A 27-year-old male baseball player presents with pain and swelling isolated to his right index finger DIP joint after hearing a snap during a pitch. Radiographs show a mallet finger injury with an associated avulsion fracture. The diagnosis is a mallet finger with fracture. Treatment involves splinting the DIP joint in extension for 6-10 weeks, unless the fracture is displaced more than 40% or has volar subluxation, in which case surgery may be needed. Complications can include a swan neck deformity if not treated properly.