This document discusses using graphene for electronic devices. It describes how graphene's zero bandgap is problematic for digital electronics but its high mobility makes it promising. Several approaches are presented to induce a bandgap, including using graphene nanoribbons, applying a vertical electric field to bilayer graphene, and creating lateral heterostructures with materials of different bandgaps. Modeling shows these approaches can effectively control the band structure and enable transistor operation. Challenges remain in fabricating devices with sufficient reproducibility and without degrading carrier mobility. Lateral heterostructure FETs are identified as one of the most promising device concepts.
Search and Society: Reimagining Information Access for Radical Futures
Graphene transistors and two-dimensional electronics
1. Giuseppe Iannaccone University of PisaGiuseppe Iannaccone University of Pisa1
Graphene transistorsGraphene transistors
andand
two dimensional electronicstwo dimensional electronics
G. Iannaccone, G. Fiori, S. Bruzzone, A. Betti
University of Pisa
Acknowledgments: EC FP7 Project GRADE (n. 317839 )
EC FP7 Project GO-NEXTs (n. 309201)
EC FP7 Project GRAND (n. 215752)
EC FP7 NoE Nanosil (n. 216171)
ESF FoNE Project DEWINT – CNR
IT PRIN GRANFET (Prot. 2008S2CLJ9)
2. Giuseppe Iannaccone University of PisaGiuseppe Iannaccone University of Pisa2
Graphene as a material for electronicsGraphene as a material for electronics
• High mobility at room
temperature (>104
cm2
/Vs)
• Symmetric properties for
electrons and holes
• One-atom thin -> promising
for scaling
• Cheap and CMOS compatible
….but ….
… the zero energy gap is a
showstopper for use in
(digital) electronics ….
Graphene Band Structure
[nanodevice.fmns.rug.nl]
3. Giuseppe Iannaccone University of Pisa
ules of graphene nanoelectronics research
Increase gap, fabricate device, but
keep mobility high, keep reproducibility high3
4. Giuseppe Iannaccone University of PisaGiuseppe Iannaccone University of Pisa4
Energy gap and the Off stateEnergy gap and the Off state
Small energy gap enables
leakage via interband
tunneling current => high Ioff
EFS
EFD
source channel drain
Poor off state
5. Giuseppe Iannaccone University of PisaGiuseppe Iannaccone University of Pisa5
Energy gap and the Off stateEnergy gap and the Off state
Several options to induce a bandgap have been
pursued manufacturability challenges
Small energy gap enables
interband leakage => high Ioff
EFS
EFD
source channel drain
EFS
EFD
source channel drain
Poor off state Good off state
7. Giuseppe Iannaccone University of PisaGiuseppe Iannaccone University of Pisa7
Impressive GNR ExperimentsImpressive GNR Experiments
X. Li et al., Science 319, 1229 (2008)
X. Li et al. PRL 100, 206803 (2008)
8. Giuseppe Iannaccone University of PisaGiuseppe Iannaccone University of Pisa8
Device modeling tool: NanoTCAD VIDESDevice modeling tool: NanoTCAD VIDES
3D Non-Equilibrium Green’s Functions
(NEGF) solver
Fully coherent transport
Generic 3D structures
• CNT and GNR FETs (TB atomistic)
• Bilayer graphene FETs (TB atomistic)
• Semiconductor NW Transistors (EMA
+ TB atomistic)
• hBCN
New version of the code as a python
module – all documentation and code
at: http://vides.nanotcad.com and on
the nanohub.org
9. Giuseppe Iannaccone University of PisaGiuseppe Iannaccone University of Pisa9
Energy gap of graphene nanoribbonsEnergy gap of graphene nanoribbons
Nanoribbons always have a semiconducting gap
Huge gap variations for a single-dimer width change
Y.-W. Son et al.
PRL 97, 216803
(2006)
(16,0)
(14,0)
(12,0)
10. Giuseppe Iannaccone University of Pisa
DGFET with L = 15 nm, tox = 2 nm
(12,0) has a width of 1.37 nm
G. Fiori et al., IEEE-EDL 28, 760 (2007)
Giuseppe Iannaccone University of Pisa10
GNR-FETs transfer characteristicsGNR-FETs transfer characteristics
(12,0)
(12,0)
(14,0)
(14,0)
(16,0)
(16,0)
(16,0) with edge
roughness
11. Giuseppe Iannaccone University of Pisa
GNR intrinsic low-field mobility
Full band modeling (e- and ph): A. Betti et al. IEDM 2010, APL 2011
Intrinsic mobility of 1nm GNR ~ 800 cm2
/Vs, mainly due to AC phonons.
≈10 x smaller
μinα1/n2D in graphene
13. Giuseppe Iannaccone University of PisaGiuseppe Iannaccone University of Pisa13
A vertical electric field can open a gap in
bilayer graphene
• E.McCann, V.I.Fal'ko, PRL. 96, 086805 (2006)
• E. McCann, PRB74, 161403(R) (2006)
• J.B. Oostinga et al., Nat. Mat. 7, 151 (2008)
• E. V. Castro et al., PRL, 99, 216802 (2007).
• T. Ohta et al. Science 313, 951 (2008).
Bilayer GrapheneBilayer Graphene
16. Giuseppe Iannaccone University of Pisa
Tunnel Bilayer graphene FET (III)Tunnel Bilayer graphene FET (III)
Transfer characteristics as a function of gate overlap
18. Giuseppe Iannaccone University of Pisa
Atomic layers of hBN and graphene domains
L. Ci et al.(Rice) Nat. Mat. 9, 430 (2010)
Absorption rate of BN 5.68 eV Egap
18
19. Giuseppe Iannaccone University of PisaGiuseppe Iannaccone University of Pisa19
Energy gap and the Off stateEnergy gap and the Off state
With a high gap region in the
channel => low Ioff
EFS
EFD
source channel drain
EFS
EFD
source channel drain
Poor off state Good off state
24. Giuseppe Iannaccone University of Pisa
Graphene LHFET - Comparison with ITRS 2012
Ioff fixed at 100 nA/µm (as for HP) [Low OP has Ioff 5 nA/µm]
24
25. Giuseppe Iannaccone University of Pisa
Advantages of LH FETs
1. Robust with respect
to fabrication
tolerances (self
aligned gate)
2. Exploit high mobility
graphene for local
interconnects an S/D
extensions
3. Several unexplored
options for the high
gap region
25
27. Giuseppe Iannaccone University of Pisa27
L. Britnell et al.,
Science v. 335,
p. 947, 2011
Britnell et al. Nano Letters 2011
Britnell et al. Science 2011
28. Giuseppe Iannaccone University of Pisa
Graphene-base hot electron transistor
28
S. Vaziri et al.
(KTH,U. Siegen, IHP)
Nano Letters 2012
33. Giuseppe Iannaccone University of Pisa
How about analog? fT gold rush
Jan. 09
fT=26 GHz
Apr. 09
fT=50 GHz
Feb. 10
fT=100 GHz
May 10
fT=100 GHz
Apr. 11
fT=150 GHz
35. Giuseppe Iannaccone University of Pisa
Exploring the design space
Extraction of series
resistance
Y. Wu et al.,
Nature, 472 p. 74, 2011
G. Fiori et al., IEDM 2012
36. Giuseppe Iannaccone University of Pisa
Bilayer Graphene improves performance
Optimized structure with tox = 4 nm , tb = 20 nm
39. Giuseppe Iannaccone University of Pisa
Graphene in microelectronics: no easy solution
Nanoribbons require prohibitive fabrication
tolerances and are prone to mobility degradation
Bilayer graphene could be interesting:
Digital: only TFETs (experiment under way)
Analog: FET (focus of the GRADE project: main
challenge is reducing contact resistance)
Lateral Heterostructure FET
(IMHO) The Most Promising device: Experiments
ongoing
Vertical Heterostructure FET
Low on/off ratio, low fT
Attempts to increase fT within GRADE (GBTs)
39