This document provides an overview of the evolution of email marketing from 2016. It discusses how email marketing has progressed from basic batch and blast strategies to more personalized approaches using techniques like consumer journey mapping, segmentation based on recency and frequency scores, and developing long-term engagement strategies. It highlights how the most effective marketers treat their email lists as valuable customer relationships to nurture over time, rather than one-time sales channels. Measurement is also emphasized, with more advanced companies tying their metrics to objectives like lifetime customer value rather than just opens and clicks. The document aims to demonstrate how marketers can maximize the potential of email as a marketing strategy through personalization, long-term engagement, and strategic measurement.
Evolution of Email Marketing: Strategies for Personalization, Measurement and Lifetime Value
1. Evolution of Email Marketing
2016 Edition
Dave Woodbeck
President & CEO
Three Deep Marketing
1
2. Dave Woodbeck
CEO, Three Deep Marketing
Email: dave.woodbeck@threedeepmarketing.com
• Self-described recovering CPA, in a good way
• Manages over 1,200 email campaigns per year
• Sends over 245,000,000 permission-based emails per year
• Works with B2C and B2B Fortune 100 to Small Businesses
• Maps marketing to consumers’ behavior and buying psychology
Visit www.threedeepmarketing.com to learn more about the
measureable digital marketing campaigns Dave and his team
provide.
10. Think email is dead?
Businesses will use email marketing more often and more effectively in
the next 10 years than they have since the beginning of the internet.
Isn’t Email Dead?
12. Cost Effective
Reach Your Customers
Nurture Repeat Business
Email Marketing has an avg. ROI of $38 for each
dollar spend. One in 5 companies report an ROI of
over 70:1. (DMA National Email Report 2015)
In 2014, email marketing was cited as the most effective
digital marketing channel for customer retention in the
United States. (eMarketer)
70% of people say they always open emails from their
favorite companies. (Exact Target)
WhyEmail?
16. 5 Email Marketing Strategies You NEED to
Master. And How They’ve Progressed
• Email Acquisition
• Personalization
• Journey Mapping
• Email Value Through Scoring
• Pulse and Respond
17. The Measurement
Gap
If a tree falls in the forest and no one is
around to hear it, does it make a sound?
Rhetorical, I know – the point is why send
an email if you can’t measure its
performance or attribute success.
17
18. Measurement is a
Large Gap
But, many don’t know how to align
against revenue.
Opens and Clicks are important, but
that’s not what executives care about.
Later in this presentation we’ll show you
a measurement model that allows you to
talk about value!
18
28. Experiment Your
Way To Success
28
Changed
CTA
Brought
White
Paper Up
• Changed ads and landing page CTA to
“Talk to an Expert” increased conversions
• Moving the white paper to the top of
page increased conversions
• Adding on page form vs pop up form
increased conversions
• Improvements increased conversion
rate by 36%
30. Treat People in Your Database Like
People
Evolve past batch and blast
30
31. What is: Batch and Blast?
Sending a single email to as many contacts as
possible without attention to individual behavior.
32. Is it SPAM?
Not technically. But some argue that
SPAM isn’t theoretically meat. Let’s just
say you wouldn’t want to serve either to
your guests.
33. Disrespectful!
33
If we’ve taken the time and effort to
understand our customer why would we
disrespect them with a one size fits all email
strategy?
34. Why do: companies blast
then?
Because it is often the easiest thing to do.
Creative variation can get expensive.
Uncertain about the economic benefits of
personalization.
All valid, so can we make it more effective?
45. Your Approach to
Content is UPSIDE
down!
45
We should be spending MORE time focused
on the TARGET (i.e. the List) and MORE time
focused on the SUBJECT LINE (i.e. the Offer).
53. Now with Real Data
-
20,000
40,000
60,000
80,000
100,000
120,000
140,000
160,000
180,000
200,000
DEC NOV OCT SEP AUG JUL JUN MAY APR MAR FEB JANUniqueConsumers
Month Since Last Open
Recency Curve as of 12/31/2015
57. The Simple
Grid
Engagement Value = Lifecycle Value
MoreFrequentLessFrequent
Less Recent More Recent
CurrentValue(FREQUENCY)
Potential Value (RECENCY)
Adapted from: http://blog.jimnovo.com/2007/04/03/recency-defines-engagement/
58. The Simple
Grid
Engagement Value = Lifecycle Value
Adapted from: http://blog.jimnovo.com/2007/04/03/recency-defines-engagement/
MoreFrequent
High Current Value
Low Potential Value
SAVE these consumers
High Current Value
High Potential Value
LOYAL: Keep these Consumers
LessFrequent
Low Current Value
Low Potential Value
REACTIVATE: Should we spend time/effort here?
Low Current Value
High Potential Value
GROW: Focus on growing
Less Recent More Recent
CurrentValue(FREQUENCY)
Potential Value (RECENCY)
59. The Simple
Grid
Engagement Value = Lifecycle Value
5ormore
High Current Value
Low Potential Value
SAVE these consumers
120K
High Current Value
High Potential Value
LOYAL: Keep these Consumers
178K
1-4
Low Current Value
Low Potential Value
REACTIVATE: Should we spend time/effort here?
64K
Low Current Value
High Potential Value
GROW: Focus on growing
314K (217K NEW)
3 or more months ago New to -2 Months Ago
CurrentValue(FREQUENCY)
Potential Value (RECENCY)
63. …And The Sales Impact
15.5%
-3.3%
12.0%
20.2%
Purchase
Amount
Frequency Penetration Sales % Increase
4.9%
7.5%
2.5%
10.7%
PURCHASE
AMOUNT
FREQUENCY PENETRATION SALES %
INCREASE
Introductory Product Upsell Product
$153 of Incremental LTV Lift
64. The Simple
Grid
Engagement Value = Lifecycle Value
5ormore
High Current Value
Low Potential Value
SAVE these consumers
120K = $9MM
High Current Value
High Potential Value
LOYAL: Keep these Consumers
178K = $27MM
1-4
Low Current Value
Low Potential Value
REACTIVATE: Should we spend time/effort here?
64K = $0.1MM
Low Current Value
High Potential Value
GROW: Focus on growing
314K = $24MM
3 or more months ago New to -2 Months Ago
CurrentValue(FREQUENCY)
Potential Value (RECENCY)
65. The #1 Predictor of Future Value!
Why Recency & Frequency?
BEHAVIOR!
68. Retail Post-Purchase
Campaign
0 days
Initial Thank You
Boot purchases only
+4 days
Survey Reminder
0 days
Initial Thank You
Non-purchase version
+20 days
How Are Your New
Boots Working Out?
+6 Months
Free 6 Month
Tune-Up
+12 Months
Free Heel-To-Toe
Check-Up
+18 Months
Free Heel-To-Toe
Check-Up
+24 Months
Upgrade To New
Boots
Email Opt-in No Footwear Purchase
Email Opt-in Footwear Purchase
72. Batch and Blast is NOT a Strategy
Personalized Broadcast and
Respond
IS a Strategy
72
73. Lifestyle / Solution Information
Product / Promotion Information
2 – 4
Jan
2 – 4
Feb
2 – 4
Mar
2 – 4
Apr
2 – 4
May
2 – 4
Jun
2 – 4
Jan
2 – 4
Feb
2 – 4
Mar
2 – 4
Apr
2 – 4
May
2 – 4
Jun
The Behavior Zone
The Broadcast and Respond Strategy
74. The Behavior Zone
Lifestyle / Solution Information
Product / Promotion Information
2 – 4
Apr
Trigger 1
Trigger 2
Trigger 3
The Broadcast and Respond Strategy
75. The Behavior Zone
The Broadcast and Respond Strategy
Lifestyle / Solution Information
Product / Promotion Information
2 – 4
May
Trigger 1
Trigger 2
Trigger 3
76. 2016 Benchmarks From Best-in-Class Companies
On Marketing Automation
http://offer.threedeepmarketing.com/marketing-automation-trends-for-
success
76
Free 14-page eBook based on research we completed with
Ascend2 on Trends for Marketing Automation Success
•Most Significant Barriers to Success
•Strategy and Planning Resources
•Most Useful System Features
•Measuring Marketing Automation Performance
So, Why Email?
Why are we all gathered here today?
[CLICK]
After all, Isn’t Email Dead? I mean the first email was sent back in 1971. In digital marketing terms that’s like a million years ago.
Over the years Emails Death as been predicted several times. First it was Instant Messaging that was going to kill email.
Then it was SMS and Text Messaging. Then it was Social Media… You get my point. Email has been around a long time and it will continue to be.
If it wasn’t this would be the shortest webinar of all time.
But, the fact is we are expecting Businesses to actually focus more on email marketing in the next 10 years than they have since the beginning of the internet.
[CLICK]
Email is yet again considered to be the most effective digital marketing tactic, and it also benefits from a relative ease in execution, per respondents to an survey from Ascend2 and its Research Partners [download page].
After all, Isn’t Email Dead? I mean the first email was sent back in 1971. In digital marketing terms that’s like a million years ago.
Over the years Emails Death as been predicted several times. First it was Instant Messaging that was going to kill email.
Then it was SMS and Text Messaging. Then it was Social Media… You get my point. Email has been around a long time and it will continue to be.
If it wasn’t this would be the shortest webinar of all time.
But, the fact is we are expecting Businesses to actually focus more on email marketing in the next 10 years than they have since the beginning of the internet.
[CLICK]
But why? Well, THREE Reasons. First, Email is Cost Effective. In most cases companies report that Email is either their best or second best marketing channel in terms of ROI.
Second, Email can be very effective in building new relationships, but more importantly new revenue. As ExactTarget stated 70% of people say they always open email from their favorite companies. And lastly, and probably the best reason email will continue to be so successful; is its ability to nurture repeat business from your existing customers. eMarketer released a report earlier this year showing that in 2014 email marketing was cited as the most effective digital channel for customer retention.
[Click]
Most are optimizing or living within an allocated budget, some, mostly ecommerce understand how to optimize the opportunity.
Later
Many marketers are overwhelmed by what to test.
It takes a solid analysis and understanding of consumer behavior to identify those things we should test.
Not technically
But technically spam is not really meat
AUDIENCE PARTICIPATION
SO HOW SHOULD WE START TO THINK ABOUT OUR MARKETING DATABASE AND PUT VALUE ON IT?
REMEMBER BACK IN 1985 WE DIDN’T HAVE ALL THIS FANCY CLICK AND VIEW STUFF, WE SIMPLY HAD A DATABASE OF CUSTOMERS.
MARTY: HEY DOC, HOW DO I KNOW IF A CUSTOMER IS STILL A CUSTOMER?
DOC: WHY DO YOU ASK?
MARTY: WELL I HEARD IT’S GOOD TO RETAIN MY CUSTOMERS.
DOC: WELL HOW DO YOU DEFINE CUSTOMER?
MARTY: I DON’T KNOW, THAT’S WHY I’M BACK HERE IN 1985 TRYING TO FIGURE IT OUT.
DOC: WELL IT’S REASONABLE TO THINK THAT A CUSTOMER IS SOMEBODY THAT HAS PURCHASED FROM YOU IN THE PAST AND YOU EXPECT THEM TO PURCHASE AGAIN IN THE FUTURE, CORRECT?
MARTY: BUT HOW WILL I KNOW WHO WILL PURCHASE AGAIN IN THE FUTURE?
DOC TO THE AUDIENCE: LET’S SEE IF WE CAN HELP MARTY OUT WITH A SIMPLE CONSTRUCT?
TAKE TWO CUSTOMERS, ONE THAT PURCHASED FROM YOU 2 YEARS AGO AND ONE THAT PURCHASED 2 MONTHS AGO; WHO IS MORE LIKELY TO COME BACK AND PURCHASE AGAIN?
MARTY: SO WAIT A MINUTE DOC, YOU’RE SAYING THAT CUSTOMERS THAT PURCHASED MOST RECENTLY FROM ME CAN HAVE AN EXPECTATION TO PURCHASE AGAIN IN THE FUTURE?
DOC: GREAT SCOTT MARTY, THAT IS THE ANSWER!
Audience Participation:
“Take two customers – the last contact with one was 10 years ago, the last contact with the other was 2 years ago. Would you be willing to go out on a limb and say the “customer” you last had contact with 2 years ago is more likely to still be a customer than the customer you last had contact with 10 years ago?”
How many have been asked the dreaded question of: What is the value of my marketing automation database?
Finally the big reveal around the dialogue of how customer value can be derived from the simple premise of recency and frequency.
In this section we’re going to give you a method to align value to your marketing automation database.
Let’s start with the definition of a MA customer record.
Let’s actually go further and define what a customer is.
[I need to think of a different word than “customer”]
You have just proven that recency is important.
In fact you’ve just proven that it is measure of customer value.
Can anybody give a guess as to what happened in October and September?
A big promotion that produced a lot of activity!
Talk about campaigns as another way to look at the performance of your database.
Add page
Can you imagine now being able to go to your boss and ask for money to keep your two best cells Alive?
Since the dawn of man a set of human behaviors have developed that can be leveraged by the modern marketer.
One of those behaviors is based on a scientific premise of recency and frequency.
Why RF(M) versus other techniques such as:
Demographics
Cluster coding
Market Research
Focus Groups
Customer Surveys
Because of something very simple:
BEHAVIOR
Behavior, specifically recent behavior is much more accurate and POWERFUL method than predicting behavior based on any other known factor.
This principle can be applied against almost any kind of activity and it can be stated simply as this:
The more recent you have taken a particular activity, the more likely (probable) you will take that activity again
This is the current POST-PURCHASE customer journey. The top is a simple Welcome message for those who purchased accessories or other Non-Footwear items.
Below is the track that our CRAFTSMAN would fall into after just purchasing New Work Boots. It is a drip campaign that communicates about that purchase from day 0 over the next 2 YEARS!
Here is the first email in the campaign that sends right after the purchase.
It is personalized from the Local Retail Store that they made the purchase.
It includes a SAVE $10 on next Boot purchase offer
And the ask to take a Survey about their shopping experience
Any overly positive survey responses or extremely poor responses are automatically triggered to the Store Manager and District Manager.
It includes the SKU’s of products purchased as well as the Sales Associate that made the sale.
This data is crucial to make sure that Red Wing can work with each store on making sure the Customer Journey of purchasing is as positive as it can be.
The sixth email is delivered at 18 months post-purchase, it is very similar to the 12 month email but this time touts harder that it may be time to invest in a new pair of boots.
As we might expect open rates are high right after purchase as the customer is engaged with Red Wing.
The interesting point to call out is that even out at 12 months post-purchase the email is performing higher than the Avg. Retail Open rate (Avg. Pulled from Silverpop’s resent 2014 email benchmark study)
And even at 2 years after purchase open rates are still not to far below retail industry average.
This is the power of understanding the Customer Journey and utilizing Data and Feedback to have a relevant and timely dialogue with your customer.
ALL THE TALK ABOUT TRIGGERED IS GOOD
BUT IT DOESN’T REPLACE THE GOOD OLE BROADCAST STRATEGY
The pulse (broadcast | newsletter | etc…) still has a very important role.
It is the catalyst that can keep your consumers engaged with the brand and indicate the items for which they are interested.
Silverpop benchmark metrics on triggered emails versus broadcast emails.
The pulse (broadcast | newsletter | etc…) still has a very important role.
It is the catalyst that can keep your consumers engaged with the brand and indicate the items for which they are interested.
Silverpop benchmark metrics on triggered emails versus broadcast emails.
The pulse (broadcast | newsletter | etc…) still has a very important role.
It is the catalyst that can keep your consumers engaged with the brand and indicate the items for which they are interested.
Silverpop benchmark metrics on triggered emails versus broadcast emails.