This document describes a case of an interesting thyroid nodule found in a 66-year-old male with a history of multinodular goiter. Further testing found the nodule to be a clear cell carcinoma, matching the histology of a renal carcinoma the patient had surgically removed 25 years prior. Metastatic tumors to the thyroid gland can occur even many years after treatment of the primary cancer. Given the patient's history of renal cancer, the new thyroid nodule was determined to likely represent a metastatic deposit to the thyroid from the previous renal carcinoma. This case highlights the importance of considering metastasis when new thyroid masses present in patients with a history of other malignancies.