SlideShare a Scribd company logo
Lauren Nourse
EDU 710
February 4, 2010

Research Article #1 Critique.

The Impact of Homework and Homework Preferences in Ninth Grade Geography
(ED507308)
Schuster, Nicholas C.

The Impact of Homework and Homework Preferences in Ninth Grade Geography
Nicholas C. Schuster
University of Wisconsin–La Crosse
November 5, 2009


Educational issue being researched.: Effectiveness of homework and type
of homework on quiz scores in ninth grade geography

Research hypothesis, question or area of inquiry. RQ1: What was the impact on
quiz scores from assigning homework as opposed to not assigning homework?
RQ2: How did the gap between students’ preferred homework conditions and actual
homework conditions impact homework completion rates?
RQ3: How did the gap between students’ preferred homework conditions and actual
homework conditions impact quiz scores?

Dependent variable(s) (if applicable.). Chapter Quizzes

Independent variable(s). (if applicable).

Where does the research take place and who were the participants? ninth-
grade geography students from a Midwestern, suburban public high school.

How were data collected? Data collected over a 2 week period in a
classroom situation with correlation to homework. Who collected it? The
author/teacher

How was the data analyzed? Broken down by multiple factors: homework
versus no-homework; When;Where;Lighting;Study space or
surface;Music;Television;Noise level;Eating
What were the results of the study? inconclusive relationship between a) homework
and quiz scores, b) homework preferences and homework completion, and c) homework
preferences and quiz scores

Critique of the design and methodology of the study. Evaluation of the
methodology section.

      Were the clients adequately described? Please explain. Clients were
well defined and adequately described. Number of students per ethnicity
and academic achievement levels was given in detail.

     Was the setting adequately described? Please explain. Setting
adequately described.

       Was the research design appropriate? Please explain. Research
clearly presented. The writer’s thoughts concerning confusions in the
research were adequately delineated and explained.

     Were the dependent variable (s) and independent variables (s)
adequately described? Please explain.

More Related Content

What's hot

Research proposal defense-powerpoint-
Research proposal defense-powerpoint-Research proposal defense-powerpoint-
Research proposal defense-powerpoint-
sanimuhammad001
 
Nick
NickNick
Proposal
ProposalProposal
Proposal
jlps0601
 
Abstract edit
Abstract editAbstract edit
Abstract edit
jennilynbalbalosa
 
Chapter 3
Chapter 3Chapter 3
Chapter 3
Nadine Guevarra
 
Dissertation defense power point
Dissertation defense power pointDissertation defense power point
Dissertation defense power point
Kelly Dodson
 
Thesis presentation (proposal)
Thesis presentation (proposal)Thesis presentation (proposal)
Thesis presentation (proposal)
Jay Aspero
 
Chapter iii
Chapter iiiChapter iii
Oral defense presentation_Ennis Brinson
Oral defense presentation_Ennis BrinsonOral defense presentation_Ennis Brinson
Oral defense presentation_Ennis Brinson
Ennis Brinson
 
Abstract
AbstractAbstract
Proposal Defense Power Point
Proposal Defense Power PointProposal Defense Power Point
Proposal Defense Power Point
jamathompson
 
Dissertation defense ppt
Dissertation defense ppt Dissertation defense ppt
Dissertation defense ppt
Dr. James Lake
 
Chapter 1 done editing
Chapter 1 done editingChapter 1 done editing
Chapter 1 done editing
LIEZEL P. DELOS SANTOS
 
Dissertation Proposal Defense
Dissertation Proposal DefenseDissertation Proposal Defense
Dissertation Proposal Defense
Shajaira Lopez
 
Action Research Y R I B A R R E N R
Action Research Y R I B A R R E N RAction Research Y R I B A R R E N R
Action Research Y R I B A R R E N R
CSU Fresno
 
Debbie watkin realms, achievement
Debbie watkin   realms, achievementDebbie watkin   realms, achievement
Debbie watkin realms, achievement
guest2b32b2e
 
Comparative and non comparative study
Comparative and non comparative studyComparative and non comparative study
Comparative and non comparative study
alkaabi922
 
Reliability acknowledgement statistical tools and analytical scheme
Reliability acknowledgement statistical tools and analytical schemeReliability acknowledgement statistical tools and analytical scheme
Reliability acknowledgement statistical tools and analytical scheme
Rone Ryan Desierto
 
Manelyn L. Mananap Thesis (Chapter 3)
Manelyn L. Mananap Thesis (Chapter 3)Manelyn L. Mananap Thesis (Chapter 3)
Manelyn L. Mananap Thesis (Chapter 3)
mtlobrido
 
thesis PPT Assessment methods used by english teachers in assisting under ach...
thesis PPT Assessment methods used by english teachers in assisting under ach...thesis PPT Assessment methods used by english teachers in assisting under ach...
thesis PPT Assessment methods used by english teachers in assisting under ach...
Liezyl Nollas
 

What's hot (20)

Research proposal defense-powerpoint-
Research proposal defense-powerpoint-Research proposal defense-powerpoint-
Research proposal defense-powerpoint-
 
Nick
NickNick
Nick
 
Proposal
ProposalProposal
Proposal
 
Abstract edit
Abstract editAbstract edit
Abstract edit
 
Chapter 3
Chapter 3Chapter 3
Chapter 3
 
Dissertation defense power point
Dissertation defense power pointDissertation defense power point
Dissertation defense power point
 
Thesis presentation (proposal)
Thesis presentation (proposal)Thesis presentation (proposal)
Thesis presentation (proposal)
 
Chapter iii
Chapter iiiChapter iii
Chapter iii
 
Oral defense presentation_Ennis Brinson
Oral defense presentation_Ennis BrinsonOral defense presentation_Ennis Brinson
Oral defense presentation_Ennis Brinson
 
Abstract
AbstractAbstract
Abstract
 
Proposal Defense Power Point
Proposal Defense Power PointProposal Defense Power Point
Proposal Defense Power Point
 
Dissertation defense ppt
Dissertation defense ppt Dissertation defense ppt
Dissertation defense ppt
 
Chapter 1 done editing
Chapter 1 done editingChapter 1 done editing
Chapter 1 done editing
 
Dissertation Proposal Defense
Dissertation Proposal DefenseDissertation Proposal Defense
Dissertation Proposal Defense
 
Action Research Y R I B A R R E N R
Action Research Y R I B A R R E N RAction Research Y R I B A R R E N R
Action Research Y R I B A R R E N R
 
Debbie watkin realms, achievement
Debbie watkin   realms, achievementDebbie watkin   realms, achievement
Debbie watkin realms, achievement
 
Comparative and non comparative study
Comparative and non comparative studyComparative and non comparative study
Comparative and non comparative study
 
Reliability acknowledgement statistical tools and analytical scheme
Reliability acknowledgement statistical tools and analytical schemeReliability acknowledgement statistical tools and analytical scheme
Reliability acknowledgement statistical tools and analytical scheme
 
Manelyn L. Mananap Thesis (Chapter 3)
Manelyn L. Mananap Thesis (Chapter 3)Manelyn L. Mananap Thesis (Chapter 3)
Manelyn L. Mananap Thesis (Chapter 3)
 
thesis PPT Assessment methods used by english teachers in assisting under ach...
thesis PPT Assessment methods used by english teachers in assisting under ach...thesis PPT Assessment methods used by english teachers in assisting under ach...
thesis PPT Assessment methods used by english teachers in assisting under ach...
 

Viewers also liked

Diversity Article
Diversity ArticleDiversity Article
Diversity Article
R. Kimberly Grigsby
 
TechEdge article - Creativity
TechEdge article - CreativityTechEdge article - Creativity
TechEdge article - Creativity
Lisa Marie Gonzales, Ed.D.
 
Diversity article
Diversity articleDiversity article
Diversity article
Hemang Jauhari
 
Hea workshop on using social media in learning and teaching
Hea workshop on using social media in learning and teachingHea workshop on using social media in learning and teaching
Hea workshop on using social media in learning and teaching
Claudia Megele
 
Article review-Creativity in Digital Art Education Teaching Practices
Article review-Creativity in Digital Art Education Teaching PracticesArticle review-Creativity in Digital Art Education Teaching Practices
Article review-Creativity in Digital Art Education Teaching Practices
fatinismail89
 
Article critique etec500
Article critique etec500Article critique etec500
Article critique etec500
Sarah Richer
 

Viewers also liked (6)

Diversity Article
Diversity ArticleDiversity Article
Diversity Article
 
TechEdge article - Creativity
TechEdge article - CreativityTechEdge article - Creativity
TechEdge article - Creativity
 
Diversity article
Diversity articleDiversity article
Diversity article
 
Hea workshop on using social media in learning and teaching
Hea workshop on using social media in learning and teachingHea workshop on using social media in learning and teaching
Hea workshop on using social media in learning and teaching
 
Article review-Creativity in Digital Art Education Teaching Practices
Article review-Creativity in Digital Art Education Teaching PracticesArticle review-Creativity in Digital Art Education Teaching Practices
Article review-Creativity in Digital Art Education Teaching Practices
 
Article critique etec500
Article critique etec500Article critique etec500
Article critique etec500
 

Similar to Research article #1

Science Vocabulary Builder Project
Science Vocabulary Builder ProjectScience Vocabulary Builder Project
Science Vocabulary Builder Project
Deb White Groebner
 
learning_environments
learning_environmentslearning_environments
Qualitative-Research-Questions-Grade12..
Qualitative-Research-Questions-Grade12..Qualitative-Research-Questions-Grade12..
Qualitative-Research-Questions-Grade12..
PhilipHarveyBagalano
 
Apa lit review #1
Apa lit review #1Apa lit review #1
Apa lit review #1
lsnourse
 
Apa Lit Review #1
Apa Lit Review #1Apa Lit Review #1
Apa Lit Review #1
lsnourse
 
Lit review outline 3
Lit review outline 3Lit review outline 3
Lit review outline 3
lsnourse
 
Action Research Presentation
Action Research PresentationAction Research Presentation
Action Research Presentation
Amanda Sauer
 
Interpreting formal summative assessments final
Interpreting formal summative assessments finalInterpreting formal summative assessments final
Interpreting formal summative assessments final
Brooke Gevock
 
Final 5 betty
Final  5 bettyFinal  5 betty
Final 5 betty
betty122508
 
Michelle Annette Cloud, PhD Dissertation Defense, Dr. William Allan Kritsonis...
Michelle Annette Cloud, PhD Dissertation Defense, Dr. William Allan Kritsonis...Michelle Annette Cloud, PhD Dissertation Defense, Dr. William Allan Kritsonis...
Michelle Annette Cloud, PhD Dissertation Defense, Dr. William Allan Kritsonis...
William Kritsonis
 
pr2 dll week 1.docx
pr2 dll week 1.docxpr2 dll week 1.docx
pr2 dll week 1.docx
JennyRoseRabang
 
Final 5 betty
Final  5 bettyFinal  5 betty
Final 5 betty
betty122508
 
Final 5 betty
Final  5 bettyFinal  5 betty
Final 5 betty
betty122508
 
A Riccardo Research Presentation
A Riccardo Research PresentationA Riccardo Research Presentation
A Riccardo Research Presentation
ariccardo
 
EDU 710 Lit Rev Outline #2
EDU 710 Lit Rev Outline #2EDU 710 Lit Rev Outline #2
EDU 710 Lit Rev Outline #2
Brandy Shelton
 
NH Next Gen Science Workshop
NH Next Gen Science Workshop NH Next Gen Science Workshop
NH Next Gen Science Workshop
OPEN NH / NH e-Learning for Educators
 
Reference and Research: Meeting the Benchmarks
Reference and Research: Meeting the BenchmarksReference and Research: Meeting the Benchmarks
Reference and Research: Meeting the Benchmarks
satlas331
 
Speaking assessment test
Speaking assessment testSpeaking assessment test
Speaking assessment test
makarenasanchez
 
Jenest poster
Jenest posterJenest poster
Jenest poster
Andrea Jenest
 
STUDY HABITS AND ACADEMIC ACHIEVEMENT OF NINTH STANDARD STUDENTS
STUDY HABITS AND ACADEMIC ACHIEVEMENT OF NINTH STANDARD STUDENTSSTUDY HABITS AND ACADEMIC ACHIEVEMENT OF NINTH STANDARD STUDENTS
STUDY HABITS AND ACADEMIC ACHIEVEMENT OF NINTH STANDARD STUDENTS
Thiyagu K
 

Similar to Research article #1 (20)

Science Vocabulary Builder Project
Science Vocabulary Builder ProjectScience Vocabulary Builder Project
Science Vocabulary Builder Project
 
learning_environments
learning_environmentslearning_environments
learning_environments
 
Qualitative-Research-Questions-Grade12..
Qualitative-Research-Questions-Grade12..Qualitative-Research-Questions-Grade12..
Qualitative-Research-Questions-Grade12..
 
Apa lit review #1
Apa lit review #1Apa lit review #1
Apa lit review #1
 
Apa Lit Review #1
Apa Lit Review #1Apa Lit Review #1
Apa Lit Review #1
 
Lit review outline 3
Lit review outline 3Lit review outline 3
Lit review outline 3
 
Action Research Presentation
Action Research PresentationAction Research Presentation
Action Research Presentation
 
Interpreting formal summative assessments final
Interpreting formal summative assessments finalInterpreting formal summative assessments final
Interpreting formal summative assessments final
 
Final 5 betty
Final  5 bettyFinal  5 betty
Final 5 betty
 
Michelle Annette Cloud, PhD Dissertation Defense, Dr. William Allan Kritsonis...
Michelle Annette Cloud, PhD Dissertation Defense, Dr. William Allan Kritsonis...Michelle Annette Cloud, PhD Dissertation Defense, Dr. William Allan Kritsonis...
Michelle Annette Cloud, PhD Dissertation Defense, Dr. William Allan Kritsonis...
 
pr2 dll week 1.docx
pr2 dll week 1.docxpr2 dll week 1.docx
pr2 dll week 1.docx
 
Final 5 betty
Final  5 bettyFinal  5 betty
Final 5 betty
 
Final 5 betty
Final  5 bettyFinal  5 betty
Final 5 betty
 
A Riccardo Research Presentation
A Riccardo Research PresentationA Riccardo Research Presentation
A Riccardo Research Presentation
 
EDU 710 Lit Rev Outline #2
EDU 710 Lit Rev Outline #2EDU 710 Lit Rev Outline #2
EDU 710 Lit Rev Outline #2
 
NH Next Gen Science Workshop
NH Next Gen Science Workshop NH Next Gen Science Workshop
NH Next Gen Science Workshop
 
Reference and Research: Meeting the Benchmarks
Reference and Research: Meeting the BenchmarksReference and Research: Meeting the Benchmarks
Reference and Research: Meeting the Benchmarks
 
Speaking assessment test
Speaking assessment testSpeaking assessment test
Speaking assessment test
 
Jenest poster
Jenest posterJenest poster
Jenest poster
 
STUDY HABITS AND ACADEMIC ACHIEVEMENT OF NINTH STANDARD STUDENTS
STUDY HABITS AND ACADEMIC ACHIEVEMENT OF NINTH STANDARD STUDENTSSTUDY HABITS AND ACADEMIC ACHIEVEMENT OF NINTH STANDARD STUDENTS
STUDY HABITS AND ACADEMIC ACHIEVEMENT OF NINTH STANDARD STUDENTS
 

More from lsnourse

Wordle wiki word
Wordle wiki wordWordle wiki word
Wordle wiki wordlsnourse
 
Coastal cleanup[1]
Coastal cleanup[1]Coastal cleanup[1]
Coastal cleanup[1]lsnourse
 
Coastal cleanup[1]
Coastal cleanup[1]Coastal cleanup[1]
Coastal cleanup[1]lsnourse
 
Coastal cleanup[1]
Coastal cleanup[1]Coastal cleanup[1]
Coastal cleanup[1]lsnourse
 
Safety picture in word
Safety picture in wordSafety picture in word
Safety picture in wordlsnourse
 
Nourse final paper dec 26
Nourse final paper dec 26Nourse final paper dec 26
Nourse final paper dec 26
lsnourse
 
Nourse20nourse[1]
Nourse20nourse[1]Nourse20nourse[1]
Nourse20nourse[1]
lsnourse
 
Nourse%20ppt%20nourse[1]
Nourse%20ppt%20nourse[1]Nourse%20ppt%20nourse[1]
Nourse%20ppt%20nourse[1]
lsnourse
 
Nourse%20ppt%20nourse[1]
Nourse%20ppt%20nourse[1]Nourse%20ppt%20nourse[1]
Nourse%20ppt%20nourse[1]
lsnourse
 
Chapter 3 only
Chapter 3 onlyChapter 3 only
Chapter 3 only
lsnourse
 
Irb
IrbIrb
Literature table june 26
Literature table june 26Literature table june 26
Literature table june 26
lsnourse
 
Nourse feedback on gerdts paper
Nourse feedback on gerdts paperNourse feedback on gerdts paper
Nourse feedback on gerdts paper
lsnourse
 
Lit review from jeff
Lit review from jeffLit review from jeff
Lit review from jeff
lsnourse
 
Megan feedback
Megan feedbackMegan feedback
Megan feedback
lsnourse
 
Nourse ch 1 and 2 rh pr
Nourse ch 1 and 2 rh prNourse ch 1 and 2 rh pr
Nourse ch 1 and 2 rh pr
lsnourse
 
Literature table june 26
Literature table june 26Literature table june 26
Literature table june 26
lsnourse
 
740 feb 4
740 feb 4740 feb 4
740 feb 4
lsnourse
 
740 feb 18
740 feb 18740 feb 18
740 feb 18
lsnourse
 
741 march 2
741 march 2741 march 2
741 march 2
lsnourse
 

More from lsnourse (20)

Wordle wiki word
Wordle wiki wordWordle wiki word
Wordle wiki word
 
Coastal cleanup[1]
Coastal cleanup[1]Coastal cleanup[1]
Coastal cleanup[1]
 
Coastal cleanup[1]
Coastal cleanup[1]Coastal cleanup[1]
Coastal cleanup[1]
 
Coastal cleanup[1]
Coastal cleanup[1]Coastal cleanup[1]
Coastal cleanup[1]
 
Safety picture in word
Safety picture in wordSafety picture in word
Safety picture in word
 
Nourse final paper dec 26
Nourse final paper dec 26Nourse final paper dec 26
Nourse final paper dec 26
 
Nourse20nourse[1]
Nourse20nourse[1]Nourse20nourse[1]
Nourse20nourse[1]
 
Nourse%20ppt%20nourse[1]
Nourse%20ppt%20nourse[1]Nourse%20ppt%20nourse[1]
Nourse%20ppt%20nourse[1]
 
Nourse%20ppt%20nourse[1]
Nourse%20ppt%20nourse[1]Nourse%20ppt%20nourse[1]
Nourse%20ppt%20nourse[1]
 
Chapter 3 only
Chapter 3 onlyChapter 3 only
Chapter 3 only
 
Irb
IrbIrb
Irb
 
Literature table june 26
Literature table june 26Literature table june 26
Literature table june 26
 
Nourse feedback on gerdts paper
Nourse feedback on gerdts paperNourse feedback on gerdts paper
Nourse feedback on gerdts paper
 
Lit review from jeff
Lit review from jeffLit review from jeff
Lit review from jeff
 
Megan feedback
Megan feedbackMegan feedback
Megan feedback
 
Nourse ch 1 and 2 rh pr
Nourse ch 1 and 2 rh prNourse ch 1 and 2 rh pr
Nourse ch 1 and 2 rh pr
 
Literature table june 26
Literature table june 26Literature table june 26
Literature table june 26
 
740 feb 4
740 feb 4740 feb 4
740 feb 4
 
740 feb 18
740 feb 18740 feb 18
740 feb 18
 
741 march 2
741 march 2741 march 2
741 march 2
 

Research article #1

  • 1. Lauren Nourse EDU 710 February 4, 2010 Research Article #1 Critique. The Impact of Homework and Homework Preferences in Ninth Grade Geography (ED507308) Schuster, Nicholas C. The Impact of Homework and Homework Preferences in Ninth Grade Geography Nicholas C. Schuster University of Wisconsin–La Crosse November 5, 2009 Educational issue being researched.: Effectiveness of homework and type of homework on quiz scores in ninth grade geography Research hypothesis, question or area of inquiry. RQ1: What was the impact on quiz scores from assigning homework as opposed to not assigning homework? RQ2: How did the gap between students’ preferred homework conditions and actual homework conditions impact homework completion rates? RQ3: How did the gap between students’ preferred homework conditions and actual homework conditions impact quiz scores? Dependent variable(s) (if applicable.). Chapter Quizzes Independent variable(s). (if applicable). Where does the research take place and who were the participants? ninth- grade geography students from a Midwestern, suburban public high school. How were data collected? Data collected over a 2 week period in a classroom situation with correlation to homework. Who collected it? The author/teacher How was the data analyzed? Broken down by multiple factors: homework versus no-homework; When;Where;Lighting;Study space or surface;Music;Television;Noise level;Eating
  • 2. What were the results of the study? inconclusive relationship between a) homework and quiz scores, b) homework preferences and homework completion, and c) homework preferences and quiz scores Critique of the design and methodology of the study. Evaluation of the methodology section. Were the clients adequately described? Please explain. Clients were well defined and adequately described. Number of students per ethnicity and academic achievement levels was given in detail. Was the setting adequately described? Please explain. Setting adequately described. Was the research design appropriate? Please explain. Research clearly presented. The writer’s thoughts concerning confusions in the research were adequately delineated and explained. Were the dependent variable (s) and independent variables (s) adequately described? Please explain.