Olegario Muñiz Ugarte1
Mirelys Rodríguez Alfaro1
Alfredo Montero Álvarez2
1Soil Institute, MINAG, Cuba
2CEADEN, CITMA, Cuba
Heavy Metals (H.M) Soil
Evaluation in Cuba, a case
study
Soil Atlas for Latin America and the Caribbean (2014)
Using the World Reference Base (WRB) Soil Classification
Heavy Metals in soils
Food Security is of highest
priority for the Cuban Ministry
of Agriculture (MINAG) and
special attention must be paid
to the safety and quality
certification of products of
agricultural origin, avoiding the
risk to human health that can
cause the toxic contaminants,
including Heavy Metals (HM)
SOIL
QUALITY
HM SOURCES IN SOILS:
• Parental Material
• Mineral Fertilizers (rock
phosphate, etc)
• Pesticides
• Organic manures
• Water and Sludges
• Mines and metalurgical industries
• Fosil Fuel Combustion
Perfil 2
The elements determined were mainly :
Cd, Pb, Ni, Cr, Zn , Cu, As, Hg, Sb
For many years
Total contents
were determined .
In present, USEPA
3051a
Microwave
During these years the
Analytical Techniques
were improved
The surveys carried out in Cuba show that only in
some areas of intensive agriculture where during
many years High Inputs where employed (fertilizers,
pesticides, machinery, etc), some of these HM
contents, despite that can not be considered an
inminent risk for human health, are higher than the
International Mean Values (Muñiz et al, 1988, 2000
y 2004).
It is the case of Red Ferralític soil
(Nitisols, WRB) areas in Artemisa,
Mayabeque and Matanzas
provinces
Perfil 2
FERRASOLS
LUVISOLS
CAMBISOLS
CARSO DESNUDO
Fuente: CNSF - MINAGRI
SUELOS
RENDSINA
VERTISOLS
GLEYSOLS
FLUVISOLS
ARENOSOLS
LITOSOLS

0 50 100
Kilómetros
Ni and Cr
Cuban soils developed
from Serpentinite rock
are characterized for Ni
and Cr contents that can
reach values of 2000.0
mg.Kg-1. In others
developed from
sedimentary limestone, Ni
and Cr content could be
200.0 mg.Kg-1
Soil Exch. Organic Fe amorphus Fe cristal. Total
1 1.66 9.67 1.84 20.84 196.2
2 1.95 9.82 1.48 10.40 160.6
Table. Ni fractions in Red Ferralític soil (mg.Kg-1) by Shuman (1988)
Source: Muñiz et al, 2008 .
0,02
0,01
0,03
0,07
0,01
0,01
0,03
0,1
0,05
0,01
0,04
0,03
0,05
0,01
0,04
0,04
0
0,02
0,04
0,06
0,08
0,1
0,12
0,14
0,16
mg/pl
Kuban 2
56 ddg
Bayama
56 ddg
Kuban 2
69 ddg
Bayama
69 ddg
Máquina y momento
Hojas
Tallos
Raíz
Tubérculo
Figure 1. Cd uptake (mg/plant) in two stages of the potato cycle
(Red Ferralitic soil) , Muñiz et al, 2004.
Gráfico 3. Pb Uptake for beans and tomato (Red
Ferralític Soil), Muñiz et al, 2004.
0,211
0,081 0,299
0,058
1,722
0,32
0
0,5
1
1,5
2
2,5
mg/pl
Frijol negro Frijol rojo Tomate
Cultivo
Fruto
Resto
1. CRITERION FOR THE EVALUATION OF HM
IN ORGANIC MANURES AND COMPOSTS
2. PERMISSIBLE LIMITS of HM IN SOILS
Studies developed
Organic manures are in present an important source of nutrients
in Cuban Agriculture (Urban Agriculture) and thus, HM must be
monitored
ORGANOPONICS
HM criterion for the evaluation of Organic Manures.
Source Cd Pb Ni Zn Cu
Vermicompost < 0.40 17 130 170 34
Compost 0.60 30 110 205 85
Correlation between HM
content in the Organic
Manure and the HM
content in crop (leaf and
fruit vegetables)
considering Codex Stan
192-1995 (2016) as
benchmark.
Tabla. Mean content of HM in differents sources of organic manures (mg.Kg-1)
H.M.
Preliminary range of
Permissible Limits on Organic
Manure
Cd 2-3 mg Kg-1
Pb 140-150 mg Kg-1
Use of Urban Solid Residues (USR) compost
Cd Pb Ni Zn
2.00 380 180 530
Tabla. HM content in composts of USR
(mg.Kg-1)
Source: Muñiz et al (2008) .
PERMISSIBLE LIMITS of HM IN SOILS
by CONAMA(2009)
Reference Values (RV): natural values in the different
types of soils (due to the parental material) according CETESB (2005)
Prevention Values (PV): values between RV and IV. Must
be monitored
Investigation Values (IV): values over which exist a risk
for human health and life (not alowed for crops) Based in Risk Analysis,
using Csoil software, according Brand et al. (2007).
For the determination of Reference Values (RV):
Samples: 35 Reference Profiles along
the country (0-20 cm)
The profiles were selected
considering the Map escale 1: 25 000,
in areas with no anthropic activity
Heavy Metals n (1) n (2) RV Mean Mínimum Maximum s
Cd (mg kg-1) 33 3 0,6 1,2 0,1 6,1 1,6
Pb (mg kg-1) 33 1 50 34,6 5,2 113,6 23,6
Zn (mg kg-1) 33 4 86 90,7 26,1 260,1 54,3
Cu (mg kg-1) 33 5 83 83,7 9,5 269,9 54,5
Ni (mg kg-1) 33 4 170 294,2 9,8 3030,8 567,6
Cr (mg kg-1) 33 7 153 463,2 9,9 4418,3 941,8
Table 2. Reference Values(RV), mean values, minimum and maximum and
deviation standard on soil HM in Cuba
n (1) total of samples used for obtaining RVs
n (2) total of samples eliminated from the boxplot
Reference Values(RV):
Element RV PV IV
Cd 0,6 2.0 3.0
Pb 50 115 180
Zn 86 300 450
Cu 83 150 200
Ni 170 400 600
Cr 153 300 400
In 2016, we began a National Project with IAEA support
with the aim of Strengthening national capacities for the
certification of soil quality and safety assurance of
agricultural products through applications of nuclear
and conventional techniques
Reference Values (RV) and Investigation Values (IV):
CONCLUSIONS
Cuban Soil Service has in present, a
methodology, still preliminary, for the
evaluation of Heavy Metals in agricultural
soils and organic manures
THANKS
SOIL is our main
natural resource
and thus, we
must preserve it
for future
generations

Heavy Metals Soil Evaluation in Cuba, a case study

  • 2.
    Olegario Muñiz Ugarte1 MirelysRodríguez Alfaro1 Alfredo Montero Álvarez2 1Soil Institute, MINAG, Cuba 2CEADEN, CITMA, Cuba Heavy Metals (H.M) Soil Evaluation in Cuba, a case study
  • 3.
    Soil Atlas forLatin America and the Caribbean (2014) Using the World Reference Base (WRB) Soil Classification
  • 4.
    Heavy Metals insoils Food Security is of highest priority for the Cuban Ministry of Agriculture (MINAG) and special attention must be paid to the safety and quality certification of products of agricultural origin, avoiding the risk to human health that can cause the toxic contaminants, including Heavy Metals (HM) SOIL QUALITY
  • 5.
    HM SOURCES INSOILS: • Parental Material • Mineral Fertilizers (rock phosphate, etc) • Pesticides • Organic manures • Water and Sludges • Mines and metalurgical industries • Fosil Fuel Combustion Perfil 2
  • 6.
    The elements determinedwere mainly : Cd, Pb, Ni, Cr, Zn , Cu, As, Hg, Sb For many years Total contents were determined . In present, USEPA 3051a Microwave
  • 7.
    During these yearsthe Analytical Techniques were improved
  • 8.
    The surveys carriedout in Cuba show that only in some areas of intensive agriculture where during many years High Inputs where employed (fertilizers, pesticides, machinery, etc), some of these HM contents, despite that can not be considered an inminent risk for human health, are higher than the International Mean Values (Muñiz et al, 1988, 2000 y 2004). It is the case of Red Ferralític soil (Nitisols, WRB) areas in Artemisa, Mayabeque and Matanzas provinces Perfil 2
  • 9.
    FERRASOLS LUVISOLS CAMBISOLS CARSO DESNUDO Fuente: CNSF- MINAGRI SUELOS RENDSINA VERTISOLS GLEYSOLS FLUVISOLS ARENOSOLS LITOSOLS  0 50 100 Kilómetros Ni and Cr Cuban soils developed from Serpentinite rock are characterized for Ni and Cr contents that can reach values of 2000.0 mg.Kg-1. In others developed from sedimentary limestone, Ni and Cr content could be 200.0 mg.Kg-1 Soil Exch. Organic Fe amorphus Fe cristal. Total 1 1.66 9.67 1.84 20.84 196.2 2 1.95 9.82 1.48 10.40 160.6 Table. Ni fractions in Red Ferralític soil (mg.Kg-1) by Shuman (1988) Source: Muñiz et al, 2008 .
  • 10.
    0,02 0,01 0,03 0,07 0,01 0,01 0,03 0,1 0,05 0,01 0,04 0,03 0,05 0,01 0,04 0,04 0 0,02 0,04 0,06 0,08 0,1 0,12 0,14 0,16 mg/pl Kuban 2 56 ddg Bayama 56ddg Kuban 2 69 ddg Bayama 69 ddg Máquina y momento Hojas Tallos Raíz Tubérculo Figure 1. Cd uptake (mg/plant) in two stages of the potato cycle (Red Ferralitic soil) , Muñiz et al, 2004.
  • 11.
    Gráfico 3. PbUptake for beans and tomato (Red Ferralític Soil), Muñiz et al, 2004. 0,211 0,081 0,299 0,058 1,722 0,32 0 0,5 1 1,5 2 2,5 mg/pl Frijol negro Frijol rojo Tomate Cultivo Fruto Resto
  • 12.
    1. CRITERION FORTHE EVALUATION OF HM IN ORGANIC MANURES AND COMPOSTS 2. PERMISSIBLE LIMITS of HM IN SOILS Studies developed
  • 13.
    Organic manures arein present an important source of nutrients in Cuban Agriculture (Urban Agriculture) and thus, HM must be monitored ORGANOPONICS
  • 14.
    HM criterion forthe evaluation of Organic Manures. Source Cd Pb Ni Zn Cu Vermicompost < 0.40 17 130 170 34 Compost 0.60 30 110 205 85 Correlation between HM content in the Organic Manure and the HM content in crop (leaf and fruit vegetables) considering Codex Stan 192-1995 (2016) as benchmark. Tabla. Mean content of HM in differents sources of organic manures (mg.Kg-1) H.M. Preliminary range of Permissible Limits on Organic Manure Cd 2-3 mg Kg-1 Pb 140-150 mg Kg-1
  • 15.
    Use of UrbanSolid Residues (USR) compost Cd Pb Ni Zn 2.00 380 180 530 Tabla. HM content in composts of USR (mg.Kg-1) Source: Muñiz et al (2008) .
  • 16.
    PERMISSIBLE LIMITS ofHM IN SOILS by CONAMA(2009) Reference Values (RV): natural values in the different types of soils (due to the parental material) according CETESB (2005) Prevention Values (PV): values between RV and IV. Must be monitored Investigation Values (IV): values over which exist a risk for human health and life (not alowed for crops) Based in Risk Analysis, using Csoil software, according Brand et al. (2007).
  • 17.
    For the determinationof Reference Values (RV): Samples: 35 Reference Profiles along the country (0-20 cm) The profiles were selected considering the Map escale 1: 25 000, in areas with no anthropic activity
  • 18.
    Heavy Metals n(1) n (2) RV Mean Mínimum Maximum s Cd (mg kg-1) 33 3 0,6 1,2 0,1 6,1 1,6 Pb (mg kg-1) 33 1 50 34,6 5,2 113,6 23,6 Zn (mg kg-1) 33 4 86 90,7 26,1 260,1 54,3 Cu (mg kg-1) 33 5 83 83,7 9,5 269,9 54,5 Ni (mg kg-1) 33 4 170 294,2 9,8 3030,8 567,6 Cr (mg kg-1) 33 7 153 463,2 9,9 4418,3 941,8 Table 2. Reference Values(RV), mean values, minimum and maximum and deviation standard on soil HM in Cuba n (1) total of samples used for obtaining RVs n (2) total of samples eliminated from the boxplot Reference Values(RV):
  • 19.
    Element RV PVIV Cd 0,6 2.0 3.0 Pb 50 115 180 Zn 86 300 450 Cu 83 150 200 Ni 170 400 600 Cr 153 300 400 In 2016, we began a National Project with IAEA support with the aim of Strengthening national capacities for the certification of soil quality and safety assurance of agricultural products through applications of nuclear and conventional techniques Reference Values (RV) and Investigation Values (IV):
  • 20.
    CONCLUSIONS Cuban Soil Servicehas in present, a methodology, still preliminary, for the evaluation of Heavy Metals in agricultural soils and organic manures
  • 21.
    THANKS SOIL is ourmain natural resource and thus, we must preserve it for future generations