed analysis NO Are data available for detailed analysis? YES NO Action Limit Continue work Low Risk exceeded? Monitor YES NO TLV exceeded? YES
  • 42.
    The TLV referredto here is the limit value associated with the index being used NOT the ACGIH Screening TLVs
  • 43.
    Detailed analysis NO Are data available for detailed analysis? YES NO Action Limit Continue work Low Risk exceeded? Monitor YES NO TLV exceeded? YES
  • 44.
    Detailed analysis NO Are data available for detailed analysis? YES NO Action Limit Continue work Low Risk exceeded? Monitor YES NO Implement TLV exceeded? general controls YES
  • 45.
    Detailed analysis NO Are data available for detailed analysis? YES NO Action Limit Continue work Low Risk exceeded? Monitor YES NO Implement Continue work TLV exceeded? general Maintain controls controls Monitor YES
  • 46.
    Heat strain monitoring NO Implement Continue work TLV exceeded? general Maintain controls controls Monitor YES What if the TLV is exceeded?
  • 47.
    Heat strain monitoring NO Implement Continue work TLV exceeded? general Maintain controls controls Monitor YES Perform heat strain (physiological) monitoring
  • 48.
    Physiological assessment CoreTemperature Heart rate
  • 49.
  • 50.
    Miner’s Core Temperature& Heart Rate Source: OHTA.
  • 51.
    Heat strain monitoring NO Implement Continue work TLV exceeded? general Maintain controls controls Monitor YES Perform heat strain (physiological) monitoring Excessive heat NO strain based on monitoring? YES
  • 52.
    Guidelines for limitingHeat Strain Factor Work should be discontinued if: Heart rate (beats per minute) Greater than 180 minus age in years Core temperature Greater than 38.5 0C (acclimatised) Greater than 38.0 0C (unacclimatised) Recovery heart rate 120 (beats per minute) (at one minute after peak work) Other Symptoms of sudden and severe fatigue, nausea, dizziness or lightheadedness
  • 53.
    Heat strain monitoring NO Implement Continue work TLV exceeded? general Maintain controls controls Monitor YES Perform heat strain (physiological) monitoring Excessive heat NO strain based on monitoring? YES
  • 54.
    Heat strain monitoring NO Implement Continue work TLV exceeded? general Maintain controls controls Monitor YES Perform heat strain (physiological) monitoring Excessive heat NO strain based on monitoring? YES Implement Job- specific controls
  • 55.
    Job-specific controls Engineering controls Administrative controls Personal protective equipment
  • 56.
    Heat strain monitoring NO Implement Continue work TLV exceeded? general Maintain controls controls Monitor YES Perform heat strain (physiological) monitoring Excessive heat NO strain based on monitoring? YES Implement Job- specific controls
  • 57.
    Heat strain monitoring NO Implement Continue work TLV exceeded? general Maintain controls controls Monitor YES Perform heat strain (physiological) monitoring Excessive heat NO strain based on monitoring? YES Implement Job- specific controls
  • 60.
     At workstation  Ta = 24 0C  Tw = 22 0C  Tg = 28 0C  V = 0.4 m/s Work involves monitoring process Minimal manual effort required Standard overalls worn
  • 61.
    WBGT Index No direct exposure to sunlight WBGT = 0.7 tnwb + 0.3 tg With direct exposure to sunlight WBGT = 0.7 tnwb + 0.2 tg + 0.1 ta
  • 62.
     At workstation  Ta = 24 0C  Tw = 22 0C  Tg = 28 0C  V = 0.4 m/s WBGT = 23.8 0C
  • 63.
    Screening NO Clothing adjustment factors available? YES
  • 64.
    TLV Clothing Corrections ClothingType WBGT Correction Work clothes (long sleeve and pants) 0 Cloth (woven material) coveralls 0 Double layer woven clothing 3 SMS polypropylene coveralls 0.5 Polyolefin overalls 1 Limited use vapour-barrier overalls 11
  • 65.
    Screening NO Clothing adjustment factors available? YES Are screening NO criteria for Action Limit exceeded? YES
  • 66.
    Metabolic rate categories Category Metabolic Rate (W) Rest 115 Light 180 Moderate 300 Heavy 415 Very Heavy 520
  • 67.
    ACGIH TLVs –Action Limit Allocation of Workload work in work Light Moderate Heavy V ery cycle heavy 75% to 100% 28.0 25.0 - - 50% to 75% 28.5 26.0 24.0 - 25% to 50% 29.5 27.0 25.5 24.5 0 to 25% 30.0 29.0 28.0 27.0
  • 68.
    ACGIH TLVs –Action Limit Allocation of Workload work in work Light Moderate Heavy V ery cycle heavy 75% to 100% 28.0 25.0 - - 50% to 75% 28.5 26.0 24.0 - 25% to 50% 29.5 27.0 25.5 24.5 0 to 25% 30.0 29.0 28.0 27.0 WBGT = 23.8 0C
  • 69.
    Screening NO Clothing adjustment factors available? YES Are screening NO criteria for Action Low Risk Limit exceeded? YES
  • 70.
    Screening NO Clothing adjustment factors available? YES Are screening NO Continue work criteria for Action Low Risk Monitor Limit exceeded? YES
  • 72.
    Boiler Cleaning Air Wet Globe Air temp. bulb temp. velocity (0C) temp. (0C) (m/s) (0C) Start of work 34 19 51 0.2 After 5 hours 32.5 18.5 51.5 0.2 Heavy manual effort required Standard overalls worn
  • 73.
    Boiler Cleaning Air Wet Globe Air temp. bulb temp. velocity (0C) temp. (0C) (m/s) (0C) Start of work 34 19 51 0.2 After 5 hours 32.5 18.5 51.5 0.2 WBGT = 28.6 0C
  • 74.
    Screening NO Clothing adjustment factors available? YES
  • 75.
    TLV Clothing Corrections ClothingType WBGT Correction Work clothes (long sleeve and pants) 0 Cloth (woven material) coveralls 0 Double layer woven clothing 3 SMS polypropylene coveralls 0.5 Polyolefin overalls 1 Limited use vapour-barrier overalls 11
  • 76.
    Screening NO Clothing adjustment factors available? YES Are screening NO criteria for Action Limit exceeded? YES
  • 77.
    Metabolic rate categories Category Metabolic Rate (W) Rest 115 Light 180 Moderate 300 Heavy 415 Very Heavy 520
  • 78.
    ACGIH TLVs –Action Limit Allocation of Workload work in work Light Moderate Heavy V ery cycle heavy 75% to 100% 28.0 25.0 - - 50% to 75% 28.5 26.0 24.0 - 25% to 50% 29.5 27.0 25.5 24.5 0 to 25% 30.0 29.0 28.0 27.0
  • 79.
    ACGIH TLVs –Action Limit Allocation of Workload work in work Light Moderate Heavy V ery cycle heavy 75% to 100% 28.0 25.0 - - 50% to 75% 28.5 26.0 24.0 - 25% to 50% 29.5 27.0 25.5 24.5 0 to 25% 30.0 29.0 28.0 27.0
  • 80.
    ACGIH TLVs –Action Limit Allocation of Workload work in work Light Moderate Heavy V ery cycle heavy 75% to 100% 28.0 25.0 - - 50% to 75% 28.5 26.0 24.0 - 25% to 50% 29.5 27.0 25.5 24.5 0 to 25% 30.0 29.0 28.0 27.0 WBGT = 28.6 0C So Action Limit is exceeded
  • 81.
    Screening NO Clothing adjustment factors available? YES Are screening criteria for Action Limit exceeded? YES Are screening NO criteria for TLV exceeded? YES
  • 82.
    ACGIH TLVs –Screening TLV Allocation of Workload work in work Light Moderate Heavy V ery cycle heavy 75% to 100% 31.0 28.0 - - 50% to 75% 31.0 29.0 27.5 - 25% to 50% 32.0 30.0 29.0 28.0 0 to 25% 32.5 31.5 30.5 30.0
  • 83.
    ACGIH TLVs –Screening TLV Allocation of Workload work in work Light Moderate Heavy V ery cycle heavy 75% to 100% 31.0 28.0 - - 50% to 75% 31.0 29.0 27.5 - 25% to 50% 32.0 30.0 29.0 28.0 0 to 25% 32.5 31.5 30.5 30.0 WBGT = 28.6 0C So TLV is NOT exceeded provided work is restricted to 50% of shift
  • 84.
    Screening NO Clothing adjustment factors available? YES Are screening NO Continue work criteria for Action Low Risk Monitor Limit exceeded? YES Are screening NO Implement criteria for TLV general exceeded? controls YES
  • 85.
    Reduce risk  Allowboiler to cool down before starting work
  • 86.
    Working methods  Mechanicalaids  Self pacing
  • 87.
    Manage exposure time Implement work:rest regime  Work restricted to 25% to 50% of work cycle
  • 88.
    Provide information, instruction andtraining  Risks  Good working practice  Symptoms to look out for
  • 89.
    Provide water  Drinkat regular intervals
  • 90.
    Health surveillance  Pre-placementmedical screening  Regular health checks  Encourage reporting of symptoms
  • 91.
    Encourage healthy lifestyle Diet  Exercise  Moderate alcohol consumption
  • 92.
    Screening NO Clothing adjustment factors available? YES Are screening NO Continue work criteria for Action Low Risk Monitor Limit exceeded? YES Are screening NO Implement Continue work criteria for TLV general Maintain controls exceeded? controls Monitor YES
  • 94.
    Furnace Repair Air Wet bulb Globe Air temp. temp. temp. velocity (0C) (0C) (0C) (m/s) 98 45 150 1 Heavy manual effort required Thick, woollen clothing worn
  • 95.
    Furnace Repair Air Wet bulb Globe Air temp. temp. temp. velocity (0C) (0C) (0C) (m/s) 98 45 150 1 WBGT = 76.5 0C
  • 96.
    TLV Clothing Corrections ClothingType WBGT Correction Work clothes (long sleeve and pants) 0 Cloth (woven material) coveralls 0 Double layer woven clothing 3 SMS polypropylene coveralls 0.5 Polyolefin overalls 1 Limited use vapour-barrier overalls 11
  • 97.
    TLV Clothing Corrections ClothingType WBGT Correction Work clothes (long sleeve and pants) 0 Cloth (woven material) coveralls 0 Double layer woven clothing 3 SMS polypropylene coveralls 0.5 Polyolefin overalls 1 Limited use vapour-barrier overalls 11
  • 98.
    Furnace Repair Air Wet bulb Globe Air temp. temp. temp. velocity (0C) (0C) (0C) (m/s) 98 45 150 1 Corrected WBGT = 79.5 0C
  • 99.
    Screening NO Clothing adjustment factors available? YES Are screening NO criteria for Action Limit exceeded? YES
  • 100.
    Metabolic rate categories Category Metabolic Rate (W) Rest 115 Light 180 Moderate 300 Heavy 415 Very Heavy 520
  • 101.
    ACGIH TLVs –Action Limit Allocation of Workload work in work Light Moderate Heavy V ery cycle heavy 75% to 100% 28.0 25.0 - - 50% to 75% 28.5 26.0 24.0 - 25% to 50% 29.5 27.0 25.5 24.5 0 to 25% 30.0 29.0 28.0 27.0
  • 102.
    ACGIH TLVs –Action Limit Allocation of Workload work in work Light Moderate Heavy V ery cycle heavy 75% to 100% 28.0 25.0 - - 50% to 75% 28.5 26.0 24.0 - 25% to 50% 29.5 27.0 25.5 24.5 0 to 25% 30.0 29.0 28.0 27.0 Corrected WBGT = 79.5 0C So Action Limit is exceeded
  • 103.
    Screening NO Clothing adjustment factors available? YES Are screening criteria for Action Limit exceeded? YES Are screening NO criteria for TLV exceeded? YES
  • 104.
    ACGIH TLVs –Screening TLV Allocation of Workload work in work Light Moderate Heavy V ery cycle heavy 75% to 100% 31.0 28.0 - - 50% to 75% 31.0 29.0 27.5 - 25% to 50% 32.0 30.0 29.0 28.0 0 to 25% 32.5 31.5 30.5 30.0
  • 105.
    ACGIH TLVs –Screening TLV Allocation of Workload work in work Light Moderate Heavy V ery cycle heavy 75% to 100% 31.0 28.0 - - 50% to 75% 31.0 29.0 27.5 - 25% to 50% 32.0 30.0 29.0 28.0 0 to 25% 32.5 31.5 30.5 30.0 Corrected WBGT = 79.5 0C So TLV is exceeded
  • 106.
    Are screening criteria for TLV exceeded? YES NO Are data available for detailed analysis? YES Perform heat strain (physiological) Detailed analysis monitoring
  • 107.
  • 108.
    Mike Slater, DiamondEnvironmental Ltd. (mike@diamondenv.co.uk) This presentation is distributed under the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike UK:International Licence