THE IRAN-IRAQ WAR

Historical Simulation of the United Nations
 By Polyvios and Lara for the KCL MUN Chairing Program 2012
Historical Origins of the Conflicts
                  Early 20th C-1988  37 conflicts in the Middle East

                  Iraq-Iran War 1980-88

                  ORIGINS?

                  1.Religious Differences

                  Iraq leader Saddam Houssein Sunni Muslim
                  Majority of Iraqi people --> Shias

                  Whereas..

                  Iran  Shias Muslims

                  2. Shatt al Arab waterway dispute

                  Important channel for the oil exports of both countries

                  1937 – Iraq acquired control ; Iran had to pay tolls
                  1969 – Iran abrogated the treaty leading to acute tension

                  3.Khuzestan oil-rich province

                  Large Arab speaking population
Key Political Actors
Iraq - Saddam Hussein

•1979 - forced the Iraqi president to resign
•He executed opponents within the Ba’ath Party
•Aim: make Iraq Middle East’s leading state
•Ba’ath party under Saddam – influenced by socialism rather than Islamic law
•Saddam was a Sunni – minority in Iraq --- > wasn’t confident of the backing of the Shias
•Neighbouring Iran – world’s most preeminent Shia – Muslim State

Iran - Ayatollah Ruhollah Khomeini

• 1979 – Iranian Revolution --- > change in power
•Former leader Shah Mohammed Reza Pahlavi (pro-Western monarch) :
 strong policy of modernization
 secularization: religion loses its authority in social life and governance
•Iranian Revolution – Islamists took control:
 reversed the diplomatic relations that Shah had established -- > anti-Western ideology
Causes for Conflict
• Territorial Claims
    – Khuzestan
      Iranian province, population has close ties to Iraq, Iraq claimed historical right
      for control of the region
    – Small islands in the Persian Gulf
      Iraq claimed a number of small islands in the Persian Gulf
    – Khuzestan Shatt Al-Arab River

• Political Chaos in Iran
    – Many different factions vying for power before Khomeini established
      himself as the new political leader
    – Iraq saw Iran’s domestic instability as an opportunity to attack

• Deaths of Tariq Aziz and Muhammad Baqir Al-Sadr
    – Attempted assassination of Iraqi foreign minister Aziz by Iranian
      backed group Ad Dawah
    – Arrest and execution of popular Iraqi Shia cleric Al-Sadr
The War Itself
                         The War Itself
1980 – the tensions between the two countries were already high
September          Iraq declares Shatt Al-Arab river theirs
22.09              Iraq invades Iran

• Khardeh and Karun were only lightly guarded, Iraqi forces quickly pushed
  back Iranian forces and gained substantial territory
• Iranian Air Force armed with highly sophisticated American-made
  airfracts

Jan. 1981         Massive counter-offensive by Iran, dented the armour or
                  Iraqi military

• Despite stalemate, neither was willing to concede or negotiate, Iran
  especially unwilling as Iraq was still occupying Iranian territory
The War Itself / ctd.
                 The War Itself / ctd.
1982     Iranian Suicide Missions – ‘Human Wave Attacks’
• Iran harnessed her population’s religious fanaticisms
• Iran’s clerical rulers preached that the ‘true believers’ who died defending
   Iran would be rewarded as martyrs
• Iraqi troops’ military proficiency was overwhelmed by Iran’s pure numbers

By January 1982
• Siege of Abadan had been lifted
• Iran defeated Iraq in the Qasr-e Shirin area
• Iraq was unwilling to sustain high casualty rates and therefore refused to
   initiate further offenses
The War Itself – Iraqi Retreats
      The War Itself - Iraqi Retreats
March 1982: Operation Undeniable Victory
• Launched by Iran, forcing Iraq to retreat – within weeks large proportions
  of Iraqi divisions were destroyed
• Marked a turning point in the war

May 1982: Iraqis had retreated to internationally recognised lines
• Iran did not regard this the end of the war and continued their offensive

June 1982: Iraq showed willingness for negotiations, Iran refused

End 1982 to 1984
• Iraq launched a new phase of ground war, both sides absorbed heavy
   losses and casualties
• Iraq denied Iran substantial gains in Iraq
• Iraq sought to involve the superpowers to end the conflict
The War Itself – War of Attrition
1984
• Neither side made decisive military breakthrough – Stalemate continued
• Iraq was facing more problems as it was less populous and the Iranian
   government enjoyed more legitimisation

Use of Chemical Weapons
• 40,000 Iranian and 9,000 Iraqi fatalities
• Chemical Weapons were used over 40 times by Iraq

1985: War of the Cities, objective was to terrorise the citizenry
• Iraq launched multiple air strikes on Tehran, Iran bombed Baghdad

1988
• Major missile attack on Tehran, many fled the city
• Highly inaccurate missiles that inflicted considerable collateral damage
Casualties
                             Casualties

                  Iran                                       Iraq
500,000 to 1m dead                         300,000 soldiers, militia and civilians
                                           killed or wounded
Iranian government’s official figure at
188,015 fatalities in soldiers, militias
and civilians
War and military tactics



1980     1981      1982   1983   1984    1985     1986      1987   1988




22 Semptember 1980                      Iran on the offensive
Iraq invades Iran
By June 1982 Iran
regained lost territory
Air Interdiction
Iraq invaded Iran, launching a simultaneous
invasion by air and land into Iranian territory
on 22 September 1980 aiming to destroy
Iranian air force base + capture Khorramshar

Iran responded with attacks to Iraqi capital
Baghdad
Both sides – 7000 deaths




 1980      1981        1982         1983          1984   1985   1986   1987   1988
Human wave attacks
 Operation Jerusalem Way (Iran)
 Human sea attack-overrun the defenders by
                      k
 angaging in melee combat-shock the enemy to
 fall back

 Iraq - 2500 killed
 Iran - 6000



1980   1981       1982       1983     1984     1985   1986   1987   1988
1980   1981   1982     1983    1984     1985     1986     1987   1988



               Encouragement of heroism and martyrdom

               Iran on the offensive to capture Basra –
               used human wave attacks – martyrs would
               go to Heaven
1980   1981   1982   1983     1984       1985       1986        1987     1988



                      Chemical weapons
                      Iran was trying to capture Basra
                      Iraq counter attacked using mustard gas and
                      nerve gas in violation of international law
                      20 000 Iranian soldiers killed ; 80 000 affected
Tanker tactics
                        Early 1984-Iraq attacks Iranian tankers and
                        Iranian oil terminal
                        Iran responded by attacking Iraqi tankers

                        546 commercial vessels damaged
                        430 civilian sailors killed




1980   1981   1982   1983   1984       1985      1986        1987     1988
Operation Dawn 5 (Iran)
                        Split Iraqi troops in Basra
                        Operation Dawn 6
                        Cut Baghdad-Basra from each other by
                        clocking the highway that connected them




1980   1981   1982   1983   1984        1985          1986   1987   1988
20th August 1988
                     UN Security Council Resolution 598
                                 Ceasefire




1980   1981   1982   1983   1984   1985   1986   1987   1988
International Community Reaction
International Community Reactions
                      Iran                                     Iraq
Saudi Arabia                                United States
• Financial aid, up to US$1bn per month     • No secret support
                                            • Financial and military aid, chemicals,
                                              military training,
                                            • Iraq as the ‘guarantor’ of US interests
                                              in the region
Soviet Union                                European Countries: United Kingdom,
• Supply of financial aid, weapons,         France, Kuwait, Italy, West Germany,
   missiles                                 Egypt, Jordan, Singapore

North Korea                                 Persian Gulf States: Saudi Arabia, Kuwait
• Support in exchange for oil               and the United Arab Emirates
• By 1982, Iran’s major military supplier

Syria, Libya, China                         Others: Kuwait, Egypt, Jordan, Singapore
Relevant UN Action
                 Relevant UN Actions
UNSC Resolution 582, February 24, 1986
• Condemned the escalation of the conflict (territorial incursions, bombing
  of civilian areas, violation of int’l law, use of chemical weapons)
• Called upon cease fire and withdrawal of military forces to int’l recognised
  borders
• Both parties refused to implement it

UNSC Resolution 589, July 20, 1987
• Demands that Iran and Iraq observe a ceasefire as a first step towards a
  negotiated settlement
• Request that an observer-team be sent to the region
• Requested that POW be released and repatriated
• Question of the responsibility for the conflict
Questions to Consider
             Questions to Consider
• Peace: How can long lasting peace be achieved in the region?
• Justice: How can the respective countries be brought to justice for
  their various unethical war practices? Should the UN take action
  regarding the use of chemical weapons?
• Prevention: In context to this war, how can further conflicts in the
  Middle East, be prevented?
• Cultural differences: Is there a way to ensure communal tensions
  between the Shi’ite and Sunni Muslims in the respective countries
  so as to not lead to further conflict?
• Protection of oil: Due to their global importance, how can the oil
  resources of these countries be protected from mutual attack as
  well as from usurpation from foreign countries with vested
  interests?
• Question of water: Can a suitable water sharing agreement be
  reached regarding the Shatt al-Arab waterway so that it does not
  become a catalyst for conflict once more?

KCL MUN 2012-03-06 Iran-Iraq War — Presentation

  • 1.
    THE IRAN-IRAQ WAR HistoricalSimulation of the United Nations By Polyvios and Lara for the KCL MUN Chairing Program 2012
  • 2.
    Historical Origins ofthe Conflicts Early 20th C-1988  37 conflicts in the Middle East Iraq-Iran War 1980-88 ORIGINS? 1.Religious Differences Iraq leader Saddam Houssein Sunni Muslim Majority of Iraqi people --> Shias Whereas.. Iran  Shias Muslims 2. Shatt al Arab waterway dispute Important channel for the oil exports of both countries 1937 – Iraq acquired control ; Iran had to pay tolls 1969 – Iran abrogated the treaty leading to acute tension 3.Khuzestan oil-rich province Large Arab speaking population
  • 3.
    Key Political Actors Iraq- Saddam Hussein •1979 - forced the Iraqi president to resign •He executed opponents within the Ba’ath Party •Aim: make Iraq Middle East’s leading state •Ba’ath party under Saddam – influenced by socialism rather than Islamic law •Saddam was a Sunni – minority in Iraq --- > wasn’t confident of the backing of the Shias •Neighbouring Iran – world’s most preeminent Shia – Muslim State Iran - Ayatollah Ruhollah Khomeini • 1979 – Iranian Revolution --- > change in power •Former leader Shah Mohammed Reza Pahlavi (pro-Western monarch) :  strong policy of modernization  secularization: religion loses its authority in social life and governance •Iranian Revolution – Islamists took control:  reversed the diplomatic relations that Shah had established -- > anti-Western ideology
  • 4.
    Causes for Conflict •Territorial Claims – Khuzestan Iranian province, population has close ties to Iraq, Iraq claimed historical right for control of the region – Small islands in the Persian Gulf Iraq claimed a number of small islands in the Persian Gulf – Khuzestan Shatt Al-Arab River • Political Chaos in Iran – Many different factions vying for power before Khomeini established himself as the new political leader – Iraq saw Iran’s domestic instability as an opportunity to attack • Deaths of Tariq Aziz and Muhammad Baqir Al-Sadr – Attempted assassination of Iraqi foreign minister Aziz by Iranian backed group Ad Dawah – Arrest and execution of popular Iraqi Shia cleric Al-Sadr
  • 5.
    The War Itself The War Itself 1980 – the tensions between the two countries were already high September Iraq declares Shatt Al-Arab river theirs 22.09 Iraq invades Iran • Khardeh and Karun were only lightly guarded, Iraqi forces quickly pushed back Iranian forces and gained substantial territory • Iranian Air Force armed with highly sophisticated American-made airfracts Jan. 1981 Massive counter-offensive by Iran, dented the armour or Iraqi military • Despite stalemate, neither was willing to concede or negotiate, Iran especially unwilling as Iraq was still occupying Iranian territory
  • 6.
    The War Itself/ ctd. The War Itself / ctd. 1982 Iranian Suicide Missions – ‘Human Wave Attacks’ • Iran harnessed her population’s religious fanaticisms • Iran’s clerical rulers preached that the ‘true believers’ who died defending Iran would be rewarded as martyrs • Iraqi troops’ military proficiency was overwhelmed by Iran’s pure numbers By January 1982 • Siege of Abadan had been lifted • Iran defeated Iraq in the Qasr-e Shirin area • Iraq was unwilling to sustain high casualty rates and therefore refused to initiate further offenses
  • 7.
    The War Itself– Iraqi Retreats The War Itself - Iraqi Retreats March 1982: Operation Undeniable Victory • Launched by Iran, forcing Iraq to retreat – within weeks large proportions of Iraqi divisions were destroyed • Marked a turning point in the war May 1982: Iraqis had retreated to internationally recognised lines • Iran did not regard this the end of the war and continued their offensive June 1982: Iraq showed willingness for negotiations, Iran refused End 1982 to 1984 • Iraq launched a new phase of ground war, both sides absorbed heavy losses and casualties • Iraq denied Iran substantial gains in Iraq • Iraq sought to involve the superpowers to end the conflict
  • 8.
    The War Itself– War of Attrition 1984 • Neither side made decisive military breakthrough – Stalemate continued • Iraq was facing more problems as it was less populous and the Iranian government enjoyed more legitimisation Use of Chemical Weapons • 40,000 Iranian and 9,000 Iraqi fatalities • Chemical Weapons were used over 40 times by Iraq 1985: War of the Cities, objective was to terrorise the citizenry • Iraq launched multiple air strikes on Tehran, Iran bombed Baghdad 1988 • Major missile attack on Tehran, many fled the city • Highly inaccurate missiles that inflicted considerable collateral damage
  • 9.
    Casualties Casualties Iran Iraq 500,000 to 1m dead 300,000 soldiers, militia and civilians killed or wounded Iranian government’s official figure at 188,015 fatalities in soldiers, militias and civilians
  • 10.
    War and militarytactics 1980 1981 1982 1983 1984 1985 1986 1987 1988 22 Semptember 1980 Iran on the offensive Iraq invades Iran By June 1982 Iran regained lost territory
  • 11.
    Air Interdiction Iraq invadedIran, launching a simultaneous invasion by air and land into Iranian territory on 22 September 1980 aiming to destroy Iranian air force base + capture Khorramshar Iran responded with attacks to Iraqi capital Baghdad Both sides – 7000 deaths 1980 1981 1982 1983 1984 1985 1986 1987 1988
  • 12.
    Human wave attacks Operation Jerusalem Way (Iran) Human sea attack-overrun the defenders by k angaging in melee combat-shock the enemy to fall back Iraq - 2500 killed Iran - 6000 1980 1981 1982 1983 1984 1985 1986 1987 1988
  • 13.
    1980 1981 1982 1983 1984 1985 1986 1987 1988 Encouragement of heroism and martyrdom Iran on the offensive to capture Basra – used human wave attacks – martyrs would go to Heaven
  • 14.
    1980 1981 1982 1983 1984 1985 1986 1987 1988 Chemical weapons Iran was trying to capture Basra Iraq counter attacked using mustard gas and nerve gas in violation of international law 20 000 Iranian soldiers killed ; 80 000 affected
  • 15.
    Tanker tactics Early 1984-Iraq attacks Iranian tankers and Iranian oil terminal Iran responded by attacking Iraqi tankers 546 commercial vessels damaged 430 civilian sailors killed 1980 1981 1982 1983 1984 1985 1986 1987 1988
  • 16.
    Operation Dawn 5(Iran) Split Iraqi troops in Basra Operation Dawn 6 Cut Baghdad-Basra from each other by clocking the highway that connected them 1980 1981 1982 1983 1984 1985 1986 1987 1988
  • 17.
    20th August 1988 UN Security Council Resolution 598 Ceasefire 1980 1981 1982 1983 1984 1985 1986 1987 1988
  • 18.
    International Community Reaction InternationalCommunity Reactions Iran Iraq Saudi Arabia United States • Financial aid, up to US$1bn per month • No secret support • Financial and military aid, chemicals, military training, • Iraq as the ‘guarantor’ of US interests in the region Soviet Union European Countries: United Kingdom, • Supply of financial aid, weapons, France, Kuwait, Italy, West Germany, missiles Egypt, Jordan, Singapore North Korea Persian Gulf States: Saudi Arabia, Kuwait • Support in exchange for oil and the United Arab Emirates • By 1982, Iran’s major military supplier Syria, Libya, China Others: Kuwait, Egypt, Jordan, Singapore
  • 19.
    Relevant UN Action Relevant UN Actions UNSC Resolution 582, February 24, 1986 • Condemned the escalation of the conflict (territorial incursions, bombing of civilian areas, violation of int’l law, use of chemical weapons) • Called upon cease fire and withdrawal of military forces to int’l recognised borders • Both parties refused to implement it UNSC Resolution 589, July 20, 1987 • Demands that Iran and Iraq observe a ceasefire as a first step towards a negotiated settlement • Request that an observer-team be sent to the region • Requested that POW be released and repatriated • Question of the responsibility for the conflict
  • 20.
    Questions to Consider Questions to Consider • Peace: How can long lasting peace be achieved in the region? • Justice: How can the respective countries be brought to justice for their various unethical war practices? Should the UN take action regarding the use of chemical weapons? • Prevention: In context to this war, how can further conflicts in the Middle East, be prevented? • Cultural differences: Is there a way to ensure communal tensions between the Shi’ite and Sunni Muslims in the respective countries so as to not lead to further conflict? • Protection of oil: Due to their global importance, how can the oil resources of these countries be protected from mutual attack as well as from usurpation from foreign countries with vested interests? • Question of water: Can a suitable water sharing agreement be reached regarding the Shatt al-Arab waterway so that it does not become a catalyst for conflict once more?