A 46-year-old man with uncontrolled diabetes presented with abdominal pain, weight loss, and fever. Imaging revealed a large liver abscess. Blood and abscess cultures grew Lactobacillus species. Lactobacillus typically inhabits the gastrointestinal tract but can cause infection in immunocompromised individuals. The patient underwent catheter drainage of the abscess and received antibiotics. Follow-up imaging showed resolution of the abscess. Uncontrolled diabetes likely caused endothelial injury and bacterial translocation leading to Lactobacillus bacteremia and liver abscess in this case.