Observations on Country Case Study 
Presentations by Participants 
(UNEP-UNITAR-cifal Jeju Workshop – 
10-12 December 2013) 
K D Bhardwaj 
Senior Program Officer 
Asian Productivity Organization
Bangladesh 
City: Rajshahi 
Waste: 195 tons/day 
Kg/Capita/day: 0.245 
Good Practice/Framework/ 
System: 
Institutes supporting SWM: 
Local Government 
Engineering Department 
(LGED) 
Bangladesh Municipal 
Development Fund (BMDF) 
Department of Public Health 
Engineering 
Observations: 
75 – 85 % compostable waste 
Why not compost plant with the 
help of external support/donor 
agencies? 
Is landfill engineered/sanitary with 
liner system? 
Efforts on 3R !!
People’s Republic of China 
City: Hangzhou 
Waste: 8876 tons/day 
Kg/Capita/day: ___ 
Good Practice/Framework/ 
System: 
Municipal government set 
waste segregation standards 
Waste segregation website 
Eco-community project for 
zero waste community 
Smart Green House project 
Smart Bins 
Observations: 
Waste segregation not practiced 
properly. 
No incentives for waste segregation 
Why incineration plants opposed? 
Misconception about incineration !! 
No space left in landfill facility after 
5 years. How to tackle this issue?
India 
City: Chandigarh 
Waste: 370 tons/day 
Kg/Capita/day: 0.370 
Good Practice/Framework/ 
System: 
Observations: 
Dumping ground or engineered 
landfill ? 
Waste reduction/reuse/recycle 
targets? 
Door-to-door collection of 
waste and Waste segregation 
Garbage processing plant for 
RDF 
Biomethanation for slaughter 
house waste
India 
City: Kota 
Waste: 300 tons/day 
Kg/Capita/day: 0.300 
Good Practice/Framework/ 
System: 
Less paper office/E-governance 
Use of polythene bags 
banned 
Sewage treatment 
100 % ash utilization 
Observations: 
Waste reduction/reuse/recycle 
targets? 
Waste collection? 
Waste processing and disposal 
facility !
India 
City: Vijayawada 
Waste: 550 tons/day 
Kg/Capita/day: _____ 
Good Practice/Framework/ 
System: 
Waste to energy plant 
Plan for composting/vermin-composting 
Observations: 
Medical waste / Hazardous waste 
handling and management 
Engineered landfill ? 
Waste reduction/reuse/recycle 
targets? 
Waste to energy plant not 
functioning !
India 
City: Panchkula 
Waste: ______ 
Kg/Capita/day: _____ 
Good Practice/Framework/ 
System: 
Good government control 
and administration 
Community Led Total 
Sanitation Program 
Observations: 
Power generation as part of 
integrated waste management 
Lack of systematic assessment of 
waste generation
Kiribati 
City: South Tarawa 
Waste: ______ 
Kg/Capita/day: _____ 
Good Practice/Framework/ 
System: 
Kiribati Integrated 
Environment Policy 
Joint Enforcement Team 
Chemical waste 
management 
Observations: 
Can not afford having waste ! 
3Rs essential! 
Minimise/eliminate landfilling
Malaysia 
City: Penang 
Waste: 288,377 tons/day 
Kg/Capita/day: 1.07 
Good Practice/Framework/ 
System: 
Waste composition 
Government commitment 
Way forward – zero waste 
Observations: 
Segregation at source still an 
issue ! 
Waste reduction targets! 
ISO14001 ?
Mongolia 
City: Ulaaanbaatar 
Waste: ______ tons/day 
Kg/Capita/day: _____ 
Good Practice/Framework/ 
System: 
Seasonal waste 
composition (50 % ash in 
winter) 
Master plan available 
Several regulations 
Observations: 
Waste processing and disposal ? 
Waste sorting? 
System to handle seasonal 
variation ? 
3Rs !
Nepal 
City: Kathmandu 
Waste: 475 tons/day 
Kg/Capita/day: 0.3 
Good Practice/Framework/ 
System: 
Waste generation 
assessment 
Construction of transfer 
station /landfill site 
Community based 
composting 
Observations: 
Waste collection and transportation! 
Final waste processing and 
disposal ? 
Waste reduction strategy!
Nepal 
City: Birendranagar 
Waste: 5 tons/day 
Kg/Capita/day: 0.0415 
Good Practice/Framework/ 
System: 
Waste composition (75% 
organic) 
Solid waste management 
plan 
Observations: 
Why landfill site construction ? 
What about composting/RDF or 
waste to energy?
Nepal 
City: Biratnagar 
Waste: 55 tons/day 
Kg/Capita/day: 0.33 
Good Practice/Framework/ 
System: 
Waste composition (75% 
organic) 
Solid waste management 
system (private sector) 
Observations: 
Why landfill site ? 
Waste reduction targets? 
Leachate treatment at landfill site ! 
Implementation of strategies?
Nepal 
City: Hetauda 
Waste: 20-25 tons/day 
Kg/Capita/day: 0.25 
Good Practice/Framework/ 
System: 
Waste composition (70% 
organic) and waste 
generation assessment 
Color based sorting 
(primary and secondary) 
Integrated waste 
management plan 
Observations: 
Waste processing and disposal 
site ? 
Waste reduction targets?
Nepal 
City: Siddharthanagar 
Waste: 30 tons/day 
Kg/Capita/day: 0.48 
Good Practice/Framework/ 
System: 
Waste composition (73% 
organic) 
Waste segregation at 
source 
Good understanding 
Observations: 
Why landfill site construction? 
Why not composting/ RDF plant? 
Waste reduction targets?
Nepal 
City: Tansen Municipality 
Waste: 6 tons/day 
Kg/Capita/day: ____ 
Good Practice/Framework/ 
System: 
Waste composition (44% 
organic) 
Compost plant 
Plastic free municipality 
Observations: 
Why landfill site construction? 
3Rs targets?
Pakistan 
City: Rawalpindi 
Waste: 48000 tons/day in 
country 
Kg/Capita/day: 0.5-0.7 
(country average) 
Good Practice/Framework/ 
System: 
National guidelines 
Infrastructure is there 
SWEEP program 
competed 
Observations: 
No law? 
Waste processing and disposal 
facilities 
3Rs targets? 
Much needs to be done!
Philippines 
City: Mandaluyong 
Waste: 400,000 m3 
Kg/Capita/day: 0.71 
Good Practice/Framework/ 
System: 
Master plan for SWM 
Ban on plastic packaging 
Barangay-level 
beautification projects 
Observations: 
Waste processing and disposal 
facility 
Waste segregation 
3Rs targets?
Philippines 
City: Cagayan De Oro 
Waste: 14,346.66 m3 per 
month 
Kg/Capita/day: ___ 
Good Practice/Framework/ 
System: 
Waste composition (50 % 
food/organic waste, plastic 
25%) 
MRF for each Barangay 
plan 
Observations: 
Waste processing and disposal 
facility 
Composting/RDF plant? 
3Rs targets?
Sri Lanka 
City: Kattankudy 
Waste: 25 tons/day 
Kg/Capita/day: 0.412 
Good Practice/Framework/ 
System: 
Waste composition (58 % 
biodegradable) 
Local authority fully 
responsible 
Waste recycling banking 
system 
Observations: 
No law on waste management? 
Waste processing and disposal 
facility 
Composting/RDF plant? 
3Rs targets?
Thailand 
City: Nong Rua 
Municipality 
Waste: 25 tons 
Kg/Capita/day: ___ 
Good Practice/Framework/ 
System: 
Waste composition (58-64 
% organic waste) 
Assessment of waste 
generation 
Observations: 
Waste processing and disposal 
facility 
Composting/RDF plant? 
3Rs targets? 
Much needs to be done
Vietnam 
City: Hue 
Waste: 205 tons/day 
Kg/Capita/day: ___ 
Good Practice/Framework/ 
System: 
30 % recycling target by 
2020 
Plan to construct recycling 
facilities 
Observations: 
Waste processing and disposal 
facility 
Waste sorting ? 
3Rs targets? 
Much needs to be done
COMMON ISSUES 
My city, my home?? 
Know-your-waste 
Finance (rich city - more waste) 
Waste management strategy (Reactive or 
proactive) 
Cost recovery (Is it must?) 
Technology
COMMON ISSUES 
Waste management priority – 
Geographic or waste stream based 
Government commitment 
Public private partnership 
Waste reduction targets 
Natural disasters
Thank you! 
K D Bhardwaj 
Senior Program Officer 
Industry Department, APO 
kdbhardwaj@apo-tokyo.org

Municipal Solid Waste Management - Observations on Presentations K D Bhardwaj

  • 1.
    Observations on CountryCase Study Presentations by Participants (UNEP-UNITAR-cifal Jeju Workshop – 10-12 December 2013) K D Bhardwaj Senior Program Officer Asian Productivity Organization
  • 2.
    Bangladesh City: Rajshahi Waste: 195 tons/day Kg/Capita/day: 0.245 Good Practice/Framework/ System: Institutes supporting SWM: Local Government Engineering Department (LGED) Bangladesh Municipal Development Fund (BMDF) Department of Public Health Engineering Observations: 75 – 85 % compostable waste Why not compost plant with the help of external support/donor agencies? Is landfill engineered/sanitary with liner system? Efforts on 3R !!
  • 3.
    People’s Republic ofChina City: Hangzhou Waste: 8876 tons/day Kg/Capita/day: ___ Good Practice/Framework/ System: Municipal government set waste segregation standards Waste segregation website Eco-community project for zero waste community Smart Green House project Smart Bins Observations: Waste segregation not practiced properly. No incentives for waste segregation Why incineration plants opposed? Misconception about incineration !! No space left in landfill facility after 5 years. How to tackle this issue?
  • 4.
    India City: Chandigarh Waste: 370 tons/day Kg/Capita/day: 0.370 Good Practice/Framework/ System: Observations: Dumping ground or engineered landfill ? Waste reduction/reuse/recycle targets? Door-to-door collection of waste and Waste segregation Garbage processing plant for RDF Biomethanation for slaughter house waste
  • 5.
    India City: Kota Waste: 300 tons/day Kg/Capita/day: 0.300 Good Practice/Framework/ System: Less paper office/E-governance Use of polythene bags banned Sewage treatment 100 % ash utilization Observations: Waste reduction/reuse/recycle targets? Waste collection? Waste processing and disposal facility !
  • 6.
    India City: Vijayawada Waste: 550 tons/day Kg/Capita/day: _____ Good Practice/Framework/ System: Waste to energy plant Plan for composting/vermin-composting Observations: Medical waste / Hazardous waste handling and management Engineered landfill ? Waste reduction/reuse/recycle targets? Waste to energy plant not functioning !
  • 7.
    India City: Panchkula Waste: ______ Kg/Capita/day: _____ Good Practice/Framework/ System: Good government control and administration Community Led Total Sanitation Program Observations: Power generation as part of integrated waste management Lack of systematic assessment of waste generation
  • 8.
    Kiribati City: SouthTarawa Waste: ______ Kg/Capita/day: _____ Good Practice/Framework/ System: Kiribati Integrated Environment Policy Joint Enforcement Team Chemical waste management Observations: Can not afford having waste ! 3Rs essential! Minimise/eliminate landfilling
  • 9.
    Malaysia City: Penang Waste: 288,377 tons/day Kg/Capita/day: 1.07 Good Practice/Framework/ System: Waste composition Government commitment Way forward – zero waste Observations: Segregation at source still an issue ! Waste reduction targets! ISO14001 ?
  • 10.
    Mongolia City: Ulaaanbaatar Waste: ______ tons/day Kg/Capita/day: _____ Good Practice/Framework/ System: Seasonal waste composition (50 % ash in winter) Master plan available Several regulations Observations: Waste processing and disposal ? Waste sorting? System to handle seasonal variation ? 3Rs !
  • 11.
    Nepal City: Kathmandu Waste: 475 tons/day Kg/Capita/day: 0.3 Good Practice/Framework/ System: Waste generation assessment Construction of transfer station /landfill site Community based composting Observations: Waste collection and transportation! Final waste processing and disposal ? Waste reduction strategy!
  • 12.
    Nepal City: Birendranagar Waste: 5 tons/day Kg/Capita/day: 0.0415 Good Practice/Framework/ System: Waste composition (75% organic) Solid waste management plan Observations: Why landfill site construction ? What about composting/RDF or waste to energy?
  • 13.
    Nepal City: Biratnagar Waste: 55 tons/day Kg/Capita/day: 0.33 Good Practice/Framework/ System: Waste composition (75% organic) Solid waste management system (private sector) Observations: Why landfill site ? Waste reduction targets? Leachate treatment at landfill site ! Implementation of strategies?
  • 14.
    Nepal City: Hetauda Waste: 20-25 tons/day Kg/Capita/day: 0.25 Good Practice/Framework/ System: Waste composition (70% organic) and waste generation assessment Color based sorting (primary and secondary) Integrated waste management plan Observations: Waste processing and disposal site ? Waste reduction targets?
  • 15.
    Nepal City: Siddharthanagar Waste: 30 tons/day Kg/Capita/day: 0.48 Good Practice/Framework/ System: Waste composition (73% organic) Waste segregation at source Good understanding Observations: Why landfill site construction? Why not composting/ RDF plant? Waste reduction targets?
  • 16.
    Nepal City: TansenMunicipality Waste: 6 tons/day Kg/Capita/day: ____ Good Practice/Framework/ System: Waste composition (44% organic) Compost plant Plastic free municipality Observations: Why landfill site construction? 3Rs targets?
  • 17.
    Pakistan City: Rawalpindi Waste: 48000 tons/day in country Kg/Capita/day: 0.5-0.7 (country average) Good Practice/Framework/ System: National guidelines Infrastructure is there SWEEP program competed Observations: No law? Waste processing and disposal facilities 3Rs targets? Much needs to be done!
  • 18.
    Philippines City: Mandaluyong Waste: 400,000 m3 Kg/Capita/day: 0.71 Good Practice/Framework/ System: Master plan for SWM Ban on plastic packaging Barangay-level beautification projects Observations: Waste processing and disposal facility Waste segregation 3Rs targets?
  • 19.
    Philippines City: CagayanDe Oro Waste: 14,346.66 m3 per month Kg/Capita/day: ___ Good Practice/Framework/ System: Waste composition (50 % food/organic waste, plastic 25%) MRF for each Barangay plan Observations: Waste processing and disposal facility Composting/RDF plant? 3Rs targets?
  • 20.
    Sri Lanka City:Kattankudy Waste: 25 tons/day Kg/Capita/day: 0.412 Good Practice/Framework/ System: Waste composition (58 % biodegradable) Local authority fully responsible Waste recycling banking system Observations: No law on waste management? Waste processing and disposal facility Composting/RDF plant? 3Rs targets?
  • 21.
    Thailand City: NongRua Municipality Waste: 25 tons Kg/Capita/day: ___ Good Practice/Framework/ System: Waste composition (58-64 % organic waste) Assessment of waste generation Observations: Waste processing and disposal facility Composting/RDF plant? 3Rs targets? Much needs to be done
  • 22.
    Vietnam City: Hue Waste: 205 tons/day Kg/Capita/day: ___ Good Practice/Framework/ System: 30 % recycling target by 2020 Plan to construct recycling facilities Observations: Waste processing and disposal facility Waste sorting ? 3Rs targets? Much needs to be done
  • 23.
    COMMON ISSUES Mycity, my home?? Know-your-waste Finance (rich city - more waste) Waste management strategy (Reactive or proactive) Cost recovery (Is it must?) Technology
  • 24.
    COMMON ISSUES Wastemanagement priority – Geographic or waste stream based Government commitment Public private partnership Waste reduction targets Natural disasters
  • 25.
    Thank you! KD Bhardwaj Senior Program Officer Industry Department, APO kdbhardwaj@apo-tokyo.org