 Jimary is a 14 year old student in 8th
  grade.
 Lived in Puerto Rico until she was 12.
 Received limited informal instruction in
  English prior to moving to the US.
 Currently receives ESL services for 45
  minutes per day.
 Speaks Spanish at home and with friends
  when applicable.
 Both English and Spanish use the same
  letter symbols
 Both languages are inflected by plurality
 Plurals are most often created by adding
  an –s to the end of a word
 Verb conjugation follows a pattern
  based on the type of verb (-ar, -er, -ir)
 While the same letter symbols are used,
  Spanish uses all of the English letters, plus
  the letter ñ and the digraphs ll and ch.
 Spanish also has the rr, which is a rolling r,
  used in words such as arroz (rice) and
  perro (dog).
 Words may also include accent marks to
  indicate stressed vowels, and can be the
  difference between two different words.
 Spanish more closely resembles a one-
  to-one grapheme-phoneme relationship
  unlike English (Jones, 1996)
 Many words in Spanish are inflected
  based on gender
 When using adjectives, the adjective
  comes after the subject, unlike in English (El
  coche rojo. vs. The red car.)
 Apostrophes are not used in Spanish. There
  are no contractions, and possessives are
  shown in different ways.
 Possessives are shown by using objects of
  prepositions (mi, ti, etc.) or by using de
  which means “of.” (Libro de Sonia means
  book of Sonia, or Sonia’s book.)
  (Jarvis, Lebredo, & Mena-Ayllon, 2005)
 The silent e does not exist in Spanish.
 When using exclamation points or
  question marks, an inverted symbol is
  also placed at the beginning of the
  phrase.
 ELLs may substitute d for th since in Spanish
  they are allophones of one phoneme, so
  changing the phoneme does not change
  meaning. (Freeman & Freeman, 2004).
 New rules, such as using an apostrophe and
  an s to show possession, and adjectives
  coming after the noun, might be over
  generalized when they are learned, or they
  may use the rules from the L1.
 Both languages consist of many of the
  same phones, a small amount of time will
  need to be devoted to phonemic
  awareness. Some practice with minimal
  pairs may be necessary, especially with
  words that have sounds that are different
  from Spanish.
 The learner is familiar with irregular verb
  conjugations, but explicit instruction is
  common with irregular verbs (to be, to do,
  to go, etc.).
 Use of cloze notes
 Point out cognates (words that are
  similar in both English and Spanish such
  as university and universidad, professor
  and profesor)
 Be careful of false cognates
  (embarrassed and embarazada
  (pregnant))
 Freeman, D. E., & Freeman, Y. S. (2004).
  Essential Linguistics: What You Need to
  Know to Teach Reading, ESL, Spelling,
  Phonics, and Grammar. Portsmouth:
  Heinemann.
 Jarvis, A., Lebredo, R., & Mena-Ayllon, F.
  (2005). Como se dice...? Boston: Houghton
  Mifflin.
 Jones, M. L. (1996). Phonics in ESL Literacy
  Instruction: Functional or Not? Philadelphia.

Language Comparison Poster

  • 2.
     Jimary isa 14 year old student in 8th grade.  Lived in Puerto Rico until she was 12.  Received limited informal instruction in English prior to moving to the US.  Currently receives ESL services for 45 minutes per day.  Speaks Spanish at home and with friends when applicable.
  • 7.
     Both Englishand Spanish use the same letter symbols  Both languages are inflected by plurality  Plurals are most often created by adding an –s to the end of a word  Verb conjugation follows a pattern based on the type of verb (-ar, -er, -ir)
  • 8.
     While thesame letter symbols are used, Spanish uses all of the English letters, plus the letter ñ and the digraphs ll and ch.  Spanish also has the rr, which is a rolling r, used in words such as arroz (rice) and perro (dog).  Words may also include accent marks to indicate stressed vowels, and can be the difference between two different words.
  • 9.
     Spanish moreclosely resembles a one- to-one grapheme-phoneme relationship unlike English (Jones, 1996)  Many words in Spanish are inflected based on gender
  • 10.
     When usingadjectives, the adjective comes after the subject, unlike in English (El coche rojo. vs. The red car.)  Apostrophes are not used in Spanish. There are no contractions, and possessives are shown in different ways.  Possessives are shown by using objects of prepositions (mi, ti, etc.) or by using de which means “of.” (Libro de Sonia means book of Sonia, or Sonia’s book.) (Jarvis, Lebredo, & Mena-Ayllon, 2005)
  • 11.
     The silente does not exist in Spanish.  When using exclamation points or question marks, an inverted symbol is also placed at the beginning of the phrase.
  • 12.
     ELLs maysubstitute d for th since in Spanish they are allophones of one phoneme, so changing the phoneme does not change meaning. (Freeman & Freeman, 2004).  New rules, such as using an apostrophe and an s to show possession, and adjectives coming after the noun, might be over generalized when they are learned, or they may use the rules from the L1.
  • 13.
     Both languagesconsist of many of the same phones, a small amount of time will need to be devoted to phonemic awareness. Some practice with minimal pairs may be necessary, especially with words that have sounds that are different from Spanish.  The learner is familiar with irregular verb conjugations, but explicit instruction is common with irregular verbs (to be, to do, to go, etc.).
  • 14.
     Use ofcloze notes  Point out cognates (words that are similar in both English and Spanish such as university and universidad, professor and profesor)  Be careful of false cognates (embarrassed and embarazada (pregnant))
  • 15.
     Freeman, D.E., & Freeman, Y. S. (2004). Essential Linguistics: What You Need to Know to Teach Reading, ESL, Spelling, Phonics, and Grammar. Portsmouth: Heinemann.  Jarvis, A., Lebredo, R., & Mena-Ayllon, F. (2005). Como se dice...? Boston: Houghton Mifflin.  Jones, M. L. (1996). Phonics in ESL Literacy Instruction: Functional or Not? Philadelphia.