Philippe Lambotte 
Mattel 
9/15/2014 Supply Chain Insights Global Summit #ImagineSC September 2014, p.1
Agenda 
 Our message 
 Triangle Definition 
 Consumer Goods example – Kraft 
 Pharmaceuticals example - Merck 
 Fashion/Toy example – Mattel 
 Putting it all together 
9/15/2014 Supply Chain Insights Global Summit #ImagineSC September 2014, p.2
Supply Chain excellence – it is all about customers 
9/15/2014 Supply Chain Insights Global Summit #ImagineSC September 2014, p.3
Iron Triangle 
Revenue 
Service 
On Time In Full 
Ensure products get to 
store at lowest landed 
cost 
Cost Cash 
Leverage supply chain 
capabilities to drive 
margin and top line 
revenue 
Optimize required 
investments in working 
capital 
9/15/2014 Supply Chain Insights Global Summit #ImagineSC September 2014, p.4
Example Consumer Goods industry 
Service 
Prod_All 
POS WM 
Cs_Shipmts WM 
Cs_Shipmts All 
• Short cycle time 
2 
• High promotional ratio 
• Regional/local supply chain 
• Focus on shelf execution 
250,000 
200,000 
150,000 
100,000 
50,000 
- 
210000187100 7.25Z MAC & CHS 35 
200740 
200741 
200742 
200743 
200744 
200745 
200746 
200747 
200748 
200749 
200750 
200751 
200752 
200801 
200802 
200803 
200804 
200805 
200806 
200807 
200808 
200809 
200810 
200811 
200812 
200813 
200814 
200815 
200816 
200817 
200818 
200819 
200820 
200821 
200822 
200823 
200824 
200825 
200826 
200827 
200828 
200829 
200830 
200831 
200832 
200833 
200834 
200835 
3 week+ reaction 
time 
9/15/2014 Supply Chain Insights Global Summit #ImagineSC September 2014, p.5
Example Pharmaceutical industry 
Revenue 
• Patent cycle/peak and cliff 
• High compliance management 
• High and complex technologies 
• 6 months - 3 year long supply 
chains 
Finished Goods 
Inventory coverage 
73.0 
30.0 
Days 
Drugs Food 
-58% 
Service level % 
97.5 98.0 
Drugs Food 
9/15/2014 Supply Chain Insights Global Summit #ImagineSC September 2014, p.6 
Source: Industry Census of Manufacturers, 2001
Example Fashion/Toy industry 
2500 
2000 
1500 
1000 
500 
0 
Manufacturing production phasing 
Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec 
Inventory 
• Huge Seasonality (Big 6) 
• Placing bets 
• Immediate write off after season 
• 1-3 month long supply chains 
9/15/2014 Supply Chain Insights Global Summit #ImagineSC September 2014, p.7
Putting it all together 
 Need to understand which corner of the iron 
triangle is most critical for your business 
 Educate your organization to understand trade 
offs and be deliberate about them 
 Keep two corners stable while driving the third 
one 
 Don’t wait for crisis to happen 
9/15/2014 Supply Chain Insights Global Summit #ImagineSC September 2014, p.8

Managing the Iron Triangle

  • 1.
    Philippe Lambotte Mattel 9/15/2014 Supply Chain Insights Global Summit #ImagineSC September 2014, p.1
  • 2.
    Agenda  Ourmessage  Triangle Definition  Consumer Goods example – Kraft  Pharmaceuticals example - Merck  Fashion/Toy example – Mattel  Putting it all together 9/15/2014 Supply Chain Insights Global Summit #ImagineSC September 2014, p.2
  • 3.
    Supply Chain excellence– it is all about customers 9/15/2014 Supply Chain Insights Global Summit #ImagineSC September 2014, p.3
  • 4.
    Iron Triangle Revenue Service On Time In Full Ensure products get to store at lowest landed cost Cost Cash Leverage supply chain capabilities to drive margin and top line revenue Optimize required investments in working capital 9/15/2014 Supply Chain Insights Global Summit #ImagineSC September 2014, p.4
  • 5.
    Example Consumer Goodsindustry Service Prod_All POS WM Cs_Shipmts WM Cs_Shipmts All • Short cycle time 2 • High promotional ratio • Regional/local supply chain • Focus on shelf execution 250,000 200,000 150,000 100,000 50,000 - 210000187100 7.25Z MAC & CHS 35 200740 200741 200742 200743 200744 200745 200746 200747 200748 200749 200750 200751 200752 200801 200802 200803 200804 200805 200806 200807 200808 200809 200810 200811 200812 200813 200814 200815 200816 200817 200818 200819 200820 200821 200822 200823 200824 200825 200826 200827 200828 200829 200830 200831 200832 200833 200834 200835 3 week+ reaction time 9/15/2014 Supply Chain Insights Global Summit #ImagineSC September 2014, p.5
  • 6.
    Example Pharmaceutical industry Revenue • Patent cycle/peak and cliff • High compliance management • High and complex technologies • 6 months - 3 year long supply chains Finished Goods Inventory coverage 73.0 30.0 Days Drugs Food -58% Service level % 97.5 98.0 Drugs Food 9/15/2014 Supply Chain Insights Global Summit #ImagineSC September 2014, p.6 Source: Industry Census of Manufacturers, 2001
  • 7.
    Example Fashion/Toy industry 2500 2000 1500 1000 500 0 Manufacturing production phasing Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec Inventory • Huge Seasonality (Big 6) • Placing bets • Immediate write off after season • 1-3 month long supply chains 9/15/2014 Supply Chain Insights Global Summit #ImagineSC September 2014, p.7
  • 8.
    Putting it alltogether  Need to understand which corner of the iron triangle is most critical for your business  Educate your organization to understand trade offs and be deliberate about them  Keep two corners stable while driving the third one  Don’t wait for crisis to happen 9/15/2014 Supply Chain Insights Global Summit #ImagineSC September 2014, p.8