Maximizing Training ROI
Through High-Impact Learning

                        …A Case Study
                 HR.com          Gus Prestera, PhD
Technology Enabled Learning      Learning & Performance Strategist
          11:00 am, Eastern      gus@presterafx.com
               June 6, 2012      www.presterafx.com
Housekeeping
• Use “Question” area to submit questions
• Use “Raise Hand” to respond to quick polls
• Will address questions at the end
War of Attrition
100%
90%    Training

80%               Self
                  Study
                          License
70%                       Exams

60%
50%                                 No Man’s                                Attrition
                                      Land
40%                                                                         Retention
30%
                                               On Full
20%                                            Commission


10%
 0%
   Hired >Wk6 Mo 3              Mo 6   Mo 9 Mo 12 Mo 15 Mo 18 Mo 21 Mo 24
“Pimp” My Curriculum

Spray & Pray Approach                  High Impact Approach
                        More sticky
• Sage-on-the-Stage                    • Blended delivery
• Class size: 150-250                  • Lean content
• 10-hour days                         • Practice/context-rich
                        More impact
• 6-Week ILT                           • 17-Week Certification
• Then self-study                      • Then high-impact ILT
                        More quickly
    “Old & Busted”                        “New & Hotness”

                        Less waste
Business Impact
100%
90%    License
       Exams     Training
80%
70%
                            Certifications
60%
                                                           On Full
                            On Partial
50%                         Commission
                                                           Commission             Attrition
40%                                                                               Retention
30%                                     High Impact
                                          Training
20%                                     Focal Point

10%
 0%
   Hired     Wk 6    Mo 3      Mo 6          Mo 9 Mo 12 Mo 15 Mo 18 Mo 21 Mo 24
How did we do it?
Principles | High Impact Learning
                            1.   Share Ownership: Stakeholders must
      Share Ownership
                                 own learning process and outcomes

    Create Accountability   2.   Create Accountability: Without it,
                                 expect no impact
     Prioritize Learners
                            3.   Prioritize Learners: Who produces ROI
      Prioritize Needs
                                 and warrants more investment?

                            4.   Prioritize Needs: Channel resources to
                                 mission-critical needs
          Transfer
            Skills
                            5.   Transfer Skills: Focus on transfer, your
                                 best predictor of individual success
                                 and ROI
1. OWNERSHIP
      Stakeholders must own
the learning process and outcomes
Self-Paced Learning

           Self-Paced
            Learning
                                    1.   E-learning Tutorials
                                    2.   Online Simulations
                                    3.   Online Assessments
                                    4.   Books
                        Authentic
 Action                             5.   Intranet Sites
                         Assess-
Learning                  ment      6.   Internet Sites
                                    7.   Workbooks



           On-The-Job
            Learning
Action Learning

           Self-Paced
            Learning
                                    1. Application Assignments
                                    2. Planning Assignments
                                    3. Job Shadowing
                        Authentic
 Action
                         Assess-
Learning                  ment




           On-The-Job
            Learning
OTJ Learning

           Self-Paced
            Learning
                                      1. Weekly practice sessions
                                      2. Study groups
                                      3. 1:1 Mentoring
                          Authentic
 Action
                           Assess-
Learning                    ment




           On-The-Job
            Learning
Authentic Assessment

           Self-Paced
            Learning
                                    1. 1:1 Manager coaching
                                    2. Knowledge Test
                                    3. Performance Test
                        Authentic
 Action
                         Assess-
Learning                  ment




           On-The-Job
            Learning
2. ACCOUNTABILITY
       Without it,
    expect no impact
Accountability for Results
                Business   Business unit leaders created
                  Unit     MBOs related to head count
                           targets, revenue from new
                           Associates, and ROI



   Associates   Account      Managers
   (Learners)   -ability




                Coaches
Accountability for Results
                Business
                  Unit




   Associates   Account      Managers
   (Learners)   -ability



                           Managers had variable comp tied
                           to Associate-related MBOs, so
                Coaches    their success was tied to the
                           success of their Associates
Accountability for Results
                                    Business
                                      Unit




                      Associates    Account    Managers
                      (Learners)    -ability



Coaches were compensated and
recognized…coaching success
evaluated as part of their career   Coaches
development
Accountability for Results

Associates Failure to pass         Business
                                     Unit
certification exams and
performance assessments
grounds for termination



                      Associates   Account    Managers
                      (Learners)   -ability




                                   Coaches
3. PRIORITIZE LEARNERS
     Who produces ROI and
    warrants more investment?
Investing in the High Potentials
                                                   Phase 3:
                                              Individualized
                                           “Establishing a
                                         Complete Practice”
                     Phase 2:
                  High-Impact
                “Growing the                       Year
                                                               $ Star
                   Business”                       One

                                           $
                                                                 Performers
                                               Licensed
  Phase 1:
                           Month 3
                         Certification
                                               and
Certification                                  Certified
 “Getting           $
  Started”              New Hire
                        Associates                                   Bad hires and
                                                                    low performers
                                                                          wash out
4. PRIORITIZE NEEDS
  Channel your resources to
    mission-critical needs
How do you prioritize needs?

                               Skill Complexity
Skill Importance


                          low               high


                   low     1                  3
                                                     Throw the
                                                   kitchen sink at
                                                         it!
                   high    2                  4
Let’s look at an example of how the savings were spent.…
5. TRANSFER SKILLS
Focus on transfer, your best predictor
   of individual success and ROI
The Learning Process
            How do we support learning over time?




              Knowledge                                                       Skill
               Building                                                     Fluency
Awareness                   Skill                             Skill
 Building                  Mastery                          Transfer




                                     Barriers to Transfer
                Skill                                                        Skill
               Building                                                     Refresh



                                                                       Prestera & Marker, 2006




                                                                                           31
Performance Engineering Model
                   Information            Resources            Incentives
                 • Clear                • Materials, tools   • Financial rewards
Organizational   expectations
                                        • Time               •
   Factors       • Relevant                                  Recognition, prais
                                        • Working
                 feedback                                    e
                                        conditions
                 • Clear instructions                        • Positive work
                                                             environment



                   Knowledge                Capacity           Motivation
                 • Know-how             • …to learn          • …to learn

  Individual     • Skills               • …to perform        • …to perform
   Factors       • Fluency              • …to improve        • …to improve




                                                                     Gilbert, 1970
                                                                     Human Competence
Performance Solutions
                    Information               Resources                Incentives
                  • Clear                  • Materials, tools       • Financial rewards
                  expectations
• Clarify expectations           • Provide resources
                                           • Time                    •
                                                                • Incentivize performance
• Provide feedback• Relevant     • Improve tools                     Recognition, prais
                                                                • Recognize performance
                                           • Working
                  feedback
• Provide instructions           • Ergonomics                        e
                                                                • Cultural change
                                           conditions
                  • Clear instructions                              • Positive work




                    Knowledge                  Capacity                Motivation
                  • Know-how               • …to learn              • …to learn
                                 • Simplify • …to perform
                                            work                • Coach perform
                                                                     • …to
• Formal learning• Skills
                                 • Development                  • Hold accountable
• Informal learningFluency
                  •                         • …to improve            • …to improve
                                 • Hire/Replace                 • Hire/Replace
What does it take to succeed?

Generate 30 new leads per week


Hold 5 appointments per week with qualified leads


Spend at least 6 hours per day on prospecting



                            $150,000
                      in new assets per week
Wrapping up….
Questions?
                                            1.   Share Ownership: Stakeholders must
                 Share Ownership
                                                 own learning process and outcomes
More sticky
               Create Accountability        2.   Create Accountability: Without it,
                                                 expect no impact
More impact     Prioritize Learners
                                            3.   Prioritize Learners: Who produces ROI
                 Prioritize Needs
                                                 and warrants more investment?
More quickly
                                            4.   Prioritize Needs: Channel resources to
                                                 mission-critical needs
Less waste           Transfer
                       Skills
                                            5.   Transfer Skills: Focus on transfer, your
                                                 best predictor of individual success
                                                 and ROI
Thank you!
                    Please complete survey

   Maximizing Training ROI
Through High-Impact Learning

                        …A Case Study
                 HR.com            Gus Prestera, PhD
Technology Enabled Learning        Learning & Performance Strategist
          11:00 am, Eastern        gus@presterafx.com
               June 6, 2012        www.presterafx.com

Managing ROI Through Hig-Impact Learning

  • 1.
    Maximizing Training ROI ThroughHigh-Impact Learning …A Case Study HR.com Gus Prestera, PhD Technology Enabled Learning Learning & Performance Strategist 11:00 am, Eastern gus@presterafx.com June 6, 2012 www.presterafx.com
  • 2.
    Housekeeping • Use “Question”area to submit questions • Use “Raise Hand” to respond to quick polls • Will address questions at the end
  • 3.
    War of Attrition 100% 90% Training 80% Self Study License 70% Exams 60% 50% No Man’s Attrition Land 40% Retention 30% On Full 20% Commission 10% 0% Hired >Wk6 Mo 3 Mo 6 Mo 9 Mo 12 Mo 15 Mo 18 Mo 21 Mo 24
  • 4.
    “Pimp” My Curriculum Spray& Pray Approach High Impact Approach More sticky • Sage-on-the-Stage • Blended delivery • Class size: 150-250 • Lean content • 10-hour days • Practice/context-rich More impact • 6-Week ILT • 17-Week Certification • Then self-study • Then high-impact ILT More quickly “Old & Busted” “New & Hotness” Less waste
  • 5.
    Business Impact 100% 90% License Exams Training 80% 70% Certifications 60% On Full On Partial 50% Commission Commission Attrition 40% Retention 30% High Impact Training 20% Focal Point 10% 0% Hired Wk 6 Mo 3 Mo 6 Mo 9 Mo 12 Mo 15 Mo 18 Mo 21 Mo 24
  • 6.
    How did wedo it?
  • 7.
    Principles | HighImpact Learning 1. Share Ownership: Stakeholders must Share Ownership own learning process and outcomes Create Accountability 2. Create Accountability: Without it, expect no impact Prioritize Learners 3. Prioritize Learners: Who produces ROI Prioritize Needs and warrants more investment? 4. Prioritize Needs: Channel resources to mission-critical needs Transfer Skills 5. Transfer Skills: Focus on transfer, your best predictor of individual success and ROI
  • 8.
    1. OWNERSHIP Stakeholders must own the learning process and outcomes
  • 9.
    Self-Paced Learning Self-Paced Learning 1. E-learning Tutorials 2. Online Simulations 3. Online Assessments 4. Books Authentic Action 5. Intranet Sites Assess- Learning ment 6. Internet Sites 7. Workbooks On-The-Job Learning
  • 10.
    Action Learning Self-Paced Learning 1. Application Assignments 2. Planning Assignments 3. Job Shadowing Authentic Action Assess- Learning ment On-The-Job Learning
  • 11.
    OTJ Learning Self-Paced Learning 1. Weekly practice sessions 2. Study groups 3. 1:1 Mentoring Authentic Action Assess- Learning ment On-The-Job Learning
  • 12.
    Authentic Assessment Self-Paced Learning 1. 1:1 Manager coaching 2. Knowledge Test 3. Performance Test Authentic Action Assess- Learning ment On-The-Job Learning
  • 13.
    2. ACCOUNTABILITY Without it, expect no impact
  • 14.
    Accountability for Results Business Business unit leaders created Unit MBOs related to head count targets, revenue from new Associates, and ROI Associates Account Managers (Learners) -ability Coaches
  • 15.
    Accountability for Results Business Unit Associates Account Managers (Learners) -ability Managers had variable comp tied to Associate-related MBOs, so Coaches their success was tied to the success of their Associates
  • 16.
    Accountability for Results Business Unit Associates Account Managers (Learners) -ability Coaches were compensated and recognized…coaching success evaluated as part of their career Coaches development
  • 17.
    Accountability for Results AssociatesFailure to pass Business Unit certification exams and performance assessments grounds for termination Associates Account Managers (Learners) -ability Coaches
  • 18.
    3. PRIORITIZE LEARNERS Who produces ROI and warrants more investment?
  • 19.
    Investing in theHigh Potentials Phase 3: Individualized “Establishing a Complete Practice” Phase 2: High-Impact “Growing the Year $ Star Business” One $ Performers Licensed Phase 1: Month 3 Certification and Certification Certified “Getting $ Started” New Hire Associates Bad hires and low performers wash out
  • 20.
    4. PRIORITIZE NEEDS Channel your resources to mission-critical needs
  • 21.
    How do youprioritize needs? Skill Complexity Skill Importance low high low 1 3 Throw the kitchen sink at it! high 2 4
  • 22.
    Let’s look atan example of how the savings were spent.…
  • 29.
    5. TRANSFER SKILLS Focuson transfer, your best predictor of individual success and ROI
  • 30.
    The Learning Process How do we support learning over time? Knowledge Skill Building Fluency Awareness Skill Skill Building Mastery Transfer Barriers to Transfer Skill Skill Building Refresh Prestera & Marker, 2006 31
  • 31.
    Performance Engineering Model Information Resources Incentives • Clear • Materials, tools • Financial rewards Organizational expectations • Time • Factors • Relevant Recognition, prais • Working feedback e conditions • Clear instructions • Positive work environment Knowledge Capacity Motivation • Know-how • …to learn • …to learn Individual • Skills • …to perform • …to perform Factors • Fluency • …to improve • …to improve Gilbert, 1970 Human Competence
  • 32.
    Performance Solutions Information Resources Incentives • Clear • Materials, tools • Financial rewards expectations • Clarify expectations • Provide resources • Time • • Incentivize performance • Provide feedback• Relevant • Improve tools Recognition, prais • Recognize performance • Working feedback • Provide instructions • Ergonomics e • Cultural change conditions • Clear instructions • Positive work Knowledge Capacity Motivation • Know-how • …to learn • …to learn • Simplify • …to perform work • Coach perform • …to • Formal learning• Skills • Development • Hold accountable • Informal learningFluency • • …to improve • …to improve • Hire/Replace • Hire/Replace
  • 33.
    What does ittake to succeed? Generate 30 new leads per week Hold 5 appointments per week with qualified leads Spend at least 6 hours per day on prospecting $150,000 in new assets per week
  • 34.
  • 35.
    Questions? 1. Share Ownership: Stakeholders must Share Ownership own learning process and outcomes More sticky Create Accountability 2. Create Accountability: Without it, expect no impact More impact Prioritize Learners 3. Prioritize Learners: Who produces ROI Prioritize Needs and warrants more investment? More quickly 4. Prioritize Needs: Channel resources to mission-critical needs Less waste Transfer Skills 5. Transfer Skills: Focus on transfer, your best predictor of individual success and ROI
  • 36.
    Thank you! Please complete survey Maximizing Training ROI Through High-Impact Learning …A Case Study HR.com Gus Prestera, PhD Technology Enabled Learning Learning & Performance Strategist 11:00 am, Eastern gus@presterafx.com June 6, 2012 www.presterafx.com

Editor's Notes

  • #2 Maximizing Training ROI Through High-Impact Learning: A Case StudyDoes your enterprise learning organization spend large amounts of money on training with little apparent effect on business results? That’s not unusual. Training dollars are often spent on knowledge transfer rather than performance support, when the latter has a stronger correlation with improved organizational effectiveness. Training dollars are often spent on infrastructure that is poorly architected and content that is poorly designed, so asset utilization rates are generally low. Training dollars are often not linked to core business results in any serious manner with true accountability and consequences in place to back up an organizational commitment to learning. These dysfunctions are commonplace, yet there are exceptions, and we can learn from them. I’ll share with you some ways to combat low training ROI, leveraging a recent case study. A global financial services firm with a national network of brokerage offices housing more than 10,000 Financial Advisors found that it was spending too much on Associate on-boarding while yielding a poor return on investment.  The on-boarding program was costly yet ineffective, because it relied completely on classroom training, was poorly designed and developed, lacked management support, and took too long to complete.  In this webinar, we’ll discuss how the curriculum was re-designed to make better use of technology and to drive performance outcomes more quickly and cost-effectively. Specifically, we’ll discuss how the team leveraged High Impact Learning principles to prioritize learning needs and concentrate training resources on the places where it would have the greatest impact on organizational performance. By picking their battles wisely, making practical use of technology, and investing in high-impact training where it could do the most good as well as high-efficiency training where it couldn’t, they maximized ROI for their organization. Short Description: Does your organization spend large amounts of money on training with little apparent effect on business results? That’s not unusual, but I’ll share with you some ways to combat low training ROI, leveraging a recent case study. Specifically, we’ll discuss how the team leveraged High Impact Learning principles to prioritize learning needs and concentrate training resources on the places where it would have the greatest impact on organizational performance. By picking their battles wisely, making practical use of technology, and investing in high-impact training where it could do the most good as well as high-efficiency training where it couldn’t, they maximized ROI for their organization. 3 Things You Will Learn: After attending this session, you will learn:How to prioritize enterprise learning needs effectivelyTechniques for driving business results and creating ROITechniques for managing costs to maximize ROI
  • #20 By doing this, we are able to reinvest some of the savings from phase 1 into phases 2 and 3, where the ROI was going to be greater.