So, be honest, is e-learning really effective?
Clive Shepherd
What does effective mean when we’re talking about
training?
People like it and would recommend it to their
colleagues
There is evidence that learning has taken place in
line with the learning objectives
There is evidence that the learning has been
translated into changed behaviour
There is evidence that this change in behaviour
has resulted in improved business performance
This change in performance was worth the
money spent on the training
Learning methods are timeless
case studies
quizzes
simulation
role-play
demonstrations
group instruction
on-job instruction
coaching
briefings
games
feedback
reading
lectures
discussioncollaboration
work experienceprojects
visits
Q&A
researchreflection
networking
observation
consultation
sharing
performance support
exploration
group projects
surveys
GROUP
ONE-TO-ONE
SELF-STUDY
books CDs
streaming video /
screencasts
e-books
interactive
materials
DVDs
3D worlds instant
messaging
email
forums
social
networks
wikis web conferencing blogs
telephone
teleconferencing
SMS
downloaded
docs
on-job classroom
Twitter
FACE-TO-FACE
OFFLINE
ONLINE
TELEPHONIC
Learning media are evolving rapidly
podcasts
tapes
mobile internet
Does the medium you use for training make such a big
impact on effectiveness?
The No Significant Difference
Phenomenon by Thomas L
Russell, IDECC, 2001
The comparative effectiveness of
web‐based and classroom instruction: A
meta‐analysis by T Sitzmann, K Kraiger,
D Stewart, R Wisher, Personnel
Psychology 59, 2006
How does self-study add value? What are its
limitations?
+
Self-paced
Accessible in small chunks
Available on demand
Allows time for reflection
Puts you in control
Leaves the learner isolated
Requires self-discipline
-
Not always self-sufficient
Why is e-learning such a powerful option for self-study?
Multimedia
a
Why is e-learning such a powerful option for self-study?
Multimedia
a
Interactivitya
Why is e-learning such a powerful option for self-study?
Multimedia
a
Interactivitya
Speed
Why is e-learning such a powerful option for self-study?
Multimedia
a
Interactivitya
Speed
Connectivity
Why is e-learning such a powerful option for self-study?
What does ‘good' e-learning look like?
E-learning is a good choice of medium for this
topicThe content is directly relevant to real-work
problemsThe learner is emotionally engaged
Lots of storytelling at the expense of abstract
rules and conceptsPictures and videos rather than words
Lots of challenging, relevant interactivity
Organised into small chunks
What positive results can e-learning bring?
47%
volume
increas
e
69%
report
reduced
time to
competen
cy
59% able
to
implement
changes
faster
Towards Maturity Impact
Case study: Leadership development at British Airways
Blended leadership development
British Airways were looking for a
fast, cost-effective, scalable, flexible and
engaging new approach to the
development of 1000 leaders. They
developed a blended solution that
included a 350 degree self-awareness
tool, custom online learning, a two-day
workshop and tasks for embedding the
learning in the workplace.
After just six months, 73% of line
managers and their peers reported that
they had already seen major changes in
the way they were working.
14
Case study: Retail induction at Levi Strauss
Drivers for e-learning
Retailer Levi Strauss developed an e-
learning programme to maximise store
sales and customer experience.
They aimed to reduce costs, speed up
induction times and the effectiveness of
new starters, augment manager-led in-
store coaching, provide a consistent
message across all countries, and
encourage key behaviours such as
consultative selling and up-selling.
They were fighting a perception that
e-learning would be boring and had
limited internet bandwidth.
15
Measurable benefits
They designed the course to fit Levi's
brand and culture. They minimised
theory and focused on what really
happens at the 'front line'. They used
learning games and inventive forms of
interaction.
1765 employees across 13 countries and
in 9 languages completed the course at a
cost per student of just £16. 82% of
learners found the course enjoyable.
78% of store managers believed it
helped the team to improve knowledge.
16
Case study: Retail induction at Levi Strauss
Case study: Financial systems training at Compass
Measurable benefits
Compass Group is the world's leading
provider of food and support
services, with 90,000 employees
operating in 7000 locations. They needed
to get operations managers up to speed
with the financial systems they use daily.
They were aiming for a training time of 4
hours to replace a 2 day workshop, to
be taken in 45 minute chunks that could
fit around the working day.
They focused only on what was relevant
on the job and used a strategy of
problem-based learning.
17
18
Case study: Financial systems training at Compass
Case study: Professional qualifications online
Richly-blended distance learning
The IPA is the UK's pre-eminent
professional body for those working in
advertising, media and marketing. Some
56% of IPA members requested access
to online distance learning. The IPA
wanted to make their members more
professional and profitable and to extend
their reach internationally.
They developed a richly-blended
solution, including e-
learning, assignments, videos and
quizzes. In addition, the LMS provided
access to tutor support and online
discussions.
19
20
Case study: Professional qualifications online
So, be honest, is e-learning really effective?
Clive Shepherd
clives@onlignment.com
www.onlignment.com
http://clive-shepherd.blogspot.com
@cliveshepherd

So is e learning effective

  • 1.
    So, be honest,is e-learning really effective? Clive Shepherd
  • 2.
    What does effectivemean when we’re talking about training? People like it and would recommend it to their colleagues There is evidence that learning has taken place in line with the learning objectives There is evidence that the learning has been translated into changed behaviour There is evidence that this change in behaviour has resulted in improved business performance This change in performance was worth the money spent on the training
  • 3.
    Learning methods aretimeless case studies quizzes simulation role-play demonstrations group instruction on-job instruction coaching briefings games feedback reading lectures discussioncollaboration work experienceprojects visits Q&A researchreflection networking observation consultation sharing performance support exploration group projects surveys GROUP ONE-TO-ONE SELF-STUDY
  • 4.
    books CDs streaming video/ screencasts e-books interactive materials DVDs 3D worlds instant messaging email forums social networks wikis web conferencing blogs telephone teleconferencing SMS downloaded docs on-job classroom Twitter FACE-TO-FACE OFFLINE ONLINE TELEPHONIC Learning media are evolving rapidly podcasts tapes mobile internet
  • 5.
    Does the mediumyou use for training make such a big impact on effectiveness? The No Significant Difference Phenomenon by Thomas L Russell, IDECC, 2001 The comparative effectiveness of web‐based and classroom instruction: A meta‐analysis by T Sitzmann, K Kraiger, D Stewart, R Wisher, Personnel Psychology 59, 2006
  • 6.
    How does self-studyadd value? What are its limitations? + Self-paced Accessible in small chunks Available on demand Allows time for reflection Puts you in control Leaves the learner isolated Requires self-discipline - Not always self-sufficient
  • 7.
    Why is e-learningsuch a powerful option for self-study? Multimedia a
  • 8.
    Why is e-learningsuch a powerful option for self-study? Multimedia a Interactivitya
  • 9.
    Why is e-learningsuch a powerful option for self-study? Multimedia a Interactivitya Speed
  • 10.
    Why is e-learningsuch a powerful option for self-study? Multimedia a Interactivitya Speed Connectivity
  • 11.
    Why is e-learningsuch a powerful option for self-study?
  • 12.
    What does ‘good'e-learning look like? E-learning is a good choice of medium for this topicThe content is directly relevant to real-work problemsThe learner is emotionally engaged Lots of storytelling at the expense of abstract rules and conceptsPictures and videos rather than words Lots of challenging, relevant interactivity Organised into small chunks
  • 13.
    What positive resultscan e-learning bring? 47% volume increas e 69% report reduced time to competen cy 59% able to implement changes faster Towards Maturity Impact
  • 14.
    Case study: Leadershipdevelopment at British Airways Blended leadership development British Airways were looking for a fast, cost-effective, scalable, flexible and engaging new approach to the development of 1000 leaders. They developed a blended solution that included a 350 degree self-awareness tool, custom online learning, a two-day workshop and tasks for embedding the learning in the workplace. After just six months, 73% of line managers and their peers reported that they had already seen major changes in the way they were working. 14
  • 15.
    Case study: Retailinduction at Levi Strauss Drivers for e-learning Retailer Levi Strauss developed an e- learning programme to maximise store sales and customer experience. They aimed to reduce costs, speed up induction times and the effectiveness of new starters, augment manager-led in- store coaching, provide a consistent message across all countries, and encourage key behaviours such as consultative selling and up-selling. They were fighting a perception that e-learning would be boring and had limited internet bandwidth. 15
  • 16.
    Measurable benefits They designedthe course to fit Levi's brand and culture. They minimised theory and focused on what really happens at the 'front line'. They used learning games and inventive forms of interaction. 1765 employees across 13 countries and in 9 languages completed the course at a cost per student of just £16. 82% of learners found the course enjoyable. 78% of store managers believed it helped the team to improve knowledge. 16 Case study: Retail induction at Levi Strauss
  • 17.
    Case study: Financialsystems training at Compass Measurable benefits Compass Group is the world's leading provider of food and support services, with 90,000 employees operating in 7000 locations. They needed to get operations managers up to speed with the financial systems they use daily. They were aiming for a training time of 4 hours to replace a 2 day workshop, to be taken in 45 minute chunks that could fit around the working day. They focused only on what was relevant on the job and used a strategy of problem-based learning. 17
  • 18.
    18 Case study: Financialsystems training at Compass
  • 19.
    Case study: Professionalqualifications online Richly-blended distance learning The IPA is the UK's pre-eminent professional body for those working in advertising, media and marketing. Some 56% of IPA members requested access to online distance learning. The IPA wanted to make their members more professional and profitable and to extend their reach internationally. They developed a richly-blended solution, including e- learning, assignments, videos and quizzes. In addition, the LMS provided access to tutor support and online discussions. 19
  • 20.
    20 Case study: Professionalqualifications online
  • 21.
    So, be honest,is e-learning really effective? Clive Shepherd clives@onlignment.com www.onlignment.com http://clive-shepherd.blogspot.com @cliveshepherd