This critique analyzes a research article that studied the impact of homework and homework preferences on quiz scores in a 9th grade geography class. The study examined: 1) The effect of assigning homework versus no homework on quiz scores. 2) The relationship between students' preferred homework conditions and actual conditions on homework completion rates. 3) The relationship between preferred and actual homework conditions on quiz scores. The study found inconclusive relationships between these factors. The critique evaluates the research design and methodology, finding the participants, setting, and variables were adequately described but notes some confusions in the research.