Pakistan International Airlines has struggled to implement an effective performance management system, changing it three times in the last decade. The Forced Distribution Rating System (FDRS) failed due to several factors. FDRS requires comparing employees against each other, but PIA lacks job analysis and competitive culture. Additionally, political influence, subjective appraisals, inflated ratings, and inadequate pay grade comparisons undermined the system. Recommendations include revising metrics, separating complaint tracking, specialized training, and reducing political involvement to implement a revised bell curve system successfully.
PIA - Pakistan International Airlines Strategic Reportmegasheeki
Presentation contains the strategic report for PIA including the growth rate and SWOT.
Best for Business Management and Strategic Management's Students.
This word file contains the detailed analysis of Pakistan's Airline Industry with perspective to Marketing Concepts such as SWOT Analysis, BCG Matrix, Porter's Generic Strategies and Pest Analysis. The report also contains the Marketing plan for Serene Air International.
PIA - Pakistan International Airlines Strategic Reportmegasheeki
Presentation contains the strategic report for PIA including the growth rate and SWOT.
Best for Business Management and Strategic Management's Students.
This word file contains the detailed analysis of Pakistan's Airline Industry with perspective to Marketing Concepts such as SWOT Analysis, BCG Matrix, Porter's Generic Strategies and Pest Analysis. The report also contains the Marketing plan for Serene Air International.
This analysis is done according to the Marketing concepts.First, It includes analysis of airline industry of Pakistan through BCG Matrix, PEST analysis, Porter Generic Strategies, SWOT Analysis. Secondly, it contains a marketing plan as well elaborating only its analysis.
This Presentation belongs to Students who worked on their own research and tried to collect sufficient data for Management presentation.
This presentation contain detailed information for PIA.
All the data present is only for Education purpose.
Prepared by
Hassan Raza
Saad Shaukat
and few other members of group.
This analysis is done according to the Marketing concepts.First, It includes analysis of airline industry of Pakistan through BCG Matrix, PEST analysis, Porter Generic Strategies, SWOT Analysis. Secondly, it contains a marketing plan as well elaborating only its analysis.
This Presentation belongs to Students who worked on their own research and tried to collect sufficient data for Management presentation.
This presentation contain detailed information for PIA.
All the data present is only for Education purpose.
Prepared by
Hassan Raza
Saad Shaukat
and few other members of group.
Hello Guys, The report that i have submitted was prepared by me along with my group members during my 6 weeks Intership @ PIA in 2010. we were given a project of conduting a surey at Jinnah Terminal's international departure lounge from passengers to know the reasons behind PIA's downfall.
Company Profile:
Pakistan International Airlines Corporation, more commonly known as Pakistan International Airlines or PIA is the flag carrier airline of Pakistan
Pakistan-based company -------- engaged in the provision of air transport services.
Other activities -------- provision of engineering and other allied services.
The Company operates in two business segments------- airlines operation and hotel operation.
History (Emphasis on Resources and Achievement):
On 23rd October 1946, a new airline was born Orient Airways Ltd. had at its helm Mr. M.A. Ispahani as Chairman.
Operating license was obtained in May 1947.
Orient Airways was a privately owned company, with limited capital and resources. It could not be expected to grow and expand independently. It was then that the Government of Pakistan decided to form a state-owned airline and invited Orient Airways to merge with it.
The outcome of the merger was the birth of a new airline, through PIAC Ordinance 1955 on January 10, 1955.
On 07 June 1954 PIA’s first flit linking b/w Karachi - - - - Dacca (Dhaka).
01 Feb 1955; PIA’s first International flit linking b/w Karachi - - - - London via Cairo.
Titled First Asian Airline with Pure-jet aircraft, by acquiescent Boeing 707-321 machine form PAN American World Airways in 07 March 1960. & extended London to New York
Meanwhile First time Helicopter services ran with Sikorsky S-61N.
OPSWAT CEO, Benny Czarny discusses the data security challenge. How can organizations determine whether data is helpful or harmful? How can they create good security policies based on this information? How can this be accomplished while making sure all users can access the tools and information they need to accomplish their goals?
In this file, you can ref useful information about balanced scorecard performance appraisal such as balanced scorecard performance appraisal methods, balanced scorecard performance appraisal tips
In this file, you can ref useful information about performance appraisal form of wipro such as performance appraisal form of wipro methods, performance appraisal form of wipro tips
In this file, you can ref useful information about importance of performance appraisal such as importance of performance appraisal methods, importance of performance appraisal tips, importance of performance appraisal forms, importance of performance appraisal phrases … If you need more assistant for importance of performance appraisal, please leave your comment at the end of file.
In this file, you can ref useful information about performance appraisal assignment such as performance appraisal assignment methods, performance appraisal assignment tips, performance appraisal assignment forms, performance appraisal assignment phrases … If you need more assistant for performance appraisal assignment, please leave your comment at the end of file.
In this file, you can ref useful information about performance appraisal system example such as performance appraisal system example methods, performance appraisal system example tips, performance appraisal system example forms, performance appraisal system example phrases … If you need more assistant for performance appraisal system example, please leave your comment at the end of file.
In this file, you can ref useful information about performance appraisal statistics such as performance appraisal statistics methods, performance appraisal statistics tips, performance appraisal statistics forms
Effectiveness of performance appraisal systembarnesali609
In this file, you can ref useful information about effectiveness of performance appraisal system such as effectiveness of performance appraisal system methods, effectiveness of performance appraisal system tips, effectiveness of performance appraisal system forms, effectiveness of performance appraisal system phrases … If you need more assistant for effectiveness of performance appraisal system, please leave your comment at the end of file.
In this file, you can ref useful information about performance appraisal journal such as performance appraisal journal methods, performance appraisal journal tips, performance appraisal journal forms, performance appraisal journal phrases … If you need more assistant for performance appraisal journal, please leave your comment at the end of file.
In this file, you can ref useful information about appraisal of performance such as appraisal of performance methods, appraisal of performance tips, appraisal of performance forms, appraisal of performance phrases … If you need more assistant for appraisal of performance, please leave your comment at the end of file.
In this file, you can ref useful information about performance management and appraisal system such as performance management and appraisal system methods, performance management and appraisal system tips, performance management and appraisal system forms, performance management and appraisal system phrases … If you need more assistant for performance management and appraisal system, please leave your comment at the end of file.
Performance appraisal of 5 companies done by shweta-bebartaShweta Bebarta
It is a PPT which describes briefly about Performance appraisal process of 5 companies. they are - TCS, GENERAL ELECTRIC, SAP, BIG BAZAAR and TITAN. These 5 companies, which process they have adopted for appraisal and why it is good for the company?
In this file, you can ref useful information about introduction of performance appraisal such as introduction of performance appraisal methods, introduction of performance appraisal tips, introduction of performance appraisal forms, introduction of performance appraisal phrases … If you need more assistant for introduction of performance appraisal, please leave your comment at the end of file.
In this file, you can ref useful information about introduction of performance appraisal such as introduction of performance appraisal methods, introduction of performance appraisal tips
In this file, you can ref useful information about performance appraisal mistakes such as performance appraisal mistakes methods, performance appraisal mistakes tips
Key result areas performance appraisalnanamoore807
In this file, you can ref useful information about key result areas performance appraisal such as key result areas performance appraisal methods, key result areas performance appraisal tips
In this file, you can ref useful information about key result areas performance appraisal such as key result areas performance appraisal methods, key result areas performance appraisal tips, key result areas performance appraisal forms, key result areas performance appraisal phrases … If you need more assistant for key result areas performance appraisal, please leave your comment at the end of file.
In this file, you can ref useful information about performance appraisal instrument such as performance appraisal instrument methods, performance appraisal instrument tips
A cognitive process: lets a person make sense of stimuli from the environment• Affects all senses: sight, touch, taste, smell, hearing• Includes inputs to person and choice of inputs to which the person attends• Stimulus sources: people, events, physical objects, ideas• Helps adaptation to a changing environment
Mudarabah is a special kind of partnership where one partner providers the capital (rabb-ul-maal) to the other (mudarib) for investment in a commercial enterprise.
The global securities market has been constantly evolving over the years to serve the needs of traders. Traders require markets that are liquid, with minimal transaction and delay costs, in addition to transparency and assured completion of the transaction. Based on these core requirements, a handful of securities market structures have become the dominant trade execution structures in the world. In this article, we'll take a look at some of the most popular market structures currently in use.
Securities that are purchased in order to be held for investment. This is in contrast to securities that are purchased by a broker-dealer or other intermediary for resale. Banks often purchase marketable securities to hold in their portfolios.
In the Adani-Hindenburg case, what is SEBI investigating.pptxAdani case
Adani SEBI investigation revealed that the latter had sought information from five foreign jurisdictions concerning the holdings of the firm’s foreign portfolio investors (FPIs) in relation to the alleged violations of the MPS Regulations. Nevertheless, the economic interest of the twelve FPIs based in tax haven jurisdictions still needs to be determined. The Adani Group firms classed these FPIs as public shareholders. According to Hindenburg, FPIs were used to get around regulatory standards.
An introduction to the cryptocurrency investment platform Binance Savings.Any kyc Account
Learn how to use Binance Savings to expand your bitcoin holdings. Discover how to maximize your earnings on one of the most reliable cryptocurrency exchange platforms, as well as how to earn interest on your cryptocurrency holdings and the various savings choices available.
B2B payments are rapidly changing. Find out the 5 key questions you need to be asking yourself to be sure you are mastering B2B payments today. Learn more at www.BlueSnap.com.
Navigating the world of forex trading can be challenging, especially for beginners. To help you make an informed decision, we have comprehensively compared the best forex brokers in India for 2024. This article, reviewed by Top Forex Brokers Review, will cover featured award winners, the best forex brokers, featured offers, the best copy trading platforms, the best forex brokers for beginners, the best MetaTrader brokers, and recently updated reviews. We will focus on FP Markets, Black Bull, EightCap, IC Markets, and Octa.
buy old yahoo accounts buy yahoo accountsSusan Laney
As a business owner, I understand the importance of having a strong online presence and leveraging various digital platforms to reach and engage with your target audience. One often overlooked yet highly valuable asset in this regard is the humble Yahoo account. While many may perceive Yahoo as a relic of the past, the truth is that these accounts still hold immense potential for businesses of all sizes.
Company Valuation webinar series - Tuesday, 4 June 2024FelixPerez547899
This session provided an update as to the latest valuation data in the UK and then delved into a discussion on the upcoming election and the impacts on valuation. We finished, as always with a Q&A
At Techbox Square, in Singapore, we're not just creative web designers and developers, we're the driving force behind your brand identity. Contact us today.
3.0 Project 2_ Developing My Brand Identity Kit.pptxtanyjahb
A personal brand exploration presentation summarizes an individual's unique qualities and goals, covering strengths, values, passions, and target audience. It helps individuals understand what makes them stand out, their desired image, and how they aim to achieve it.
Understanding User Needs and Satisfying ThemAggregage
https://www.productmanagementtoday.com/frs/26903918/understanding-user-needs-and-satisfying-them
We know we want to create products which our customers find to be valuable. Whether we label it as customer-centric or product-led depends on how long we've been doing product management. There are three challenges we face when doing this. The obvious challenge is figuring out what our users need; the non-obvious challenges are in creating a shared understanding of those needs and in sensing if what we're doing is meeting those needs.
In this webinar, we won't focus on the research methods for discovering user-needs. We will focus on synthesis of the needs we discover, communication and alignment tools, and how we operationalize addressing those needs.
Industry expert Scott Sehlhorst will:
• Introduce a taxonomy for user goals with real world examples
• Present the Onion Diagram, a tool for contextualizing task-level goals
• Illustrate how customer journey maps capture activity-level and task-level goals
• Demonstrate the best approach to selection and prioritization of user-goals to address
• Highlight the crucial benchmarks, observable changes, in ensuring fulfillment of customer needs
Premium MEAN Stack Development Solutions for Modern BusinessesSynapseIndia
Stay ahead of the curve with our premium MEAN Stack Development Solutions. Our expert developers utilize MongoDB, Express.js, AngularJS, and Node.js to create modern and responsive web applications. Trust us for cutting-edge solutions that drive your business growth and success.
Know more: https://www.synapseindia.com/technology/mean-stack-development-company.html
Digital Transformation and IT Strategy Toolkit and TemplatesAurelien Domont, MBA
This Digital Transformation and IT Strategy Toolkit was created by ex-McKinsey, Deloitte and BCG Management Consultants, after more than 5,000 hours of work. It is considered the world's best & most comprehensive Digital Transformation and IT Strategy Toolkit. It includes all the Frameworks, Best Practices & Templates required to successfully undertake the Digital Transformation of your organization and define a robust IT Strategy.
Editable Toolkit to help you reuse our content: 700 Powerpoint slides | 35 Excel sheets | 84 minutes of Video training
This PowerPoint presentation is only a small preview of our Toolkits. For more details, visit www.domontconsulting.com
Digital Transformation and IT Strategy Toolkit and Templates
PIA Performance Evaluation System
1.
2. Introduction
Pakistan International Airlines is one the biggest
airline in Pakistan having both National and
International transportation routes across the world.
PIA has been as air travel pioneer since its inception in
1955.
PIA being a national carrier, and a publicly owned
organization, has a culture geared towards
maintaining linkages for the country, creating
employment for the public and presenting national
image to the outside world.
3. Problem Identification
At PIA, since last one decade management has
changed the performance management system thrice.
Firstly they had ACR system, then Forced Distribution
Ratting System (FDRS) also known as Bell Curve
System. Than again is on cross roads to restore the
ACR system.
We have focused on the reasons for the failure of
Forced Distribution Ratting System (FDRS)
4. PERFORMANCE MANAGEMENT
SYSTEM
Effective performance management systems require employees and
supervisors to work together to set performance expectations, review
results, assess organizational and individuals’ needs and plan for the
future.
Feedback
Setting
Objectives
Motivation
Performance
Appraisal
Identify
Training
Needs
Standardize
Performance
Career
Development
5. KEY FEATURES OF PERFORMANCE
MANAGEMENT SYSTEM (PMS)
Section
Explanation
Job Review
To be filled by appraisee at the end of review period
Part A (Objectives)
This part shall be filled by incumbent in consultation of reporting officer and superior
reporting officer at the start of review period. Part A carries weightage of 70% for non
customer focused areas and 30% weightage for customer focused areas.
Part B1 (Skills and
This part is meant for employees working in customer focused areas. This part carries
Abilities)
70% weightage in computation of the final score for all the employees.
Part B1 (Skills and
This part meant employees working in non customer focused areas . this carries 30%
Abilities)
weightage in computation of final score for all the relevant employees.
Part C (Assessment &
This part consolidates the data/assessments written in pervious sections. It consist of
Ranking)
seven sub parts. here employees is ranked and his/her comments are recorded.
6. Level of Performance and Evaluation
Level
Rating
Abbreviation Scale
Measure
Score
Level-1
Outstanding
OS
Performance far exceeds the
4.6-5.0
5% T0p
performance standards i-e excel in all
scales of the work
Level-II
Very Good
VG
20% Remaining Performance frequently exceeds the
Top
3.6-4.5
performance standards i-e excel in some
important scales of the work and meet
all other aspects.
Level-III
Good
GD
50% Remaining Performance consistently meets all the
Top
Level-IV
Needs
NI
Improvement
standards of the work.
20% Remaining Performance doesn’t meet performance
Top
2.6-3.5
1.6-2.5
standards in some important aspects of
the work.
Level-V
Inadequate
performance
IP
5% Last
Performance is well below the standards 1.0-1.5
Remaining
of the work.
8. Forced Distribution Ranking System
(FDRS)
Forced ranking is a controversial workforce management tool that uses
intense yearly evaluations to identify a company's best and worst
performing employees.
Managers rank workers into three categories:
The top 20 percent are the "A" players, the people who will lead the
future of the company. They're given raises, stock options, and training.
The middle 70 percent are the "B" players, steady-eddies who are given
smaller raises and encouraged to improve.
The bottom 10 percent are the "C" players, who contribute the least and
may be meeting expectations but are simply "good" on a team of "greats."
They're given no raises or bonuses and are either offered training, asked if
they'd be happier elsewhere, or fired.
9. Forced Distribution Ranking System
(FDRS) …
Forced ranking systems direct managers to evaluate their
employees' performance against other employees, rather than
the more common (and often grade inflated) measure of
evaluating performance against pre-determined standards. The
result of such a process is often brutally blunt.
Forced ranking is also used by General Electric, Cisco
Systems,
EDS,
Hewlett
Packard,
Microsoft,
PepsiCo,
Caterpillar,
and
Sun
Microsystems, to name only a few well-known employers.
10. FDRS System at PIA
Grading employees as under:
4.6-5.0
3.6-4.5
2.6-3.5
1.6-2.5
1.0-1.5
Outstanding or Exceptional
Performance
Very Good Performance
Good Performance
Needs Improvement
Inadequate Performance
11. Failure of FDRS at PIA
Cultural Aspects
The organization is highly people oriented. Along with
giving competitive salaries, PIA takes care of its employees
by providing lots of benefits like medical, passage, pension
and gratuity etc. Most importantly, people feel very secure
about their jobs which make them complacent. This is one
of the reasons why FDRS failed at PIA.
Since no job analysis is ever done in the organization, work
activities cannot be described as either team or individual
based. People do work in teams but the sense of
competition and achievement is lacking. This may be
because team based reward system is absent and even if
one person is capable enough to raise team’s performance.
12. Failure of FDRS at PIA…
Biases
A low performing department may have
employees in the top 5% category and thus
would still be eligible for reward. This
practice
overlooks
the
need
for
improvement and nurturing the best
people.
The goals are not set high enough, then
almost anybody can get a superior rating.
13. Failure of FDRS at PIA…
Political Involvement
Being a government organization, there is strong
political involvement is still the part PIA and also
corruption is playing positive role. Many of political
parties have their staff unions in PIA and all have their
own vested interest.
Such political involvement will never support a
performance evaluation system like FDRS.
14. Failure of FDRS at PIA…
Appraiser’s Attitude
Performance grading which is done as per
Behaviorally Anchored Ranking Scale
(BARS) at PIA is not normally taken very
seriously by some departments.
At PIA, appraisal forms are generally filled
without careful planning and in a hurry
(just to get rid of this excess burden).
15. Failure of FDRS at PIA…
Lack of Knowledge
The appraisers’ and appraise is totally lacking knowledge
regarding the benefits of FDRS system and there
ratings disrupts the bell curve.
16. Failure of FDRS at PIA…
Subjectivity
The appraisal form used by the organization is highly
subjective and performance grading depends heavily
on reporting officer’s whims and repartee’s
relationship with his / her boss.
A forced ranking system often incorporates the
subjectivity of department heads, which can
Institutionalize bias and devalue older workers.
Interestingly
17. Failure of FDRS at PIA…
Inflated Rates
Managers don’t want to give bad news to their people.
This might result in inflated ratings and may distort
the shape of the bell curve.
The essence of FDRS is sacrificed if managers are given
autonomy to change the shape of the bell curve. This is
exactly what is being practiced at PIA and instead of
keeping employees motivated, has resulted in
aggravating the situation as PIA employees give much
consideration to comparing themselves with each
other
18. Failure of FDRS at PIA…
Inadequate Pay Grade wise Comparison
FDRS requires that for comparison there should be a
homogeneous group of adequate number of people. At
PIA, even within one department, people of similar
pay grades are doing completely different jobs and
their cross comparison is irrelevant.
In some departments, there may not be enough
number of people to compare against each other. In
this case, if these employees are compared over and
above their department level, their good performance
may show up as inadequate and causes de-motivation
19. Recommendations
Revisit the Key Performance Indicators.
Separate complaint management cell be established
handled by a separate team. The monthly report of
each department will be circulated and also the on
backend have complete details along with particular
employee details. This cell shall also circulate the hard
hitters across the board in order to motivate them.
The same must be included in annual appraisal.
20. Recommendations…
The personal and professional factors in appraisal form
must be evaluated separately. The 50% of the professional
score includes from Competency level. The complaints
during the year must be the part of appraisal system.
Re shuffling of employees. The placement of right person
at right place according to their designation and pay scale.
This will suffice the purpose of comparison
Incase if any have reservations against the annual appraisal,
he/she can consult with HR department where this must
be headed by head of Human Resources
The annual appraisal form must include the need for
training and development
21. Recommendations…
In order to avoid the same pay level problems, the employees
with pay scale from Group I to V rate more than the Group VI
to V. Mean strong evaluations required for higher level
employees.
The final ratings must also be compared with the overall
performance of the department. The complaints must be the
part of annual appraisals
Management shall try to reduce the political involvement.
The bell curve must be for management employees.
The extensive training programs shall be arranged order to
facilitate employees to participate in annual appraisal to
implement bell curve system successfully.
22. Recommendations…
PIA management shall revisit the ratting structure. Below is the
proposed ratting structure.
4.6-5.0
Outstanding or Exceptional Performance
3.6-4.5
Very Good Performance
3.1-3.5
Good Performance
2.1-3.0
Average Performance (Needs Improvement)
1.0-2.0
Poor Performance
The bonuses shall be awarded to employees comes under the
Good performance and above in following manner:
Good Performance
One Basic Salary
Very Good performance
Two Basic Salaries
Outstanding Performance
Three Basic Salaries
23. Recommendations…
We recommended basic salaries because PIA management is already
giving lots of benefits to their employees in terms of tickets as well as
other facilities.
outstanding performers as per PIA current practice shall be posted on
higher level upon availability they may also be posted in PIA’s foreign
office based on the job requirements.
The promotions shall also based on the ratings. PIA management shall
also introduce promotion approval committee with each member from
every department (Departmental Head), GM Human Resource, Head
of Performance Management Evaluation Cell, Head of Complaint
Management Cell, a judge of high court (As in all government
entities), Government representative, it could be the Defense Minister
or his/her nominee (As it comes under ministry of Defense) and
Managing Director PIA. The MD PIA shall head the committee.
.
.
24. Recommendations…
PIA management shall separately introduce the
department for performance management system and
evaluations under the direct report of General
Manager Human Resource, Managing Director PIA.
Apart from annual evaluations, midyear reviews shall
be introduced that create the habit among employees
to understand the advantages of evaluation system ad
also know the proper way of ratting.