Setting the Stage for Vertical Social
Networks
Rebecca Lieb, Industry Analyst
@lieblink @altimetergroup | #B2BSocial
Q   Who here has
        heard of vertical
        social networks?



2
Q   Who here uses
        vertical social
        networks?



3
Vertical Social Networks well poised
as the most credible info source
Agenda
•   Defining VSNs
•   Community-Driven Content
•   Robust Community
•   Workflow Applications
•   Business Models
•   Case Example
Vertical vs.                 Horizontal
• Highly segmented user base   • Highly diverse user base
• Specific topics covered in   • Broad topical range
  depth                        • Low specialization
• High specialization          • Less public privacy
• Generally more
  private, gated
Vertical Networks – “Socializing”
Business Functions
                      HR   IT                       Fin   Med   Dev         R&D




  Industry Specific
                                                                      ...
                            Where IT Goes to Work
  Networks




  Professional
  Network

  Personal
  Network
Community-
Driven Content
Community members
generate the bulk of site
content and drive site
interaction

                            Learnist has been described as the
                            „Pinterest‟ for education, enabling users to
                            add blogs, feeds, video, podcasts,
                            comments, votes, etc. to “Learnboards” in
                            order to quickly create lessons and course
                            units.
Robust
Community
A concentrated and highly
specialized community, with
shared issues, interests, and
connections


                                GovLoop is a platform of more than 60,000
                                public sector professionals dedicated to
                                best-practice/blog/resource sharing, finding
                                career opportunities, training, and
                                connecting with other government workers.
Workflow
Applications
Providing tools and content
to enable
professionals/members
better accomplish their
work/goals
                              Medical professional network, Doximity
                              offers all members secure digital fax lines,
                              accessible via web and mobile. It also
                              enables secure messaging and search
                              between colleagues and other providers.
VSNs: The Business Case
Possible business models selling to brands and
advertisers
•   Marketing solutions                      •   Platform solutions
    •   Advertising & content                    •   Co-branded platform functions

    •   Targeted audience                        •   Workflow applications

    •   Influencer identification                •   APIs and embeddable widgets

    •   Influencer contracting                   •   3rd party shopping (“s-
                                                     commerce”)
    •   Sponsorship, promotions
    •   Lead generation
                                             •   Research/Analytics
                                                 packages
•   Hiring/candidate-sourcing
                                                 •   Customized reports for brands/
    •   Matches employers with job seekers           vendors
VSNs: The Business Case
Create value for members
•   Membership model                             •   For businesses themselves
    •   Enable members to better perform their       •   Empowers employees
        jobs/functions
                                                     •   Career development
    •   Enable knowledge sharing via
        community, 1:1                           •   Integrating VSN into existing
                                                     business model
    •   Jobseekers can engage and collaborate
        with fellow jobseekers

•   Premium subscriptions model
    •   Access to premium
        access, features, APIs, etc.

    •   Enable member-brand communication

    •   Integrated Apps, APIs
E-Toro incentivizes top investors (influencers)
and takes a cut off of each trade




   With 2M+ users across 140 countries, the central feed showcases top investors‟
   activities in real-time and allows users (novice traders) to mimic their decisions.
Managing investments worth tens of billions annually, the company pays traders $10
13     per follower and then takes a commission (.1-.3%) off each transaction.
Example: Forrst leverages
membership for targeted job ads




     Forrst offers immense value to members, as a
   community where developers and designers can
crowdsource and test their ideas out. The site makes
 money through both membership and piping in job
      posts and relevant ads targeting this highly
  14              specialized audience.
Example: LinkedIn‟s multi-track
Business Model drives mass scale




       LinkedIn‟s revenue grew 81% YOY in Q3 2012 at
       $252m, jumping to an estimated $940m full-year.
                             20% of total 50% 30%
                            revenue
Putting the Pieces Together:
      Case Examples
Wave handles accounting for SMBs, liberating
them to focus where they really need to




     Wave serves as an all-in-one solution for very small business payroll, personal finance,
accounting, invoicing, payment transactions, and other key finance WORKFLOWS. They bolster
 their COMMUNITY with a paid pro network, SMB forum, and CONTENT like FAQs, discussion
                            threads, SMB data, and other resources.
Spiceworks provides value at every
 stage of the purchase cycle…
                        Learn                         Connect
                                            Network with buyers inside the
                                             leading social network for IT


 Uncover IT buyer behaviors/preferences
     that shape purchase decisions



                                                                                           Sell

Reach




                        Marketing tools to reach an               Link your sales force or reseller
                        audience of over 2M IT pros                directly into our marketplace
THANK YOU
                            Rebecca Lieb
                            rebecca@altimetergroup.com
                            rebeccalieb.com/blog
                            Twitter: lieblink


Disclaimer: Although the information and data used in this report have been produced and processed from
sources believed to be reliable, no warranty expressed or implied is made regarding the completeness,
accuracy, adequacy or use of the information. The authors and contributors of the information and data
shall have no liability for errors or omissions contained herein or for interpretations thereof. Reference
herein to any specific product or vendor by trade name, trademark or otherwise does not constitute or imply
its endorsement, recommendation or favoring by the authors or contributors and shall not be used for
advertising or product endorsement purposes. The opinions expressed herein are subject to change without
notice.
20




ABOUT US
Altimeter Group provides research and advisory for companies
challenged by business disruptions, enabling them to pursue
new opportunities and business models.


Visit us at http://www.altimetergroup.com or contact
info@altimetergroup.com.

Vertical Social Networks

  • 1.
    Setting the Stagefor Vertical Social Networks Rebecca Lieb, Industry Analyst @lieblink @altimetergroup | #B2BSocial
  • 2.
    Q Who here has heard of vertical social networks? 2
  • 3.
    Q Who here uses vertical social networks? 3
  • 4.
    Vertical Social Networkswell poised as the most credible info source
  • 5.
    Agenda • Defining VSNs • Community-Driven Content • Robust Community • Workflow Applications • Business Models • Case Example
  • 6.
    Vertical vs. Horizontal • Highly segmented user base • Highly diverse user base • Specific topics covered in • Broad topical range depth • Low specialization • High specialization • Less public privacy • Generally more private, gated
  • 7.
    Vertical Networks –“Socializing” Business Functions HR IT Fin Med Dev R&D Industry Specific ... Where IT Goes to Work Networks Professional Network Personal Network
  • 8.
    Community- Driven Content Community members generatethe bulk of site content and drive site interaction Learnist has been described as the „Pinterest‟ for education, enabling users to add blogs, feeds, video, podcasts, comments, votes, etc. to “Learnboards” in order to quickly create lessons and course units.
  • 9.
    Robust Community A concentrated andhighly specialized community, with shared issues, interests, and connections GovLoop is a platform of more than 60,000 public sector professionals dedicated to best-practice/blog/resource sharing, finding career opportunities, training, and connecting with other government workers.
  • 10.
    Workflow Applications Providing tools andcontent to enable professionals/members better accomplish their work/goals Medical professional network, Doximity offers all members secure digital fax lines, accessible via web and mobile. It also enables secure messaging and search between colleagues and other providers.
  • 11.
    VSNs: The BusinessCase Possible business models selling to brands and advertisers • Marketing solutions • Platform solutions • Advertising & content • Co-branded platform functions • Targeted audience • Workflow applications • Influencer identification • APIs and embeddable widgets • Influencer contracting • 3rd party shopping (“s- commerce”) • Sponsorship, promotions • Lead generation • Research/Analytics packages • Hiring/candidate-sourcing • Customized reports for brands/ • Matches employers with job seekers vendors
  • 12.
    VSNs: The BusinessCase Create value for members • Membership model • For businesses themselves • Enable members to better perform their • Empowers employees jobs/functions • Career development • Enable knowledge sharing via community, 1:1 • Integrating VSN into existing business model • Jobseekers can engage and collaborate with fellow jobseekers • Premium subscriptions model • Access to premium access, features, APIs, etc. • Enable member-brand communication • Integrated Apps, APIs
  • 13.
    E-Toro incentivizes topinvestors (influencers) and takes a cut off of each trade With 2M+ users across 140 countries, the central feed showcases top investors‟ activities in real-time and allows users (novice traders) to mimic their decisions. Managing investments worth tens of billions annually, the company pays traders $10 13 per follower and then takes a commission (.1-.3%) off each transaction.
  • 14.
    Example: Forrst leverages membershipfor targeted job ads Forrst offers immense value to members, as a community where developers and designers can crowdsource and test their ideas out. The site makes money through both membership and piping in job posts and relevant ads targeting this highly 14 specialized audience.
  • 15.
    Example: LinkedIn‟s multi-track BusinessModel drives mass scale LinkedIn‟s revenue grew 81% YOY in Q3 2012 at $252m, jumping to an estimated $940m full-year. 20% of total 50% 30% revenue
  • 16.
    Putting the PiecesTogether: Case Examples
  • 17.
    Wave handles accountingfor SMBs, liberating them to focus where they really need to Wave serves as an all-in-one solution for very small business payroll, personal finance, accounting, invoicing, payment transactions, and other key finance WORKFLOWS. They bolster their COMMUNITY with a paid pro network, SMB forum, and CONTENT like FAQs, discussion threads, SMB data, and other resources.
  • 18.
    Spiceworks provides valueat every stage of the purchase cycle… Learn Connect Network with buyers inside the leading social network for IT Uncover IT buyer behaviors/preferences that shape purchase decisions Sell Reach Marketing tools to reach an Link your sales force or reseller audience of over 2M IT pros directly into our marketplace
  • 19.
    THANK YOU Rebecca Lieb rebecca@altimetergroup.com rebeccalieb.com/blog Twitter: lieblink Disclaimer: Although the information and data used in this report have been produced and processed from sources believed to be reliable, no warranty expressed or implied is made regarding the completeness, accuracy, adequacy or use of the information. The authors and contributors of the information and data shall have no liability for errors or omissions contained herein or for interpretations thereof. Reference herein to any specific product or vendor by trade name, trademark or otherwise does not constitute or imply its endorsement, recommendation or favoring by the authors or contributors and shall not be used for advertising or product endorsement purposes. The opinions expressed herein are subject to change without notice.
  • 20.
    20 ABOUT US Altimeter Groupprovides research and advisory for companies challenged by business disruptions, enabling them to pursue new opportunities and business models. Visit us at http://www.altimetergroup.com or contact info@altimetergroup.com.

Editor's Notes

  • #9 Learnist, from test prep company Grockit, has been described as Pinterest for education. Learnist enables users to add Web resources -- such as blogs, feeds, videos and podcasts -- to Learnboards to quickly create lessons and units.
  • #12 http://alexdc.org/2010/12/want-to-create-a-vertical-social-network-answer-these-10-questions-first.htmlhttp://socialmediatoday.com/fidoogle/116245/business-model-open-social-networksExamples of Platform Solutions:LinkedIn’s LinkedIn Recruiter, InMails, or ProfileStats Pro, premium account types include premium features
  • #13 http://alexdc.org/2010/12/want-to-create-a-vertical-social-network-answer-these-10-questions-first.htmlhttp://socialmediatoday.com/fidoogle/116245/business-model-open-social-networksExamples of Platform Solutions:LinkedIn’s LinkedIn Recruiter, InMails, or ProfileStats Pro, premium account types include premium features
  • #14 http://techcrunch.com/2012/03/13/social-investment-network-etoro-is-picking-up-another-15-million-from-spark-others/eToro is an investment network that lets user follow and trade based on activity of other investors.
  • #16 http://bmimatters.com/2012/05/16/understanding-linkedin-business-model/http://www.wired.com/business/2012/11/linkedin-blowout/http://www.forbes.com/sites/ciocentral/2012/08/04/why-wall-street-likes-linkedin-more-than-facebook/http://techcrunch.com/2012/11/01/linkedin-q3-2012/WHY INVESTORS LIKE LINKEDIN MORE THAN FBHow is it that LinkedIn, less engaging and so much smaller than Facebook, is so much better at making money?Professional versus socialThe answer seems to lie in the nature of information found on each platform. When aggregated at scale (and mapped to true identities), both sets of data are easily monetizable in a number of ways. But professional data holds key characteristics that are currently making it, pound for pound, more valuable to Wall Street than social data.Recency:Our professional lives don’t change at nearly the same pace as our social lives. Many users only return to LinkedIn to update their profiles when they change jobs, but the information LinkedIn has about users’ professional life is relatively current and up-to-date. On the flip side, Facebook requires you to constantly update your rapidly changing social information to retain value as well as stay relevant to target advertisers.Authenticity. People take a great deal of creative license when they represent themselves in their social circles. Of course it happens in professional life as well (I’ve seen quite a few cases of rounded-up GPAs or overstated ‘charity’ involvement), but you don’t typically see resumes where the candidate says they attended “The School of Hard Knocks” or are the current President of the United States, when actually they are still a senior at Berkeley. On Facebook, facts are just not as important as having fun and impressing your friends. But it’s easier for advertisers to monetize accurate information that truly reflects consumer identities and preferences.StandardizationWhat defines me professionally is far more limited than what defines me socially. My social identity on Facebook is a complex and ever-changing amalgamation of ideas, interests, thoughts, pictures, places and media that I am perpetually curating and refining as my tastes and life change. However, in the professional arena, I am defined by a far more standardized set of criteria: where I live, my age, where I worked, my job title, where I studied, what I majored in and my GPA.  For recruiters, this is easy data to digest and utilize, and it doesn’t change very often. This is also what makes it so valuable and inherently easier to monetize.Put it like this: if users simply stopped editing their Facebook profiles, Facebook would have little value to advertisers after about 3-5 years. Conversely, LinkedIn would still be the largest collection of professional data and resumes in the world.Enterprise spend versus consumer spendConsumer-focused business models can be a real slog, and steady monetization is elusive. First, there are the challenges of scaling and distribution, then fast-paced innovation and blistering competition, not to mention the fickle and unpredictable spending habits of the customers themselves. Remember when Netflix increased their prices marginally? Members were outraged and attrition skyrocketed.SAP and Oracle steadily increase prices on their enterprise customers each year with clock-like dependability with very little fallout.When companies find a solution that works, they adopt it, integrate it, budget for it, and are unlikely to shed it. Mass adoption can take years, even decades, to achieve, but once established, the revenue streams can resemble a long-term annuity.Despite yielding revenue from premium subscriptions and consumer-facing advertising, LinkedIn, at its moneymaking core, is an enterprise company. It sells its lead enterprise recruiting solution, LinkedIn Recruiter, at a high price-point, as well as a number of other offerings for the enterprise.My gut tells me that Wall Street likely values the long-term enterprise contract revenue at significantly higher multiples than the consumer-facing streams.Whether that’s advertising to users to buy a good or a service, enrolling them in a game, Facebook makes money in one way: facilitating consumer spending. This generally means more volatility on the path to monetization.
  • #18 http://techcrunch.com/2012/12/17/with-500k-users-wave-rebrands-to-tell-the-world-it-isnt-just-about-free-accounting-anymore/BIZ MODEL: Freemium model, supported by ad placements and certain paid features.Other specs:Specialize in companies with under 10 employeesgrowing at 1,300 new business sign-ups a day!57B tracked in income and spending130k bank accounts connected33M transactions downloaded11M minutes of data entry savedCompany can undercut a lot of other options out there, without sacrificing features, through integrated advertising and select paid products, like the payroll offering, and the online credit card payments it’s using for direct response to invoicing. Wave is a great online accounting application for small businesses. There are several features that, taken together, make Wave different from other accounting tools. 1) Accounting is totally free. Not freemium, or free with usage caps. Just plain free. 2) Wave Accounting is a full double-entry accounting app, which is preferred by accountants. It also has financial dashboards, and can track expenses, and can be used in a lightweight manner if business owners don’t need or want full accounting… “It’s really about bringing together all sorts of different functionality together into one place for small business owners. We’ve signed up about almost 500,000 small businesses around the world so far, and are adding new ones at a rate of about 1,300 new signups each day.” Free offerings will remain a core part of the platform, and that freemium will always be the plan for Wave. He says that with products like direct payment transactions and payroll where charging a fee makes sense, they’ll continue to do that, too, and also notes that conversions are very promising in terms of getting customers on board with those products from the existing free ones, though he wouldn’t go into specifics.
  • #19 Intro with DCJ, ANIMATIONS illustrate their 360 approach….Worth mentioning they’re gathering all of this 360 data about IT buyers on the backend…BACKGROUNDSpiceworks connects a community of 2.4 million IT professionals with 1,500+ tech vendors, offering a wealth of content-types and a suite of IT workflow apps to help members better perform their jobsCOMMUNITY- Advice, Q&A, Discussions, Meet-ups at events, etc. WORKFLOW- Help Desk, Inventory, Monitoring, Purchasing appsCONTENT- How-to’s, Product Reviews, Vendor PagesResults2.4m memberbase growing at *2,300/dayUsers spend 500m min/month on IT applicationsMore than 30k product reviewsHigher engagement (time per unique) than LinkedIn (3:09 min. vs. .18min) Revenue per registered user is more than twice that of LinkedIn’sMonthly Engagement2.9M unique users14.5M tickets produced56M page views550M minutes