How to analyze a
               case study
      Example: Advertising and sales
         promotion: Dabur Honey
Anilesh Seth
Ideator, Co Founder & CEO, KROW
www.krow.in
Ex-CEO/MD: LGSI, Qatalys & Supervalu India

www.slideshare.net/anilesh
http://In.linkedin.com/in/anileshseth
anileshseth@hotmail.com
- Do quick reading of the case. Get a “feel”
First: Do a quick reading
                            - Look at the questions at the end, if any
First: Do a quick reading



                            - Make a summary of the key points
Read the case thoroughly    - Make notations on how to use some of the
                              Information provided
Dabur Honey: Key points
•   In India, Honey is seen as a traditional product (Existing mindset?)
•   Most of it is in the unorganized sector
•   Around 1985, Dabur decided to source from agriculturists and brand it and sell it in
    glass jars on shop shelves, offering a consistent quality and ready availability (What
    “need” was Dabur able to address?)
•   This went well with their portfolio of ayurvedic products (What was the
    positioning?)
•   At the time only other company was Khadi Gramodyog – but this was unbranded
    (no major competition)
•   Low demand – restricted to therapy (sore throat), skin conditioner, ingredient in
    other ayurvedic formulations. Dabur solved the reach problem but there was no
    new incentive to buy. (main segment: Housewife)
•   But they saw huge potential (why? Could they expand the uses and therefore the
    market?). They had a huge plus in that the brand was synonymous with quality.
    They were clearly not in a mature market ( large adoption, but potentially huge
    competition)
Dabur Honey: Key points
•   By late 1980s, small regional brands started eating away at the low volume
    market, and although they lacked wide distribution, Dabur’s sales went from slow
    to sluggish
•   Other brands (Golden Meadows, Allied’s, Mehson’s) started gaining recognition in
    the undifferentiated market by offering lower pricing and fancy packaging (easy
    pickings!)
•   1991 Dabur took to national advertising – new platform (purity). Focus on towns
    with population of 1 lakh plus - spillover effect into smaller areas
•   Growth jumped to 20% but not good enough as the base was small
•   The purity plank didn’t seem to help - (since Dabur anyway was synonymous
    with quality). Problem was no new uses compared with just medicinal use
•   Big competition like Lipton and Nestle started eyeing the market potential if it
    were to be sold as a breakfast additive (looking at new uses for the product)
•   Dabur still had low spends – 10 to 15 lakhs a year. When their agency, Enterprise
    did focus groups, they found that using honey for other uses was a problem : the
    goodness of honey was standing in its way!
Dabur Honey: Key points
•   Dabur’s umbrella brand that was focused on Ayurveda simply went to confirm this.
    The “personality” was dull and traditional. Could taste be another plank?
•   Objective became to expand usage by targeting the mother who was involved in
    family diet and health
•   Three ad print campaign aimed to reposition Dabur as a tasty, nutritious health
    food combined with TV ads to demonstrate its scope of use (repositioning)
•   Magazines were used to give the housewife detailed suggestions on what it could
    be eaten with (expand uses)
•   Ad spending for 94-95 went upto 50 lakhs – started sponsoring recipe and food
    sections in women’s magazines
•   Increased the jar size, added POP, took more shelf space, gave more incentives to
    wholesalers and the sales force
•   5 months later, 65 % growth over last year. Shift to the 500 gms jar. Per house
    consumption is rising
•   Dabur has 10% share – all other branded players together account for 4 percent
Questions for discussion
• What should be the advertising and sales
  promotion strategies for a new competitive
  product entering the branded honey market?
• Should the new competitor charge the same
  price as being charged by Dabur or should it be
  different? Give reasoning in support of your
  answer.
• Suggest some new sales promotion techniques to
  Dabur to increase the rate of product trial by
  those consumers who have not used the product
  so far
First: Do a quick read




Read the case thoroughly



                            - What tools/frameworks can you use?
Organize your information   - Think SWOT, Product-Market Grid,
                               Positioning Maps, Segmentation,
Organize your information: SWOT
Strengths                           Weaknesses

- Financial?                        - Existing brand value?
                                    - Distribution network?


Opportunities                       Threats

- 14% of the market is with branded - Transnationals
  players. That leaves a potential of - Dabur
  86% of the 8000 tonnes a year
  market. Potentially almost 100
  crores
- Market is not mature. Growth yet
  to happen
- Sugar substitute? Other additives?
- Further sub-segment the market
  (socia economic?)
Organize your information: Positioning
                 map
  Premium




Pricing
                        Dabur



      Low

            Medicinal             Tasty, nutritious, health food
                            Use
What position can you occupy?
                                                                   Expanded
  Premium
                                                              use…opportunity to
                                                             subsegment, repositi
                                                               on, offer multiple
                                                                    brands


Pricing

                        Dabur


      Low
            Medicinal    Tasty, nutritious, health food   Sugar substitute

                                   Use
First: Do a quick read




Read the case thoroughly




Organize your information



                            - Pretend you are actually there
                              Think 4 Ps of marketing
   Immerse yourself!!
                            - Web research can provide some “added”
                              dimensions
                            - Pick a position. Debate! Role playing can
                              be fun!
Think: 4 Ps of marketing
Product                                 Place

- Dispenser unit for ease and           - Adjacent to breakfast foods as
  accuracy of dispensing, with refill     additive
  packs                                 - Adjacent to competitions’ jars
- No spill feature                        with flavours (eg Ginger flavored)
- Flavoured honey in small trial        - Chemists?
  bottles (Ginger, Lemon, Elaichi)

Price                                   Promotion

- Potential to offer lower pricing on - Social media/Competitions
  refill packs                         - Social media engagement – eg
- Potential to offer higher pricing on   benefits of honey over sugar
  flavoured variant                    - Free dispenser
                                       - Free trial packs with branded
                                         breakfast foods?
And finally answer the questions
• What should be the advertising and sales
  promotion strategies for a new competitive
  product entering the branded honey market?
• Should the new competitor charge the same
  price as being charged by Dabur or should it be
  different? Give reasoning in support of your
  answer.
• Suggest some new sales promotion techniques to
  Dabur to increase the rate of product trial by
  those consumers who have not used the product
  so far
Thank you!

How to analyze a case study

  • 1.
    How to analyzea case study Example: Advertising and sales promotion: Dabur Honey Anilesh Seth Ideator, Co Founder & CEO, KROW www.krow.in Ex-CEO/MD: LGSI, Qatalys & Supervalu India www.slideshare.net/anilesh http://In.linkedin.com/in/anileshseth anileshseth@hotmail.com
  • 2.
    - Do quickreading of the case. Get a “feel” First: Do a quick reading - Look at the questions at the end, if any
  • 3.
    First: Do aquick reading - Make a summary of the key points Read the case thoroughly - Make notations on how to use some of the Information provided
  • 4.
    Dabur Honey: Keypoints • In India, Honey is seen as a traditional product (Existing mindset?) • Most of it is in the unorganized sector • Around 1985, Dabur decided to source from agriculturists and brand it and sell it in glass jars on shop shelves, offering a consistent quality and ready availability (What “need” was Dabur able to address?) • This went well with their portfolio of ayurvedic products (What was the positioning?) • At the time only other company was Khadi Gramodyog – but this was unbranded (no major competition) • Low demand – restricted to therapy (sore throat), skin conditioner, ingredient in other ayurvedic formulations. Dabur solved the reach problem but there was no new incentive to buy. (main segment: Housewife) • But they saw huge potential (why? Could they expand the uses and therefore the market?). They had a huge plus in that the brand was synonymous with quality. They were clearly not in a mature market ( large adoption, but potentially huge competition)
  • 5.
    Dabur Honey: Keypoints • By late 1980s, small regional brands started eating away at the low volume market, and although they lacked wide distribution, Dabur’s sales went from slow to sluggish • Other brands (Golden Meadows, Allied’s, Mehson’s) started gaining recognition in the undifferentiated market by offering lower pricing and fancy packaging (easy pickings!) • 1991 Dabur took to national advertising – new platform (purity). Focus on towns with population of 1 lakh plus - spillover effect into smaller areas • Growth jumped to 20% but not good enough as the base was small • The purity plank didn’t seem to help - (since Dabur anyway was synonymous with quality). Problem was no new uses compared with just medicinal use • Big competition like Lipton and Nestle started eyeing the market potential if it were to be sold as a breakfast additive (looking at new uses for the product) • Dabur still had low spends – 10 to 15 lakhs a year. When their agency, Enterprise did focus groups, they found that using honey for other uses was a problem : the goodness of honey was standing in its way!
  • 6.
    Dabur Honey: Keypoints • Dabur’s umbrella brand that was focused on Ayurveda simply went to confirm this. The “personality” was dull and traditional. Could taste be another plank? • Objective became to expand usage by targeting the mother who was involved in family diet and health • Three ad print campaign aimed to reposition Dabur as a tasty, nutritious health food combined with TV ads to demonstrate its scope of use (repositioning) • Magazines were used to give the housewife detailed suggestions on what it could be eaten with (expand uses) • Ad spending for 94-95 went upto 50 lakhs – started sponsoring recipe and food sections in women’s magazines • Increased the jar size, added POP, took more shelf space, gave more incentives to wholesalers and the sales force • 5 months later, 65 % growth over last year. Shift to the 500 gms jar. Per house consumption is rising • Dabur has 10% share – all other branded players together account for 4 percent
  • 7.
    Questions for discussion •What should be the advertising and sales promotion strategies for a new competitive product entering the branded honey market? • Should the new competitor charge the same price as being charged by Dabur or should it be different? Give reasoning in support of your answer. • Suggest some new sales promotion techniques to Dabur to increase the rate of product trial by those consumers who have not used the product so far
  • 8.
    First: Do aquick read Read the case thoroughly - What tools/frameworks can you use? Organize your information - Think SWOT, Product-Market Grid, Positioning Maps, Segmentation,
  • 9.
    Organize your information:SWOT Strengths Weaknesses - Financial? - Existing brand value? - Distribution network? Opportunities Threats - 14% of the market is with branded - Transnationals players. That leaves a potential of - Dabur 86% of the 8000 tonnes a year market. Potentially almost 100 crores - Market is not mature. Growth yet to happen - Sugar substitute? Other additives? - Further sub-segment the market (socia economic?)
  • 10.
    Organize your information:Positioning map Premium Pricing Dabur Low Medicinal Tasty, nutritious, health food Use
  • 11.
    What position canyou occupy? Expanded Premium use…opportunity to subsegment, repositi on, offer multiple brands Pricing Dabur Low Medicinal Tasty, nutritious, health food Sugar substitute Use
  • 12.
    First: Do aquick read Read the case thoroughly Organize your information - Pretend you are actually there Think 4 Ps of marketing Immerse yourself!! - Web research can provide some “added” dimensions - Pick a position. Debate! Role playing can be fun!
  • 13.
    Think: 4 Psof marketing Product Place - Dispenser unit for ease and - Adjacent to breakfast foods as accuracy of dispensing, with refill additive packs - Adjacent to competitions’ jars - No spill feature with flavours (eg Ginger flavored) - Flavoured honey in small trial - Chemists? bottles (Ginger, Lemon, Elaichi) Price Promotion - Potential to offer lower pricing on - Social media/Competitions refill packs - Social media engagement – eg - Potential to offer higher pricing on benefits of honey over sugar flavoured variant - Free dispenser - Free trial packs with branded breakfast foods?
  • 14.
    And finally answerthe questions • What should be the advertising and sales promotion strategies for a new competitive product entering the branded honey market? • Should the new competitor charge the same price as being charged by Dabur or should it be different? Give reasoning in support of your answer. • Suggest some new sales promotion techniques to Dabur to increase the rate of product trial by those consumers who have not used the product so far
  • 15.