I focus on a possible transition of organizations who are introducing the agile way of working. Starting with a traditional project setup using permanent PMO (portfolio level). What will happen if we the keep the team together as an agile team? What does that mean for the project manager, and what is the most important competence of the PO? I will continue my story by adding an agile team. Coordination between the teams can be managed by a scrum of scrum. Still no need for a project organization with a project manager and a project board and no need for a temporary PMO. I add more teams and the coordination asks for a project manager. We can continue and institutionalize the coordination and removing the PM by using frameworks like Nexus, S@S, SAFe, LeSS et cetera. I will add some new to be created teams (asks for a Project Manager to organize this hybrid project organization) et cetera. I will end with an overview and positioning of different agile frameworks (more than 50) and the role of the permanent PMO in an agile world (focus portfolio management and Center of Excellence) and what has to change if you want to make a transition towards a more agile organization.
Learning objectives
1. A clear overview and positioning of different agile frameworks. Along the way, I will answer the question “Why do so many agile transitions fail?
2. Understand the new role of the project manager in the agile world
Keywords: Agile, Hybrid PM, Agile culture
Henny Portman - Will the project manager survive in the agile world when scaling up teams
1. 1
Will the project
manager survive in
the agile world?
Agile Tour Vilnius Conference, Lithuania, October 24, 2019
Henny Portman
2. • 1981-2017
• Tiel Utrecht Verzekeringen: Developer/Analyst/Head System Development
• Consultancy ING Fatum Paramaribo, Suriname
• ING Investment Management Nederland: Head IT
• ING Investment Management Europe: PMO Head
• ING Insurance Central Europe: Regional PMO head
• ING Insurance STO: Global PMO Head
• I build hub and spoke PMO’s in Europe and Asia
Now:
• Partner HWP Consulting
• Certified MoP, P3O, MSP, PRINCE2, PRINCE2 Agile, AgileSHIFT trainer,
SAFe SPC4 Certified Consultant,
• PMO Value Ring Certified Consultant, Judge PMO Global Awards 2019
• P3M3 Consultant / Assessor
• Blogger, reviewer Managementboek.nl
• Author of PM articles and books
+
https://hennyportman.wordpress.com/
https://www.linkedin.com/in/hennyportman
Biography: Henny Portman
4. 4
The difference between project work and
BAU work
Team
A
Project
Board
Portfolio Board
Project
Manager
Team
B
Team
C
PMO
(temporary)
Project direction
Pre
project
Initiation
stage
New or significantly
revised product
Close Goes into
production
Incrementally
Agile team
Chng n
Chng 6
Chng 5
Chng 4
Chng 3
Chng 2
Chng 1
Project work
(temporary): Move
people to the work
PMO
(permanent)
New project,
One delivery
BAU (ongoing): Move work to the people
6. 6
Continuous delivery by an Agile Team
Agile Team
AUS n
US 6
US 5
US 4
US 3
US 2
US 1
Team backlogindefinite
Product
Owner
Scrum
Master
BAU (ongoing): Move work to the people
Key
Competence?
Prioritize
Refine
No project
Organization
Project
Manager
7. 7
Is a PO a:
• Shopping list manager?
• Order taker?
• Backlog secretary?
Or …
Key competence: have the knowledge and mandate to
say NO!, otherwise …
8. Is this what your backlog looks like?
Your Product Backlog
Is full of garbage!
Source: blog Raphael Alexis Nov 4 2018
13. 14
Few teams together; one product
Agile Team
A
Scrum
Master
Scrum
Master
Coordination via
Scrum of Scrums
Still no project
Organization
Project
Manager
indefinite
Agile Team
BUS n
US 6
US 5
US 4
US 3
US 2
US 1
indefinite
Product
Owner
US n
US 6
US 5
US 4
US 3
US 2
US 1
US n
US 6
US 5
US 4
US 3
US 2
US 1
Product
Owner
BAU (ongoing): Move work to the people
14. 15
Many teams together; one product,
integration, dependencies, …
Agile Team
AUS n
US 6
US 5
US 4
US 3
US 2
US 1
Agile Team
B
Scrum
Master
Scrum
Master
Coordination via
Scrum of Scrums
not enough
Asks for a
project
organization
Project
Manager
Agile Teams
C, D, E
Scrum
Master
indefiniteindefiniteindefinite
US n
US 6
US 5
US 4
US 3
US 2
US 1
US n
US 6
US 5
US 4
US 3
US 2
US 1
US n
US 6
US 5
US 4
US 3
US 2
US 1
Product
Owner
Product
Owner
Product
Owner
BAU (ongoing): Move work to the people
15. 16
Many teams together; one product,
integration, dependencies, …
Agile Team
A
Agile Team
B
Scrum
Master
I can
do it!
Project
Manager
Agile Teams
C, D, E
indefiniteindefiniteindefinite
Project
Manager
Project Board
Portfolio Board
Project work
(temporary): Move
people to the work
US n
US 6
US 5
US 4
US 3
US 2
US 1
US n
US 6
US 5
US 4
US 3
US 2
US 1
Product
Owner
US n
US 6
US 5
US 4
US 3
US 2
US 1
US n
US 6
US 5
US 4
US 3
US 2
US 1
Product
Owner
Product
Owner
BAU (ongoing): Move work to
the people
16. 17
Many teams together; one product,
integration, dependencies, …
Agile Team
A
Agile Team
B
No project
organization
Project
Manager
Agile Teams
C, D, E
indefiniteindefiniteindefinite
Integration Team,
Roadmap Manager,
Release train, …
indefinite
US n
US 6
US 5
US 4
US 3
US 2
US 1
Scrum
Master
Portfolio Board
US n
US 6
US 5
US 4
US 3
US 2
US 1
US n
US 6
US 5
US 4
US 3
US 2
US 1
Product
Owner
US n
US 6
US 5
US 4
US 3
US 2
US 1
US n
US 6
US 5
US 4
US 3
US 2
US 1
Product
Owner
Product
Owner
BAU (ongoing): Move work to
the people
Chief PO,
Product Manager
Managing the
product
backlog
17. 19
But be careful, don’t throw them all!
Maybe you still need some!
Abbey Lincoln: Throw It Away
Project Managers can be thrown away
18. 20
Many (one-time) teams; one product,
integration, dependencies, …
Agile Team
B
Agile Team
C
Asks for a
project
organization
Project
Manager
Agile Teams
D, E
indefiniteindefiniteOne-time
Team A
One-time
And a hybrid
approach
Scrum
Master
Project work (temporary): Move people to the work BAU (ongoing): Move work to the people
US n
US 6
US 5
US 4
US 3
US 2
US 1
US n
US 6
US 5
US 4
US 3
US 2
US 1
Product
Owner
Product
Owner
19. 21
Many (one-time) teams; one product,
integration, dependencies, …
Agile Team
B
Agile Team
C
I can do
it!
Agile Teams
D, E
indefiniteindefiniteOne-time
Team A
One-time
Scrum
Master
Project
Manager
Project Board
BAU (ongoing): Move work to
the peoplePortfolio Board
Project work (temporary):
Move people to the work
US n
US 6
US 5
US 4
US 3
US 2
US 1
US n
US 6
US 5
US 4
US 3
US 2
US 1
Product
Owner
Product
Owner
Project
Manager
20. 22
Many (one-time) teams; one product, integration,
dependencies: hybrid organization
Agile Team
B
Agile Team
C
I can do
it!
Agile Teams
D, E
indefiniteindefiniteOne-time
Team A
One-time
Scrum
Master
Project
Manager
Project Board
BAU (ongoing): Move work to
the peoplePortfolio Board
Project work (temporary):
Move people to the work
US n
US 6
US 5
US 4
US 3
US 2
US 1
US n
US 6
US 5
US 4
US 3
US 2
US 1
Product
Owner
Product
Owner
Project
Manager
ART, LeSS, Nexus, …
US n
US 6
US 5
US 4
US 3
US 2
US 1
Chief PO,
Product Manager
31. 33
Leading causes of failed agile projects
Organizational culture at odds with agile values 52%
General organization resistance to change 48%
Inadequate management support and sponsorship 44%
Lack of skills/experience with agile methods 40%
36%
Insufficient training and education 35%
Lack of business/customer/product owner availability 32%
Pervasiveness of traditional development methods 28%
Fragmented tooling and project-related data/measurements 26%
Minimal collaboration and knowledge sharing 24%
Regulatory compliance or governance issue 16%
13th annual State of Agile Report
Inconsistent processes and practices across teams