3. POSITIVISM OF IR
STUDIES
3
Objective reality independent from the
observer
Objective laws and rules of relations
among states rational choice is
possible
Realism
Liberalism
4. CRITICAL VIEW ON IR
4
What does critical approach critize?
Not the preceding theories
themselves
But their positivist back ground
IR as both theory and practice are
not independent from the human
who develops concept and makes
decisions
5. GORBACHEV AND THE
TURNING POINT IN IR
5
“Ideological differences should not be
transferred to the sphere of interstate
relations, nor should foreign policy be
subordinate to them …”
Refusal from Cold War geopolitics
Didn’t follow the logic of hard realism
On the one hand, it was a political
decision
On the other hand, it changed global
international relations
6. CONSTRUCTIVIST
APPROACH
6
Alexander Wendt was the “The Father
of Constructivism or Socio-
constructivism”.
“Anarchy is what states make of it:
The social construction of power
politics” (International Organization,
1992)
8. GENDER THEORY
8
Explain how gender factor influenced
international relations:
• From the very early ages IR were
driven by patriarchy
• Nowadays men and women have
more equal rights
• However, the sphere of IR is still
dominated by masculine
doctrines
9. POSTSTRUCTURALISM
9
Try to explain, how existing theories
and approaches push the world in a
certain direction
Focus on discourses in written and
spoken texts, popular culture and
deconstruct the policy through
discourse
11. GEOGRAPHY IS ABOUT
MAKING WAR
11
Yves Lacoste said in “La Geographie, ca
sent, d abroad, a faille la guerre”
(“Geography is first and foremost about
making war”, in 1976)
Geography – a discipline that supported
imperial order overseas
• Geographical knowledge and the
study of of space – socially produce
• The need for a thorough revisionism
within the discipline of geography
12. HOW DEVELOP CRITICAL
GEOPOLITICS?
12
What does critical approach critize?
Not the preceding theories
themselves
But their positivist back ground
IR as both theory and practice are
not independent from the human
who develops concept and makes
decisions
13. GEAROID O TUATHAIL:
TO CONCLUDE …
13
Geopolitics – a problem solving
theory for the conceptualization and
practice of statecraft.
• This is how the world is
• This is what we must do
Critical geopolitics
• How “geopolitics” and the
“geopolitical tradition” have been
textualized with certain meanings
at various times and in various
contexts.
15. GEAROID O TUATHIL ON
MAPPING OF THE
WORLD
15
The influence of geography on foreign
policy because geography has
multiplicity of different meanings
Geography is a historical and social
form of knowledge about the earth.
To consult geography historically
• To view raw physical landscape,
• To read a book
16. GEAROID O TUATHIL ON
MAPPING OF THE
WORLD
16
Geography is social and political geo-
graphing
• Earth writing
• Cultural and political writing of
meanings about the world
Geopolitics writing of geographical
meanings and politics of states
17. HUMAN FACTOR IN
MAPPING THE WORLD
17
Mapping developed alongside with
emergence of traditional geopolitics
One of the ways to divide the world
into “us” and “them”
Several methods of drawing maps of
the world
Each method could not be
distinguished from the person that
used it
18. CRITICIZING OTHER
“HUMAN FACTORS” IN
GEOPOLITICS
18
Geopolitics – a bourgeois ideology
Geographical materialism is
reduced to an intellectual weapon of
the bourgeois revolution and
worldwide imperialism
Geopolitics – a spatial exclusion
The ideological dimension in how
this is justified and explained and
understood by the population; the
”other” is seen as different if not an
enemy